Morgane Gouyon-Rety talks History and Hubris
Transcript
hey gamers this is Liz Davidson from beyond solitaire and I am here with a very special guest with Morgan gue young pretty the designer of Pendragon what do they call you the mother of pin dragons is that your name now Jenna cannot do that so I can't use it for but you are a history buff and a fantastic war game designer so I just want to ask you about first I was looking through the notes for Pendragon that is your first published design how did it feel to jump into the deep end you know you just do it and then you realize afterwards I guess how big it was it's not my first design it is the first one which which gets released I was very the key to have guys I mean from Kalinka to start with who has been a big support for the development of the game actually becoming the lead developer or toward the second-half of development so obviously that was a huge help and then you know the staff had TNT I mean you there's not that many permanent staff but what there is and even the semi-permanent I mean they just know how
to do things so they let me TP do whatever I'm not going to say it was easy because it wasn't but at least need to be done and when and what you know that was part of the structure so I yeah it was so what wasn't that tough I mean I guess if you go self-publish and something it would be entirely different route I would consider at all there might be more money I don't know but I mean who don't do that for the money anyway so just know I mean honestly just getting published he's he's just fantastic so and then on top of it I mean people like to be do to be like all but seems interesting and that were three orders and then you understand in two orders so wow you know truly I mean you you come up and we have a subject matter that you don't basically there's no game for it so you just do your own game and then people gets interested and you actually get published and other people come and play your game and then you get feedback but these I mean I don't that wait so it sounds like you love the entire process of game design
maybe not the entire process but it wasn't that bad it's long that's that's the main thing it's so long but then as I mean vocal tells it all the times that again is never finished it's only get to reached but at some point you have to say okay I'm reasonably happy with what we have I don't avoid this which might be but you know what okay let's for the language here and get better you know ready and Pat no no fully you draw the line at you know place that makes sense I must say that as of today there is nothing with Pendragon that I wish we had differently so so fast it that's good um how how did you get into wargaming to begin with from what I understand you first make contact with folk up because you had a historical correction which means that you must have been playing and paying attention to organs for a while so how did it start for you I to wall gaming since I was about 10 oh wow yeah so growing up France but it wasn't as big as in the US but still we had we had a couple shops and games the big thing was that since most of the games were produced in the u.s. in English that was there was a language barrier at least initially so
we mostly relied on your French productions or Italian productions there was a fairly active Italian production at the time best TVs but not the same scale I hope you again swear like French English Italian Spanish cetera so so my very first war game was called idiot okay on the wall in Troy right terrible game but you know I can't walk into history I mean I was always I mean as far as I can remember I was completely mad about history I learned to read because I wanted to read history books which were everywhere in my grandparents and parents house so and I was already interested particularly interested in ancients and so when I read in some magazine or whatever I buy the game on you know the war in Troy I said yeah I want this for I think it was my birthday oh sorry and then I was like I played games before I mean I was playing with other stuff so the principle is it simply was a terrible game but but yeah and then then got some games found some guys to play with it's really kicked up
I think when I was in where engineering school was probably when it's really because there was a very active Club basically every night every weekend we'll be playing we had a very active stew you know that was the early 1990s we were starting to have internet email stuff like this so we were playing play by email diplomacy and other games so yeah that's how it started and then I started building my collection of games so yeah it's been a long time it's been a long time and then so in so you were mentioning work also in 2014 I had been when we were living in just outside of San Francisco at the time and so I started doing regularly to the GMT west weekends which were like a couple hours drive from from home and and so I have actually started working on it was not my first design project but it was like probably the most advanced I had tried yet which was not been ran so I was trying to pitch it to GMT getting some
feedback etc and then that's how I discovered the coin series and I think very initially like many players it was like what's his visa war game it's like color beats everywhere and understand what's going on - Matty's like trotted and the mess and the very first game was Andean Amazon Colombia and to be very honest with you I mean I was like the theme was like man so you know bees are messy no good thing so I stayed away which was a mistake by the way because it's a great game and then in some wave of con games there was very brave and a distant plane on Afghanistan and bats while I played in handful toward the Genting we can I think right after it was released if I'm not mistaken and actually you know in a group with some experienced players so I into the system and it was like wow yeah just open up a wound um of possibilities in terms of yes we can have really factional we can have sure a symmetry we can have you know interactions in so many different ways yeah it was Wow and then I think
