Skip to main content
Loading video...

Horrified: Dungeons & Dragons (Review)

Transcript 26:17

Hey folks, welcome back to the dungeon dive. Daniel here. I hope you're doing well and if you're not, I hope you are soon. Okay, today we're taking a look at the new horrified and this is the Dungeons and Dragons themed Horrified and I think this game is pretty cool. So, I've played the original Horfi, the Universal Monsters one, and I think that's a fantastic game. I think that's a perfect gateway to kind of the co-op hobby tabletop gaming world. I love that original horrified. I have also played the world of monsters version, and that one I did not like at all. There were quite a few rules ambiguities with the main bosses that you were fighting that just prevented me from having fun with the game and uh that one just really really fell flat. Uh but the Dungeons and Dragons one I think is pretty good.

However, I think there is a kind of a missed opportunity here and they could have made one very easy to implement change that would have done a lot to kind of expand the theming of Dungeons and Dragons and it wouldn't have added any kind of complications or anything. And I'll talk about what I think that change should have been uh a little later. Let's take a look at the back of the box here. So, a cooperative game against the most iconic monsters of Dungeons and Dragons. So, in this game, the bosses are a red dragon, a displacer beast, a mimic, and a beholder. And so, this says here, "Dealth below the city of Water Deep into the most nefarious dungeon of all. Beholder, Displacer Beast, Mimic, and Red Dragon are terrorizing Under Mountain. Your team of heroes must defeat them by completing each other's uh each creature's unique challenge. adventure again and again or adjust the difficulty by facing a new group of monsters every game. So, one of the things I do really enjoy about these horrified games is the board. They always put a really cool picture on the back of the board. So, when you open your box, you're greeted with this awesome image. And I absolutely love that. And I think all of the games have a really nice look. And that's especially true with the board. I think the boards for these games really pop.

And I also like the price point and I like uh the ease of play. Yeah, the these are just mostly great games. Of course, I've only played u the the one, but I've heard the others are good. And I know on BG there are some complaints about that world of monsters one with those uh with those boss monsters being a little difficult. So here we have the map here and we have water deep. So we have the city of water deepep uh up here and then we have the dungeon below and we have our different dungeon level the arcane chambers. We have skullport down here and willow wood here. So I think this looks really really cool. There are some teleportation chambers in each area. So you can teleport from each area. And there are also some secret passages that the monsters can't take that the heroes can't take. So, you can take this uh castle corkcrew down to the skullport gate, and you can take the yawning portal, the well, and the yawning portal down to the entry well of the dungeon. And so, here we have our boss monster sheets. So, there are four different bosses in this game. We have the mimic with a little treasure miniame, so you can find the mimic and make sure you can attack the mimic before it attacks you. We have our displacer beast and you will be putting items on this displacer beast and then rolling a d20. So, one of the things this game does different is it does introduce a a d20 system kind of, you know, like like D and D. And you have to match the number that you roll with an

item that you've placed on the beast in order to find the real beast and defeat it. And the displacer beast is one of the enemies that the game does recommend you uh you use for a starter game. So, we'll place him over to the side. Uh, we also have a red dragon. And the red dragon is kind of the big complex boss that you can fight in this game. And it's a multi-stage part where you have to do a little puzzle and then you have to find the dragon's layer in order to destroy the dragon. So, we'll place him off to the side. And the other monster that the game recommends for your first game here is the Beholder. And the Beholder has all of their eyetocks with different um abilities. and you will roll on a random chart to see what kind of power that the beholder uses. And you have to you have to uh lop off you have to destroy each of the beholder's tentacles in order to defeat the beholder. So we will place them over there. So the game comes with one two three four five different heroes to play. We have the wizard, the cleric, the fighter, the rogue, and the bard.

