Skip to main content
Loading video...

Viticulture 10 Years On: A retrospective - has it matured like a fine wine?

Transcript 15:03

i received a complimentary review copy of viticulture essential edition from the publisher so thanks to stonemaier games i'm often torn when trying to identify the hook of a game is it the theme the narrative the setting that draws players in or is it the mechanisms at play the design choices the unique engine which drives the game with viticulture i could make a really strong case for either of those things but there's a third hook and that's the game maker themselves more than any other publisher stonemayer games has nurtured a community since its earliest products and published in 2012 viticulture is their earliest product a little bit of stonemaier history for a great many stonemeyer fans that's a hook in and of itself at the time of filming viticulture sits at number 25 on the board game geek top 100. it's a game with some clout if you haven't played it you've probably heard of it an early kickstarter success story co-designed by a then nascent inventor jamie stegmeier honed with expansions community input and revised editions this is a game with a lot of heart history word of mouth famous designer critical acclaim it might not be the only hook but make no mistake it is a hook i'm adam porter i design games and i run this youtube channel where i primarily focus on game design and the board game industry in this series of reviews i'm analyzing games as products and viticulture is a fascinating one because it's 10 years old it's already

proven itself as a strong commercial product and i'm compelled to unpick why in viticulture you play as the owner of a growing vineyard in tuscany each round of the game represents a year with four seasons which work a little bit differently in spring you select your place in the turn order with players later in the sequence gaining immediate rewards victory points money or cards representing vines wine orders or visitors with special abilities in summer you place workers onto various action spaces allowing you to draw or play cards from your hand plant vines in your fields and build structures to increase the efficiency of your yard once an action space has been selected it's blocked so it can't be used by other players but each player has a single grande worker who can break this rule and visit any action location even if occupied you're probably not going to want to use all your workers in summer though because you're going to need to hold on to some of them for the winter actions in autumn you simply draw a visitor card but winter is a repeat of the summer process only using different action spaces in winter you can harvest your fields you can add red and white grapes to your crush pad train additional workers convert grapes into wine and fulfill wine orders on your cards when one player passes 20 points on the tracker that indicates that this will be the final round of the game and when the year's been completed the highest scorer wins every product makes a promise expectations are raised by the art style the name the box size the publisher

designer duration and age range as a game maker you need to deliver on these promises the shifting cover art from the first edition to this essential edition of viticulture illustrates a key point about aesthetics that i frequently made in my videos this is viticulture first edition the strategic game of wine making the title and sub line spells out what we're going to be doing in the game and it's supported by a painting of an idyllic italian landscape it's a fine start an effective box cover tells you what the game involves but the essential addition goes one step further the addition of two attractive smiling figures in the forefront carefree as they lift grapes from a container gives us a little hint of who we represent and most importantly how we're going to feel viticulture is an inviting relaxing game to play much of the game takes place on your own personal board cultivated only by you and your own family of workers untouched by other players the covered world is tough but pre-modern rustic tuscany is pretty zen i think this points to the second hook of the game the setting and narrative of viticulture has broad appeal we all want to live in italy we all drink wine and we all want to be as content as that attractive pear on the cover big generalizations of course i mean i don't drink wine it makes me really ill but i still buy it i gift it to friends and family i offer it to guests and i aspire to a sophisticated lifestyle with

good food stimulating conversation and fine wine flowing in an industry full of popular titles with horrific backdrops grotesque monsters and war and global pandemics viticulture offers up a much more appealing theme aspiration seven years before the mega success of wingspan designer publisher stegmeier had his finger on the pulse of eurogame players the most significant market for tableau building and worker placement games is not action-oriented teenagers or party oriented young adults the market is largely made up of 30 or 40-somethings looking for a quiet thoughtful puzzle to play with their family and friends bird watching and winemaking might not be the most exciting themes but they're just so very wholesome all that aside the product wouldn't have succeeded if it didn't have something special going on with its gameplay the core mechanical hook in any worker placement game is usually pretty tough to pin down try to condense what's unique about architects of the west kingdom into a short pithy phrase it's not so easy even though the game's pretty unique and likewise superficially viticulture is formulaic and familiar but there are enough little twists to make it stand out among the crowd the grande worker who can break the rules to visit an occupied location the rewards for playing late in turn order the wide variety of guests visiting the vineyards with their disparate abilities the changing seasons with limitations on which actions are available at any given time

all of this gives viticulture a unique identity it doesn't have one groundbreaking new mechanism but a number of small twists add up to a distinctive flavor my reviews are becoming less structured i'm starting to break free of my product design analytics but i'm not ready to give up on all of that just yet so let's plug viticulture into my ladder formula each game is awarded zero to three points in five different categories pushing the game further and further up a ladder representing engagement perfect score is irrelevant anything over 10 will reach the top of the ladder and indicate a real classic starting with thematic immersion well viticulture does well here i know exactly who i am and what i'm doing of course there is abstraction as in any euro game but the theme and mechanisms go hand in hand so it scores a three for interaction though it's a one viticulture features accidental blocking when you utilize the location it ceases to be available for other players but even that is eased by the presence of the rule-breaking grande worker the game is largely played solitaire on your own little player board and i'm fine with that for stress and challenge viticulture gets a two there's a lot to do and there's not enough actions to get it all done the setting is placid but the game plays a little bit more intense it's an enjoyable struggle but even on your less productive turns you're probably getting plenty done and you're not going to be punished for not getting things done that you've set out to do