fire in the lake wasn't testing at the time so the next weekend I actually played a player's game of fire on the lake and yes it was it was like a kind of liberation a war new domain of gaming application of historical modeling and conflict simulation etc and then I remember on that very occasion I know if you ever had the chance to go to GMT we can I mean these things end up very late at night because we play and we talked and we came over and we chat some more and you visit in bed at 2:00 in the morning and I remember one late-night discussion with some friends there and I was like when you are was working on actually went became finished and one guy asked me this very game you would like to you know some theme something you would really like to design and I was like yeah we'd really like to do something about the you know the the end of Roman rule particularly in Britain and but I don't know how to approach it and then probably about analogue months later you know all these things sort of percolate and and I can I can tell you
exactly where it was I was in my car stuck in a traffic jam okay oh yeah did famous for that going up toward the helicopter and bringing back home you've got nothing to do but think and I started sod off and I was like okay so the conflict in the roman retain is ready about different factions at odds at different levels and they will fight for different things and they sometimes we cooperate some trying to fight and it's all a mess and it's all like it's like a coin game and the thing was the jump I would say the conceptual jumpers were all the con game to date where Kong and counterinsurgency and there's no insurgency in Pendragon - all right I saw the con games for I think what they truly are which is asymmetrical conflicts multi factional conflicts covers counterinsurgency but other stuff too and so it started to and suddenly a lot of things that it makes sense and probably got stuck like an hour in traffic tele typical and when I finally arrived home you know I just went to my desk took a sheet of paper and started
German and these basic principles remained true today so the the foundation thing we do which were really what are the four factions were having relationships on we're aspects with the ten to collaborate on what aspect they tend to be in opposition etc and what would be the main drivers I would say 90% who was sent on that day now obviously it was something I had been reading about and thinking about for a very long time so it just came together but see you incubated for a while and ended up with the proper tool to moderate which was the columns engineer which the missing power because I'm not you look at the situation in Roman Britain at the end of the region there's no way you can simulate it with a traditional Morgan it's just to miss it so until we had something like Banco scavenging I don't think we could properly represent by bad situation smelting latest I can't disagree with that so you are a huge enthusiast for this period in history before I ask you about hubris what would you recommend as a book for people who
are interested in this period in the period of Pendragon to read alongside the game to kind of enrich their experience what's your favorite my favorite but unfortunately I think it's quite hard to find give me a sec yes so Edwin pace after and the four of Roman Britain the narrative history of PEEP century Britain mm-hmm this is not the most complete booty this is not the way the one I mean you won't have a full field for a period with this book but this is to me the one which presents the most interesting I'm not saying this is the final nuts with truth but it makes a lawful lot of sense to me having read I mean you probably seen the list of sources for Pendragon I mean I've literally have tens and tens of books on this period this is to me the one which which actually I read roughly shortly before well no that's not from 2009 good anyway it's it's the one which to me was the most influential in shaping the basic structure of the relationships between factions especially of the very interesting rule of fidelity in this contract and and
especially in and I've read most everything about alpha at least what could be the historical alpha I'm not that much interested a little bit not that much into the mythical but it always tends to be very black and white you know and being myself descended from you know Breton family so basically from exile written tend to obviously see after as the last one we fought for us but this book to me demonstrate he but it was probably a lot messier than what history tells us which is in my opinion makes it much more interesting but also sort of gave me the all backs how everything stored into place with the really factional aspects with the symmetrical aspect so that could be the one there's many of us I mean I'll check the pan dragons videography it's very very extensive until it is not what it has it oh that's that's the thing and and again you may be more interested in like the daily life you might be more interested in the brief and exciting the Germanic side service there's so many aspects that needs to be taken into account that I try to capture to some extent in Pendragon but there is not just one book
which which has it yeah there never is I guess but so let's talk about I'm pretty sure that that first advanced design that you're talking about is hubris correct which is now going to be coming out soon so why don't you tell us about it right so I've got I always had a lot of interest for for the Celtic world and get history but there is actually one period of history where I'm even more interested in that ancient Greece to some extent tension room and especially what we call the arena stick period which is the period which starts we the death of Alexander after his campaigns in Asia and his conquest of the Persian Empire up to basically the Romans taking over the eastern Mediterranean so it's to me it's fascinating in many ways because first it's like bleep it on me of any culture when it met with the Torah of agriculture from the ancient world conquest through establishing these new kingdoms and there was a huge fusion of cultures of religions of science of which led which which I'm convinced is actually the foundation of how acid
