Skip to main content
Loading video...

Legacy: The Testament of Duke de Crecy Review

Transcript 26:08

welcome to John Gates games today I'll be reviewing Legacy this is a highly thematic worker placement game where you will be guiding the fates of your family tree through four generations as you attempt to hone the greatest Legacy ever known first I'll go over the rules and then I'll jump into my review here's the starting setup for a two-player game of Legacy we see that each player has their own private board as well as a head of family and an endgame Victory condition there's also a single communal board that's in the middle of the table the first thing the players must do is decide if they're going to begin the game as a matriarch or a patriarch we see that these player cards are double-sided and there are differences between these two sides so let's say that black chooses a matriarch they get nine money a single income and five random friends in addition they get the red disc and they begin with a single income the white player chooses to play with a patriarch at the beginning they only start with five money but they have two income and six random friends along with their yellow disc and now we can begin playing the game this is a worker placement game where each player has two Universal workers and then they obviously begin the game with a single one-time use colored action worker we see there are many of these colors I'll explain what these do later on each player's turn they will be doing a single worker action where they can place their worker on either the four spaces on their personal player board or on an empty space on the communal board this means there are 10 worker placement spots to look at so let's start talking talking about him

it's important to note that a player can choose the same location multiple times on their own player board however once a location is taken out on the communal board no one else including that same player can come back and choose that specific spot until the beginning of the next turn let's begin by looking at the marriage or arrange a marriage action here are the five random friends that the black player began the game with we see they have four male friends and one female friend now this game is set in the 1700s it's very heteronormative if you're doing a marriage then a man must marry a woman so since the black player began as the female character The Matriarch they're going to need to get married to a male to start their family so let's say the player playing Black choose to begin the game by marrying Pascal an officer in the Cardinals guard the first thing that you do is you look at the top and you see that it costs minus two this is effectively the dowy that you are having to pay in order to make this wedding happen next up we see this one income bag here this means that my family is going to increase their income by a single bag so we shift that up and finally we see this here it says gain one yellow disc so I would take a yellow disc from the Central Supply and put it into my player area finally we will take the Happy Groom pair it up with the happy wife and we need to make a baby so we go to the top of the children stack and we draw the very first card and we see they have a boy there are two different sides this is the young boy and this is the adult boy so it starts off as a child we go ahead and put the child directly underneath them and that fully evaluates the marriage the other option you have for

the marriage space is to arrange a marriage where you essentially make a marriage happen in the future for your current children so for instance the player playing Black here now has a little boy they could try to arrange a marriage with a woman in the future next up on the player boards is have children now I fast forwarded here and I gave white the starting marriage and a child so let's say that white chose this option here now we choose a couple in our family tree that have less than three kids there are a couple cards that break that rule but these are not any of them so we choose this couple here they only have a single child and they just simply have a child you either draw one from the top of the deck or you could lose one Victory point to choose the sex of the child so you would keep drawing until you drew the boy or girl that you were looking for so they would draw the top card from the deck and uh-oh so this is called a complication in birth and it says lose the mother or the child so this is pretty terrible it's the 1700s and bad things can happen so either the baby or the mother dies at birth and it is the player who's playing decision about what happens however in either case you keep this complication n birth card in your player area to show that in this generation you had a single one of these you're never allowed to have multiple of them you just discard new ones within a single generation next up is ask friends for money and this is really simple by going to the spot you either take $2 and nothing happens or you can take $3 but lose a victory point because people start to look down on you or you can lose a victory Point lose a friend from your hand and take four points showing that theyve just completely left your circle of trust because they're quite upset of you for borrowing all that money and the final

option on each player board is socialize this one's relatively simple as well you see you can spend zero money to choose one new friend from this face up stack you could spend one money to get two friends or you could spend two money to grab three friends from this area it's important to know that once you take friends from here they do not automatically refill it's also really important to note that if you ever take friends so that there's a single one remaining you are forced to take that one as well at which point the bank will be EMP and we would then refill it with five new friends now let's look at the six options on the communal board and you'll notice that there are multiple colors on them so this is where these onetime action discs come into play you can always use your Universal workers to go on any of these slots however this yellow disc must always only be placed on one of the yellow slots on the communal board likewise this red disc must only be placed on this red slot right here so let's start talking about these options the first to discuss are these two yellow options we have air title and contribute to the community they're both yellow so two yellow actions can be evaluated in a turn however this one only applies to these three over here and this one applies to these three over here once you use this spot you simply pick one of the three available options and you spend the cost in the top right corner to grab that specific contribution or in this case title and you add it to one of your couples in a family and then you get some bonuses for instance this right here is simply a church donation you spend three money to the bank and you get to draw four face down random new friends you take the card you associate

