Talisman w/ all expansions Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for talisman with all the expansions except the harbinger expansion in the nutshell of what the Harbinger does he is also a character that moves about the map and there's a deck of harbinger cards which are all awful take you where though they're all awful and they suck and then there's oming cards and in all honesty we could've played with it oh man we suck the omen cards dwindle down and if if someone doesn't win by the time the omen cards go out everyone loses oh man so I heard you started laughing okay so I will actually start no you won't because this is my channel absolutely and when was the last time we played this game with Mike no how is you tired yeah we played it since then but I know what else this also holds an assaulter for me because this was actually my first board game not counting descend like don't count the same this is the board game that got me thank you that got me into this hobby and I can definitely say that this is like it started with just the main board I loved it and then it just kept building and building with more expansions there's not gonna be anything yeah there's not gonna be any more because Fantasy Flight lost the rights to it with weather games workshop's and
unless the Games Workshop decides to make expansion but even then well why would they get the rights up they weren't gonna make more well they were partnered with Games Workshop's and there no one really knows either maybe Fantasy Flight didn't want to renew it with them or game porkchops didn't want to renew it so maybe they realized how successful Fantasy Flight was and was like hey you can't profit off our stuff anymore so they said they should well that I don't know if that's the case but they just didn't renew the contract and they could but everyone hates games workshop's because fancified did fourth edition they Pro even then like everyone doesn't have anything else I wanted to do if it's exactly well they've still done more maybe not more science but they could have done more come connection yeah like I like this even though I was the only one that did it you could have connected the city to the Highlands and some but then there were the atoms of when it comes to creating something I think there comes a point where if you overdo it you're not inspired by any more room there's no point in like continuing it does a point where it's like making Assassin's Creed games right right they should have either done it taking their time and been inspired by where they should have stopped there's a point where it becomes too bogged down with all the expansions like look at how many cards we didn't go through I shuffle all these two like I intensely shuffled all of them combined all the expansions and there's some people that bother that that bothers them because let's say because you can make this very a lot more thematic you can do all of the the Blood Moon cards the werewolf cards to get that Halloween
fielders the snow ones which are the frost March so you could Windell all this down and have a more thematic sense but to me one there's so much variety 69 different characters we went through two one two four five six seven went through seven Matt Taylor today there are 61 different characters some of them are generic Luke actually was the only one who yeah who had a very from the base game yeah I'll go through a few there's a rogue a dreadknight a gypsy the necromancer a bounty hunter a sage I mean and they all have different abilities a nice of I guess think of sixty Minute Rice it's it's so amazing like oh we were bidding the fantasy dumb lately we've been playing the remastered Skyrim and I was looking through my board games and I was like I really don't have any fantasy games like I really don't have it like well yeah ignoring talisman I was like there's no like of that like fantasy fantasy like RPG like our ancient fantasy and then I was like boys I never see star because it's in this box I never see that actual outside guy and then I was like I never see talisman because it's in this box and I was like oh yeah this is the epitome of fantasy I mean and I just love it so much I like going through my character and leveling them up and a lot
of people think this game isn't thematic like this could have been about anything like this could've been sci-fi which is relic relic is the Warhammer and it's the same style but they just have so much and you can if people think it's not thematic then they're playing you're wrong in a sense because man no man yeah Matt started role-playing his character I will play my character by stealing [ __ ] if it gets too somatic then it becomes linear I feel like it could good I mean nah it's just a different type of game not all games can be heavily thematic you know a lot of people hate it because it's just like this is we never I said Arkady Quest is a Meritage to its core this this is a mere trash this and Arkham or an element or a marriage like what Samara trash this literally you have almost no choice on what happens to you like occasionally like we're going to go that's if you get the die roll yeah and if I had to uh if I had any complaints which I don't have a lot is I don't really care for the role to move that's because that's like played more like this it's monopolies all right five well I can go there or there I wish each character kinda have a base speed like okay look like a burglar is no way an agile ultimate was fine but I just don't like that you can roll as well as one like there should like you said a face well yeah I start in the to counter arguments like well you go get a
