Skip to main content
Loading video...

Arkham Horror (2nd Edition): Discussion

Transcript 30:47

Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome to the discussion for Arkham Horror second edition. Now we have we're doing this right after we just got done playing third edition, so a lot of comparisons. Seth asked me which one you thought was my favorite and I said, I don't know, maybe third edition and he said, really? And I said, well now I don't [ __ ] know. Cuz it's been It has been a while since we have not. It's been And the very last time we played it, we played it with every single expansion known to man. That is true. We played it with six people. This was 2 years ago. Six because it was it was going to go on the channel. 2 years ago. 2 years ago. Uh yeah, we were we were going to play with we had every single expansion now like all all my friends there and I'm 100% so that took me forever to set up too. And uh Just forever to play.

And it took us forever to play and ultimately it was like a 6-hour game. I didn't want to edit it and everyone was falling asleep in the discussion so uh I was like, you know what? This isn't worth putting up. But So after third edition came out Oh people were leaving too. People had to leave. I think a couple people did leave. Yeah, so I mean it was I mean that's just what happened. Which was our fault cuz it was quite a long game. Yeah, and so now after replaying second edition uh with no I mean we had some expansions like we had like the the the personal stories, those are expansions. little little Things that that could pop up like a bunch of this stuff, all these cards are strictly scenario based. Like they might come up, they might not. Yeah. After playing this edition, now what is your answer? Do you like third edition better or second edition?

I still do like third edition better. I do too. Um they did definitely tighten up they learned is what they did. They was exactly. I Which is what they're supposed to do. Cuz I wasn't sure whenever we were talking about third edition, I know I liked it and I was like, man, the second edition. I just have such fun memories and that I think that's really what they are. It's just it's a nostalgia thing. Because after playing this again, I like Eldritch way better, too. Uh you know, Eldritch is just never been my favorite. Really? Yeah, I don't know why. I just cannot get attached to it. Like Hmm. I don't know what it is. I don't know what it is. It's not the game. It's just there's something about it. don't get me wrong. It might be this because I Don't get me wrong. I still like Arkham Horror second edition a lot. Uh I think the disconnect is that Arkham Horror, this one, and and now the third edition, but we're going to focus on this one, centers around Arkham. I feel like it's more relatable. You're in the town. Monsters move around. They get in your way. You're familiar with everything within Arkham. Eldritch Horror is I think it feels too big, which is weird to say, but it's like I can't get attached to go into the science building or to the black cave in Eldritch because we're going to Tokyo. There's like a disconnect, which is why I feel like Eldritch is easier because Arkham does have that, oh, monsters move around. It's like, oh, we need to move over there. Then it's just like, boom.

Yeah. Crap, we can't do that now. And you It just feels tired or tougher. But I will say that Arkham Horror third edition, I think Mhm. will ultimately make me get rid of all this because it's like if I can play third edition, I would rather. Only because this is a very clunky game. Um it's just it's super bloated. Which is weird for me to say because I was saying in the third edition discussion that I like that, but I like that with the encounters. I love that the encounter decks for each location is this big. Yeah. But I don't like the fact that whenever I'm setting up, I'm like, I don't even know what to use. Like, I have all this stuff that I don't even remember if I need. I had to hand make a cheat sheet to figure out what the black what the borders mean. This is it's just older.

It's just old. What? No, it's just yeah, it is. Uh so, it's like, okay, crap. So, what does it what does the outskirts mean? And if it's like, do I how many people can be in there in the terror track? What how does that go up? And so, you're like constantly thinking you're forgetting something. At least for me, I'm constantly thinking I'm forgetting something. cuz I don't set these up. Right. And throughout the game, I'm like, am I missing something? Like, we we won. It's spoilers if you don't want to watch the run through. We won, but I'm like, did I forget something that made it to where we did win? Yeah. Um What did we do wrong? Yeah. How did we how did we get how did we win? Uh I didn't have a blessed dice, so. And yeah, exactly. And so, it's just like there's just too much stuff in here that back then it was like, okay, yeah, that's fine. But then, even then, before third edition came out, and even before Eldritch came out, because Eldritch is getting is at that point, too, where it's just like, I don't I don't know what to use anymore.