And another thing that this game does that's a little bit different and kind of adding to that uh that kind of character variety that we are typical that we typically find in a game of D and D is uh the hero's special abilities are randomized. So in the other games of horrified each character had a special ability or two that they could trigger by taking a special action. Well here when you take your special action you will roll your d20 and you will do what it says. So, there's a chance that you might fail on your special action or you might gain a really cool special action if you roll a 20 and you would also gain a perk card. And then there are three other items. Now, the chances for each of them are the same on each character. So, we have a 2 to 8, a 9 to 15, and a 16 to 19 for what you roll or your modified roll on the d20 in order to in order to trigger that ability. Uh, I will play I will set up this game here.

We weren't not going to do a whole game play, but I'll set up this game using three characters. This is the game I was playing last night with the rogue, the fighter, and the cleric. And we also have our town folks. So, each of the horrified games, the horrified games has these civilians. And these civilians are one of the threats that you have to manage. And these civilians will will come out on the board, and then they need to be escorted to a certain area by the heroes. And when they are escorted, they are removed from the board. And then you gain a perk card, which are cards that give you special abilities. And they are very squishy. They are very easy for the enemies to kill. And every time a citizen is killed, the terror track goes up. And if it ever reaches that last spot, that's one of the ways that the game can end. You also move the terror track up every time a hero dies, and then they just come back. So that's the main penalty. That's the main way that the game can lose. This is the area where I think there was a real missed opportunity because one of the things especially in D&D 5e, especially in modern uh Dn D, one of the things that a lot of the players like to do is fighting minions. And I think that they could have swapped these civilians out for different enemies that you could fight on the board. And that would have gone a long way to make this game feel more like Dn D and to uh a long way to make it feel different than the other the other horrified games. It would have made the D&D theme, I think, pop a lot more than just relying on this standard

mechanism of rescuing the civilians. You know, we have four different areas. We have water deep, we have the dungeon, we have Skullport, and we have over here we have Willow Wood. Each one of those four areas could have had, you know, three different enemies that they could have come out with the cards and they could have roamed around their area. You know, in Water Deep, we could we could have had, you know, thieves or bandits. In the dungeons, we could have had goblins or orcs or something. In Skullport, or in Willowwood, we could have had kind of magical enemies or maybe undead enemies. And the different enemies would have gone a long way to kind of bolster the theming of each area. And you could have added a simple little combat rule with a little simple reward mechanism for defeating the enemies. And we also could have had something like it where if there were too many enemies in one area, then that would be another way for the uh the terror track to go up. And it just yeah, it's a real shame that they just decided to stick with this because I think this one simple little little change would have really elevated horrified Dungeons and Dragons to something that I would wholeheartedly recommend. I think it's still pretty cool. I still like the game quite a bit, but I I think that is a real missed opportunity.

Uh let's take our hero uh minis here. So, we have some of these components here. So, each of the heroes does come with their own stand. And so, we'll take our cleric, we'll take our fighter, and our rogue there and place them on the board. These are randomizer tokens for when you need to find a layer. So you will randomize these and you will put those out on the board. Then you have to trade a certain number of items that have a value of three or higher in order to discover the layer. And that's mainly used for the red dragon. The red dragon also uses these kind of little like Tetris-l like pieces, these little sliding puzzle pieces that you will use on their board when you are using the red dragon as an enemy. We have this flame. What is this called? The fire up.

I always forget the actual name of that. the frenzy marker. And so certain enemies will become frenzied and they might take two turns in a row. I believe when you are playing with the beholder and the displacer beast that uh the beholder starts uh in frenzy mode and that can move in between the two different monsters. Now these little X tokens, these are the cheapest tokens in the game and I wish they would have given us something a lot more robust. I almost actually threw these away because they're really hard to see on the chit sheet. And so these are used to put on the eyeballs of the beholder when you kill them. And these are really really little flimsy X tokens. I think I will end up replacing those with some wooden tokens or some uh some little uh plastic crystal tokens or something. And especially they're black. They're just hard to see. These are probably easily easily the worst component in the game.

