Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 28:56

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free audiobook with a 30-day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audible.com for word /bg unlock the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video everyone welcome to the discussion for tapestry which this is the new discussion based off of no more hype around this game there's no more no more outside influence so there's no expectations and one quick Arava is in the last discussion that i said i said that people got paid to do their reviews a guy who works at still meyer did comment and say we don't do that so I'm here to apologize for stating that I was incorrect so just re recorrect anon on that um so what'd you guys think of tapestry it was not too bad it's okay it's okay I mean I don't have flicks it games to really mm-hmm reference I think he did seven that's kind of a sieve game more or less I mean to get replaced admirers of a civilization on PC way back okay okay it was like the xbox version god yes whatever yeah sid meier's civilization so okay but but yeah so the games what do you think yeah

I'm definitely just gonna say it's alright it's this game is long it says 90 to 120 minutes we probably did that 120 it's like yeah it's it's about two hours um which I guess for a sieve game is not portable so here's the thing I will say if you've watched my previous discussion for this ahh my feelings towards it are better than what it was last time but here's the thing this game is I'm it's completely overrated everyone who is like raving about this this is a at best ok game it has decent mechanics for a sieve game it's very simple but you kind of do a whole lot of nothing to get like for 2 hours like in a civilization game what you want at least what I want is I want to see my progression I want to see my civilization grow and I'm gonna say this right up front the fact that they put this little blurb here ass it hurts this game the fact that if this wasn't here no one would have any civilization expectations you wouldn't be comparing it to through the ages you and be comparing it to seven wonders you wouldn't be even comparing it to sid meier's civilization because you wouldn't have that already going in so they should have just named it tapestry and it could have been whatever people would daemon is our name it and literally whatever else because you see

no progression there is no thematic ties to this the fact that you went from maker of fire to theocracy to capitalism

I mean yours kind of makes sense you just structured like different types of government in in yours but me to go from maker fire to broker of peace okay to espionage - then the Dark Ages there's no theme I mean it was kind of fun me the matically saying what I did to do that but I had to have to aggressively throw that on the game normally in a civilization game like there or era cards yeah yeah yeah that's actually a good point there are a this is era one so no you're not gonna be getting computers in era one by era three then then you do so Devon I mean what are your thoughts whether you like witty let's start with dislikes what do you not like about the game well I mean I have difficulties with this do with the dislikes I mean because I'm kind of limited um I suppose didn't think it likes a little wow factor okay I mean the materials are nice yeah mm-hmm but I don't know I'm just kind of out of me yeah I kind of had a great taste I mean I wouldn't really come back to it I'm like I think that like just isn't disliked but I could be taste where ain't it sure mean and yeah and I'd like civilization games I like having that feel of like progression and like thematically being like oh this is what I'm gonna do because you can also play like for example through the ages and never change your government you can

never go into military and literally have guys with night with bows and arrows but you're really advanced in computers and things like that so that's the kind of fun part about civilization and you don't really get that here like this entire game revolves around you gain some resources and then you go up on four tracks that's it like and they all kind of do something different yeah like but they're all still relatively you know you're gonna be placing explorations so that's gonna get you some points military you're gonna be conquering I do like the fact that in a sieve game like you conquering me doesn't it doesn't hurt me in any way yeah that is nice cuz there's nothing worse than like yeah I'm gonna build all this up and then you're like oh okay I'm gonna demolish everything we've just spent two hours [ __ ] doing so there's none of that that is nice and you get a bunch of points for conquering for resources which get you you know a further up on certain tracks science is really nice revolves around getting some tapestry cards furthering up your advancement on other tracks but also gaining some benefits and then technology you gain that [ __ ] 10 points you getting the technology cards which I only I specifically went for the ones that gave me points mmm and then I literally went for market so there is a theme and what we've kind of found out was final score wasn't one 198 to 185 to 113 I I went why cuz I went and all in on really food like the farms and the market mm-hmm and that seemed to kind of

