Quest for the Best Light, Medium & Heavy Solo Board Game | The Hobbit, SETI and Creature Caravan
Transcript
Welcome back to the quest for the best solo board game. This is episode two. I am Dylan. This is all you can board. If you missed the first episode, what are you doing here? Go back and watch that episode before you watch this one. We have three fresh games to take a look at. Of course, one light, one medium, one heavy game. Before we jump into those, I'm going to quickly throw up on screen the current champions just to recap everybody. So, we have Flip Tunes, which is our light champion. We have Marvel Champions, which is our medium champion. And we have uh Collution, which is our heavy champion. I almost say Clads of Calonia. That was last episode's heavy game. Um, so again, really, really quickly, what we do in the series is I look at three solo board games, one light, one medium, one heavy, and we see if any of them can overtake the current champion as being the best solo. I don't know why I did this. For me, it will be the best solo board game in that weight category. And then at the end of the video, I'll also break down a top five for each of those weight classifications as well, just so that you can see if a game didn't become the champion, how close did it come, is it still in my top five, and where do those games sit? Has there been any other movement since the last episode in terms of high ranked solo games based on how I'm playing them? That'll all be at the end of the video. But before that, of course, we're going to jump in to the very first game, which is going to be our light solo game, and that for this episode is The Hobbit. there and back again.
So, The Hobbit there and back again is less of a traditional roll and right at times and more like you're kind of flipping through a puzzle book with eight to distinct chapters. There are there is this foundation. There's these base rules. There's these dice that you're going to often be returning to and rolling in the same ways obviously, but each chapter is sort of remixing that foundation, reinventing it in different ways. And so if you're expecting to come into this and say, "Every single time I play, I'm going to get better. I'm going to get, you know, higher scores." It's not that that isn't the case. It's just that how you approach chapter 2, chapter 4, chapter 8, they're all going to be very different in terms of the way that you're interacting with what you're actually doing. And so getting better at one doesn't necessarily mean you're getting better at the another chapter. There's certain things that carry over, but not everything. And I just think that's an important distinction to make coming into The Hobbit. But the good news here is that getting the Hobbit to the table is super easy.
All you do is open the book, flip to the chapter that you want to play, grab your dice and tokens, and basically you're ready to go. Realistically, you're playing within 5 minutes every single time. That is about as frictionless as it gets. Now, the one thing that will slow you down, really the only thing that's going to slow you down as you play The Hobbit is the unique rules for every chapter. you're never going to really have to return to the overall rules and how you play the game. But every chapter, like I mentioned, is going to remix it in different ways. And so, there is going to be a bit in the setup time, especially if really only if you haven't played that chapter before or you haven't played it in a while and have forgotten the mechanics that you're going to have to sort of look at the rule book, look at the rules that are listed on the actual page of the chapter you're playing, and just familiarize yourself with the different ways that this is changing things that you've come to expect already. But that is really the only hold up, the only place that you're going to feel slowed down. And one of those things that you're going to be learning each time with each new chapter is, of course, the game scoring.
So, right off the bat, there's no Ottoa here. And and honestly, that's not a problem. The an Ottoa wouldn't make sense in a game like this because really when you're playing multiplayer, the only player interaction that happens is with the dice selection. and that and it's it's a good bit of player interaction and it can lead to some tough choices and and sort of figuring out what to do with the dice that you're left, but the game has another way of mimicking that in terms of there being an Ottoa that's also playing it would it would be pointless. This isn't a game that that needed one. But it is important to keep note that really what you're doing here, this is a score chase. You're you're scoring at the end of each chapter that you play and the the goal the the joy of coming back the replayability is from the fact that next time you'll have to beat that score. Can you get a higher score? So the it I'm naming that I'm calling that out because for some people that is a dealbreaker like and I understand that because there's some games I play that are score chases that it's just not compelling. So just know that that if you don't really get super invested in just competing with your high score each time, there's not going to be a lot that's bringing you back in terms of the scoring system here. So, as I mentioned though, in the multiplayer, there is light competition through dice selection, and that's where the tension really comes from in the multiplayer experience. And the game tries to replicate that shared tension in the solo mode by forcing you to make simple dice decisions each turn. So, you're going to be rolling five dice, dividing them into three different groups. And in two of those groups, you're obviously going to have two dice to choose from. And so, in those two groups that have two dice, you're going to have to choose one to keep and abandon the other. And this will leave
you with three dice that you're going to be using to then interact with your board, gain resources, etc. And honestly, this this works completely fine. It's it's less engaged and less exciting than when you have another player making those decisions. But it's still pretty engaging and fun to to look when you have a role that you really wish you could take both dice, but you have to abandon one to sort of weigh the pros and cons. Which die do you take? How is that going to influence the other decision you make uh in terms of which one you abandon, which one you keep? The way that they've replicated that here for the solo mode, I have no issues with. It's not earthshattering. It's not going to be the thing that brings you back to play, but it is sort of just a really simple way to sort of make that transition from multiplayer to solo. But my issues with the solo integration here really do show up at the end because once you total your score, you don't really know what it means. Yes, the game shows you theoretical maximums, but at least for solo play, those often feel so far out of reach, they don't actually help contextualize your performance. So, your first few plays of any chapter end with a bit of uncertainty and anticlimactically. There's going to be a lot of the chapters that you finish and you're like, "All right, cool. I got 56 points. I don't know if that's good. I don't know if I should celebrate. I don't know if I should be, you know, thinking I'm going to have to try this again. That was a poor score." until you start playing multiple times, you're almost sort of making the leaderboard yourself, and that's fine. But without the leaderboard, I have to admit, it is it is less compelling and very antilimactic when you finish a game.