it with a couple and now there are less options for future turns next up we have the fertility doctor and in order to go to the spot you have to lose one friend from your hand as well as $2 but the big bonus for the fertility doctor is that you get two children for doing this action as opposed to the single child you get for the one on your board next up we can buy a mansion this costs us one friend and it costs you three bucks but when you take this Mansion you flip it over and it's really nice and pretty and we see that there are two shields on it so if we were to do this and put it for this couple over here we would then push the shield track on our player board up by two next up we have initiate Adventure this costs two friends from your hand as well as one Victory point when you take this it gives you a money bag so you can put this down on a couple they own that and it would increase the overall income that you're going to get at the end of each turn and the last option is undertake a mission this costs you one friend from your hand and you simply draw the top card and look at it in secret it's kind of a quest that you are trying to fulfill this only happens if you have at least two Nobles in your family once you do you can spend one money to the bank and you'll get three victory points and you'll Force every other opponent to slide down once on their Shield track now you might be asking yourself how do you know if you have Nobles in your family so let's take a look at some of these friends we see in the leand side of all these cards there are little icons and these show the kind of work that these specific friends do so this is the noble icon so they don't really do anything this is the artist here this is a politician we have a scientist here and here is an artisan it's also important to note that there are little flags on the right hand

side of each of these cards and that is the nationality of that specific friend once it's a player's turn and they choose to not take another action or they simply can't then they pass and once every single player has passed we are going to skip to the next turn we look at the turn track and we shift it down once we see this little gold money bags icon so we shift this over here and this signifies that each player now takes money equal to their current income level so the player playing Black would take three money and the player playing white would now take two money we would then shift this over to show that is now turn two and the starting player token would shift over to the other player in a two-player game or just clockwise in a 3 to four player game at this point we would take all of the workers off of their different playing boards and these one-time use discs would go back to the main Supply so now let's talk about what happens at the end of a generation we see that the first generation only lasts two turns the second generation lasts three turns and the third generation lasts four turns so at the end of the second turn we will shift over here everybody will take their income again and then we will go to this spot right here and you see that it's kind of a star with a little shield on it at this point each player gets victory points equal to their current Shield level on their player boards now we'd shift it to the next spot which has a star and a little card on it this is the symbol for children so at this point each player is going to get victory points equal to the number of children they were able to make in a given generation so now the generation is over and we move this marker over to here we see that there is a little disc what that means is any of these one-time use discs that were not used by players they get discarded and each player gets one new one randomly we take one of each

type we shake them all up and we give them out to each player at the beginning of each new generation the other thing that happens is the contributions and the titles are generation specific so these level one one cards would go away and the level two cards would come down next up we shift our marker down and we see a little turny card here and that is when all of the children grow up and any arranged marriages happen so we do this in player order so we see that why does the first player here they have no arranged marriages so they would simply rotate all of their children over and now it's this player's turn their little boy grows up and immediately gets married to Eliza the poetes so we already got them money we did that when we arranged the marriage and now we get to do the rest of the card we see that we get to take one face up friend from the pool so Eliza has friends that get added into our family but then we also see that you gain one green disc if you have any other British friends in the family so you see a little British symbol right here obviously at this point we don't have any of those but this is the reason why those little Flags matter many of the friends in the game and many of the missions in the game will let you do certain bonuses if you have given nationalities amongst your family tree the last thing we have to do is this happy new couple needs to have a baby so we draw the top card from the deck oh it's a little girl they go ahead and place this down here and now you officially have a grandchild it's important to note that in this game you're going to have children grandchildren and great-grandchildren which means means your family tree is probably going to get quite large and use quite a bit of table

