Solo Thoughts | Shadows of Kilforth (and comparing it to Gloom and Call)
Transcript
hello everyone welcome I'm Rober and today I'm going to discuss Shadows of kilforth and uh if you've been watching my content recently you know that uh I made a uh Gloom of kill Forth video and a call of kill forth video so uh this is the actually the second title in the series and I kind of ended up um acquiring the titles out of order and playing them out of order so I first played Gloom and uh I do really like the title uh then I played a call I do also really like it I had a couple issues with it so feel free to watch that video uh if you want to find out more uh and but I still do really love both titles and um you know it kind of felt a bit incomplete that I had the first one and the third one I kind of kept telling myself you know why do I need the second title but I do really like the game so much that uh I couldn't help myself and uh I went ahead and got uh shadows as well okay uh so uh it is the second in this this is the second in the series like I said and uh in case you haven't played any of the Gloom of kill forth games I'll give you a a brief uh overview of you know what this game is about so this is an uh adventuring RPG uh it's car driven and you're going to generate a map with uh random uh a a a deck of um location cards and you're going to pick a
character a class and you need to defeat an ancient right that you're also going to pick okay and you're going to have uh there's a a knight deck that has about 25 that has 25 cards so you have about 25 days uh it acts as your timer and and that's what you use that's what you use to um you know uh keep track of time and you're going to explore the land you're going to uh defeat enemies uh and uh you know complete quests uh and meet strangers and you're going to progress uh in uh you're going to progress like that acquiring items allies uh spells and you know getting stronger until you reach your Saga finale okay you you'll also choose a saga uh and when you go through your four chapters of your Saga you're then going to uh face the engent and try to defeat it right so uh that is consistent across all three titles right that's the uh that's the uh you know summary of what happens okay so how does Shadows um you know differ from the other uh two so uh so Shadows uh it uh it has a Oriental a theme okay uh and also it is uh it is an um an increase in difficulty over uh Gloom of kilforth and now that I've actually played call of kilforth I'll say it's
more difficult than K of kilforth as well all right um so uh let's discuss uh uh what I've done all right U you know what my experience with this has been what I've actually played before I proceed so um I have played four games all right against different Asians ancients uh and uh I only won two of those games all right uh I do tend to have a pretty good win rate with this uh game but um the the increase in difficulty was noticeable for sure but yeah I only won two of those games and um so I played four games and I played with all expansion content thrown in all right and this has been the case with every uh kill fourth game that I've played to date um I've learned since that typically adding the expansion content increases the difficulty even more um but but when I bought uh kill forth originally it already had all the expansion content thrown in there uh so that's just how I've been it was a secondhand copy so that's just how I've been doing it um you know every time that I bought one of these all right so when I bought call of kill forth I just throw everything in the kitchen sink and you know I added all it all in um you know from my perspective I simply thought that it added more variety but it does seem to have an effect on uh difficulty all right uh so you know I kind of wish I had known that but it's too late I just throw everything in
right so I played my four games with all expansion content uh that includes the new Tails expansion by the way which is a expansion that came a few years later specifically made for Shadows of kill kill for quite a pricey expansion but I just wanted to have all kill forth content uh so now with with that expansion now I have the whole trilogy completed um and uh let's discuss uh some things that um you know how this does um some interesting things that this title does so uh so the first one is a difficulty right as I mentioned and how does it do it well um through the car design the engine design sign but also um when you set up uh you need to discard from the start you need to discard a certain amount of uh day or night cards from the night deck okay um and that means that you have less time okay so it's a it's a very uh easy and straightforward way of putting more pressure on you you're going to have less days to uh increase your uh you know um your character's strength right to face the engent uh so time is of the essence here it always has been really but typically when I when I have a definitive victories against ancients in other uh kill forth games uh I end up having like five or so U Knight cards left in the Knight deck
uh maybe three if I if I died at some point uh you know if my character uh got knocked out at some point uh throughout the game uh you know that might have set me back so maybe I'll end up with three or two night cards uh but running out of time uh unless you're very unless you're very new to the series uh it didn't really happen a whole lot to me okay um so yeah that's one way uh and you can adjust so when you set up after you doing all the standard setup stuff you can choose uh you know if you want it to be a bit easier you only discard one one night card okay uh but the standard is discarding two night cards so you have 23 days right so you have less time here and that does make a significant um impact on difficulty um now other things uh through card design uh there are some pretty brutal cards that you're going to encounter okay um I've seen some pretty nasty effects uh remember that with certain effects okay I don't have want in the map to show you currently um but uh uh there are certain effects that have the word the keyword map all right and you have to read them carefully because sometimes those map effects affect you no matter where you are in the map right so you might think that uh so if an encounter says map um when you