ization the Romans except for the legal aspect which are very the real Roman are only the perpetrators of what the Hellenistic period did for us both in terms of art in terms of science in terms of philosophy etcetera so I always found it a fascinating period historically and then from a gaming point of view it's I actually came about this period by kind of accident it was 1992 and at least the way Greek history is taught in France and I'm sure it's not that different oh it was not that different in the US was you would know everything about you know the the medicals the Peloponnesian War the rise of Athens democracy blah blah blah and then the concrete by philip ii Alexander's father and then the compound of an extender and then Rome where we knew about maybe Italian I we knew about a few things but each was I mean honestly if you had like one paragraph in the history book but was it so I knew nothing nothing of the actual political history or militaries through your back clear and then in 1992 so I
was sitting in German school and there's there was it unfortunately doesn't exist anymore there was a great game magazine not only wargames also you know were playing games that sort of thing in trance called so in French Casas be nice okay castles very case for Ward metal and and the other again most issues probably and that one which was called live yet look so the yellow code was the terms in creeks for the successors of Alexander and it was a kind of diplomacy violent and we looked at it with my friends were playing diplomacy already and we looked at it and it was wrong sounds well I mean it was it had some interesting to it so we played it and we're like oh but search to protect balance situation etc it must be completely artificial because we knew these guys right but Stevens so when I when I came home and I started some digging and I realized no it wasn't obviously that been simplified and but though it was based on actual facts and we discovered I discovered that some of my friends were with me at a time and we were like gosh that's the most perfect situation for war game that
you may ever see because basically the situation is Alexandra dies just complete the biggest Empire but the world had ever seen at a time and these lieutenants were all incredibly gifted and who are total experience from the campaign's well Taoiseach we have the same resources the same means same military technology there is no ideology whatsoever it's pure personal ambition okay there are so these guys off I mean I'm defending the interest of the young king or whatever but it's basically it's naked personal ambition these guys are all huge far talented big personalities you know and and we fight it out for forty years it's it's you know the closest parallel at which think of his just imagine that Napoleon actually managed to prevail in Europe you know basically winning against Russia so how you know forcing Britain to make peace and then dies living on your own hair and you got all these marshals fighting for peace I think that's the closest equivalent you
could dream of you know huge talent love qualities big personalities and technologies and weapons it's pure personal ambition there's no ideology there's no massacre is less no whatever it's perfect ground for a war game or again like this so that's how it started so we started babbling on the game on the on the period then never came to anything like a playable prototype and for sure a lot of successors the game by Maxima niche and we shall bear I think both the ever Anil and then the GMT version still probably one of my preferred games even flake would speak for hours about everything that is wrong with this game but anyway see ya regret game and so I always add this and then so in 2013 I had actually been working on something else I mean I was trying to universe the ancient war series by Richard Burke which has two volumes yeah right again great ideas terrible execution in my opinion but anyway and but the ambition of this series was to recreate an operational level campaigns of the ancient world and I was like hey I want to see the companion of the successors so I started actually
drawing by hand the maps for the entire eastern Mediterranean all the way to Iran at the ancient war scale yeah I got that someone but anyway and then I was like actually it started this way I was one night I was playing with a colleague of mine was a guy from Texas by the way and he played you know we had played war games when he was younger and not played for I don't know how many years and so that's who we're colleagues like what's telling him about what we're doing so I introduced him to some of the newer games and we had Twilight Struggle that night and as I was putting away the game and I got a complicated relationship with Troy that's true I mean I admired the game and how its polished and everything I just hate the theme and I hate I don't I don't like to play that just admire the wait stop anyway so I was like such a great game too bad it's not on the Steam I actually be careful and something you have been stopped coming together and so I was like but you know what the Layton mystic period when you know not the period where the kingdoms were being forged but