work but I don't know I wouldn't sit I wouldn't sit here for another two hours to play this and like I said I I enjoyed this run-through better than the first time so that is a positive to the game a negative to the gaming industry that hype can actually influence up mindset when they're playing in because the expectation is so high right that you come in expecting this glorious [ __ ] revolutionary sieve game and you're like wait we we spend the resource and go up on a track and that's it yeah yeah I mean yeah turn quality I mean it was kind of neat getting you know later in it's like Hawaii all this this is giving me points that give me points that's pretty cool but yeah I mean tearing conversation is incredibly simple it's like okay what track do I want to go up on pretty yeah do I have the resources yes I mean there's a few combo turns where it's like oh I'm gonna be getting a house which also gets it just give me the extra resource lets me do another track or you know hey I concur hey I'll take the resource yeah and and then just keep going like that I mean I there's a positive of the game I do like games where the players kind of dictate the speed so if you wanted to like really you get a really good tapestry card that the one you currently have kind of sucks you've been instantly income and be like okay boom I'm gonna already be here and then I'm gonna be able to like if I if I had gotten the industrialism card like early on then I would have been like oh I'm gonna get that and then benefit from the fact of constantly because they're not what if constant been getting these circle points as I also get them again when I

advance so you get some neat combos but really it's luck of the draw mmm how your strategy's gonna go I don't like that like cat got capitalism and I'm like that's perfect for me right if eclis for me I will never get to try that I wouldn't like if my strategy is markets I will never get to use capitalism mmm we're in other Civ type games you get to oh wait you went you went that right I can also go that route if I want to we're not limited based off just luck of the draw so I don't like that um I really don't like this part at all in the capital city yeah I mean because you get sucked you get [ __ ] you really get [ __ ] for a you okayed placing all these just to get one resource or hey I get an extra point grant it if I got in five I might have been trying to go for these because then it'd be fine I would have gotten 15 points for that but it's just this is just this is just annoying it's it's not even really fiddly as he's kinda like it's it's a puzzle yeah like if you like to kind of like click it like at one point I got one I think row and I was like I know I'm just gonna I'm not you know I'm not gonna put too much right my [ __ ] not in factory barn yeah yeah I mean like you said components are great like the fact I mean this game I should say this game is $100 hmm mainly because of these the fact that these are pre painted and I mean they're not cheap which is good cards are really nice love it

but at the end of the day this is just kind of I don't really care for this at all like I would have enjoyed more but place them on the tile and you okay I'm a place a farm there and so every income phase I get I can you know whatever that farm is on or something like that there'd be a reason to kind of do the board a little bit more all in all there's really no reason to kind of do that the exploration is kind of fiddly where you're like wait so is is this so is this is this like do I get do I get a water point for that too because there's it's just and the fact that they went at cheap not a cheap a a small rule book there's no clarification whenever you're coming in here and being like oh man so like whenever you mention landmarks and I like looking at it I said landmarks and it was like landmark miniatures I'm like oh yeah these okay yeah so you're getting a [ __ ] to the points and then you add I'm glad you double-checked you're like are these landmarks and I'm like because it felt broken as hell I'm like oh no they are not so and I thought so too um okay I mean what are you what are your thoughts what do you said it was okay yeah I'm just generally not like super impressed with it it's not you know crazy this game I've ever played something more game I've ever played it's a little long for my taste just for what it is I never felt like I was actually playing like a civilization game I just felt like I was just allocating my resources like a source placement game yeah and then like with you know some civilization flair to it like I was explaining to catch she's