Another minor thing I didn't really like about the scoring system is that there are um bonus scoring objectives in The Hobbit where when you play multiplayer, the first person to get to that objective gets the two bonus points or the five bonus points. And so the way that they they accomplish this in solo play is that on the round track that you're that you're moving every single round of the game that progresses, some of them are going to have this little red X that says you have to cross off one of those bonus race objectives. And you get to choose which one you cross off. It's just for some of the the chapters, this means that you you you often don't get any of the bonus objectives or you are kind of always crossing off the same ones every time you play cuz you know, okay, this one is definitely out of reach, but I can possibly get this one. And that doesn't often change. And so there are certain chapters where every time I would get to the first one where it says, "Okay, cross off a bonus." I'm like, "Yeah, well, I'm crossing off this troll because I know I'm not going to get to that." Or if I am, there's a better chance I'll get to one of these early ones. And so those cross-up decisions start to just feel very sy and almost I just didn't see a point in them. I almost wish that they had just removed all those bonus objectives for solo play and injected some other solo specific scoring thing to to replace them. I think that would have been way more interesting and engaging. It's not a huge deal honestly. You could also just play with ignoring those and you'd probably not even notice uh for at least for some chapters. Some chapters there's there's more of them and so it's a little bit more engaging. some of the early chapters, especially the first one, it it doesn't really work very well in solo play. So again, it's minor, but
it is something that I noticed while I was playing. But ultimately, scoring is only important if you're enjoying the ways you score those points in the first place. Now, while there's no literal timer in The Hobbit, there absolutely is a clock. For solo play, each chapter has a fixed number of rounds, and once you hit that limit, the game ends and you total up your score. Now, just to be clear, there is still the other re regular objective that can end the game. Every chapter has a trigger that ends the game that if you were playing multiplayer, that is how the game would end. That's still present in solo play. But I, in my experience, the times that you actually finish a solo game with the objective for the chapter versus the the round limit are few and far between, very rare. Maybe if I played each of these chapters a lot more and got really good at it, I could reliably be hitting that goal. But often it is just going to end with the the chapter limit or the round limit. And so that is another thing that kind of just feels antilimactic. You have this goal narratively that says, you know, you have to get as many or whoever gets the the all the dwarves to bag in first wins or things like that. And you almost never get to see the objective completed in solo play. You just say, "Well, I got close to it and the games ends or I just got this many and then the game ends."
And it it's good in some ways in solo play because it gives you this other metric to say how close did I get to completing the objective. So beyond the score you can say I had a better game because I was able to complete the objective. But so many of those objectives just really feel out of reach in solo play. Not all of them but a lot of them do. And a lot of them it's not even the most efficient way to score there. It's often better to not finish the objective and score a whole bunch of other things and just say I'm not going to get the points of the bonus I would have got from completing the objective. But narratively and thematically that just kind of feels like a bit of a let down. So I wasn't a huge fan of that. I wish that there the games weren't just ending with a round limit. I wish that there would have been maybe another amendment to the the chapter objective to say in solo play this is the objective or something like that. That would have been more compelling. the one that's in here now. The way the game ends usually does feel a little anticlimactic. You're going to be looking at your dice, reading the board, trying to squeeze as much value as possible out of every decision you're making cuz you have so few of them.
You'll be asking yourself questions like, "What can I complete right now? What do I abandon? What is actually realistic for me to do given how much time I have left?" And don't get me wrong, the race aspect, it does add some really fun tension to the solo game and it makes many of these decisions have more weight to them and you're making uh ones that feel more engaging at times. But the trade-off is that I found that it often felt unsatisfying to finish a game of The Hobbit. I'm someone who loves in board games when you cannot do everything. you know, you feel like you're just getting super powerful, overpowered at times with the abilities you've gotten, like a tableau builder, and the game ends before you can completely use that engine the way you wanted. But maybe that incentivizes you to come back and be able to produce that engine more efficiently and then get more use out of it before the game ends.
The problem with The Hobbit is that I found that largely I almost always left feeling that. And so if every game feels unsatisfying, if every game you didn't get enough done, it starts to feel like where are the when when are the games where I get everything done, where what am I working towards? When do I have that game that says, "Okay, I finally, you know, did the efficiency puzzle just perfectly to be able to have this super satisfying game." Honestly, in my experience, I never really had that. There was aspects of it. There was hints of it. there was me replaying a chapter and saying, "Wow, I was able to actually finally, you know, get to the end or I was able to get an extra troll killed here or something like that. That felt good, but nothing that really left me with a satisfying feeling that is drawing me back into play this multiple times. But sidest stepping here, I would be remiss if I didn't mention the theme and the art, cuz the care and the detail that's put into the artwork and the characters here is fantastic, and the style it's adopted, while it might not be for everyone, is one I personally really like. I would say that for existing fans of The Hobbit, seeing how the game thematically adopts the major plot lines from the story and mixes them into the gameplay, super enjoyable, super interesting to see how they kind of made it all work and rolling, right?
