Skip to main content
Loading video...

Hobbycast Episode 14: Top 50 Postmortem, and 4 brief negative reviews

Transcript 28:20

hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive hobbycast i hope you are doing well and if you're not i hope you are soon okay so on this episode of the hobbycast we are going to be doing a little kind of a top 50 post mortem if you guys remember back uh towards the earlier part of this year of 2022 i did the first ever dungeon dive top 50 dungeon dive and adventure games list we're going to be talking briefly about that i'm going to answer a couple questions i've had people responding to that top 50 ask me like where is game x what happened how come this game isn't on the list we're gonna talk a little bit about that and that section is actually going to include three brief negative reviews for three big games that were not on my list and then talk a little bit about some a few games that i possibly overlooked at least um at least all three of these should probably should probably have been included in the top 50 and for some reason they just weren't so let's uh quickly do a recap of the top 50. i'm just going to go through and read the list from number 50 to number one so i'll see number 50 is roon bound third edition and then we have 49 with dungeoneer tomb of the lich lord 48 aftermath 47 fallout with the atomic bombs expansion

45 shadows of malice or 46 shadows of malice 45 lord of the rings journeys in middle earth uh 44 advanced hero quest 43 assault on doomrock 42 tomb 41 warhammer quest blackstone fortress 40 dungeon universalis 39 ether fields 38 folklore of the affliction with the fall of uh the spider expansion 37 dungeon run 36 legacy of dragon hold 35 tales of the arabian knights 34 prophecy 33 space hulk 32 mini rogue 31 space cadets 30 secret unknown stuff escaped from dulce 29 fortune and glory the cliffhanger game 28 runebound second edition 27 and dungeon crusade book one genesis of evil 26 for against darkness uh speaking of four against darkness i have a bunch of books out on the table right now because we are going to be returning to the four against darkness series uh uh next week uh 25 hellboy the board game 24 24 darkness night second edition 23 rogue dungeon 22 warhammer quest shadows over hammer hall 21 a touch of evil the supernatural game 20 eldritch horror 19 wander the cult of barnacle bay 18 zaya legends of a drift system

17 is d100 dungeon with the world builder expansion 16 and dark light memento mori 15 cthulhu death may die 14 mansions of madness 2nd edition 13 dungeon degenerates the hand of doom 12 quest for the lost pixel 11 kingdom death monster 20 dungeon are 10 dungeon quest nine talisman eight shadows of brimstone seven escape the dark castle six explore it the valley of the dead king five machina arcana i'm gonna say third edition now since that has come out since i did the uh did the list four sleeping gods three warhammer quest silver tower two warhammer quest ogd and number one secrets of the lost tomb overall i'm still pretty happy with that top 50. um in the first video i explained the way i did it is i just went to pub meeple and used their comparison algorithm thing where it you get it you get two games and you and i choose one to over the other game and it puts them in a list i think i put in about 100 150 or so games somewhere around there i don't remember the exact number i don't have that original list and i just went through very quickly kind of off the cuff you know uh didn't think about it too much as which game would i want to play uh between those two games and i built the list like that and i didn't reorder anything after the game so if i were to put in that same grouping of games that same 150 or so games and do the same comparison today

a lot of these would might be in different orders especially the ones uh out of the top ten the top ten are kind of solidified um at least for now but um overall i'm pretty happy with the list there are a few that maybe one for sure shouldn't be on the list i already talked about this one during the top 50 and that was number 42 tomb whenever i think about tomb i think of it in terms of its kind of its potential it's a game that i think has a lot of potential which is kind of odd because that potential has not yet been fully realized after the game has already been out for like what 15 years or so um ah there's so much cool stuff in tomb so many cards with just tons and tons of unique art i did recently do an art of tomb video just showcasing all of the great cool looking art in that game but just the the fact is this the game is not that great it needs a lot of help and every time i get close to kind of developing a cool solo mode for the game something else just comes up and it just doesn't quite work so in you know factually tomb should not be on a top 50 so i would definitely remove that another game i might remove is a fallout with the atomic bonds expansion it would probably drop just below the top 50. it's still good i still really like it i definitely like

it a lot more than some people but i wanted to make room for a few others and another one is a room bound third edition um i like third edition it would still be in like a top 100 but uh second edition i like a lot more and i think there is room for these three games that i possibly overlooked and i'm not sure how i overlook these i'm not sure maybe i just forgot to include these in the basic uh in the the overall list where i was comparing but somehow these three games failed to make it on the list and i think they should be and those three games are walking dead here's negan um hand of fate or deals and fallen lands i'm really surprised fallen lance didn't end up on the list i think i think maybe because i put the game kind of completely out of my mind while waiting for the second edition and the new big expansion that was supposed to deliver last summer uh they seem to be pretty behind that's fine it's a kickstarter that's to be expected so maybe i i've been wanting to replay fallen lance but i've kind of just been kind of uh waiting for the next edition to come out because it's going to i think it's going to make things a little bit easier to manage and it's going to add a lot of cool more more cool encounters as if that game needs more encounters uh if you like random encounters and you like pretty in-depth random encounters that include combat and non-combat elements

