Skip to main content
Loading video...

Twilight Imperium w/ Prophecy of Kings and Thunder's Edge: Discussion

Transcript 1:12:21

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and we are doing a massive discussion for Twilight Imperium and the newest expansion, Thund's Edge and probably of Kings. Uh there are six of us as you can tell where uh the only new one for the channel is Chris. Chris, thank you for being here.

Hello everybody. Um, tell us your deepest, darkest secret before we hop in here.

Deepest, darkest secret. This was my first board game.

Oh my god.

Uh, no. So, it's been so long since I've done a discussion for with this many people and such a massive one to do a discussion for, including the expansion. But caveat, three of the six people here, this was their first time playing. Another one who's only played it one time before, one who's played it a handful of times, which is me and the EXPERT WHO [ __ ] LOST BECAUSE HE SUCKS.

He's going to be like, "No more choosing next the the virus. You're [ __ ] next game.

We're going to play S class only."

And he's round three.

I got zero points. Um, so I'm trying to kind of figure out how to make this not just be a verbal diarrhea jumble of a discussion. Uh, so I think I'll go down the line and quickly What was everyone's thoughts? I'll start with you three cuz this was your first time. Your first uh

I hated it. This was awful. It was just a bad time. No, it was a

All six hours.

Yeah, all six hours of it. I was just in agony. No, this was a this was a blast. I had a I had a good time with it. Uh, lot going on. I have to say I was uh paralyzed with what uh could be called analysis.

I think there's a short idiom for that.

A trial. Yeah. Yeah. Little bit of that. Yeah. A lot going on. A lot you can do. What was it? Upgrades. Ship tri. What is it called? I just learned this. 4x.

4x. Yeah. Yeah.

It's like probably the the top of 4x in the genre. I would imagine

it's definitely up there. um

besides other games that are similar to this like Eclipse which is more Euro than this one but this one really captures all four of those I think the best experience

um but yeah

so you liked it

yeah it was a good time I mean like

by honestly I think

what other games have I played similar to it would uh

we played Zia Zia

Zia would you call Zia I played once I bought it from you

I got Yeah, you fool.

Yeah, I was like, "Oh, painted miniatures."

But I mean, Rising Sun. Well, no, it's not Forex.

Um, Last Light, if you've played that one,

Last Light is basically like an hour. It's like a quick hour version of this a little bit. Um, but I don't think you've played that. This might be your first Forex game besides maybe a video game that does something similar to it. You play area control games, right,

like Rising Sun or Blood Rage or things like that, but nothing with the extent of

tech or um negot like as heavy negotiation as this one can have.

Mhm.

Um Chris, what do you think?

Uh I think it was a pretty good great game. Uh the faction I chose I felt like was not beginner friendly and that's probably on me. I was not aware of when to be aggressive cuz I was too busy trying to be peaceful.

I didn't even think your faction was meant to be aggressive this entire time. But I do feel like I took risks that I should not have taken so early and that did set me back in a way. But otherwise, I think it was a great game.

All you did was sllight me on a point and I'm like, I have to kill him now.

Yeah, I lost more units to black holes in that last last fight.

I think that really almost took you out of the game was you lost your flagship. I think you lost a dreadnot at one point and they were all carrying units. So, it's like, well, there's And then your presence was just virtually gone while you're adjacent to a guy who almost feels late game to be super powerful. Um, Kyle, what do you think?

It was Yeah, it was a lot of fun. I do think that my faction was one that is better late game. I was building up to something and I had a large a large deck of action cards that just never got used.

I know. Yeah, you did have so many. Is there really no way you can use these besides what their actual

Yeah.

uses for just stalling? Just stalling.

Yep.

But um yeah, I mean there was a lot I had planned and just Well, we only got to go four rounds.

I know. That actually surprised me. I didn't know if that was uh due to the expansion being added or what led to it. I mean to be fair though a lot of people have the stigma with TI of it being like a 14 15 20our game and

and that was base game and three three was 14 hours.

Yeah,

but they streamlined it.

Yeah, cuz in in that can definitely attribute a little bit more of what fourth edition brings. But yes, like my experience was 6 to 8 whenever I was playing and we we actually ended almost exactly at 6 hours,

right?

Um but you three were the newest and you all had a great time.

Yeah, that was fun. Awesome. It can only get better with more experience. Right.

Right. Right.

The guy to ask. I haven't played in like years.

I mean, we only asked him 400 questions.

No, I was I was so happy that you were able to make it because I was like,

we looking up rules.

The game is just rule.

Shout out to what was it? The cardboard uh the cardboard cuck. Was that I don't remember his YouTube name.

Oh, the walkthrough.

Yeah. For the for the how to play.

Well, you should do different videos.

What was it? the crash course. Cardboard or cardboard?

Cardboard crash course.

Yeah, he has like a whole channel.

He was awesome. Like with his how to play video that was a godsend and and two hours long to get over the basics.

An hour and a half if you skip the setup.

He even had a faction video over my guys. That helped cuz I would have no idea.

Yours came out like a couple days ago.

Oh, they just came out.

Just uploaded that.

Perfect.

Um still lost.

But yeah, no, for sure. So, shout out to him because he was a godsend for learning the game, relearning the game.

Um, Brad, what do you think?

This my second time playing it. It went,

you know, it's I still enjoyed as much as I did the first time we played. I think I played like a

more points than the last time you played.

I can't remember. I was the necro, so yeah, I had more

cuz I was screwing everybody over. But

um but no, I had my one big move where I puked out and I have like 20 ground units on the the center of the board, which I would have been interested to see how that went before somebody rushed the end. But um

yeah, it this game almost has that tipping point of like, okay, cuz you you have the first two points of like setup and then it's like then it starts to snowball. Um, and it's like if I couldn't take it, then Zach was gonna take it or someone was gonna just immediately steal it from me. And I was like, I I have to try and end this.

If you didn't have that skill retreat, I was going to get out from under him because

Oh, cuz you had the way to just bomb cuz I was three and he was four.

Yeah.

So, you would move out. It would go through. I could activate mel first. He would lose a point just to try to come in and take mel. Oh, that's so funny. Um, and last, Zack, what do you think of this of your favorite game of all time?

I mean, it's pretty much fantastic.

It got worse. The expansion made it worse. You're like, "This sucks."

No. Playing with us just made it the worst game. He's like, "I'll never touch this again."

Sitting there like that Auntie Donna video, I got to get out of here.

No. Are you watching Zack?

No. Hockey. But I I imagine with both expansions coming in, it just elevated from a 10 to a [ __ ] 15.

Yeah, it's a near perfect game for me,

right? Um so with that being said, uh what cuz without just anyone throwing out there, um also for me, uh yeah, no, this game is always it's whenever we do our top 100s for the year, it's like the year I play it, it's like top 20. like it it just jumps up and then if I don't play it, which it's so hard to get to the table, it like shoots way down to like, well, I haven't played it in 5 years. It's still fantastic. I don't think it's ever left my top 100 and I've never even though I mainly at this point only can get two or three people to the table.

This game is not great with anything less than four.

So, I think four is a decent number.

Four is okay.

Four or six. You want like you want even numbers. Yeah.

Um, but because of that, it's never been a game I've ever thought about getting rid of. And there's many games where I'm like, "Ah, this is best with four. I'll probably just get rid of it."

Uh, this one I'm like, "I can't. I can't. It has to stay in my collection. It's too much of a staple. Too fantastic of a game when you can get it to the table."

Yeah.

