Moon Review - Pick and Pass Perfection!
Transcript
hello and welcome to board stupid my name's Wayne and I'm Matt and this is our review of Moon by Sinister Fish Games moon will play one to five players in 45 to 90 minutes and you can pick this up if you're lucky as a late Pledge on the recent reprinted Kickstarter that they've launched or through their official website and you can find a link to their official website down in the description of this video and uh just to be clear this is a sponsored video um we um got uh we were very likely to get um a copy a review copy from the guy Sina fish to review the game uh they didn't ask us to make it it look good uh so this is our honest and uh true review of of the game it's pretty good anyway but yes um you can you can buy the game straight down from the Le Link in description and um yeah let us know what what you think about it and if you already got it uh otherwise stick around cuz we're going to talk about this uh little gem absolutely let's go see how this game plays Matt tell us about Moon um so moon is um sci-fi uh Twist on the uh pick and pass card drafting game um something uh similar to Seven Wonders sush girl but in this one you are on the moon on the moon creating moon bases and
it's like those games but cranked up to 10 basically yeah yeah yeah it's it's more um it's more complex the mechanics are are more uh interesting that more mechanics than just like the simple one in sushigo for example um and um yeah uh all the art and and everything is absolutely fantastic so um yeah I I really like this game I know that you love this game absolutely love this game are you kidding me yeah so I played this for the first time at UK G this year back in the before times of June or June or July June it was I think which feels like a million years ago at this point we're nearly at Christmas oh my God so yeah played that for the first time then and I absolutely loved it I love card drafting anyway you do you do the the idea of okay I have a hand of cards I pick one of them and then I never get to see these again right they're going to go around or maybe yeah like like I got give my opponent all of this amazing stuff in my hands that's like really stressful and tense in a really good way uh and there are tons of great cards in this game that give you great combos right I think that's quite interesting I just hate giving them up so um uh at the start of the of your of the game of the era you're playing you're playing in three different eras you're going to receive um um a bunch of seven seven cards in your hand again as way was say you pick one you pass the rest and you got another play is going to pass their ones um this makes this game um uh very
tactical uh so the the good things as in every like um drafting games you're trying to build Combos and stuff to get more resources or more points um but again you don't know what the next set of cards going to give you so you need to be very smart and U being flexible enough to create this or that combo you can't get fix on just like oh I'm going to win doing this things so could be that those cars never go back to you um yeah it makes it very tense around the table when uh when you really want a car then you like oh but I really want this one please come back it never comes back it never comes back uh but yeah like you said plays over three eras and the eras get ever more intense because the combos go up in you know power essentially so era one you got some basic you uh abilities but the time you get to ER three you're doing crazy stuff tapping things and comboing stuff and doing other people stuff that they've got there which is really really nice and so the first part of your turn is relatively straightforward right you you take a card from the card that you picked and you're going to play it right you'll have to pay for it via the various resources that you're going to gather uh during the game and one of the things I really really love about this game is if you don't have a specific resource you can send one of your little lunar Rovers off this little sort of moon rover to someone else's card and that will get you that resource that yeah this is very uh what I find it absolutely great in terms of like theme
like having the the moon roll just like it just like make it roaming around um and the other things yeah is about you building your base but you need to think about as well that that your the other players could use the resources that you're actually creating on your own base and that could be a good thing or could be a bad thing so it could be that you're helping them but Som sometimes you want to help them because you got probably some secret plan that you wanted to unveil at a later stage and if you've got like a really attractive moon base with loads of resources and people are sending you loads of Rovers to use them you get to keep those Rovers yes to use it for the for the next era which is amazing yeah so the idea will be I build a big base where I get all the other players that want to come and pick up my stuff good come come come and the next turn I'm going to be the one with all the Rovers so in the next era I'm going to be the one that goes and picks the what um resourcer I need um again it's is a mechanic that is very thematic it's um is a really good and it's really like interactive what what these games has um that is quite different from yeah from a sushi go or 71 H is the fact that you constantly playing with the other players you will have some special cards that let you use um a power that is on a card on on on your um on another player's board so you constantly need to keep looking what what's going on on the