when they were established and fighting for supremacy and then Rome was starting to intrude into the into the region so it's like wow it's a little bit difficult but it left on you you can actually fight well so understanding you know things started coming together and and so every start life as a kind of derivative of to Alex real or applied to the latent mystic period and that's basically where I pitched to GMT but here because I didn't make a playable prototype just when I did all right and so you know that's the difference between having an ID and adding a project when you can start actually playing with it well first thing you immediately see what works what doesn't work at least 90% of it but if it's only in your mind you get very complex and very clever things but there are blind spots because you cannot test it just by ok I'm playing this and why can I do I should be able to do this ok and you go back to the drawing board and then the next thing is you can play with other guys and then you get feedback because again when you design you design based on what
you know and you play based on what you know so in a way you are not stretching the model a lot because you are a prisoner of your understanding of this difficult period you taken someone from a different you know comes at it from the first time probably never heard about it and he stops doing stuff and you're like hey you you shouldn't be able to do that well where is it recruited and then you start thinking like ok so they didn't do it historically could they have done it if they could that's ok if they couldn't then you have to do something about the roots all about you know the capacities or whatever so I mean so that was it and so I was working and playing and polishing that there shall feel breeze for about a year about a year I mean interesting process especially for the first time designer and and then this idea but Pendragon came up but my biggest concern which Pendragon was hey every coin system has been set in modern times or nearly modern times at the time there was no falling sky there was I mean liberty or death was in pre-order and even leave a Childress to many many aspects is much like a modern coin so so I was like is
that even an option am I crazy are they even going to consider going way out of there's no insurgency there's back sort of thing and at the time I didn't have a prototype it was just a concept anyone know number of sheets of paper with IDs and backgrounds and tables and wearing thin July I think of that here gently announced falling sky and obviously being French loving Celtic history and I was like wow you need to be and and so but then part of my man was like hop so okay so they are ready to go back in history and so I contacted might be at with Shelley who at the time was the con series developer when you from met him a number of times in Hansel so I gave him a call and I'm like to know Mike I just so fun excitement so these three the day it was you know the newsletter came out and said man you know what if you need someone to declare this thing or help with you know research or whatever like access to French text or I would be delighted to hand and he was like okay
thanks I'll let beaucoup know blah blah blah and then he and then we start chatting you know what I mean you doing rabbits etc and some I don't know why I mentioned that I had been toying with his concept of a again which was actually not named Pendragon at the time and he was like Oh tell me more about it just the concept and so I I did and then next thing I know I get an email from volcko say tell me everything you're
working with from the sky and so I remember spending most of my summer actually doing your order of back and forth on falling sky and working on Pendragon I remember especially I think we spent two weeks in France with my parents in San Fran Fran so leave the you know the time difference yeah you know I would basically first thing in the morning I would get everything which I come during the night review eat answer make my suggestions then I would switch to Pendragon I mean my parents hated me because I was on my computer all the time we actually found the time with my family to go and because the place of my parents in central central highlands of friends is actually a couple hours drive from the site of Jabalia the one of the big battles between Caesar and the center towards for some reason I had driven by but never actually gone and visiting it so we did that I think I was done was 2014 he was like fallen half loved it I mean it's very interesting there's actually several locations some very interesting
archaeological digs I mean it's yeah it was Excel and took picture I think one of his picture service so he has an illustration for one of the even cars in the game anyway so that was a very busy time and then we thought it was like okay I would like to see your well not Pendragon at the time it had a Latin name penny was it was named the provisional title was they exceed you Tanya okay which is basically the title of get baths essay which is one of the few primary sources for for the kid we found that it was talked to and then we want for something how could they exceed yoga Kanye anyway so so the target was like okay let's say and volcko was coming to the Ghent us we can the for weekend which which is in October and so the target was like let's have a prototype ready for October remember we're like August right well nothing ok ok things going on in my life in here so so I do that and then toward
the end of August or early September we're back in San Francisco and I get a call or message from volcko and he said hey by the way I'm going to be in San Francisco meet September I'm invited to a game design convention whatever and by the way you should come and it would be great if you can show me the game and so you just get like your mom's from a very tight schedule so anyway I did manage to have something which was kind of playable why not playable but not complete when Volvo was was in San Francisco in like mid September he liked it and then and then we had Bitcoin at the GNT West weekend but October which we actually confessed Matata we add I mean we're presenting so fire in the lake was just recently released we had little children p500 we had my game plus Ken his game on the Philippines also in development think there was another one I mean we had a forward section so that's how Pendragon