riding horse that allows you to roll two dice or even better yeah and then there is there will then there's ions and stuff that allows you to move up to your role so there's different items in here but whenever you have how many cards were there over a thousand probably that it's like tough trying to find it originally I took out talismans from this I felt like you had the more just draw like oh I got at Ellison but then I was like this game is long enough as it is to actually trying her name but then there's warlocks quest there's just so [ __ ] much and Mike I can't pinpoint a favorite expansion I guess I do have another complaint about some expansions that generally do the Harbinger is fine she made a complaint about the Dragons expansion the Harbinger really does add too much too much negativity yeah the cars they're all balanced yeah they're all bad like I'm not crazy with the dragon salon um when I played it's not wearable but it's kind of there I feel like it would be better if you were just playing this yeah it's just like oh my god okay and the Dragons and if you forget like you forgotten oh [ __ ] yeah yeah but I was actually up with it this time typically there is a board it goes on the the in light but so no one encountered this they added the Lynch it that used to be the Grim Reaper and then there's a mutant that you fight and then
you go through the valley of fire I wonder I wonder if I would like it as much without the expansions I've never played it normally with this game I just all get all together yeah but I wanted to I wanted to like throw everything on just keep the base game and just read these cards you go through those way more and it definitely shorten it down there it so there are two there I guess I do have a few complaints there nothing major the werewolf and the Reaper they're fun but with all the expansions like the werewolf London New Jack [ __ ] because of us right right so you buy even that's that's a possibility if you were just doing base game you have very limited places you can move you can more active the Reaper was a lot more active than then I thought he was going to be no one died from him I feel like even in this game it would be too much time both of them because there's just like I feel like they're almost gonna get one someone every time yeah do not burn these faces that's Church my way very funny that's true but they're not all bad like you rolled a six on the Reaper and got to choose you know something in the world does the same thing so the fact that they they're just there and you could just move them out of the way um and then what was the other the other thing Oh at the very beginning of the game you can't you have no goal at the very beginning I mean just level of its kind of your goal and well is it freedom you
do have freedom but you're also still limited freedom based on die rolls yeah i what I do like is there are revealed alternative endings some of them is like for the Thieves Guild or for the city one is you try and get as many values whoever has the most bounties or once you have a certain number of bounties you can make it to the crown of your man and you win so I feel like that gives you more of a drive yeah I like the idea that you you know what you need to do but you need a train first you need to go out and experience things that's at the heart of what an RPG is yeah that's true and anything you have objectives and goals in an RPG maybe not I guess Dark Souls II you don't Dark Souls you just stood there and you do have an objective in this well the Dark Souls II do non-inductive you're supposed to rekindle the flame but it's okay it's a pretty vague and they don't explain yeah dark like like for example thanks for playing yeah I could Pokemon you have to grind you have to train but you know what you're doing or what scattered there's a main there's also other things right right first right and that's my favorite part of most RPGs is is going out and experiencing the world without a good sense of direction that's true and making making your own goal and that's why I feel like you should kind of have more speed and stuff like that this is one of the only time in our trash games I've really liked do you think do you think you you liked it so much because you were doing so well you're doing very well if any part of it I think because this game can really break you down to your core like I felt
very essentially in that in a good mood almost always so he was he was taking it he was like oh god this sucks I would have been like I feel like that sir I feel like I really feel like that's all I'm a trash no you all Americans look good I guess yeah those were 80 nights I loved it I'm doing well okay but if I'm doing really bad I'm just like this is the worst game yeah anything that's anything that's so luck based it's gonna be very like which is definitely this game all the way like all the way this game is it's so so luck based so I understand why especially eurogamer's can they they can't decide like okay I don't have my camp I don't have a strict like I'd set path a linear like I do this then this then this and have a few options this is just do whatever you want to do the thing about in Marrakesh is I wouldn't want to play them all the time but every once in a while I don't want to be like playing games so deep in strategy and it's like all my choices something I just want to play a game like this and I can just roll and encounter things and have fun yeah exactly cuz in this one I made strategies like using spells and shading but it wasn't it wasn't like no gonna do right there take it your whole turn now yeah I'm pretty much every year or the ages there's no much every yoga in my plate I've just been like thinking the entire game and sometimes you just want to yeah you roll and be like alright we're all playing the strategy role-playing is just kind of the experience of it and strategy is just way more like involve