falling little hands is pretty dang cool um hand of fate or deals that's a game that kind of saw the dungeon dive bump a little bit when i did my revisit of that game a lot of people were going out and trying to find it and and the the prices of that game have really started to skyrocket second hand especially for the uh the expansion so that's a really great game i like the endless mode i talked about it in my last video for that game it has that kind of endless a rogue-like mode and uh really a really cool game with a great look and all kinds of clever mechanisms and it it really does feel like an adventure game and a good solid dungeon uh deck building game combined a really really great game and that i'm pretty sure that should be in my top 50 because it is kind of that idiosyncratic game that just appeals to me possibly a lot more than it appeals to other other gamers and so i really do think that should be on that list and walking dead here's negan um talk about an underrated game it's so underrated that i forgot about it that game is really good you know whenever i talk about space hulk i often lament that it doesn't have a really good solid official um solo mode but here's negan really is a solo space hulk it gives me that same kind of tension it's got very simple mechanisms that rarely get in the way it's got that really cool cool thing about how negan

is this force of chaos that is neither good nor bad but he can really help you or really hinder your progress through the game all depending on his his mood and his whims and that's so much like that character it just does a fantastic job and i'm not a huge like i said in my review for that i need to redo my review for that um watching some of my older reviews lately i really uh i think my i think my delivery has improved a little a little bit i would hope so but i'm not very happy with my with my video for walking dead here's negan i i think i need to revisit it and uh do that game justice because that game is really it's really really good so uh those were the three games that i possibly overlooked walking dead here's negan hand of fate or deals in a fallen lands and now a couple people have asked me why these games weren't on the list and that is let's see the first one is arkham horror third edition so i really do like third edition but the last time i played it one thing really bothered me and that was the map i don't i really don't like the way the map is constructed and more importantly i don't like the way the map looks i'm not a big fan of that putting together those tiles and this kind of like node system it just doesn't look like a city and it adds this

it adds this extra step to the setup that doesn't add anything to the gameplay and so when now when i'm thinking about playing arkham horror third edition even though i really like the way the the questing evolves i love the gameplay i like its streamlined nature and i like the way the game makes me feel when i think about having to set up that map i'm kind of like uh i'll just play elder tour because the map is already set up even though with that game also i wish the map was like half the size seems like ffg and their arkham file games they have a problem with me with the maps the boards like just making them right neither the right size or the east so so yeah i'm not that is probably why arkham horror third edition did not make it on my list just because that that kind of that negative feeling of setting up the map and just the way the map looks it doesn't look like a city it looks like some weird kind of like sci-fi dome structure or something i don't know i still really like the game and i still really want to play it more often i just i just need to get over that i guess about the map um another one people asked me about was dark venture um dark venture it's just a game i don't play that often and it is i think kind of a long game and there are some elements about the game that that do kind of weigh it down a little bit because it does have that huge big box fill in such a small box and i recently

talked about this game on my comparison of the uh of the science fiction small box games and that big box feel of dark venture is kind of a double-edged sword because while it does give you this grand epic experience you also have to deal with that grand epic experience so it's just not a game that i play a lot of i would like to play more i'm hoping that the second edition kind of smooths over some of those edges i know uh rob lemon is incorporating some of my solo house rules into the base game he's doing some other things to tweak it to where the game some of the setup of the npcs is a little shorter so you should be able to get through a game a little quicker uh the same thing is happening of course without roger on dungeon crusade really looking forward to the new rewritten uh crusaders handbook for that and the true like lone wolf solo mode and the um the new minion combat mode uh once all of that stuff gets officially put into the rulebook i am definitely going to dive back into dungeon crusade a lot because i think that's going to really speed up the game and make the game better i think and i'm hoping the same thing happens for dark venture because it is a game that i really like um i especially like the look of it it looks incredible it has amazing art and um speaking of that i need to contact rob lemon about possibly doing a commissioned piece of artwork for the uh dungeon dive or a t-shirt that just came to me i can't believe i haven't thought of that before