So, one thing that might be interesting is again going around the table. And what was We'll start with Chris. What was your favorite thing about the game? Since we all liked it, I don't think anyone here was like, "This [ __ ] sucks."

Uh, honestly, going through the the how to play video, it's just knowing how many factions and choices it has really feels like this game, you could play it so many times and always feel different. And I feel like with a lot of Forex games, especially the like baby's first, like Katon essentially, eventually the game feels like stale. You start to understand. I don't think you could ever future plan in this quite the same way because they could just be completely different.

Sure.

So easily and I love games that I can keep playing coming back to and I always feel like it's a refreshing experience versus I'm just waiting to win.

You're going through the motions like okay yeah I know what and I I feel like some factions Zach can probably attest to this a little bit more. Some factions lend more to the this is what I'm going to do more than others. But like you said, there's 30 fa 30 factions now,

something like that.

I think um which is insane considering the fact that every faction has their own unique ability. All some of their ships are different. Their flagships are in it. They have their agent, commander, and heroes, their own uh um promisary note, their own texts. It's not a million different texts, but like just enough to make you still feel even more different. And the board can be different when things come in is different. There's a lot of variet variables that helps the variety. It's

has a lot to play with.

100%. Yeah. Deon, what was your favorite thing?

My favorite thing about the game that we played. Let's see. Man, [sighs and gasps] one thing specifically something

I [clears throat] did make a war. That was pretty badass. I mean, I really enjoyed my faction. They were they were fun. I hated that they started the weak u but everything about their snowballing effect uh really spoke to me.

So I guess I can say my my my faction I enjoyed them.

Yeah.

Uh their being being a being a wararm

monger.

Oh yeah. Yeah. And that's the thing is like you also I feel like

you played you both played

pretty difficult factions.

Um well actually yours is probably the most difficult to play with two different factions. I I almost feel like there were five that came out in the Thunders Edge expansion

plus the

plus the C codeex one. So, six technically.

So, I I don't know what the the other two do cuz we did play with four new ones. The Crimson Rebellion ended up surprising me a lot more than I thought they would cuz I was like, "Oh, they spread out too thin. I'm going to get [ __ ] on." Uh to be fair, I just put a breach out and I'm like, "Hey, you guys don't get abilities anymore. I'm not even [ __ ] that shit." and it was an any I'm going to hand myself. Kyle, what was your favorite thing?

I mean, I do agree. Of course, the complexity lends to its replayability. Um, which, yeah, I can't see myself getting tired of this game. It would take so many replays for me to feel like I mastered any part of it. Um,

yeah. I mean, the specific part that I like the most probably the technology trees. Um,

yeah,

I think the choices you get so many choices and there's so many different avenues you can go down, right? So,

and even though the game takes a long time, you only do like four texts besid Well, not four techs total, but like one guaranteed way to get tech besides other abilities. So, you're never going to get all your techs out and well figured it out.

Um, so you have so many different decisions. Now, you said there was a strength between the techs of like blue is like the best, red's the best, red's second,

right? There's tech paths that most people play. So, blue gives you movement in this game. Movement wins you [clears throat] games,

right? I can see that for sure. Now, with the expansion, they expanded about that so you can get to higher level text faster because of your breakthroughs,

which then opens up because like I got the best level of green and that one is pretty solid,

right?

Um, and most people pre thunder's edge were never getting that.

Yeah. No, there's no time.

That makes a good point because with the deep rod being in, I got my Warson out. I didn't even expect to go war sun, but because of my breakthrough, I was able to get, you know, a couple blues and then a red. And I'm like, cool. Now I'm just going to reduce the yellow I need. And there there it is.

Uh I did build one. But it was always this big like nuke like, "Hey, hey, don't fight me. He's he's sitting right here like he can just show up out of nowhere." Um, my favorite thing about this game, and it always has been my favorite since third edition, which is the only other version I played, is which we only did once this game is the politics. Like no other game has ever that I could think of has ever actually implemented laws and and agendas and things that get voted on by players that can where it's like cuz we only saw two uh surprisingly but they were both for or against but the other version is like elect player

that there's so much negotiation that goes into this game uh with so many ways to actually negotiate cuz so many other games are like hey let's negotiate like we can only trade money you know they're so restrictive on your negotiation. here it's like we can trade oh with this card we can trade action uh cards we can trade promisary nodes we can trade promises for there's just so many things you can do that then ties into the politics phase of like hey if you vote for me then I will do this for you and it actually matters and they have both the binding ability of like I will give you 10 trade goods [clears throat] and you can't neg out on that you can't be like actually never mind if you can trade it immediately you have to but if it's future stuff you can be Actually, never mind.

Right.

That's always been awesome cuz so many of the politics cards can be really, really huge if you have the planets to basically be like, actually, I'm going to vote against this or whatever. So, I've always loved that. Uh Brad,

my favorite part each time I've played this is always the is the strategy cards.

Mhm.

No. Oh, these.

Yeah. because you you the one you choose you get that big action but then you have it keeps you engaged in the game enough because then especially in a six player game you have the chance of doing five other sub actions.

Yeah.

So I mean it it gives you all that variation and choice that you can do and you have to manage your strategy tokens of course.

Yeah. But um just having that variation and it's also turn order.

So it's like, you know, I just like that having that multi- stuff and keeping you because if it didn't have the secondary ability, you'd just be sitting here for 30 minutes waiting for your turn.

That's true.

30 minutes per person turn. So it's like you did a great job with also making it that you don't want to just instantly use your ability because that second ability could just be what changes the game for someone else. you have to be cautious with when you invoke your options.

And they added a lot of ways to kind of even mitigate that even more. I don't know if like the the one I played against you where it's like, "Hey, give me all your [ __ ] or do your strategy." Um, and I think I think I played that right whenever I did my Imperial to get the two points because I was I was worried that you were going to do something to stop that. So, I'm like, I'm actually just going to kill your turn by making you do a tech and that's it. You certainly did because I had a plan and you're just like, "No, you got to do this or you're going to be fine.

Give me all whatever 15 trade goods and all your action cards."

Yeah, I had 10 at the time.

Oh, no. Or just, "Hey, how about we tech?" And I think that actually gave me cuz I was able to research. Oh, I got assault cannon, which never came in handy, but it was good cuz I was going to kill your uh flagship at the start of space combat in a system that contains three or more of your non-fighter units. Your opponent must destroy one of his non-fighter ships.

Oh, great. So, I was going to move from my breaches here and over there in there to so I would have had a destroyer, carrier, and flagship to make you just lose your flagship and then I'd be able to take the planet,

right?

Um, and that's just one out of hundreds of examples of what literally one card can do

to affect the game.

Uh, Zach, what is your favorite thing about this game? Probably my favorite is it doesn't do any one thing perfect, but everything combined makes it probably one of the best games out there. Negotiation, it's perfect, but it's fantastic. Combat's not perfect, but it's pretty good.

That's true. Combat is literally just dice,

but it's not like there's a there's not a ton of ways to modify it, but there's still a little bit.

Um, it's not super predictive. Like you can come in where statistically you should win and you don't. It's like old accidents and allies. Sometimes you just roll dice and you just lose on fights you shouldn't lose.

Um not super often but it does happen.

Um again the voting agenda phase. It's not perfect but it's pretty good.

Yeah cuz you wanted you wanted the votes to be like gamebreaking.

Yeah I wanted to be more gamebreaking. Um because they leave it open. I do subscribe to like how the space can peace turtles community works. Um, and so they do it fairly structured and it helps speed up the game, but I've played with tables where it's there's no structure,

right?

