Root: The Homeland Expansion Review - Ribbeting
Transcript
Hi everyone. I'm Tally. This is Frell. And we're bored of it. And today we're going to be reviewing the latest expansion for Routt, which is the Homeland expansion.
Yes. So this expansion comes with three new factions, the Lily Pad Diaspora, the Twilight Council, and Navs of the Deepwood alongside three landmarks, and two new maps, the gorge, and the marsh. So we're going to get into basically what these are and how they act. or how they're different than what exists. And then we're going to tell you what we think.
The lilyad diaspora are a frog faction and finally been waiting for this for so long. Now, they're going to be very mobile, moving all over the woodland and dropping their enclave tokens in clearings. These enclave tokens are double-sided. They'll either be flipped to peaceful or to militant. Now, they need peaceful enclaves to score, but they need militant enclaves to recruit warriors. And keeping that balance is key to doing well as the lily pad. Now, they also come with a deck of frog cards, which are a frog suit. And this is because their enclave tokens will either add the frog suit to clearings where they are if that enclave is peaceful or if it's Milton, it will cover the base suit of that clearing to make it frog only. So it's good for everyone to have frog cards in case this happens.
The Twilight Council are bats and act as a sort of UN peacekeeping faction. Their goal is to get assemblies out onto the board and flip them to their governing side, which will score them points. Interestingly, when there are governing assemblies, it limits what can be done in that clearing. Eg, no other tokens can be placed. Essentially, they want to hole up in a few clearings with a big force to protect their assemblies as if they don't rule, the assemblies will close down. They can also gain loyalists which sit on the playerboard and when a new assembly is added all of the loyalists can go out alongside it to get instant rule of a clearing.
The navs of the deepwood are an alternate vagabond faction shown by the fact that you can't play with both them and the vagabond in a single game. But what they are doing is you are going to have three captains represented by vagabond meeples and skunk warriors. Each turn you will have to act with a different captain until you've used them all and then everything will refresh. Like the vagabond they're going to be using items or exhausting items to take actions, but they can also take actions independent of that. And like the vagabond, they're able to move in and out of forests. Essentially, what you're doing with the naves are you're popping out of the forest, hitting people over the head, and then you're dragging them back into the forest and holding them hostage. then you're going around town and bragging about it because the naves will score points from the number of kidnapped warriors they have from the other factions that they're holding hostage in the forests and they'll also score from their acclamation tokens which they drop either through just kind of going around and bragging or when they kidnap someone.
Finally, the two maps. There's the gorge map which is based around a large dam and creates a greater focus on map positioning. Whilst the marsh map is designed more with higher player counts in mind, eg five or six, as it has a greater number of clearings, some of which will be filled with landmarks which are included in this expansion. However, some of those clearings can be blocked off with flood tiles to make for more balanced play with four or fewer players. what we think will be a little one-sided as Tali's only played one of the factions whereas I've played all three but you have played both maps so
that's true
yes so I think yeah maybe let's just start with the map first since we just mentioned them you get the two maps and I think to me the least interesting is the marsh because
it's one that's primarily designed for a higher player count so The marsh is great if you have five or six people because it has these extra spaces and plays in with landmarks, but there wasn't that much of interest to me when we played in a lower play count game. I think because you cover up spaces and I found like the the way the artwork can be a little confusing almost
to to maneuver around and figure out cuz you're laying these tiles over spaces.
Yeah. I think some of the clearings were almost kind of too close together. And then some of the pieces were just getting a little bit jumbled up. Maybe that's just us not organizing in the best way, but it wasn't super intuitive. Maybe a bit the wrong way, but the pieces were
blending a little bit and then that made it a little bit difficult to navigate, I would say.
Yeah, there was two dead center
uh in the middle of the board and they kind of almost blend together if if you have a lot of troops in those locations. It has a river on it, right?
Yes.
So, I did think it was quite nice for the frogs,
actually.
But they all have a river.
Yeah. That one particularly sticks out in my mind as being useful for the frogs.
Okay.
Personally.
Yeah. So, then the other side is the gorge map. And this is particularly great map. Uh, and it was also created actually not by the designers or the people at Games. It was made by Lord of the Board. I don't know if you knew that. Oh, I didn't know that. No.
Yeah. So, and he got made into an official map. Lord of the Board is is another channel that we know and he's a really nice guy. So, this is I I really enjoyed this map. It's based around a giant dam and like a gorge. And I think this has elements that make you think a bit more about your positioning because of the way the connections are.
Yeah. And I just I think it's maybe the most beautiful map uh out of all the root maps. And I just I just really liked playing on it.
Yeah, for sure. It's the most novel, right? Because of the way that the bridge is working and yeah, in the beginning you think that you can sort of move around and then you realize actually no, you got to go around to go under. I agree. I think that's very novel and a cool twist.
Yeah.
Versus the other ones. So going into the factions, why don't you speak a bit about the lily pad since you have played those?
Yeah. Well, I think you need to say some words because your favorite animals are frogs, right? So you were absolutely desperate.
One of them. Yeah.
Yeah. For uh to get
enjoy frog.
Yeah, I did enjoy playing the frogs. I think I personally found it a bit difficult to really get my engine going with them. Um, yeah. So, you have to put out these enclaves and then it's just very tricky. I mean, it's a good challenge, but when they go militant, that's when you can sort of battle people more easily and but then you want them to be peaceful because that's what you score for. It was a challenge to get that balance right because you also want to um what is it when they're militant you can recruit basically get more troops out then you can't score.
Yeah, I I really enjoyed playing it and trying to navigate it through. It's just I I couldn't find my way with playing them very well because also you can only score maximum four points per round and that's doing your absolute best aside from crafting. Um because you can only score one type of clearing per round. So foxes, rabbits, mice, plus if you can craft something. But then I personally never got the right crafting cards. So I was really struggling to get it going. But I found it an interesting challenge.
Yeah.
To try and navigate this balance of being militant versus uh peaceful. I think that was like very cool.
Yeah. So I liked I think first play I really enjoyed them but then yeah you start seeing the constraints. Yeah
with more plays where
the problem is is that yeah you can basically so they're a faction that they can kind of score high out of the gate because you can depending on the layout of clearings
and your starting hand you could score four points in the first turn but then
you're always like limited by that being the maximum. Whereas other factions might be able to get five or more or something
um when they if they manage to get everything out
and you're heavily dependent on crafting because they're very good at crafting but you need to get the cards like you said then I think you also because they can be quite militant you need to focus on kind of getting a few points here and there from knocking out other players buildings and tokens. So they they kind of have to to pivot and grab and it could be quite tricky because other factions might start slow but have bigger turns.
Yeah, for sure.
So yeah, coming on to the uh Twilight Council, which I played, they I actually really enjoyed them. They were probably the one that sounded the least interesting at the outset, but that I found to be the most kind of in interesting to play in a sense. very annoying to play against.
Yes.
So, they're quite funny because essentially all you're trying to do is you're trying to get a bunch of warriors in a clearing and have control of that clearing because then your assemblies are short to open and then you score from open assemblies um or governing assemblies as a term. But what's interesting is to score points you need to have enemy pieces in that territory. So they work quite well with the frogs who are throwing enclaves everywhere for example, but with other factions it might be tough
and they're kind of able to manipulate other factions movement. So there's also an interesting puzzle of kind of whacking someone from one clearing to go to another clearing so you can use them to score.
Yeah. Uh, and they're quite interesting as well in how you can kind of gamble uh if you if you play bird cards where you roll a dieice and then you have to remove that many warriors from a clearing and you can score either score a point or you add them to your loyalists. And you can get loyalists other ways, but essentially it's kind of like a separate subgroup of warriors where when you put out a new assembly, you can kind of also add all your warriors. So you can instantly take over a clearing depending how many people are there. And that's quite interesting that you kind of suddenly be like, "Oh, I control this now."
Yeah, very annoying to play against like I said because when the you have gumming assemblies and you can't place any tokens down, which for the frogs, you need to be getting those tokens out. So yeah, that was an interesting battle between the two, let's say. Very frustrating to play as the the frogs then because again, you're limited by the kind of four points that you can score and then you were not letting me get any tokens out. So then it limits it even more when you're playing against these two. Yeah, lessons were learned. I'd play differently.
Yeah. So I think they're who I'm looking most forward to playing again. And then finally, we have the Naves of the Deepwood. And they're quite an interesting faction. As I said in the explanation, they're very uh vagabondlike. And it is, I think, they're almost one of the funniest factions to play because you are popping out of forest to hit people over the head and dragging them away and then like telling everyone about it. But what I kind of found, I don't know, maybe I need to play play a bit more with them, but
I I found them almost a little bit the more boring of the three
because what you're doing every time is it's like the same goal. You're just like, "Okay, where can I pop out and knock someone on the head
and like how can I drop an acclaim token in a clearing where I don't have one?"
If that makes sense. It was like
there's no like push pull of like
Yeah. There's no like arc like you know if you have the moles for example you get better and better as you build out. Um you know if you're lily pad you can kind of get a lot of warriors on the board and start making moves that way. Hero was always kind of yeah popping out getting someone you know. So I don't think they're a bad faction at all. I really liked how they played. It just wasn't the most interesting I think at least the experience I had in the games we played.
Fair. But overall, I think everything uh is is great and has its place. Obviously, weren't fans of the the Marshmall, but that has its place if you're playing with more players. I think all the factions are are really nice. Um I think they're going to be a lot of fun if if you're looking to expand your kind of root collection.
Yeah,
the thing is that they're not all super great for low player count games. So, these are definitely factions you want if you have a group of three, four, more. Uh, just to say, but one of the better expansions overall, I'd say, if not just for the quality, but also for the wealth of content, cuz usually you might get two factions or one map and two factions. And here you're getting Yeah.
Yeah.
all this stuff.
Mhm.
So, yeah. Any final thoughts?
No, I mean, you can't go wrong with more route, quite frankly, can you? I think we have everything, right?
Pretty much.
And I think there is still one or two factions that I haven't played as. I think
so. I mean, that's quite incredible, isn't it? Because Root's one of our most played games ever in our collection. And we still I still haven't managed to like get through all of the content. Yeah.
I really like that because then obviously it gives you something to look forward to and keep exploring.
Exactly. So that will be a review of the Homeland expansion. We have uh an well only outdated because this expansion has come out buyers guide for Root. So if you want to know more about kind of everything Route, go check that out except for the Homeland expansion, but we'll be updating that at some point in the future to include it. But there we cover all the other expansions, the base game, what you need to know about Route, what you need to know about all the expansions. So yeah, so if this was uh enjoyable to you, if it helped you, please consider subscribing. We also now have on YouTube a kind of membership thing that you can go and join if you want to support the channel in any way and then you get kind of special extras such as kind of uh private shorts or early access to videos or things like that. Uh so check that out if you would like to support us and we really appreciate you watching. See you next time. Bye bye.