Finspan VS Wingspan VS Wyrmspan: What One Is Right For You?!
Transcript
first there was wingspan then worm span and now you're telling me there's a fin span fin span why but also I need it ston Meer games recently decided to break the internet and break everybody's brain by announcing um the third and kind of final installment of wingspan which is worms or not worm span that's this one this is fin span but if you already have one of these games whether it's wingspan or worm span or both do you really need finpan I mean is this one that you need in your collection let's kind of dive into my thoughts on this subject because I have lots of them Hello everybody welcome back to the channel today my name is Carly and today we're going to be kind of taking a look and chatting about the newest title from ston Meer games which is finpan when ston Meer games announced this um a handful of weeks ago I feel like everybody kind of freaked out a little bit so many people kind of commenting and saying that like why did we need this this shouldn't have even been made and then a bunch of people on the other side saying well you're not saying anything about the 500 versions of ticker to ride or all the other all the other games that come out with so many iterations so there's there was kind of like two groups of people right that were arguing kind of back and forth but whether you like it or not fin fan is here um and I was able to Jamie was kind enough to send me over this kind of like early I'm kind of review copy so I could
play the game kind of share my thoughts on it primarily why I kind of wanted to make this video was to kind of compare all of the games so far right wingspan worm span and nil fin span because inherently there are differences between the three games um they all kind of rest on that kind of core mechanism that core mechanic that is found in wingspan where you have a board you're slowly building out whether it's birds or dragons or fish and you are kind of get getting more and more that kind of like engine building mechanism is kind of at the core of all three of these games but there kind of are differences between the three so what one is the right pick for you and for your game group that's kind of at the heart of this video and kind of what we're going to be discussing today so very briefly before we dive into finpan we're actually going to kind of really very briefly kind of talk about wingspan just in case you are not familiar with this game I'm sure I mean those of you who are familiar with wingspan um I'm sure you could probably skip the section of the video wingspan is the first of this Trilogy it was the very first one that was released wingspan kind of like broke the gaming world like everybody I mean even like people who are not Gamers know about this game like that's that's how popular it is but in this game you have this individual player board that opens up and you will actually be playing birds into your Sanctuary here you will have a set number of action cubes each round and it is with those action cubes that you can do various actions on the board whether it is play a bird into one of your rows gaining food laying eggs or drawing bird cards as you place Birds
onto your rows you will slowly Place more and more kind of making these rows longer and longer why that is important is because let's pretend you place this bird here um into your Wetlands what would happen now is next time you chose to draw a bird card you would actually take your little action Cube and place it you place it on the first empty slot activate that and then you work backwards activating any birds that has a if activated tag on them so if you had built this row all the way up to here well next time you go to draw bird cards you will actually get two birds um with the possibility of getting an egg or discarding an egg to get another one and then again slowly working back stopping on all those birds this mechanism of having some sort of animal playing it onto your engine board right building it out kind of getting stronger and stronger as the game goes on that is found in all three of these games in wingspan and worm span and now in finpan something that wingspan offers that the other two don't though is kind of the way that resources are handled through this bird Tower is it called a bird Tower I don't know the game comes with this beautiful little like birdhouse which you will actually have dice drop those dice into it and during the game whatever is showing on the dice well that is the act those are the resources that you can collect or gain throughout the game so for example if it was my turn and I chose to gain food this is the only food that I could gain I could either gain two berries I could gain a wheat I could gain a wheat or a worm or
a rat the resources in this game is are slightly more tricky because it does have a little bit of that luck element to it in regards to the dice that are showing now there are birds that you can play into your engine that inherently generate a rat for you so every sing every single time it's activated you will gain a rat and you know you have that available but in regards to the dice tower it is just pure luck something else that will be generating on your birds um are these a eggs birds lay eggs right and so for every single bird um they will be able to lay or potentially lay a certain number of eggs which can be spent to sometimes fulfill cards needs um but primarily they kind of are worth points at the end of the game the eggs in worm span are actually really similar to kind of how the eggs operate in wingspan in fin span they do have eggs as well but they operate slightly differently so we'll get into that in just a second so that's essentially what wingspan offers is you're bu building out your bird Sanctuary again using your action cubes every single round there will be um a end of round um scoring or end end of yeah end of round scoring and based on where you score you'll actually Place one of your action cubes on this row here which inherently it'll stay there for the rest of the game so going into a future round you will actually be one action short so by the end of the um or going into round four you actually have three less actions as the game goes on this is is also kind of found in worm span but not found in fin span at all which we'll talk about that in a little
