Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 34:18

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Alone. And Brad and I are doing a discussion over the Dark Quarter, which was a game that we were highly anticipating uh for a while. Um because after the disappointing you know response of like Destiny's which was and because we had we like Van Rider Games, we like Lucky Duck. Um at that time neither of them could do any wrong. Uh both you and I really didn't like Destiny's. Uh but we were on the fence about this one for the same reason. But this was fully cooperative set in like this voodoo uh dark kind of gothic New Orleans. Yeah. a New Orleans setting, which is always a really cool setting. Um, that we eventually backed it and then it got delivered, then it was delayed because they the app wasn't uh wasn't finished.

Uh, but the app is finally released and this game is so boring. It it it's it's just it's so disappointing because God there's just there's nothing here. There's no substance uh of of gameplay. Uh we'll get to the app in a sec, but it just feels like a watered down Mansions of Madness. Well, I would say almost I mean watered down uh um Chronicles of Crime. Yeah. Cuz like at least you're doing something like you're looking at the crime scenes, questioning and stuff. You're figuring out you're trying to solve a a case.

This one you're doing that, but it's like you're just moving, rolling some dice, doing this and that and everything. So, it's like it takes that whole crime scene investigation out of it. or I mean note takingaking and stuff or like trying to figure out who to talk to. I mean yeah this game kind of has semblance of that but really literally all you are doing is I mean again like Destiny's the board means nothing like you have this top down view of New Orleans and it it it serves nothing. uh like it has you place these markers in whatever various locations that are just kind of there for whatever purpose of visual thing whenever. Again, it could just all be done in the goddamn app. Um but yeah, like you said, we take our miniature, pop it to somewhere we want to go, hit the button, and then you know, we have two dice, we roll, and we're like, "All right, I got six. I can You compare it to a stat sheet. I got two successes. Boom. Boom. Read something. Maybe you get an XP. Maybe you get an item. And you rinse repeat for Pete for like two and a half hours. So, which is funny because it makes you think it's like, well, you do that in who done it games. And I think honestly what makes those games such a success and what this game really fails to do is this writing. Yeah,

man. It is it is fourthwing Twilight teen cringe. Like it it literally has an adult rating on it. Um for the most like immature levels of crass. Yeah. Uh, this is like whenever someone like a teenager just figured out cussing and is trying to just they throw it in all over the place. It doesn't feel natural. It feels forced and cringy. Um, like the scenes that they put in here that are supposed to be edgy and like creepy are just hilarious, right?

So, and I mean I'm not saying I could do a better job, but I'm not touting myself as a writer, right? It's like so I'm not engrossed in this world in any way. Um the the characters that we have have barely any depth to them. Like it's like ah Julia's a vampire and she doesn't want to be. She's going to try and figure it out. Well, in your vampire thing, I think came to the forefront a little bit more. Like I used my getting drunk to talk to ghosts. What once? Yeah. I mean, so it was really kind of a Who knows? You talked to that little Asian girl. Was she a ghost though? We don't know. She said spectacularistly delicioso. Probably the one that went and killed that cop because she said she had to run and go do something real quick. Yeah. And you got to fix or do task or whatever favor with whatever it was. Um, the only time that we legitimately laughed was whenever I went and talked to the the big woman, Annie, and I was like, "I'll tell her a joke." And it was actually a funny joke, but then that same exact joke was repeated. Yeah, cuz I was I was telling the main the boss guy. It was the same thing. Yeah, it was the exact except he interrupted and it's like, "Oh, all the best jokes have dicks in them." And I'm like, "What? Who wrote this?" Like, who is is Evan? Raf Rafal it just it it's it's it's so it's painful honestly

like so the gameplay for it is virtually non-existent. Um the who done it I mean it's not even really who done it. It's just a narrative story um is not gripping in any way. So, like like for example, if you're going to have heavy narration, I mean, if you're not going to back it up with gameplay, then you got to have solid writing that it's like, okay, yeah, I don't really care about what I'm doing here cuz I'm so invested in the story. I I just could not have cared less. Well, the replayability is gonna suck because like if I was to play my copy of this where there would be differences with characters because like the one the guy we didn't choose. If I went to his house at that one location, it would be kind of interesting to see what came up. But like it's it's all coming to this point.