space we see that at the end of the ninth round we do the typical thing where we go here we score Shields then we go here and score victory points for each of our children in that generation but finally we score victory points for that special card one of these for instance is the Madame de pador we see that you get nine points if you have at least seven children during the third generation But Here Comes the tricky part we see this bottom area with the red border these are optional endgame scoring conditions now you only activate these by using unused Mission cards but it's a little more complicated than that during the first generation and second generation when you use this undertake Mission you take the card and you look at it it's got a quest and you try to fulfill it however once you're in the third generation which is almost half the game you don't actually look at the cards anymore when you go to undertake Mission you simply take the top one and you leave it face down in your player area and for each of these face down missions that you choose on turn six seven eight or nine you get to activate one of those two optional endgame Victory scoring conditions at the bottom of your card so if I had done this once I would get to choose one of these two endgame conditions to evaluate or if I done it twice in turns six through nine I'll get to evaluate both of these once you add all those up into your Victory Point track you see who has the highest and that person is your winner if there is a tie for victory points then the person with the most shields on their player board wins the tie if there is still a tie then they share the victory for my review of Legacy I'll be covering each item of this list starting at the top and and working my way down so let's begin with the Positive points and the first of these involves how well the theme is woven into the very mechanics

of this game if you get rid of theme entirely you have a solid playing Euro game it's fun but you add that theme on and it just elevates and multiplies the enjoyment that you get out of this game because every single nook and cranny everywhere you look is strong thematic tie-ins you look at the rule book and there is a paragraph over every single ability that you can do explaining the theme it says this is why you might lose a friend or two this is why might gain some Prestige here and the reasons why because you are Aristocrats and oh you got a new mansion and they're pissed off they wanted that Mansion too so they leave or oh you had to go to the fertility doctor well that's not a very good thing for Nobles to have to do so some people are going to look down and you're going to lose friends that stuff just makes sense to me also when you just see the mechanic of building that family it makes a cool engine which I'll get to in just a second but it just feels like you're building a legacy the game name of the game is legacy and that is what you have at the end of the game you look down you see your great grandchildren and you say wow I built a legacy you look at all the different nationalities of all these different people and that's interesting in thematic as well you have uh the largest percentage of people is going to be the French but there's all sorts of other nationalities in and a lot of them are like racists there's some that just give you negative points for having specific other nationalities in your family there are many that synergize with that same nationality in the family which kind of makes sense you marry in a Russian lady and she's really happy to see that her um uncle-in-law and her grandfather is also Russian it just kind of adds in this thematic context that just makes so much sense for this game and it just really works and positive number two has to do with how the engine building in

this game was designed I feel like the designer could have gone one of two different ways one way is you build this big pyramid and everybody bounces off each other and they all this ability does this and every time you do this this this and this procs and they could have done that and I bet they were incentivized they probably wanted to do that because that sounds cool but that would have made your brain melt that wouldn't work with this humongous pyramid of people that you're building instead they built an engine building game of one-off cards pretty much everything that you do you place it down it does it once and that's pretty much it the only ongoing effect you get is uh what they do are they a noble are they an artisan are they a scientist and what their nationality is but there's no real complicated factors to that you can kind of look around and be like oh I have three Nobles I have four Russians that's pretty easy to look at the stuff in the past you're constantly thinking about the future like pushing forward how this is all going to build up which cards in your hand might synergized together in a oneoff fashion and I think that does a really good job for keeping downtime lower than it potentially could be and I think it's just kind of a refreshing thing I haven't played that many games that have you building this big colossal thing through a series of oneshot effects it seems like most engine building games bounce off each other all like crazy I'm glad they didn't do that and I think it makes sense from a thematic TI as well which I heard talked about a little bit because it's like you know time is moving forward the the people behind you are not necessarily live all that time so it's just adding to the Legacy that you had a scientist in the family who happened to be Russian not necessarily that person is still there doing stuff for you so I just

