Graphic Design for Board Game Designers!
Transcript
hi I'm Adam Porter I'm a board game designer from Wales and on this channel I very frequently talk about board game design now when we talk about design uh in in the board game industry what we're tending to talk about is creating the rules creating the rule sets so that's kind of my job but there's this whole other area of design that's about the graphics right graphic design and that's somewhere where I have very little experience apart from my own sort of self-learned uh experience from making lots of prototypes over the years and kind of seeing for s what works and what doesn't work now I've been aware of this designer uh Daniel soless for many years and when I say designer for Daniel I'm talking game designer and graphic designer and he's written a book called graphic design for board games so I reached out to Daniel specifically to ask if he could possibly send me a review copy and he put me in touch with the Publishers and they did so I've had this uh this complimentary copy of graphic design for board games and I've learned so much from it which I knew I would this is why I reached out to Daniel in the first place because I knew that he's an expert a master in this particular field and I know that because I've played some of his games and also because I've read this previous book which is also by CRC press this was not a review copy this one I actually purchased um at Great cost I should say this is an expensive book uh the building box of tabletop game design and Encyclopedia of mechanisms by Jeff engelstein and Isaac shv now this is an EXC excellent book about all the
different sort of mechanisms that are out there in the board game world and it breaks them down into types and so on but the book is full of um illustrations uh detailed diagrams and icons for the various different mechanisms and these illustrations are all done by Daniel soless that I mean they're excellent they they illustrate what can be done with icons and diagrams and they were one of my favorite parts of the book um but I also knew Daniel from his games uh specifically the games kadama which is this beautiful game where you're laying out cards to make trees and you got these little Fantastical creatures fairy type creatures and things in it um really graphically appealing game but also the game Trickster uh which Daniel actually contacted me and sent me a review copy for a number of years ago when he saw my video about trick taking games so trickster is a a game an unusual trick-taking game where the second card that is played into a trick kind of changes the rules for everybody else playing into trick and every individual card has loads of different special abilities on it this isn't a review of the games of Daniel soless this is a review of his book so we'll stick on this graphic design for board games um I found this fascinating this book I I don't know how to review a a book I've reviewed many board games over the years I've never really reviewed a book so I'm just going to ramble on about it right at the start of the book it talks a lot about typography that sounds really dull doesn't it it's not it's fascinating okay I'd never really um thought about typography in any great detail I kind of
knew that some games I look at them and I don't like the font right particularly old games like for example um the game archaeology the card game I've got in my collection where it doesn't really matter how good the artwork is and frankly it's not good uh not in this particular Edition but the the the font is terrible as well and it just makes the whole thing look cheap and old and the same thing with uh Aladdin's dragons this little card game I've got here again the font just seems you know badly Chosen and and and not thought through and it doesn't serve the game at all it makes the whole thing look quite amateurish if you look at very modern games much more recent games most of them are pretty slick actually with their font choices but this word kept coming up in this book about serif right serif fonts and Son serif fonts now I've heard this word before but it's not actually something that I understood I didn't know what it meant I've just heard the word or seen it in words Pro word processes but serif means the little little flowery bits that come off letters right so if you're using Times New Roman font you've got all these little flowery bits that come off the edge of the letters whereas if you're using Ariel or hel helvetica or I don't even know how to pronounce all of these fonts because I've only ever seen them written down but if you're using those sorts of fonts there's no flowery bits it's straight down to business just the letter and so on and I've never really thought about when I might use one of those fonts and when I might might use the other I suppose I've always done it kind of intuitively one way or the other
