Scythe Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to chairman of the board today I'm talking about scythe which is a 1 to 5 player economical area control euro style game it does have kind of elements of like a mirror thrash kind of mechanisms in there as well but mostly a kind of Euro style game by Stowe Maier games this game came out quite a few years ago now you know three four years ago to tremendous hype and had a tremendously successful Kickstarter campaign and this is actually surprisingly has kind of kept its hype and kept its critical acclaim since then and it's been consistently doing well in kind of reviews and it's actually in the top ten of BoardGameGeek rankings so tremendously successful and I'm a that had me very intrigued to try it out for myself I like euro style games so again very very intrigued to get this to the table I play this a few times now and I have to say I'm very impressed with a it's a very solid design a lot of kind of tried and tested tested kind of mechanisms in there but some new spins on it as well and that's those kind of that new the new things that I put into the game is what I think is kind of taking it taking the game into that upper echelon of games because on a whole the game isn't really anything you know completely you know outstanding in my opinion it has a lot of things that you'd expect from Euro games got the area control side of
things it's got kind of managing your resources as you'd expect but the kind of USP about this game is the the engine building side of things because every player has got their own kind of player board and as you go throughout the game clicking these resources you can buy upgrades to your board and you're basically making things cheaper to get better rewards by doing it and it works so so well that's very intuitive these player boards are very well designed and it's just good as you as you improve things things getting cheaper you getting more efficient you're getting faster and it just it works very well it's great there's quite a bit to this game it's quite well it's not fiddly in places but there's quite a lot to it but consumerist quite a lot - it is quite intuitive and it moves very quickly very little downtime in this game basically you're gonna choose an action perform the action and then you can you've got the option of kind of trading in resources to get like an upgrade or something but as you go into that second part of the game the plate can continue around the table so you can kind of get on with your own turn while someone else is carrying on the game the flow of the game so a very good amount of uptime here and it takes along very nicely let's get back to the theme at a minute so this game is kind of set it's like 1920s alternate universe in universe like this kind of war-torn country where they've got this huge mech so it was real kind of juxtaposition of the 1920s with these huge machines and it just the artwork that kind of accompanies the
game is absolutely phenomenal beautiful games to look at the board is really nice huge huge board the player the the player boards are very clear and nice to look at but the artwork of the cards and it's wonderful it really is like it's not like board game eyes like proper like works of art you would expect to see on a wall and I actually think the the artwork was kind of made before the game and the kind of the artwork inspired the game and you can really see that because the artwork is out of this world beautiful absolutely beautiful very kind of fascinating and interesting so anyway yeah let's go back to the game so there's a lot I like about this game so I really liked the victory conditions of the game or the endgame conditions because you've got these kind of ten criteria such as like getting a certain amount of upgrades or getting your mechs onto the board or getting all your workers out or you know getting all your what other things I lots of stuff at that such as winning fights and stuff like that so you've got to kind of perform six of these criteria and once someone does it kind of triggers the end game and I really like that kind of race the race field of the game because everyone's kind of trying to be as efficient as possible - to trigger their endgame mechanism so they've kind of fulfilled more objectives compared to everyone else but it also uses something that I generally like in games . erm a lot of my favorite games use it such as all the arms and
and Concordia where you get these kind of multipliers so basically while you're trying to fulfill these different objectives and control these different regions on the board and generate as much resource as possible you're also going to be going up this kind of track on the board like it's like a popularity track and the higher you get up that track means the higher kind of endgame points are going to get in relation to those three criteria it's a mechanism that I really enjoy and this does do it very very well that it kind of works in a weird way because in this kind of theme you'd expect there to be a lot more kind of confrontation and war than what there is and I have to say the kind of the conflict in this game it's actually quite muted there's not a lot there because people are going to be trying to build up their military strength in order to get one of those one of those six criteria before they actually start initiating the fights it's kind of it's kind of a bit weird in that way it kind of has a bit of a disjointed feel to it and it all of a sudden people will start fighting towards the end of the game but no big deal now I don't really like fighting in neuro games at all anyway it's not what you'd expect so no no bother for me there loads of decisions to make here you just you want to try and venture into these new areas on the board you're going to be racing to the factory in the middle of the board which kind of can give you an additional kind of action space on your own unique player board that you can