You're just pretty much trying to find this cemetery and go to that deal and it's like that's not going to change. Yeah. Yeah. Because it's not like one and stuff, right? It's not like Chronicles of Crime where you pick a scenario to try and solve. This one is just you pop open the app and then you start playing. Now, I mean, in terms of like like physical content, I mean, it's very clean. Um, but like you get very tired abilities. So, like yeah, you're picking some abilities, but it's like they're so basic. Oh, hey, you can reroll some dice. Ah, you got a success during questioning. Uh, and even like whenever I was reading the rules and originally learning it, I was like, "Oh, that's kind of cool. The characters will react to them and you know if you intimidate someone and they're not meant to be intimidated, you just kind of beat." But like you're not doing anything with that. It's just you click like half the time it's like cokes intimidate, drop the subject, cokes intimidate. It's like okay, I have I basically have two options cuz I'm not going to. So it's a 50/50 shot and then you like I'll intimidate. And it just goes, "Ow, that hurt." It's like, what is this? Resident Evil 1 voice acting. Oh, wait. No, there is no voice acting because they delayed this goddamn app to work on their [ __ ] free source saxophone jazz. Um, and in this day and age for a narrative heavy game, put some [ __ ] audio narration. Yeah, that is

it. it at this point it is archaic. Yeah. And unacceptable cuz companies with less money are doing more uh with apps or they're they're hiring foreller to do it. Yeah. Foreller would have that would have been a good one for this to all the stuff. Yeah. Because again the music well the music that they have on loop is I mean it sounds nice but like you had you had so many potentially colorful characters. this game. I would not be ragging on it as hard if they had voice actors. If like the the gravedigger you come across is actually speaking French. And I'm not over here sounding like a [ __ ] racist trying to speak French. Um or like if you actually were talking to, you know, what was it? Black Rex and Annie Christmas. It's like the the jive like if our characters who talk like or they have dialogue for them. If it was actually like a banter back and forth.

Yeah. I could excuse a lot of stuff because I could be invested, right? Nope. None of that. Why they delayed the app? It sure wasn't for app development. Still not completely. I mean, is there coming out for the later step? Oh, yay. Sure. That's gripping, right? Yeah. Maybe there'll be a big update. Maybe the when they release that, they'll be like, "Ah, we've been doing voice acting." Oh, yeah. You think they would announce that? Because like a a great example is right now I mentioned this in my Dawn of Madness review. I mean those things are novels and I mean if any game is heavily narration based and I have to do a lot of reading I'm I'm I'm less likely to play your game. Um but they just went on crowdfunding and that that was a whole big thing. All 18 books are being professionally narrated, which even they they were a small team of like three people who were trying to figure out whether they were going to do it in-house um to save money, of course, or if they were going to professionally do it. Well, they're going to outsource it to cuz it's like that's going to be amazing if it's done right. Not like Stars Vicarios where it's really bad or I think Dragon Eclipse even has some mess ups too. Um, but yeah, like there's so much reading and it's like if if if I'm not doing a good enough job to try and animate it and make it

entertaining for like you, right? Um, like imagine the straight ass reading like if I just like Yeah, it's it's it's just inexcusable. Um especially with just how delayed this was. We had this what for three months at least two I can't remember exactly when I got it but yeah like two or three months of just holding on to the physical copy which which is unplayable without the app and before people start you know screaming this is why apps shouldn't be in games. Shut the [ __ ] up. Um like I I fully support app integration in board games when it's done right. Yeah. Um, I would agree. But I mean, this is this is your this is your justification example of like, well, people had Dark Order for months and they couldn't play it. It's like, yeah, and then they get it and turns out the app didn't even matter because it's not even a good game with the app. I mean, I almost got no redeeming qualities, man. Like, I feel like the components are nice, but I mean, that's that's really But again, they're useless. It's like whenever we play Destinies and it's like, "Oh, I don't even need to touch the board." No, I'm not saying you, but I'm just meaning like just looking at it. It's It's dual boards well made. The art I mean the art is nice. The characters I mean Taylor Swift's hot. So, uh, Kurt Russell, Jeff Bridges over there. Jeff Russell, Kurt Bridges over there. Uh, and then the other two characters who don't I they don't look like anyone that I'm aware of. But I mean that must be the

