Skip to main content
Loading video...

SETI - Review and round the table discussion

Transcript 13:33

We've just finished an epic fourplayer game of Seti. So, SetI is a game that came out in 2024. It was definitely in my top 10 games of that year, but the more I've played it, my feelings on the game have just increased. I love the game. I think it's great. I think the theme of the game is great. And when I'm talking about theme, I don't just mean the setting of the game. I mean the way that the game works, the cards, the effects that they have, the actions you're taking in the game. It actually feels like we are launching probes into space and we are analyzing data and things like that. It doesn't feel like an abstract game with a theme pasted on. So I I very much enjoy the game, but Mark has just won the game with a score of 188.

So, we traditionally go to the winner of the game first. How many times have you played TETI?

Maybe like five times or so. Somewhere between five and 10, I guess.

And how many times with the expansion?

This is my first time playing the expansion.

But you've played the game enough to know

whether you like it or not.

Yes. Um, yeah, I love SEI. It's definitely in my top 100, this game, and I really like what the expansion has brought to it. This was fun to just kind of because it's just encouraging you to play with some other aspect of the game that you don't do as much. Like this meant a lot. I want to do a lot of like oo I kind of want to do a lot of the different traces and try and time these actions. So it's like and I I messed up a couple of times but that's fine like that. You can't always sequence that perfectly.

Um

so you enjoy the game.

Yeah. the expansion.

Definitely.

You would always use it if playing with experienced players.

Yeah, I think so because it just adds a little bit extra in intrigue to it.

And I really I enjoyed the new the new alien we had.

We had we had one of the new aliens.

Interesting.

You know, funny enough for me the other one's new cuz I I hadn't actually

I had not played with this one, so I had no idea how

and I really liked that one as well. Like these ones were both quite interesting. There's a few of them where you feel like they're much more minor, whereas these things felt like they impacted it more. It's like, oh, I actually need to do something with these on. And that also adds to the theme, this whole kind of like

you're you're collecting samples and then transporting them somewhere. Exactly. Yeah.

But yeah, I I kind of echo your sentiments. The thing that's amazing about this is as well as being a really fun puzzle and just the choices you get from the cards as you go.

Multi-use cards is always a always a benefit in for me. And if if you watched the playthrough video and if you're only watching the review video and you haven't watched the playthrough video, go and watch the last five minutes of my turn where it was like, how am I going to do this? And because the cards are multi-use and because you can do all sorts of shenanigans. Um, yeah, it was and and I like that game. I I like a game where you can try and work out how you're gonna do it.

I think that is one of the reasons why I like this one so much cuz even though it's quite a different game, something about this gives me slight vibes to underwater cities. Another game I absolutely love with the way that these cards come and kind of present like here's a shiny tempting thing you might want to do that's sort of a better way of doing stuff that you can do in other ways.

Is it worth it? Do you want to do that? Is it do you need to pivot or do you just feed that into your engine some other way by just discarding it or

getting rid of it? And I know they're different but that part feels kind of similar.

Mhm.

Yeah. I love it,

Rob.

Yeah. So

thought you were going to win. It

was very close.

But Mark just just picked you at the end. Now you own Seti. Yeah. So you obviously like it enough to buy it, but this was your first time playing the expansion.

Yeah. So new aliens. Brilliant. Was expecting some interesting new stuff

and some these new action cards as well.

Yeah, there's 48 new cards that get shuffled into the deck.

So I think pretty sure that was a new one. Uh yeah, little expansion symbol. This really liking the new asymmetric unique abilities. Yeah.

Be really keen to see how these play sort of as I get to play other ones.

Yeah.

The only thing I'm

not 100% sure yet on is the skipping the first turn,

right? Which is optional. You don't have to do that.

You absolutely don't have to do that.

So, cuz I know I spoke to quite like that first turn because it gives them a chance to sort of get a feel and start to develop what their strategies are going to be.

Whereas jumping right in,

it locks you into certain paths that maybe aren't what you want to go for. So,

would absolutely get the expansion. You just may not use the first round.

Most may not use the first round. Yeah.

And the reason that they did that is

some people found that round one was a bit slow, but also there's now more to do, I think.

And this also kickstarts you off a lot, doesn't it? Gives you income where

more than normally you just have like one card of income or something.

No, you get the full

I can't remember what the normal starting cards were. It's like

it is it is whereas you got three extra cards as income at the start.

I think the ability was relatively weak.

I think I think the low value cards

they get a lot more income

but their ability is relatively

basic two I think are much stronger.

I just messed it up in round one and I didn't use it in round one cuz I took the wrong tech.

Constantly cycling through really costefficient powerful actions.

Oh yeah. All all of yours gave you three cards as income at the start. It was just It was just mine.

But yours didn't have quite as much.

Let's hamper

income on the card.

I didn't have as much stuff here, I think.

Yeah, I started with

three income.

No, you similar one.

Okay. Fran had

31 and a publicity, which is interesting as income.

But that's cuz the

Yeah.

thing uses.

Oh, I guess you had you had a bit higher stuff there. Mine's very low there. And you get one for this team.

Yeah. Uh Fran, so you caught up quite a lot at the end. So you're not that far behind in the end. So I got 176, you got 167. So less than less than 10 points behind.

How many times have you played SETI?

This is my second.

And you weren't that keen on it.

It wasn't your choice.

It Yeah, it wasn't my choice. It's better.

Um I I prefer, you know, it's it's gone up in my estimations. Um I don't get help though. The last round I just found very frustrating.