But having said that, if you if you don't know the story of The Hobbit, I'm not going to tell you that this is sort of like an engrossing interesting way to uncover that story. It's not. It's a bare bones sort of retelling of it. Really, I think the enjoyment you get out of this thematically is if you come in with that knowledge already and say, "Okay, I know this plot point happens in The Hobbit. How did they turn that plot point into a roll and write?" Because the way that they have super well done. I really, really appreciate how they've integrated the thematics here. It is a cozy feeling rolling right and one that really will get your brain thinking. And the best way to understand that is to look at what a turn feels like. Let's say we're playing chapter 3 and we're in the third round. This chapter asks us to roll the black dice first on our turn and then cross off the thunderclouds with that number that is rolled. We roll the black dice and get a five. Luckily, what this crosses off shouldn't affect our plans this turn.
Next, we roll the five white dice, split them like so. For this first choice, we decide to keep two wizard hats because we need some bread to be able to traverse the spaces that are coming up on the board. And we can use these two wizard hats to cross off these spots here and get the one time bonus of two bread. Now we have to take this middle die. No decision there. But for this last decision, we're going to opt to go with this one and abandon the other. All right, time to draw our paths. We start with this single line first and we'll draw it here. Next, we'll take this shape and rotate it and mirror it because you're allowed to do that in the Hobbit and draw it here in order to get through these spaces that require bread. Now that we have enough with the two we required earlier, and that's our turn. Most turns in The Hobbit fly by like this. That's why it's so common to finish games in 10 minutes total. You're going to be able to get a lot of chapters played many times with very little time commitment. And so, if you're liking that cycle in solo, it can definitely contribute to a healthy.
And this is where it's going to become really player dependent because like I said, there are eight chapters. Once you've played through the entire, you know, eight chapter narrative story, which again, if each game only takes a max of 10 minutes, it's not going to take you very long. You could honestly sit down, if you're going to play them back to back, you could get this entire thing done, all eight chapters played in an hour and a half to two hours, no problem. So really, the incentive to come back is going to be chasing your highest highest scores in each chapter. These are little mini rolling rights then that you're that you're playing multiple times. And if you don't feel the pull from just chasing your highest scores, there's not really going to be anything else pulling you back. And once you have mastered a chapter, mastered, gotten as close as you feel like you can to that theoretical maximum, I don't know that there's going to be a huge pull bringing you back to it. But having said that, the game does try to provide you with ways to have more reasons to come back. So they have a hard mode for every single chapter. And I wouldn't say any of them are earthshattering in what they do to change the chapter, but it is really cool to see the ways that they've sort of upped the challenge and given you these extra incentives to come back.
Especially if you're really compelled by a certain chapter and you've like maybe you played it like 20 times and you finally feel like, okay, I've optimized it in a way where I'm not getting anything else out of it. The fact that you can then say, okay, now I'm going to do the hard one and come back to it. It does add more replayability that way. Now, if you are someone who ends up loving all eight chapters and really wanted to get back into each single one solo optimized, then maybe you're getting more out of this. But for me, I just wasn't feeling that that kind of pull from The Hobbit. Luckily, this is not an expensive game and so this might be enough value for you and you'll be content moving on from it whenever you're done with it and you know, you didn't invest a whole ton for the time that you spent on it. Okay, so where does that leave the hobby? You might have been able to guess by the way I'm talking about it that this is not going to take the crown for light solo champion. Um, and I'm actually going to say that I won't be playing this again solo, but I will come back to a multiplayer because playing this multiplayer to me has been a really really enjoyable uh sort of cozy roll and write experience. The fact that you can then play the entire chapter or entire eight chapters all the way through with different people um each time or you can just hone in on specific chapters, play the hard mode together, things like that. There is a lot I think I would get out of this playing this multiplayer and keeping it in my collection as sort of this puzzly uh you know rolling rate that I can come back to that has more of a cozy feel and not a lot of overhead. We get it to the table super quickly. I've been enjoying playing with my partner. So it's definitely a game I want to continue to explore multiplayer. I don't know how long it's going to last in my collection as a multiplayer role and right because that's a competitive genre and I it's this is not the best one that I played
even in the last couple years. But it is really solid. So, it'll be staying in my multiplayer rotation, but it does not take the solo crown. And I think I'm done playing it solo. Creature Caravans, a diced-driven tableau builder where you're assembling a caravan of characters, creatures, and misfits, all while moving across a map, fighting off threats, gathering and using resources from the engines you've created, and trying to score as efficiently as possible over 12 rounds. Every turn, you're going to be rolling five dice, assigning them to different actions on your player board and the cards you've collected in your tableau, and slowly utilizing the abilities on these cards to accomplish your goals. And really, those cards are everything. They define what your caravan is capable of, how you score, what kind of strategy you're going into, and how you connect with the thematics and the world of the game. And what that means is that every game of Creature Caravan does a really good job of feeling different from the last. Not just mechanically in terms of the strategies you're adopting or how you're playing, but also in the band of characters that are joining your caravan. There's a surprising amount of personality and charm in the immersion here. And you'll get much more out of Creature Caravan the more that you feel compelled to lean into that immersion.