replayability is like the story beats are going to be the same, but like the characters you play with. Same with Destiny's though. You picked a character and the story was the same. You you you picked a different character and it was the same, right? But in this it's like like I said like with the with the um uh John Robish show uh yeah I mean it was his house right like that like that that's a a good example that we could like go to or yeah I guess Destiny's a personal deal but the game you had different abilities I guess and so yeah this would be better in that Um, and I don't know, like it was funny because with Destiny's I felt like, oh, you opened up a quest that I could go and steal from you and it was like this stupid rock paper scissors of like, oh, I have this goal, but we might share the same goal. It was I hated it.

um that so it's like I would snipe quests, but here it almost felt the exact same way where it's like, yeah, we're playing cooperatively, but I'm over there doing my own thing, asking the same useless questions, but then you come across a bunch of evidence that it's like, oh, it's fine. It's my turn. I don't know what to do. Yeah. Like, at least you can't finish the quest without that I started. You know what I'm saying? Right. It it's not it's like a it's not a personal dig to you, but like narratively I want to stick within the theme and it's like cuz I I play D and D so much. It's like I don't want a meta. I don't want to be like, "Well, my character was over talking to the police officer. You're over here talking about talking to this bar owner getting information. Why am I all of a sudden like, "Oh, I know about the cemetery."

No, we don't. We have pagers. Oh, well, yeah. automatically. That's how I call me up on my Yeah, you page me and like I got to get to a to a a pay phone. What's that? But yeah, it just feels cheap. It feels like I'm again kind of stealing your moment where it's like, "Oh, I found all this evidence. I want to go figure that out." It's like, "Okay, I guess I'll try and do something else." And then you run out of options to do. It's like, "Okay, I guess I'll go there." Um, and then every check you do is rinse repeat. Like, oh, you get you got zero successes. Refresh an effort die. So, you get So, you basically get more dice to increase your value. So, you do the same check again. Then it's like, oh, all right. Now, you got some successes, right?

Okay, you got a new lead. Go talk to this person. Oh, man. Like this game was exhausting. Safe system was nice. The app we played what we played with the first through intermission another day and then we played through all this. Yes. And and we we kind of fudged it to get into get done with. But it's like we played a long time first scenario. Yeah. 4 hours and it's like four hours of just like let's just finish this to get to see what the experience was and then at the end of a scenario or chapter or whatever they call it they um they give you like an epilogue. So I mean it does have technically different endings. Uh each chapter is like a different ending but I couldn't I I don't care. It's like the Chronicles of Crime thing cuz it always tell remember at the end it would tell you if you did this. It would give you like the rundown like oh because you did this this if you oh you you know this person ended up being the one that did you know it kind of did the same thing. It's just a mish mishmash of another iteration of that whole thing with the Destiny. They kind of stuck with that and it really did surprise with Destiny's not I mean because it was really Destiny's was really popular when it came out. We were definitely in the minority but then I mean you can get it for dirt cheap now. Yeah. people came to their senses. Well, I know, but that's that's my that thing like this is not

that far off of it. So, yeah, I will say at least Destiny's worked when you got it. Yeah, cuz Van Rider I think is why this cuz if this was just Lucky Duck. Yeah, that wouldn't have been as popular. A lot of people were they were riding the Van Rider Final Girl thing like, "Oh yeah, they're horror riders. They're like, you know, Van Rider's kind of hot right now cuz they did Final Girl and all that stuff and they're hooking with Lucky Duck and all that stuff." And yeah, I should have listened to my intuition when I didn't back it this way. Well, yeah. And it's like whenever cuz yeah, you would think with Final Girl, oh, they're huge horror fans, which is I don't I'm not discrediting that. Um, but then you read the death cases, the campaigns of death in in those books, and that's that's pretty cheeky or campy at best. So like, and you were like, well, those are short blurbs. Benefit of the doubt on that.