Um, and so it can be pretty wild and it can take your votes from being like a 30 minute event to like two hours.

Jesus.

Um, so it's those type of things. So, and again, Dane and everybody made it open-ended enough that you get to choose how you want to do that while still fulfilling the rule set.

Yeah.

Um, and so again, I like the rules that they are a little gray at times.

Yeah. And what's God, it's just so fascinating. Like there's so much to talk about with this game that it's very difficult. I think that's probably why I've never done a review for it because it's like where do where do I even play?

We just Yeah, we just took six hours to play the game. How do we succinct that so it's not a 2hour uh review? Um was there anything in this game that you guys didn't like? Like any negatives that you would be like, "Well, I don't really like this about the game." Um I'll leave this one open-ended. Uh so if anyone has anything that's negative that they personally didn't like about the game, if not then,

um h the turn order was a little wonky as a first- time player. um you definitely had to keep us on track quite a bit. Um and then I felt like I missed several uh opportunities for the secondary actions the way we're kind of jumping around. So it kind of threw me off uh in that aspect. I mean I get it. It's part of the core construction of the game. Just something you you get around. But my my least favorite part would be its odd initiative.

Yeah. No, actually I guess that's a good point. The fact that three of the six players are new. There's might be things that you you personally struggled with or didn't like as a first-time player versus what you would probably have hundreds of hours of experience me being middle of the road. Um,

no, that's actually a good point because I even for me there was some windows that I was like, "Fuck."

Yeah,

I could have done that. And you don't want to because it takes so long. You don't want to be like, "All right, everyone, hold on. This was an hour ago. Let me do it." It's like we're No, no, you missed that.

Yeah. Uh, was there anything else that you guys didn't don't particularly like?

The only thing I think and this is any game and and it's built into this game, so it's not the game's fault per se, but I hate I don't like like how it can be over like

oh where it's like finish or something like that.

I love that about this game.

I know, but it's like

um

I'm a Euro player mostly, so I like to have

You like you like Formage and Formage is a Nope, game's over. So, they did fix that.

Everybody gets to finish. Well, no, that one doesn't.

But, I mean, that's it's not a six-hour game either. It's a 40 It's a 40-minute game.

True.

So, they did put um options um game variants in this game. So, one of them is and they I try to remember it's like friendly something. You start the game with all the objectives revealed. So, all of them. You can score as many as you'd like. And when you hit 10, it doesn't immediately end the game. You continue through till everyone's passed and then whoever has the highest score at that point wins the game.

Interesting.

I would like that score.

It'd be an interesting It's a different mechanic and there's lots of different varieties. I haven't really played any of those yet.

I almost feel like man that would be it's like because I don't think and you can correct me for I don't think the twos are that drastically difficult versus the ones that if they were all revealed it's just like why would anyone ever go for one? twice as hard cuz they're like so the influence one that's out there um the onep pointer is half the value. It's literally all of them are just double the

Oh, really? Yes. Um, my biggest complaint and I had found a solution, but I have never seen almost anyone else figure out what I call a really good solution is is a table hog and it is a card hog because like so all especially see with new players, they put every card individually out where like I have just a stack of planets and they're just for

but then like tech gets the problem because you need to see which techs you have versus ones you don't.

Um, the complaint I was going to have out of [clears throat] everything they could have done, a dedicated cardboard card would have been a tech tree so you can pay attention to dependencies and like understand all up front instead of me shuffling through. That's because you didn't play TI 3 where they had a legitimate

like your civilization. If you've ever played that go and it was Yeah, it was specifically Oh, to get assault cannon, you need this specific tech before that one

or you needed like three other techs down a different pack to get to it.

It was your more traditional in four. The biggest improvement in my opinion is the fact that it just became color coded. You just need three reds. Doesn't matter which reds, right? But now

I would have been okay with that. I wish it would have been nice just to have the tech like little cutout. Just understand there's greens.

There's player aids for that out there.

I was going to say I'm like I bet you there's something where it's like that where you just mark it

and it's like it like I mean it might be a massive page but it's like where you could just check mark that you've unlocked it so that you can just look at the sheet instead of have a million cards out,

right? That would probably be that would alleviate a lot of that because what sucks is I spent like filament to print all this stuff to try and organize it and it it didn't it didn't matter like I mean yeah like this is nice you know having all your units in one one box instead of in different piles

but you had defined system for the cards actually out there

might be one of those where you have that specific game table that has the card holders. Well, have you but have you seen the guy who made like a $2,000 table for TI that has RFD codes and everything?

Go look up on YouTube. It's stupid.

And that's the thing is this game like there's so many campaign games that like Devon Devon owns one, I own one that's like your camp your lifestyle game. Yeah.

This is not a

you have one. Yeah. Shadows of Brimstone. Um but they're all campaigns. They're commitments of like progressing the game. This is a lifestyle game that has none of that. Once we're done, we played it and it's like, man, that was a fantastic epic experience. Pack it up. Like I don't have to be like, "Guys, when are you free next to continue our When are they making Twilight Pure Legacy?"

They did a role playing game for it. So,

did they really? Yep.

They also made the rolling, right? That wasn't awesome.

It wasn't great.

It was Yeah, it wasn't It wasn't awesome. Um, my my only negative, which I think Zach kind of mentioned, is the combat. It is literally just rolling d10s. Yeah.

Um

I prefer that versus the way Voidfall did it where it's deterministic where I can just sit here and be like

there's nothing you can do. I am going to win this combat. That's deterministic combat. I think that's atrocious.

But like I like Eclipse's combat a little bit better where you have ships with bigger and heavier guns that truly do more damage per hit that they do or and they have ways to modify dice with it.

Um

yeah, the only way you modify dice, I think, is action cards

pretty much. I mean, some people have abilities. My thing is like especially ground combat, you'll get to the point where like there'll be two infantry and they'll just keep rolling back and forth because they have to hit a nine and Oh, we have and no one will hit for like

10 rolls.

Yeah. Miss, miss, miss.

Which when you start playing this online, they just automate that

really? Yeah, cuz it it does come down to that where you just had one carrier with two mechs on it and I had high value ships. So, it's like, all right, I need an eight or a nine, six, five, four. Can you just leave? Just retreat, please.

Like at one time someone had one fighter and they brought in a large fleet and you guys rolled them like just take the piece off like it's dead.

Oh. Oh. Oh yeah. With the one fighter. Yeah.

Roll the fighter once to see if it does any damage and then kill it.

Yeah. Or the fact that this game is such a tablehog and yet that and you want the tiles to be bigger or you want ways to not

muddy up a section. Like when he brought in 20 units, it's just like, dude, don't even worry about I'm I'm retreating. I I have strategic retreat. Just just I'm going to move out. Don't even take it because it's like, well, I have to take them off. I have to

It's like I guess you have to in case someone sabotages my retreat.

Um, did you guys have any negatives? I know you said the the space, right, for the

Yeah, it's just a way for cuz I'm since I'm so new, I didn't know what all the tech did and I had to shuffle through so many times to just

understand what tree I want to go down.

Yeah. Kyle,

you don't have any negatives? Damn. He's like, "Man, this game is [ __ ] awesome. I'm gonna go buy it."

Well, the game is awesome.

The game is amazing.

I mean, some of the [ __ ] are literally just like, "Well, how do I make it so I don't spread out so much on this awesome game?"