so all right well uh we'll see what he says about that um let's see somebody else ask me about legends untold and uh yeah legends are told that's just one that i don't play and not a lot of it's a really good game and i've been i have been thinking about it more in the last few weeks i've been wanting to get it back to the table and so i think i will and i know they're supposedly releasing like the next set of those games to add the next kind of step in the development of the heroes and the difficulty so that might be a really good time to revisit it and i do like the game but it's just it's another one i just don't play enough of to really include it into a top 50. and somebody also asked me about popper's ladder because i'm pretty high on that game i'm impatiently waiting for the new expansion the moon towers expansion which just looks like it adds so much cool stuff to the game that is one that i am going to play a lot of and poppers ladder is one that i could see you know the next time i do this list it working its way into that game it's just such a pleasant effortlessly fun game and i am all about effortless fun these days when it comes to my board games um just it's a such a charming delightful little game i absolutely love it and i'm going to be doing a playthrough i think of the game because it's totally my speed i can do a play through with probably only uh 50 mistakes instead of

100 because because the game's easy but i do want to show off the moon towers expansion when it comes in okay so now it's time for three negative reviews because the big three there are three like huge giant super uber popular uh dungeon crawl board games that were you know people were like where are these games actually there's four maybe we'll do four um yeah so that was i didn't think of this other fourth one but i know people have asked me i guess people have stopped asking me about the fourth one because um it's just not my kind of game but those four games are madara bloomhaven sword and sorcery and mageknight those four games i think most people who really really are in two dungeon crawl games adventure games most people would probably put those four games in their top ten especially people who are into solo games often put mage knight and as their number one solo game of all time people absolutely love madara and greenbaby and sword and sorcery and they're not even my top 50.

i don't even own any of these four games i probably wouldn't put any of them in my top 200 gloomhaven jaws of the lion might make it in a top 100. just based on the fact that it's it's just let's talk about gloomhaven gloomhaven i respect the crap out of it is a very very well made board game and i wish i was into it because for the price i had gloomhaven and i paid like a hundred dollars for it it has so much content so much thought and creativity went into making the game i wish i loved it because it would offer me so much gameplay and all fits in one box just yet a very very well designed game but one that i just i don't have any fun playing it and one of the the main reasons is how you have to discard your cards while you are playing the game because glue haven has this like inverse excitement uh curve to it where the first few turns are super fun because you have all these possibilities you have like these great things that your your hero can do but each time you rest you have to burn through one of those cards and so by the end by the last few turns of a dungeon the last few turns are super boring because you've already done all of your cool things and you can't do cool things anymore and so your heroes become less

heroic the more time you spend in a dungeon and i don't like that that is it it just it's it's like the exact opposite thing that i want to see you know i was thinking of like uh you know in the the lord of the rings the fellowship of the ring the the first movie from peter jackson when they're in the minds of moria and you know they're uh they finally escaped and or they're they're about to escape and the ball rock comes and you know they have to make those those heroic leaps over that that crumbling um architecture and imagine if like they were like ah sorry i've already done my heroic leap for this dungeon can't make it that's kind of like what happens in loomhaven is and i get it you're supposed to have this trade-off it's supposed to be this uh these um you know your actions are it's an economy of actions but it just doesn't end up being fun for me i also don't like the semi-co-op nature of the game how you can't share gold and that could be because i was not having a good time with the group i was playing with because i was playing this kind of like slow character and everyone else was much quicker so they were going around and hoovering up all the gold and i was like hey uh can i get some golden well try to get to the gold and you can have some but i was like taking care of all the monsters for them i did not like that at all and i also don't like how the weapons and armor are all like one use basically you use them like items and they don't just stay equipped i know sometimes you can flip them back

over and use them multiple times and i just recently there was a game i think it was at dungeons of doria where you could use your armor but then you had to take time to repair it that's cool that's a little thematic but in gloomhaven the weapons and armor are more just like one use items that you can use one time per game and that just that's not fun either so for me a lot of the elements of gloomhaven just constantly kind of got in the way of the fun and it felt more like work and i did not enjoy that madara madora is a game that i think the core mechanisms are fantastic i think the dice pool system is cool tons of loot lots of things to discover it's got a bright colorful world with a lot of backstory it has all kinds of great things i love anime it's got that anime looking vibe to it but um i don't want to read a novel while i'm playing a board game when i want to read a novel i've got a thousand novels to read and when i want to read a novel i will sit down and read a novel um the the amount of story that you have to read just to play gloom haven is way too much it's kind of like a uh you know metal gear solid uh three or or or four where it's like three hours of cut scene for every one hour of game or something like that and there were multiple times when i was playing with my group where we would get together to play and we would read almost as much