Yeah. And they got to do hundreds of them for a bunch of different cards. and the the combinations of, you know, killer to scenario. And again, it's a lot of work, so you're not going to make it as gruesome as you possibly could be. Unfortunately, that's the same level of writing in here, except throwing a bunch of [ __ ] [ __ ] [ __ ] an elephant, just a lot of vulgar lot literally all all just And then, man, then you had like a moment out of nowhere with a guy named Frank. um that I was like, again, it has nothing to do with, you know, anything like that. It was just so like I was talking to a guy and then you go there. I was like, "Oh, maybe you can talk to him." The guy I was talking to was no longer there. Your left and Yeah.

then the new one came in and then it was just this weird awkward like almost forced um just scene that is like is this this is horror? This is hilarious. Um, found out something about myself. Yeah, it was funny and but then it's like but then it's just over. It's just like, all right, it's gone and it's like, what the [ __ ] was that? I bet those pop in like once per scenario probably cuz your your thing you were waiting on the thing I was waiting on. I bet second scenario they probably pop in, do something, and then they're gone until the third. Yeah. Like I mean, god forbid there's like an actual sex scene or something where it's like I meet up with my ex-boyfriend and it's like oh man cuz it was it was definitely there were there were getting some some moments of just I want to see how many scenarios are in it talking.

Probably three. It's it it it's just like the most basic level of of of romance that you would you would expect to see in like those romance novels that are critically acclaimed like the Fifty Shades of Gray stuff is is what is almost thrown in here. There's four four chapters and then additionally the Yesterday Demon and Other Stories expansion will be released in waves. So there's in this deal there's four in this main story. I mean, if you're just someone who really likes just content, like I guess I mean, it's here, but it's it just isn't fun for multiple people when one person is like reading because not everyone is a strong reader.

Not everyone likes to read out loud. I have Artisans of the Splender Veil that is sitting because that requires heavy reading and you almost have to have people who are animated with their reading and get into character. Oh, that game and this is boring as hell if you're just reading it straightfaced. Yeah. So, and I'm the only person Well, me and Devin are he's the only one that actually kind of reads and gets into it. Everyone else just reads it as is. And it's like, God, the the items and that you collect are basic and boring as hell. They all have QR codes on them. So, it's like I can scan this and it's like the Westworld doesn't look like anything to me. Yeah. Hey, what do you think about this? I don't know what I You think I give a [ __ ] eating grin about that?

What? This game also falls into like the Destiny's because, you know, you might as well just play it solo. Mhm. You know, and that's kind of the similar you could run two heroes on this and run it solo. And I can't even remember if you have to run two. I don't think you have to pick two characters really. Um Oh, no. When playing solo, the player must choose at least two characters. This ensures a balance and narrative cohesion. In general, there's nothing wrong with a single player controlling several characters. Okay, there you go. Did you know that there's nothing wrong with you you playing with two characters like a loser? Oh god, I want to keep I wish I wish I I wish I wrote some of the dialogue down just just to give clear examples. One lady said that tell me a joke or something that tell me a [ __ ] slapping joke. That's what she said. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. A joke that'll like that that'll tickle my [ __ ] or something. Something like that. It was which I mean we you know we we we cuss on this channel a lot and stuff like that. It's fine. But it's just still it's just throwing it out there just it's like oh we have a a mature rated game. We're just going to throw a bunch of [ __ ] out. That that's exactly it. Yeah, it it never feels like it's just a natural swearing. It it a lot of the stuff cuz like I've done this on many many occasions like whenever we're reading that I'll just randomly throw in something just to just to be funny. Um and every now and then I'll like get you like or I'll get someone where it's like is that actually in there? And it's like no. Uh it's always a proud moment of mine.