Just cuz they kept adding stuff in there. They're going to do the same thing with third edition. But what third edition does over this that I think streamlines streamlines it is the scenarios. Yeah. I think back on I think the scenarios streamline the game. Yeah. Um and the fact that combat is like it tells you what hey, this this monster is elusive, and that's what that means. So, yeah, that was something that that like I've always struggled with this game. And there there's just some games that like just because of the way they choose to do combat, this is actually the same way with D&D. Um like I will never not ask what am I supposed to roll. Right. Like I'm constantly like, okay, I just I I just don't get it." Like I like tell me tell me what I need to do. And No, and and and that completely makes sense. So, there's a stuff in here that I don't really knock it because it is such an older game. I think this game the base game came out 2004.

Yeah, so so with that you kind of have to look at it like you would with any kind of technology. Like when the TV first came out or like when the CD player first came out. Like it's like, "Oh my god, this big [ __ ] deal where one can only play black and white." And then one was just it's it's outdated now, but like we still respect it for what it was. Yeah, no absolutely. I will never not love this game because it's such it's it was my second game at right after Talisman. So, I went to Talisman which was had a [ __ ] ton of expansions. They kept coming out with more. game we ever played together, yeah. What was the first one? Twilight Twilight Twilight Imperium. That was it. And I didn't break up with you, so um but Talisman, yeah. Yeah, and that's what they were my first two games and they grew my love of Fantasy Flight, grew my love of board games and and theme and Ameritrash. Just this I really hope we win. Oh no, I [ __ ] rolled a one. Great. Well, we lost or oh my god, okay. Like cuz this game like more gates kept coming out and then I was like, "Crap." I thought at one point we were going to get overwhelmed because we were both in the other world. And I was like, "We we can't stop it because we're not there to stop it." So, we didn't like I think we just got incredibly lucky.

we got really lucky with how the cards came out and we just happened to have the elder signs in the right spot. Yeah, and honestly at the end like if I didn't roll that I was going to take my elder sign away because it's like, "I don't give a [ __ ] if I'm hopeless if we win." That's true cuz we would we would have won. And Yig is Okay, so Yeah, you do appreciate it and respect it for what it did and and moving forward, but at the same time it's not like You can't How do I want to say this? You can't ignore its flaws because it was respectable 14 years ago. Just cuz a new edition came out, it's not like, "Man, the TV was great when it came out. I don't want a 4K TV because of that reason, you know?" Exactly, because no one's going to look at that and be like, "Wow, look at that." Like at a like at a [ __ ] like a shitty ass garage. So, you're not going to be like, "Oh, look at that."

You're just going to keep walking. You'll be like, "That's awesome." Next. So, right, right. So, let's talk about as as we usually do in these discussions, let's talk about things we don't like about the game at this point. mouth. Uh cuz there is there is stuff. And there's stuff that I didn't like when I when and I didn't start playing this game in 2004. I I don't even know if that's when it came out. I might be completely wrong. you would have been in like sixth grade or something. I'm I'm going to look that up because I I could be completely wrong and in 2018. okay. I'll be like, "What? Arkham Horror second edition versus third edition." Uh I need to go to BoardGameGeek. There we go.

This came out uh in my It I was close, 2005. So. Sounds good. Wow. Oh, eighth grade, seventh grade for you. Wow. Yep. Cuz you're 2 years ahead of me, anyways. And I would have been in fifth grade, so. Wow, that puts it into perspective. Uh so, All right, here Here's what I don't like. And I was watching a top not a top 10, a Q&A with Sam Healey from The Dice Tower. And someone asked him, "What game do you think is bloated with too much content?" And that's not saying too much content is bad, it just means, "Okay, it's it's unnecessary." And he said he said Arkham Horror. And I was like, "Yeah." Because what they unfortunately didn't do is they didn't streamline it each time they kept adding expansions. So, they just kept adding more and more and more and more and it's like And I have all of it.

Yeah. And I don't know what to do with all of it. Yeah. So, I do think it is very bloated because they tried and a lot of the stuff they have in Eldritch or in and even in third edition they have some stuff. Like Eldritch they have the conditions which they kind of started here. They have these um wounds and stuff like that which they have in Mansions. And a lot of stuff they took into their other games from this like but it was just it just a lot of the stuff just feels like it's there. Uh one thing I really don't like and I almost like it was funny whenever we were setting up the characters I was like, "Oh, I forgot about that mechanic." I [ __ ] hate the sliders. This is dumb at this point. It was fine when we were playing it. It wasn't even fine when we were playing it. I will say that.