bit later that aspect of wingspan is actually different than worm span and fin span this is the only game that H kind of does this um where you're one action short every single round so that kind of end game kind of ramps up a little bit all right so kind of hopefully that gives you a general idea of kind of what wingspan is all about let's go ahead and dive into worm span worm span has that same kind of mechanic of wingspan except there's a little bit more going on this is the map for uh worm span and you can tell it kind of has that same look of the wingspan map you're going to essentially kind of be doing those same things but just in a different way in worms fand you're actually going to be playing Dragons into these three cave systems the opening entrance to the caves are already kind of excavated or dug out so you can just inherently fill a dragon in those slots but every single slot after that one you actually have to excavate it first so that's the first action that you can do is excavate when you excavate you will pay a coin which coins are essentially like the action cubes in wingspan um but you will pay a coin um and then you will be able to actually dig out which basically means place kind of a small little um excavated cave icon on that location all of these cave cards have like instant uses or instant abilities so when you play them you act you actually get the abilities that are under him once that cave system is in place then that's when you can actually entice Your Dragon this is kind of getting hard to hold but every single dragon has a cost so if you're able to pay that cost then that's when you can entice the dragon to now fill that that
empty cave slot filling out your cave systems is super important because if you remember in wingspan when you take your action Cube if you have a really big row filled out then you can basically do more and more with that particular action this acts the same way but in but you actually will be traveling through your caves instead of working backwards and your little traveler when you take this action this is the explore action um what you can use your little traveler and you will go through your cave systems as far as you possibly can until you reach one of these stop icons then that's what triggers you to return your little Explorer back to the base camp here so you have excavate entice which is bringing your dragons into your caves exploring which we just talked about when you do explore either your first second or third time there is a cost an inherent cost that's associated with exploring so it gets more and more expensive the more that you explore so you really want to make make it worth it every time you explore and again kind of similar to the birds these dragons um lots of these dragons have little abilities so when you do go through and activate them they will um generate some sort of resource for you some of them generate endgame points some of them generate like one played um there's lots of different ways that the dragons very similar to the birds and wingspan and similar to The Fish and fin span just generate great things for you in your engine one of the big differences between worms span and the other two games is this Dragon Guild board throughout the game you might trigger this symbol up here on the board um when
that does you will have a little icon that's placed on this board and you will be going in circles around and around and around and every single time you stop somewhere you will generate whatever is shown so this kind of helps generate stuff for you but then you also will have these goals um there's lots of different goals that you C that come with the game and whenever you are um move on to this top or bottom location you can actually put one of your cubes claiming this ability sorry not ability claiming uh endgame points just ways to score more points at the end of the game and just to be clear you still have your um end of round stuff that you're trying to score score points for so just kind of think of this as like an whole other way to get points from this game these are obviously just kind of very general explanations of how these game of how these games play um but I hope that kind of shows the differences between at least wingspan and worm span so far lots of people refer to worm span is like a more gamery version of wingspan which I definitely agree with there is more you have to think about there is more going on even just simply having to excavate an area before your dragon can go in right versus wingspan where you can just you can place a bird if you can pay for it you can place but this adds just kind of It kind of just feels like wingspan but with an an extra level thrown on top of it so if this is the more gamery version of wingspan then what is finpan the way that finpan has been described is it's kind of like a more accessible version an easier kind of more
streamlined version of wingspan so let's dive into it right off the bat when I opened up this box the very first thing I noticed was like in for example in wingspan and in worm span my box is like packed to the brim it's really like it's hard to kind of shove everything in there there's a lot going on this is literally all that's in this game you have your player boards you have this nice little holder um and that's it I mean I have a lot of extra room in here which I was shocked because it's like the complete opposite of the other two so right off the bat there is inherent there is less components than the other game which is nice so I'm going to kind of um pull out the player board some like a little nitpick I I have with this game I have a couple nitpicks so I'm I'll Point those out as I um as I kind of show off stuff um in and really my nitpick just kind of comes down with consistency because this is meant to be like a a trio of games it's meant to be kind of like a series wingspan worm span now finin span so there was there's just stuff that I wish would have been more consistent this is the very first thing I noticed so in wingspan and in worm span the art is actually on the outside of the player boards and then you open it up and you see the pretty kind of what you're actually going to be dealing with it's the opposite in this game so the art is on the back which I wish I don't know I just wish this would have been on the outside of the board and then you open it and then you have your actual board just in terms of consistency because wingspan and worm span are both the opposite so it felt weird a weird move for them to do it