came to be that's basically when Gina and volcko said yes we want to have it on the on the schedule and when I put the grease on the side right well couple yes yeah so then as I was going through pen dragons development I was sometimes going back to rebreathe so evolving but not much and then the more I basically I guess the more I learn we've been draggin the more dissatisfied I came to be with her briefs as it was and especially I guess I have been drifting away from the original trailer so template quite a bit already but I realized that this template was actually kind of forcing me into a direction which was not what I wanted to put in Phase II song okay so so once Pendragon was completed and then not right away because I went through a best floor period ban which stopped me for quite some time but anyway when I finally came back to it I was like I got that friend I mean the period the basic model surprise right but the focus is wrong hmm and you know try that struggle in the way is a very I might say Marxist
approach to to the pier individuals are not mentioned or in a very marginal way the more I was thinking and reading and we going back to my sources and and maybe it's wrong but the history of the ancient world is very much driven by individual peasants maybe it's wrong but I don't think it's wrong I think that the structure of states natural political organizations etc was very much centered on individuals and and so that was to a large extent I mean it was it was modeled in a way but not not in a way which prevents center stage right I felt that was very wrong so I basically told on everything and we started from scratch and so I redesign who is entirely and when I redesign it the second time still on the main axis to be leader centric and the main the main the basis you will the building block of the of the hubris system is that you don't have a hand of cards like you would have in a traditional CDG I have a court of leaders you've got your
king and then and then you have his friends which is by the way and this story could turn up at the time yes the advisers of the DC Kings were called fellow his friends which goes all the way back to the old Macedonian court where they were probably truly friends I mean later on because more the honorific title but still that was the title and so these guys and a couple ladies our students and witnesses some stuff they do that it's not about subbu dad there's some sisters they actually stink off of the act and another houghton characteristic is just how reliable they are are they loyal do they tend to do a lot of intrigue you know and so to some extent so instead of being right I got a hand of cards and some cards are good some cats are bad how can I maximize the impact of the good ones and minimize the impact of the bad ones which is what most CDG's are about here it's about okay I got some stuff to do to do anything I need to appoint someone so that it goes off she goes and does it and I got only a limited number of guys I can truly rely on so it's a matter of resource
management it's like human resources and then it should be this you know decision should be okay well your king usually is one of your own list is reliable is not going to obviously betray you but it tends to be fairly effective not all of them but most of them well but they cannot do everything so you got to you know to use over guys so you need to have a secondary company maybe to go crush the rebellion somewhere this guy is very good but is you're cruising and he's ambitious can you trust him with an army send this guy we safe Birds not so good you know maybe he's not going to lose that war but maybe instead of crushing it in one compare is going to drag on and drive with so season for a long time right do you have this guy as personal relationship with that city you aren't so I want to you know strike strike an alliance with that city I should send in that but it's also good at administration and I need backed a stick in Cairo so you have only a limited number of activations limited number of guards and that's the main engine of the game that was really fun I think it's very appropriate to the period because it was so personal in terms of power and networks but I think this is actually true of many other time periods
and I mean whenever I talk OB system I mean guys I know it could be great for you know mythologies or that could be great for you know late for man it could be great for the ceiling wall it's I think it has a lot of relevance for pretty much any period at least until you get into kind of industrialized countries mm-hmm if you might makeup on sometimes but but that's probably where I would sort of cut off use of such a system but but I know for instance Pendragon basically stops when you are the sort of chaotic a number of small kingdoms warlords fighting each other and and I'm thinking about doing a photo op which would be calling which would be said for me about 400 years later during the Viking Age oh okay but but in between there was a lot of interesting stuff going on and it was intensely personal you know kingdoms and we think of kingdoms like Murcia Northumbria all with sex or Gwyneth and but the truth is that none of these kingdoms had any sort of last institutions and structure they rose and fell with the Kings when there was a
brilliant or worthless or lucky or whatever individual probably managed to get a couple good you know competent guys with him at that time you achieve great stuff and then he died and usually he just crumbled as soon as he died yeah so so I think that would be an interesting way to approach his period as well I can see that so I have an appreciative out hereis as somebody who makes solo BOTS for it I know you're not a big solo player yourself but it's funny because we actually had an interesting discussion with DES Aqualand recently and we talked about it there is an element of very support in here is because one of the design choices I made is about the players are the idealistic kids room is a lone player who it it goes it has its own rules one of the thing I want to present is but this was an alien power they didn't think the same way they didn't work the same way didn't go by the same rules and this is something which by the way the historical kings took a long time to recognize this is by the way one