I think everything else is actually pretty good. Uh here we have our tracker. So, we'll keep track of our um of our terror track up there. And then we also have two small decks of cards. And I think I like I said before, I think the art in this game is really nice. It has a really good look. And I think that's also true about all the cards. So, here we have our perk cards. And I love the way these look. These are really cool. And these are all represented uh these all represent different NPCs that can help you. And the players will start with one perk card at the beginning of the game. Then there are more opportunities to gain more perk cards as you play. But they will give you special abilities such as add or subtract up to four from any player's d20 roll. Uh can be used on monster rolls. Uh skip the next monster phase. Any number of heroes may be placed at the yawning portal. So you can kind of call them back to the yawning portal there.

Uh, Drist here, the current player takes two additional actions. That's awesome. You may reveal a layer or you may move a monster to their starting location. So, all kinds of different abilities. Uh, let's go ahead and shuffle these up and we'll draw our three starting cards. So, the top will be the rogue, the next will be the fighter, and the cleric. So, the rogue can summon any of the heroes back to the yawning portal. Uh the fighter can at the next d20 roll a player rolls this hero phase is an automatic 20. So that's an automatic special ability. Uh a really good special ability. And then the black staff here. Uh choose a hero. Each other hero may give that hero up to two items. So you can kind of hoover up items for one character. We also have a card here and this is the d20 card that we will consult when the beholder uses its special ability. And depending on what you roll, they will do that. I do like that. I think that is really cool.

It makes the beholder kind of fun and random. You never know what the beholder is going to do. And then we have a couple player aids. These games are really simple and they're really fast. And that's one of my favorite things about the horrified games is the turns go quick and they're always fun. And so on the hero phase, each uh one hero will take up to four actions and the number of actions is shown at the top left of the card. All of the heroes have the same number of actions in this version, and that's four. They can move, they can guide a citizen, they can pick up, they can share, they can advance. That's how you deal with the bosses, they can defeat a boss, they can take their special action, or they can reveal a layer token. And then the monster phase, you will put new items out on the board. You will draw an event card, and then the monsters will move and attack. And that's basically it. You do the same thing over and over again. And then we have all of our event cards. and the event cards. These will tell you how many items come out and the items get placed in the various uh random locations. They will tell you which uh monsters move and they will tell you some kind of special thing that the monsters will do on their turn. And these all have a really cool art, too. I love the vibrant colors that these horrified games always use. They just always look great on the board. And every time we play, you know, if I play with new people, everybody always comments how how uh cool this game look or how cool the horrified games look.

And I just love that you can uh you can buy games like this just at Target now. You can actually get good mass market games. I think I think the horrified games have really kind of set the new standard of what people should expect from a mass market game that you can pick up at Walmart or Target or something like that. Uh let's see. So, the rogue starts in the sword and sexant. And uh this is one of the things about the game is is trying to find all the all of the locations when you're first learning. The sword and sex is down here in Skullport just off camera. So, I'll put the rogue down here. And the fighter starts in the Hall of Heroes, and the Hall of Heroes is over here in the dungeon. And the cleric starts at Castle Water Deep, which is up here in Water Deep. And then we have our bag here. And these are all of the tokens.

And this is kind of the main thrust of the game. The main mechanism of the game is you have all of these different items. And the items are uh separated into three different categories. We have physical items, we have magical items, and we have mundane items. And they have different numbers. And a lot of the times you're looking to collect sets. And the monsters will need different items that are placed on them. you will have to combine, you know, maybe a blue and a and a a yellow item or three red items in order to defeat a monster. And so, one of the main things you're trying to do is to collect these items and then use them to defeat the monster. You can also use these items to defend against a monster attack. So, at the beginning of the game, we randomly deal out 12 items.

So, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12. Okay, so there's our 12 items. And then these items, they tell you where they go. And so you kind of have to do a little hunt and peck here to in order to find all of the various locations where these items go. So I'm going to do that now. Okay. So all the items are set up. We have a couple items up here at the House of Wonder, one at Castle Water Deep, one at Skull Manor, one in the Hall of Heroes, one in the Goblin Bazaar, and so on. And so uh now let's take our monster mini. So, we have the mini for the Displacer Beast. We have the mini for the mimic we're not using. We have the mini for the red dragon, which we are not using. And then we have the mini for the beholder. And I need to see where those uh where those get put out. Okay. So, the displacer beast goes on frenzy spot number one.

And so, that will be at the abandoned camp. So, the displacer beast goes into the abandoned camp. And the beholder gets placed on frenzy spot number two, which is down here in Skullport on Skull Island, uh, just off the camera to the south there of the map. And then we also have our 3d6, and those are used to trigger hits when the enemies attack and also sometimes uh, their special ability. And we do have our d20. And so, uh, yeah, everything is, uh, everything is now set up. and we can play a couple of example turns starting with the rogue who is just off camera down here. Okay, so here's the rogue at the sword and so the first thing I can do is I can go ahead and spend an action to pick up that item there, the spellcasting focus and then I can take a couple points of movement here. Now, one of the other things I like about this game is a lot of the locations have a number associated with them and the enemy like the displacer beast kind of is constantly moving around and they're kind of hard to find and so you're often told to roll a d20 and move an enemy to that random location. I think that's pretty cool. I do like that a lot and it goes in with that theme of the displacer beast and uh the beholder can kind of move around as well. So, that was one action. Um, let's see here. Let's go ahead and take Let's set up one of my special actions. So, I'll take a special action with the rogue. Let's see what they can do on their turn. A one. Oh, no effect. Okay. So, I lost that action. Uh

let's take another one. Um a five. Okay. Share items with any and all heroes. So, I could uh teleport this item to any hero that might need it. I'll just hold on to that. And for my last action, I will just move there. Okay. Okay. So, after I've taken my turn with the rogue, at the end of each hero's turn, you draw an event card. So, let's see what happens here. So, this is a citizen. So, Oliver Stillwater comes out. Uh, starting in the Goblin Bazaar. Uh, let me find Oliver Stillwaters. Now, see, now if this was an enemy and this is a, you know, a goblin enters the dungeon and then you could place the this goblin in the dungeon and then that would be something that the heroes would have to fight. That would have been so cool. This game would have been so much better if they would have just swapped the citizens out for some kind of minions for that kind of threat rather than rescuing uh civilians as a threat which are you know that that thing is in all of the horrified games. So maybe this should be like the first horrified game that come that they make an expansion for a minion expansion that just adds that little kind of Dn D layer to the game. But he comes out in the Goblin Bazaar and he needs to get to Dead Man's Corner, which is over here in Skullport.

So that needs to happen before he is killed by one of the monsters. Okay, a sea hack in Skullport who sells the zombies in exchange for blood. So that's who Olive Stillwater is. And now we look at the enemies. The frenzied enemy goes and the magical enemy goes. So the frenzied enemy is the displacer beast. I have the frenzy token on the displacer beast and so they move one towards the nearest hero and then if they can they attack with two dice. Well, I can't get anywhere to the nearest hero. So, I think the nearest hero is actually let's see one two to skull port because the enemies can use a teleportation uh portal. So, I will move the uh the displacer beast here and then also magical enemies go. And I don't think any of the um the displacer beast or the beholder is not uh does not follow that symbol there. You trigger the monsters depending on what icon they have. And you always trigger the uh the frenzied beast if you have that frenzied icon. So that's basically it for the monster's turn. Okay, so now it's the fighter's turn. So the fighter is over here in the hall of heroes. For the fighter's first action, I will pick up that item there.