this way but in um in fin span what you're going to be doing is you will again same layout right but this time you're vertical because you're going to be diving into the ocean right off the bat in case you can't already tell you actually begin the game with some fish um already placed in your ocean that is completely different from worm span and wingspan sorry beckam woke up so he's going to be joining us for the rest of this video another thing that's really different about this game um is you will actually start the game with these starter cards in wingspan and also in worms span I believe um it's been a while since I played worms span um but you are randomly dealt cards and also you have some resources oh you okay you're just randomly dealt cards and you have resources and then you can choose at the at the beginning of the game what cards to discard and what cards to hold on to but for every card you hold on to you have to discard one of the start like one one of your starting resources um that's like a really really big important moment of the game right off the bat and this just kind of eliminates that you basically just get a couple starting cards then you grab a couple regular cards and that's your starting hand that's just like what you start the game with you will also grab your little like divers your little divers of your color here I believe you have five is it five of your color one two three four five six it's six of your color these divers are also inherently different than the other two games because in the other two games the amount of actions that you have in every single round can kind of fluctuate or change in this game
you have six divers you will have those six divers throughout the entire game that will never change on your turn there's really two things you can do you can either play a fish card into anywhere on your board you don't have to build out like you have to do in the other ones you can play a fish card anywhere um as long as it matches um the particular Zone that it has to be with or you can choose to dive into one of your um like sections on your board there are three sections there's this blue section purple section and then green section and when you dive you actually will take your little diver and you will dive all the way to the bottom even if it's not built out this is another big difference between the other games cuz in wingspan and worm span you will only go a certain distance before you inev inevitably have to stop and go back but this game right from the beginning you can dive and you will activate all of these little brown spots obviously the more you build out the more brown spots or um activations that you will actually be able to do on that dive action but it is nice at the beginning of the game you can automatically kind of generate more resources than the other games these fish card operate essentially the same way that the other games do some of these have a when played ability some of them have a when activated ability some of them have at game end ability um so there's really nothing inherently different the only thing that you just kind of have to keep in mind is what zone you are able to place your animals
in because there are three zones you have the daylight Zone which is the largest you have the what is it this middle Zone I forgot what it's called like the middle area and then you have there is it Twilight The Twilight Zone and then you have the Midnight Zone which is the bottom of the board in wingspan and in worm span there is like those that egg element right where you're kind of producing or making eggs worm span takes that same kind of idea but actually Alters it and changes it um and honestly I think they change it for the better I like the way that this game does eggs versus the other games now don't get me wrong I love like the wooden or resin eggs that you might have in the other games I think those are amazing and I love them but I just think that they're just more interesting in this game and this is why a big portion of this game is is actually um making eggs okay so you're going to be making eggs and you're going to be putting them on your on your fishes on these three columns of what you can do with your diver is this First Column is all about getting cards the second column is all about um getting eggs and then this third column is about hatching eggs when you are making eggs you will be able to place one egg on every fish every single fish can hold one egg across the board um when you are hatching eggs though that's kind of a really big part of the game which is completely different from wingspan and warm span you will take your eggs that you've produced on the board flip them over to their little young guppy face there are many instances in times throughout the game where you can activate an ability that actually allows you to move these fish
independent from the other fish that you have placed um onto these slots you can move your Guppies up and around and whenever you happen to move three together on the same location they actually turn into a little school of Guppies and why this is important is because at the end of the game every egg is inherently worth one point every guppy is inherently in worth one point but then every group of fish is actually worth six points at the end of the game these are also important because they have to do with your um Mid uh or your round end of round scoring which is the same again as wingspan versus worm span but it doesn't have worm span's kind of like extra level of scoring you have to do um basically you have just your basic um end uh end of round scoring kind of like like in wingspan so you have your ocean board you're slowly kind of building out again you can build anywhere on this board you want to anywhere you want to whenever you dive you go all the way down to the bottom you never lose your workers right so you will always have those six workers throughout the entire game or six actions for every single round you don't have any resources really the only resources that you use to attract fish into your ecosystem is by spending other cards and when you spend those cards it actually does goes to a personal discard pile which many abilities give you or many fish give you the ability to actually reclaim a card from your
personal discard pile so just because you might use it doesn't mean it's gone forever you actually can pull it back as well sometimes some cards do um require an egg okay it'll it'll require an egg or a guppy or some fish like the great white I don't know where the great white is but pretend this is the great white um will actually eat that fish so kind of coming back to finpan kind of claiming it's an easier version of wingspan I don't know if it's necessarily quote unquote easier because honestly wingspan is a pretty easy game it's it's pretty simple it's pretty straightforward but fin span does seem like a more streamlined version of wingspan I think the thinky level is still the same because you're still kind of like thinking ahead a little bit you still are trying to think through those chaining actions right if I place this here then that could mean this which then could trigger this which I love in wingspan this still definitely has that so it still has that level of thinking but it's just more streamlined in the sense that there's not um the kind of fiddlin that you have to worry about you don't have any sort of resource that you're trying to juggle on top of placing your cards that's just completely cut out that's gone again you can place anywhere on your board right you can place anywhere done when you are diving you go all the way to the bottom there's it's just there it takes a lot about the core gameplay of wingspan but just makes it easier to dive into it's like if somebody has never played wingspan before this is the game that I