at times we would spend as much time reading as you would playing the game and none of us were really into the story or the characters and i also don't like how the game um it forces your characters down certain paths because your characters act in the story a certain way so i never really felt like i was playing my character i felt like i was living this life of a character who was already created and was already living its life you know my character when i was playing would say things in the story or do things that that's not the way i would have handled it and i'm playing that character so i don't want to see my character act in a way that that i didn't like and a lot of that does have to do with that kind of japanese rpg inspiration for that game because a lot of japanese style video games they feature things in cut scenes that you cannot do in the game and i hate that i despise cut scenes in which your hero is super heroic or does amazing things but when it comes time to playing the game you can't do any of those things it's this kind of uh this disconnect decide what are they uh pluto narrative dissonance or something like that where what i'm seeing doesn't reflect the gameplay and i felt like that in medara constantly you know my character would say something while i was reading i was like well i wouldn't play it like that and so it's not really my character i never really felt an attachment i also didn't like and this was the same thing with um

uh secrets of the lost station the follow-up the secrets of the lost tomb i don't like how the game governed what you were able to get in terms of a loot the loot deck was really boring in madara i never liked opening chess because it was always just some gold and that was pretty boring and i didn't like how the game divvied out the loot and this the drops weren't enough for me and it kind of seemed like this it was so tightly balanced that i never really felt like i was getting more powerful because every time i would get something new since the game told me when i could get something new the enemies or the scenario would also get something uh new at the same level to where it just kind of felt like we were constantly at this same level just with new stuff and you know i like a game like secrets of the lost tomb or warhammer quest the the og where you can you have the chance to get a super powerful weapon like on your first turn you might get lucky on a draw and then you can be overpowered for a long time and i like that feeling in the game and madara just never gave me that um and then sword and sorcery uh sword and sorcery i don't like anything about that game i feel like it's so on rails that i just never really felt like i was experiencing a sense of adventure uh i do i do not like the writing at all i don't like those anachronisms some of the the pop culture references i think there's like a reference to siri

cortana like just in the these weird interjections of anachronistic humor and pop culture references just did absolutely nothing for me i thought that the ai for the enemies was way over convoluted for no reason it didn't really add any kind of like excitement to the game for me it just made it really really difficult to play um there were just an abundance of of icons you know i've never seen more icons until um tiny epic tiny epic dungeons came out and now i think that game is the king of icons um but sort of and the the characters i just i never really liked any i only had i had the bass kickstarter the first kickstarter and i just never really felt like any of the characters were very fun to play i would look at their powers when i was able to level up and have two choices and a good game will always give you two great choices to write oh man i really want both of these a bad game will give you you know one great choice and one lame choice where it's like well it's obvious you're gonna choose this choice in sword and source you just kind of for me just kind of gave me two choices i was like yeah i don't really want either of them so i guess i'll pick this one but yeah there's a i don't like the way the maps look the weird shape of the tiles it just it didn't look like anything on the table um and i just i never really felt like i was doing anything in the game except

following this really strict path down this uh scenario it didn't offer any kind of exploration or or um or sense of discovery for me and so that is why uh sword and source yeah i do not like that game at all and uh mage knight mage knight is kind of similar to gloomhaven it's a game that i respect but i don't like and i just don't find it fun it's so balanced i should probably do a video sometime on balance and i think balance is another word for boring i know some gamers a lot of modern gamers really don't like swinging luck in their games but for me swingy luck is us is synonymous with excitement and balance is synonymous with boring uh gloomhaven is incredibly balanced it often comes down to the last few turns if you're going to win or not and i don't like that um in this kind of adventure game you know because if you make one little mistake you're done and there's really no chance to come back from it and and uh mage knight is very mathematical but it also has a great sense of this kind of epic narrative to it and you get a complete epic experience in one game so i really respect that a lot the components are beautiful it looks great i love the way mage knight looks i wish i liked mage knight more than i did uh i wish i liked to major tonight a little bit even if i liked it a little bit it would be in my collection because it would be one of those kind of like once a year

games uh it would never be a regular rotation game for me unless they came out with some kind of a simpleton version of mage night maybe they'll come up with um like mage knight jr that and that might be uh that might be a game uh more my speed so uh so yeah so that was just some uh quick negative reviews i don't do a lot of negative reviews on the dungeon dive i am going to do one coming up soon probably for two gamecrafter games two very very expensive game crafter games that probably shouldn't even be on sale so we'll do that soon but yeah i did want to revisit my top 50 and talk about those few games of where are they talk about a few games that i overlooked and just kind of revisit my top 50 i'm i'm still pretty happy with the top 50. you know most every game in this top 50 except for the ones i mentioned before i would probably play it at any time and um yeah so that's it i hope you guys enjoyed this video and or this uh if you're watching the video or listening to the audio i hope you enjoyed this podcast and we will talk to you later bye you

Progress saved