and I've probably made tons of mistakes but it's interesting to look at board games with that in mind and think right which ones do use serif and which ones use son serif you know no no flowery bits and why so for example if we look at the recent game mm space agency it's obviously a a science fiction game and yeah there's no fancy little serf bits in it right there's it's all son serif right it's just plain straightforward lettering whereas if we look at some a little bit more Fantastical and and sort of beautiful and Flowery like um Fara the everel sequel yeah we've got serif in there okay so we've got these little extra bits on the letters that make it look a little bit more story book right and not quite so futuristic like we see in mm so these are things that I've just never really thought about before I've just kind of looked at fonts and thought yeah I'll go with that one or I'll go with that one cuz I like it more than the other one um but actually there's more that goes into these decisions or there should be than that and this book illustrates that really well the next chapter in the book is all about iconography which I guess it's what I thought I was getting into when I bought a book or when I asked for a book on graphic design for board games icons seem to be such a major part of of what we do when we design and when we're playing games going back to Daniel's game Trickster it's got a whole series of icons it's got text on there as well so the cards have ch he he's opted to use text and icons and I guess the icons
are there to catch at a glance right to know what that card does at a quick glance but the words then detail it in case you don't understand the icon you need to read it and some of those icons are really simple some of them are a little bit more complex so you might use the text a little bit more but what you find from those cards and what what he um elaborates on in this book is how he's created this sort of visual language so if he's talking about um you the player then then your icon the icon might be in white but if he's talking about the opponent it might be in Gray or in black um and interestingly when you look at the trickster icons some of them aren't really very thematic so if he's talking about you know home like you your base he's got a picture of a little house and it's quite a quaint little house not a futuristic house that would fit in with the trickster Universe if he's talking about trashing a card or discarding a card he might use a picture of a bin and it's a very much a kind of a trash can or a garbage that you might just see you know in someone's house in the modern day again it's not futuristic but you don't tend to notice because that's not what the icons for the icon is is small and it's there to make a very clear Point very quickly but again he elaborates on those decisions when that's appropriate when it's not when you might want to use a more thematic icon and so on I found myself with dilemas around iconography when I was making my game thrown so it was in fact it was a major part of the the of the development of that through multiple prototypes at at various stages
I wanted to make that game completely language independent because I thought it might maximize my chances of getting a publisher to look at it right they don't want to produce lots of different language editions was my thinking they just want one edition they can sell to lots of different markets so I tried to remove all text and represent everything with icons but of course I've got no basis in graphic design no knowledge of it I've never been on a course I've never read a book on graphic design until this point so creating I which indicate that you know this die has been rolled this die has not been rolled this die belongs to the player this die belongs to an opponent and so on it's difficult to come up with a separate icon for all those things that's intuitive easy to read and easy for players to just understand at a glance and I'm not sure I succeeded I then of course go into the process of putting together the game with a publisher it was it was published by Whiz Kids a number of years ago and so a graphic designer came on board and of course the graphic designer doesn't understand the game like I do right nobody does nobody understands that game like I do and so trying to work out what is the appropriate icon the graphic designer will come up with something and then I'll look at it and I'll see problems because it that that icon they've come up with might imply something else that relates to the game that they haven't fully understood and so we go back and forth back and forth and we end up with this system this language for the game and it's nothing like as good as the language that Daniel sess came up for in trickster it's
nothing like as coherent but it was a really interesting experiment and experience for me trying to put that all together later I created a game called Zulan which is uh should I call it a game it's a puzzle a series of puzzles in a box I like to think of it as a game but um but it is a a series of of puzzles of increasing difficulty and again I was going down the route of language independent in fact that's the whole selling point of the game is that you're presented with a card it's got a series of images which are essentially functioning like icons and they indicate um where different things happen you have to then Place individual components to kind of piece together the picture that these icons are pointing you towards so try to create this visual language through Zulan each individual puzzle as as they progress they will introduce new Concepts new icons no text okay so you'll be introducing us to new icons you'll interpret them and then they'll be used over and over again in different ways so that you gradually learn this visual language while you play and by the time you're getting towards the end of the of the cards you know there are 60 different puzzles in the deck they're getting more and more complex with more and more of these icons and some of them have things that you need to interpret you know you need to imagine what's happening in the story some of them are a case of just using the icons that you've seen previously and so on it was a really fascinating uh experience putting that together but also working with a graphic designer to get it to work that was really intense