But before you get into any of that, you have to get it to the table. While there are a few different resources and components that you're going to be pulling out of bags, there's really not a lot here. where the board just slides together really quickly. You just have the option of using either side of every board to kind of uh vary the experience from the last one based on the terrain that's going to show up. Really, the longest thing that's going to hold you up is the deck of cards. Like any game with a lot of cards, shuffling is going to be a thing. Especially if you want to try to avoid seeing the same combination of cards that you sort of all had together last time and then maybe didn't get shuffled properly. And so those same cards are coming up. You're going to want to do a good job of shuffling them. and there are a lot of them, but really that's that's a small hold up. And maybe you have like an auto shuffler machine at home and that's not even as big a deal for you. But in general, that's really the only thing that's going to ever hold you up in terms of setup. And that's not the only aspect of Creature Caravan that's easy and intuitive.
So, Creature Caravan does include an AI Ottoma opponent, and it's handled through the backside of the player board combined with a dice system. On the autumn's turn, you just roll five dice like a player would and then follow an order of operations print it on the board to determine how those dice are used. So, at first you might at like the first couple turns that you're doing the Otm's actions, it might be a bit of a hold up and you might be like, "Oh man, man, like why am I having to refer to the rule book so much and all this kind of stuff?" But I did find that honestly by the time it was like halfway through my first game and then on all subsequent plays, I didn't really have to consult the rule book at all for the Ottoma turns. And not only that, that they would they would fly by in like 20 to 30 seconds. Sometimes you want to roll things for the Ottoa that is going to involve you doing more. Like when you roll my favorite die roll for the Ottoa, which is the number three. That was sarcasm if you couldn't tell. Um, which has you drawing one card at a time, having to compare it to cards they already have to see what scores. That's the one that usually takes the longest versus I think it's the number five.
When you roll the it just Ottoa gains a fruit token and that that that takes two seconds. So like if if you roll a lot of things that are just move them, move them, move them, get a fruit token, then their turn's done. It's back to you. And so that's the really the the good thing about the Ottoa here is I love a good Ottoa system that feels like it's still engaging with the game that we're actually playing, but doesn't take all my time cuz I want to spend my time on my turns. And luckily, Creature Caravan is really good in that regard. But another interesting thing I'll note here is that the challenge that the Ottoa provides wasn't really consistent for me across games. Some games the Ottoa felt really beatable. Other games it suddenly feels like it's having an incredible run and you're scrambling to keep pace and finding that it beat you by 20 points. And that unpredictability is kind of actually compelling. It mimics the feeling of playing against another person who just sometimes has a better game than you or playing against different people each time where some people are better at the game and some people are worse at it. So, I honestly I I don't mind that kind of variability.
For me, it was an issue, but I will say that that lack of consistency in how the Ottoa performs means there is less challenge here sometimes you play. Now, there is one part of the Ottoa that I really didn't enjoy, and I've alluded to it a little bit. That's the way the Ottoa handles its tableau of cards. Because as the game goes on, the Ottoma builds its own tableau of cards like the human players do, but without the cap of how many cards you can have. And this leads to the Ottoma sometimes having a lot of cards in front of them. And the way it scores and interacts with those cards often relies on the keywords and double-checking which ones the Ottoa already has, which scoring conditions already exist on the Otto's cards. So you end up spending a lot of time scanning through those Ottoma cards depending what they roll, checking for keywords, comparing them to the newly drawn cards, figuring out what scores and what doesn't. It's not that it's difficult. It's not that it's confusing.
It's just it just feels unnecessarily tedious. It feels like they wanted to have the Ottoa still be engaged with the card system cuz it's the the main draw of the game. And that makes sense to me, but it's not interesting for me to have a, you know, a stack of 20 Ottoma cards. And I say stack because at some point with my table space, I just started putting them into a stack of cards and then flipping through the 18 to reference keywords. It's just not super exciting to look through a stack of 20 cards after you've drawn one to say, "Okay, this is a delver and nocturnal. Do I have anything in these cards that scores for Delver versus Nocturnal? Oh, yes, I do. It says if you have four Nocturnals. Okay, I got to go back. Let me let me check this stack to see if I already have four because if you already have four nocturnals, you don't need this extra one. And you'll draw the next card. Oh, I only have three. Okay, I can take this card. Oh, I have four. Okay, we discard that card. Now, we draw another one. Oh, this one's a tiny. Now, let's look for the tiny keyword. There's one action that is draw five cards and whichever one has the highest value, give that one to the Ottoa. Yes, that adds a lot of RNG randomness because they might just you might just draw a set and they get 11 points off of it.
But it's way quicker and way more um satisfying to just be done with the Otmus turn knowing they got some points from the cards then getting back to yours than shuffling through that entire deck or looking through their entire temple of cards to see what you should be doing with a card that was drawn. So that was one thing I just really didn't enjoy with the way that the Ottoa was implemented. And that idea of interacting with cards, managing them, scanning them, that carries directly into the games. Creature Caravan lives and dies by its cards. That is the most exciting and the best part of this game in my opinion. You have a huge selection of of unique ones here. each of them being different character with their own sort of like slight bit of theme injection, unique abilities, unique ways that they all work together. And surprisingly, this is also where it occasionally loses me.