mm-hmm cuz like in Skyrim you're not usually oh my god like how am I gonna you know you're just kind of like kind of grind go and then if you'd already know where it gets you like [ __ ] are you just reload you're saying like another another complaint but once again this one is actually the biggest complaint I'm glad I remember it but you were gonna say something Oh gotcha so sorry because sometimes you just [ __ ] like okay the sports show not use your brain they take on more play more hard no argA more is hard yeah okay I I lost yes like I'm dying I'm getting devoured right now right so I guess my biggest complaint and this is actually a valid complaint the movement the randomness that's all I love I love all that the randomness I love because it's essentially real life now you go to the city and shits Gummidge is going to happen you have no control over what happens and i remember show up and sit down there there two guys well neither more but essentially it was two guys from London who trashed on Arkham war because they're like you go to his face draw cards something happens to you you can't do anything about it I'm like like real life like when you walk out your door I guess maybe they want that detachment they want that control here when it's not out there yeah I like the fantasy I've always loved fantasy oversee fight and might but but my biggest complaint is in how long this game is we probably need eight hours I would say the biggest
complaint I have I don't think it's ever happened to me I've seen it happen to multiple people had let's say we had gone five hours in six hours in you got exactly to where you were you draw a card you roll oh that's actually oh yeah if you were a lycanthrope you're killed if you're like you just die so imagine imagine if we had gone where no one's close to winning that you were the best you draw this card you die you wipe everything now well I'm all leveled up everyone's all leveled up and stuff you now have to play catch-up and part of that was the expansions - this is this is from the Blood Moon but I mean like the expansions make everything longer yeah but based in wooden base game well the big theme was still a good two three hours oh yeah so imagine but even length I guess it wouldn't be that big of a deal in like a 30-30 60-minute game but in a two hour game imagine if we're all level up good to go we're loggin our characters you're also really good if you were that character and you just draw happen to record and die nothing you can do I guess in that case with the prophetess you go you would get to choose again but we couldn't six people as well yeah and so when Matt died and we'll Taylor left and Ukiah died it's almost very it's disheartening whenever you're like I'm base character and you don't get [ __ ] but sometimes so that that can really suck that would probably be my biggest complaint is if I had this character and I was oh if I make it to him I'll win I get to the crown of command and I'll win or [ __ ] like the [ __ ] void it's where it's like oh okay this is one of those
games that's you want to do it over two days I feel like yeah I don't ever want to do this again I don't ever want to spend an entire day playing one game right it's not it's just it's a lot of time and it's a long sitting and yeah I mean I won't get tired from sitting like I'm still very much climb this thing when you start yeah yeah you would think I'd hate it I always walk during my job so I'm kind of I'm more of like you know but like though I just I think like four hours one day for us the next day I wouldn't like it a lot more but I still had a lot of fun you know it's not that right well we think it's too intense to like I remember we played Twilight Imperium the like if it just gets to nothing also that's also that's probably the longest game I have and that's dry that's a head that's like every strategy you know if you're like already nine to only let's just say you're just playing single not in the mood and you have to sit there for like eight nine hours and you're the whole time you're just like oh my god what's it gonna end that's true and that's not fun because then you're not going to be fun obviously like we were riding today right yeah so like playing long games like I could have kept this game going like if I items absolutely love this game there are other games where I'm just like please yeah if we done with the boy they would have been doing for quite a while yeah and I'm glad everyone I'm glad you all were like let's pick a different one cuz I was like we thought we all won I thought we did do that rewrite out like Oh another one I was getting ready to go back here I was getting ready to go start you know do my own thing but then who knows like I
could have easily died yeah it's funny like and once again I've never lost this game I've gotten close to losing but we never finished I was on the verge of losing but like with this game anything that you could have been turned into a toad and you lose everything so if you had lost everything and I run by and pick up a look that's a huge and it's like alright that's the only year I would say that's I look at all this [ __ ] I have my could spend I could spend four hours getting all this [ __ ] yeah that's why I think you can die and you can start over with you start over with the road and I mean well the cool thing is it's like sometimes you do they're not all the characters inherited the worst character in here see there's a dragon rider Maori elf the elf yeah elf is literally the worst character and you're if I can find them yeah there's a there's a fire wizard there's an alchemist I do like that you can area start as a new character so that this stopping uses because I feel like even even if you don't think you can win and time with your new character everyone else could die experiences right right Matz was a total upgrade yeah all it depends so the elf well you think that you roll for us whenever you're not here you my god I'm obviously not gonna win but I'm still having fun right right which is awesome which is why I love this game but the elf is he can you bait creatures and characters in the woods if he's in the woods he can move to a different set of woods in the