really like how that works neutral number one has to do with those special action tokens that you get in the game I think it's a really cool idea this is a worker placement game where you only have two workers but then you get all these One-Shot color-coded actions that can only do one thing that's neat uh the issue I start to have with it is kind of how they were executed they the first thing is you get them randomly uh as you new generations in the beginning of the game you kind of get it randomly based on your starting player character but then later on you're just drawing them out of a hand and oh congratulations you got the fertility doctor you're super happy or oh looks like you got the build another Mansion one that's not very interesting it's going to be worth maybe a couple points to you depending on the time of the game but it's not going to be helping you build your engine and I there's a lot of like H kind of let down moments when you're getting those randomly and I feel like it was just a missed opportunity I feel like this is a great mechanic that they have in the game like many of the friends get you new the new special action tokens when you marry into the family and that's great I feel like the designer felt that he wanted these actions to be used more often like maybe people weren't marrying often enough to make use of those so here you go you get some random ones at the beginning of the turn but I just wish there was maybe they were on more people so you got them through more marriages or maybe they got passed out based on reverse turn order or something which I'm going to get to in just a little bit I feel like it was a bit of a missed opportunity to fully flush out that really interesting idea of the special special action tokens neutral number two has to do with the touchy subjects that this game inevitably brings out as I mentioned before there's a very strong thematic connection and

the theme at this time is not the greatest when you think about it from a human equality perspective you know in this game you can have complications during pregnancy and guess what the mother or the child has to die and you need to make that decision it makes a lot of thematic sense but it's kind of dark uh and you can you can try to laugh it off and oh we'll Remar and whatnot but it's not the happiest thing in the world when you're thinking about complications at childbirth also you have an asymmetry between genders in this game and I think the game is designed in a way that Treads this line very well however it doesn't change the fact that when you marry men into the family you gain income and you lose money because you are paying a doy to marry the wife or when you marry women in the family you get money instantly because of dollies it also seems like a lot of the women get you more friends oras the men get you more Prestige and from a thematic standpoint this makes a lot of sense where in the late 1700s you are all nobility you're trying to build you know pompous Family Lines everybody is sexist and it's kind of terrible that being said the game does a really good job of having a large diversity of these two genders you have beautiful women you have ugly women you have beautiful men you have ugly men and there are some men that you get money for paying because well they're very lowborn or they're just ugly and there are some women where you have to pay money because they're very lowborn or they're ugly and that's ah man I mean it thematically makes sense but there's no getting around the fact that it's kind of uncomfortable if you really want to think about it that way and it might be an issue for you it

has not been for us in fact if anything these things have just increase the enjoyment I've had for the game because of that thematic connection but it's just it's just something you should know about and now let's move into negative Point number one and this has to do with the way turn order is evaluated in the game turn order specifically whoever goes first is very important in worker placement games you know pretty much by definition you want to go to a spot once you go there nobody else can go there that's a big deal one spot's probably going to be better for you and getting that initiative to get there is very important but in this game at the end of a turn you just pass the starting player token to the left and that person goes first and if everybody had the same number of turns being the starting player that would be forgivable in my opinion but it's not in a three-player game that's fine this game always plays nine turns each person is going to be starting player three times in the two-player game that's not the case one person is going to be starting player one more time than the other person and in a four- player game you're going to have somebody who is going to be starting player less than other players and I just don't like that I have not seen this lead to imbalances in the game like I haven't seen the fourth player always lose or the first player always win but it doesn't get around the fact that I think it's just a missed design opportunity almost like a bad design opportunity uh in games where you have a bunch of rounds and then you clear off and reset and you go back in I feel like they should always have a mechanic for moving the starting player token that is not just clockwise around the table uh there are lots of different things you could do you could have it be the person with the least amount of victory points or the person with the least kids or there's just lots of things you could do

or you could potentially have it move clockwise but have a reverse draft on getting those special action tokens I wouldn't like that as much but even that would be better than the way the game currently evaluates it because there is no balance for being the fourth player in a four- player game I just I don't like how that happened and like I said it has never broken the game but every time I play it just does not sit well with me negative number two has to do with that endgame scoring card you get the beginning of the game I like this in general like this is great in board gaming it's face down nobody knows what it is it gives you a direction to play the game it also adds to replayability because it's going to be different from game to game what I dislike is that bottom part of the card where you activate some uh endgame scoring conditions based on Mission cards that you've drawn now if you remember the way this works for a large portion of the game the entire third generation when you activate the mission space on the board you take a mission you don't even look at it and you just put it down on your player board and you say that is going to activate one of those two things on my little card and that works but man is it clunky it's awkward to teach and I also think it gets rid of a really cool aspect of the game which are those missions you know the a large portion of this game is that third generation and the entire time you draw a mission card and you don't even look at it I love looking at them and seeing what the conditions are oh if I have three scientists in the family and I paid two bucks I put this down and you know everybody has to give me a scientist from their hand or something like that those are cool and they add variety as you're playing the game it makes that an interesting action and of course it is nice unlocking these endgame bonuses on your card but I just I feel like that is clunky that could