would introduce this is the game that I would use to introduce them to this system I mean inherently so many people are comparing this to wingspan right and they're saying why if we have wingspan if we have worm span why do we need f span um so let's so let's kind of touch on that because what I just mentioned is for me the reason why I like having fin Span in my collection and why I think this is a good one to have because I personally love wingspan honestly kind of where my thoughts are wingspan is still my favorite most Gamers like I want to be very clear most Gamers do not agree with me most people prefer worms span to wingspan I'm kind of the odd one out where I like the dice tower I like trying to um figure out my turn around the randomized dice or try to make my actions more efficient so I don't even need to worry about the bird feeder I just really like wingspan it's it's been my favorite it's on my top 100 games of all time I love it I really like worm span too I don't think there's anything wrong with it I like how it is kind of more crunchy I just find myself kind of drawn to wingspan more personally um having said that I was really skeptical kind of coming into finpan because I was kind of like is it really going to change that much like wingspan is pretty simple why why would I need a even more simple version of wingspan for me though this does just kind of fit that niche of wanting to introduce somebody especially like a non-gamer to wingspan cuz I know like my mom every single time we sit down to play wingspan she really wants to play it but it takes her like a full game to kind of like remember what to do kind of remember her turns I have to sit and walk her through every single turn
this game is what I would introduce people to like this like this is because it just streamlines so much much so for me I actually am really happy to have this in my collection and I do think that there is a need for this game if you are like a really big heavy gramer who has a dedicated game group uh and you don't really introduce wingspan to new or younger players at all I don't really necessarily know if you need this if the theme doesn't speak to you then maybe this isn't one that would that would kind of help enhance your collection for me personally I play a lot of games with people who would be considered non-gamers or younger G like I think Addie could easily dive into this game and play this much easier than wingspan we have yet to play it with her yet um I'll Circle back around when when we actually do but um I I just think I think the theme is fun I think it is interesting um how you are dealing with the vertical board instead of the horizontal something I will mention is it does kind of make the table space funky because like for example this table if I were to place this on the table like there's not enough space on my current Table for two players to have their boards um directly in front of them so you kind of have to like layer out your boards and it just makes the game I don't know it just looks kind of funky and a little bit different so I don't like that aspect of it but I love like the thematics of like diving into your ocean um and playing out um the cards so kind of rounding out this video here I really liked fpan for me
personally I am really happy to have this one because this is the game that if nobody's if if we have people around the table who've never played wingspan before this is so much easier to teach because in wingspan you do have those minor nope your Cube actually goes to this one and then you work backwards and then you have to do this and oh you have to place your Cube here to then gain an egg here it's it's just way more streamlined it's way more simple this is the one that I would start with and then if they enjoyed it then that's when I would bring out worm span or wingspan and then work your way up to worm span right I like actually how how they did this I like how they took that core mechanism they really did give us a game that's slightly more complicated with worms span and now finpan which is a slightly simpler kind of easier to dive into version of wingspan at the end of the day wingspan is still my favorite like I give I give wingspan a nine out of 10 um I actually I give it higher with the with some of the expansions actually finpan I mean I really like this one too I'm going to be giving um finb an 8.5 out of 10 I really enjoyed this one um and I really do think that if you kind of hit with you kind of are in the same boat as I am as I don't really have a super dedicated game group I just kind of play games as I'm able to right as I see opportunities as we have families over for dinner or um a random friend comes into town that's kind of when I'm able to game and so I'm happy that I can have this to help introduce the wingspan world just kind of a more approachable way to introduce um
wingspan to more players thank you so much for watching this kind of like comparison video slash review I really hope this video kind of gives you the information um you might have been looking for or needed in regards to these three games and which ones would fit for your collection maybe wingspan maybe worms span maybe finpan maybe all of them no matter what one kind of like fits your your game style more um I really do think these are three fantastic games great titles you really can't go wrong with any of them thank you so much for watching this video today if you enjoyed this video and you haven't yet subscribed to the channel it means so much if you could do that really helps support me in everything that we're doing over here but until next time I hope you have a great rest of your day and we'll see you later oh yeah and I totally forgot to mention this but when are we going to come out with like transparent cards for this game I need them so bad you have no idea I need transparent cards so it actually looks like you're putting fish in your ocean without the white border like please please Jamie please I want transparent cards for all of these games I want dragons I want my birds and now my fish I I need them so bad please please