Skip to main content
Loading video...

How Midway Got Me To Love Historical Board Games | Wargames - Avalon Hill

Transcript 9:38

Hey everybody, I'm Zilla Blitz, and welcome. I want to talk today about Midway, which is a historical board game, and how it spawned a lifetime hobby for me. And what is special about historical board games, and why some of you out there, if you haven't experienced them yet, might actually enjoy this type of game play. Now, before we can jump into the whys, the story needs a little bit of context. You can tell this is an old battered game. This game was published in 1964. I got it somewhere in the 1970s as a birthday gift from my brother. And if you don't know contextually what type of game this is, Midway is a historical board game, often called war games. They're a subgenre of board games that explore generally historical battles throughout time. Ancients, World War I, World War some hypothetical ones for future conflicts and things like that. Now, back in the 1970s, we had games like Life, Risk, you know, we played a lot of cards, there was Payday, Monopoly, and things like that. But there was also this company called Avalon Hill that made historical board games, and they were actually somewhat mainstream. You could go into large department stores like Sears back in the day, and you could find their games in their stores.

Hobby stores had them and things like that. So, you this was something it was kind of in the recesses of board games, but they existed, and a lot of us back in that time period bumped into these games in some way, shape, manner, or form. And for me, the introduction was my brother gave this game. I must have been like gave this game to me when I was like 11 or 12 as like a birthday present in the 1970s. So, I get this game Midway, and I'm like, what is this thing? And you know, when you open it up, and there are hundreds of pieces, like individual Japanese ships and plane symbols and all these kinds of things, like, what is going on? So different than any other type of board game I'd experienced to that point in time. And historically, too, to set the scene, right? If you're not familiar with the Battle of Midway, feel like, what's he talking about? Midway historically, World War I, the US is fighting Japan. This was probably one of the most decisive at the first decisive US victory in the Pacific theater in World War II. The Japanese had sent a carrier strike force to try an invasion force to try to take the island of Midway, which was to the northwest of Hawaii. The US had gotten wind of their attack plans. They were lying in wait.

Big aircraft carrier battle, launching planes, sinking ships. US forces a decisive victory in that they just basically obliterated the Japanese carrier strike force and forced them to high tail it back towards Japan. And so yeah, we all knew the story of Midway, but then this box comes along and it changes everything. Because up until that point in time, you know, you knew Midway from a movie or from a book and it always happens the same way. And at certain points in that story, they're like, "Well, imagine if this, you know, this catapult on this Japanese search plane actually worked and the Japanese found the US forces before the US forces found the Japanese forces. How might history have been different?" But you don't know, right? Or what would have happened maybe if, you know, the US carrier had the Yorktown hadn't been repaired in time and there were only two US carriers there instead of three.

You can imagine it, but you don't know. But you can take that carrier out in this game and now you can play it and that's where this box changed everything. Because it up until that point in time, history is a line and now it's got infinite possibilities. You can explore all the what-ifs and the decisions that were made and the alternate decisions. You can go this way or that way. You can play so many different ways and there's a designer, Herman Luttmann, who designs these games and he says, "Once you make your first and second move in most war games like this, you're exploring alternate history because you probably aren't doing the same thing that the leaders did in that day." So it puts you in the shoes of those leaders and it gives you all the ability to make all kinds of decisions to try different things. And you know, what if weather What if a storm had blown up two days before it actually got there? What if this decision went the other way? So much possibility. And as you can see, you know, I played this game 50, 100 times. It is so tattered now. And every single game ended up in a different way.

