Song for War Impressions & Light Review | Wargame Historical Game | Invicta Rex
Transcript
hey everybody I'm Zilla Blitz and welcome today I'm going to offer up some Impressions and a Light review on song for war Mediterranean theater by invictor Rex games this game is coming to Kickstarter in early 2025 and I've had a chance to spend over a couple of iterations of the game probably about 15 to 20 hours playing it now so I wanted to offer up some thoughts on gameplay before we start what is song for war Mediterranean theater it's strategic operational level game set in World War II in the Mediterranean Theater now there is a in this version of the kickstarter there are four scenarios two larger scenarios that are kind of strategic and operational in nature covering the entire Mediterranean theater and then new to this Kickstarter are two smaller scenarios one set in North Africa and one set in Italy that can be played in a shorter time span with a couple of mechanics left out that are in the larger game I'll talk more about that momentarily but that in a nutshell is what song for war Mediterranean theater is now the question is do I like it the answer to this question is yes unequivocally I do like it but I need to explain some stuff because I think this game more than a lot of games I play hits on the things that I personally really really like in gameplay and the words I would wrap around to describe this game are uh creativity and and and creativity in design certainly but what I what really I what I'm talking about with this element of creativity is that it lets you as the player play creatively in
particular uh at the on these larger Mediterranean theater scale two scenarios the bigger ones I think it really holds true and I'll talk a little bit about some nuances between the larger scenarios and the smaller scenarios momentarily but creativity is one and I love games that let you kind of go off in a bunch of different directions and this of course the creativity is tied to this hypothetical ahistorical nature of the game this game is Loosely tied to history so as the axis allies forces reminds me a lot of it's set in the med Mediterranean theater but it's a Sandbox of gameplay you can go a ton of different directions as either side and very quickly you could you could go right along the historical path but you could also deviate quite easily from history not in terms only of the strategies you take but in terms of the force pools and what type of combat you're going to try to engage in as the the forces that are involved in this theater I should say too uh this is a two to four player game so if you have four players well if you have four they have four factions you have the Allies which consist of the US forces and the Commonwealth forces you have the axis forces which consist of the German forces and the Italian forces and the Italian forces are an equal player in this game uh which ties in a little bit to this a historical nature of the game that we'll talk about momentarily um if you're playing two players then one player controls the axis and one player controls the allies and if you're playing three then you can figure it out you kind of you know mix the sides up in that regard um but that's so we got creativity we've got this hypothetical nature of gameplay and the other thing that I think these other
two terms that go together for me that describe the gameplay are fun decisions and problem solving um I love games that throw fun decisions at you and I think on two levels in particular with this large the larger scenarios that really throws a lot of fun problems at you and gives you a lot of fun decisions these are factors in game plays that gameplay that I really really like and if that describes the type of gameplay that you like I think you will like song forward Mediterranean theater as well now there is a little bit of a Nuance here and I and this allow me to talk a little bit about the differences this is a little bit of History I guess we're talking about of this game this game was brought to Kickstarter a couple of years ago U there's been a lot of refinements made as it's returning to Kickstarter now for the second time uh they've added two scenarios which are smaller scenarios that are going to play out in a shorter time span that leave off a couple of mechanics in the larger scenarios now I really really really like the larger scenarios because you've got creativity in problem solving on two levels level number one is the Strategic level because the larger scenario is the big map the entire Mediterranean theater and your problem solving is like where are you going to go you're going to go up through Greece you're going to go through C Sicily you're going to go up through Italy how's North Africa going to play out as the Germans are you going to hit Malta where are you going to put your forces where you going to Counterattack so you've got this kind of strategic cat and mouse deception like game where you're shifting forces and this game has really good momentum
things happen fast so you're never waiting too long to kind it's not like you're going to have this idea and execute it like an hour and a half later in gameplay you're going to have an idea and you can execute it right away so the game has really good pace and momentum so it's playing fast you're making all these decisions about where you're going to go and you're always wondering what your opponent is going to do so you've got this kind of strategic level of fun decisions and problem solv in these larger scenarios and then in all four of the scenarios you have the the micro problem solving more of the operational nature which is how are you going to string together within this really interesting sequence of play how are you going to string together your operations and reach your object objectives for example if you're trying to take Alexandria as the axis forces how are you going to conduct that operation and launch that offensive on Alexandria and that's a smaller scale set of fun decisions and problem solving that's that runs through all four scenarios so well I really really really like the larger scenarios because you've got these two levels I like the smaller level ones because the smaller ones to a certain degree lack that grand strategic problem solving that the larger scenarios have in song for war Mediterranean theater so I've talked about how much I like gameplay I think there's two misconceptions you could make about this game one which would lead you to buy the game as a mistake and one would would lead you to not buy the game as a mistake let me talk a little bit about both of these the first is if you are a war gamer that's looking