Right. Yeah. There's I don't think there's ever been an instance of this game where I'm like, "This is awful." Like, out of this game would be a 10, now it's a nine because of this. You know, I don't really have any glaring. I don't even mind the combat that much. I just wish it was a little bit more had some on it versus just oh details. But then again, for a game like this that's already long, it might actually be one thing where it's like you don't know what you're asking for.

You want heavy like more in-depth combat now. It's an extra two hours,

right? No, I like that it is what it is. There are probably better combat systems out there, but then that would take away from Okay, then how do I politic better? Because

yep, you're threatening me, but I see that it's like I still have a chance. You could roll bad.

That's true.

And I can still win.

Yeah.

Where if you have it more predictive, then it starts becoming, okay, this is way more negotiation versus risk.

Yeah.

And I played this game where we've never had a single combat. And I played where it was, oh, we're just playing risk. Like, yeah,

it's just advanced risk. Well, what' you say? Your last game you played, everyone had wars out.

We had six people, four people had wars out,

right?

Yeah.

And I I remember my comment to you on that was like, "Oh, so everyone has wars, therefore nobody has wars."

Yeah.

It's like everyone in the world has nukes, but no one's really using them. Uh cuz these wars are easily the most

using them.

Oh, sure.

I did think when Devin slided me on that strategic, I'm like, I'm going to pop my war and just sweep through his spaces. [ __ ] him. [ __ ] him at this point. I'm not winning.

like he's helped me out this entire game. He's used one card to [ __ ] me.

I was I was kind of hoping Brad was going to take it from you then. That would have been that would have been gold.

Yeah, I was a little surprised he didn't go for it.

Well, I mean I it it is always interesting for stuff like cuz it's like could he have won? I because you didn't have the way to shut down my space cannons anymore. Still based off die rolls,

right?

But I had my war son at that point so I could have thrown it in.

His flagship is pretty solid.

His flagship.

His well his flagship. No.

Oh, your yours was he didn't take it from me.

Yeah.

Oh, yeah.

Yeah. Brad couldn't have got it [clears throat] from you. I don't think Brad could have gone from me in what he was bring.

If he got through the space, but I don't think he could.

Yeah. If he survived the space combat, then yes, it

you have better stuff in space.

Yeah. My freaking my second secret objective was attack the person with the most victory points and we were allied. So, I'm like, okay. So, I come out with nothing. Great.

That's Well, I mean, to be fair, you could have done that. You It becomes a wash on

people with support for the throne still that were out there. lost the score with someone else.

So you would have lost the point then you would have gained the point. So you stay even on points but then you no longer have that threat of losing the point two points to win the game.

Imperial,

right? Yeah.

Which is the bigger deal.

Well, that was okay. But that all went down before I had that card. The Brad situation, the Imperial blockage.

Yeah.

Oh, gotcha.

Yeah. This ends up becoming one of those games where you look back on it and you're just like, there was the there's the mistake. And because I've played a lot of these kinds of games where if I lose, I'm like, I don't know what I could have done better.

No, there's almost always the like if you lose, it's because I turned the key one turn too early. Yeah.

Or one turn too late.

Yeah, I took Oh, man. I missed this. And that that could be frustrating for some people, especially new players who are like, "Oh, I didn't even know that was a thing." But

you got me with the relic cuz I only brought one mech cuz I'm like, "What's the worst that'll be happen?" Until you're like, "Bab fracture. That's what's going to happen." And I'm like, "Oh man, that whole fight's toast now."

Which one?

Cuz over here I brought only my one mech. My goal was to take the ground with the mech.

Yeah. My breaches

and you were just like, "No, he won't survive the conquest." I was like, "Oh no,

those out of my biggest surprise with this game was that those breaches were cuz I thought they were just going to be used for movement for me teleporting across and they just I never did it. They just ended up becoming like actually you guys don't have abilities anymore." Oh, it's cuz my flagship was out.

And realistically, your flagship stayed alive a lot longer because I had two people pressuring me right next to me Rex. I'm like, I want to kill the stupid flag. Let me kill the flagship so I can stop this problem.

All I did was literally camp on Mech Rex with that with that active breach. And I'm like, all right. And that's why I kept clarifying, hey, is this the end of a combat? Because now I can pop my breach in there. And nope, you can't bombard. You don't have sustained damage anymore. You don't have the planetary shield, which doesn't matter because bombardment's gone. It It was great.

Y

um so Zach can take it from here because we can move probably move on to the expansions so to get every gauge everyone's thoughts on that. So Prophecy of Kings, not counting factions cuz none of us play the Prophecy of Kings factions,

right? So things that came in were agents, the exploration is all that was the big one from Prophecy of Kings mechs which really changed ground combat from being the most sluggish thing ever. Uh that's Prophecy of Kings fixed a lot of problems that uh base game had of being kind of slow. Um big things in this one was the breakthroughs and synergy with Thund's Edge. um and just introducing a ton of legendary planets. So, there were four legendary planets in Prophecy of Kings and now I want to say there's like 12 to 15 something like that.

Um

Kyle has them all.

And they are pretty cool. Like they all do something pretty

and they're not an action to use.

They're not action to do. Um

Thunder's Edge is pretty cool with its ability. Um I did do the one thing I was trying to which was time it so I got to place Thunder's Edge down. You're going

to be so mad. cuz I was sitting there and I was looking. I'm like, "Oh, I have two and everyone only has one." I'm like, "I should be able to place it,

right?"

And then I was like, "A!"

But here's the thing. Even if you got the infantry, I still got to place it at the last person. You just get the two troops. I would have still placed it somewhere.

So, even if you only had one, the last person, yes, you claim it,

but I would have taken it as soon as that happened because I would have placed it exactly where I

So, with Prophecy of Kings, uh, we can start with the agent. So, these on the side with the agent, commander, heroes, and then your mechs. Um, what's everyone think about

what what did everyone think about those?

There was a wide variety of power

fluctuations cuz mine was not very mine was not a very good

ability at all.

Your agent?

Yeah,

they used them to help balance base game factions. So factions who have really weak starts got really good agents and then factions who have pretty good starts

basically didn't get very much.

Gotcha. So the foundation of soul are they actually are they like a mid-tier faction? Are they

so they win uh I mean I want to say they win on a higher rate than like the higher the 50%.

That's interesting

because they again they're good at infantry and ground and taking planets so

and they get lots of and their economy is good. So, it just really you just needed to be hyper aggressive.

You needed to be a little more aggressive. Brent needed to be a little bit more aggressive. Um,

I tried and then you guys talked me out of it.

Well, that was the thing. You just don't let people talk you out of it. Just go do it.

I know this game is not friendly to I mean I guess it can be like where it's not like a game like Kat where it's all combat. It's like if you don't want to fight, you don't really have to.

No, I mean I didn't fight very often on anybody. I didn't need to.

That's true. I didn't see a reason to buy very often.

Your only threat was when I was going to move in and you're like, "Yeah, you won't stay there."

Yeah, because like you could go in, but then like but I have enough dreadnots right there. Like it's just not going to matter at the end of the day.

Yeah, this game has a lot of that. Uh like almost bluffing. Maybe not even bluffing, but just like it could be empty threats of like

there can be empty threats, but to me it's harder to do some empty threats cuz you can see well like yes, I could take that but then like I could come back and take that that wasn't a problem but then I would be weaker and so someone else's forces could just go walk in.

So it's like it's stalemate at that point,

right?

Um

or like this building the war sun and just not actually popping it out but just keeping it there cuz this was at the start of combat. I could purge that to put any when I produce I can put them on that card

and at the start of combat I can purge that card to put all those units there so they just kind of show on a war.