same region and he doesn't need to roll the die I'm a forest that's of abilities limited there's two spaces he's a he's a basil based game character too he is he is literally the worst character out of all of them so sometimes if you get the elf you wanna die yeah those people who were like [ __ ] I hate this character and the Lawrence trained in the dungeon and died you do have the option to choose though oh yes technically how many do you draw how many do you get dealt I don't remember but they're in the video I watched you said you can either do it randomly or you can choose your Kurt yeah I don't let people choose I think it's more fun to do randomly but in that case you know that kind of yeah yeah yeah if you get started yeah if anyone got the elbow it actually probably be like nope and then handsome like yeah great if I got the elbow I would try to make him good yeah like I would try to make him good just like popped out like you thought you were gonna die I didn't think it was my only one because I had the riding horse I did that bolted me through Lord 1 yes yeah he controlled I have a 24 welcome your 90 I roll if we read right 416 he could have rolled up to a 4 and I would have beaten him by 8 because of the catechism late so and because I was leveled up enough my craft was 5/5 a nickel for every one I rolled this here's here's here's here's one of the things I usually would take the flails out because they're too Opie and here's another thing there's a warhorse the
warhorse allows you to add your craft to your strength during battle yeah so I might gotten the war I should've gotten that yeah if you get the warhorse and then one four seven three the warhorse is for four yeah if you get the warhorse and the flail I would have rolled two dice added them yeah you can get Opie if you know what what you get in the city that would have been perfect for me because I haven't [ __ ] tiny fragments well before I bought the items like three strings yes I would have had 12 grand 12 string and if you're only if you have the flail you roll two dice and add them to your adventure that's your strength roll yeah major oil doubles there's nuts in the lepak you would have had 23 in strength and then so if I had that it would have been [ __ ] okay that's that's taught me them I really liked the dungeon for that but I almost think it's kind of its kind of cheap because you skip all that while some people have to go yeah The Woodlands I really really like The Woodlands maybe my favorite expansion it may probably make a woodlands dungeon Island City I think it'd be more fair if you killed the Dark Lord right to the crab if you could beaten by seven you go to the plane of peril to be beaten by six it's a portable power so you have a chance to at least get closer and then trying to trudge all the way there because these silly rules I was trying to get the SPECIAL man there's only one entrance and when you welders yeah in in this oh yeah I forgot the Cataclysm what do you think of the different board but you guys think of it I guess you you've never played compete with the original I wouldn't know cuz I was in Highland
Games so no I mean yeah I really actually wouldn't know it's pretty cool cuz I got to familiar with this yeah I mean this was interesting because I got I got taken down by what was it [ __ ] Blackwood fanatics and I was like I've never [ __ ] heard of that they just stomp you to death yeah I really really did I really liked the denizens how they're like the scavengers of the people of who survived the apocalypse but they can get annoying when you have specific items like Matt you had a bunch of gems but couldn't sell them to the alchemist because he wasn't a spot in the city like he was in the base game but he shows up and even if he gets discarded you just shuffle him back into the deck so he'll he'll come back I really like that these things are really cool there's like a stack of maybe 20 and I think maybe ten show up on each face so they're really cool the art is fantastic oh yeah on this game it's a it's amazing is literally amazing for every single thing it's all what a gambling hall you're looking the art makes sense for for what they're doing with how many cars are are for the art to be back yeah it's incredible and there was one I can remember I know I was on my top five of top ten art and board games the relics if anyone had beaten the Eagle King you could have gotten his eagle dreadwing which he rolled two dice and had them together to Karen how far you move yeah and if you roll the same result on both dice for your movie you made teleports so whenever a little in the Snake Eyes I could teleport into any
space in the same region you could actually get him as a follower arc now you can discard the teleport to any space in the same region and then this weapon do you actually basically get any everything that he or anything that's on him um any other complaint or any any complaints right yeah oh yeah I forgot about the dragon I had really done yeah [ __ ] it's the biggest slap in the face because yeah oh but you get a lot of interesting stories and funny stories sometimes it's like what the [ __ ] why are we doing this why are there two minutes I [ __ ] fall through that hole twice twice yeah that was funny yeah I don't really I like the dragon I like the Dragons I just don't like the tokens I wish there was a different way maybe maybe while too many tokens yeah they just kind of show up [ __ ] graffiti yeah yeah because like you know how we were like we're like a year old five go five here oh well that's the red dragon girl fight that's sort of driving again like that that happened no one and nobody wanted to go to them yeah yeah oh it was was affording the entire game yeah that's true so next time I probably I debated on not even including them but I was like well it could be fun because once I mean it's the one one part was really funny when four dragon yeah [ __ ] village well that place is dead no never we're never going back to visit right yeah like I couldn't I could go on
