Planet Unknown - Board Game Review - This Is A Solo Mission
Transcript
thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk Kinder stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on audio is over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to keander and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so on today's show thanks to kiender who have sponsored me with a review copy for this particular title Planet unknown man was I trying to get this play for a long time I mean the amount of Buzz I've seen for this game from reviews and from people that I knew and seen it played at my Portsmouth Club I was like I want to try this game but I didn't want to jump in on the kickstarter because I've been trying to hold back on those and it kind of like came out as a Kickstarter bundle and sold out immediately and all of a sudden we've now got the retail box which again keeps sending out pretty quickly especially as it's been nominated for a Kenner Spiel award so that's a big deal naturally everybody's trying to hunt this game down and so I was Keen to try it even though I've not heard of Adam's
Apple games and it's like oh okay this is brand new this will be interesting will it work will it not but it's got mechanics that I do enjoy the question is are they worth it and have we seen it all before Planet unknown is a polyomino space game so put the Box the right way up that might help essentially you have this giant Lazy Susan Contraption in the middle of the table and we'll get onto components in a minute but essentially this spins around and you get to select the tiles based on where your station is and again based on number of players you have a specific Faction board with tracks that you level up resources on and can give you special Tech bonuses and abilities but you also then have a map which can either be a generic map or it could be an asymmetric map which could be all sorts of things like having a chasm in the middle to being entirely encased by water that was quite a fun one the other day and you know having weird electric currents you know they've got all sorts of different weird and wonderful effects so how does the game work well with this Lazy Susan thing in the middle you you choose which station you want in a multiplayer game this is and say you know what I could use this tile here everybody else simultaneously picks from the pair of options that they have and decide which tile they want they then place it on their map subject to the usual placement restrictions you see in every one of these games start at the perimeter and then Place adjacent to one you've already done not diagonal can't overlap the grid can't go overlapping the tire you know all the stuff we've seen what the terrain tiles do is that they add resources to your
technology tracks here of which you've got different colors for black blue red green and gray I think gray white something like that and basically as these level up not only do they score you more points but they get you various abilities like special bonus cards Green Forest tiles that you can place to fill up gaps you know new technologies and you can play normal mode or you can play asymmetric mode where you have a unique set of tracks and text for yourself as well as having the combination of having that with a unique map for yourself that can lead to some pretty decent combos there now in terms of components gotta say very impressed for the price you pay for this game which I think is somewhere within the 50 to 60 pounds Mark which is not the cheapest thing for a game you still get quite a bit in this box I mean firstly this is really cool it works it's fine yes a couple of tiles may fall off in the box if you jiggle it around too much that's a slight Downer but honestly for something that works as well as this this is pretty impressive for a polyamino game to have I mean imagine if Baron Park had something like this and made that one a quicker one to set up and you know what I mean when I talk about Baron Park but on top of that you've got a lot of these different you know where have you got here you've got wooden pieces you've got big chunky plastic Rover pieces and you move these around the map to collect things like meteorites that fall down and life pods for more points but then you've also got the cards themselves and in terms of the actual boards I'm gonna have to tip the box it's the only way it's going to work here we go put that on the floor you've got a lot of these boards this
game's got a decent amount of variety in the Box for the money that you are spending on it as well as good Spacey artwork and clear to follow tiles so component wise pretty solid although not happy that you made Variety in the game a Kickstarter exclusive I don't approve of that merchandising you've got a decent amount of variety in this box I think six different maps and six different technology boards great the rule book though at the back has rules for another like six of these I think another six of each of Technology tiles um Corporation sorry and asymmetric planets I don't like being told and reminded of what I don't have okay you know why were they not in the game you want to add another Fiverr to the game but give me 12 planets and 12 boards that would be fantastic but I don't approve of Kickstarter exclusives being variety for the game that sort of thing is important enough to put in your bags you want to upgrade the components fine this is the retail copy of the game and I think the components are decent for a retail copy you want to upgrade those fine you want to do linen finish rule book fine you want to make this nice and shiny and painted fine but actual gameplay editions shouldn't that really be Kickstarter exclusives it's not a practice I'm a fan of but I digress I'm probably getting ahead of myself there you know in terms of the gameplay if you played a polynomial game before you've kind of seen this stuff before as well I mean it's I find polyomino games quite fun the idea that you go right I'll put