Now, don't get me wrong, because you might be a little confused. I I said I really do like the cards, and I do. I love them. They're the best part of the game. But a lot of the ways that you interact with the cards do come down to the keywords that are on them. It's like a pseudo set collection game where you know a card will say this gets you eight points if you have four plus cards with the tiny keyword. And so a lot of the card system just boils down to when they're in your tableau if you're looking at scoring from them in any sort of meaningful way. You're just continuously referring to these keywords. And I think that's part of the reason it bothers me a little bit looking through the Otus cards is I'm already doing enough keyword searching and and uh factoring in in my strategies and stuff that I don't want to then do even more of it for a Ottoa that doesn't really have synergies form with them intentionally. It's just what cards they happen to get. The the cards themselves, the abilities you get from them, the the thematics that are on them, the characters that the that card represents, that's all great. It just the keyword system to me was a little bit underwhelming. It's not a bad system by any means. I just didn't find it overly exciting either. And because this deck of cards is so large, there will be games where you just don't see the cards you want or need. That randomness can be exciting for some players and it's just a factor that is in this game you'll have to deal with. And and every game is a new puzzle because of it. But for me, it never quite reached that level of satisfaction where I was excited to dig back in and try again to see if I could get the cards that I wanted. But I also want to be clear. I've never had a bad game of Creature Caravan. I have enjoyed all my plays to different degrees, but
I've never been completely wowed by a play of Creature Caravan. I've never been really compelled to come back to it. I haven't be beyond maybe the first time I played where, you know, it's a brand new. You have the rose colored glasses. It's a brand new game. You want to see what else it has. Once I've gotten past that initial sort of entry period with the game, there was nothing about it that I thought, "Oh, I really want to play another game of Creature Caravan." But again, what did stand out to me is the theme and the presentation. This game has a ton of personality. For example, imagine you have a caravan filled with a grassin beekeeper and his emerald bee. You're all traversing in a trinket wagon being managed and repaired by the toad folk engineer you picked up when you camped at the lake last round. You've got a fish folk cook who's keeping the whole caravan fed along the journey, while a lizard folk scout does his best to keep a close eye on the zombies that regularly attack the caravan. and you've got a theoretical mystic along for the ride, studying meticulously from his tomes, trying to discern the origin of these zombies maybe and how to stop them once and for all. Suddenly, you have these emergent narratives that don't really matter mechanically to the game, but they add flavor and they add personality, and it makes the caravan feel alive. It makes the caravan feel more than just a set of cards you have on the table. But eventually, all these decisions you're making, how you build your caravan, what you prioritize, how you adapt, funnel into what a turn actually looks like in this game.
Let's say you're a few rounds into the game. You've got a small caravan built up, a couple of resource engines online, and you're starting to push forward on the map. You roll your five dice. You've got a six, two fours, a three, and a two to work with. You decide to start by using your six to draw three cards and discard one because you need more options to play from your hand. You can use the six here because whatever number a dieice spot shows, you can use that number or any number of higher value. You've drawn a card now that costs 10 bread that you'd love to play this turn. So, you have to use your four and your three on your beekeeper and your B to gain five bread total. Now, you decide to use your two to trade at the market. You've got three gold to trade with, which means you can activate this spot on the trade board and gain another five bread. You now play the bounty hunter to your caravan, paying your bread to the supply. Now you've got a way to defend yourself against future zombies.
Finally, you use your three to move forward one spot on the map. You didn't move as much as you'd like this round, but hopefully you can move more on the next round. Now it's the Ottoa's turn. They roll two sixes, two ones, and a three. Starting at the top of the board in the order of operations, you use the two sixes to complete the lowest available trade for the Ottoa, which will score them points at the end of the game. Then you use the two ones to move two spaces forward and two spaces up. Lastly, my favorite action, you use the three, which means you'll draw one card at a time and keep checking to see if it completes or adds to any existing scoring conditions in the Ottoa's caravan. If it does, the Ottoa gains that card and the action is done. But if it doesn't, you discard that card, draw a new one, and continue this process until you find a card that scores for the Ottoa. And that really is how it feels to play Creature Caravan. The Ottoa turns are really quick, and you're constantly juggling. Are you going to prioritize moving a whole bunch on this board on this turn or are you going to build up your engine or are you going to utilize your engine? You you really with only five dice can't do everything every turn and so it becomes this balance of what are you doing on this turn versus what are you doing on the other turns to be able to sort of maximize your your points to maximize everything you're doing. Are you going to try to reach the end of the board this game to get the maximum 25 points and the bonus for actually reaching the last tile or do you have this other engine to score points and you don't care as much about how you move along the board? Maybe you're content only making it to the third quadrant and losing those other points. And how you feel about everything I just described and showed you, how compelling it does or doesn't sound will contribute, of course, to the
games. On one hand, there are a lot of cards. And so, out of every game I've played, I have never seen the same caravan twice. I've constantly seen cards that I've never seen before. There's still so many cards I haven't used that are in this deck. And even if you see a card that you've used before, you've never used them in conjunction with other cards in your caravan, that the chances that you're going to have an identical caravan is is slim to none based on how many cards are in this deck and what's going to become available to you. The flip side here is that the game that you're interacting with with beyond your caravan is very sy. Moving across this board starts to feel very sy. Yes, you're going to get new abilities on your cards that might have you moving across it more efficiently or less efficiently, but I would say that it's not super exciting to just move across this board. The most exciting part of it to me is figuring out where to camp because there's different bonuses on there that you might get a fruit if you camp here. You might get to draw three cards if you camp here. You might have a card in your caravan that says if you camp on a lake spot now, you get this other incentive. That's the best part of the movie on the board, trying to say, "Okay, is there a way I can make it to this spot? Cuz I would love to camp there this term. It thematically feels like it works with uh with what you're doing." And it is an interesting decision. It does start to feel a little samy and that variability does suffer a little bit. It really is sort of like the variability in the shelf life of this game is putting the entire the entire weight is being put on the cards here. And luckily, they do a pretty good job. But just know that once that starts to uh sort of stretch thin for you,
there's not going to be a lot of other places that the variability is going to exist beyond those cards. Okay, so having said all that, Creature Caravan, this might surprise some people, but not only is it not the champion for me, this is not going to be a game that I'm going to play again solo or multiplayer. And I really want to just stress here before I upset anyone who really likes this game or is excited for it, this is not a bad game by any stretch. This is a really good game. It's just not a game that I am feeling super compelled or excited to come back to. The amount of times I played it, I I saw what I wanted to out of the building your caravan, out of trying different combinations of characters. I would still be open to trying that again multiplayer, but there are so many games in my collection and games that are are competing for table space, even just Tableau builders alone that this is not one of the top ones. This is not one of the ones I'm excited to show people.