in historically accurate simulation of the Mediterranean theater this is not the game for you okay it's just the supply is limited this is designed there's an emphasis on gameplay here now that's not to say that this is a simple game I'll talk about that when I talk about the next Point uh but you know as Germans you could be building a a kind of a fleet of aircraft barriers you can have all these different types of decisions that really don't line up with the actual World War II history but it lines up within this sandbox of strategic and operational decisionmaking that in Victor X Games has crafted but if you want something that's a historical simulation of the Mediterranean theater and you get this game you will be disappointed by the game it's not that type of game so that's the first mistake you could assume it's a historical simulation get the game and you're going to be disappointed the second mistake I think you could make here is you could look at this and look at the map and look at the pieces and hear me talk a little bit about like this sandbox of gameplay and look at it and say oh this is just an axis and allies clone um it's not that either right so this game has a lot more subtlety there's actually some fairly good and Rich complexity of gameplay when you're talking about some of the operational combat decisions you're making and the uniqueness of units and how it all integrates with this the sequence of play so this this balance if you would or this dance between the sequence of play all these units that have unique abilities and then the complexity of the rule set it's lands in
a really sweet spot of gameplay and it's more complex more subtle and deeper in richer than axis and allies nothing against axis and allies great game this game is more like a war game in many ways than access and allies is and it is deeper and richer and so if you're are a war gamer that likes the thing I talked about earlier you don't want to dismiss this game because you think it looks like access and allies it's not it's there's a lot more going on with this game so if you pass on the game making it its assumption that it's access and allies you're also making a mistake and the conversation about complexity kind of brings us to a point of what would I give this game as a complexity rating I would say a three and a half out of 10 it really hits that sweet spot I think between playability and complexity now if we talk a little bit about the complexity rating I think we also can offer up a little bit of thoughts on soliter there are some guidelines for soliter that are coming out that I haven't seen yet so this may change the rating a little bit as I talk about it right now I'd probably give it a five and a half out of 10 in particular the larger scale Mediterranean theater games have a a hidden Fleet which actually plays a surprisingly big role in a lot of the strategy because where that Fleet or where those fleets pop up and trying to find those fleets can really kind of alter a campaign game there a game as you're playing it so that's kind of a bigger mechanic I think in those larger theater games in particular I think the smaller scenarios like the North Africa scenario and the Italian scenario um the the hidden fleets play I think less of a
role and so they work really well I think as a soliter game and on the whole outside of the Hidden fleets you're going to be playing both sides two-handed but I think there's a lot of fun to be had in terms of those problem solving elements and the fun decisions you're going to be making as you swap back and forth between sides so certainly not a soliter un friendly game about a 5 and a half out of 10 and I am very curious to see the soliter guidelines and how that might influence this rating as the game gets closer to uh its Kickstarter and its final release probably should also mention a little bit about the components in the game I think the map's absolutely fabulous it's just to me it's in person too it is one of the most stunning Maps I've seen in a war game yet I think it's absolutely gorgeous the depth the color palette the design and these big Mediterranean theater map when you put it together I think 46 in or so it's just it looks gorgeous it's got this war room type feel to it and it just makes you want to play I mentioned this earlier on but in earlier version I was playing the game my wife walked by and she's not a war gamer at all but she's looking wow this map is really good it's like yes this map is really good and the components the the pieces the units really good the player Aid is absolutely brilliant after you read the rules I find that 99% of the information I need to play the game is in this really elegantly designed and crafted player Aid where you've got all your unit information on one side and your sequence of play and the other information you need on the other side really nice design and I think there's a real Elegance to this game in terms of