the piece there now this gun could fit nicely in there oh I've blocked myself up hang on uh need this time right okay cool we can put that in there and you're trying to pair the different resource tiles together because you're trying to either sometimes create big groups of them or you just want to level up specific tracks so you need hmm I need the green and the red is there a green and the red combo there no but if I use the yellow in the red close enough I can deal with that okay yeah it's impossible with a lot of the sort of spin this and go wee at times it just kind of happens or maybe that's just me I don't know no sir I didn't see you playing with your dolls again good I like a lot of the aspects of this game from a gameplay perspective you know the different tracks are all useful um I haven't played it enough to notice if there's an imbalance with some of the technology like technology tracks all the planets they've got different complexity ratings that are listed on there but honestly I think that the combinations are quite vast for a retail copy that I haven't really noticed one that's broken per se but you know you'd have to play it a million times for that to be a problem here's where the game filters a little bit though the player scaling for this it doesn't quite work because this is the game that takes supposedly takes 17 minutes to play you're looking at more 90 minutes with more players because yes it's simultaneous but you're only as fast as your lowest common denominator and the more players you add the more time that's added so you are definitely looking at a 90 minute Affair for this it could drag on past that if you've got some AP players who are waiting to sort of go hang on I need to uh can I look at
the tile first and check it fits before I get it on my board no God please no no but the main problem with player scaling is that the other players in the game don't do jack for you there's no reason they're there all you have is a set of objective cards which essentially you play out between your neighbors as a common objective so uh here we go have the largest single area of tech terrain the single largest water a single large Forest there's energy whatever rinse repeat have the most unique air unique Technologies I have the least Water Resources whatever they're mostly concerned about what type of terrain you've built you have one between you and each neighbor that is it that is the entire amount of multiplayer interaction in this game a little objective what the hell is like that is it yeah because the whole selection of the thing here you might think well hang on what if you select a tile that you know others can't use if you have the cognitive power and the eyesight to be able to look at four or five other boards that are this big okay this big with tiles all over it and their technology tracks and deduce what piece they're gonna want from all of those in a mass multiplayer game then kudos to you you are a friggin genius all right most of us aren't so the whole concept of choosing a thing here is literally for yourself only I don't care what the other players do I want a long straight this is what I want if he gets a t he
gets an L he gets a tiny little one there I honestly don't care and that's the problem yes you can play this with six players but there's no real reason why you would because it just adds time yeah but your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could they didn't start to think of you think all right well I'll just play this uh two players then the problem is well a sense of problem it depends on your perspective in the multiplayer game you can select whichever tile you like in a two-player game though it rotates one each time so you plan ahead as to which tiles you like that I kind of like more though and I think about it because the in multiplayer it's random what tiles you get and in six players it's just the luck Fest you know one every six turns I get to pick the time I want the other five turns I might as well just close my eyes and go you know whatever there you go that's my tail I could do that to myself I don't need five other players at the table to simulate that level of Randomness so at least with two players you know what tiles are coming so you can plan ahead for them and in Solo mode which honestly is pretty much the main way I'll play this game it works in a similar fashion you have an event deck which you can add as a multiplayer variant but frankly I don't see the point in adding it as a multiplayer variant it's got green alert yellow alert and red alert cards that go up in the scale of how bad they are you construct this deck which augments your target score for the game and then you pretty much play the exact same game you did before with a technology track a planet and this and it rotates one each turn so you know what tiles are coming up so it's pretty much a two-player game
with one less player and an event deck that's essentially what it is you know beat the target score and win it's not beat your own score thankfully but solo just feels like the way I want to play it because I get the fun aspect and I know I've ran I've ragged on it a little bit for the last 10 like five odd minutes but the game gameplay itself is still fun I think this is a really cool engaging you know polyamino puzzle and partially it's because of the wide variety of tile shapes you've got and these technology tracks but I think one of the main aspects is just because I do find these asymmetric planets good fun I mean I will never play the basic Planet I'll give it to someone they are teaching the game to and ask if they want to use it but honestly I'm taking a you know asymmetric Planet every single time I want to try Persephone and next time I want to try Petra next time I want the the water Planet you know and they do create really different things I mean a Gaia for example you know wants you to pick up life pods because they're worth more points to potentially chew on here but the last game we played I played this one the whole planet is encased in water you have to place water tiles like on water entirely in order to get the resource or sorry it has to be touching water but here you can't do that you have to place them on solid water or not they can't overlap ground and so because you've got all these water spaces on there you're kind of thinking well oh okay when do I build on the land and do I maximize water or do I decide I'm not too fast it's they create vastly different play Styles which is