take and some of these are very very powerful so there is that room race to get to the center to get a first pick of those factory cards I like that kind of tension of everyone trying to race there and probably getting into a fight on the way there's yeah obviously there's the the way you kind of are producing you're kind of your workers produced goods on their different tiles and basically the more and more workers you get out which obviously means you can generate resources means each time you produce you have to pay a bit of a fine such as like popularity or lose some military strength so there's a bit of a pushing for there you got to kind of weigh up the benefits and and you know decide if the sacrifice is worth the resources you're going to generate I really like that decision and again the engine building is what really makes this special for me and I'll still like to be talking all day about this but I just have to say it's very intuitive very ingenious and what makes this game unique I do have a few concerns about the game basically each faction does have a unique power or a maker like a player ability and I must have it the first couple of times I played this I was not really too fussed about it but I played this again the kind of imbalance between the faction kind of became a bit more apparent to me again I've not played this a bucketload of times I've under five times but it's just kind of something I have in the back of my head and they'll be interesting to actually hear from you guys if you have had an issue with the
kind of balance between the factions because that is something that's quite important to me and if there is like clearly a discrepancy in the power to these faction that is something reap it me off the game but again more more plays will will tell you know time will tell on that thing yeah the mechanisms of the game very intuitive you just take one of your player actions and do what do what it says and the play will constantly flow around the table you can choose to activate that second ability if you want to to try and get the upgrades trying to fulfill those endgame criteria it's a very quick moving game as I said the the downtime in this game is absolutely amazing really or what uptime I should say considering the nature of the game but at the same time that does work against it in a way for me because I am sure be kind of so sure in a way and this one everyone's so kind of fixed on their own player board and the play goes round so quickly and you're focusing on your own board so much that like it's complete silence around the table everyone's got the heads down getting on with it dun dun dun dun dun dun dun and it kind of becomes very kind of sterile and very multiplayer solitaire that's not something that really bothers me but I like a bit of social interaction and apart from kind of blocking spaces and maybe you know having an odd scuffle with players there's not really much interaction between the players here at all so that side of things doesn't
really bother me but the the kind of the fact that players are kind of generally automatically assumed we're not assume but the natural catcher aliy don't really communicate much during the game there's a bit of a a bit of a kind of you know negative for me but that's just something that's that I've noticed as as time as more plays I plays I've played the game sorry but also some like some way our mates have said the same thing as well it's like very very silence you don't talk at all you just kind of get on with it replayability here you've got the different factions you've got I guess you've got different strategies you can take you know going down different routes to try and see what you're going to focus on first different players sort of different factions going to have different kind of focuses I think some of the about one of the factions isn't capture only winning two fights because basically normally two of those ten criteria is winning a winning a battle but one of the one of the factions can fight as many times as they want and get stars that way so that makes kind of their strategy a bit different so you've got a bit of variability there there's some more expansions out for this as well which I'll probably review down the line but at the moment I'm just sticking at the at the base game so there's there's a good amount of replayability here let's have a look I've covered kind of covered player interaction aesthetically as I said absolutely stunning to look at the the plastic miniatures to come in the game they're
not the best but they're certainly up to scratch and they look all right comparative quality overall really good nice chunky board nice chunky pieces you've got the wooden pieces you've got the plastic pieces you've got nice coins and Orsi cardboard coins but I'm talking about the standard retail edition here anyway not the not the kickstart exclusive stuff that's certainly a great kind of retail package here and pretty fairly priced as well for the amount of game you'll get ting theme of the game I really like it I think it's a very kind of very unique theme the the artwork is very striking as I said that that kind of throw back into the 1920s but with these huge mechs just it just has this real kind of unique feel to the game and I do like that a lot set up no real issue here you know pretty much pretty much what you expect with a game of this nature so no issues there either so overall I must say that I do enjoy the game and I'll certainly be playing it more down the line but I'm kind of struggling to see what sets this apart so much from other games of this type and bigger tomorrow is very very solid and way up there definitely a top we know 100 game for me but the fact that it is in the top 10 of working geek is a bit kind of I don't know I just don't quite get it I mean for me a game like Concordia is it has the edge on it and I'll expect to see that in the top 10 and maybe this one switched places in the rankings but
I don't know it must be something about it maybe it's not so dry as games like Concordia and stuff of that but overall yeah a very solid game one that I can certainly understand why it's so popular you've got lots of different things to try looks great plays nice and smoothly and lots to think about but not being too brain burner e because you've you know you are limited to those few actions and the engine building and it is very clever and what is what makes this unique as I said so I you know I love the things that you can focus on like getting upgrades for your playable so when other players take that action you get a bonus as well so again another way to keep you engaged and great amount over uptime plays pretty succinctly you know you're gonna get a game played in under two hours and yeah overall a really decent quality game one that I'll be playing more down the line and yeah overall I enjoy the game so that's my review of scythe I hope you enjoyed the review and it is what it is if you have enjoyed the videos please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos to read one else I'll see next time on chairman of the board by