Queen Alice Game Review
Transcript
Hey y'all, thanks for joining us at Tantrum House, Studio 3. I'm Will Meadows.
I'm Sarah Meadows, and today we're sharing our thoughts on the new game, Queen Alice from Combo Games. And we managed to get a copy of this while we were at Spiel Essen this year, and we've already got it to table several times, and we're excited to share our thoughts.
Yeah, this is a mid-weight plus Euro game for one to four players. It'll take you about two hours depending on your player count. This game assumes that you already know the rules to chess, that you are familiar with deck builders, that you have read and enjoyed the Lewis Carroll looking through through the Looking Glass book. There's a lot of assumptions, which is probably actually why we enjoyed it so much, I think.
Yes, this game was designed by Hector Carreon and David Heras, and it features artwork from Amelia Solis.
Uh we wanted to give you at least a brief overview of the game. There's a lot going on, and we want to give you the gist so that you know what we're talking about. Let's go.
In the game, players will start with a deck of cards that represents the different chess pieces on the board.
They will be building their deck over the course of the game, but on each turn, they will play a card to collect its discard bonus, and then they will play a card to get its reward and to move the corresponding piece on the mini chessboard.
They will move the piece following standard chess rules, and if they manage to capture another piece, they will collect it for additional bonuses.
And then, based on where their piece ends up on the board, they will look at the row and column to decide what resource they will gain and then what action they will take next.
Resources in the game include red cherry cake, white butter toast, and tea. Time is also a resource in the game, and it can be spent as a substitute for other resources.
Back to the chessboard, you'll see there are four standard playing card suits and then the star icon. The star is wild and will allow you to choose where to go, but when you land on any of the other columns, the matching board is where you'll head next.
On the heart board, you'll be taking hearts from your player board and placing them over flowers to collect either ongoing abilities or immediate track bumps.
On the spades track, you'll be moving to Mad Hatter and the White Hare, spending resources to collect ever-improving resources and to build your deck.
On the clubs board, you'll be teaming up with Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum to add books to your reading collection, and then you can exchange those books for bookmarks, which will grant you different kinds of rewards.
And finally, on the diamonds track, you'll be building Humpty Dumpty's wall. You'll collect resources from the bricks you place and victory points each time you bump Humpty back up or back together again.
Ultimately, in the game, your goal is to get to the top of as many tracks as possible because that's where you'll claim crowns, pushing Alice towards her coronation.
Once all the crowns have been claimed for your player count, the game end will be triggered. Alice will either end up as the Red Queen or the White Queen, depending on which side has had the greater influence, and then you'll score points.
You'll gain points from bookmarks that you've claimed. You'll score points from the Alice Wish Scrolls on the track, and you'll be able to score those based on Dinah the Cat's track.
You'll also score points for the chess pieces that you've invited to the coronation or called from your deck, and then the player with the most points will be deemed as the most influential courtier in the new era of Queen Alice. So that's pretty much the simplest explanation that we can give you of everything that's going on in this game because there are levels to all of it. Why don't we kind of walk through each of the uh boards, the side boards, and give a little bit of additional details, and then we'll share our thoughts, obviously, as we go along. Uh let's start with the Hearts board, but also maybe we should start even a step further back. I don't think we explained that the color chess piece you move determines the actions on the next board.
Yeah, so every time you play a card for your turn, the that's the chess piece you're going to move and if it's red or white, that's going to determine if you're going to move the red or white piece on the next mini board.
Yeah, so we the chess board is not a full chess board, but there are plenty of pieces out there. There is plenty of chess strategy that you can use in the game. Capturing other pieces as you capture them, they'll go in your jail. You'll get a little bit of time and some bonuses when you do that. If someone else plays a chess piece that you have captured on their turn, then it you get a little bit extra time for it, but they get to place it basically anywhere on that side of the board, which is nice. And yeah, that strategy of okay,
some more resources.
I've got these three cards to choose from. Which one of these three pieces can I move cuz I know I want to take the spade action. How do I get to the spade? He could get to the spade or the queen could get to the spade, but if I play the queen, I can capture another piece. There's some cleverness that you feel when you play chess in the game, even though this game is not a chess game.
