Skip to main content
Loading video...

Oathsworn: Into the Deepwood Review - No Right to be This Good

Transcript 31:06

hello my babies today we'll be talking about the world's biggest baby oh Swan just how big is it well it's bigger than my entire vinyl collection bigger than my entire role-playing game collection and bigger than my entire wife hello don't say collection anyway this looks stupid why in the world are we Aker game where even it's forklift just to get it to the table no no don't say it don't you dare say it it's really good oh Swan flies in the face of everything we hear at nobody included stand for but let no one ever tell you that I'll stop us from recognizing a fantastic game despite its price and size and mountains of plastic and representation literally everyone in this game is white and feminine characters posing like that parody Avengers poster I have to admit this shot is all of our preconceptions and reveals itself to be the smartest design of this entire decade it's on here three year old decade but that's not the point the point is that oswan has absolutely no right to be this good and yet it is let's take a brief overview of what this game is trying to achieve first it's one of those grandiose crunchy tactical fantasy rpg-like experiences you have your archetypal characters for example in

Archer that's also a tree that fires arrows plugs from its own skin gross but exciting there's a bear with an ax and it's a bear and it also has an ax and let's not forget your typical sword dude who really needs to get out more look at him old dour could do with a night out this fella right here though he goes out too much talking of going all out with most games tactical crunchy combat as they say in Yorkshire that'll do oh Swan says hold my kefir because we're gonna ferment this baby and then milk it for all that it's got not only is there 21 rambunctious scenarios not only is that entirely separate combat part and Story Part each with its own individual rule set not only is there a gigantic miniature for most scenarios to Grace you with its bossness not only is there a whole writing team with novelists and YouTubers on it not only are the replaceable weapons for your Miniatures making this the world's first kind direct Dungeon Crawler not only is the there an app that reads you the story but it's voiced by James I was the bearer on Game of Thrones Cosmo I'm still on the bit where there are four boxes of this thing well put a pin in that for now why what are we doing next the story kill the trees kill the trees kill bird trees

there's two types of trees in the world deciduous that's the one with the leaves and whatnot and coniferous the ones that eat meat and that is what oath scorn is made out of trees that eat you you play as the eponymous oath sworn an organization dedicated to keep the evils of nature outside of medieval cities your Crest is literally a sword going through a tree and if by this point you're already thinking what is this anti-environmentalist fear of the outside xenophobic bulldozer hold on to that feeling because oath sworn will surprise you I imagine a lot of you want the crunch talk tell me how combat works and hey that's coming but I think the story part perfectly illustrates how this jumbo jet of a board game subverts Expectations by being really smart the affectionately named deep wood the Wildland surround ending oath sworn cities is indeed lethal you're shown that within the game's first few sentences you're also shown an isolated and scared Society guards knock on your arms to see if they've become wooden before they let you into the city for example for some reason the ranger that's literally made out of wood doesn't bother them though no one really understands the Deep wood apart from maybe you but they know to fear it I think we've all gotten used to taking board games at face value the last time a publisher boasted of hiring a novelist to write the game's story We've Ended up with tainted Grail a dark reimagining of

Arthurian Legend and while some of our viewers were adamant that tainted grail's writing was indeed good I'd counter that it not only profoundly misunderstood Arthurian Legend but we also got a card of graph stoic miserable characters in a story that efka summarized as like I was having a conversation with a drunken adolescent who was very passionately explaining nature yeah yeah truly very very dark like a single elongated trombone fart at this point all someone had to do to impress us was not use the adjective dark to describe its characters and locations but despite leaning into the same themes and tones as tainted Grail it delivered with actually good writing in the moment to moment stuff and subversions within the big beats of the setting it did at one point use the phrase pregnant silence but hey we all make mistakes crucially it understands that to learn a grim setting it can't Hammer the same nail like a cecipian carpenter it knows when to let up let the sun shine in show moments of cheer or Humanity every chapter is made up of a story part and then a combat part and the game uses this dual structure to balance its tone we've had some Whimsical Town Adventures followed by ruthless combat and some particularly grueling story moments followed by an easier slightly celiotactical confrontation and sometimes it's just paddled to the metal heart but by that point oswan earns it but what about this

xenophobic setting well it's definitely got that frame but whilst I have to be vague here to avoid spoilers that's all it is a lot of fantasy and sci-fi has similar frames for example alien features a ruthlessly corporate universe but it's what you do within that frame that matters and whilst You could argue that it's us players that have the agency and in a game that has multiple moral paths you could open up avenues for nastiness I think that the writing team did enough work to show us that that's not what's going on or at least I think they did we're reviewing this game after a third of the entire campaign if our opinion changes in the future we'll let you know however there are moments in oswan that do harken back to the idea that edgy for some reason means dog where it thinks it's Game of Thrones but because it's a board game it has absolutely no room for new ones just broad Strokes where it shocks you with deliberate gruesomeness that's less ariaster and more Michael Bay via Eli Roth and win the game amongst its casts of dozens and dozens can't offer a single character of color or feminine characters that somehow don't end up being victims you have to ask when will board games grow up I'm waiting very patiently siffy and Carpenter ever could just tell me about

the mechanisms give me the juice the meat feed me like a coniferous tree okay so shall we do the story mechanisms or the combat mechanisms first I think you're right let's do the story mechanisms the locations and monsters in osworn are sealed away I like that in envelopes in the standee version all big lumpy boxes in the miniature one here I do have to issue the dreaded very minor spoilers warning emphasis on the very minor but honestly you'd be forced to see that stuff by visiting ozone's Kickstarter page which is the only place to buy it all by simply reading the rule book if the publisher can't teach the game without spoiling the location of the monster for scenario one neither can we and if you want the 4 all spoilers of our adventures in oath sworn a bonus video is live on our patreon now and if you join our patreon we'll mail you this dog most story paths leave your party through a sort of narrative Choose Your Own Adventure but it's more akin to something like Sherlock Holmes Consulting detective rather than seventh continent the very first chapter will lead you to the city of Boston represented here with a map that honestly looks good enough to hang on the wall and next to that map you'll also have a time tracker chart that appropriately tracks the amount of time you spent visiting Baston Scenic locales like

this decade or something called the underways each time you visit a location you'll learn something new about the mystery you're investigating although the real trick is to follow the clues in the narrative and skip the locations that don't directly lead to the solution when you visit a location you also take its token and place it on the time track eventually covering up bonuses you won't be receiving anymore because you darling too much Osborne rewards paying attention and the carrot on the end of that stick is combat tokens and potentially extra loot which sounds okay Until you realize how harsh combat is and how precious extra Loot and tokens Can Be you'll count your blessings for every last morsel of advantage and what is genuinely brilliant is that oath one recognizes that it's a game of two equal parts meaning that the expansive store story needs something mechanical to reward the players that engage with it in this way each part feels intrinsic to the experience make good choices do well and perhaps you'll squeeze out a marginal advantage that might tip over the scales of combat if you're careless and make decisions like hi this tavern brawl sounds like fun let's partake you could end up losing a hit point and as you only have six hit points to start with you're literally doing the monster's work for it you might even

discover details about the monster you're hunting early letting you select combat cards knowing more about the foe you'll face equally if you stumble not only do you have to face a murder machine unprepared but they might Ambush you robbing you of first round volleys there's also a touch of luck where you'll have to pass tests via a card slash dice mechanism that will cover in more detail in the combat part where it reappears in its grander form you'll get a target number and you can draw as little as one card or up to 10 modifier cards if you draw two blanks you've failed if you didn't reach the target number you failed you can also out to roll dice instead of cards which has the same odds but the card deck offers The Delectable dish of card counting you can mitigate your chances by reshuffling the deck but at the expense of tokens that you will need for combat later these tests are few and far between but they feel more like tense moments rather than frustrating mechanisms of chance in fact Osborne is very good at not making you feel like it's out there to cheat you there's no surprise gotcha pivot where the rug gets swept from under your feet I've played enough story based board games with a plot twist down the middle where the designers probably thought they were being very clever with an annoying development that I had no way to prepare for because there was no foreshadowing and now everyone on the table feels stupid and paved that's not