Yeah, yeah, okay, you're right. Yeah. Cuz it was like every time we always forgot. Or like if they MOVED YOU'RE LIKE, "SHIT!" Or it's like yeah, you you always forgot to do the focus thing and you never know like for sure when you're going to need it so you're like, "I'll I'll leave it alone this round." And then five rounds later you're like, "I completely Yeah, oh, I needed will. And it doesn't even thematically make any sense. Hey, all of a sudden I can't fight. All of a sudden now I forgot all the lore I've ever known ever. Exactly. So, it was just some weird RPG element that I'm so glad they streamlined like in third edition or Eldritch or uh Mansions last. It's like, "Here's your character. Here are his stats. This is what they can do." Like and you you get bonuses through events. I really like that. I think that's way better than just being like, "Woo, oh hey, I'm slow now, but I'm strong now. I'm It makes no sense."

Yeah. Um so, I really I really hate that. Uh and the other thing that I don't like is the fact that the monsters and their abilities are color coded. So, I feel like you're constantly in the rule book. Yeah, I would too cuz it's like you can't like you realistically cannot memorize how like look how many there are. Yeah, like this I I've had to like I couldn't keep everything and this was back whenever I was taking every game and putting them in these boxes which which I hate. The way I did that. They're really useful boxes and some people don't give a [ __ ] how their games are stored and if you are going to store your games in any other way outside of their box, really useful boxes.com. I'm not a sponsor, they don't pay me.

Or go to your Office Depot or OfficeMax and you can find them because the it's it is awesome. I'm just I like this. I like seeing my boxes now. But yeah, so it's you're constantly in the rule book which bogs the game down. Um and the expansions while cool oh man, like it's just it's another extra board which has its own extra rules and then you're just constantly like you will never play with all expansions and and that's just so uh it there's so many rules all the time and they're so fiddly. Like it's like okay, so I'm going to draw I'm going to draw my mythos card and okay, so I think okay, so a person needs to be summoned there and then this is how they move. So, this is their symbol. Okay, so and it moves on blood. So, now it's there. But wait, do they move if I'm there? And is this No, they can't How do I fight them and it's just it's very clunky. Then they have these different rumors and rumors go here and and you have to and they have rumors in Eldritch but I feel like they were just cleaner.

Then they have the headlines and stuff like that that are just hey, something happens. Um and then you go into combat Mhm. with like the ancient one if they if they awaken. And that's another thing is like they have their doom track where it's like, "Okay, so [ __ ] Do I put those on there?" And then, "Okay, so I guess he awakens now. Now Now we have to fight him." Huh. Okay, so how do we fight him? And then they added more expansions where they have a variant with epic battle cards that you're like, "What do I do with those?" So you just have I think ultimately comes down to there's just too much stuff and it's not streamlined in any way. Mhm. And once third edition came out, Eldritch came out and it was streamlined straight out of the box. Like we played base game Arkham here. Uh Eldritch is on the channel, so go check that out, but I think we did it with the newest expansion at that time.

Which was the pyramid one, I think. And it was streamlined then. And then we've done Mansions and then Arkham Horror third edition will go up the same time this one does. And it's just like right out of the gate you're just like I just if I want to set something up, I want to set up anything other than this. Um No, I don't blame you. Um cuz that was a debate tonight. You were like, "Well, I can either cook or I can set up Arkham." And I was fine with you cooking. I did both anyway. But well, cuz you cooked something that took significantly less effort. That's true. But um Yeah, like I was like, "Okay, but if I do it wrong, you can't complain." Like Right. And And that seems to be a theme with the Cthulhu games. You set me You let me set up Mansions one time and I was Oh, well, that was first edition.