like so is tap tap here's a sieve game I'm like it's the Lacroix of of civilization games you kind of give a little taste it smells like a sieve game like the orange one smells like an orange it tastes like ass so here's their like there's a good meme for this which is where it's Chris from Family Guy yelling at his family and he's like you know it's Meg its Meg yeah you guys think you're so much better than me this is tapestry yelling it like three days yeah when they're all pompous yeah I'm gonna make that maybe that mean yeah it's funny I'll kind of leave it at that but yeah sure um so I mean really a couple a couple quick questions I do you think that they're the four I'm because really exploration and and military go together like you get you gain points for each place you conquer over there you gain points how high you oh yeah I mean I just felt an actual to me that's why I went that route right and then you have science and technology going together and so that I mean sure I mean that makes sense but do you guys feel like there's one Avenue that's more broken than the rest yeah I'd probably agree with you there I mean you did stat quite a bit in the fact that it refreshes on like of a number of texts you have today you get a point for each thing that you go and just third three into the tree there and your mate suddenly doubling on however many texts you've collected so yes so essentially I

gained one two three four I gained 18 points yeah it's like I know early game you're you were generating quite a bit on your income phase victory point why isn't yeah and it also didn't help that I literally took these ones they I made a good point the fact that I ran away with all the ones that came out there were victory points whenever they got to the circle one or the top one that probably didn't help your that's this case is either just because you guys let me using the touch technologies your bill that's fine I mean I mean all I mine was doing okay and we were pretty close we were really cool like honestly like I was kind of doing a little tally there you know if I had done the middle before you mm-hmm granted you would have gotten the knockdown first cuz you would have gone second though I don't know if you would have I probably wouldn't have tried to use don't win of no I I didn't think about it I thought about it like halfway through just to get the extra five points and I'm surprised you didn't bulrush the tech are you there to try and get the extra five points back here yeah I thought about it but the fact that these are knocked down I'd have to go I'd have to explore or concur in and go around this way I can't say how it would have turned out but I was like oh I'd knock that down but then I may not have gotten two knockdowns on you sure oh so we actually gonna go out for cat but likely I also got I had the benefits of this one getting five points for each one I completed row it didn't even matter where I was but it was been close the fact that what you I mean you were at 185 I was at 198 so thirteen point difference it's it's still really close yeah um cat was doing really good I feel like you just based out at the latter

half of the game if you were keeping up with us for a while then you're like yeah um oh no like initially when I first played this game I thought there was a like there was an unbalance to these but I really don't think there are I think that I mean it's kind of simplistic if you're gonna go tech do your markets if you're gonna go exploration to your food they all kind of if you're gonna go there gee it's just it's just one of those things that it's very simple that it's color coded so military do your armories and you'll gain benefits cuz you're conquering so you're gonna get points each time you for all the space that you've conquered right so it I mean they go hand in hand if you're doing military and you're also doing farms well that's a little weird you're probably not gonna get as much points so um so the other thing was these you guys think these are balanced the special abilities these I should clarify have been erratic like they have come out with basically like a separate version to balance out from first edition things something to consider them balanced it were initially yes and that is true I do remember specifically reading that I kind of ignored it because I was like oh I'm never gonna play that game again but I ended up doing it so I don't know if the version I have here is has those included but but what you guys think well I'm I love this pic yeah like it based off the rules I didn't just randomizing me like

you do with what you got I wanted to these are the two I got right I mean mine essentially let me get except for that first era where you guys didn't play what I needed I mean I just was generating a 10 victory points from there on in mmm six to ten some I mean that's pretty well all mine was I get to copy some three-point ability yeah every year yeah what Jers give you mine was the I could place on here and then just bought myself up goes up once on the track and gain the benefits and gain the benefits yeah so but but she yeah so I mean and then mind was I had to complete I had to complete a track or be higher than everyone which is virtue and get a point for each opponent I which was I don't think I ever got more than two points on that because I had a card I almost was gonna do socialism which advanced or regress to match the closest opponent and I was gonna do that to catch up to one of you guys and then and then the advanced tonight but what sucked is every time it the closest one was ever this one every time like you would be here or it'd be like that so I would only catch up to that one see you guys were never on the same one for me to jump and match with you so I'm like man that's such a waste uh but that's why I fought so hard for these because I was gonna get so I don't know I I do think they're unbalanced in a way I thought like yours in particular was kind of lame like okay

