Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ark Nova VS Terraforming Mars - Which Board Game Is Better?

Transcript 20:27

have you ever considered what civilization might be like if we lived on mars or are you someone who's enjoys the prospect of building a really successful zoo well in this video we compared two board games head to head terraforming mars and arc nova two car driven games to see which one is better let's go so we gained 25 income from this track i also gained 25 income from this track i play this card because i've already got these tags in my tableau i play this card because i've also got these icons in my tableau i place this forest tile on the map to raise the oxygen levels i place an enclosure of size 5 near your forest and place a zebra in it i release these inert gases i release these lines into the wild i tow a comet and then i warn you about this giant ice asteroid that's heading our way hang on i don't think we're playing the same board game here so you're telling me that we're not actually playing terraforming zoo tycoon on mars oh dear how could they ever get this game so wrong humans have always wanted to venture out to other planets to live settle and colonize always having an option b as a place to live seems pretty feasible to me i always say two board games are better than one as well in terraforming mars plays take on the role of giant corporations all contributing to a

collective effort to terraform mars so it can be inhabitable raise the temperature levels increase oxygen levels and raise the ocean so humans can survive there all whilst making a healthy profit on the side of course throughout the game players will be playing project cards by paying mega credits into their tableau certain cards have restrictions and can only be played when the conditions are optimal green cards provides players with resources and increased production value blue cards give players additional actions to choose from whilst red cards can impact your opponents tags on cards can help trigger really cool effects ultimately this is a game about producing resources managing them and using them to your advantage increase plant production to plant forests use heat to increase the temperature build a city to earn victory points everything you do is related to your terraforming rating have the highest rating at the end of the game to win animals are creatures that we truly care about imagine building a zoo that is centered around conservation and an effective breeding program that is recognized worldwide arc nova is a beast of a euro game that fosters the love for wildlife as well as allowing you to build an amazing zoo across the game players will be selecting from five action cards on this action row activating their power level based on their cards position for an action players can draw or snap extra cards into the hand like some sort of seagull or they can build an enclosure onto their map gaining any bonuses that are covered up players can also place animals into empty enclosures in their park only if

the size of the enclosure and the terrain and icon requirements are met though look this ain't no jungle book and we aren't just providing the bare necessities of life create an environment that emulates the real world and your animals will be truly happy players can also play blue sponsorship cards that provide alternative ways to score as well as providing unique buildings for their zoo players can also travel worldwide and make deals with other global zoos on this association board and contribute through their conservation efforts conservation cards help to move the conservation marker around the score track when a player's appeal and conservation markers cross over the end of the game is triggered both terraforming mars and arc nova share similar dna both are card driven games where the cards played require certain conditions to be met or have tags that trigger other bonuses and abilities both have long term game goals that players are racing to achieve and both have score tracks that provides players with income and are related to their victory throughout the game in terms of the theme the game allows players to dabble in lots of different elements the theme really comes through the project cards as well as the map itself one player might be dabbling in growing trees and plants whilst another player might be dabbling in symbiotic fungus what i really like about this game is that a lot of the ideas and concepts are presented through have a scientific backing or scientific understanding that underpins them which is really explained in the rulebook itself i really like the idea that the designer has thought about the potential

for different types of technology that might help terraform mars as a planner for example this card called giant space mirror is using um the sun's rays to try and help uh redirect the sun's light onto the planet to help plants grow and that is a really cool idea one other aspect that i really like is how the map itself reflects the topology of mars itself taking the actual geography of the planet and turning it into this board game structure is actually really ingenious arc nova is a game that i've waited a long time for i've loved playing zoo tycoon and planet zoo and building my own zoo and this game does it but using some really great euro mechanics the theme comes through strongly in terms of the artwork the photos that look like they've come from a stock footage archive as well as the maps on the player boards now a lot of the art is very divisive uh you either really like it or you really don't like and i'll just give you this when i first saw the cover i really didn't like it but then when i actually had the game in my hand and uncovered all the cards i actually fell in love with it it doesn't really bother me the photos actually to be honest i actually think they represent the animals really well but in terms of the theme there are some elements to this that i would describe as very puzzly and yuri and abstract for example the partnerships and gathering all the icons and there are other elements i think are really thematic like building the zoo enclosures deciding how big they're going to be matching the terrain also some of the

animals have particular abilities there's a vulture that has scavenging which allows you to shuffle the discard draw three and keep one so i think a lot of the abilities in the animals do marry up to the way that they would be in the real world so in terms of theme arc nova wins uh danny why is your arm in my fish tank you did just say i should get completely immersed in this board games theme terraforming mars provides players with a plethora of action and choices on each and every turn players have access to standard projects milestones and awards that they can contribute to but primarily a lot of the actions come from the cards that plays have in their hand and a lot of the actions are actually driven by the economy in the game the resources that you have and the resources that you produce each and every round having the right amount of resources and the right tags in your tableau is going to help you to play more projects more efficiently and then gain the bonus effects that come with it a lot of the effects are all about driving up production levels because the main focus of this game is to try and terraform the planet and by creating a production engine of resources that nets you more resources in the following round and more resources the following round after that creates a really cool sense of progression so cards like the archaeobacteria which increases your plant production or the shuttle which thematically decreases the amount of

energy production that you have because you need to invest energy into making the shuttles but increases the profit that you make each round it's also important to note that some of the project cards have conditional requirements and if you draw some cards later in the game those project cards aren't as useful to you because those parameters have either been exceeded or surpassed one of the main elements in arkanova that i think it excels exceptionally well is how plays execute their actions there is this action track where players have access to five different actions and depending where it is on the track that's how powerful that action can be executed so have a card at level five and you'll be able to create a really powerful move like building an enclosure that's five in size or maybe playing a sponsorship card worth five in power in addition to that players can add little x tokens to the power so if they've got a card lower down the track and they want to use it now they can pay the extra x tokens to increase that power level and get more of a benefit and more of a bonus being able to flip the cards over and upgrade them is a beautiful progressive mechanism that allows players to advance and strengthen the actions as they play the game so in terms of the action selection mechanism arc nova wins now in terms of bgg weight both games are pretty heavy there are a lot of engine building opportunities that terraforming mars has to offer i love this resource board the idea that you produce all these really

cool resources each and every round and then you move these little cubes around to indicate how many cubes of that resource you've got the idea that you can convert accumulated plants material into forests that go on the board and the sense that everything here is connected to the map the idea that this energy can be transferred into heat and that heat can then raise the temperature levels which then impacts the conditional status of this game that you're playing and that you're terraforming the idea that your credits are related to your score track and the victory points that you currently have around the edge of the board is super cool like the blood flowing through your body that blood is going to help feed everything that you're trying to do as it branches out and it develops and grows over time

are you going to be paying for that board game uh yeah of course what do you think i am some sort of cheapskate so that's two gold cubes one silver and one bronze cube thank you in terms of engine building and economy there are two ways arc nova primarily achieves this the first is using the appeals track by player encouraging players to place more animals in their zoo that forces their little appeals marker to move around the little ticket track and whichever it stops in whenever it's a break players are going to gain that much money players can also generate money by placing these little kiosk tiles which are little shops on their map earning one dollar each time a break is triggered the fact that plays can um trigger the break and determine how fast the next break is going to happen is really great game design and it means that players can kind of pace the round out if they've got a lot of money to spend or if they don't have a lot of money to spend they can use their sponsorship card to really push it along the other engine building element that this game offers is through the sponsorship cards the idea that you can actually get these ongoing break effects where whenever there's a break you can gain a particular resource as depicted by these hand symbols as well as cards like this where if you gain or put have particular icons in your park or place things next to certain terrain types you can gain a bonus at the end of the game

the only downside that i'll mention is that sometimes when you draw a sponsor card the sponsor cards don't really apply to the zoo that you've established or you might draw it too early in the game to be able to decide where you're going to go or you draw it too late in the game to be able to trigger any of the effects so in terms of engine building terraforming mars wins so when i play this project card i get to place a cube on this other project card because it's got the same tag and because i play this other project kind of triggers this other card which i put another cube and then i put some cubes onto my little production board and convert those cubes into these other cubes which these other cubes become other cubes which other cubes become other cubes that have to put on the board wow what an engine in terms of the tile placement mechanism there isn't much of a deep puzzle that players are really engaged in in terraforming mars it is incredibly thematic however because the geography of the board really reflects the actual true nature of the topology of mars itself and the idea that certain ocean tiles can go in certain places only is really cool to see i also like the synergy between surrounding your city tiles with greenery tiles that feels really thematic the idea that those greenery tiles are providing oxygen for the people living in those cities and it's also interesting note that the placement of the tiles are really quite symbolic and representative of your progress throughout the game but that can kind of feel a little bit samey every time you play because the map essentially stays the same the tile placement aspect in arc nova is incredibly intriguing i like the fact that players have to think about the size of their animal as well

as the size of their enclosure they're going to pre-build those enclosures before they place those animals there's a multi-step level of thinking that has to be involved i also like the different shapes of the actual enclosures and trying to fit those shapes topologically onto your map and trying to connect certain habitats to the water tiles and the mountain tiles because those animals desire those environmental conditions is a brilliant touch the idea that you're placing these tiles so that they cover yellow bonuses helps you to build a tile placement engine and one thing that really shines about this game is that you feel like your zoo is expanding at the beginning of the game you've got lots of space to place those enclosures but towards the end of the game you find that your space becomes more and more restricted and that size five animal might not be able to fit in your zoo if you really want to get those last minute points and the idea of building a really unique enclosure like a reptile house to move all your reptiles in there or make those enclosures empty again so that you can put late-game animals into your zoo so in terms of the tile placement art nova wins so when in this game do we get to deploy our fleet of spaceships and engage and roll for combat oh different game by shaping the cards around particular themes players can kind of feel like they're narrowing in on a certain playstyle that can be exhibited throughout the game so if i play this decomposer card whenever i play an animal plane or microbe tag into my tableau i get to add a microbe to this

card the end of the game i get one terror forming raiding point for everything microbes on it later on i play this ghe producing bacteria card because it has a micro tag i get to put a microbe on this decomposer card i later then play this nitrate reducing bacteria card which allows me to add three microbes to the card and then later on for an action add one minecraft to the card i'll remove three to increase my terraforming rating one step because i play this tag i put another microbe on the decomposer card later on i play the symbiotic fungus which allows me to add a microbe to another card so because it has a tag i get to put a microbe on that and i'm going to put another microbe on this kind of remember i've got two options here i could do it on this cut or this card i might do it on this card here i might play this extreme cold fungus card which allows me to gain one plan or add two microbes to another card so later on i use an action to place another two fungus on this card here but because it's also got a microbe tag i get to put one on a decomposer card in terms of card synergy and combo i really like the tag system that's in this game and that's very similar to terraforming mars i also like how some other cards are connected to the power level and that the tiles themselves are placed in your map are all connected to the card too that kind of synergy between tile placement and card actions is really crucial for making this game flow however in terms of synergies between the cards themselves i feel like that is a little

bit sparse there's not actually that much that happens the sponsorship cards do introduce that element of when you play these icons you might get this bonus or you get these at the end of the game but in terms of the animal cards themselves there's very little interaction between animals of the same continent there's one i think that does dabble in a little bit and that's the herbivores where you can place herbivores into the same enclosure because they get along and they're not going to eat each other so in terms of card combo and card synergy terraforming mars wins i absolutely love the symbols and iconography in this game it makes this game so easy to understand in terms of the player-to-player interaction terraforming mars does have a healthy dose of it and it does so in a few different ways whilst players are trying to build their tableau and whilst that seems to be quite solitary this main map of mars is where a lot of interaction happens players are racing to compete for awards and milestones players are collectively as a group working cooperatively to move the three parameters the oxygen the heat and the ocean levels out into the map which kind of determines the tempo and speed of the game as well as trying to place tiles out to claim certain resources that are on the board and connecting those tiles is super important there is another way where plays interact and that is through using these red project cards which allows you to stop production or reduce production of another place plant levels as well as

stealing money and credits from other people and if players are playing with the drafting variant at the beginning of the game players have a little bit of interaction there when it comes to denying certain project cards to certain plays in terms of play to play interaction and game length arc move is definitely a long game because even at the two player level you're probably looking at a minimum of two and a half to three hours of gameplay so be ready and strap yourselves in for a safari ride folks here the game feels like a race i know each player has their own player board and it kind of feels like you're playing multiplayer solitaire but the race to get around the ball and move the conservation is what drives the tension the idea that you can also purchase these cards and snap them from this central area is something that players are often competing for but also there are certain tags that trigger when you play sponsorship cards into your zoo so when someone plays science icon that might trigger something else in someone else's tableau so there's that kind of indirect and passive interaction that does occur in this game one really interesting element to the game is the idea of trying to fulfill and get those conservation cards so there's three or four that are placed out depending on your play account at the beginning of the game that everyone really fights for but then you can actually get more conservation cards as the game progresses and fulfill them as you go what that means is that the way you get conservation points constantly changes so in terms of player to play

interaction terraforming mars wins so which of these two board games do you think is better both of these games have a really strong place in my board game collection i think that both games offer something different depending on the situation if i wanted to play a multiplayer game with three or four players i'd definitely get out terraforming mars and use those project cards and i really like how the project cards provide plays with lots of different actions but the actions provide players with short-term gains whereas arc nova is a really long game that i would definitely only play at the two-player level i think the actions here are fewer but the actions are deeper richer and provide lots of long-term gains so in comparing both games i think my ultimate and final decision would have to be arc nova it's just a theme and a game that i connect and resonate with more thank you once again for joining me and making it this far into the video if you really like the quality of my videos and you really love the board game content that i provide please consider giving me a subscribe head over to my patreon page and like this video that would really really help this channel grow and i would really appreciate it and if you want to start a conversation please let me know your thoughts in the comment section below which of these two did you think was better otherwise this is danny sunny can't wait to bring you another great review in the near future goodbye

Progress saved