I was like, "Sorry." That doesn't Yeah, that doesn't Right. It's just And then like going through gates is just like it's a it's a slow process. I understand what they were trying to do. going through the gates. I do, too. And I really like the gates, but ultimately I like Eldritch so much better. I like being having an other world deck Yeah. of cards cuz they they fit Those were tied in and you had decisions versus just going there and they're color-coded. It's just like half the time you don't even get where you're at. Oh, yeah. You're like, "Okay, I'm in the abyss. Okay, and it's blue and red. All right." which is weird, but you draw and you're like, "All right, I got blue." Well, there's no abyss there, so I have an other encounter, which is boring.

Yeah. It's like I want the ones that are pertain to where I'm at. I want to be I want to know what's happening in there. through a gate, you want to go through the gate with it. Yeah, exactly. Not just have some lazy other and some of them are just like "Oh, the creature waves its hand at you. Blessings upon you. If you have a cursed card, you may discard it." It's just like, "Okay." Pretty good. It is pretty good, but they're just kind of there. Eldritch, you have the uh the actual gate specific Yeah. encounters. Which I very much like. Uh what don't you like about the game? Sorry, I've been talking about the stuff that I don't like. Well, combat and um the trackers is the only real thing that I can think of right now that you haven't talked about. Well, other than what you talked about trackers, but yeah, combat is just it's hard to grasp. Not that it's hard to grasp, it's hard to keep track of.

Yeah. Yeah, I mean cuz you have the horror check. Especially if you're blind and you don't have your glasses on and you're like, "AH, WHAT DOES IT DO?" LIKE YEAH, EXACTLY. And it's like, "Okay, well, I guess yellow, they don't move, so they just stay there. This one, if you you have to fight it until you one of you died. If you pass a combat check against spectral hunter, return to the box and gain $5." Um and then you have these trophies that at some point I finally gained enough that you can go down to Ma's boarding house or the to South South Church gets you a blessing. If you have five toughness worth of monster points, great. Which is totally worth it. Or a gate. It's cuz you get gate trophies as well. Yeah. So, you're just like, "Okay, you you want to go kill monsters." But then there's the outskirts, which is just weird. Yeah. I mean, I have very little complaints about this game. I always will because I'm just significantly easier to please most of the time. There are some games that I will definitely rip apart, but but um this has always been one of my favorite games, it will always be one of my favorite games. Um I've never really complained about anything out of the ordinary. Not a big fan of combat, not a big fan of the sliders, they're just weird.

Mhm. Um I Should we just let him in? No. Like my cat is trying to get in. Lincoln needs in right now and we're not letting him. Um Uh yeah. Other than No, yeah, that's the only thing I can think of right now. So let's talk about things that we do like. Um which for you will probably a lot. Uh I mean I like like you said, I don't I like mechanics-wise, there's some stuff that I'm like, oh that's just old. But and I don't hate this game. It's just more at this point Eldritch. Yeah, you just prefer the third edition. Well, they're more world building, I think. I think they're more thematic.

Like and you may disagree with me, but there's a lot of stuff that the the I I just feel more drawn in with Eldritch because of the they all the clues, you don't just go somewhere and just pick them up. Oh, yeah, I know. There's just something about Eldritch. I play it and I just don't go boom boom and then you just okay, I have clues now. Maybe that's like the one saving grace of this game is they don't make it so [ __ ] They don't make it Yeah, exactly. I like I mean I like I just like how Eldritch does it. You have an encounter with them and that makes it more thematic, but it's not as stupid as third edition where it's like, hey spend three turns to eventually find a clue, maybe three turns and then you may not get it, but now you're prepared cuz you know what it's going to require. So it just kind of drew out getting clues, but trying to be thematic, which it also was. I just think Eldritch is like, okay, I'm in a space with a clue.

Here's my clue card. Okay, and then they read this and then it's like, if you pass gain this clue. It's like, great. Great, that was that was that. Yeah. Now, skill checks I've always liked. Um, I felt that was very D&D RPG-ish. Uh, I just like how it's a static skill, not just this weird, I'm I'm strong now, slider. Uh, I like how the Ancient One can awake. Um, I've always liked that cuz it's always like, we might have to fight him. Like, we might actually, you know, we might have to actually deal with him. And most time you're like, yeah, we're totally going to [ __ ] lose. But it's like, if it's near the end of the game and you fought your [ __ ] ass like to really get there and you're amped up and you've got a ton of spells and you've got weapons and then it can actually be kind of like, we might win.