So that's why I put it there and like there was a point where I didn't think I was going to be able to um end the game. I was like I could just have two war two boobs on the side as like a just a big it doesn't matter where if you're going to fight me I'm just going to pop these in here. And someone could have been like, "Okay, bet. Now your war sons are out. Like now they're now you have to move them normal. Um, so I don't have this teleport ability anymore."

Mhm.

Um, what do you guys think? Kyle, you're quiet, which is normal.

What do you think of the agents and uh and these guys?

Yeah. I mean, I didn't get to use my hero, but

What was your hero?

My agent just got to do everyone else's abilities, so it was pretty good. I think you could use

Oh, did it let you do everyone else's abilities? I only use mine.

I I mainly use yours cuz like like a lot of them were combat based. Yours was just like the most useful to me.

Uh no, I mean that's what's great about it. It's just like hm which one is best for this situation. And yeah, my agent ended up being awesome. I never used mine really for myself.

Yeah.

What was your hero? Each other player shows you one action card from their hand and their balls. For each player, you may take that card.

So, I can like load up on action cards or make you all discard your action cards.

Oh god, they're so It's so interesting because the action cards give you so much variety, but yet they're kind of one note. It's like, hey, I do stuff with action cards. That's it.

You can like build the build it up to like do something massive during one round. Um, but it take like maybe if I had a chance to do the next round, I would have been able to do

or again when it ties into the negotiation uh or just the empty threats,

you have you have 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 nine. You have 10 action cards and it's like every time I was doing something, I was like terrified that you were going to cancel it.

And I I never got one that allowed me to cancel.

Thank god. I think I got the only sabotage in the game. Well, because they added so many more. So, base game with a sorrow especially, you went through the deck the entire time and then you had to reshuffle. Well, Dane did not like that. So, Prophies of King, he put enough in that there was no statistical way for you to get through the entire deck. So, there's only now four sabotages.

Oh, okay. Yeah. This is how many action cards we had left.

Yeah. So, there's only four sabotages now in the entire thing where before you kind of had planned that by end game all four were out there somewhere. You just had to know it existed.

It's like playing against a a blue mana person in commander where it's like great. I guess you're just going to play.

Yeah. You just know there's four cancel.

You know there's four of them.

Um what do you guys think? Did you guys like the agents and all that?

Well, I mean we have reference for without them, but they uh they added quite a bit. Uh let's see here. What did I have? Um, I got the additional galvanizing effects, the immune to sabotage, which was uh useless to me down the line because uh you sabotaged me before that came out,

right?

Uh

but then again, you never have to worry about it for the rest of the game, right?

Mhm. No, I mean, no, they're a great additional and like you said, uh it was a balancing measure.

Yeah.

So, no, I uh I enjoyed them. Uh mechs are badass. I like that each of our our mechs were slightly different.

Yep. Just a slightly different.

Was everyone Are the combats the same on them? Are they all two sixes?

Uh, some have slightly different combat, but most the vast majority are all the same.

Yeah, mine was a deploy effect where it's like during the commit ground forces, I could just put one out.

Okay,

which I forgot to do on me Rex.

Yeah, mine blows up and then it buffs the rest of the infantry in the area with galvaniz.

All your infantry.

Three of them.

Three of them. God. which is again, so you were actually a good counter to him with

Yeah, we were both powerful ground uh fighters. We should have been next to each other. Warning.

And to be fair, this game ended up being like if if we play again, try and make this an annual thing. The website he he handed me, I could have just given you guys the link and there was a draft. So, I could have done it to where it was randomized factions, not the way I did it, but they would have all been there.

You could have drafted for your slice, so your section of the map. You could have drafted four um factions,

faction, speaker, and slice.

And speaker. Yeah.

A snake order. So,

yeah. So, it could have been like Chris starts and then he gets first pick, then it goes around as Zach, then Zach gets two picks, and it goes around until everyone has picked because of just everyone's first game. I just kind of pseudo chose for everyone except the factions cuz we did it a different way. But you have a lot more control over. So, I probably would not have picked the one that has a [ __ ] war or a supernova right in front of my face. Um, because it doesn't help me from a deterrent. No one can take my base anyway,

right?

Um, so that's just something that gets again better with experience.

I had I had an action card for that massive deal in the middle that was going to let every everything that does combat in there gets plus one to their dice roll.

Oh, for yours? For your stuff.

And what do your industry hit on?

Six. six or higher. So you have 5050

and if they die they get to repop

at home

back if they if I roll

kill me zombify

another another swarm of infantry.

Uh Chris, what do you think?

I think mine

you use yours I think the most.

Yeah, my faction is clearly built around mine. So I don't think I would have functioned well if I couldn't get coexistence cuz otherwise I would have to do suicide tactics to get people in. So

yeah, a lot of your stuff unfortunately helped people where you couldn't you had no negotiating power. It's like I'm going to use that.

Yeah, I don't entirely have choices with some of my stuff. My my most important threat is I'm going to delete this technology and I think I'm just not skilled enough to know which one would have changed the tide.

Now was that a was that a tech that was in the deck?

My choice.

Your choice. So the the ability is this action purge this card and a non-unit upgrade technology you own or from your deck and then purge all cards with the same name owned by other players and in other players decks. right down.

You get another one back because it's then each player that purged a technology that owned researches another technology, but it still shuts it down

if something.

So things like getting rid of Lightwave is pretty good cuz that's how a lot of people will end um

home systems is through Lightwave.

Yeah, there was a way and he actually the the cardboard crusade. I can't remember his name. I've immediately blanked on that YouTuber. Um, but one thing that he mentioned about their strategy is to try and get the light wave as quickly as possible cuz otherwise people can camp here and then therefore I can't like teleport

from my spot cuz my only connection to the main board from my home system is here.

We could have just [ __ ] on.

You could have blockaded it. Um,

oh man.

Right off rip until I get enough tech to go past you guys.

Um, but luckily that didn't happen. Um, and I had enough riffs out that I it wasn't going to work. Uh, but knowing that it could it could have stalled for a for a decent amount of time. Um, yeah. No, I agree. I think the agents are amazing. Um, my dog's freaking out right now. Uh, they're so diverse. I mean, the fact that every faction already had a unique ability and then there were all those just made them even more like asymmetric. And I like the fact that like you start with your agent, so you already start a little bit different.

Unlock your commander later on and then your hero is a one time use

and they're always big

and they're always massive like when am I going to pop this? Which is just fantastic.

Yep.

Uh Zach, I'm assuming you love the agents. Yeah, I think the agents overall balance it. Um, they give you more choices and they again your agent you can sell because it is to any player. Um, the commander you can kind of sell to one person by selling your alliance.

Um, and they are passive ability. So, I do like the fact that it is one time per round passive and then a one per game ability. It's the same for everybody. It's the same format. Uh that's pretty solid. Um so that's always enjoyable.

Yeah.

Uh last thing for Prophecy of Kings was the exploration.

Yep.

Uh which were those decks and like the the different like the green the frontier tokens, the green or the red.

Um

what do you guys think of that?

And relics.

And relics. Yeah.

So it added relics. It added those exploration markers completely.

Yeah.

And the decks. So, so all the all the decks that we use for exploration, every time you took a plant, all your um anything that basically got handed when you took a planet that first time was new for Prophecies of King.

Oh, okay.

It made it actually 4X. Before it was not technically 4X cuz there was no exploration. The map was fully built.

That's true.