of the big difference why actually wrong is not a desk on like and Twilight Struggle no but the tension between the west and the east during the Cold War was actually very understood each other very well right and their direct lines of communication and in you know the red phone and that sort of thing where they could communicate and I would say you know make sure that tension could go down by a direct communication there was no such thing at the time the allistic kings were faced with a completely alien in and that it took them probably at least fifty years before we started to trust what they were dealing with and how these people were thinking hands a lot of thing and that's why it cannot be a player we cannot negotiate with ROM you cannot know this and this that has to be an element of randomness because originally it was very good tourist role is very deterministic and it was wrong because players would know exactly when to stop I can go up to bat point and not father their historical counterpart should not do that they did not have Bethan standings so it has to be an element of randomness they could know that something might draw the higher of you know wrong but they were never sure sometimes they were completely you know blindsided by what was going on so
Romy's a non player so how do you handle room the way is that the game is a free play again it could be play to play or film easy but so wrong initially I developed a full-fledged but with charts and logics and everything because my fear was that players obviously as cognizant of the historical events as I am we were exactly what happened and we do everything they can to keep Rome out of the game because you know you don't want to bring the war thing to but and so it was very clunky and heady twelve Bernie twelve was not fun so some day and I was observing a players we're playing and I'm like I don't think I need that so I did she and instead I set a set of guidelines so Rome at the given time you have you have some cards which give you a sort of status what the situation is in Rome so at any given time Rome as an agenda and they can go through different agenda for the game basically the augment is going to grow there is the status of their war with cottage because this is the time of the second Punic War which kind of have it be as a migrant weather so on and then
you are general guidelines Rome will try to do this I've got I got a set of cards which I call the Roman wall cards which basically whenever you need to have Rome activate you draw one of these cards and they will tell you okay so they gather diplomacy action they get a comp an action they get Batmen you know that many troops are variable but many sheets available and that's it they don't tell you what wrong we do it is the player of the kingdom with the most because kingdoms can acquire influence in the Roman Senate just like you acquire influence on other cities obviously you cannot control the Roman Senate you can only get some degree of nutrients so the player with the highest influence in the Senate at the time of the war leads Rome assuming of course that they are not themselves at war with Rome then we go to the next one if there is a tower you take the players with the least victory points and the resolves from action using the resources under the constraints and the guidelines but the system said buddy it's actually finished or you got two cards and then you have like half of a player it's or guidelines and it works it works great and my original concern that player would try to keep from out of you
know no way because when you are in the you know the big conflict and you are anybody coming you want better to I mean it works in a perfect way and if we produce what they actually did then we winner but so it works as soon as we are players gotta if if it is a single player it would be a lot more contracts and then so I'm currently so I haven't developed a solar system yet if there is to be a certain system and I guess GMT will probably insist there is because that's the trend I want the system to be you know we've seen some very interesting things happening with little Gandhi there our unit system and plumbing is burning and what's coming up with subsea she etcetera where you use cards and not so much tables and charts and flowcharts so I definitely want something on the lighter side be very something and I will definitely ask for the someone and one of the big heads good at solar systems that we engineer over it you know there's Orion or Jason boosts to
help me with my back sister but the truth is that I'm not entirely certain we need one and let me explain there is no hidden information whatsoever in the game which means that the game I mean I tend to play storoe games in god modem and playing all factions as as you know as long as there is no hidden information that's why CDG's are in this respect because you do handle the hidden hand but here there is no hidden information so it actually works very fine same thing with the con game has no hidden information in the con game so do you really need a solo but I'm not sure because tech pendragon the the if you take the rule book of Pendragon I think 60% of the rule book is a lone player rules which I'm grateful for so what it is what I mean is that they did you a feel for the the relative complexity of the base rooms right in the loan payable I see them up there rooms as a layer that you have to sue impose yes over the basic rules and this is a lot and it is very complex and you I just see I mean I am I'm managing the bgg page for Pendragon so I see all the questions coming up I would set for the