that was an intense month or six weeks I would say working with that graphic designer because again he would do things which seem great superficially okay on the surface they look great but they change everything okay they change the way that things are understood in relation to previous icons and future icons and game mechanisms that that graphic designer doesn't necess necessarily fully understand at the level that the game designer does so I suppose I'm making a case for why graphic design should be important to you as a game designer you need to be aware of this stuff because you're going to get involved in those conversations at a later stage the next thing that the book goes on to talk about is diagrams now I've never really made a distinction between icons and diagrams but it makes sense right if you're in a particularly in a rule book if you've got an example uh and so it might show a series of images showing you how to carry out a turn for example and in this book Daniel talks about how that can be related to comic books and how much he learned from Reading comic books it reminded me of um this book understanding Comics by Scott McLoud which was recommended to me um by one of the view one of my regular viewers on this channel um thank you very much for that it's a really good read um and it talks about how Comics are put together and how panels work and how you know well so much in that because it's so it's complex stuff right but an understanding of how comics comics and panels work and how readers sort of Traverse the page is really
useful when trying to um you know form diagrams and and use those icons in and make sure that the reader is getting the most out of them and following them in a logical fashion one of the biggest areas in this that this book covers I think is of most value to us as game designers is about cards specifically about the layout of cards that is a big part of what we do in our prototyping and certainly as we go into production we're going to want to keep an eye on that to make sure that the publisher is doing what is needed to make it as easy for the players to to play and read as possible so the book talks about visibility you know making sure that the icons and the text are of an appropriate size it's a complaint that's commonly thrown at everel right everel is my favorite game you know it's fantastic but the best thing about the the everel cards is the beautiful beautiful artwork by Andre Bosley which is just incredible this is what like the major selling point for the game frankly isn't it it's a fantastic game but the artwork is amazing and it just sells the game but as a result that artwork is is prominent on those cards and other things particularly the text is really quite small and that's going to make it quite hard for some players to um uh to to to to read and and to play it's it's it makes it less accessible for some players Daniel also talks about the hierarchy of the information so where on a card certain information should be where it should be located on the card in order to be read where the most important information should go um and where you can sort of hide away on the
card the stuff that you need to be there but it doesn't need to be read all the time so it can kind of be be hidden in a bottom corner where it might be covered by another card at certain points and things like that um and of course the conventions that build up over time we've got used to playing so many games that use information and present information in a certain way we might need to follow some of that format Daniel talks about the brevity of information you know keeping your text brief uh making sure that your icons aren't spaying out all over the place that they're not too complicated and so on and I think that's uh important too and then he goes on to talk about different types of cards so he talks about playing cards so playing cards would be a card that basically just has a number on it right think about a traditional playing card where you've just got a number and a suit okay and that is the case in many many games if we look at a game like um snack rap abits for example this is just numbers and uh and suits you know numbers colors that sort of thing and there's so many games like that I I haven't played the game zebra yet but I imagine a lot of these Amigo games are just numbers right numbers and colors something like UNO For example would be another example of a playing card but then he goes on to talk about word cards which would be similar to the cards that I would use in my game Doodle Rush um the drawing game where you've got a word that you need to then illustrate or cards that you might see in code names for example where you've just got words on cards and that's it so how do we design them paragraph cards which are cards where you have long passages of text that may tell you a little bit of a story you