board or who got this or that resource and um of course you want to try to a certain point not only playing about your B about your board but you want to stop maybe Wayne's new combo that you just creating and you see that's happening so I'm definitely not going to give the card for him to finish that combo I'm going to keep it for myself and maybe just trash it just I don't want to so that is um uh the interactivity in this kind of game um a is to me is very important cuz otherwise is U you're playing and building your your de your your engine build on your by yeah I don't those are not my type of um games I know you love them but uh but yeah this one I found that is the perfect like Middle Ground still having a lot of like very interesting Combos and mechanics that each single card will bring to the table yeah absolutely this is definitely not multiplayer soliter it keeps you constantly engaged during every player's turn because like you say there might be something that is interesting to you either for you to send your over to or to maybe activate via one of the various abilities that you'll have in your moon base or on these Expedition cards which will stay for the whole round and these are a bunch of different abilities which are great also on your turn you can actually claim one of these um reputation cards which are amazing and these are kind of like achievements in the game right where like if you fulfill a certain requirement you get to claim one of
these and these are both points at the end of the game and they're an ability yeah exactly so it will give you a bonus while you're playing so you want to try to achieve one of the of of the six cards as soon as possible so you can have ongoing effects but the same time at the end of the game it's going to give you points and uh again the the good things on of these games as well that all these Achi achievement cards and everything you got a acquire a number of cards that every time you're going to shuffle so every game is going to be different um if you see at the at the number of cards that you got for each era uh it could be like if you're playing two players it could be like a lot of this you're not see them for a while yeah um so yeah it's um replayability is really really high it is super high yeah just because the the nature of how you Shuffle the cars together of course it's going to be very different each time and as you say there's loads of these reputation cars to make that very different too you've also got a whole feature here about trying to collect the most flags so you're trying to maybe look at building buildings which will give you more Flags because the most flags of certain types that in the beach era will give you more points so you're also looking around the table being oh Matt's got he's got three sort of home home Flags but I've only got two if I get an extra one I'll get those points from him and he won't get those points there lots of little you interesting decision spaces which very much like no again it's um it's an interactive pick and pass Pi um
something like and I really love like creating the combos with this with this card it reminds me some of the um of the combo mechanics that you're going to build um very much like I don't know wingspan or something like that where where you start having four or five cards in a row that they going to interact with each other cuz this going to do this then let me do this then add me this and get me a point here and a point there and three and you keep building those kind of combos so that's when it remind me of something like um something like w you can build a little engine a little bit going on as well which is fantastic but yeah it's um it's a very good game is uh I would say it's not super straightforward to pick up but at the same times it's not that complicated you can you can literally like read the rules and after 10 minutes start playing and then discover like more more things the the the the thing is like each car will have a different power so you can't really learn every single one but yeah um it's it's it's really interesting really interesting uh what do you think about player count M because we've played this at three and four yes and I've not played it at five but I don't think I'd want to no I would say that uh three is the right spot it feels like The Sweet Spot um at four um I felt it going a little bit too slow for me yeah uh that we we literally like um take the time on like it it gets
quite like um uh you got like 10 11 minutes without really doing much with a Fourplay count while with a three playay count it's much more like Bank on every yeah you you do a lot of things the the counterpart is with the four play accounts you see more cards and you make more crazy combos true so it's more rewarding at the end you're like oh my god look what I build um while the three player is I think is um less cards more F so less the comos that you're going to build a less spectacular but still keeps the game mechanics and all the things that that we like about this game is really relevant at at three play yeah yeah absolutely and I think that long stretch that you talked about there that sort of 10 minutes is there's this weird part of the game where if you're the first player uh I think it it takes you twice as long before it comes back around to you cuz this moves around first player changes so when you're first you then become last and it takes a little while for you to you know get a turn um but and then also that's compounded by the fact that you've got a bunch of cards when you got that first round you're reading the cards you need to read all the cards because you need to understand again I um I very much imagine that play more and more and more you will know exactly what what cards you get in your hands but for the first few games especially if you got four people on the table each one of them needs to read every single card at the start then I
passing those cards and I need to read all of them cuz otherwise you don't want yeah you want to understand what you want to think what you can do what you're going to do um that that is the only things that I found a little bit a little bit sticky yeah a little bit slow for me in the in the things but in terms of mechanics uh there are other bits that we're going to speak about later um they're all the things that I found um a little bit could have been done better however the guys actually did it better but we'll talk about we'll talk about that we'll probably talk about that now yeah let's let's move into the production of moon so moon is actually really well produced and this is the retail copy that we've got here so all of the cards have this lovely sort of linen finish so they're all all like nice quality cards satisfying to play satisfying to play with um wonderful artwork the sort of poppy not very serious tongue and cheek style you know SciFi art I really like it it's a silly sci-fi it's kind of like you can build um a country club and to play golf on the moon or you can build a a a pub on the moon um and each card is very thematic to what they they do what power they have absolutely yeah cifi we should call it syi Moon based building so there was that which is great it has this wonderful form factor I mean you can see the box is Tiny yeah so um which I also really like as well everything