cuz like where you're at on the track it might not even be good for you to do that one and it might never be good for you to do that one yours was I thought was the best one here cuz be able to coffee go pretty great um and then you almost copied the other one again before you nuked it to uh to gain almost was just unbalanced we're reading it wrong right right but still being able to copy any ones like because you copied my SP not just a copy you're trapped here than other ten so and in mind was just really [ __ ] difficult to do so I don't know I I don't really care for these there's a bunch of them in the game there's sixteen that comes straight into the end of the game you're mystics like that you would have had to there unique in there you look at that again now that I know the game right yeah so they're unique they are different they're not a type of civilization you're not like America who gets this benefit or anything you're just kind of these generic titles yeah which is interesting I guess so this game is virtually themelis you have to put in a lot to get a theme out you use that imagination which I thought was kind of fun at least for me I thought it was I mean it was it was kind of neat for me to me it's not bad for someone to like who's just like doesn't mind being creative but like to someone who's very very mechanical very logits like boom boom boom this is whether if I went broke release espionage in Dark Ages left brain left someone said you know

someone who's like incredibly left brain who enjoys strategy games who's like yeah this is gonna be a civilization right I could see someone like that having trouble right not not because they're not capable sure and I mean just to give a couple of examples Cowboys or second one with the traders yes and to be honest I didn't feel the traders that's why sure so the traders prefer to connect with other civilizations economically not militarily you start with 4 player tokens here at the beginning you may place one from here on any territory on the map matching one of these descriptions an empty territory gain one point per adjacent territory controlled by opponents and for the moment later conquers a start you may gain the benefit of any unselected conquered die as you roll it as if he rolled it or a territory with exactly one opponent outpost gain the benefit of the territory hmm remember the territories with two tokens cannot be conquered so that would have been really good for you because he was conquering and tricked like I guess not it's a yeah well it's like you're connecting with them by placing your [ __ ] eyes I guess if mine was Alchemist the alchemists love to push their luck this is what Josh had in the hopes of accelerating advancement at the beginning you roll the science die and mark the result here with a player token so it's one kind of like yours you mark a player token if you roll in advance you've already rolled or you may then roll again or stop if you roll in advance may already rolled you bust

remove all tokens and gain resources s consolidation for your terrible luck otherwise when you stop you may advance on each of the advancement tracks you rolled each some the final result of this ability would push you off the end of the track gained five so basically you so at every income he gets it he gets the oldest die 1 2 4 so it's like okay like so I put one on the exploration okay oh that's military so he can keep going if he goes again science then he could stop and then go once up once on science military and exploration for free but if he busts so if I did it again so I bust there I would get three resources or we gain one resource as a consolidation so it so these are unique they're they're different but they're not I don't think they're not all created equal so if there's been well they're not they weren't all changed well some and then our changed to kind of be a little bit more beneficial because I remember the one I had the first time I played this game it was it was [ __ ] garbage I don't mess I mean I'm sure if I look through here I'd find it but I don't want to but there's 16 there's some really neat ones but I really don't find them like some of them are kind of neat but like oh wow I could get lucky or oh whoa I bust again okay what but you just get to copy whatever even though it's yeah it's like okay okay so oh wow that's that's heck and then Oh El techo

ki boss yeah so it's it's just I mean I remember Josh busting but then if he's going off the tracks so if he's advancing like crazy then every time he would advance when he would gain five points thank you so that he would constantly but you only get to do that so many times but yeah I mean this game is this games okay like it's simple to learn if you don't really care about any civilization progression or anything like that I guess try this out the tapestry cards even though they're random like they're they're different it's it's it's okay so um no one went no one was freaking space route oh I was trying to get there so bad I was mapping now in one these are pretty good because like whenever you get them you just you you I'll remember it's like this one right here you get a food a culture and eight points nice like this one you get a tapestry place another tapestry and gain a point for each tapestry you rose this one you get a house and get one point for each house so these ones like conquer territory gain one so space exploration is uh i mean its role of science die get six points you know things like that so they're interesting oh there's only been perfect game the tech upgrade attack get a point for each attack though it's been perfect for me but like you're only getting that you can get a max of 3 mmm three science but yeah so very themelis game not bad at three actually so that's that's a positive and and yeah I mean so relatively close what Oh what