why I'm still angry that they put six of them as Kickstarter exclusive yes I've heard that they are going to sell them as separate retail packs later but that's a kind of screw you give me money type approach which I'm not a fan of if you'd have put 12 of each of these in the game for that 60 pound price point oh my word I'd have been singing the Praises of this from a variety standpoint that being said there is still a good amount of variety here for the 60 pounds but there could have been more the fact that there could have been more and it chose to make it exclusive just irks me a bit it's not something I want to see other Publishers start doing okay Cosmetics are good for exclusives actual gameplay additions aren't although don't start sticking random untested expansion content in there don't do that a couple other little aspects to mention the rule book is pretty clear I mean it's a nice big size rule book it's got a decent amount of pictorial examples and text is not too small I didn't find it too difficult to read this I understood the game from one read through of this and I was able to teach it without too much trouble and you do have a good glossary of turns on the back although again reference card proper player would be preferable but this game is not too complicated so this should be enough I can sort of let it slide a bit in this one but there is one little Annoying aspect with the stations part of it because I said that you pick tiles from which station is in front of you how do you know which station is in front of you this has a very big table presence it is a huge table hog when you've got
multiples of these and these next to everybody and this in the middle trust me this is going to take up a lot of space on your table but when you have different numbers of players where do you sit around this thing you essentially have a little arrow that you use that's it a cardboard arrow is the only way I can tell you that this is the station I want if that Arrow shifts at any point though every time somebody spins it and goes all right this is the tile I want inevitably they will stop it in such a way that somebody is going to ask uh well is it the left one or the right one because now the arrow is literally pointing in between because somebody wasn't isn't precise with their alignment that gets annoying very quickly particularly in games of three four or five well four players if you're sat perfectly around this thing is fine three players though five players those are numbers that are pretty screwy with this whole series of Susan and you're gonna get that said a lot I'm gonna be like all right which tile am I picking left or right thank you you know that just gets irritating a lot you know this little cardboard token is not enough it would have been nice if they kind of separated them out a little bit clearer on here you know I mean I don't think you could have made this any bigger I don't think that would have been a solution but it's just one of those annoyances you have to worry about with multiplayer again it's another cross on the list of why I would want to play this multiplayer if the idea is cool I want to play a game with lots of friends and this one can cater for that many there are other games that will cater for a lot of players and yet be quicker
and smoother I mean do I need to go back to Seven Wonders yes it's not polyomino but that works but then I could also play something like Alice's Garden you know it's my one of my favorite polyamino games at the moment 20 minutes the game is done I can play it with four players and it works just fine for players I don't often need five or six and if I do end up with six players typically I'm splitting into two groups of three anyway but I get that not every group Works in that fashion so overall I do enjoy the gameplay of this a lot you know this is a really good fun game as much as I've ragged on the player scaling aspect leveling up the tracks trying out the different planets trying to balance out what you're gonna do with these polyaminos especially in a Solo mode is really cool and I think that's why you've got to be mindful of who you're playing this with for me I'm giving kind of unknown from my perspective in eight out of ten it is a great game despite the flaws I've mentioned but it is an 8 out of ten if you're prepared to play the solo if solo gaming is not your thing and you only intend to play this with three plus players that rating is gonna creep down at Max 7 possibly even a 6 out of 10 in fact I would definitely give this a lower rating if you start putting five or six players in this so you know this is an eight for me because I can play it solo which is my preferred way to play it I'll play this with three players three players is not too bad you but then again you've got the randomness of the multiplayer selection but at least it's a bit easier to look at two other maps and see what they want rather than
five but I just don't see any point in going above three players for this at all and of course the fact that the tile selection is essentially random you know you add more players you just add more Randomness with all the other side still impressed with the price of the box but what you're getting in the retail Edition the amount of variety that's in here despite that Kickstarter annoyance there's still a lot of good things to say about this game just bearing in mind how many you're gonna play this with make that your decision for wanting this game for yourself so that's it for me on this episode of the broken people if you like what you see then please remember I thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on Board Game Geek when the review goes live get your comments down below what do you think about the game do you not care about the player count what are the maps that I haven't been able to play like those Kickstarter exclusive maps are they any good I don't know you're telling me what I can't have for now but still I'd like to know your thoughts on your on the game itself any broken combos that kind of thing let me know your thoughts but until next time you can check out more content on the show including other reviews I'm doing recently including Moon from Sinister fish games and mind bug from nerd lab games check out those two when they go live I don't know what order I'll do the three of them in but by all means just catch them when they do until next time regardless of how much you're gonna get obsessed with wanting to spin this loads it's still only a game bye for now thank you