Um that was a complaint, but Prophecy of Kings made it truly 4X. M

yeah, both of the expansions are basically I I'd say a mustave to the game.

I would say definitely Prophecy of King. You could be playing a really happy game of Twilight Imperium with just Prophecy of King. Thunders just ratches up again.

That's true. Um what everyone think of the exploration. Devin, you don't think you did any of it?

I did a little bit. I did a SCO. I did a few of those. I liked it, you know, when I was just claiming planets un unopposed. That was a good time. Yeah.

Um, let's see here. I mean, I guess a little something to incentivize you

uh to move early game uh being the first to claim. You get a little bit maybe an infantry or extra resource of some kind. Yeah, just a little booster.

Yeah, it's mainly I feel like you get those fragments

so you can get relics.

Um, which did everyone here get relics except you guys didn't get relics? We got all the weaker effects on our exploration where it was like gain a commodity or if you happen to have this you can do this.

If you have commodities do this I don't have any. Well then you got nothing.

So again that's where experience will be. So like I know for fact like when you're taking red plants use mechs to do it because then you don't have to sell infantry.

Greens are going to give you commodities or if you have commodities they're going to trigger other abilities.

Okay. Um, and blues are blue.

Thank you.

Yeah. And the blue deck's fine, but has the most um fragments, so you have the best chance of getting relics from the blue background.

Do you think relics enhance the game or make it unbalanced? Cuz I feel like

they all make it unbalanced cuz you get ones that are eh.

Okay.

And then there are some really good ones, but they now have enough of them. Again, it was one of those things where you didn't have enough and now there's plenty of random that people who are getting relics aren't just winning the game because of it.

I gotcha. Yeah, cuz the one that I ended up getting, I got literally I I the first three things that I explored was a uncolored relic and then I got two red plants. I was like relic fragment, relic fragment. And then it's like cool.

And you got a really good

and I got a really good relic that was

and like I got a good one that gives you plus or minus to it. One die roll per round. Well, okay. That's not bad, but it's not like

it's not. Yeah, it's not.

It's something you have to think about.

That stopped me from using those gravity warps several times,

right? And then my

I'm like, I could use that, but

Oh, yes. I rolled a four actually three.

There goes my flagship.

Yeah, Chris knows about that.

I saved his flagship with it.

Yeah. Did you?

Yeah. And then I went right in and killed it. And he's like, "Yeah, he used it to extort me." And he's like, "Good. That worked exactly the plan." But now,

my ships were on the board and you could clearly see what I could do.

Right. Again, this is one of those things where almost everything in this game is can be tweaked in a way as a negotiation.

Yes.

Like I mean, I think Zach had a good point of like he he had a way of shutting down my relic completely where I had no chance of and he's like, "Hey, I can uh" he was talking to Brad or something. Hey, I can turn them off. Or Z, you could pay to have me not turn them off. And it's like, hm, I guess I can,

right?

Um, Brad and Kyle exploration, you guys did a decent amount.

I feel like

it's fine having the card deal. I like the I like the

Yeah, relics.

The relics edition and stuff cuz this one with his ability also

cuz this was I whenever I do a technology, I can exhaust this card to get rid of one prerequisite. Oh yeah, with him I could cut two off.

Yeah, which is insane.

It's pretty good

because it's like basically at that point you're gonna get every relic for free or every uh technology almost for free.

Yeah.

Um Kyle, you did actually a lot of it.

Yeah, I did. Uh I guess the one thing I would complain about is I have nine planets.

Mhm.

None of them have technology. Oh, the the technology ability or the

I just feel like technology abilities are a little too rare. Maybe a little bit.

Well, to be fair, there are a ton of planet to tiles in the box.

We just happen to get ones that didn't have tech.

We didn't even play with half the tiles.

Okay.

And in the new stuff, so Thunder Ed SE helped with that. There are now plans with double text skips.

Yeah. [snorts] Okay. Like it'll be a red yellow text skip.

Yeah. And I and I in the website I included both expansions obviously because we have some of the new anomalies. Um that's just how it how it happened to come out. Again that would be one of those things where if we were playing again and drafted you could look at the slices and be like oh that has a tech planet on it. So I I wouldn't pick that one.

But to be fair like some of that what you need is so you have an objective for that. You have now 20 objectives and you're only pulling five of them.

So the chance that you're going to get that it's unlikely. But you had two legendary plants, which is kind of an three legendary planets.

Three legendary planets.

No clinics with technology,

right?

Yeah. And these were all great. Uh and they were all enough like Well, Hope's End was basically yours. We could have fought for M ML Par. Uh you can may exhaust this card at the end of your turn to ready another component that isn't a strategy card.

That would have been good, too.

Yeah. Uh all right. So, Thunder's Edge, the newest expansion, one that I was surprised. I think almost everyone might have been surprised besides I guess anyone who's really in the community. I just expect Fantasy Flight to if it's not Arkham Horror or Marvel Champions, they're not making anything. So, whenever they announced an expansion to TI, I was like, "No way." Now, how much is it? This was like How much was this expansion?

Like 120 something like that. It's expensive.

It's very [ __ ] expensive. And whenever I got it, I was like, do I even want to keep this expansion? Can I just return it to get $120 back? But I'm like, [ __ ] it. Let's let me see if I can organize a game to to play it. So, you said this one came obviously with Well, we actually played with four of the new factions.

Yeah. So, because it came with all the codec stuff, it came with six factions and then a fair amount of stuff. Um, the bigger thing is it came with two different game modes. So, there's a Frankenste game mode in it. Um, and then it gave options for different game rule plays. So,

Oh, yeah. There's a like the the event deck.

Yes.

The Galactic Events. Have you played with those?

Uh, I played one game with those and they are pretty wild. Okay.

Um,

there's a deck of uh Well, you can explain what they do.

Yeah. So, like, so we'll go through a couple. It's like, you know, if you're a Euro player, you can play with all of the objectives open. It completes an entire round and whoever has the highest score wins. It's not just first 10. That's pretty cool. There's one that you everyone starts with fighter two. Um, your fighters can have one capacity now for everyone, but all your non-fighter ships when they die, they are purged from the game. So, they are gone. You have five of them. Like, you have five dreadnots. You have two warons. They die, they're gone.

And you can throw as many of those in the game as you want, right? They suggest one, but I've seen people because they had announced them like when they were coming out during the teasers, they threw a couple out and people had put multiple together. There's ones that uh you can trade tech. You just straight up trade tech with people.

Um so it's a negotiation tool. There's total war. It's like every five uh so every time you kill a ship, you get that many trade goods on the card. And when you have like I think it's five or 10 of those trade goods, you can count them as point. Um, but they but they stay in your home system. So if somebody comes and takes your home system from them, they get all of those as well and can spend them for points and they're not trade goods. They're just markers for points.

Gotcha.

Um, and so you can have six point swings with nothing and just end games.

Um, and so again, depending on how your table plays, what you want to play, and there's 22 of them. The one I really want to play, there's two uh hazardous worlds. So, red worlds have uh automatic enemies depending on their value and you have to go kill them because they are hazardous worlds.

Gotcha.

Um there's minor factions. So, all the equal distance planets have a faction from the game that play on the board. When you take those worlds, you get their alliances. So, you might just get randomly cool alliance cards.

Um so, again, there's lots of different ways to play that game. This expansion to me feels a little bit like the last Cosmic Encounter expansion a little bit

where it's just kind of like because the last Cosmic Encounter expansion basically came with like 20 new aliens plus a little bit of something for every single expan like variant that they threw in from all the seven other expansions. This feels a little bit like that kind of concept where it's like here's a little bit of new stuff. Here's more action cards. Here's more agendas. Here's more relics. Here's more factions.