That's true. fun. I like the gates. I like going through them. Um, uh, I like some expansions. Uh, not everyone's a winner. That's just not possible. Right, there's so many. Yeah, as as much as I hate it, I like that you can become blessed or cursed. Um, cuz you are finding all these relics. Chances are you're going to pick up the monkey's paw at some point. Oh, right, right. I think that's I like that they have they have like little terror trackers that like shops will close down cuz it's just like, this is just getting too spooky. Yeah, like I mean, thematically the terror track is neat cuz every time it goes up and and and ally leaves, which doesn't really matter at this point cuz there's such a big ally. It's like that. That one ally could be anybody.

Ryan Dean's gone. Whoa, who cares? I'll grab someone else. Oh, no. Not Zebulon Whatley. Oh, Zebulon Whatley, he's a [ __ ] I think he was summoned the Dunwich Horror or is the brother of someone who did that. Yeah, the Whatleys. Uh, The old Whatley boys, I think I'll summon them. And and the Dunwich Horror. But yeah, so and then yeah, eventually uh, once it hits three then the general store goes down. Six, I think the curiosity shop goes down. Nine is I think the old magic shop. So yeah, shops start closing down. The ones that you really need to not shut down will get shut down. Right, because they're the ones that you buy can buy stuff from. They added some really cool things like memberships. You can be a member of the Sheldon gang which affects encounters. You can be a member of the thousand uh what is it?

One One of the thousand year cult or whatever. Thousand cult, whatever. Well, if you can't read it, I can't either. Yeah, and then so then you have these encounters. So there was a lot of theme that they did put into the expansions. Which by the way, I think there's like eight eight total expansions. Three big ones and then four four big ones technically, but one of them was just a collection of just more stuff for all the other expansions. And then they have these small ones. Um King in Yellow, Curse of the Dark Pharaoh, Lurker at the Threshold, and then Black Goat of the Woods. Which is Those were all the small ones. I love the amount of people you have. It's like 48 I think people.

Yeah, somehow I always get the same character. You do always get the same one. Um and I and I did a random number generator for them. I love there's a bunch of ancient ones and I really like how they are Oops, they are all different and this is similar to the other ones how they Everyone Every one of these games seem to have a cultist special ability. So all cultists have something unique about them based off who they are like the Yig his was the cultists are actual snake people. And if you fight them, they deal four damage of a combat. Do you think so? When he gains a doom doom doom token whenever a cultist is defeated or Oh, so he technically has one more Doom token. Oh, no. But he has a base attack, but then they add an expansion which has battle cards which affect things and then he has his own special cards.

Um but you're right, we've won games before where they awoke or we intentionally woke them up Yeah. to kill them. Yeah. Um Or like bring in all the dumb pieces. very, very difficult cuz whenever you fight them They they have like some Yeah, so each investigator must pass a speed plus one check or lose one sanity and stamina. It's modifier decreases by one each turn. So over time, it's like it's I think it's like it's poison. But he has a modifier of minus three, so it's like, "Great. Okay, well, I'm I'm really strong, so minus three isn't much." And I think each success you get, you remove Doom tracks from the Yeah. Yes. Uh in Eldritch, they have their own decks based off what happens. I don't think you ever really I don't think you fight the Ancient Ones in Eldritch. And in Arkham Horror, you have a scenario, so you don't know what your ultimate goal is.

Mhm. Uh so I do very much like the Ancient One system. I wish the Mythos deck was more geared towards them like it is in Eldritch Horror instead of just a Mythos deck of just random stuff that's that's happening that's not really tied to anything. Mhm. Like they're just there like, "Okay, well, this time the city is gripped by blackouts. Oh great, you closed the general store and you had to close the curiosity shop and the old magic shop." Oh, it's until the end of the next turn. So uh just stuff that is like, "All right, well, that's that." Mhm. Um it just seems everything's more more tight knit. Uh but other than that, very much love and I love this about all the other ones and they all do it. I love the encounter system.