There's other ones I'd rather play before this, and there's going to be more games that are going to add to that that are going to bump ahead of Creature Caravan. So, realistically, if I'm being realistic with my game time and what I'm playing, this just isn't one that's going to be finding time to hit the table. But, I'm really happy to have played it. It is a beautiful game to table and a lot it's just rich in characters and stories that can come out of it as sort of like an emergent storytelling type thing. And so, that by all by every metric is the best part of the game in my opinion. And I'm really happy to have experienced it. It's just not taking the crown.
SEI is a game about scanning the cosmos, launching probes, developing technologies, and ultimately trying to find life beyond Earth. You'll be playing some of the many cards in this game, generating resources, upgrading your capabilities, and finding efficient ways to convert all of that into points. If you've played something like Terraforming Mars or Earth, a lot of this will feel familiar structurally, especially when it comes to the large deck of unique cards. What SetI does differently is wrap all of that in this evolving solar system. You're sending probes to planets. You're landing on surfaces and eventually you're discovering life among the stars in the form of alien species that you can reveal each game that will shift the way you approach the remainder of that game. All while the rings of the solar system rotate and make it harder or easier to get where you need to go. But before you get to any of that discovery, you have to actually get SETI to the table.
So, I'm not going to bury the lead here. SETI is a lot to set up and to tear down each time. There are multiple boards, multiple tokens that you have to put in specific spots. There's there's tokens you have to put on top of other tokens only after you've sorted all those tokens into individual piles. There's just going to be a lot. And and it's it's you can get it more efficient by playing it more often, but it's never going to stop being a bit of a slog in terms of the thing that might hold you back from playing it solo. Do I have time for the setup? Do I want to do the setup right now? You're going to spend a lot of time as a solo player just setting up and tearing this game down. But now when it's all on the table, I mean, it looks incredible. The table presence is fantastic. It feels big. It feels important. It feels like you're engaging with something substantial.
It's beautiful thematically. It fits the space theme. And there's no denying that it's both eye-catching and satisfying to interact with. But getting there is honestly going to be the dealbreaker for a lot of people. Now, it might be surprising to say because we haven't even started talking about playing the game yet, but I have to comment on the fact that depending on what you have capacity for in your life and why you are approaching board gaming solo, that's going to dictate whether this is the game for you or not. Because if you're dealing with very minimal time, if you're dealing with a game that you can't leave set up, that you're going to have to set up and tear down in that session, this is all going to factor into whether this is a game that you're going to want to add to your solo library. Because if you're dealing with, you know, yeah, small kids or or playing on a dining room table that you have to have cleared before you eat, that is all adding to the time. And this is not a game that's playing in, you know, 20 minutes either, especially when you're first um getting into this game and understanding its systems and the strategies. It's going to take you like 2 hours to play solo probably, and you're going to eventually get that down, but that's probably where you're going to start things off. This can be an amazing game under the under the hood. We'll get into that in a little bit to see if it is. But that doesn't change the fact that it might just not be feasible as the game that you are going to engage within your home. But interestingly, one of the aspects you might expect to add to the complexity and the weight is actually one of the most surprisingly streamlined.