But most of the stuff that was in here, you're like, "Is that really there?" And I'm like, "Yes." Like, "This is not This is a a elementary school level of of writing here." Um, and honestly, that's the worst part. That that really is. I can forgive the app delay if they were like, "Hey, we're delaying it because the audio narration isn't ready." Um, I can forgive the basic gameplay. Uh, Dawn of Madness is a crazy example because that gameplay is actually uh involved, but Maners of Madness is the most involved game in the world, right? Uh, but I mean, you actually have pieces you're moving around, but you have you have spaces, you have enemies that you're doing stuff with. So, checks actually like there's a lot more going on than that.

But with levels like this, it's just when the world doesn't feel alive. um the the narrative game just, you know, falls flat. So, and I can't imagine it gets any better. No, I don't think so. Funny enough, whenever they kept saying like blinker, like for like people who aren't dead, I was like come like really like it's like that same [ __ ] with zombies whenever they got they got screamers and runners and it's like can you you can't say that's a that's not a trademarked word. You can say zombie. Nope. We got splinters and and creers. Shut up. Shamblers. Yeah. And it's like, ah, we got a casket girl. All right. I guess you got a casket girl. And then like with my character, she would like the way that she would talk to other characters and it's like, I think I'll fight her. And then it's like the easiest check in the world. And then it's like I just backhand her and I'm like, you [ __ ] [ __ ] Oh. Oh, God. It's It's It's exhausting.

It's so It's so bad. Oh, and I'm so sad. I wanted to like this. This is such a unique theme that's literally never touched on. Yeah. Yeah. Cuz I think this was on at least my most anticipated. And I don't know if it was on yours or not cuz I don't know if you put on this last one because it had been delayed so much. I think so. So, I think I've wanted to give games that had a chance of being delivered. Yeah. But I think I had it on mine. I know you had in the past cuz I think I had it for a couple years on that list. Yeah. Just because they sold it so well. Um, guess what? It's going to be on another list. Which one? I don't know yet. It could go on either one. I think it depends uh like how how we want to take it how many worst games there are that might overshadow it. throw this one into the into disappointing.

Um I I got I got nothing else. Like yeah, there's the Lost in the Night expansion. Don't care. Like Oh god. Just Just here. Basically do yourself a favor. Download the app. It's free. And just read through it. That's all you have to do. Like say you own the base game. go through the whole don't like again you don't need this the physical stuff literally doesn't matter I mean I guess you need like if you want to scan QR codes but uh again half the time you didn't have to do that right you can get away with just a check like again for example it's like when you have to open up a shed it's like oh you can brute force it see how many checks you get but if you had a crowbar or something you could have opened it using that right um but it's like okay so just like I mean yeah you if you need to scan an item you obviously They can't do that. But you can get through 95% of the game just saying you got just say five successes.

Every test five successes that's going to that's going to guarantee you like you're never even getting above that. Cuz I think the way they do the skill system is actually kind of I I initially liked it. I was like, "Oh, that's unique." You have these cubes that like you roll your dice and it's like, "Oh, I got a six. That's in my combat. I have two successes." Um, I actually prefer that over the standard Arkham Horror where it's like fives and sixes, right? Uh, yeah. So, that was that was actually unique. But just go and download the app and read and read through it and if you're if you're maybe having a bad day at work and you want a good laugh, uh, I got a good joke for you. Hey, it that that that joke which I'm pretty sure I have heard somewhere at some point um was was actually genuinely funny. Um and then of course I ruined it by doing the exact same joke.

Uh yeah, I don't know. Like Well, Brad, on a scale of 1 to 10, how hot is Taylor Swift? How hot is Julia Paris, who is very clearly model? I I like vampires. Yeah. Like I was getting like underworld like not even not even the first or second underworld. I was getting the bad underworld uh movie vibes. Got the Lykan War or whatever the Yeah. Well, there was Yeah, cuz then there was like two more after that one. That one is even somewhat passable. That was decent. But yeah, the other two after that are really bad whenever uh it's like her kid. Yeah, those are those are awful. Uh, that's the kind of vampire vibe I was getting. Um, it just didn't hit. Yep.