I mean, yes, once I would win or the other side would win and and those are are drawn lines. But the story and how you got there and what happened and the degrees of victory and the degrees of defeat are always different. And so many interesting decisions and fascinating things to explore. So, as someone who liked history and likes history, the ability to explore history in other than a linear format is something that just resonated with me and it made me realize that yeah, I was going to play these games for the rest of my life, right? Because that they just open up so many different aspects of history that you can't get at with a book or a video, right? And the second thing that I think resonated with me with this game and in particular with these games in general is connected to those alternative histories is story, narrative. One of the big reasons why people play games is because of narrative, right? You want to tell a story. And this the game and historical board games in general, every time you played it it was a different story. Connected to of course that different history, but the narratives are so vivid and you're there, you're part of it, you're making decisions and you're seeing it unfold before your eyes. Sometimes you would play this for an hour and then you would sit around afterwards and talk about it for an hour. So, the ability for these games to tell stories and unpredictable stories and different stories and infinite stories and be able to relive and talk about those stories afterwards. You'd be like, "Remember when we did that and you did this and I did that?" And then somebody would be like, "Where were you?

I was looking for you up there." Because in this game it's kind of like Battleship on steroids. You've got these screens and you can't see where your opponents are. And so you're like, "Where were you? I couldn't find you for these days." And you're sweating it out while you're trying to find where your opponent is. So, that ability for alternative history to explore alternative history, but then also to to live in those stories again and to create story like that was just a magical gameplay experience for me. And the last thing I think about historical board game situation that creates a resonance with me and really makes me you know, it's created this this lifetime hobby for me. It puts you there. Right? And so so many times playing this game, you know, in Carrier Combat if you're not familiar, who finds the other person first and who can strike first, who can hit first has a huge huge advantage and is probably going to win. So so much of this game is trying to outthink and outmaneuver and hide and outpredict where your opponent's going to be and what they're going to do. Because if you can find your opponent's carriers first and hit them first, there's a really good chance you're going to win the battle. Right?

So you've got this inherent tension as this game is unfolding, whether you're the US forces or the Japanese forces, like where is my opponent? Can I get my forces there? Can I strike? Can I hit hard enough? Can I take out some of his carriers so he can't wipe me out in a counter strike? And so you've got this literally sweating tension as you're trying to outpredict and outthink your opponent and make strikes as this game unfolds. And sometimes you have these amazing victories where you you you destroy your opponent's carrier and you're like, oh, everything went really well. And there's this elation there that's And then sometimes it goes sideways and you get hit first and you're like, ah. And sometimes you find them first, but then your strike doesn't work and they counter strike. So I mean, all of the different nerves and excitement and energy that surrounds that type of experience is in this game.

And and and the thing about it is that you're not just passively watching it like you would with a movie and you know how it's going to turn out. You don't know what the story is. You don't know what the history's going to be and you're acting it out in real time as you're playing this game. So in a sense, I mean, it it's cardboard counters on a table. Yeah, it's nothing like what it would have been like to actually be in a battle like this. But, it creates those same emotions, albeit perhaps to a silly and and and trivial degree, it creates those same emotions, and it puts you in that historical context that allows you, I think, to imagine with greater capacity what it would have actually been like had you been one of the people there. Imagine the tension. If you feel this nervous in a silly game about with little counters and cards and maps, imagine what it would have been like with those feelings magnified a hundredfold, a thousandfold if you were really there and your life were on the line. So, the ability for these games to transport you to that historical moment and to help connect you to the emotion and feeling that would have been surrounding that battle or that moment in history, to make you an actor in history instead of a passive consumer of history, is something that just came to life as soon as I started playing this game. So, that those three things, I think, are why this silly birthday present, when I was a teenager back in the 1970s, leads to something like this behind you, what you're seeing here, right? Where now you've got hundreds of games that allow you to explore,

you know, similar experiences with different moments in history or, you know, science fiction, it's still the same type of thing. But, they allow you to explore history and different pathways, they allow you to tell different stories, and they put you there as an actor in history rather than a passive consumer in history. And that's why Midway became a lifetime hobby for me. If you've enjoyed this video and some of the stuff that I'm talking about resonates with you and you're thinking, "Wow, I might like to try a historical board game." I've got a video, I'll put a link to it up there, that has best beginner war games. Some of these war games can get fairly complex, and these ones are hand-selected hand-picked by me and picked by me to be a good introduction to the hobby of historical board game. Thanks so much for watching.

Progress saved