So, to set credit, the way that the Ottoa is handled is pretty great. The Ottoa here uses a similar system to games like Colution or Clans of Calonia that we've talked about before. You flip a card, follow an order of operations, and execute the first valid action. It's clean, quick, elegant, and it works really well. It's very similar to how you distribute the dice in Creature Caravan. There's also this really nice system in terms of how the game um introduces advanced cards for the Ottoa. So, you start with four basic cards, and when the deck runs out, that's the end of the Ottoa's turn. Um, sorry, the Otto's round, and there's only five rounds in the game. But because more cards get added in, the Ottoma slowly is able to do more and more before it has to pass and is out of the round. And that really mimics uh a player sort of running out of resources, but over subsequent rounds having more resources, having more things they can do before they have to pass. So the way that they've integrated that is really interesting and it adds this extra layer of tension as you do things or the Ottoman does things that are going to add more advanced cards into the deck because you know the Otto is getting more powerful. You know, the capabilities are starting to widen. But now, I will mention that for the first couple games at least, you're going to be referencing the rule book a lot. The iconography here takes a little bit to internalize, and you'll need to double check how certain you are that certain actions are what you think they are. But ultimately, for such a heavy game, you will spend the majority of your time on your own turns. And this is something that is really, really important for heavy games, at least for me. And it's reasons why I love to play Clans of Calonia solo and Cibolution solo. And
importantly, it's also competitive. Even at lower difficulties, the Ottoa can and will push you. And with five difficulty levels available, there's a lot of room to scale that challenge up if you're enjoying the game and want to keep coming back to it. I'll also say I think the task tiles are essential. They are only introduced at difficulties two and up. And I found that once I played with task tiles, I had no incentive and no reason to want to go back and not play with them. The Ottoman does suffer for some from some of the things that you see most commonly with Otto. And that's where you'll be doing something that if you were playing with other humans, someone would absolutely stop you or make it harder for you to accomplish that thing. And you'll be playing with the Ottoa and they will not even regard what you're doing at all. That's just something that's really hard to introduce in a solo game without having like a really complicated flowchart of operations saying if the player has done this, do this. It's not it's not egregious here. It's not going to be something that's really making you roll your eyes when you're able to accomplish certain things because the Ottoa is still competitive in its own ways. So even when you have these amazing turns that could have been stopped by a human player, the Otto is still doing something that you're having to compete with or keep up with. So it's not a big deal breaker by any means. It's just something I want to bring up in that this isn't a, you know, wildly sophisticated Otto AI that is going to challenge you in terms of the tactical decisions you're making. it's more going to challenge you in the overall score that you're trying to keep up with. Even though the Ottoa is one of the easier things to manage, you're not just managing that Ottoa in isolation. You're managing it alongside everything else
that SETI is asking you to keep track of. And depending how you feel about that, it can have different effects on your In my opinion, there's no denying that STEI is a good game. Honestly, Seti is a great game. It it's for some it's going to be a top 10 game. This is a fantastic game and the card play specifically is really really solid. There are moments playing STI that feel incredible. When you chain actions together, execute a really strong turn, score a bunch of points, pivot your strategy at the right moment. It all feels fantastic, especially because the theme is rich and it comes through in all the things that you're doing. And you can lean into it even further if you want with all the flavor text that exists on the cards as well. And especially that moment where a new alien race enters the game and suddenly introduces new scoring opportunities, new rules, new priorities, it feels awesome. It's it's akin to opening a secret envelope in a campaign game and seeing how it changes the experience. It genuinely genuinely feels like the game shifts under your feet. But as I said, there's just a lot to manage here. And I don't just mean the decisions, I mean everything. You're constantly scanning the table, not just to plan your turn, but to make sure you're not forgetting something, you're not missing something. Did you score that correctly? Did you apply that bonus? What's the cost of that again? Is there a task that I should be focusing on? Is there a mission I'm overlooking?
Is there a card in the market I want to use my publicity right now to claim? And for sure, there's going to be some people out there that tell me after I play four times, I never made mistakes. And and I mean, that that's great. I just I have a feeling that's going to be a a lesser case and it's going to be more common to have to play this many times before you feel really comfortable with everything that you're doing. I think if you I think honestly playing this multiplayer like having already played this multiplayer multiple times and then approaching the solo would probably be a better introduction to it because you're going to have a way less of an overhead of trying to figure out what things are and and all the things that you could forget. But if you buy this and are your the primary way you're going to play it is solo, you're dealing with all that by yourself in isolation versus having a bunch of other people that can catch things around the table as well. And because there's so many systems layered on top of each other here, it becomes less about making those interesting decisions sometimes and more about making sure you're actually accounting for everything. And for me, for a solo experience, it just felt like too many things. Not because the systems themselves aren't good, cuz they are, but because there's just too many of them. And then when you pair that with the already long setup time, it starts to feel less like sitting down to play a game and more like committing to an entire process. But ultimately, a lot of how steady lands for you is going to come down to the question, is the juice worth the squeeze? Now, I will say this cuz I think it's important. There's a bit of personal bias here in the sense that I am not a big space theme guy.
It's not that I don't find space themed games or movies or shows that I like. It's just that it is always a bit of a harder theme to sell me on versus something that's more grounded on an actual planet or a world. That personal bias I think is a little bit important to say here because if you are really really connected with the theme and if you love space games that might be another layer that makes it way easier to overcome the setup for you because even as you're setting it up it's enjoyable and it's exciting to put all these pieces together to think about what aliens are going to be under there to see all the planets you're going to be trying to explore and interact with. So that's something that I didn't get out of it and that might have, you know, affected why I was a little bit less willing to kind of trudge through the setup and the tear down, whereas you might be more willing because the theme is so exciting to you. Let's come back to the cards here for a second because they're great. Like Terraforming Mars and Earth, the variety is massive. The directions, they push you and feel meaningful. Every game has its own identity. The cards will offer more efficient ways to accomplish actions.