to say that Osmond lacks surprises even early in the game days and I don't use this phrase lightly draw dropping developments but they always feel earned and somehow Fair despite conforming to the game's somber and devastating tones and finally if the phrase this is a bit like Sherlock Holmes Consulting detective gave you a constipated sense of sitting down and reading a lot to your friends or worse yet having your friends do a lot of reading to you don't worry the entire narrative is fully voiced by James I was the bear on Game of Thrones Cosmo and let me tell you James I was the bear on Game of Thrones Cosmo gives it his best I can't over emphasize what a pleasure it was listening to Mr Cosmo's performance with different shades of tone to individualize the Myriad of characters or the pace suddenly rationing up in a tense moment and then a meaningful pause to fill the room with pregnancy silence that of course requires an app which is well implemented although a function to replace sound Clips we already heard without winding entire scenes backwards would be very nice but you you don't have to use it you can do the reading yourself with two Mammoth tomes if you're really insistent on not hearing the sultry Cosmo tones after two piles lie before you you can either continue your pregnant waffle about board game stories or you can give the people and me what they want the combat you won't

have time for both give us the combat kill the trees kill all right all right all right all right I'll do the combo it's not just detectiving though most chapters bring something entirely different from chord drama to Wilderness exploration when you sit down to play oh my word enough words about words now for these words them's fighting words can I talk about how the linearity of story contrasted to something like that at the heart of every encounter which is the osworn word for combat is the monster in chapter one it's a gigantic rat literally the size of a hovel why are you fighting it well I'll leave those details for you to discover yourself suffice to say that the length of the story part justifies itself here oath swan meets you on the field of battle with an immediate sense of brutality each of your four characters and there will be four characters no matter the player count starts with a maximum of six hit points fewer if you've managed to Fumble through the story and this to our knowledge never increases throughout the campaign mother Mouse on the other hand here 30 hit points not to worry you get to go first each Osborne gets a bank of generic fantasy word action points that they can spend to either move one generic fancy word action point for one hex or perform some sort of an attack by playing one of their cards which will have the cost in generic fantasy word named action points in the corner so far so simple you move play a card to attack

maybe it has an ability like striking three hexes in front of you instead of just one or maybe it will let you pick cup an enemy or even a corpse and Chuck it at another enemy thereby doing them damage but there's a catch any card you play also has a refresh value ranging from zero to three meaning that as soon as you play it will go to the appropriate refresh slot and you can't have it back until it crawls all the way back into your hand if this were any other board game you'd think aha these cards move one space over the end of every round no no no the cards only move when you play a card to a slot and then anything that was already there moves one's face down and if this were any other board game you'd think aha there's a daisy chain effect where cards move and then they move other cards and they move other cards not a chance you play a card and it might move some or none cards one space and that's it this sense of frugality towards the players is what makes oath Swan so frustrating and so darn compelling when players are done spending animus or when they just don't want to do anything anymore it's the monster's turn what they do is determined by a card drawn from a deck exclusive for that monster which is normally composed of something bad that happens to you followed by something worse that happens to you and sometimes it's appended by a Sprinkle of salt literally rubbed into your wounds okay but since we're trying to outwit one big

boss enemy rather than fighting flunkers you'd think that oh Swan would give us tools to outsmart it right yes but each enemy has various body parts Head Shoulders Knees and Toes each body part has its own hip points reduce it to zero and you break their enemy location meaning that if it ever uses that body part to attack it loses its best attack die or card great let's do let's do it right haha no see there's a problem every time you break a location you also trigger the monster's next card giving it a bonus turn can we break two locations at the same time yes and then you'll give it two bonus turns not to mention that the monster deck is tiered and the more locations you break the faster it advances through to the next tiers making it more desperate and more deadly each encounter takes on the Cadence of where you're poking and prodding you don't know what's in that deck so you're taking things slow but you know it's just gonna get a lot more deadly permeating everything with an underlying sense of dread over and over the story tells you that the deepwood is deadly and after the first encounter you know that to be true and just like with the story part also one knows that the only way you can maintain that sensation of ragged downtrodden beaten Adventures at the most desperate is to balance it with moments of generosity combat uses

the same card slash dice mechanism as tests in the story mode each monster has a defense value each time you cause damage in multiples of its defense value you take away one hit point from it so if a monster has a defense of two and ideally it six damage and I'm attacking its front Arc I will take away three of its snout points now comes the tricky part unlike in the story mode there is no target number that I need to hit my only limitation is my own hubris my weapon might grant me access to card slash dice that have bigger numbers yellow red and then black but once again I can draw as many White cards as I like up to 10 but if I hit two blanks I miss except this time I get to manipulate things and push my luck even further remember those token nuts I've been storing for the winter during the story part well in the words of James Cosmo winter has come and now I get to Pelt them at a giant rodent let's say that my ax gives me a red card and then I decide to draw three more white ones a one a mess a two and another Miss but that's okay I've got a reroll token I will spend that and that lets me redraw any card that I like that's a four and not

only a four but a crit which means I get to draw another card and if it misses it won't count that's another crit and then I draw another three off of that that's a total of 12 damage six now points to the face how about these Nazis stupid foreign I need to calm down it's all about Rhythm you start the fight prepared you have a pool of tokens but as things get meaner they also get leaner your tokens are spent your animus has run out you're on your last two hit points and the rock is about to attack you you could play a card to increase your defense because you've only got a defensive free and it's got a way stronger attack than you do but for that you need cards in your cards are stuck in your refresh slots you make a desperate attack spending your only cons spending your only animus and then you draw one two three four cards ah a mess but wait you're forgetting about the determination rule anytime you miss on an attack you get a free token of your choice you realize that the card you just played bumped free cards from refresh slot one into zero you choose a battle flow token and then immediately spend it to take all of these cards into your hand and now not only can you play one of them to temporarily increase your

defense but you've also got another one that will remove the attacker's highest attack value dice or card and the best part is that these response cards generally don't even cost animus to play meaning that you might just live in fact some oswan players have cleverly caught on that if you want to you can deliberately draw 10 cards to ensure failure and get a token I mentioned that you can draw cards or roll dice well you can flip-flop between the two however you want even in the middle of your role or your draw your role is your draw oh someone is so full of dials and minutia that there's always something clever you can engineer some mechanism you can tamper with to eke out an advantage not to mention that you draw the monsters event card before the start of your turn knowing exactly what it will do giving oswan a puzzly pandemicy field that's the board game not the event you understand and now that efka has mentioned the dreaded word that's minutia not pandemic let's get into some of the things the answer great you know what I'm gonna say the rule book and whilst it's better than other grandiose Kickstarter over promissor rule books it's still quite murky in fact to this very moment every 20 minutes like clockwork wheel wait a minute how does that work

let me check the rule book just one sec It Isn't So Much the clarity just the amount of rules for targeting line of sight breaking ties order of enemy activation facing attacking multiple monster locations and whilst once again just like with the story oathswan is great at making each encounter feel different and surprising it also introduces complications that grind things to a whole not to mention some rules that painterly shouldn't exist I'm looking at you facing rules get it because look face because you look with your face it's a joke I'll explain it later not only do you have to track where every figure is looking at all times but it's further compounded by clunky monster movement rules that intersect with the tiebreaker North then West rule it is literally rule upon rule upon Rule and whilst I can't argue that it's irrelevant maintaining facing matters for large Miniatures in terms of knowing which of the mouse's chicken legs I can Target the benefit for tracking the facing of smaller niches feels tedious and only becomes relevant if I have a character that has a 1 in 20 card that gives a bonus for attacking its flank or whatever so very clearly this minutia stems from ambition the game promised a lot on Kickstarter and Promises it will deliver all of them great and terrible ones check out this playable character roster so many