might see them in narrative games like um Cav Ventura or um the adventure game series or um Clank Legacy where you've got these these long passages of texts that you need to read on the card commodity cards which are essentially um they're basically like resources right so in a game like the rich and the good you've got all your different resources that you're buying all the different stocks and shares are individual cards they could be represented by a little lump of coal or a little piece of wood right a little tokens but actually in a lot of games I guess for reasons of cost and and also the the functionality of passing these things around and stacking them often they are a deck of cards then there's action cards which probably take a lot of thought game games like ccgs a lot of Euro games cards which you play them in order to take some sort of action so something like Disney L Carana right you play the card it's got quite a lot of information on there about how the card Works uh how many attacks it has how many defense it has all that sort of stuff the cost of the card so this is where we get into looking at that hierarchy of information to make sure that everything is on there appropriately and then cards that have an ongoing effect so these are cards that remain on the table um so that everyone can see them and they know the rules for that particular round or that particular game this is how the game thrown my game works where we've got a series of cards laid out that just set the rules for that particular round of play Daniel goes on to talk about bleed
and trim and use of layers and different card sizes these are all things that I've covered in quite a lot of detail in my videos I've got a video about choosing the right size for your card I've got several videos about you know trying to get the trying to use the bleed and the trim to get them correct lined up so that you can send your your your files off to a printer to make your prototype or to make your final product but it's useful to have it all written down and laid out in a book like Daniel's book about graphic design he's got chapters on creating punch boards game boards talking about how game boards are manufactured so you know you've got that uh that sort of sticker over the front of the board that folds over onto the back of the board and then you might have a second sticker where you put information so it's not included in the folds of those boards thinking about the orientation of the boards so that every player is able to see information depending on where they're sat and how that's different for a two-player game where of course you can have the information facing the player that needs to see it compared to a multiplayer game where it's going to be very difficult to do that and some players are going to be seeing stuff upside down he talks about uh areas of noise and quiet in the images on that board to make sure the most useful information is very visible and that the artwork is not not distracting from it but also so that you don't have massive empty spaces he talks about how to you know um Define your worker placement spaces so that we know that this worker placement space is available for one
Maple this worker placement space is available for multiple mles or has an additional cost to go on all those sorts of things he talks about laying out Maps he talks about how to choose appropriate terrain for terrain tiles for a game like dominant species where we've got um you know forests and grasslands and oceans and how to distinguish between those different terrains in a way that players can just intuitively understand at a glance he's got a whole section on designing your rule book he's got a section on designing boxes and packaging so as you can tell there's load this is not a video right now about teaching you graphic design right I I I'm not qualified to do so okay I've made so many mistakes throughout my career I'm getting better at it okay but I'm I'm not good at it by any means so this book has really really helped me okay I have so many positives to say about it I've I've I've ranted a little bit I've raved about it here I should probably throw in some negative shouldn't I the only thing the only thing that really bothered me about the book ironically is the Graphic Design Within the book itself a lot of the um the diagrams well they're all in grayscale right they're all black and white images and often the text will refer to colors and use of colors but when those colors have then been transferred to grayscale the image doesn't quite make sense and sometimes I've even been left in the book reading it and and looking for an image and I'm not even sure that the image is either in the book or or maybe I'm not understanding where the image is or why
the image is there some of the images have been shrunken so much that you can't quite make out what exactly they're trying to show you with that image so it's a strange strange irony that a book a brilliant book about graphic design with fantastic content in it it's kind of let down a little bit by the diagrams and the images within it um not the way that the diagrams have been intended I'm sure if they're blown up to an appropriate scale and they have the colors and things in there I think the the the diagrams would probably be really really functional but as they are some of them only some I didn't quite get them okay none of that ruined the book okay none of that changed the fact that I learned so much from it and I think you had probably learned something from it too if you're a game designer so I would highly recommend having a look for it it's called the graphic design for board games by Daniel soless and it's produced by CRC press from the Taylor and Francis group and I think it's one of a a new series of books that Jeff engelstein is overseeing okay so there's already been one which is all about theme I haven't seen that I'd quite like to look at that one maybe I'll maybe I'll have a look at that as well and then I think there are future books planned um and I I also think Jeff engelstein is kind of I've seen him reaching out to designers asking does anybody else want to produce a book on a specific topic that might fit into this range so you might want to consider that as well um so there you go graphic design for board games go and find yourself a copy if you enjoy this you might enjoy some of my books so I'm
going to share a link