what it looks like and how it plays and the quality of the components another question I'd like to address as we talk a little bit about this is the replayability of the game there's four scenarios again if you get the full version there's four scenarios if you get the smaller Kickstarter option I think it's going to include the two smaller scenarios and again if I were to to comment on those to just to kind of reiterate I think the game really shines at its best in those these larger scenarios it's very good in the smaller scenarios from that problem solver kind of nut cracking kind of problem solving fund decision way but the Strategic decisions that the Mediterranean theater offers really adds another level of gameplay to this and the Strategic level those kind of larger scenarios also have a mechanic that's left off in the smaller scenarios which is the unique units and kind of the national support element to the game which is really kind of like a research part of the game so every turn you're going to get a couple of national support tokens you're going to get some cards that you can opt into purchasing as one of the factions and they might include a special unit like a mosquito bomber or a special ship or like the B7 bomber if you're the US and those units are upgraded versions of the core units in the game and they're quite powerful and quite unique and so in any given game you're not going to see all of those you're going to get a completely different set of these unique cards that are going to be given to you because you don't get to pick from all of them you get to pick I think it's three in a turn and so you're going to be limited in each game as to what
you're going to get and those cards I think can actually dictate strategy and if you get a certain type of unit you might say okay let's build a lot of these and let's really try to attack from the sea or the air or let's make our land forces strong and concentrate on that so I think with that in mind that those um the kind of The Campaign games the larger scenarios uh really have an element of replayability because every game's going to play out quite differently depending upon the units that you get so yes I think the game has a ton of replayability especially in those larger scenarios uh the mediter the theater type scenarios let's talk a little bit about potential negatives um I think there's three things probably to mention the the first is there there is a good bit of dice chucking here uh and sometimes you can have a very well-crafted strategy or operation get all the right pieces in all the right places and you just don't roll the dice well and your operation falls apart um I you know you want to be aware of that I don't think that I wouldn't say that's a negative feature but some people don't like that right some people want the better strategy always to win this is a game where I think 75 to 80% of the time the better strategy is going to win but you are going to have some situations where you do everything right and you play really well and the dice Gods just just don't shine on you and everything falls apart um so there is that I think to be aware of in gameplay which I think fits in with the spirit of the game it's a very playable very accessible game um and that's kind of almost like an evening Factor against players that
might be at different skill levels the second thing I do find uh it takes a little while to wrap your head around the uniqueness of the units and all of their functions and the sequence of play and some of the rules in particular with like two space firing there's some there's some intricacy and some depth to this that's going to take you a little while to wrap your head around and play and figure it out one of the things I think that this connects to is the fact that every unit in the game is like a tool in a toolbox it can do a certain thing so these operations you want to kind of time them right you're going to bring your air in you're going to bring your sea in then your land forces come in and getting that sequence to work well it is takes a little bit of time to wrap your head around those rules in the sequence of play and how it makes it work so not really a negative it's more of a positive right because this game has I think a rich complexity to it and a really nice subtleness subtlety to play that really brings out elegance and how you're playing but it is going to take you a little while to kind of wrap your head around the sequence of play and some of the rules involved with the uniqueness of units and how they all interact in combat and the only other thing I think I would mention again this isn't necessarily a negative but I would like to see some even smaller scenarios in the game and I think you could make those up on your own as I was kind of creating the gameplay video that I I created a couple of weeks ago for this game I just created my own small scenario which was just an attack on trook a one- turn attack on trook by axis forces with the British forces trying to hold I ended up playing that like three times the first time I played it it was unbalanced I screwed it up I
didn't have the units right so I tweaked the kind of the order of battles for both sides and then the second time it worked out really really well I made a video on it and I'm like I kind of want to see what happens again so I played it a third time so I think like these little one- turn scenarios you can almost generate them on your own with it' be cool to see more of those in the game you know with like an attack on Rome or Beach Landing in Sicily or something just one turn scenarios with a limited space on the map with a limited Force pool and let players go at it for an hour because those were really fun for me to make when I created the video so I think it's not necessarily a negative it's just I think there's an opportunity here for a a kind of a smaller set of very quick scenarios so you could play when you've got like a half an hour 45 minutes or something like that and with that I think I've dumped my brain with song for war Mediterranean theater I hope it helps as you go up and look at this on its upcoming Kickstarter I'll put a link down below to that if you're interested in it be happy to entertain questions thanks for watching and if you did like this Impressions uh video there is a video on gameplay that I'll put a link to up over here that you can check out song for war Mediterranean theater by an Victor games coming to Kickstarter in early 2025 thanks for watching Everybody bye