It fixed a lot of things that Dne did not like. So, for the fact that you couldn't get endgame tech easily. So, like I already we ended this game in four rounds and I have two level three techs already.

Yeah.

And I didn't get a lot of tech. Like I have one, two, three, four, five, six, seven tech in total total.

Yeah, I have

five. Not counting my free one I got from the whatever nebula or whatever it's called.

But that was one of the things that changed is let's get more tech out. Let's get bigger tech out so people are playing bigger games um more epic games and more chaotic games.

Um so from your guys's perspective uh with the I guess the only people who messed with the fracture was Chris and Zach,

right?

Um but the concept of the fracture that pops up rand I guess you have what depending on the number of players six chances for the fracture to show up.

Yeah, pretty much. Um, with that being something that also can increase your chances of getting relics, what do you what do you guys think of that being an add-on from the expansion?

I feel like we didn't play with it enough is the problem. It came in and we kind of ignored it cuz we were so caught up with the middle when that could have been the game changer.

Yeah.

So, I think that's

I know. Kept trying to get there.

Well, yeah. They all appeared on a random side. Literally all on one side. you had to have an action card to even have a chance to go there.

Um I'm kind of mixed on the fracture. Like the neutral units are just kind of there and then obviously you're going there to get a relic which is still really cool but there's no real reason after that cuz it's not like oh cool if I take that planet from you I also get a relic. It's kind of like all right this is almost here. Attaching the relic to the planet, making it one and the same would probably be a good workaround there where instead of keeping the relic, if you take the planet, you get to take the relic that relic that they got for it. That's not a bad idea.

Well, except there's too many relics that are just like one time use like Stella converter is one time use and there like dominance orb that [snorts] you spend them and they're gone.

Um, and the troops are fairly like you have to bring a fair amount to take any of those plants. Well, um, and like you don't like you looked at these and I would agree these plant two were less valuable, but it's two relics versus like that's three bucks. That's pretty much just the best type of non-leendary planet out there to get. And then sticks is four. She almost just goes Thunder Edge. It's legendary, so you get a point from it and you got a relic from it.

Um, we just

Oh, Stixs gave you a point. Stix's legendary ability is a point.

Damn it. I Yeah, we read that at the beginning.

And so that's where like again I think once you start playing it more, these become like people will focus on these way more heavily than just what's in the middle, but the middle felt bigger because it's Rex,

right?

Um yeah, and I was going to go for that's why I was bypassing through Chris cuz I was going to head there. Um because the assault cannon just says your opponent. So, I was going to be able to go there, pop my war there, and have his dreadnot just immediately be removed

from the combat. So, I was going I I completely forgot that sticks gave you a point. I was just going for the relic,

right?

Which again, relics are good

and they're super fun.

Yeah.

Um, what are you guys' thoughts? You guys don't

on the fracture.

On the fracture,

I it never even got close to it. So,

it was just so far away. I mean, I I could see where it'd be an interesting add-on, but with it only being on one side of the board, like if you're if you start way over here. Yeah.

Yeah.

So, I [clears throat] mean, yeah, that's true.

Which again were what? Oh, it's based off the person who coughs it based off their breakthrough color. It's Yeah. So, it's your breakthrough and it's three per color of your breakthroughs. Two colors. So, six could go out. But if you again like um we said if you don't have very many tech skips throughout the map then there's going to be limited.

Yeah.

So I could take it or leave it. I mean

yeah honest with you.

Kh.

I mean I I also didn't get to really engage with I didn't even get my breakthrough. So

did you not?

No.

Oh [ __ ] I thought everyone but Devon got his breakthrough

because you took two. And I didn't even need to cuz I took two get type.

I guess yeah, that's that's a talking point on the breakthroughs. Um I love them because again it just ramps tech even more.

But

if you don't immediately go for it, then a lot of times you just don't get it. Got to get the planning.

Yeah. And they're so easy to get to. Like they're not really that it's like, okay, I don't have a secret objective right now. Okay. There are certain ones that are easier and then there's other ones that you just have to make a choice, right?

So like

I don't think anybody took Diplo on turn one. Well,

if someone had taken Diplo but they had the opportunity to do get something else, you could almost always get enough to get five resources or five influence to be your backup plan with that diplo card. But then you're using Diplo to do it. Same with whoever took politics turn one. You're not using those action cards, right? you are choosing I'm going to use this strategy card to get my breakthrough,

right?

Even if those two action cards are fantastic.

Yeah, I think I just it could have just been edge case where I already started with mine as my faction, but then my two secret objectives, one was having like three laws out and another one was something that wasn't going to be obtainable right away. So, I'm like, this isn't worth

Oh, yeah. Yeah. No. Yeah. first people to take leadership, what I see is most just discard their secret because they know they're going to have enough opportunities to get secrets again.

Yeah, that makes sense. But I guess in Devon's case and I guess in yours because you weren't able to hop on the Thunder's Edge immediately, you weren't able to get your your breakthrough.

Yep.

Did you guys find that extremely hindering or did it end up just not really mattering a whole lot? didn't matter to me too much because my breakthrough is more of a negotiating tool.

When you can allow other players to use your stall tactics or scheming faction, when you do, you may resolve a transaction with that player during the action phase. That transaction does not count against the once per player transaction limit for that turn. If you had ways to trade your Huh,

that would have been awesome.

Your your breakthrough, what does it do?

I would have been able to produce ships uh in places I already have command tokens.

Oh my god. Uh yeah, place those ships in a system that contains one of your command tokens, at least one of your ground forces, and no other player ships. So whenever I I produce, I could tap this and just produce somewhere I' I've been.

You've already moved,

which would have been fantastic front lines.

Mine was a production one, too, cuz it mine was when you produce a ship with capacity. You may also produce any combination of ground forces or fighters up to that ship's capacity. They do not count against your production limit. So you guys should have you guys I should have if I had known what your faction did, I should have moved it to where you guys were right next to each other. Have your guys' ground.

Yeah, we've been distracted the whole time fighting each other.

Yeah.

Um next to staff and destroyed

we would have been best of friends the entire time. Um no mine was mine was so tied to my faction though. Like your guys's are a little bit more liquid. mine was basically I can flip an active or inactive breach. Um, which again ended up being super helpful, but it's like if there was a moment like for example where I thought someone was going to use a breach to pop over next to me, it's like I'm just going to deactivate that real quick.

Yeah.

Um, which could be really cool. And yeah, yours was I'm because I'm sitting I I played the Crimson Rebellion. Kyle's in the wrong spot.

He did. He played the loser ass Yasaro tribe with their huge goblin balls from the lore. Uh oh yeah, you could just freely do transactions with people

using your salt tactics. But again, I wish you had ways to you I feel like you should have the ability to trade action cards.

No, it's like Han who's the traders do.

Um

their job is just to gather secrets, not sell secrets.

Yeah. Uh what else came with the thunder's Edge? I mean Thunder's Edge itself, the

uh I mean so just things like the new planets. So a lot new legendary planets, the new tear, so you can eat much easier get faction tech um if you're next to it or in it.

Um the fracture new factions coexisting so you can be actually friends

on on ground combat. That's that was weird cuz last game I played I played Titans and they could put their um their PBS or something

their PBS's all over in coexistence and that's weird. And then we would both get extra action card during the status phase. So like I was drawing five extra action cards per round.