They'll offer missions and goals to chase for. They'll offer incentives that'll give you more scoring opportunities. They have multiple uses and can be discarded completely for immediate benefits. But again, they're adding to an already very full plate. And the best way to understand that balance between this is awesome and this is a lot is to look at a sample turn. Imagine you're in round two of a game of SETI and it's your turn. You have several main actions you could choose from. What you're hoping to do is launch a probe. You could take the regular launch a probe action to do this, but instead you're going to use the play a card action to play Rosetta Probe from your hand. This is the same cost as the launch a probe action gives us the same result, but in this case it will also leave a mission in play for us that we can complete later by having a probe on a comet. Now, normally you can only have one probe in space at a time. And since you already have one, you wouldn't be able to take this action. However, you already have this upgrade token that allows you two probes in space at a time. So now this is completely legal.
You pay the cost and launch the probe, but placing it on the Earth's space on the board. But you're not done. You'd really like to reach Venus this turn as well. Even though you have no main actions left, you do have free actions. So you discard two cards from your hand that show the probe movement icon in the top left, allowing you to move this new probe immediately, the two spaces required to reach Venus. Lastly, you claim the one publicity bonus shown on the board for having a probe reach the Venus space. Now it's the Ottoman's go. They flip the next card in their deck and follow the order of operations to find a completable action. The second alien species isn't yet discovered, so we skip that. The Ottoma doesn't have a probe in space, so we skip this second section, too. And so, we do this third section. First, we rotate the solar system. Next, we check which space of their Ottoma board track their token is on. And this determines which upgrade token the Ottoa receives from the board.
They score two bonus points for acquiring the two bonus point token here for being the first one to grab from this stack. They also move one spot forward on this track for the draw card bonus that was on the token they received because the Ottoa doesn't draw cards in this game. Lastly, they move another space on this track for the symbol that was on the actual action card that the Ottoa drew. And now their turn is complete and it's back to you. Some turns will be more involved than this, but it should give you the feel of what it's like to play SETI and carry out the autumn actions as well and how that would factor into the longevity of the game in your collection. There is so much here when we're talking about variability. This is probably one of the strongest categories for STI because the cards alone are going to make every single game feel different. Out of every game I've played of SETI, I didn't see in any game more than a third of the cards. usually less than that based on what I was acquiring and what was in the market. And so there's a lot to draw you back just in terms of the variability of strategy and how you're going to be able to interact with all the systems. That's not even speaking to the fact that you're going to have different aliens come out every single game. You're going to have the Ottoma act in different ways and compete with you in different ways, different directions you're going to go, different endgame objectives that you're going to be scoring for, different um upgrade tiles you're going to try focusing on that game. The variability here is going to be something that brings you back every single time. No question. So, in terms of shelf life, this is a game you don't have to worry about if you're going to get your bang for your buck because there's lots to love here. But all of that variety only matters if you are willing to keep getting it to the table. And for me, this was the sticking
point because as exciting as that discovery is, you still have to go through that setup and that tear down. You still have to manage everything during the game. You still have to have the patience to play STI solo. And that friction does add up. At least for me, it did. And yet, it's a game I keep thinking about and wanting to play more of, which really only leaves me with one conclusion. For me, this is a game I am not going to be coming back to solo, but I will no question be coming back to this multiplayer. I I I think that this is such a fantastic game. I don't know where it's going to land for me over repeated multiplayer plays. And I don't know especially how it's going to compare to a game like Earth which is my favorite in that sort of like genre of games like Terrifying Mars Earth Arc Nova where you just have a lot of cards and they kind of that's where you get your variability solo-wise not going to hit the table for me anymore. But multiplayer really excited to see where it lands and I'm sure we'll have more to say about the about it on the channel after I start playing a bunch more and after Carlos played it as well uh and Braden so we can all kind of weigh in on it cuz there's there's a lot I'm curious about in terms of what I'll think of it but also in terms of what they'll think of it.
That's all I got for you. Those are the games for today's episode. But before I leave you, we have to look at the top five for each of the categories. So, I'm popping that up on the screen. Now, the ones you have to be aware of in terms of movement from the last episode, Cozy Stickerville bumped out of the number five slot. No surprise there. It was really there because I just have not played enough light games to to have that be a super competitive top five quite yet. So, The Hobbit has bumped in there, but I don't think The Hobbit is probably going to stay there that long. Again, I much prefer playing it multiplayer, but it's there for now until I play enough light solo board games. Uh, medium spot, Creature Caravan does not crack the top five. It's not super far out of there, but again, it's just not one I'm planning to return to, so it doesn't quite crack that top five. And for the heavy games, uh, SI doesn't crack the top five either. I honestly think I'm going to really, really enjoy STI as a multiplayer game. And it's one that I wouldn't be surprised if you saw it as sort of on it. If you saw STI on my like top 50 uh games one day or especially as I play more multiplayer, it being a game that I'm talking about more on this channel as I dive into more. Maybe I return to it solo one day when I have a slew of games under my under my belt and and I find that it's easier to get to the table and and pack up and everything, but right now there's just too much of a barrier there for me.
So, those are the current top fives. Thank you for watching episode 2. if you have any game suggestions. I've I'm I'm always playing a ton of solo games at once. And so often when I've already finished an episode like we are with now, I've sort of already been working on the games for the next episode, but I'm always looking for more games to sort of get into circulation and then that way I can consider them for future episodes. So light, medium, heavy. If you have solo games you'd love to see here or you're just curious my thoughts on them or you just want to find out, have I already played them? Are they gaps that I'm looking to play one day? Leave those in the comments and I'll respond to all the ones that I can. Otherwise, thank you so much for watching and we will see you next time.