a really engaging game often features frequent and generous feedback rewards bonuses and power-ups to motivate you and lift your spirits as you play feedback is steady in viticulture wine orders bonus actions and other transactions award victory points throughout the game and points are recorded on the track at the base of the board and that's my least favorite feature of the game i don't enjoy race mechanisms like this in strategic games i'll discuss this a little bit more when we look at my customer journey map so viticulture gets two points worker placement games are generally fairly cerebral affairs the strongest strategic player is usually going to do pretty well but viticulture is more tactical than most in the genre it's often a case of playing turn by turn making the most of what's on offer in terms of your visitor cards and the spaces available on the board unblocked rather than pursuing long-term strategies the visitor card powers can be really useful or they can be pretty useless depending on the game state at the time so there's a significant chance element in the game a degree of luck of the draw which is uncharacteristic of the worker placement genre it's not a criticism it's more a feature of the game but i am going to score the game down a little bit for meaningful choices it's still a complex strategy game though so i don't want to hammer this point too hard viticulture scores are two so the overall score is 10 viticulture pushes over the threshold and sits atop the engagement ladder another explanation as to how it's connected with so many fans and why 10

years after publication it's still held in such high regard quickly reviewing my customer journey map we can start to plot pain points in the product areas where my mood drops significantly so the onboarding process is a bit of a hurdle there are a lot of rules to learn especially surrounding the value of grapes and wine the storage and mixing to create blush and sparkling varieties now i was taught the game several years ago and i found i only truly understood all the various interactions after completion of that first game revisiting the game after a very long break i turned to the rulebook and i found it pretty dense it's not badly written it's not badly laid out but the game is simply pretty complex i mean i should say it is comparable to other similar games in the genre and worker placement games do tend to be this way as i frequently do though i turned to rodney smith's watch it played youtube tutorial to learn the rules but even that was compromised by the fact that the tutorial relates to a second edition while i'm playing the essential edition on the positive side those setup and teardown are assisted by the inclusion of some excellent storage trays the game could potentially be really fiddly with all those little pieces so this is a massive help losing the game that's a bit of a low as in most games i suppose but here i feel the loss is harder because of the abrupt end to the game in viticulture the first player to 20 points ends the game and after completion of that round the

highest scorer wins there's no reward for second or third place there's no opportunity to sit and calculate your score at the end to ponder over where you did well and how your opponents ran away with it that delicious tense anticipation of the reveal is absent in viticulture if you're behind you know you're behind everyone else knows you're behind it's there for everyone to see it's not always easy to stay motivated when you know full well that you're out of the running is the game innovative well it's iterative in all the right ways viticulture builds on what's gone before and adds in some micro innovations in the gameplay mechanisms particularly in this revised essential edition much of the innovation on display here though is in the marketing but we're going to come back to that does it answer a need yeah in 2012 and to this day the market is absolutely swamped with high fantasy combative and action-packed settings viticulture was a breath of fresh air with its idyllic vistas and constructive rather than destructive narrative there's a sizable market for this stuff and that market isn't yet stated there's a reason the industry is churning out nature-themed games in 2022. wingspan demonstrated how big that demand is and inventors and publishers were quick to follow viticulture was an earlier example tapping into an underserved community of gamers and giving them what they wanted could the product grow with its user

yeah absolutely there's plenty to explore in this box a large variety of cards will give a different feel to each game but more importantly there are several distinct but balanced strategies to explore even if the cards are identical from game to game the included automa factory solo rules and expansion decks and modules that you can purchase to add to your package and there's a strong support from the community of fans as well as stegmai himself and this all makes it a real dynamic living product branding are there opportunities to develop this brand i think so viticulture is a known entity in the board game world if you're a tabletop gamer and you haven't played viticulture then you've probably heard of it and if you haven't heard of it you've probably heard of stonemare games and if you haven't heard of them well maybe you've heard of jamie stegmeier viticulture is a brand within a brand should jamie wish to and i have no reason to think that he does jamie could certainly explore stand-alone sequels dice games card games and roll them rights carrying the viticulture moniker and logo and they would sell so all that remains is to plot viticulture essential edition onto my idea execution matrix the best-selling products invariably marry a fantastic idea with outstanding execution pushing up into the red and orange parts of the chart viticulture was a very strong idea 10 years ago and it would still be a strong idea if it was released today it's a little bit derivative in its game play there are no groundbreaking mechanisms here so i'm holding off from the top

spot but it's still very impressive the execution of the product has been fascinating to observe viticulture was a big success in the early days of kickstarter stonemeyer made some mistakes and missteps which necessitated a second edition and then this essential edition which incorporates some elements of the original tuscany expansion it's all very confusing but they also pioneered several key components of the kickstarter model which are still ubiquitous today international fulfillment centers backer involvement and brand advocates jamie stegmar's cultivation of a community and his constant focus on the stonemeyer brand have inspired many self-publishers that followed viticulture was the start of all that but setting aside these intangible aspects of execution and focusing purely on the physical product and ease of use viticulture is still a big success it looks great it's accessible and it's engaging it takes its place one step from the top right hand corner of the grid and of course the absolute top right hand corner is occupied by stonemeyer's later game wingspan the million cellar where stegmai pulled together all the lessons he learned from viticulture and really took flight if you enjoyed this review please let me know in the comments hit like subscribe to the channel and i'll see you next time all the best

Progress saved