do you think of the player elimination I guess it's not really elimination but I mean you do have to be careful but I mean like if you just if you run out like I did and you just run out it's like yeah you're just sitting there I better hope that they're efficient with their turns and that they're not just like cutting around and it's not you know forty minutes later right that that is one and then to the thing that I hate the most not so much that the player elimination is is the fact that your final score is visible so like once count was at 113 and I did one thing and she so she already knew she lost so she has no investment and the way the game ends like ever Dell for example is a game where players can end quicker than others but all points are scored at the end yeah so you don't know so that kind of leaves some excitement here it's just like up 113 okay beat it once you get to 185 and I was still going it's like you're sitting there hoping well I hope he doesn't have enough points as soon as someone passes that back and forth you're like yeah all right great yep look at that I guess I lost and I have to I guess you don't have to sit here but if you're recording you have to sit there the whole time yeah and I think that's what happened to me in the first recording is I I think I finished before once they passed me I was like I was just furious because I'm like okay that's yeah that's pretty cool I guess so and then the text really don't [ __ ] matter like the fact that it's calendar comm tower it's like none of that is

thematic in any way hmm I know I'm in the dark ages but I guess I have a comm tower right so I have a comm tower but I can't read it I have credit cards but I'm still in symbology it's funny I guess but yeah so I'm just carving into the plastic cuz I have plastic to make my credit cards and rubbers ooh so low so with that being said scale of 1 to 10 Deveney I will reign it six six slightly above average I mean I mean maybe like a bit of like a you know the taste thing also mm-hmm but then LEDs I feel like that affects them but uh it was okay it's not bad but yeah it definitely lacked any type of excitement yeah what's there ever a point that you were like that's kind of going long yes there was okay I mean yeah yeah especially at the end and it's like okay so okay uh you know I'll give it a 6 - oh that's interesting okay yeah I think it's more than average you know I had a reason for that and I completely spaced oh because it's a stone mired game and quality is key I am very impressed by these little many things and you know means a lot I will

say well well like the art is very flat on the board the mark like through the tapestry and the box are like history the box are they do like I know you really enjoy like the quality mm-hmm love like the cardstock and everything else so I do think that that matters sure Stoudemire does make beautiful games yeah I mean yes I still admire this I mean so like I gave her the for the first time I played it this on the give of the 5 like it does go up like I I wasn't fuming by the end of it I liked it definitely was a better experience but it's still a whole kind of a lot of nothing there's there's really like at now I will say I wasn't sitting there watching the clock like I have with other games but by looking at it's like that was two hours and there was a point in the in the run-through I was like I don't know how I'm so I like I could I was like I I really I'm just you're just going through the motion you know you did the math but you're like it's kind of like when you zone out on a car ride you're like I'm [ __ ] my foot is on the bun yeah how do I get home so I mean and I went in with a completely different mindset wasn't expecting a sieve game so it does go up a little bit for me but still I wouldn't come back to this one I think I think unfortunately still Meyer missed the missed the mark on on this one so it goes up a little bit but not too much average game I quality-wise you mentioned the minis and things like that they're good but they don't do anything they literally sit on

this gray yeah like there's no representation of your civilization out on how long the board they do look nice I wouldn't pay $100 for this and I didn't because this is this was actually a review copy mm-hmm so they sent it to me just like they did between two castles Mad King Ludwig I sent this one I asked him I thought I would do it again so I guess if you're at this point in the discussion take what I take what we say with the grain of salt but I'm not sitting here praising it either so okay so I did I didn't pay a hundred for it but I did pay a hundred the first time no I think it was eighty on pre-order but still like it's an expensive game for a average to our game so so that's it that's that's our thoughts on tapestry everyone let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like how much share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you hey one thank you for watching I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any to run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time what day it is for you

Progress saved