Yeah.

Yeah. It was fantastic.

And that's just like again that's just one faction that like we can play this exact same game. one person pulls a new faction in and it completely changes the dynamic

or we all just play different ones.

Well, that's what I'm saying is like Yeah, that's what makes this game great is that

like what Chris was saying just we have we could play the exact same game and just have completely different outcome.

Yes.

Um without this having to really have that much [ __ ] I mean, there's a lot of stuff, don't get me wrong, but I don't have a million different boxes. We're not sitting here like with Kingdoms 4 going this needs we need some stuff to make this game good. It's like this game already has

everything it needs

to be good.

Um well

yep I'm like I can't think of anything. Uh no one really had any major negatives um and without drawing it out about the nuances of of things. So on a scale of one to 10, what would you guys rate it? Zack

zero

10.

Yeah, I mean it's

Did the expansions What was TI for you before the expansions? Do you Or did you never play TI4 with with

I did. Yeah, I played quite a few games. Um it would probably been nine, maybe a 10.

Okay.

Uh it's hard for me to know because it's always been in my top 10.

Yeah.

Um so it's probably always been a 10 because I think it's always done what it sets out to do well. Mhm. Like if I want to play a politics game, there are better ones, but they don't have war.

There's hegemonity, which is Politics the game,

right?

Which you've played.

This one is just probably the best of them all.

Uh in terms of 4X.

Yeah. Yeah.

And then the expansions just made it better each.

I know. I don't think there was anything the expansions brought that was like uh

or made it worse.

That sucks. Yeah. Or you [ __ ] up the balance. It's like they only balanced it better.

Yeah. It's more chaotic,

which is what I also which is kind of what I want.

Yeah, I like that.

Um Brad, scale of 1 to 10,

I'm going to go with eight.

Eight.

Still really good, but like

I mean, you know, I I I will play this maybe maybe once a year,

right?

And stuff. And not not to say Right. Right. Exactly. And you know, like I I I like Eclipse.

Yeah.

Better.

I've never played Eclipse. So I

cuz it's it's more of a Euroe style. So that's why with you know

this is still great though. I mean

yeah you know

yeah to some directors out there an eight is a good rating. Five [clears throat] is also average. Not the worst game we've ever played.

Um I'm with Zach on this. This is a 10 for me. Um like I said it fluctuates if if I get a chance to play it. Even whenever I haven't played it for years and I talk about TI, I mean, I think Devon had heard us talk about it and and I I've always

I've only heard it whispered in Legend,

right? Where I've always like

a great 9h hour game.

It's one of the more epic experiences you can have in board gaming. Um, especially now that if we, like I said, can make this more frequent with the same group with who now knows how to play, it just gets better from there with people aren't trying to be like figuring out what the [ __ ] is going on, being overwhelmed by like just what one card does or something. It gets even better. Um, we had a few moments where it was like a you [ __ ] like and that just gets amplified where it's like I am going to rain hell on everything you love. Um, and then that person could just come back and be like, you don't have the power,

right?

Uh, yeah. Everything about this game I've always just absolutely love. The expansions made it even better for me. So, it's a 10 for me. It's 10 for me, dog. K.

Solid 6.5. Slightly better than Kingdom.

Just a little. Just barely ees it out.

I I give it a nine.

Nine. Damn.

Yeah.

Yeah. It's It was really fun. Yeah.

I I can't think of many negatives. I do think that maybe I would have had more negatives if we didn't play the expansions, but in its current form, it's uh Yeah, it's a solid game. And what's honestly amazing is you guys were new that most of the time it's like you guys are new, we're just gonna play base game, right?

We're not but you guys were new and then we threw in both expansions and they've somehow added the expansions to feel fluid.

Yeah.

Versus like, hey, if I didn't tell you these were expansions, you would have just thought

you would have separate piece. I assumed it was an expansion.

No, the uh Well, the cards are separate pieces. This wasn't a space game. the Oh. Oh, yeah. I guess they wouldn't because that's where the sheets go. But yeah, but I mean this is that's tied in. So you would have just thought it was just an extra portion.

Um which is very rare, especially for a game like this where it's like,

all right, the teach was two hours. That was base game. Now let me teach you expansion stuff. Um but it could also be fair that the the YouTuber killed it with his how to play video.

No, he was very precise. Well, I think an upside though is the way this expansion looked and I've seen this in like Wingspan. The expansion fixed holes

and that feels good when it's feels natural to the base game and is complimentary to how the game was already played.

Yeah.

And like some of our factions, the Deep Rock could not exist without any of that extra stuff. It was obviously made the second. So, I think complimentary is the perfect word to use for the expansions just because I feel like base game was still like a nine. You're not really going to find holes with it unless you literally lifestyle it. Um, and then you just add more and you're like, man, this is all great. Cuz I've always hated expansions that fix a game

where it's like, hey, this game sucks, but we have made an expansion, make it better, spend 40 bucks, and I don't think I mean, Zach could probably again attest to a little bit more. I don't think you needed the expansions to fix it.

It just enhanced it. Yeah, if unless it was your lifestyle game, base game got fairly predictive.

Yeah.

By 20th game where

20th 26-hour game.

Yeah. Where um either of the expansions make it chaotic enough that it stopped being predictive.

Yeah. Deon, scale of 1 to 10.

Two.

Two. I'll get it. Honestly, yeah. I was doing decent. Thank you. ish, you know,

your support regret our

welcome. Your alliance helped me.

Oh, I will give it. I'm kind of with Brad on it. I'll give it a I'm torn eight. I'll give it a solid eight. Confidently, it's good stuff. We had a good time. Uh the playing all day is I mean I guess in the niche groups it could be a bonus. Yeah.

Um but the I mean I I appreciate this one stop. It was the 6 hours versus the, you know, a 10-hour is what I heard whispered. So,

well, that's because I mean that was a safe bet with three new players. Essentially, four new players.

Why does it take us 10?

Christ.

Right. I mean, to be fair though, uh, we start Kingdom Flororn at 10:00 and [ __ ] end at 10:00 and we only get through half a [ __ ] quest.

That's very true. And that's we're also quitting that game. So,

putting it on pause,

quitting. But that's the thing is like yeah, we were able to play a six-hour game and feel fulfilled.

Yeah, I'll give an eight.

Eight. Chris,

do do you want me to stick with a whole number or is fractions fine? Explain why.

7.23. Uh uh you could do.5s.

I would say eight and a half.

Eight and a half

because Scythe is my nine and I really love Scythe. And I think this would be a nine.

This setup was where it got me. If we did that serpent drafting system, I probably would have put this at a nine because I would have had more control of who I am, where I'm at, and then I would feel like,

but you could give it a nine because that is a possibility. We just didn't do that cuz I was trying to set the game up way ahead of time just so I guess you know that it exists.

So yeah, I'll say it's eight and a half with the potential for the promotion once I play more. Yeah,

cuz that's what it looks like it's going to end up. This is close enough to Scythe with the same mechanics of Scythe I love. So,

I also love Scythe. Um, I think everyone Well, Brad hates Scythe.

I don't care for it.

He doesn't like it.

I know.

Zero War game.

I know. He [ __ ] he he he loves Star Wars Unlimited. It's It's [ __ ] atrocious. Um, but yeah. All right. Well, does anyone have anything else to bring up about TI? Nope. We're all good. All right. Well, that is it, everyone. That's our thoughts on Twilight Imperium fourth edition with the thunder resides expansion and the prophet of kings expansion. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved