Caverna Board Game Review
Transcript
this is a year of our review of caverna the cave farmers by of a Rosenberg which is a sequel to a previous very popular game at guerrilla war survived a Rosenberg and I'm going to do two separate reviews for for this one for people who are new to agricola haven't played that game before and a separate review for people who are experienced with the GRIK Allah so this review is for people who haven't played agricola before and i can tell you straight away that agricola was a fantastic game still is a fantastic game an absolute classic sat right at the top of the board game geek charts for a long time and still right up there it's accessible it's tactile its strategic it's harsh it's got a good learning curve it's a great great game now caverna is essentially the same game just with new elements added and rules tweaks here and there to agricola but we're going to look at this from the point of view of not having played agricola at all so the basic the basic starting point for caverna is that you've got this board here and you have a collection of these disks which represent your dwarves these are your workers you can see on the board here I've got three now at the start of the game my board would look nothing like this okay my board would be completely
empty it would just have these forests spaces as you can see underneath there it would all be forest and this mountain would be completely empty and just empty spaces like this but throughout the game you're going to build up this whole network of tunnels and caverns you're going to cut down trees to to develop what to get grab wood and to build these fenced areas where you can keep animals so we've got pigs here and we've got sheep over here and sheep of being guarded by this sheepdog we've got another pic here we've some cows up here in space called the breakfast room and in the mines over here we've got two donkeys okay and these are all lovely little wooden pieces which give the game that tactile element that I was talking about and and it all really starts to tell a story as you go along as you're placing these animals on the board it's not just animals though you've also got vegetables so we've got these pumpkins that you can grow on fields here and grain that you can grow over here all these things are going to score you points at the end of the game you basically you score points for most things and you've also got these different building resources so bits of wood and stone these ones are or so these are these are what you're going to
use to to build weapons and throughout the game although weapons is a bit of a misnomer they're not really weapons we'll talk about that in a little bit and then you've got these rubies which act as a sort of wild card really rubies can be spent to buy most different types of things throughout the game and then these cardboard tokens which represent food and throughout the game you're going to have to make sure you have enough food to feed your dwarves now you'll notice these dwarves also have symbols on top of them these are their weapons that they've developed so this guy has got a level four weapon which isn't that great but this guy's got a level 13 weapons so he's really effective when he goes out on expeditions which are going to do throughout the game so the game is about developing this board and then at the end of the game you get a scouring pad like this I don't show you my scores embarrassing and so let's fold that over and there we go so you've got all these different scoring categories every farm animal a dog you have will score you one point any farm animals that are missing so if you haven't got any cows for example you get minus two points every grain is worth half a point rounded up every vegetable one point every Ruby one point every dwarf one point any spaces you haven't used on the board a minus one point and then you get these rooms I shall move you over to the main board now this is going to intimidate you if you haven't played agricola before over here we've got all these different types of rooms which score you points which
get placed onto your player board this one's the cuddle room where you can place a whole load of sheep there's a little German joke there Yeah right so this one gives you as many sheep as you have dwarves you can put onto this room it doesn't give you the sheet but you can put as many sheep onto this room as you have dwarves and it costs you one word in order to build it and at the end of the game is going to give you two points so these are all the different ways that you can score points throughout the game the other thing that you can do is grab and tokens which represent goals so you've got these in various different numbers ok so these these are just straight up victory points at the end of the game and how the game is going to work is when it's your turn you take one of your dwarves and you place him or her somewhere on this board these are all your different options for what you can do on your turn so for example if I wanted to go logging I can go here and I would take three bits of wood I also have the choice if I want to to go on an expedition but I don't have any weapons on this particular dwarf so I can't do that i could go here and take a bit of stone now wood and stone is what i'm going to need to build most of these rooms most of these rooms require wood and stone in
order to build them to give me points and to give me extra powers and abilities what sort of other spaces have we got here we've got these ones which are about developing the land so this one gives me a bit of wood it's a clearing but it also gives me one of these tiles and so I'll gain a tile like this which I can then place on my board in order to start to develop this sort of farm area over here ok then there's also similar sort of things as I said about going up here this one would give me stone but not only that it would also give me a double tile here which is going to help me to dig into my mountain and give me caverns and tunnels now advantage of having tunnels is that they when they're paired up like this allow me to use a space which pops up later in the game to build mines so I can build an ore mine or I can build a ruby mine on top of that these give me points at the end of the game but they also mean that when I go and gather or so if I take or I'm going to get extra or two more or for every or mine or if I go and gather rubies up here I'm going to get a ruby but I'll also get a ruby for every
ruby mine that I have or well no actually I'll get one Ruby if I have at least one Ruby mine ok now the clever thing about these spaces is they're blocked if i take this space the next player that comes along with his dwarf and tries to put it on this space he's not able to because i've blocked it off and so that is the the basis of a lot of worker placement games you block off the spaces so so there is some competitive play there where you prevent another player from taking a space and the spaces which haven't been used in a turn will accumulate more goods so you might end up with a situation where suddenly you've got you know six wood on this space and it becomes very attractive to take that space and take the wood off it okay there's lots of other spaces and throughout the game each round new spaces will be revealed so new cards will be turned over which will give you new opportunities to do different things final thing I should mention really i mean the game goes on until we get to here ok and between rounds there are usually harvests between each round and in a harvest you're going to have to feed your dwarf so you can have to make sure you put food your animals are going to breathe eat your vegetables and wheat you're going to start to take those off your fields where you've been growing them so there's all sorts going on in this game I should probably talk about expeditions so expeditions what you're doing here is you're taking a dwarf that you've
previously given him a weapon and you give him a weapon using a blacksmith space on the board spending all and so that's these are the black bits spending this to give him a weapon and the weapons at various degrees we know how much all you spend so this guy is a level four if he goes on the next perdition so supposing he uses this space up here which is the blacksmithing space well let's look at giving him a weapon so he goes on here he's got no weapon at the moment but he's got a bunch of all he can spend up to eight or so let's give him five he spends five or okay which gives him a level five weapon so we'll stick a level five weapon on him he then gets to go on an expedition and this expedition is going to give him three bits of loot now you would expect an expedition to mean fighting and that sort of thing it doesn't it means you go out and you find yourself a cow or you find yourself a pig so these are all the different things he can take on his expedition but he can only have stuff from level 5 down okay but he can take up to three things on this particular space so you could have a pig a donkey and a sheep or it could have to only kind of the two points because that's a six he could have a pumpkin he could have a wheat he could have a dog okay he could even go here and after the expedition all his weapons and all this Dwarfs will be given plus one and when he completes this expedition his weapon is upgraded so throughout the game by
going on more expeditions you gain more experience in it orbs get better at gathering stuff and that really is it there's not much in a way of interaction in the game the only interaction is in blocking each other it all looks quite daunting but actually you pretty quickly get used to what all these different buildings do you know they're all very logical as one there let's go two points for stone it's one the scores you points for or there's one that scores you points for rubies there's one scores a point for vegetables and grain it's one that's cause your point for weapons you know pretty much if you if you stick to a particular strategy there's likely to be a car tire leather that's going to score you points for it and this game really it requires you to kind of diversify and do a little bit of everything you can specialize a little bit you know you could have a ton of sheep or something like that but you're going to get scored down if you don't have one of each farm animal and you're going to get scored down if you haven't filled up all the spaces on the board so you're going to need up to build up your mountainside and your farming side if you're going to get maximum points the game plays for well it plays really well with one player actually but it plays with up to seven players I haven't played it with that larger number and I imagine it would take a long time the boxes 30 minutes per player and I think that's fair for players who know the game but if you're Blauman new players it's going to take even longer than that so for a seven-player game with new players I think you're looking at a day
so but yeah 127 players which is a nice spread and there are a ton of components in this massive box this is an enormous box you know and really really heavy it's absolutely packed with stuff the stuff I've showed you so far obviously this is just one board there are seven of these 47 player game now it doesn't come with storage solutions so you have to come up with your own but this is all the wooden bits that come in this game okay a ton of wooden bit this by the way is a box from Mayday I go from board game extras website but but this is a useful storage system but that's not even enough because we've also got all these tiles so this is where I keep all my set up separate tiles to place on the board and even that's not enough there's a load of stuff that I couldn't fit into these containers which are still in plastic bags in here so and and there's extra board here for more action spaces when you're playing with more players so that the board doesn't get too crowded it ok i can tell you straight away that this is a fantastic game as a gray color was before and as the other games by you've a rosenberg and in this sort of harvest family what used to be the called the harvest trilogy and they're all fantastic games but i'll talk a little bit more about why i like this game so much caverna is a absolutely enormous production is quite expensive
this box is big and mia compare it to a more standard size box so the box for regular these are heavy boxes to hold up in one hand so there's a gray color ok you can seek a burner is considerably bigger thicker ok so this is quite an expensive and quite an expensive game it's well worth your investment though it is absolutely round for the pieces the stuff doesn't even fit in the box if you use the sort of storage solutions that i've talked about and it barely fits in the box as it comes but but but but this is it its value for money you know you there's a lot of game in this box my experience with ag rigler has been that it has been a very accessible game of being able to play it a lot with with family and with couples and non-gamers and I think caverna is still there you know it's this is in some ways this is a little trickier to pick up so so you know but but but the theme is still very accessible this idea of farming and a little bit of mining but it's also you know bear down to its absolute sort of the simplest aspect so they're having a mind this gives you a little bit ov or just you a little bit of all you know nothing very detailed here and but it tells a nice little story and most of it is fairly intuitive
in terms of what you do and the other thing is it's quite this this game is quite them forgiving you know it's gonna get you're gonna get points for most stuff most stuff can be converted into food so you're not going to be struggling to feed your dwarfs and you know it's not a stressful game to play and stress is something that was often talked about in the previous game agricola and this is not a stressful game to play but it is fairly complex this is probably not again to throw somebody straight into if they really haven't played any sort of Euro games at all and that's what this is this is a Euro game through and through it's me this is sort of listen and a grifter and a benchmark by which all other euro games are really compared it's a classic worker placement I know Kahless went before but but worker placement really came into its own up for me with a gray color and this is the same game I mean this could it feels almost like this could have been introduced as an expansion to agricola rather than a whole new game but but but but but it's fantastic now why is it so fantastic and the tactile pieces brilliant it looks lovely that board it just looks lovely when you've got all the bits building up and you can look back and see what you've achieved you know and then losing one of those sheep or losing one of those cows you know to give food for your dwarves that's quite heartbreaking really because you know
I've built that and and and I'm pleased with it and it's there and it feels great to have it there and then you can find ways to make points from what you've built by adding in little rooms and stuff and that's fantastic so that tactile sort of nature of it really really for me is a big sort of selling point for it and that accessible theme and there's lots of strategic decisions this game has very very little luck in it there's a little bit of variation in terms of when the rounds when the different action spaces become available very little you know you've got three action spaces they might come up in order ABC or a CB or whatever but they're going to come up at roughly the same time there's a little bit of variation in when the harvests happen you'll have a certain number of harvests throughout the game but it is randomized when they occur but other than that essentially everything's laid out in front of you and you make the best of what you can see the slight downside of that is there's not going to be that much variety between games but the variety comes from what the other players do and how that interacts with you and how that prevents you from doing stuff yourself what it does mean is that the solitaire game eventually I think will become tired because you're doing the same thing you've got everything laid out exactly the same and you know it's ultimately you do as well as you can and they'll come a point where you go what
I've done this now but that's it most games don't even have a solitaire option and this one does and it works well and so so that's good too and just to talk a little bit about which other games this is like I mean the obvious one to compare it to is a gray color which is essentially the same game just with tweaks and alterations and that sort of thing this obviously predates it this is a fantastic game agricola absolutely brilliant this for me is the best sort of the modern board games that I've played I know that everybody doesn't agree with that but for me this is fantastic this has got a lot more variability in it than caverna because it's got a ton of cards and you only have a certain number of those cards in each game and so every game you've got a different focus to the last game some people don't like that some people find that that over complicates things but but for me agricola has huge variety almost infinite replayability again packed full of tactile composes a fantastic game agricola and as you start to add in the expansions Farmers of the more here and which introduced horses and forests and peat and fuel and all sorts of other stuff extra actions and the goodies expansion which introduces all the little wooden animals and a bunch of cards and you know neat extra sort of playing boards and that sort of thing and then you've got all the sort