three quarters of question afternoon with none Belarus I believe it but the other thing is true though is that solar players at least in my experience from you know I'm sort of coming towards war games from out of right people tend to not want to play both sides they want to have something to go up against and I know that I think I think people who come to solo through wargaming are more used to playing both sides I think that solo players from outside of where gaming might feel differently if that makes sense absolutely I think you're right I think you are thinking right yes that's definitely a kind of different sensitivity to that I know I know myself I mean I'm not playing that many dedicated solo games I do play some who think we are though we share a appreciation for the walls of Marcus Aurelius but but most of these games and I think one of the reason I like this game is that well I'll play Warsaw Pact two soldiers and it doesn't feel I'm not saying it's not but it doesn't feel like you're playing against a super raid system the army boots or sandals by which you are playing and and which is going to make you lose whatever ninety percent of the time as a player I find this very frustrating I want to be in a
fair situation states of siege some of them are pretty good but I mean I got one on depression in young war which is come to another title from DBT this game is horrible I mean if we just draw enemy leaders in whatever order you tended the very good British tons of resources at the start of the war which is completely unstable it has no real it bears no relationship whatsoever with reality or with Anna's you see what I mean if there is if there were an excellent you know artificial intelligence against me playing with the same rule and beating me in a fair you know wrong thing yes I would love that but you can't not increment that on a on a go game it's just - hey so so most of the solo games are just so heavily weighted against the player that's even a perfect combination sequence or a lot of luck to win and I what's the point you see what I mean it's it's not fair it's not put and to me if it's not fair it's not further if it's not realistic it's not fun yeah I think we solo players like to lose a lot I mean there are definitely eyes that
are better and as it worse but we I think as a group of people who game like to have a low chance of winning cuz then when you do win it's like yes because I mean if you're playing by yourself you know you have to have the challenge from I would say the euro gaming but that's probably broader than that I think and when you are presented you in the solar system which is super tough essentially you are solving a widow but it's different every time it's if it's pure luck then there is definitely zero interest I think yeah so if it still when you are trying to crack the game that's what you're trying to do and that's fine I mean I'm not saying it's the morality I'm just saying it's entirely different from playing a war game when I play a war game when I historical simulation I want to experience the dynamics the constraints the viewpoints of the actual persons who were involving that I'm not solving a riddle I'm not trying to find you this is what until cause the third I've done and there's only one good answer for maybe there's a couple answers I have no that's not interesting if only because once you've cracked it you're done I want to have the richness of interactions I want to get a feel for what constrains what world views what
prejudices etcetera shipping the way they saw the world and interacted with each other and with the world I don't want to crack a riddle I think that's the big difference I think I think that as solo games progress that that experience is getting better so I was very impressed with what what Kahn is able to do for example impacts from here I think that we are as we play as a solo gaming develops I do think this little AI is getting better I'm excited for how it's gonna be but so we were talking about before I let you go I just want you to tell me what have you been playing recently that you are really liking most of my time recently has been devoted to Febreze and other things now I started I started laying the foundations for my orbit following game so I've been spending a lot of time when I'm not doing your twisting because victory is down to the kind of systematic mechanical you know like writing the rules double-checking everything's consistent doing the key index terms checking references checking is consistent with the player ads and the event count etcetera so it's important but it's not the turn of firm let's be let's be honest so I need the creative freedom of starting even you get so I've been spending a lot of time
with add another games set in Hellenistic times by the way I don't know if you want to talk about it but then I give it a game but okay so the the provisional title for it is Dmitry odd after two historical characters the materials of parallels and Dimitrios the city taker sort of Antigonus so essentially this is again this this will be a con game three player which will be set in the city of athens in the late fourth century BC it's about fashion politics in the midst of a global war so essentially the factions will be regards the democrats and the king king of Macedon yep and they all trying to push their own agendas I mean base you know fun stuff while the city is so obviously I mean the city is no longer fully independent as it used to be but still do the institutions and it's a state function to some extent and there is this workers trouble between Macedon and Antigonus and so the materials and so they play a role because they are trying you know to influence and to gain influence etc so
but-but-but Antigonus individuals again will be an ontario thing that won't be a player and and I'm I'm interested in these dynamics of the between the three factions so yeah I'm I'm quite excited by this but as it stands I have kept you while Morgan thank you so much for coming on the channel to talk to me to talk to all of us and everybody and leave us leave us some comments if you have anything to say about our conversation sure happy gaming everybody