and on about about this game because I absolutely loved it it's I was worried actually playing it again if because I played so many different games if it would still be my favourite I was like well I have more variety I have more to pick from it's it's still my favorite like nostalgia out the window eight scratches that fantasy itch that I get in from time in the fantasy Moodle will always want to play talisman because I still love fantasy I'm always down for anything so and you can shorten it to it's not always gonna be a seven-hour game or eight-hour game you can definitely shorten it um I guess that uptime sucks but that's whatever I actually I love setting up my board games there were two things that didn't happen no one ever burnt cards oh there is one more thing I do want to talk about we did never burn cars burn cards were poly the e frites are basically terrorizing the land so there's fire tokens that make areas more perilous you and your turn there you lose alive yeah yeah we played one there was it said the city gets burned down or you place a terrain tile on a space and happen to go on the city so if we did let's just say the ruins I think it was the ruins we placed on the on the city and we made it like formatic we were like you can no longer in the city because it's ruins the city space got destroyed that's how you enter and I think I was obviously he was the optimist in The Alchemist can go and sell items on the city space and turn or not turn them into gold and the city
space wasn't there so made your character useless so that's one now technically you could have been like no you can go through the rubble and make it but look how the city got destroyed so I mean this is destroy no it's just something fanatic we did uh like you could make this game more than anything is inherently yep and so that's what that was and then so yeah the the burning card for ruthless from the game it probably matters more whenever you have not a thousand cards to go through um and the other thing you what do you think of this spells what do you think of that all the spells cuz there's also a [ __ ] to them in here there's some that are just [ __ ] intense the rain wave casting yourself at any time your craft value is doubled until the end of your next turn drainlines Castleman enemy you are about to encounter discard the enemy and heal an amount of life equal to the enemy's strength or craft so there's a lot of [ __ ] I personally love playing characters who have spells I don't think beginning spells I cast really ruined anybody I don't think anything's cast I mean definitely like really I feel like but if there wasn't one that try yeah it was enough to where like it was annoying but it wasn't enough to ruin the game for me right right I think there was a pretty good balance I don't want more hate them alright I just think they're about where they should be right there is one you couldn't cast on someone the vindication that could have totally spear especially when the fates took everyone's fate and then you cast it and
they roll one they're like oh what would have happened oh I nothing they would in the prayer I would have just been ignored but they can roll one and die yeah so you can really screw people over is that is that one life or it's all lives for I fear ol one if you want your kill so yeah if you have you have the whole thing and like when you were out like six or seven yeah you your day yeah see I what something like that seems kind of show you know and to me it's like well we're all adventuring here's we're all trying to get the crown command trying to get the power so I definitely I hold nothing back this game and that doesn't know they're being like that carts lose a spec is a little bit o P it's based on luck and timing he's like if they roll one like Madeline's turn into a toad he spent a fate to re-roll especially considering the fact that a character like mine can I can literally I could spend spell every turn and again mmm like assuming that I'm in a position to spend it yep I could just and I could just get something like that willy-nilly used to go I'm gonna use this to kill someone get another one yeah oh yeah oh yeah that's why I like playing him there's cards in here that it's their one made ones even called random and it's literally a die roll and what if your old one you're turned into a toad so I love this game absolutely love it probably won't play with the Dragons mansion down my favorite if we do base game we'll all try at some point but anyway anything
else anything else on this game okay so that was our thoughts on talisman with all the expansions yeah tell me what you think if you played this game and love it as much as I do but other than that like comment share and subscribe and happy wonderful with every time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I hope that you enjoyed the video if you want to help out the channel I have my teacher on my private if you want to make some suggestions on more games you like to see us run through I have my BoardGameGeek list right there and when it does you don't like the Facebook page I have my facebook link right there and wonderful whatever time of day it is pretty good