Mhm. Yeah. That's probably my favorite thing about these games is the fact that, "Hey, if you're in uptown, if you're at the old magic shop, you have a separate encounter tied to that spot. Yeah, I love that it's color-coded. That is very nice, too, because it's easy to set up. And the other ones, all the expansions, have their own separate decks. Um, but yeah, you're like, it's like, "Okay, in the woods this time, this happens. I came across a cringing dog." But this next time, "Strange coins have been strewn about the glade, forming an odd symbol that pains you pains you to see." So, just a bunch of different things that can happen. And you will never like even when the first game came out, just the base game that I had, it was like eight cards. And in all reality, you're not going to unless you adamantly go to that spot all the time, you're never going to see them all.

And it's Fantasy Flight, so they just make a bunch of expansions. Like this is this is one or all the expansions for this. And every single time, it's just like, "Wow, we didn't even go to any of the red." So, you will never see all the content. So, every game will be completely different, which I very much like, which I do still like that over the scenarios because the scenarios will get stale. Like you you "Hey, we beat it. Great." Or probably not going to go back to that unless we're playing with new people. Right. But at the same time, this is not easy for new people to get into. No. Um, especially when people come in and they see all the stuff. They're like they're like terrified. And it's like I don't want to know."

Yeah, and it's like, "Don't worry." I thought you meant we were playing Candy Land. Yeah, it's like, "Don't worry." Most of the stuff will never show up. Yeah. But I have it out just in case it does, because you can become the deputy if you have a specific encounter at the police station, you could be like, "Oh, hey, oh great, I'm the deputy now, and I get all these deputy cards." So, it's just um I mean, nostalgia still it it does hold a special place Yes. in my heart as playing on the floor with like Back when it was small. Back with the game. Yeah, back yeah, when it just was the base game. Or even then. And they have a bunch of other stuff in here, too. Like with more people you can have relationships with each other, which both which give like me and like the person next to me a benefit and then you gain a benefit from someone else. So, but that just I almost never play with that. And none of the stuff you have to play with, but it's difficult to not just include it.

Like whenever I put the Mythos deck together, I was like, "Oh my god, there's a lot I just threw I just shuffled them all together." Like the the Mythos deck goes about here if you have all of them out. And so, whenever we were I was setting up, I was looking through and taking out, "Okay, well, this one doesn't even that that gate spot doesn't even exist in the base game." So, it's very hard to kind of pick and choose what you're including. So, ultimately I just shuffled I it all in together and I'm like, "Fuck it." But, it's I don't know. I don't know. Eldritch had the prelude cards, which you draw one and then if it it happens to be and if it's like if this thing if this is your ancient one, play with this. I thought that was a easier way to incorporate expansions, um, versus just having everything out on the table. Plus, it's a table hog.

Um, but yeah, it it's just nice. Um, I it it's clunky, but it's it's I just I have a I have a great time still playing it. So, Yeah. I'm trying to think of So, after all that you still like third edition better. Yeah, I said that at the beginning, too. Okay. Well, I wasn't sure if we we talked more about it. You're like, "Yeah, you know, actually third edition sucks." No. Um, it's interesting. What have I am curious Now that you've played this again, how come you still like third edition? Cuz it's more streamlined. Cool. Like yeah. I feel I feel like I said that. Um Yeah, it's just it's just it goes smoother. Um And it's it's just a lot less to take in.

Mhm. They Yeah, and I like how they Yeah, like again. Do you feel like it's more Like do you feel like you're actually going more through Arkham in third edition? No. You don't think so? No. Oh. Well. I just I do uh you know, to do Oh yeah, I like the layout of this one ironically. I do. I just do that. I definitely don't like the layout of this. I think it it literally just looks like some half-ass drawn map. Like it looks like a sketch that you were trying to do. Like okay, well, Rivertown's right here. And then you draw And then right down here is French Hill or something. I I feel like the third edition modular board I very much like. Uh that said, I'm versus just blah. Here's your spots. I like those. How how each site has their own artwork. Um But yeah, the board layout I I very much like over over this one.

Um That's all I got. That's all I got that I can think of. Uh scale one to 10. Give it a seven. A seven. That's where I'm at, too. Um cuz we both gave Arkham Horror third edition. You'll have to listen to that to find out. But yeah, I think a seven is is accurate. It is. But let us know what you think of Arkham Horror second edition in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone. Thanks so much for watching this. And if you like this video, then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out. And right next to that subscribe button is a little bell. Click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos. If you want to support the channel, you can definitely visit my Patreon page. The link is in the description below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day this is for you.

Progress saved