Okay. Because

because I ended so early.

Oh, right.

And I had four cards, right,

that I just had to get rid of for cash.

Ah, right. Okay.

Um cuz you know I was ahead

of you guys and then

and then we all went right. you fizzled out in the last round because you just ended up with

cards that you couldn't use cuz you ended up throwing away from to buy that. Right.

And that one

money's very tight

and that one card was like nine points worth

like nine points worth of card.

Yeah.

So I didn't want to not play that.

Yeah.

And I played the the one of those to get that which actually did help cuz it helped me to get the extra one of those. M

that's one thing I found interesting about this game which I I don't remember from other games is in round three you ended

four turns before us.

I've never had that happen before.

And then in the last round you ended five turns before me.

Whether I just got something slightly mistimed or whether I just got my resources not quite balanced and I could have unlocked more if I had done a different

I'm glad you didn't play more because you were already 20 points ahead by the time that was passed.

But then by that time in the same

Exactly. Exactly.

Well it happened the same to me. I think I had one time. Whereas

you will have like three or four turns for it.

Interesting. You never know what the alien's going to be cuz the cards you get can have very different effects.

Yeah.

You know, so that be one of the other different ones again. It could have been something again. I was so close to getting the thumb on there now myself

just having the alien for me. So

yeah,

I definitely think I'd like to try with a different card cuz this was useful

but it was a bit boring really.

It is a little boring.

But then I have a play.

It's a nice easy one. Yeah. Yeah. It's the nicest pic and I can understand this one now. This is quite complicated. You've actually got to go,

wait a minute, how does how does this work?

And I I now get how it works.

So, I've been quite scared of playing anything other than the basic

the four suggested starting ones. Now, I'm happy to play anything

because they're only minor.

These are not like major asymmetric powers. It's just

pushing you.

No, exactly.

I mean, mine, for example, was a little or what number was yours? Um, mine was a difficulty nine.

Nine. Okay. So, that was

Well, it's out of 11. So,

it's quite high. Yeah.

So, my other one was was only an eight.

Yeah. But only an eight. That's eight out of 11.

Yeah.

And it's B. I think they're all balanced. It's just how how difficult is it to play compared to the game without them? I think with this one it's because of the timing because you can't

try and get the trace at the right time. These are very strong and wasting being able to flip them is not good because it's such a good discount.

Yeah.

Mostly one cash discount for most of them, isn't it? So it's pretty much

one rather than two, one rather than in the game where cash can be so tight. Yeah.

Yeah.

Um anything anybody wants to add other than

I love it. I think it's amazing. You you really like it.

You really like it. This was your second game and you preferred this one to your first game. Yeah. Would you play it again?

I'll definitely play it again.

Yeah. [clears throat]

Yeah. My group are interested to see how this was going to be with the expansion. So, I'll

You'll be borrowing this then.

Um,

well, we got Quidcon coming up. So,

yeah. So, in terms of my favorite games of 2024, this was in my top 10. Colution was my number one. Honestly, I'm now leaning to more towards SETI.

As much as I love Colution as a game and I love playing it,

this makes me happier. And that could be the theme.

Yeah.

Something about

this is another quality production from CGE. You can see the amount of smooth development that's gone into the game.

Polish.

Polish. Absolute polish.

Components. Gorgeous. graphic design. Perfect.

The only minor quibble that I have is that they put these outlines the wrong way around. Um, which makes no difference whatsoever, but it affects my uh my OCD a little bit.

The game play is just fantastic. Every time I play it, I love the puzzle. I love what you're doing. Uh, and the fact that it has an astronomy theme and it's it's

and it's well implemented. It's it's hard sci-fi

if you ignore these. In other words, this is realistic.

Yeah.

All of the cards are actual real things.

Yeah.

And they do on them

what you think they would do for the you know, all of the missions that are on here. Oh, the Mariner 10 mission gets points for going to Venus and M. Well, that's what it did. Yeah.

So, it it's great the amount of effort that's gone into making sure the game is scientifically accurate. And then you've got the aliens.

Even though they're kind of like speculative hard sci-fi, aren't there?

Well, there's one of them which is real.

Yeah.

Which is um Uma.

Yeah.

Um that is actually a real thing.

Um

but the rest of them obviously we hope are not real. But we never know.

I hope not the one that that can harm the players and something like where you have the cards if you've got them at the end of the game, you'll lose points. that I've played that one is where is where and it's a push your look thing you can drill down and it's like this one

but there's no padlocks you choose

you just choose

and if you go I'll tell you what I'm going to drill here I get better rewards um but at the end of the game who whoever did did the most damage

like a third

you lo you lose like 10% of your points or something

and I I I did lose again because I was ahead

but I drilled like mad Uh your hubris caught up with you.

Dug too greedily too deep.

I did did

project arrogant hubris is on course.

Um so yeah, thank you very much to everybody for watching. As I said, this is going to be released as a separate review video, but if you want to watch the playthrough, it it is there on the channel from earlier on. I have done other playthroughs of this and I have covered the solo game and I really enjoyed the solo game of it as well. So that's there. You have like goals that you've got to try and achieve. Um, but other than that, we are all done. So, yeah, thank you very much to E3 for joining me for today. It's been a space themed day. And, uh, thank you very much to everybody for joining in the chat. And thank you very much to PCGE for the copy of this game. And a big thank you to all of my Patreon supporters. If you like the content that I create and you want to support me and help me carry on making videos like this, because this is not sponsored, um, you can support me at patreon.com/gamingrules.

Progress saved