Review | Halls of Hegra
Transcript
mechanically there's a lot to like here the game combines worker placement with different worker types which is really cool and back building as well as a little bit push your luck which makes for some really interesting decisions hey everyone this isos and what is this you see here uh Theos is covering a war game yeah yeah it's finally happening um although I have already covered like one like warlike game before right peacemakers horrors of War if you want to call that a war game I mean it kind of is right and today I will be covering horse ofra um first of all I need to apologize to the designer of the game to Peter because I've been meaning to do this video for at least half a year maybe even longer it somehow just didn't work out to do a lot of different reasons right but finally now I'm getting around to doing so so before we continue grab yourself a cup of tea and let's do this and yes my tea was already half empty before starting this video because well I drank quite a bit while setting up this game because setting up the game takes a little while all right so what do we do here well HS of Hera simulates um a battle uh in the early days of World War II where like you uh command a group of Norwegian volunteers and you fight like numerically Superior German forces so this game is based on actual history um in well we all know what happened right in the original the Germans one the bad
Germans but uh in this game you have the chance to actually win right so we're playing the Norwegian forces here and there is lots to this game this game is long and it is complex right and there are like loads of different phases I will get into that while I explain the game how will I structure the video today well I was thinking about doing a playthrough but this game is complex it is very long I don't know how interesting it would be to watch me play a war game especially since I'm not an expert at War gaming right I am playing a lot of War games and I think I know what makes a good war game what are good mechanisms what works well and what doesn't but I'm not an expert war game I think watching me play this game isn't as interesting as watching other people play that so what I will do today is I will give you like a rough overview of how this game works I will talk about the different phases of the game because they are very different this game like really really like gains an excitement so to speak and attention um throughout the game I will talk about all of that I will like show you roughly how this works if you want like a full how to play video a detailed one with all the rules or if you want like a really good play through I suggest just look online on YouTube there are like lots of very good videos covering this game right and I doubt I could make a better video so I will focus on what I can do best for this game here and that is to like give you an overview of how this works and then give you my opinion about it and I think my opinion might be interesting because as I said I am not a war gamer so it might be interesting for those of you who are interested in the game but are not really War Gamers um yourself so I this is like who my review is targeted at so let's talk like roughly about
setup here right um we have our Reserve here in the very on the very left right there like all kinds of tokens and German soldiers that can come into the game and also here our forces right um they can come into the game throughout the game just depending on like what I do here we have our game Bo and there's lots happening here but in essence it is quite easy to break down up here we have a map where we can like open up Supply routs and collect supplies which is very very important um here on the left I like several things here like the supplies we have here are our forces that we have at our disposal or even not if they're like tired or need to rest right and um up here we have like artillery and stuff that is um relevant in later phases of the game and down here we have like the the main thing of the game this is like where we put our workers because yes this is essentially mostly not just but mostly a worker placement game one thing that's interesting I need to show you this one thing that I really really enjoy um yes I know I'm not my review yet but still I will show that to you you see like there like this mobilization board here that's like for the first phase of the game right later on in um in other phases you just turn over the board and at the end you actually take it away which is very very interesting um instead of like doing like another board that you have to put aside um this is a really cool idea actually to have like a board on top of a board in order to like um work with different faces a very very good idea all right um also down here we have our fear and doubt only important in the first phase right and then here we have
our morale which is also very important and then here on the right here have the five piles for the five phases that we have right uh mobilization first attack Siege one Siege two and Last Stand I put them here usually you might see it up here right here are the phases as well usually put the cards up there but if I did that then I would have to pull up the camera even more and you would see even less right so I'm not going to do that that's why I put them here right 1 2 3 4 5 in that order um I guess that's okay and then also we have high and low morale cards I will get to that a little bit later dispair and hope cards as well then we have the patrol bank here of the German U officers that will Patrol the area we have here our hit back in case something happens we need to pull from here and also we have a recruit B this is like the main just of the game right um because here we will like get our recruits that will help us actually to work on like to use like in these worker placement spots right okay this is like mainly what you see here um just a rough overview because I will go go into a bit more detail when I actually talk about the different phases the game is divided into 11 days so 11 rounds and these rounds are like divided into different like phases so Days 1 to three make the are the mobilization phase days four to six you can see it down here uh is the first attack Days 7 to 8 is the first Siege and days 9 to 11 is the second Siege with the last stand being the last day right as I said I'm not going to play through the entire game but I will uh like explain to you how the different phases work all right let's start actually with the first phase and that is the mobilization you always see like
the turn record down here you see like which phase it currently is right so currently we in Phase One of course right and now we will start with the event phase right for the event phase what we will do is we will draw the top card of the event deck right I will just put it right here and here we do different things now first of all we now move the weather marker according to the symbol right it is a cloudy right so it will say cloudy which is good right cloudy or even Sunny is even better right because that tells us like how far we can how much we can move here right that is very important because this is like where we get our supplies right if the weather happen if this had been a snow symbol we also would move the snow marker uh further to the right and then we resolve the text on the event card from top to bottom we do everything that is possible right so first of all we will injure one Defender that means we look at these symbols here right and at the top we have our volunteer here right so we take one of the volunteers here and we roll one of these dice to like see how injured they actually are right and that is a three so you see like we have like the infirmary here so we take this uh this guy and we put it in one of the beds at number three right we can heal the defender to get it back into our supply here um all right and then we also add one soldier and what that means is we take one tile from the patrol B um give me just a moment there we we go right and you see like these are the the uh the German forces here and
there's a four on here and that means we now look at the at the stage we're in we're in mobilization that's the green stage the top row here right and we put this one on the four in the green row right there so this one is now blocking us from getting supplies right which means that we will have to like somehow deal uh with them in order to get supplies and you also see like I'm a little bit of flavor text here wonderful patrols ran into a German Patrol in the forest north of hegra makes sense right right up there then we have this little icon here that tells us to put a doubt disc into the recruit B right and these are these pink ones here and we check the doubt tracker here to see like how many we put in there right so one so we take this one and we put it right in the recruit bag up in here then we shuffle all of that up and then we draw one to for this from recruit B so this is like a pushy lock mechanism now right so I don't need this anymore right so I would just discard this here to the side off screen we don't need that so now we draw one to four disc we need to draw one at least so here's the first disc that I drew I will just put it right here that's a blue one okay that's that's okay that's not too bad right that's a volunteer we can use that one for several things and now we can continue drawing discs um uh in the beginning there are two D discs in here and a lot I don't know how many but I think 10 to 15 at least um like soldja discs right so we can uh keep drawing but as soon as we draw for a doubt a doubt disc um we need to stop we can only keep one of these soldiers and the others are return
to reserve they actually taken out the back right which is pretty bad but we need soldiers so I would just continue pulling okay there's another Soldier here and another Soldier that's it and now we can only draw up to four right that's um the maximum we can do all right and now um the cool thing is uh we can take all of these here and we can put them in the ready area right and not only that also since we have for each volunteer that we draw because volunteers are a little bit weaker than others right they can't do everything so to speak right they don't have any special abilities for each volunteer that we um that we uh that we draw we can one add one dis to the supplies here so that means we take another yellow Cube here and put it right here so now we have two two supplies right we can also like push put one die there to signify that it that it is worth five supplies right but we have two supplies so that is fine and that already was the event phase so the event phase is like pretty simple you just draw a card from the respective stack and you just uh you just resolve it right so now we go to the morning phase first you would move all Defenders here from the rest area into that area we don't have any there so we don't do anything so now we can spend um also supplies or morale tokens to move Defenders from the tired area to the ready area right and um the number of Defenders you may move for for each Supply spend is determined by the position on the supply marker right so see here currently one Cube means four forces right that's like how it starts
but um we can of course also um like move this to the right at some point like if it moves to the right then we can move less from the tired area to the ready area right okay also you can always move up to two Defenders from the tire to the rest area but only two it says like Max two there right um and these will then become ready on the next day but not yet all right and now we have the main thing of the game right we now take our Defenders here and we put them like on all of these work placement spaces I want to talk about all of those in detail right but there are like specific things so for example we can put one here to fire at the Germans right and the the thing is it will tell you like in which order we will resolve that later on right so 1 2 3 4 5 6 right that's like the order we will resolve resolve this in right the most important things are Supply run is very important so for example right we can down here um open a new Supply route right this is a times two here that means we need to put two people here so for example we could put these two volunteers right here and that would mean that we would uh be able to add delivery tokens to new Supply Depot up here right so that means we can like add supplies up there I will show you later how that would work we can also negotiate that means we can move one work on one marker on fear or doubt uh down that is good right because the further down they are the better that is right because the more fee are the more doubt we have the more issues we have for example for doubt right the higher it is the more doubt marks we add to the back which are bad because I told you when we whenever we draw a doubt marker you can only keep once one of the uh
recruits and everything else will be put back into the supply which like into the reserve which is pretty bad then here we can now send a new out a new Supply run right that means we can um put a soldier out there that actually can get the supplies that we have um um added to the Supply route and then down here is like also like a lot of things that we can do we can shovel snow we can put a person here to move the snow markers to the left if it ever reaches that top left that uh tile here to the very left we can now um flip over a snow tile that means we have uncovered we have dug out something that we can use these can be new worker placement spots for example right so um for example I think last time I had the field telephone which was pretty good then we can repair that means we can remove one damage tile and that is very important right because these um are all damage tiles here right and if you want to fire at the Germans later on we can uncover these to have like more um we can fire at then we have bolster that means um we can add a miss or defense tile right to the hit back because the hitback we always have to pull a tile from here we have two in here at the moment and whenever there's something negative happening right so that's why um for example like if the snow reaches the uh the very right here we need to draw one tire from the hitb for example right so we can add like tiles in there that are not as bad like Miss and defense up right right that means like the Germans don't um can't do like too much to us then we can promote a Defender that means we can just take any Defender except those that are crossed out right except like a medic um
which we don't have at the moment unfortunately um in order to promote the defender right and then also here we have um we can move the morale marker up the moral marker is right here and that always makes sense to do so right because um like the higher the morale is the more stuff we can do right so for example Drew draw two high moral cards and resolve one that's good these cards are good if we down here we draw two low moral one uh cards and resolve one which is also bad right and this like gets worse or better the higher or lower we go here um and then we have the infirmary that's like one of the last things here um that means we can just heal people right we can just put a person right here and then uh we can heal someone right there are like other symbols here like these cross out ones it means we can't use that type of Defender right and so we couldn't use the commander I think it's called right here for repairing and bolstering stuff um but whenever there is a two up here like there and there then that one actually counts like two uh two Defenders which is pretty good and the interesting thing here is um we have that one spot yes but we can like put more there right so sh with snow I could like put instead of just one I could put like three Defenders here if I wanted to right so all right so let's just uh play like one Short Round Here and show you how that works um so what we do now is for example I would definitely want to shovel snow um we don't have a Defender unfortunately that one would count as two um I'm thinking about like actually putting three people there um in order to oops to shovel a lot of snow uh maybe
that's a good idea because you want to uncover some of these tiles because these can be really strong also I would like to send out a new Supply run the supply isn't there yet but it will it will come right put it right there then we want to treat a patient right because we definitely well actually do I want to treat a patient yeah maybe I think I actually want to uh move the morale marker and if we now I take one of these here that one counts as two right so we can put that there we need two so we just put one there that's fine we still have these two here right um I think the most well actually also the artillery here is quite important actually I think I might repair one of these spots here so we need two Defenders so we will just put these two soldiers here so now I've used all the Defenders that are in the ready area so now we go to the day phase which is the last phase right um so in the mobilization phase it works like this that now we just go through all these things here right we start with these that are um that belong to the belong to the mobilization phase because it's a zero there right so first we open a new Supply route that means um I will take this stack here that one grants us new soldiers and we put that wherever it says up here right so right there that's already it and these not go to the tired area and then we just continue we don't have anything here not anything here Supply run and then we send that one out here to The Fortress here right to the mountain there because that's where we like are hiding so to speak and
defending from right and now we can move you know it says move our Supply runs this like our one our one Supply run and it like dep determined by the weather it says like 1 to five and now we can move this one one to five spaces so 1 2 3 4 5 for example see so we have almost at that spot and then we just need to move back again so now if the weather is worse then we just move less if we hit a German soldier we can do several things for example we can either stop the movement or we can try to sneak but we need to uh pass a check here then all right then we go to number four maintenance so first I will shovel three snow right that means one two three um so now I can flip this s top snow tile and this is actually the Feld telephone again okay that's funny um this one is pretty cool because that one can later on give us like plus one on the roads when we uh when we fire at the Germans here defend the walls or if we suppress Two Soldiers so that is not too bad then here we would need these two to do one repair I would probably like repair this one here right so now we have two defensive positions here Inspire would mean move the moral marker one up like this um right here and we didn't heal anyone actually we should have healed as well but we didn't do that right um and then we go to the morale phase here at the End by the way I mov the doubt marker I have to move the morale marker one up and then you see like um like these hearts and stuff like around here like right that means like these now
would also move the moral track but there aren't any that I'm triggering here as far as I know no I don't so um that means that um I cannot dve draw two high morale cards and resolve one so I would draw these two then I would like check which uh which which phase I'm in which stage I'm currently in this mobilization here I would can gain one Supply which is good that means with Supply I can move like more people here and here I can move two Defenders from the tired area to the ready area it's pretty much almost the same thing um just this one is better because I can move four for each Supply right so I would resolve this one here and gain one more Supply right um that works so I can just remove those as well and then what we also do is um at the end you see down here like there are like uh German Patrol markers here there are two mentioned here and like shown there so we just draw two we need to add them to the respective things so that is a five all right that works and also a four so there's another Soldier right there so there are two and then since the game is not over because we're not in the last round we just move the turn marker one further and that is how you would play like one round we will continue that two more times now for the mobilization phase and then we would go into the first attack Siege and um The Last Stand at the end and like the game will continue like that so but what happens what like changes well like as soon as we are done here with the mobilization phase right like in round four we would take this one here and we would turn
over that board to the first attack phase because now in these phases German soldiers would start like um being added to these sectors here they would move up these sectors and like try to hit us right and we can defend them or suppress them either we can do that with uh with the firing here at the Germans or if you have the field telephone only use also use that right so pressing just means that we can turn them sideways so they don't attack hitting them which is like a DI check here right 50/50 um hitting them would like remove them and this is like where the field telephone comes in because you get plus one on each die if you like uh put like two Defenders here or just one of these uh commanders I think they're called um in order to like get plus one on each time you rolling here right like on each defensive position and that's it's important to like remove these like to repair them to have like more spots here right because these just keep approaching there also of course the cards are different right so you see here remove one delivery token from each of the left most two open Supply Depots so right there is like Supply Depot and there's one as well you would have to like remove one each so things like that right and also you see like how many soldiers are added um to the first attack and that is still not all right because this is not getting harder because now you need to also defend here and you cannot just do this stuff here right you still need to do that stuff right because of course I mean you don't have an unlimited supply of soldiers right like of Defenders I mean you need hide more and more right you also need still need supplies you still need to work on your morale you
still need to shovel snow still need to repair things right so you still need to do all of these things but also defend against the German soldiers and that you do that for three more for three more turns right and then you have the siege and The Siege makes it even worse because because first of all you have new cards here right that add like more patrols for example right and they're getting like further down like everything there will be more and more patrols here right and also now you have this here you have the artillery right so now the Germans are attacking you with artillery that you need to defend right and that means here you can like fire artillery you can like hit also these right because these are also like placed on the map then and also you have like these here that are added to the hit tile right so you're also getting bombarded by these planes and these bombard are done in a pretty clever way because um they just say it might be a little bit too small but they um they say just what happens right so if you draw one of these you you you lose a supply he would injure in Defender right injuring Defender remember you roll a die and then you add that Defender here to the um to the infirmary minus one morale which is very bad right you don't want to have low morale like morale is always like very very important and The Siege two is pretty similar just that the cards are just getting harder and worse right so for example here you lose lose three Supply if you don't have enough instead injure three Defenders also the snow track here right so you move the snow TR snow uh the snow counter more to the right if you don't keep shoveling snow then you will have to resolve d uh tiles from the hit bag
and these might be these bombardments here right so it like gets tougher and tougher you see like uh add more bombardment add artillery add four Germans that like just keep charging right so um actually um in the all of these phases after the first attack you also remove this board here I forgot to say that right and all of these you see like there are many more soldiers that will actually attack you right so um this is really really crazy and very intense but you also get like a new placement spot here Reckless defense you can just put a Defender here and hit Two Soldiers which is amazing but you also injur the defender right because you need to like uh outweigh like um the pros and the cons of what he doing here so yeah um and then you have the Last Stand which is like the very last phase where you then draw one of these cards there like only three in here right because you only have the last at once and you see that there's lots of stuff here right injured to Defenders or move surrender one level up which is also bad as soon as you move up that Cube to the very top you also like yeah you surrender and you lose right um and then you just another another bombardment and another artillery and seven soldiers and whatever right it's it's really crazy but if you actually manage to hold out all 11 turns without having these ROM marker at the very top or without losing all Defenders then you actually win the game you just need healthy Defenders at the end of the last time without having to surrender to win right so you don't need to like defeat anyone you just need to hold out right like all of these waves and what's been thrown at you I didn't go into like extreme detail here
but I think I could give you like a pretty rough overview over how this game works well all right you now you should have a pretty good idea of how HS of heg has played but how do I like it well let me tell you to start with I'm not particularly a fan of the theme of War games in general but that wouldn't be a fair way to review the game so instead let's ask is the game thematic I'd say yes and no at its core this is very much a Euro game with quite abstract mechanisms but despite that the theme still comes through when Defenders are injured nursing them back to health makes sense going on Supply runs that works too so why thises is mechanically an abstract Euro it still manages to feel thematic my most favorite thematic touch here is shoveling snow and actually uncovering things I think that is done really well the designer also has put a lot of effort into historical accuracy which really elevates the theme you're not attacking anyone You're simply trying to hold it against an overwhelming enemy force that makes a big difference in how the game feels and to add there is actually a historical background section here over four pages that gives you like the entire historical background of this game what happened back then very very cool touch visually the artwork is a little bit drier than i' usually like but let's be honest this is a game of what war a colorful vibrant board wouldn't fit the theme at all the components are solid looking and feeling high quality my only nitpick is that the German Soldier pieces are way too large I would have
much preferred like simple discs like most other components mechanically there's a lot to like you the game combines worker placement with different worker types which is really cool and back building as well as a little bit push your luck which makes for some really interesting decisions there are plenty of different strategies to explore and multiple levers to pull giving place a lot of control over how they approach the game that said I do wish there was a player eight the game could definitely use one and its absence makes things a little harder to reference during play yes there is like the play a on the back of the rule book but it doesn't like go into detail like what specific symbols and whatever means right you need to like go through the entire book and find those right so you have like the entire phases here but that's it everything else you have to look up in the rules The Rook itself is Well written if you sit down and read it through like from front to back but if you're trying to quickly look something up mid game it's not the easiest to navigate so I'm not a huge fan of this now let's talk difficulty this is a very tough game and winning is hard that's not necessarily a bad thing but it's possible to get into trouble early on especially if you're unlucky and keep drawing doubt discs yes the chance is small but you know my luck in games right if you're unlucky and keep drawing doubt discs you are in a lot of trouble or maybe you just didn't prepare properly but if you're early preparations aren't strong enough defeat might be inevitable one thing the game does exceptionally well is tension at first you're mostly preparing for what's coming then as balance unfolds and you
start being attacked things get more and more intense the difficulty ramps up instead of tapering off making for an experience that keeps building very few games manage to pull this off so effectively and that's probably the game's biggest strength so would I recommend it that depends if you don't mind a wall theme and are up for a difficult longer game this could be R be early fans of challenging survival games like Robinson cruso for example might find a lot to enjoy here but if War thems aren't your thing or you prefer a more forgiving experience this might not be the best fit um the win rate here for this game is approximately 10% just to give you like just a throw number out there um I have played the game often enough to like support that claim but that's like the number you like find floating around online and forms all the time 10 to 15% so if that doesn't scare you off this might just be your game all in all this historically grounded pretty thematic Euro game with solid components and an impressive escalation of tension throughout mechanically it offers engaging work placement back building push your luck and plenty of strategic death however the lack of a player Aid with like the symbols and the Rooks less than ideal structure for quick reference can be a drawback it's very tough to win and early mistakes or bad luck can put you in a rough spot if you enjoy challenging strategic survival games and don't mind the war theme this could be a great choice but if you're looking for something more forgiving you may want to look elsewhere well that concludes my
review for halls of hegra thank you for watching and sticking to the very end a huge thanks to all of you and a special shout out to my generous patrons the biggest thanks go out with tho for supporting me at the highest TI you can also support me watching liking and commenting on my videos subscribing to my channel supporting me on patreon and joining my Discord server to hang out with me in my amazing Community all right I'll see you on the channel or my Discord server take care everyone stay safe and cheers