fits in here it has dividers so it's you structured well which is really good as well um it's mostly just cards so there not huge amount you know to really go wrong with that uh the resources are fine the little um moon rers are excellent these little wooden Moon mles Moon Rover mles but the only thing I think you had a a little bit of a problem with is these like part counters Point counters my my only thing was like about the um yeah the point counter you see those um those hard shaped cardboards um each one will have two numbers will have 150 on the other side of the one and the three on the other side or 10 or 20 yeah at the start of the game is fine when you start collecting a lot of these hearts on your on your board it's very easy that to accidentally flip them and so one points can become three or three points can become one and then it's kind of like oh was I on 17 points or or 15 points go I can't remember now um uh yeah that that is the only things that I found a little bit and then in particular you playing with a lot of this and uh every time even having a nice surface and Ice it's still like it's a bitti yes um however however uh the the the deluxe edition of the game uh that we don't have here we just have the the the retail ones the
deluxe edition that you can find the link downstairs in the description um will have actual like ch chips for um for for the yeah for all the resources for the uh for the scoring points and you got an upgraded version of the of of the moon rover screen printed moon rover um they they they're really nice um and Frank is nice as well Frank is nice so yeah I think with the if if you want to get the game I will say 100% get the deluxe edition cuz that is um it's just like quality of life for not much difference in the between the the the two copies like um price pricewise uh it just like much better quality of life um I think that everything should still fit in here it does yeah um so again you put everything in the in the same box it also comes with like little component trays as well which is even better so 100% um if if I was going to buy a copy of it I would not even hesitate if you can get the deluxe one get that one if that's still available in the affiliate link uh then that's one we'd recommend so Matt who do you think that moon is for um I will say if you again if you love sushi girl if you look love seven wonders if you love wingspan if you love having cards and drafting your um um your your boards and and creating Combos and all that stuff this is
definitely the game for you um I would say is more complexity one is higher than a sushi go or or a seven wers definitely defitely um it takes a little bit longer to um to explain and to play suo You'll Play wait 15 minutes really yeah yeah and and you'll play with a with a 10 years old kid or my mom uh don't play with my mom um but uh this one is a little bit more more complicated uh but again it's it's not oh my God it takes ages to learn the rules you kind of like start 10 minutes after reading the rules and then learning what what you're doing it's a little bit a slow process but you get there and uh and it's really really um uh rewarding once he start actually getting into the into the mindset of the game and um achieving those like big Combos and or or simply look at your or your base and and be like oh there's a just great absolutely this is really awesome okay so Matt give us your conclusion and your final rating for Moon Sinister fish I think moon is an absolute uh great game um uh you I would like to play the game I like I would like to play the game more um and uh to me is a 4.5 out of five um this is just because
the for this version of the game maybe the deluxe version will have a five out of five but uh for the retail one uh this component issues um and U and the timing things in in the game plan that it what knocks down that that 0.5 for for a full cour but yeah absolutely I I loveed it and yeah we played a lot and we I'm sure we'll play even more absolutely moon is one of my favorite games of the year so this is a five out of five for me I think this is an absolutely exemplary card drafting game uh I love all of the different cards and all of the different combinations you can make with them it's really it gives it such great replayability um and there's something about how it plays and the artwork that really just speaks to me and there's some really smart stuff that it does that I haven't really seen anywhere else I love the way that the rovers are used sending them out I think that's really unique to the game and then you're actually just giving them away to someone else and something we didn't even mention the more Rovers you have that's that's a tiebreaker yes so which actually is really important when it comes to things like these flags and you're looking for majorities of things and so that's a really interesting consideration as well I think you're probably right the um in terms of the production wise small finicity little issues but picity little issues uh but probably fixed uh if you've got the better version of the game um but I certainly have nothing really bad to say about it I absolutely love it one of my favorite games ukge and certainly one of
my favorite games games of the year five out of five for me so that was our review of Moon by Sinister fish games but what do you think have you managed to pick up a copy of this game and if you haven't remember description below click the link buy yourself one and let us know how you feel about the game do you agree with us or do you think uh you've got a better pick and pass game that you think does it better than Moon definitely let us know let's see let's talk about it let talk about and um yeah if you like what we're doing hit the Subscribe button whatever it is and um yeah to to hear more more from us yeah check out the rest of our videos thanks for watching we'll catch you again real soon
ciao