make a test sacrifice an asset something like that uh that doesn't necessarily mean just when you when you're in the same location as that card it means throughout the whole land all right so I've seen some really nasty effects all right that affect the entire map okay uh uh I've seen some pretty strong um you know enemies and whatnot um and the Knight cards are pretty brutal as well okay so uh the difficulty also reflects through the car design but I also want to mention the ancient design in this title uh I think it's the most interesting and challenging uh ancient design that I've seen right across the three uh titles okay uh so in Gloom of kilforth um the ancient design was relatively basic okay uh you know U it was the first in the series I kind of appreciate them being a bit more basic uh then I went to call of kilforth and definitely the Ancients had a lot more going on uh these ones though will really put you to the test okay okay because uh this ancient right so what you see here is this is the uh the final uh board state of my game using my uh Samurai Watcher all right uh against uh against the river of malice okay now um what some of these engins do is they really um they really don't let you sit on your laurels and they really
you really have to be efficient when you decide to face them and you have to make sure that you have some uh typically you want to have some extra a good amount of Knight cards left in the nin deck but for the river of malice for example okay so he does something interesting so you have to remove all gold tokens from the loot bag all right and uh speaking of the loot bag a little tangent here one other thing that this game does okay uh the loot bag is a lot more slim uh it it doesn't have as many loot tokens as Gloom of kilforth all right uh you know Gloom of kilforth had had a huge loot bag all right um you know tons of loot tokens so it it was very swingy now this is a bit more tame right it's a bit more tightly design the the loot tokens that are in here because it's a smaller amount okay and this is also the case for Call of kill forth all right so little comment on that I had there another thing that if if you're coming from goom of kill for the loot bag is a you know you can see the contents and understand the contents better all right because it's a smaller amount of loot tokens now back to this right so uh this guy when you set up the game you have to remove all gold tokens from the loot bag which I did right so you're not going to be able to count on gold tokens when you obtain loot from um from uh encounters uh and then the interesting
thing that this guy does right is that um among other effects right but um when a battle round starts each Hero has to discard one Loot and any hero who can't is eliminated from the game okay so uh this guy uh before I faced him I had to make sure I was uh stacked with six uh F fully stacked with six loot tokens uh those three loot tokens you see there were the ones that were used throughout the fight I ended up defeating him within three rounds or right so it went well this was my one definitive Victory uh in my four games that I played all right I had plenty of cards left in the night deck and I even had three remaining loot cards or loot tokens okay so I defeated him pretty def you know it was a pretty definite Victory all right um uh so yeah that's one of them let me show you a couple more ancients all right because they really do have interesting effects here so another one that I faced I ended up um losing okay actually no I think I won against her all right but this is a sign of um sorrow and uh you'll notice that I have you'll notice that uh I have the um Spicer card uh the signs uh in the in you know that I implemented in the Dark Shadows that I implemented but uh this one has a card design that's a bit much I don't think I don't even know
if I can show that on screen so this is the the one that comes in the box but there is an alternate art version that's spicier for this card okay for sign of sorrow but um uh now sign of Sorrow when a battle round ends uh you um uh the sign of Sorrow relocates to another location and uh she's pretty tricky because um that means that uh that means that uh you know remember that when an ancient is in a location if you move to a location right uh you still have to draw an encounter deck so that sets you back all right so you have to make sure that you have contingencies for that okay uh you know the the the sign of Sorrow is going to make you move around the map and potentially make you draw more encounter cards and you can't really assault the ancient until you clear uh any encounter cards in their location okay so uh she's pretty tricky if I remember correctly I did um beat her uh but uh yeah uh so uh very interesting design there's also another one here uh render of Flesh I did not go up against um I'll tell you who I went up against in because you know I played four games right you would think that I did one against each of the four in the box but I have the um news expansion so I actually instead of him I went against one of the engines from the new TS
expansion I'll tell you in a second but uh for Bishop of Pride which is the other one that I actually lost against Bishop of Pride so when a battle round starts you have to draw on discarding Knight card that is pretty brutal all right so if uh you know if you don't roll well during combat and you know luckily he has the least he has the lowest um Health U out of all the Ancients right but you know every battle round you have to discard a knight card so that's pretty brutal you have to make sure you have a nice stack of Knight cards before you face this guy okay I did end up losing against him uh so very very interesting very brutal ancient designs now with the dark tales expansion you get uh even more all right uh so uh what you what you do with this is uh so you get new ancient cards and you basically just use the same plot cards with the existing ancients right so you get a new uh Mountain uh Centric ancient and you know for every other location type there's a new ancient all right uh I went against the Dragon King okay and uh I um I played a let me show you some of the uh class cards because they are pretty cool here uh uh sorry race and class cards so um against the Dragon King I used a wear tiger okay uh pretty cool um
pretty cool stuff uh so you have saraf Spirit Walker word tiger F the some of the new TS expansion stuff is thrown in there well all of it really uh so you do keep that in mind okay but you get some really cool classes like bbor uh and we tiger so uh this we Tiger game that I played against the uh King Dragon King uh I think it's the worst game like RNG wise that I've played uh across all three titles um everything so many things went wrong in that game my dice rolles were awful uh I was even then I was just like one round away from killing the dragon when I faced it but uh I died and at some point to game so that sent me back and also there were multiple instances of me rolling me rolling like nine combat dies and only Landing one hit and then the enemy would roll like five dies and land three hits like that happened a lot and I'm not saying that that happens all the time it does happen every now and then but it happened an abnormal amount of time during that game so my RNG was awful that game um but anyway so still fun all right um so so that's how this this game does things differently uh there's also it introduces a couple other things right so those are the the difficulty aspect now there's a couple new mechanics as well all right uh so uh there's location abilities all right
which uh we not really other than the uh other than the uh locations that have direct uh that are linked so that you can move there's a for gloom of kilforth there's a pair of locations that are linked together right uh you can move across the map to each other okay uh that is also the case here but uh there's now uh location abilities that you have to pay close attention to okay uh so uh there's uh locations where when you uh when you enter that location you gain an action point for example and then there's certain locations where if you um if you enter them um you lose an action point okay or uh also the way that uh when they're flipped to Gloom side some locations uh you know it used to be across the board minus one Health Point on all locations coming from Gloom of kill Force but now it's distributed a bit differently there's this one location where you actually gain three points when it falls to Gloom you gain three Health but you have to draw a KN card all right so there's a drawback to that um there's locations where you actually don't lose any life so it'll just have a hyphen so you don't lose or gain any there's locations where it's minus one minus two so the distribution of um life loss or gain when a location is flipped to Gloom is different it's not as static as just
minus one across the board like it was in um uh in uh glue okay um now uh so that that's uh that's one thing you have to pay a bit more attention than usual because when you enter a location you have to you know you have to think a bit better of because you might enter a location and you didn't realize that you had to lose an action appoint when you enter that location so you have to pay a bit extra close attention uh for that okay um uh so yeah so that's another new thing there's also uh interludes Saga interludes okay so uh so uh this is basically like a almost like a finale right so um instead of just Gathering keywords for this part of your Saga you just uh have to go to this location and then uh do tests repeatedly until you you uh reach that amount and then you have you still pay your five gold uh you still do require one keyword okay uh but it's like a it's like a almost like a finale right um so it's just another interesting way of instead of gathering the standard three keywords you get the interlude okay uh so yet another thing that this game does differently so uh I don't believe oh I almost forgot the faction aspect okay another thing that this game does differently uh this is also uh everything the last three the
last few things I mentioned the location uh the location abilities um the interludes and this which is factions okay uh so this is also present in Call of kilforth so uh there's two factions doomguard and Rosen Knights that is assigned to you randomly at the beginning of the game okay and certain Knight cards will have positive or negative effects depending on which faction you have and at certain points when certain KN cards are flipped face up you're going to have the chance to change factions if you want okay but it's it's still pretty random but if you if you learn after enough place if you learn the Knight deck you're going to have a bit of a better idea of when to switch factions for maximum effect okay another interesting thing that uh this game includes is uh this which I have not tried because the the game is brutal enough as it is but um you know there's this city location that you can replace it's called cohort of the Dead um so you might not perform you know instead of the instead of the standard safe uh you know city right you use this uh Heroes may not perform Market actions here and heroes begin the game with one less maximum HP so that is brutal okay that's Ultra Dante uh Must Die mode all right um so I have not felt the need to
pull this out because it's already tough enough as it is um but um I've still had great fun and I'm really happy I have the the full Trilogy now uh I've really come to the more that I play this the more that I appreciate it and uh one of the main reasons uh there there's two main reasons one uh it allows you and I think I emphasized this uh in my last one of my two videos videos previously okay uh on the series I love that you can play with one character a lot of these uh RPG style games they demand that you play with multiple characters and some of them uh the the upkeep aspect uh and the information overload aspect uh it it varies between titles okay some of like uh too many bones for example I do not mind controlling multiple characters right but that's not the case with other RPG titles for this one it works perfectly fine with just one character it doesn't feel compromised in any way this is the case for all kill forth games so that's one thing that really makes me appreciate it the other thing that I really appreciate is um the the the fact that it's card driven it's it's completely card driven and I just love card driven games and that's just a bias I'm just biased like that uh you know these types of games can work fine with boards and other ele and other components but I just love the fact that this is card driven um just adore that um I still think um so you know commenting on my only negative
really with the the the you know the title these titles in general I still think that the rules are such a pain to learn um you know and even then um uh this is like my 20th game in you know the the last with this game this was I would say this is my 20th game across all titles in total uh you know there's still things that I learn uh and there's still weird interactions that I find that I have to go on Board Game Geek and look and sometimes it can be a bit tough to to find the answer just because you know I'm trying to find an uh rules question based on a certain keyword but then uh you know then it gets modeled with other search results so it can be tough to find the answer to certain rules interactions okay uh so this system is just a bit of of a pain to learn but once you do it's just wonderful um and I've made uh I've made a cheat sheet for it okay I think I'll try to publish it later I need to clean it up a bit hopefully it'll learn it'll help other people learn the game a bit better I need to clean it up a bit but um as I mentioned in a previous video on how I learn complex board games like this uh there's a chit chit that I make for games of this type and I've made one that I think is pretty great uh that has those key things that can easily be forgotten uh that uh you know and this is across all three titles after playing all three titles I've come up with this couple Page Long chit shet
uh that I'm hoping to publish and eventually when I do I'll leave a link okay um uh but uh after all that experience I feel pretty comfortable with the system uh but yeah there's the occasional interaction where I odd interaction that I might need to look up but it's still great once you overcome it that really is my uh one complaint and and sometimes s the lack of clarity is still there with certain effects I did bring this up with call of kilforth uh so for example uh there will be some effects that will tell you um yeah for here so it tells you at the first stranger from the ples deck to any adjacent location right so uh as I interpret that as you know reveal cards from the top of the planes deck until you find a stranger and put it in an adjacent location then Shuffle the ples deck that is that's a you know I think that would have been a lot clearer but that that's a lot more words I get it but not everybody has played magic not everybody plays board games so that many board games so I just wish that the the card effects were have been more clearly written right because I'm pretty sure that's what the designer meant but uh that's a bit of a theme across all three titles some card effects are written in a way that are a bit unclear okay um but again uh minor complaints just love this series uh there's a chance that this this um this series of games might make it to my top 20 next year I'll say it's
pretty tough it's pretty competitive it already was uh between my top 20 and top 30 all right it was on my honorable mentions um when I made my top 20 video last year but the more I'm playing this the more I'm appreciating it okay and um and uh last uh thing I cannot uh emphasize enough how much I uh I can't see myself playing without these playmats okay this character playmat uh I got it originally with my Gloom of kill for secondhand purchase and so uh was the case for that uh World M I think I don't I don't typically buy playmats for board games but this is just one it's to me it's essential the the grid really helps keep everything neat and aligned and uh the character W also so does the same it helps you um it helps you remember the you know the limit of loot cards and assets keeps you know your your character dashboard is just absolutely uh this is just uh crucial to me all right um if you do end up uh liking these titles I strongly advise you get a hold of at the very least the world uh playmat all right uh from what I understand these are not available anymore it it looks like they were Kickstarter exclusives but that is a shame because to me this is a must right when when playing these titles but but that is uh Shadows of kill forth and the series in general folks like I said I
highly recommend it just be prepared to uh have a bit of a painful learning curve with the system to get a grip of the system but uh just a super fun uh you know card driven adventuring RPGs all right and uh with that I want to thank you so much for watching if you have any comments questions feedback go ahead and put them in the comment section if you enjoyed this content make sure to like And subscribe and I'll see you in the next
one