of individual card decks so these give extra odds this is the Belgium deck you know we got here netherlands deck you know so these will give even more variability to break that now caverna plays a bit like a mix of agricola with farmers of the more and also a little bit of the game sort of thrown in there as well so you know a little bit of Lahab and a little bit of war at the boar i don't have a rapport and these games used to be called the harvest trilogy so the harvest trilogy was lahav love comprehensive and agricola at the gates of loyang this was the harvest trilogy until or a the Bora came along and that suddenly became four and then we had a two-player version of agricola all creatures big and small fantastic short half hour version of agricola and which has a lot of influence on Coburn are actually converted does feel like it's it's got a lot of all creatures big and small in there as well in terms of those little tiles that you place around that's a good little game more creatures big and small and then we've got the heart the inland port which again is a two-player version the heart small quick easy to play so suddenly there's harvest well thats a certainly has been the last couple years this harvest trilogy has become a harvest family and every single game in there i mean i haven't played or a labora the others are absolute classics brilliant brilliant games
brilliant games this way the gates of law yang is is underrated criminally underrated it's a fantastic game and really really good this one is all about the sort of growing of vegetables harvesting of vegetables trading of vegetables supplying customers there's a lot of card drafting in it but it focuses on the on the vegetable and sort of wheat aspect that you see in agricola and really focuses in on that assume there's a simpler game than the others but brilliant two-player game not so good with three or four but brilliant to play and pretty one player game as well good solitaire game the heart is all about placing buildings and using those buildings and and gathering resources and converting resources into other things there's more interaction in the heart than in the others because when you use a building it's going to have an effect on another player as well but the strategy is a bit more focused it pushes you in one direction so you don't have quite that you've got to die a huge diversity of choices but you're ultimately you're going one way which is not true in the game arkham burner for example but the heart again great game andorra labora i'm told feels most likely half a development of lahav with elements of agricola put in there as well so those are the other games that you might want to look at if you're considering a game in this sort of genre and really bouvet Rosenberg has carved out a whole genre of his own with these harvest games and
I don't think caverna has replaced agricola it feels like an alternate version of agricola something to play for variety you know if you play a bit of agricola well let's play a bit of caverna it's the same way that i use Farmers of the more I don't play it every time I play agricola but sometimes I'll add it in sometimes now I think I'll play caverna instead of playing agricola and it's quite a nice option to have but I don't think it's it's completely replaced agricola as some other reviewers have already suggested that said it is as good as the other reviewers are saying it's a really good game I'm trying to think if there are any downsides to it and the sort of things that people used to complain about with the curricula some of those things have gone so no longer do we have to worry about it being stressful it's not and there's there's still some thematic sort of problems little things that don't make sense all that stuff about why why if i take this space you know somatically why it cannot kalai not have a baby at the same time as he has a baby or or whatever that stuff's still in there there's not that much player interaction in this and which is perhaps a bit of a shame there's still that sort of aggressive blocking tactic that you can do and some people didn't like that in the previous game so they won't like that in this either and one problem with some of the title an infinite loop has already been discovered and where if you get four of
the the titles and put them all together which is quite a feat to achieve then you can generate infinite points and that's a shame but it's a minor minor thing okay you can you can change a rule okay I've got about five different alternate rules that i could use and i just discuss them at the beginning of the game and I'm practically sure the designer will come up with a alternate rule for that one of those tiles that will sort that out very soon he's already talking on the internet but what he's going to do and so I don't think it's a problem that should make you stay away from the game it's a mind thing as so many of those tiles you know basically just don't do it don't don't use that infinite loop and it's fine and any other downsides to the game well it's expensive and it's quite intimidating for new players although the theme will really carry a new player through it does tell a story you know it just all makes sense and and so that's really helpful and that's what makes the game actually quite accessible and even though it looks daunting at first glance and when I'm talking about theme here this is a really thin Matic game but not in the sense of the sort of Americans thematic games where you got fighting here where we're developing weapons but they're not really weapons you know we use our weapons go on an expedition and find ourselves some grain or a vegetable you know we're not going out fighting with other dwarves that option isn't in there so well I'm talking about this being a thematic game what I mean is it tells us a gentle story a simple story
quite slow story and but but you can see something develop in front of you and it looks like what it is it looks like a toy farm that you're developing in front of you and and so it is thematic in that sense not in the American thematic game sense and yeah caverna is as good as everyone saying it is well worth you getting a copy if you're interested and also have a look at those other games if you haven't played them because you've got a world of fantastic games ahead of you if you get into the harvin lie and a GRIK there any expansions and the two-player versions and all of that so fantastic world of games