What are you giving it scale of 1 to 10? A three. Yep. Three. I just can't. It's a three for how many months it or a point for how many months it was delayed. Well, it's just there's just there's nothing like I don't know. There there's just nothing like the re the replayability. It hurts too because even if like there's just not, you know, like there's no way for I'm going to go and do but you can't skip scenarios, right? So like if I was going to try to go through this, I would have to fudge my way through the entire 4hour first scenario. Yeah. Just to get to new stuff. And it's like there's no not going to change a whole lot. I mean like you said, there's some character changes. Yeah. I mean depending on how well you like succeed in the finale will change or different I mean you do make decisions you do but um but they they stress so hard about like the time decisions you have oh you can play it on extreme timer mode uh which is the way it's supposed to be played happen like what five times a scenario yeah maybe you have so much time it's like 30 seconds and it's like you it they made it sound like it was going to be like snap decisions where it's like oh man this could impact my whole character uh and one and I get it you have to have to read. Like they can't have it be 4 seconds where it's like I couldn't even read that, right? But so you read it and then those choices are so lame of like ah do you tell him about his brother or do you

not? It's like I don't I don't care. Sure. I I tell him. And then whenever you even made that decision, nothing even happened. It was like h I can actually tell you about your we got to go. Okay. Goodbye winter. I'll see you later. Yeah. And it's like, oh, okay, winter will remember this later. It's like, oh, yeah. So, yeah, I'm going with a a solid three. Very solid three. Um, yeah. You know, I think I might I might go lower. I think I'm going to go with two there. I thought I was going to be the low one on it. Yeah. Well, here's the thing is like I really really dislike the writing um in this narrative 90% narrative game. I don't like the fact that it was delayed for no significant reason except if their excuse was to they had to put in the horrible writing. If I would have been reading it might have been a two. I didn't have to read any of it. I read all of it. That's why I did three. And I tried I tried my best to make it entertaining. I ran out of voices. I ran out of energy um that I just didn't give a [ __ ] This would get this would actually probably I kid you not hit a five if it had audio narration. I could at least somewhat get into it. Yeah.

Yeah. I think so too. It was just I don't know. It's Yeah. You were reading some of those deals and I was just like this. And then it's like and then whenever it does present you with choices, it's the same [ __ ] thing. Cokes intimidate nothing. Oh, I guess I'll intimidate him. Ow, that hurt. Or what do you think? Get the [ __ ] out of my face, you blink eyed sinner. What? I don't even know what's happening anymore. Um, and it's like I and I even told you, man, that A rating makes me nervous because they can go one of two ways. they could be very clever with how they're going to handle mature content. Um, or they're going to go really cringe and bad. Unfortunately, it's the latter.

Um, so there's that. There's the fact that it was delayed. Uh, so I had to wait on it for this uh for an experience like this. um the the content or the the actual components are are useless except for the QR codes which you sometimes need and even whenever you try to use them in a clever way it's not even worth worth anything. Uh and then like you you spend two to three hours on a scenario. I I promise you you pick a location, you roll your same two dice and then maybe an effort die. I refresh an effort die. Do a check. Didn't get anything. All right, next time I get more dice. Go to the same thing. Boom. Oh, now I got some successes. Read. End of turn. Your turn. Move. Same.

Everyone's doing the exact same thing. Yep. So, it's just it's such a waste of time. And I feel bad. I feel bad. Like I I want to say and I've made this I made this same comment in past reviews. It's it's like with the rise of AI, it just feels like Mhm. I would have taken Siri's voice or or reading the [ __ ] thing. Like you know what I you know what I probably need to do and know that would be way too much work than this game deserves, but it's like man whenever pops up see if chat GPT can read it to me or something. which is probably how they got the writing done. So, it's it's just I mean I know I know obviously a two is like way like way too low.

Like it it's not a one because you can technically play it. Um there's just so many other factors that really make this just not worth it for me in any way. Um so yeah, that's it. You anything else? Well, that's our thoughts on The Dark Quarter. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching, and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon, and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other runthroughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved