What Makes a Board Game ADDICTING – Board Games & Coffee Ep. 1
Transcript
uh good evening or good morning depending on where you are welcome to board games and coffee this is my new live show this is something I've wanted to do for a while to sit down and talk about our board game hobby so uh since this is the first episode let me tell you a little bit about how I've structured it so during the week I opened up a poll to ask my subscribers what they'd like the show to be about and after the poll the topic for today is uh what makes a board game addictive so then I had a few more polls and a quiz asking a few questions getting some ideas hearing other people's thoughts I've recorded all of my thoughts and responses in advance now I'm going to be streaming this with normal latency so there is going to be that like that delay between what I say and when you hear it so as far as comments are concerned what I'll do is I'm going to go over my notes here and then at the end we'll go over people's comments and we'll end with that so I am actually filming this from okanawa Japan and it is 7 a.m. on Tuesday but I think most of my viewers are in the United States so that's why I usually do things on East Coast time I
lived in New York for a while I had lots of friends in New York I I I I try to think in terms of East Coast but I'm over here in the future in Japan which is why board games and coffee all right so my thoughts oh and also I wanted to include that we have the Discord channel uh oh if you are a patreon member then you are on the Discord Channel and for you I'm going to keep that tab open oh my gosh I lost the tab there it is all right I got that tab too so if you're on Discord and you're on our Network there then you can share your comments there as well all right so I think there are really two ways to uh think about categorize addictive board games and really when I did the polls I got two different types of responses because I asked two questions with or rather I had two options would you like the game to be about how addictive games can be or another option was what exactly is replayability anyway and the second most popular topic was
what is replayability anyway and then when I asked people to share with me what they think makes a game addictive some people gave me traits of games that I would categorize as replayable so I think kind of inherent in this topic is what's the difference between something being addictive or replayable um I think of addictive as being something that you want to keep playing over and over again you sit down you play it once and you're like well hold on a sec we we let's play it again really quick because I want another go at it right I think of replayability as something that uh you you you want to replay but not necessarily in a row now that's not that's not everybody I found out and and it really gives me two categories for addictive game game play uh because the first thing I noticed when I considered all of my board games is that the addictiveness of a game is seasonal you've got the games that you kind of binge play you play them over and over again maybe you play for days or weeks and then after you've sort of like had that fix they sort of go back on the shelf for a while you might not play them again for a really long time then you've got the Evergreen games which are the that have that addictive quality that you will take out whenever or the ones that you keep wanting to
bring back because something is calling you in fact I couldn't I want to be I want to share with you the game that I'm going to be thinking about for the next several weeks but you know I'm GNA I'm going to hold off on that I'll tell you I'll tell you at the end so uh first the games that have that seasonal addictive quality or or or you know even with a replayability the next thing I noticed about all of these games is that there is a social element to these games and I think you've had that everyone's had that feeling before where you have a game you're really excited about you you you tell your friends oh this is going to be a great game like I'm really excited to play this you get it on the table you set it up you teach the rules people are like okay yeah yeah sounds good sounds good you play it and it just Falls flat like like it's just not as enjoyable as you remember at last and you're going ah you know I'm sorry I I I I remember this game being different and I think that's the social quality of a game because I will be sharing with you my little list of games that I think are addictive at least to me and I know I know you will hear some of the games on my list and you'll go really like that's not I don't I don't think that's a very good game game I'm sure you will but it depends on where it lands and who it lands with and sometimes I get surprised I will take out a game that I actually
am like okay well I don't know if I like this game that much but it's probably it's probably like a good game for who I'm with and I teach it to them and then because they like it I like the game more that social quality of a game so that adds to The Addictive value of games all right so the first idea we've got the two categories second idea we've got that social element and then finally third idea the profile of these games so um of course you know me the way that I like to analyze games I like to break it down into five attributes so we got design interaction Artistry skill and complexity that's how I think of all games and even when I think about games that are attributes that aren't in five attributes like addict addictiveness I think adct addictiveness breaks down into those components as well so of the five attributes the three attributes that contribute to addictiveness and I'm talking about that that seasonal like serial playing you can't put the game down mechanics luck and or skill rather and complexity so uh mechanics meaning that the design of the game is mean mechanics focused rather than thematic rather than telling a story uh that the skill in the game has a higher degree of luck and that the game has a very low complexity
it's quick to set up quick to play over and over again and the best evidence of this is just look at the information from the most recent poll if you if you missed it my last poll the one that I did last night or this morning was uh which of the four games uh has the most logged views and the choices were Ark Nova terraforming Mars Azul and Splendor and by the way some other games that people liked like Scythe um uh spirit Island like I looked at the numbers for those games too they didn't even compare I even looked at Kanan the only one that was that had a lot of was noteworthy but I didn't put it on the quiz was Ticket to Ride but Ticket to Ride would have been uh really big numbers as well so which of those games has the most plays logged on Board Game Geek a zoo of all games and think about why if you're not familiar with Azul I mean it's a it's a tactile tile placing game you're you're making rows of different colors it has like no theme at all so it's strictly mechanical I say and then the whole point of the game is collecting collecting these tiles that come out randomly so you're collecting tiles that come out randomly you're putting them on your your pad you there drafting I there you know depending on the number of players you got five pools of tiles to take from but there's no there's no strategy in what the
available Market is you're just taking the best of the five so you got that element of luck and you got low complexity you teach this game in less than five minutes and people and it gets it gets on the table so I think that adds to The Addictive quality but there's something else really special about about uh games that I want to play over and over and over again and that is almost all of them have an Abrupt ending so in specific mechanics these games have an Abrupt ending and they often have in fact you know what I want to share something somebody wrote somebody wrote me they said uh this is from jaming sometimes YouTube handles jaming um sorry I don't know what it's supposed to mean the YouTube handle I wrote either you're building towards something later and you feel like you're getting progress or you're able to produce something substantial and I really liked that idea you're able to produce something later it's that engine building quality of a game you get this momentum you're doing something that you that you want to achieve you're working towards it you're working towards something and then if the game has that abrupt ending like somebody triggers the end game or they score the threshold of points necessary for the game to end it's just like oh oh I didn't get to finish my thing I oh if I had one more turn if I had one more
turn and that probably more than anything else adds to The Addictive quality of the game if I had one more turn now Azul in my opinion doesn't do that aul you play until you run out of the tiles so there's no game in trigger and you're not even taking the points as you play you do the points at the end of the game so I'm actually kind of disappointed to see that well I I wouldn't use aul as the best game for Addictive quality you know what I would use I would use the like the the more recent uh I would I would almost call it like an adaptation of aul because it feels like a zul it's the game harmonies which is like brand new um it has same kind of like you're you're you're getting these wooden tiles you're putting them on your pad to attract animals you're trying to build ecosystems and get more and more animals but the thing is as soon as somebody's Board gets so full of tiles that they have two or less spaces left the game ends with everybody gets the same number of turns but then the the game ends and so if you've got animals that you haven't pulled your board or you were working on a forest and you haven't added the Treetops or your mountain range isn't complete you you're just like oh oh if I had can I have one more turn can I have one more turn and you don't get it or another one man if you've played um okay so Ticket to Ride I said Ticket to Ride has a lot of plays so a long time ago I did a list on games about uh games that were better than Ticket to Ride and one of them was
ethnos ethnos is a is interesting game but it's hard to find it was out a print I thought it would come back in print instead they did a um reimplementation of ethnos called Aro Society you can't see it in the frame but Aro societ ARCA Society is basically a card game but as you're taking cards and you're you're playing these sets of cards uh each round as soon as a card gets flipped over like there's three of these idle cards okay the first idle card comes out it's like okay the end of the game is near the second one comes out it's like oh boy it's getting really close and you're trying to complete sets you're trying to complete sets you've got a set of like five cards left if you could just play this card if you could just play this set you're going to score so many points but then the third idle card comes out the game immediately ends you don't get you don't get another turn you get nothing it is over immediately that kills oh if I had one more turn that is such an addictive quality anyway so that's how I feel about the seasonal games did I include anything else here let me look at my notes you're going to okay so here uh I made a list of the games that have this quality oh and the season too so like in my early season of playing I I loved playing ticket to ride over and over
again I don't I don't anymore but I used to play K I used to play Dominion uh Santorini you know Santorini the crew uh these games don't have the same in early game trigger but man they're so easy to set up and play again and that really helps the crew you play like it's Cooperative it's Cooperative you play a game that takes five minutes you lose and it's like oh it's only five minutes let's let's just play one more time I have had so many games of the crew that go late into the night even five minute games but we can't stop playing because every time we lose we just one more time let's try let's try one more time archo Society harmonies gizmos has that engine building effect uh where somebody somebody hits the threshold of points that terminates the game it's like oh I not done if I had one more turn uh Machi Coro so I don't you know Machi Coro it's such a it's an older game but Machi Koro same thing engine builder with dice and cards it's got the element of luck very easy to explain Splendor does it but Splendor man 15 points first to 15 points and then it ends and you've got those objectives uh fertility now fertility man well I'm not going to go on about fertility and you know a different one well I I wrote down code names code names is a team based game it's completely unlike the others anyway um all right so next
thing those games that are evergreen characteristic so here's the difference big big major difference between the Evergreen games in the seasonal games uh Evergreen games are not so easy to set up so you play them once you get to the end and even if you want to play again you're like well gosh I would like to play again but I'm not going to put away all the pieces that we put out on the board and then set it up all over again and then play again and maybe there like three hours long like that you it can be as no matter how addictive it is there's no time I'm ever going to play I don't well I think one time I played two games of eclipse in a row I think but it was on a retreat where like I think I played Eclipse I mean that's a crazy game to play twice in a row but generally speaking I will never play two hour three hour plus game twice in a row no matter how addictive it is but what is it that makes these games hit the table over and over again and like you know I'm going to share this comment I like this one a lot I liked how they said it this is from Nitro rev he wrote for me it's how expansive the possibilities games like root and spirit Island have endless possibilities because the variability of player Powers but also of special abilities found within the card
pool and how they interact with playable characters card X on character Y is decent but the same card on character Z is amazing it makes the game feel like a laboratory that you can experiment while playing but also think and theorize about it while not even playing these are the types of games that you can easily find yourself obsessed with and then going back to the other one by gmv um wait where's the shoot I missed something maybe it's the other one ah here this one actually biod delic uh simply said it all comes down to the loop how does it flow how variable is it how open to experimentation it is I love that how open to experimentation it is that is so true um so the game that I'm obsessed with right now this one is called what do I have to click right here boom rip nope this way uh an age contrived so and actually I have it ah I have it in front of me right now I was trying to set up the frame so that you could see is that so beautiful it's like I'm like shaking the camera all over the place like stop shaking it um man this game has it plays up to five characters or five people which is cool
and it has five characters which doesn't sound like a lot but what's cool is the achievements that come out every single time and then the location of bridges which are like in game I don't know super abilities um and then the the rewards that you get on each of these monuments things that like what the what the comment said the guy said um let's hide that um things that open up experimentation okay so so this achievement for this character is awesome but if I was this character and how could I use that ability with that objective oh so sweet I want to play the game like that I've played this game with three different characters and you know sorry this is not a review for an age contrived but now that I've got it in front of me and I'm talking about it I'm being specific it doesn't matter what you're playing here let me list a bunch of them these are just a few of the ones that I wrote oh man I wrote them down in different groups too so AR well arcan NOA is arcn NOA has a lot of plays that game by the way had more plays this month than aul did it's it's actually I didn't find a game that has more plays this month than Ark Nova Arc Nova doesn't really have player Powers you've got the different boards but the cards that's what it is with Arc NOA the cards you've got the sponsors that come up and then the different animals and like you can try to play a strategy that uses like for
got the expansion like sea animals but if sea animals don't come out or if they get taken from you you got to go another route um revive I man I really like revive I and I think and I don't know I didn't know why I liked revive so much until I did this but it's exactly what we're talking about here uh Roco now roko doesn't have a lot of cards but the the the different strategies that you can use with this kind of like card Builder mechanic to it I really like roko and by the way I will say something else about this if you if you don't like Great Western Trail like me or maybe it's not that I don't like it I I I don't get great Great Western Trail I think R Coco does what Great Western Trail doesn't do for me I keep try I keep trying I'm trying to like like it better um then there's a there's a few games on here too that I wrote down that do have that that um addictive quality of the seasonal games but they're a little bit longer so I don't play them all in a row they they're engine building so think like everell or Wings span you got your Tableau building but you've got the end game trigger I think that's crucial so you're trying to do your thing and then someone ends the game and you're it just makes you want
to play again Earth is like that Earth I've called is like a you know it's kind of like wingspan but un unlike everybody getting the same number of turns it ends when someone hits that trigger wonders creatures that's like everdell with an ingame trigger um so I wrote that down those two games but not wingspan and
nevero H well I think I think I mean I think that's it that's what that's what captures me with these Evergreen games but I look at like sometimes look at my shelf some of these games I just don't think I've played enough yet so I think I'm going to switch over to comments Now comments and questions starting with Discord right so I do have a question and the question is uh how does theme let's see how do I get there we go so I do have a question and the question is uh how does theme affect uh replayability so that is what I think is really interesting so a lot of the addictive games have like no theme they're they're virtually themeless and again I'm going to use aul and Splendor as my examples because there just they have so many plays aul is about mosaics in Portugal like no it's not it's about it's about little hard tiles tactile tiles people don't you know play this game and go oh you know this really captures the essence of being a mosaic designer it
doesn't it's just an abstract game Splender you actually feel like a a gym Merchant when you're playing Splender of course not it's about the tokens and in fact I didn't think about that but both of those games have that physical tactile element to I think that adds to their um that adds to their addictiveness but the most addictive games are not very thematic now some of the Evergreen ones are but I think the mechanics are really bring it in like here here here's an example here's a game that's not addictive at all I like it I like it a lot I think it's a great game Twilight Struggle right one of the most thematic games I've ever played about the Cold War granted it's like you know takes six hours to play but you don't play that game and oh let's play it again like because the theme is so good I've never played an addictive game where the theme really draws me in maybe the most thematic addictive game that's even on my list is harmonies but even then why because it's got little animals in the in the ecosystem it's barely thematic I I I almost think that a game that is thematic it almost can't be addictive because it has a story to it and that's it it has a story to to it if a game has a story to it then it begins it has a beginning a middle and end and when it ends it's just like ah and now we've completed it and the story is done but with an early in-game trigger oh no no you're just like oh it didn't
have an ending it didn't have an ending we have to play again because it didn't end all right I got another one from YouTube ah I might need to move to see it how wait I got two from YouTube hey hey hey the anticipation of a Game ending early makes the game addictive in my mind District no Noah with the Game ending automatically when a player collects all three City cards may or may not be in the deck yes okay so I haven't played District district Noah but the quality that you're describing about the the cards that are may or may not be in the deck that is exactly what I'm talking about with our chaos society and the other one I got here is do you think having an easy setup tear down leads to a game being more addictive than ones with more setup oh um so yes absolutely I don't think I I adequately explained that when I was going over my points um but yes like part of the reason why Splender is so addictive I mean again I Splender is not my most favorite game but I think so many people know it and I got to use examples people know the reason why it works so well is because you just put the cards back shuffle them and do it again um in fact maybe it's the only thing
about our Cho society that kind of bugs me is that you've got all of the it has two elements of addictiveness but what's cool and Al kind of a drag is that the cards H uh the deck is different every time you pick six different characters to put into the deck and you Shuffle it so if you want to play again like oh let's play again but let's use the use different characters well the problem is okay well how are we going to do that we got to we got to sort the deck we got to put all these characters back we got to take those characters we got to shuffle again it takes so long to sort a deck of cards and who really wants to do that so every time I play archo Society more than once I play like well I guess there's been some times when I've gone gone through the trouble but I wonder if that was more for learning the game than because I felt like it it's not fun to set something up more than once it's not fun to set something up more than once I enjoyed setting the game that was up in front of me just because I like the excitement of setting up a game but after I've done it once no don't want to do it again so yes and no I'm trying to think if there's any example of a game that's difficult to set up that I don't mind
H I can't think of one I can't think of a single game that's that's difficult to set up that I that has that addictive quality where you want to keep playing over and over again all right well I'm going to give it one more second we're about to sign off let me take a sip of my coffee
jump over to the Discord ah gosh I should have put my keyboard on the table no all right well Men at Work easy to is set up oh darn I don't know man at work I'm sorry I can't respond to that one gosh should I know it is that one I need to learn well anyway here's what's going to happen moving forward so uh we are going to be meeting again next week same time whether that's 7:00 a.m. on Tuesday or 6:00 p.m. on Monday same time as next week and stay tuned make sure if you are a subscriber you will get a notification when I put up the next poll we're going to vote on the next topic and I will be sure to put a bunch of teaser questions on there uh to to get the conversation going uh as far as this game is concerned at age contrived this is the game that I'm currently obsessed with and I will be doing a few uh different videos and features for it coming up soon so you can look out for that if you like if you're like the people who are saying that addictiveness is player abilities and and unending possibilities and opportunities for experimentation
this one just hit retail last month so I I very much recommend it but I will be doing some more in depth reviews for it again thank you so much for watching and thank you for your participation in the comment section