have been done in a way better way that maybe it could have been the number of missions you completed would activate some of these things on the bottom or just something I feel like it was a missed opportunity it's awkward it's the hardest part to teach in the game and I don't like it and now let's talk about replayability I honestly don't have that much say about it because I feel like Legacy has a very standard amount of it it's not bad it's not particularly amazing at the beginning of each game you get that Victory point card that's hidden and there's a few of them in the box so that adds a little bit of variety those missions add a little bit of variety although like I just said you don't get to use them as often as you'd like um and you're going to get through that entire friend stack pretty much every game and since they are almost always face up as they go after pretty much one or two games you will have seen every friend in the deck but that's okay because as you're building that big pyramid that big Legacy of your family it's going to play out differently every single time because it's all about how the order of that those friends come out and the way you can make them all kind of connect up synergize and work well together so this game I could definitely see getting quite a bit of play it certainly is getting quite a few requests to play so it's not getting stale anytime soon okay let's talk about player count now the game plays two to four players and I've played all those different sets and it works with all those different settings I'm going to start with a four player and say that I would not necessarily advise the four player game usually because a couple different things the first thing is downtime can become an issue analysis paralysis is not a big deal in this game but late game when you have that big pyramid and you might have 10 people in your hand you got 20 money there's a lot you can think about and I've had situations in the four player game where you're it's really not getting back to

your turn as fast as you like so that's not ideal also as I mentioned in that negative the way the turn order Works in this game is not very favorable for a four player game because somebody is going to have less turns being the start player than somebody else which is really not great and lastly this game takes up a lot of space you're going to need a pretty large table to play a four player game because that pyramid of people gets big and they have this over here and this over there I've seen some people get compact down but it gets hard to play the game in that setting so I'm not saying I'll never play four player again but it's definitely not my favorite and now for the three-player game I would say this is probably the best player count to play for a couple different reasons the first of which is pretty simple it gets around that starting player issue that I have every single player is going to be starting player three times throughout the game it's nice and equal that's good also it is a good balance between downtime and tension because downtime is not as bad as a four-player game there's only two people between your turn and your next turn uh but also you have enough people getting in the way in worker placement games you need that tension of oh is somebody going to get to that spot before I can get to it can I do this thing first because it would be good to do that later and you have a good balance of that in the three-player game uh shifting into the two-player game it's definitely good at two-player I liked it quite a bit but again you have that starting player issue which I'm not going to rehat again also there is definitely less tension there's just less people going out there onto the board there's pretty much always people fighting over the fertility doctor but beyond that it's definitely more open I I like it two-player I really like it three- player and I could be convinced

to play four player if I need to but it's definitely not ideal in conclusion I've been really impressed by this game it might seem like I've harped quite a bit on some of the negatives that I have but that doesn't get around the fact that that first positive the great mechanics to theme integration is so big it kind of dwarfs everything it's the first thing that I tell everybody and it's the most important thing that I tell people about Legacy because I think it is rare to see a solid Euro game that also has such great theme like you feel like you're doing what the game box tells you you're doing how many games do that you feel like you're building a legacy you feel like you know marrying off your kids and marrying off your grandkids that all makes so much sense that little game of figuring out the hand management of which cards to play in what order that's all solid all this is just so solid which I think is probably why I talked so much about the negatives because those were a little bit glaring like it a little surprising so much of this game is elegant streamlined and just really welld designed and then these couple things just kind of seem like Thorns like Oh weird why why was that done that way and they do not get me even close to not recommending this game I recommend this game entirely and wholeheartedly I just have a little asteris that the torn order is a bit weird and there's a couple little weird clunky things down there I wish they had streamlined those and if they had this game would be like a Beyond glowing recommendation but as it stands I definitely recommend it of course like I mentioned in the neutral points there are touchy subjects that you want to think about as you're playing the game it might affect the age of which the people you are playing with is or if somebody's just particularly sensitive you need to keep that in mind

but man it's just a really good package i' as I said I've been very impressed with it and I recommend you give it a shot if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel also if You' like to become more involved with the channel you can directly support it at patreon.com jit games thanks for watching

Progress saved