I will go ahead and roll up a random ability on their card here, a five. Immediately move to the nearest monster location. Okay, that's kind of cool. I like the way that they that the fighter works because they can often move to the monster, thus causing the monster to stay in place and attack them instead. So, that's pretty cool. So, it can move to the nearest monster. One, two, three, four, five, six, or one, two, three, four. So the displacer beast is closest. So I will move uh the fighter to the displacer beast using that teleportation circle. So now the fighter is here. Uh that was my second turn there. So I have two more actions. I have two more actions. Um let's go ahead and place this on the displacer beast. So the way the displacer beast works is this row here. You need to place an item with one or more uh strength. And the strength is the uh number in the upper left. This row here two or more. This row here three or more. And then four, fives, and sixes can be placed on any row. And so if I were to place this covering the two when I would take an action to try to defeat the displacer beast, I would first have to discard items with a total value of seven or higher. And then I would roll the d20.

And if I rolled a number that was covered by an item, then I have found the real displacer beast and I would kill them. And so if I were to take that chance right now, I would have to roll a two. And I rolled a 17. And so the more items you have on the displacer beast card, the better chance you have of finding the real displacer beast and vanquishing them from water deep. But I'm not going to do that. So let's see. That was one, two, three actions. I believe I will take an additional action and I will just go ahead and uh let's do another special action here. Um actually let's go ahead and we can use our special ability. So the next d20 roll a player rolls this hero phase is an automatic 20. So my special ability would be an automatic 20. That allows me to draw a perk card. And so now I can add or subtract up to four from any player's d20 roll can be used on the monster rolls. And I gain two additional actions. Let's go ahead and take another special action. And 11. During the monster phase, ignore all hit results.

Rolled by the monster roll by one attack. Okay, that's cool. So, I'm going to go ahead and I'll just forfeit my last action because I can stay here with the displacer beast and if the displacer beast attacks me, I can use that ability that I just rolled on the fighter to negate that attack. So, let's draw the fighter event now. So, we have monster action. the I found you. Move each of these hat monsters three locations towards the player with the most items. Okay, so the most items is the rogue with one item and that is a displacer beast. So they will move three locations. One, two. So they are now in the same space as the rogue. So they will stay there. Okay. And so now we do this. The frenzied monster does not move, but the potion monster will move and attack. We don't have a potion monster on the board now. And so, uh, nothing happens. And so, that is the end. We do need to, what thing I forgot to do, we'll have to back up, is I forgot to put the items out for these cards. So, for that first card here, we need to put out three items. And for this card here, we need to put out one item. So, I will draw four items here.

And then, so then we would go ahead and we would place our lantern at the altar of uh, Jubillex. We would place our amulet at the abandoned priori. We would place our wand at the black staff tower. And then we would place the pouch at the yawning portal exterior. So yeah, that's basically how horrified uh Dungeons and Dragons is played. I think it's pretty cool. I like this one. It does give me a little bit of a D&D feel or at least a D and D board game feel. It almost gives me the feeling of a that the old TSR dungeon game. And I think that feeling would have been greatly bolstered had they introduced the ability to fight some kind of minions. I'm surprised I just didn't think of that. I mean, maybe they did and they just didn't want to introduce a new layer to it, but I just I can't help but feel that this is a huge huge missed opportunity for a D&D horrified game. Just the very simple thing of changing these civilians to minions that you could kill in order to get a reward would have made this feel more like a D and D board game. And I would love to see that in in an expansion. I don't think there have been any expansions for any of the horrified games and that's probably because they are a more mass market oriented. But if they could put out an expansion for horrified Dn D with, you know, a couple new bosses and some minion rules that

you could use instead of the civilians. I think that would make this game fantastic. And with that, I could wholeheartedly recommend horrified Dungeons and Dragons. As now, I think it's kind of a tepid recommendation. I think this game is fine. I like it more than the World of Monsters version. I don't think I like it as much as the the the basic Universal Monsters version, which I just think is a brilliant game. I absolutely love that. But it does play really quickly. It it's very easy to teach. The games go fast. Everything looks great on the board except for these stupid little X uh cheap little tokens here that you use to destroy the beholder. These obvious these really need an upgrade, but that should be easy to handle. But uh yeah, so I hope you enjoyed taking a look at uh horrified Dungeons and Dragons, and we will talk to you later. Bye-bye.

Progress saved