different archetypes with the robo clearly delineating the complexity level and they all come with their own miniature and it is a cool miniature bro be ashamed of something oh crap here we go again just glue your Miniatures Africa what's the problem well I would you see but you get an add-on called The Armory that turns your character into a Kinder egg yeah that looks fun ironically this actually stems from a rule that is good and refreshing to see in a campaign game after every scenario you have to lose one item that you brought into the fight want to use your best weapon and your best armor and your best trinket be ready to lose one of them there's no out best part is if your character goes unconscious you have to give up two items this transpired into probably my favorite player engineer at moment where Elaine named her characters axi and swordy and very promptly after scenario one axi lost one of his two axes and Saudi was now brandishing a shield and a spear because that's all they had left now that's what I call a Farewell to Arms speaking of old Swan take it with one arm and with the other it painted a picture the new

gear cards you get tie in with this story in ways I won't spoil but I will say that sometimes getting a new card told a story of its own but then this miniature Kinder egg stuff doesn't just feel silly it undermines that storytelling which brings us to the mouse in the room and it never has a mouse taking up so much unnecessary space there's a lot to be said about the size of these four boxes but here's the thing two of them are just taken up by absurd Miniatures and the third is terrain that you won't use because it's annoying and gets in the way and I know miniature fans will defend big plastic here as part of an experience and I guess you can put a house on top of it and oh look it's Disney but I have to ask you sincerely if you enjoy miniature presentation which by the way I also do you think that this lump is good genuinely I love a good mini is this a good mini or is it just big because whilst not all of them are the same this broadly speaks to the quality of sculpt you get in osworn is this worth the two or three extra boxes the nearly doubled cost and increasingly difficult Economic Times the dare I say it environmental damage from shipping and Manufacturing the space in your house I'll come clean I love Osborne I think

it's the most thematically consistent campaign experience I've had the pleasure to engage with it's smart smarter than your average board game and it compels me but this stuff nah you can have it except we have to get the second hand and I didn't realize that it's either the miniature version or the stand D version so there's no standees in my box and if I want to keep it and I do genuinely genuinely think this is fantastic I have a decision to make do I keep all of this in my house which brings us to our very last point oh Swan's flexibility I think it's very clear that by now a verdict is a reserved recommendation for the stand D version not because we don't like Miniatures because that's just not true but because the game's strengths lie in host one and most of the game's weaknesses lie in Blue Swan it's a pun thank you Discord for this pun but that's just where I sworn's flexibility begins we mentioned that your company has to have four characters meaning that as a solo player for example you're piloting four complicated dashboards except you don't have to each character has its full mode or a streamlined companion mode you can if you want to just play with four companions does this work yes we've also mentioned mixing

Dice and cards as randomizers does that work well sort of you'll have to draw your own lines to suit your own needs if you find card counting overwhelming excise the cards dice are swingy but they've also been responsible for some of the most raucous moments at our table and we've spent half of this video talking about the story giving you no ability to skip it which is where osworn is even better than this channel you can't entirely skip the story in oath's form but you can run a truncated version that will take you through a few tests stole out a few tokens and gives you the general story beats but I think the narrative is this game's standout feature that separates it from myriads of others it Blends two big genres and pulls it off with a plum that is a remarkable fee on its own but if you don't want narrative skip it although if you're inclined to do that there's other games out there with excellent combat I like the combat in oath one but it's a little bit too clunky to fully endorse it on that alone but you do what you like oathswan knows that this is your game for you to have fun it will meticulously and intricately construct its 21 chapters with attention to detail oh Swan is a game that promised a lot and the Miracle is that it achieved almost all of it with subtlety that goes beyond expectation I know we alluded to Smart design a lot without going into to detail on what it is that actually makes

it so smart but you'll just have to trust us on that or I'll remind you again if you want the full juice a spoilerful chat is available to our patreon backers plus you'll get bonus access to our patreon only Discord server which is community moderated and full of enthusiastic board game people just having a nice chat are we done I think we're done there's been three Campaign games we've reviewed in a row I'm really looking forward to reviewing something lighter next time like flamecraft we're reviewing flamecraft right right

we'll probably do both

Progress saved