Skip to main content
Loading video...

Carnuta Board Game Review

Transcript 10:15

Use your runes and ingredients to craft the best potions in Carnuta.

Welcome to Tantrum House Studio D. I'm Melissa Delp.

And I'm Kevin Delp. Carnut is a set collection game for two to four players. It takes about 30 minutes to play. It's published by Repost Productions, a studio of Asthma. Now, they gave us this copy to review, and it is a work in progress copy, not the final published version. So, there could be some production changes, and we won't be reviewing the component quality.

Makes sense. After we give you a brief overview of the gameplay, we'll divide our video into our four C's. Our thoughts on components, our critiques, our commendations, and finally, our conclusions. In Carnuta, you're playing ingredient cards into your potion to collect icons and provide scoring opportunities. The end of the game is triggered when a player has at least 11 cards in their tableau. After the game ends, players score their ingredient cards, and whoever earns the most points wins.

Here's how the game plays. On your turn, you take two actions. You have four options. Take a card, play a card, take runes, or flip runes. You can choose the same option for both.

Take a card is simple. Pick one of the eight face up cards and put it in your hand. At the end of your turn though, you can have a hand limit of three cards.

To play a card from your hand, you must have the matching runes on your player board. Then you flip or discard the runes as shown on the card.

For an action, you can take one type of rune, either sun or moon, from the center reserve. You can take as many as you like as long as you have empty slots on your player board for them.

Now, the final option for your action is to flip runes on your board so they all match. So, all to the sun side or all to the moon side.

Manipulating your runes is a big part of the game. If you can work it right, playing one card will set you up to play the next card.

This game is all about the scoring. So, here's how it works. Each card has one or two icons to represent a specific type of ingredient. Salt is wild, but when you play the salt, you have to add it to an ingredient type you already have.

Most cards will either have a fixed point value or will give points for having certain ingredients played into your potion. You'll earn points for each matching ingredient or set. So, you can get a lot of points from a scoring card. The player with the most points wins.

So, that's a brief look at how the game plays. Before we move on to the review part, we're going to just take a look at the components. Since this is a work in progress copy, we're just going to show the components instead of critiquing them. It's possible that some things may change in the retail copies. Uh the player boards have a little slider that track the number of cards in your tableau. Uh the cards, they have uh sun and moon types and starting cards. And then there's the rune tiles and cardboard tokens. We also have a playmat um but we assume that it's going to be like an additional purchase or some special item that you can get. So, now on with the review, starting with our game critiques. So, the costs and the benefits of the cards are a big thing in this game. And it did seem like they weren't all equal. Sure.

So, some cards have a base value of five points. And it seemed like all of them you had to have four runes, but some of them you're just flipping the runes to the other side. others. You're trashing some of them and flipping some. And so it can feel more punishing when you have a lot of the trash runes as opposed to the flipping runes. That also comes up with the salt cards, the ones that are wild. There's one of them where it's trash three and another one might be flip three. So your uh the cost isn't always equal to the benefit. There's a lot of variety there and you kind of have to pay attention to what you're picking up cuz there was one game where I was like, "Oh, I really need a salt because the other players keep taking that one icon that I need to make my set.

Oh, now there's a salt. I'll grab it. Oh, it's the discard three salt where earlier in the game some of the better salt were on the table." So, it is just something to kind of keep track of and keep in mind that there are different costs and some of them are going to feel more penalizing than others.

I I just add a little bit to this as well because sometimes you you might say, "Oh, well, you can take an action to get more stuff to refill your your tableau with whatever you want, the suns or the moons." One, the suns or the moons might might not be out there to get. And two, it's always a little bit more efficient to flip the runes to play your cards cuz you're actually be you're you're able to like play a card, flip the runes to the one side, I play another card that actually uses those runes. So, you're a little bit more efficient with your turns. If you're taking a whole turn

to either gain

to gain your things or to spend your the runes, it does feel like you're not being as uh efficient with your turns. I agree. Also, this game is all about the cards. Um, so you're going to have the highs and the lows of like, oh, everything's working perfectly. I'm getting all the icons I need and the lows of I just need those one room to complete the set.

I kind of felt that. Or I need this one card to flip into the row and it's not there.

The one nice thing is the scythe token, which will segue into our commendations. So, every player starts with two Scythe tokens at the beginning of the game, and as a free action, you can spend a scythe token to basically wipe one of the rows of cards and get four new ones, and hopefully you'll get what you need, but not guaranteed.

That is very true. I think the first couple times we played, we didn't use utilize the side tokens. Like, it just didn't cross my mind. and then later games I was like, I really need to be using these to try to maximize what I'm getting.

I agree.

Uh, another thing that I like about the game is that the card backs show which ingredients are in which deck because you have that sun deck and the moon deck. And there's four ingredients that are only in the moon deck and four ingredients that are only in the sun deck. And if you're trying to collect something and you can't remember which deck it is, you just look at the pile and you go, "Oh, I need a berry. I need to go into that moon deck. That's where I'm going to find that ingredient."

Oh, another thing that I like about this game is sort of like you're unlocking benefits as you sort of move up um how many cards you have in your tableau. You're moving up on your player board and you're getting things like um new um resource or dead little tokens that you can get, but there's only one of each. So if someone takes the egg from you, can't take it.

So there's one token for each ingredient and you can take that to add to your potion in total number of

which is good. And then the other thing is that you're also unlocking more rune spots on your playerboard, which I like cuz then you can actually do a little bit more a little bit freer with what you're doing. And actually I think one game that actually saved me because like oh I get to unlock a thing which then lets me get one more sun or moon tile which was very very helpful to do what I needed to do. I like that the game does not end immediately. It's not one of those where

Kevin has played his 11th card stop. Boom.

Instead,

well, first off, you can kind of track how people are doing by looking at how many cards they have or on their player board that tracker that Kevin was talking about. Plus, what happens when someone reaches that 11th card that they've played, it triggers the end, meaning you finish that round and then you play one more round. So you have a little bit of time to hopefully finish your plans or at least make a little bit better of what you were trying to do instead of it just stopping and you're nothing happening and disappointment and all of that.

Yep. Well, let's move on to our conclusions. So, as you've seen, this is a quick and easy game. It's two to four players. I think I like it at all the player counts, maybe a little bit on the higher player counts. um easy to teach, which I like about the quicker games. Um you can sort of say, "Hey, this is what you're going to do." And you can get right into it pretty quickly and it plays in about 20 25 minutes. So I like all those things about this game, especially teaching new players. So I really appreciate that.

And the game, the pieces when you're playing is language independent. So you don't need to be able to read anything. It's all icon based. And I thought the icons were easy to understand. I mean, it's basically scoring. Do you have these things or those things? So, you could play it with younger players who aren't reading yet or uh players that um have different languages. So, there wouldn't be an issue with the game components playing wise. I agree with what Kevin was saying. It's a nice game to fit that 30 minute aspect where you just want something quick to play that is more than a party game. You know, it has some thought in it. It has some strategy trying to decide and pivot. Do I need to go a different scoring route? Am I going to take this card because it flips my tiles really well to play a different card, but it's not going to really score me points. or do I take that extra action to flip things? So, I felt like it had good decision space for the level of game that it is. It's not a complex game, but it still uh made my brain think, which I enjoy out of the lighter weight games.

Yeah. Well, tell us in the comments what are some of your lighterw weight games. We'd love to hear from you. And be sure to check back for more videos coming soon from Tanger Mouse.

Progress saved