Yeah.
is a chess game.
Yes, and it whatever you do in that chess game kind of has a domino effect on the rest of what other players are able to do, um which pieces are on and off the board at certain times. Um pieces may end up getting locked into where they are cuz they can't move. They get surrounded. Um so there's all kinds of things that can happen with the chess part of it. There's also a a multitude of different setups for that chess since it's not a regular chess board. Um the backs of all the player aids have a setup that is different to start off with that may give a little more advantage or power to certain ones of those chess pieces.
I do want to put this in the BGG thread soon. Can you castle in the game is what I want to know. You can? That in the rules?
Oh, I don't know about castling. You can. There is a bonus for getting a piece all the way across.
Not the same thing.
Not the same, but.
So we were going to then move to that hearts board. That's where the flowers are happening. Those flowers are going to give you ongoing ability. So if you can collect the different types of flowers, they're going to do things like allow you to hold five cards in your hand instead of three or to pay less time to transfer time into resources. And then as you collect the second one, the power is going to get even better. Um that board is limited as I discovered in my second play of the game. We played it as a two-player game the very first time and we were like, oh okay, we figured out the strategies. We went back to the second to play again. This time with three players and I was totally dominating on the hearts board. I had all the hearts off of my board. I was getting ready to claim a crown and then poof, before I knew it, we ran out of spaces on that board. There isn't a whole lot that changes in your player count from game to game, which means that your gameplay strategy is going to have to change because it gets everything gets tighter.
Yeah. All those those spaces are finite for the hearts board. The other tracks um you can go up the tracks whether or not other players have done so. So the moving on to
board is a little bit different, but yes, the other two spades and clubs.
Um that one there is a bonus for being the first. So there are some major [clears throat] point advantages for being the first to move the mad hatter and the white hare along that track first. Um and then obviously you will gain the crowns if you can make it all the way to the end of each of those tracks. That is the main way to gain cards to add to your deck and those cards are really powerful.
Almost all the tracks on the game are going to give you the abilities to upgrade kind of anything and everything, but each board also is going to kind of specifically have its own focus. Deck building is what's happening on that spades board. You're going to be able to choose from the bronze, the silver, the gold cards as you make it further along the track and being able to add those cards to your hand and cull out other cards is going to then give you greater abilities every time you play that chess piece.
The clubs board is where you're gaining the books. If you're the first player to one of the spaces that has a physical book token sitting on it, you'll gain it. The other players will get whatever is underneath it. So the way that you gain the bigger bonuses in that game is by spending the book tokens to get the bookmarks. Some of those have ongoing abilities. Some of them are end game scoring bonuses, which can give you a decent amount of points. So being first on that track is also beneficial.
Yeah, and then when you finally get to the diamonds track, that is where Humpty Dumpty's hanging out. It's kind of fun that he's two different pieces and you've got to move him up the board. As soon as you finish one side of the wall, he's going to bump to the next round. That board also is going to allow you to pull the diamonds off your board, which is another way to get to those crowns. All the boards have some similar Like they're pretty well balanced. I felt like when we were playing this game, it wasn't like I could just the very first game, I think we kind of avoided what in a two-player game we were able to kind of avoid one of the boards and just dominate on the other three. As soon as you add additional players to the game, then you you're going to have to go to all the places just to get tokens off of your board and to actually be able to get the resources that you want.
Yeah. Most of the time the thing you're going to be needing to pay attention to, which I failed the first time I played the game, um is the dina cat track. That is how you're actually going to be allowed to score most of the end game scoring points. So Alice is moving up the track. If you're taking a lot of white chess actions, it's actually going to gain you a lot of red dina pawprints. So it's the opposite. So if you're trying to go up the Alice the red Alice and get the red pawprints, you're going to need to take white actions, which is counterintuitive. It just makes you think a whole lot harder in the game. Um but that cat track is how you're going to score, so don't neglect it. Honestly, you need to probably focus on getting those along the way. And whichever track that Alice makes it up to the throne at the end, those two Alice Wish tokens are going to get flipped to be worth double.
So if you haven't gone up Dina's track, you're not going to be scoring those points.
Right. And so that variance alone, those four wishes that come out each time, those are variable every time you play the game, those are going to determine really what your goals should be throughout the course of the game cuz that's what's going to score you the majority of the points. You can get a bunch of points by getting crowns, moving up the track, achieving lots of stuff. But at the end of the game, if you've got double the points and you've leaned into those two, you know, actions on that side of the board, getting double is huge. That is going to be probably what tips the scale in your favor at the end of the game.
Yes, there's also a way to gain more points by culling your deck um in on the spades track and other places um on a lot of the cards.
themselves.
Yeah, there are ways to discard or trash cards completely from your deck and it is inviting that chess piece to the coronation at the end is is how they theme it. Um, but those cards all have victory points on them and some of the higher level cards even have bonuses. So every um night that you have in your deck is going to score points and every certain different cards will give an additional points besides just the base value that they're worth.
Yeah, there are so many different ways to score points in this game. It's It's a little nuts and you've got to kind of track and balance all of it because you might be further ahead on the scoreboard halfway through the game and think you're crushing it, but if somebody's tucking away end game scores or tucking a bunch of their cards, uh it could be anybody's game, which is always exciting when you get to the end of the game. This game also does feature a solo mode where you play against Dina the cat. You flip over one of your player boards. It's a different board that she works on and you're going to be playing against her in multiple difficulty settings. There's also some variance in the game um where you can have like in-game goals that are secrets or you have the crowns have powers on them, different things like that. Those ones aren't as big as some like the game itself. They're just going to be some little additional things that you add. But man, so much going on in this game.
and when I pulled the rule book out, I was like, this is a very small rule book for how many things are going on in this game. I I think some people will complain about the rule book. I found it very concise and they assume that if you're playing this weight of game, you already know chess, you already know how to play a deck builder, you already know how to move up tracks and gain resources. There was only one little thing about resources I needed to just verify on BGG, but otherwise everything actually did make sense in the rules for it being so few words.
I think they did a good job with the like the explanation of what all the icons do. There's tons of icons in this game. I think it's language independent on the board uh because everything it has a cheat sheet that explains what you like you've got a little handy board that shows you what all the flowers do and what all the trades and actions do. There's actually kind of like maybe too many icons on there, but then when you open up the book, the books explains every single scroll, every single card, everything you need in the game, which makes it very easy to jump to once you're playing to remind yourself how you know how these things work.
Yeah, I did think that this game made logical sense. I felt very satisfied making all the decisions that I was making each turn. That chess piece is going to determine which color that you can advance in whatever track that you end up on this the column to the matching board. There's ways to take additional actions on your turn if you have extra time. And so um there's lots of different ways to be able to manipulate whatever you have to to able to try and gain the crowns to score lots of at the end.
I tell you this is the type of game also where you're going to get better the more you play it. There's So there's plenty of luck and how your cards come out and and getting started, but we've each time we played the game our scores have like gotten significantly better. Uh and then we've played against players who have gotten even higher scores than when we first played the game. I was like, why would there this token go up to like 300 points or something like that? It's achievable. There are are things that you can do to optimize your play. You're going to learn, you know, which cards work better together. You're going to get better at capturing pieces. Um I didn't really feel like I struggled with like, you know, analysis paralysis. Even though there's a lot going on, I kind of usually could tell like, oh, I don't have any red pie. If I want to take that action, I'm going to have to go get it first and come over here. And then you could stare at the chessboard for a little while and be like which pieces when you especially when you got five cards in your hand like which one will give me the bonus and the resource I want and allow me to capture somebody. But I really felt like our turns have started to go pretty fast in the game.
And I feel like it's the type of game where I I mean, I'm ready for the challenge again. I want to try it at all the player counts. I'm not usually interested in solo modes, but I'm even curious to see what that feels like in this game. I feel like they did a really elegant job of like tying the theme to the actions, making things as she was saying like logical. You kind of know what that next step is that you're going to need to take, but giving you lots and lots of options, lots of different ways to do it, and then a good amount of variability from play to play.
Yeah, this sounds like something you're interested. You can check out Queen Alice from Combo Games. And as always, we thank you so much for checking out this video and liking our channel here at Tantrum House.