Castle Panic Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
hello welcome back to the ball games 4k youtube channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews play throughs unboxings which i really like to talk a lot of bollocks that table saw gaming in gym and in this video we're going to be talking about a our defence game we're gonna be talking a about castle panic and in this game you will be attempting to defend your castle from a horde of vicious monsters by playing cards that will allow you to win the game so in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules we'll be telling you what we do like what we don't like then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not castle panic is still worth playing 10 years after it was first released so remember if you're new here then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below and we will see you after this board games 4k so castle panic how to play this game so castle panic is a tower defense game for one two six players you're gonna put the ball down in the center of the table and you're gonna set up the tower standees in the castle area and then you're gonna surround the tower standees with wall standees each player is going to get a certain amount of cards based on the player counts if you're playing with three players you're going to get five
cards each and you're going to set aside one troll two orcs and three goblins put the rest of the tiles back in a bag and you'll randomly place the remaining tiles that you got in front here in one of each of these six sectors on the game board so this game is divided into a number of phases the first thing that you're going to do on your turns you're going to draw up to a full hand of five cards right so after you draw to a full hand then you will have the option of discarding one card from your hand and then drawing a card blind from the drawer deck so in the third phase you will be able to trade cards with your fellow players you'll be able to discuss what strategy you want to employ whether or not you want to trade out some night cards and that sort of thing so you'll be able to have a period of discussion on how best to formulate your strategy in dealing with the horde of nasty bastards so next thing you're going to be able to do is going to be out of play cards from your hand you'll notice on a board that's divided into three different colors you've got blue you've got green and you've got red you'll also see that these sectors are again divided into rings that conform to what is on the card you'll have a ring with the swordsman you have a ring with a knight and you'll have a ring with an arch and you also got the forest ring which is where monsters will appear so some of the cards that you might be able to play you might be able to play a green archer this hits one monster in the green archer ring you might be able to pair up a brick card with a more card which will allow you to repair one of the walls you might be able to play the tar card in which case you'll take the tar token and you'll place it on a monster and that monster will not move this turn there's also
hero cards that count as a sort of a wild card so they can be archers knights or swordsmen and there's various special cards like the scavenge card which allows you to search the draw deck for any card of your choice and place it back into your hand or there's the missing card which means that you just don't draw any monsters that turn so once you're done playing cards then it's time to move the monsters and all monsters on the ball will move one space forward towards the castle any monsters that are actually in the castle space will move clockwise and destroy any structures that are in their way and then you'll draw two monsters from the drawer bag or from the cup you get a little draw bag with the wizards tower expansion right so it's not just goblins orcs and trolls or in the bag you've got some special monsters you might draw the goblin king which says you've got a roll to die and place the goblin king in the forest of that sector and then draw and resolve three more monster tokens you might end up drawing the troll mage and you'll roll the die and place a trial major in the forest and then all monsters on the board including the troll mage move one ring closer to the castle or one space clockwise if they're in the castle ring you might get a token that means you gotta draw three extra monsters or four extra monsters you might get a play card which means that all players must discard that category of car so you keep doing this you'll keep following through these phases until either all of the tower standees have been destroyed in which case you'll lose a game or you've burnt through all the tokens in the bag in which case all the players will win the game of castle panic so what do we like about castle panic
so the first thing that we really like about this game is that it is a really excellent primer for more complex games like maybe carnival zombie or dawn of the zeds i know dawn of the said it's got its own step-by-step system but essentially what i'm trying to say is it's a bloody good gateway game for more complex tower defense games right so the second thing that we really like about castle panic is that the trading cards element even though it's understated or classed as optional in the rulebook it's pretty much essential in being able to defeat this game because if you weren't allowed to trade cards you'd just be drawing cards into your hand and then you'd be stuck with what you got so it does allow you a period of reflection and it really does bring to life the cooperative nature of this game love it so the final thing that we really like about castle panic is that there is a really good variety of not only cards that you can draw but also tiles in the bag obviously the cards are going to help you the tiles are going to hurt you but there's always a chance you're going to draw maybe like the barbarian that's going to be able to destroy a lot of monsters in one go you might even have the boulder you're going to draw out a tile bag which is going to sort of help you and hurt you at the same time so there's always the chance of being surprised when you're playing this game so what don't we like about castle panic so the first thing that we don't like about castle panic is the two denature of the monster tiles stands in direct contrast to the 3d nature of the castle standees well it would have
been a nice little touch if they'd added a few more standees so that you could maybe stick the monster tiles and make them a little bit more 3d because it just seems a little bit flat the monsters where they're laying down they don't seem to be particularly menacing and it just detracts from the overall aesthetic of this game so the second thing that we don't like about castle panic is the tile draw can be frustrating and devastating if you get a really bad draw i mean we've played this more times than i've had dinners and there have been games where you are drawing the draw three monster tiles and then you're going to draw draw the full monster tiles when you've drawn one of the three monster tiles right so the fact that there's no real way to sort of manipulate what comes out of the bag means that some of these games you're just gonna feel like you're banging your head against a brick wall so the final thing that we don't like about castle panic is when this game goes wrong it goes wrong really quickly you're going to have gains in this where you're going to be thinking we've got a real chance here we're coasting along we're doing really well the bags off empty and then bang you draw three troll tiles and then you draw something that means all monsters move forward and you get swamped really really quickly feels like you're drowning in a bath of baked beans if you add to this the fact that the order of the cards has a massive direct influence on the outcome of the game it could mean that even without firing a shot you might have lost this game already because there's not really any way to influence the order that the cards come out into your end right
so to summarise is castle panic worth your time at bother today and in the future so we are going to say yes this is a very very solid gateway game that i sort of tend to play mostly with my kids these days it does suffer from just that little bit too much randomness with the chaos of the tile draw and also the predetermined nature of the card draw having said that castle panic is the perfect introduction to more complex games like carnival zombie and dawn of the zeds and cooperative games in general so there you go that's castle panic remember if you knew it and please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below and we'll see you next tuesday you