Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 21:37

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. And today I'm going to be doing a discussion over The Game Makers. This was a game that was extremely anticipated, highly ambitious because, as you can clearly see, this is a game that is about making games. And in this game, you are essentially making all of these games. Um, and they have thousands upon thousands of games. Now, the original plan was for me to do this discussion with my friend Brad. You've seen him on the channel before. he's the one who actually owns this game, but uh you know, we just didn't get a chance to actually do it. And so here here we are. Now uh like I said, this game is extremely ambitious in the sense that it must have cost I would imagine it would cost a fortune to [clears throat] be able to make make this game. Comes in this massive box, extremely overproduced. This is a perfect picture of everything in it. And it's essentially kind of a rondelle worker placement game. Uh your forklifts are your workers. And over the course of the game, you will be moving these workers around to be able to get resources in order to make this game. It is a tableau building game, more or less. I mean, you have a 4x3 or 3x4. I think it's the same. And the game ends whenever someone

has created all these games and then you score and whoever has a higher score wins. Now this one is extremely unfortunate because I find this game um absolutely mid. It is not a terrible game, but it pretty much confirmed my suspicions on it because like I said, I do not own this game. And I was going to back it because I mean, look at the cover. The the cover of this game is amazing. Well, the cover design itself I actually think is really bad. But with all there's so many good games on on here uh that cover a a wide array.

Hey, I mean, if you were to just have all these games in your collection, you would pretty much cover all bases um of of every genre in the industry and you would have some absolute bangers. This cover alone constitutes, in my opinion, a fantastic collection. Um, but there was something about the idea of this that just had me uh skeptical. It's like, okay, how are you going to make this interesting besides make I mean, you could easily make this a a really deep and thinky Euro. Think like a Vo Larda kind of style game, or you could make it very approachable, and they leaned more on the approachable side, but I think they leaned too on the approachable side.

This game unfortunately has easy access to everything you would ever need without having any type of variety. And yes, the variety is in all the games you make, but there's nothing discerning themselves apart. If you you you essentially have categories of games. You have co-op, war, uh euro, and then I can't remember what the the fourth category is. Uh but you have red, purple, blue, and yellow. And they essentially just have different combinations of resources that they need. And almost all of them kind of provide the exact same scoring. Uh, in the last game I played of this, I literally made only co-op games and all of them happened to be okay. You get points if you have co-op games because you have a tableau like I mentioned. We'll use this picture, this fantastic picture. you have uh this tableau and it's like okay this one this one scores for uh every point you uh for each yellow you have in your columns up to a max of four. This one scores a max of six points for co-ops if you happen to have uh co uh co-op games or games in these two columns that require a uh a resource like that. And a lot of the

ones I happened to get were co-op games where it's just hey have co-op games in the far two the far right two columns or have co-op games in the far left two columns. And the problem with this game is you don't really have to work to make that happen. And a lot of tableau building cuz I love Tableau style games because usually there's spatial awareness. You have to work to get them in the right pattern. You might block yourself. you might get the just the right move and it can come together really well or fall apart. There's nothing that would ever prevent you from not getting exactly what you need because it's so easy to get what you need. Now, the Rondell system of this game is interesting for about 30 to 45 minutes and and unfortunately this game goes over way too long. Not that it's like the most ins insanely long game ever, but it it just runs probably about 30 minutes too long because by the time the gimmick and of you know of the the rondelle and uh you know the interesting nature of seeing what games that they put in here, once that kind of wears off, you're ready for the game to be over. And so you basically have multipliers. As this wheel rotates, it opens up options of where your uh your forklifts can go. And that can be multipliers or you can find ways to get multipliers because you have a little bit of worker placement with different levels of workers. Again,

super easy to get all the different levels of workers. And it's like, okay, if I only want to get co-op games that get me up to a max of six points, then I okay, I'll send a worker to the one that lets me draw three cards plus, you know, plus one or two or three. And you just fish through the deck and or hey, how do I get a level three plastic? Oh, okay. Well, you can just go get one pretty much as soon as it becomes available. You can just go get it and nothing stopping you. No, there like it is a very light worker placement game. So there's no competition at all. It's not like a lot of other worker placements where it's like, "Oh, damn it. You went to the spot I wanted to go to or there's none of that." I mean, I [snorts] think most worker placements now kind of bump have that bump system where it's like, "Oh, you went there, but I can go there, but they'll bump your worker back. Do I want to do that?"

There's no second level of thinking here. You just go and get what you want. And I think that'll appease to some people, but for me, after about 30 minutes to maybe maybe an hour, I was ready for it to be done. Um, so, so yeah, you could just fish for your cards. And this last game that I played of this, we had uh Brad had it and he diversified. He got two tracks because again there's these tracks that are multipliers for victory points. Uh again, super easy to go up on these tracks. You literally just get a certain level die and just grab it's okay. Hey, a level three die is available. Just grab it and roll it and oh man, I got a six. Okay, choose a track. Move it up six. And sometimes again with workers over here, you can increase that by one, two or three. and he got two tracks leveled um all the way leveled and I did two I did my trees and I did co-op obviously and the score was I mean the final score was relatively comparable. it was easy enough to, you know, okay, he he wasn't that far behind me, but the problem was I he was diversifying and I wasn't. Um, in fact, the way that the final score worked was

is if we removed my entire score of purple, I still won. So, my tableau didn't even matter because I got so many points elsewhere. The trees super easy to do. it is. It's just not that interesting of a game. And my overall pro problem with it is in the in the theme itself because this is clearly a game for people in the hobby, us people who are probably watching this. Uh I don't see anyone who isn't in this hobby seeing this game, this massive ass [ __ ] box, and going, "Oh, I want to get that." First of all, this game is insanely expensive for what it is, and I know why. I imagine, well, I guess I don't know, but I imagine they have to pay some royalties to all these people. Um, and it's like, okay, well, this is clearly for people in the hobby.

And for me, the most fun part about this game was the fact of just kind of looking through the deck and seeing what games they had. But that was it. It just reminded me of better games. Oh, here's a game that I'd much rather be playing right now. Oh, man. You have Oath Sworn. I can make Oathsworn. How How different is that? Oh, it requires a level three plastic, a red dye, and three cards. Okay. How is that in any way related to Oath Swarm? Except for the fact that there's plastic because there's minis, there's dice in the game, and there's cards. That's that's the deepest level of thinking for these games. Uh you have, you know, let's see if I can find another one actually. Oh, not on that one. Probably on the one that I've been using the the main picture for this one.

We take a look at this person's game. We have uh Oh, Hul. Okay. It requires tiles and plastic. Okay. Yep. I guess you play tiles and you have there's plastic in the game. All right. Well, between two castles. Well, that's a co-op game kind of cuz you're working kind of with your neighbors. Oh. Oh, there's buildings in there. There's workers and there's tiles. That's literally it. Those are your only resources. And there's three levels of each. The most interesting aspect of this game, I actually think, is the assembly line, which again is super easy to get, but you draw from three different bags. And whenever you create a row of three connected things like this person has done with dice, uh tiles, and cards, it reduces uh the level of of something you would need, uh like a resource you would need.

Well, okay. Okay. So, if you want to make oath, which I don't know why you would want to, uh, this person only needed uh, that's a level two die, the orange one. He only needs a level one die. And then for cards, he only needs three cards instead of four. So, any and then any tile, again, there's three different tiles, he would only need, you know, if it was nucleium, he would need a level two. And then sometimes you can actually just completely wipe it away together. If you need a level one die, you don't need a level one die anymore. But I mean, again, you don't really have to work that hard. It just makes you producing cards uh or games even faster. However, the best part about placing these is what they call tweenies, which I actually really really don't like that word. But whenever you create kind of a spot that it can go in, you just take any one of your tweenies and pop it in and it gives you an ability, let you pull back a worker, lets you get any level of something you want, things like that. Uh, so that was kind of that was some there was some spatial awareness with that. Uh these three things you get at random at the beginning or you can draft for them A, B, and C.

Those give you either a unique way of scoring, a unique worker replacement spot, and then another unique passive ability. I actually really like these, but again, you have to get resources to make them, and they're super easy to do. I think that's cool. that gives you some uniqueness between players. But there I mean if one of them is worth nine points and you need three level threes and another is worth seven points and you need three level twos, getting those is just as simple. It's not it doesn't make it harder for the person who needs the level threes to get it. And the points are so close together anyway. It's pretty much comparable. So unfortunately like whenever the first time we were playing this game and we were setting up I was taking the cards and I was kind of making my own game with it like hey which game would you rather would would you which game would you rather play and then I would just grab from the deck and it's oh it's a zool duel and oh it's ctographers or which game would you wipe away from existence altogether and it's Aon's End and Rolling Heights uh that was more fun to me than actually playing this game.

So, [sighs and gasps] I again I don't hate this game by any means. It's I think this is a a perfectly fine albeit expensive and overproduced family weight game. But I almost feel again that the the theming does nothing except for the adults in that family who are into the hobby. And because none of the kids are gonna I mean they might recognize some of the games, but I it just doesn't really do it for me. I I wish that the games actually had like maybe not have a million games, maybe have half the number of games, but they all did something, you know, that that was a little bit of essence to what the game was. I know that would have been incredibly hard cuz how do you how do you make it balanced that way? How do you make Gloom Haven give you a special ability that um that uh uh I'm blank uh that wingspan looked over that wingspan and how you would give you and make them balanced, you know, or at the very least I mean this would have been a million resources as well, but have them not all cost the same. have the the tableau actually matter uh have the scoring matter in any way. It it just it didn't really come

together to me. I think this is a game that most people are going to be going after because it has all those games in it. But whenever you play it, it kind of comes down to, well, this kind of just fell flat. I can see this being one I'm glad I didn't pay for cuz it's $200 for this version. in like the big big box version. And I remember seeing that and I was like, this feels kind of like a cash grab. Like clearly they're using the title as as an eyecatcher and be like, "Hey, look at all these games. They're all in here." They are all in there. And it's it literally you could swap any any of the games that none of none of them matter. They might as well just not even be. They could be madeup games. I actually would have had more fun if the games, you know how some games don't have the rights to be able to make a character or um get the title of some major IP, so they get cheeky with it.

Um, I almost much would have rather had that where oh, they didn't get all the games, but this is clearly slay the spire um called play play the prior, you know, whatever dumb [ __ ] like that. That would have been more fun for me because then I would have actually enjoyed looking at the games versus, oh, I made Scythe. Okay. And it it definitely gets to a point while you're playing that you you're not even looking at the games anymore. I promise you it is no the the gimmick of all the games that are in this game goes away about 45 minutes in, maybe even faster where you no longer are looking for a particular game because again it doesn't matter. You are just looking for a color. Oh, I really need blue. So let me just fish for that. And okay, I got my blue. Boom. put the rest of the cards down and I'm gonna start working on blue.

I hate games like that. You definitely go through the motions in this game, which is unfortunate because I feel like there is something here, but but not not for me. Uh yeah, like there's no reason besides Gloom Haven being a cooperative game. I mean, Too Many Bones is also cooperative, but they put it in war again. Hey, well, there's fighting in Gloom Haven. Why isn't that war? uh like there's too many bones in Gloom Haven. You could easily just swap those and it would make no difference whatsoever to the game. So, in terms of mechanisms, I don't like the tableau uh system. It is in as simple as it could possibly get. Um the board games in here just make me wish I was playing all these games. Uh, the only fun kind of meta thing that they have in here is whenever you're done, there's a QR code you can scan where you can scan your Tableau and it tells you your highest ranked game and where it's at on BGG, which again is only for people in the hobby. People who are into this hobby are going to be the ones that uh are even gravitated towards this. Um, I like even if it's so family weight or light that I could just casually play it. Like for example, I play I show a lot of board games to my girlfriend cuz she was never into this hobby, but she loves playing the games that we play. I couldn't even play this with her because

she wouldn't get any of these games. Uh, so it's like, okay, this is clearly for me and I don't even really like it. Um, but yeah, the QR code thing was kind of cool to look at it and be like, "Oh, hey, Frost Haven was my highest ranked game." Cool. Um, I mean, man, they could have done something even more with that. Some re real meta stuff where you actually have to utilize BG in some way. Uh, that would have been kind of cool. integrate, not really an app, but the the website while you're playing to have you make decisions or get key scoring points based off of where the game is on BGG, what year it was released, you know, how old the designer is, who who knows what.

They could have they just could have done something with this. And like I said, it's not a badly designed game. It's not unplayable. It's perfectly serviceable. It's just too expensive. the theme falls extremely flat that I just have no interest in ever touching this game. Um, so yeah, I mean ultimately that's it. I think on a scale of 1 to 10, I would give this game a flat just a right in the middle five. Did I even click on game makers? Yeah, I'm going to go ahead and give it a five. I don't own it and that's where it'll stay. I don't have any interest in ever trying this one again.

And but maybe this theme could be done better elsewhere. And I don't know. I don't know. This one, I can't say I'm too surprised that it ended up as kind of a five because I was already skeptical and pulled out of the crowdfunding uh whenever it was originally going going live. Something about that price didn't didn't sit right with me and I'm glad I passed. Anyway, that's it. Uh let me know what you think of the game makers in the comments below and like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved