Splendor Duel Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm taking a look at Splendor Jewel now this is a two player only game that takes around 30 minutes to play on average now if you've made it to my channel you're probably aware that a splendor is an existing game for two to four players very popular and streamlined engine building game now Splendid jewel is designed by the original designer Mark Andre but it also has input by Bruno cathala now generally speaking I'm not a huge fan of Catholic designs when he does games on his own but I was a huge fan of Seven Wonders Jewel which was the two player only version of another popular game Splendor so I was quite intrigued to see how he put his twist on the Splendor format now before I get into my review of Splendid Jewel I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who am I go to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order so of course there are a lot of similarities between the Dual version of Splendor and the original and you know the winning condition is going to be essentially the same where you're trying to collect these cards and racing towards a certain number of points in this example you need to get towards 20 points on these cards you acquire however there are some changes in the victory conditions like for example you could also be the first player to acquire 10 crowns so you can see here that some of the cards have crowns on or you can also win by having 10 points in the exact same category because again
much like the original splendor you have all the different gem types as you've got the red ones the white ones the black ones Etc so again if you have multiple cards of the same type and that accumulates up to 10 then you will win now the biggest change in this game is how you acquire the gems in the first place so in the original you could just pick and choose which ones you wanted as long as there were some available there but in this one you have this board that you are sharing with your opponent this is how you're going to draft these tiles so when you take these towels you can take any orientation of horizontal vertical or diagonal as long as you don't do not pass through these gold tokens and they need to be next to each other as well so for example I could say I'll take these three gems here or I could take these um maybe maybe these three or these three depending on which ones you want and of course which cards you are building towards so you have the very simple gems here which are quite easy to aim for and then for example this one here needs two uh two Reds and two greens and if you wanted to cash in those gems you could buy this card you wouldn't get any points in this example but you always get a kind of bonus here which means that in future purchases you'll get one black gem discount and as you can probably imagine the more and more cards you acquire the bigger and bigger discounts you get and it makes it a lot easier to reach the more expensive cards and where you can get a whole chunk of points here now there are also other changes you can see so on these cards um they're not only worth points and you know um discounts on future cards some of them have special abilities on them
as well so they're represented by these symbols here so this symbol means that when you purchase this card you'll instantly get another go um I believe this one here means that you can put this card in any stack and it'll be a discount of which one you choose there's ones here that let you steal from your opponents and there's also ones that will give you a kind of um the opportunity to grab a matching gem from the board if there's one available now another mechanism that's been added to the game are these privileged Scrolls so you can see if I bought this card I'll get privileged scroll now there are other ways you can get privileged Scrolls as well but if you grab these it means that before your actual turn which would normally consist of either taking gems buying a card or reserving a card by putting it in your personal card Supply and you can do that up to three times much like the original and you'd also grab a gold gem which is a wild but these privileged Scrolls would actually let you kind of do a pre-turn I suppose and grab any Gem of your choice from the board as long as it's not gold so this can be really useful and there's only three of them available so it means that um if there's one there you can grab it but if there's none left and you gain a privilege you can actually grab it off your opponent so that's a few little twists there and that's essentially what the differences are and as normal again you're trying to race towards um those cards being the first to reach one of those three winning conditions now the Scrolls will also count towards these three kind of public sorry four public characters now much like the kind of um I believe
they're called like patrons or the Nobles from the original game these are going to be kind of a first come first served um characters and these you're going to get these by gaining three crowns or six crowns so you know when you reach three crowns you'll grab one when you're going if you gain six um crowns you'll grab another one and these will give you points and will also give you the ability to do one of these special um kind of actions there again stealing gems getting another turn or taking a privilege now as you can probably imagine as the game goes on the board here is going to get depleted by these jet um well depleted of gems and as again another pre-turn and optional action you can choose to replenish the board State um by you know refilling them from the back here and they'll be done in a very specific order so that you can't kind of game gems that you particularly want and if you refill the board because of course you're going to be giving yourself a nice option to do that you're also going to give your opponent a privilege so sometimes there's a bit of a um attention off you know I hope my opponent refills the board yes they're going to get first dibs but I'm going to get a privilege for doing so and then again I'm going to race and race and race until get all those cards much like the original Splendor and I think I've covered all the differences there now I do think it's worth mentioning how I felt about the original Splendor because of course there was a lot of similarities here and I always thought that Splendor was a very well designed game very clean you know hard to streamline it any further and I always appreciate that but I couldn't always I couldn't help but feel that the game was somewhat sterile and it left me wanting you know I always thought that was kind
of a bit procedural and almost by the halfway point or three quarters points I was ready for it to end and I thought it dragged on a little bit long despite even not being a long game now despite me actually thinking for every element of change in splendor duel is for the better like for example I think the drafting system is much more interesting um because you know it's a bit more of a puzzle to it um rather than just grabbing the gems that you wanted to get definitely think this is a huge Improvement I think the multiple winning conditions is a lot better uh it means you need to be on the ball a bit better and keep an eye on your opponent and what they're aiming for because yeah you could be getting a ton of points that they could be aiming towards the crown cards and can kind of beat you to the punch there so again something you have to be very careful of I also do like those kind of mini decisions of am I going to give my opponent a privilege by refilling the board um can I String turns together by aiming towards certain cards and getting repeat turns by getting that kind of um bonus action there and he's become very useful and get another good touch to the game I do definitely feel like the Lasting Impression was pretty much identical to the original Splendor um and again I this is one of those games that I should like you know everything about it I'm struggling to look why I don't like it because again it's so streamlined it's actually quite satisfying when you get that engine rolling but again I just feel that it's so procedural and so clinical um that it's almost again it just lacks a bit of soul for me and I felt the exact same way with the original as I do with this one despite there being some
good interaction here you know it's a very pivotal part of the game you know beating your opponent to draft the tiles you want or the sort of the tokens you want are the cards you want Etc there is interaction embedded into every aspect um of this game I think it could have been taken further through the drafting system like for example you know normally you can only take again at least three tokens next to each other I do feel like say you drafted these ones here like so I think it would have been a cool idea if that would have been or given your opponent the opportunity to draft three in a row even if there are gaps between them so this will like create a new opportunity for your opponent to grab a red a blue and a black rather than just getting three that are exactly next to each other and I'm quite surprised that wasn't added into the game and it would have made things a little bit more interesting and add a little bit more consequence to your actions so yeah I think that's a bit of a missed opportunity there maybe I'm missing some balancing issue I'm not quite sure but I don't think I am and I think it would have been a really nice touch and made it even more Dynamic if that was an actual Rule now one new thing that I did not mention is that there are a new resource here these pearls now these are slightly different by the fact that there are no cards with pearl engine building benefits on them so no cards are ever going to decrease the amount of pearls that you need now in the games we played that kind of brought the game to a bit of a standstill and made it a bit slow and plotting because there were loads of cards in the Tableau that needed pearls but of course we were sharing two between us and of course once you spend them they'll go back in the bag meaning that someone's gonna have to fill the board back up and so on so I definitely
thought that slowed the game down a bit and I don't actually think that helped the game so that's probably one of the only changes that I didn't like I do appreciate how the game it maintained that simple turn structure you're taking one or three very simple actions on your turn are the take gems buy a card or reserve a card with a piece of gold I love how that's been been maintained very clean and you know easy to digest so full respect uh in that regard now I suppose the big elephant in the room for me and something that I'm surprised more people weren't talking about at least from what I've seen is that the actual Original Gamer Splendor played well at two players now despite me enjoying all the slight changes that have been made here um again especially the drafting mechanism in spender Jewel I'm kind of thinking why would you choose this one when you could have a more versatile game with the original Splendor that could tailor towards three or four players should you need it to now I suppose if you have a designated uh you know partner who you play all your games with then I'll say yeah definitely true Splendor Jewel over the original because I think the game is better but I don't think it's that much better to forsake that three or four player option I think the production here is fantastic the cards look great I think they actually look better than the original nice and vibrant a slightly more cartoony aesthetic with this one you've got smaller cards and things but of course it's a small little game that fits in a nice little box here so yeah I definitely like this box size to have full props for the production choices here you've got that still and the quality Um poker chips here in a
slightly smaller format but yeah I do definitely like the way everything looks here um yeah no issues at all with the production in fact it's very nice okay so let's share some final thoughts on Splendor Jewel now I have to say I pretty much feel the exact same way about this one as I did with the original You know despite appreciating it from a mechanical standby point on a design standpoint and how clean and how streamlined the rule sets is um I just felt somewhat numb with it I just don't get too much enjoyment from the clinical nature and that procedural nature of the gameplay now I'm so surprised by that because no I should like this game on paper um I think of all these slight twists are improvements on the original but again that loss of the flexibility of the player count is a big hindrance so definitely kick that into consideration and that for me would be the main takeaway talk point that I have to say about this game you know are you willing to sacrifice that three or four player count for some very slight rules tweaks now again the drafting system here is much more interesting I think it could have been even more interesting if that mechanism I mentioned earlier with it being able to take three in a row or call them or diagonal would still be an option even if there are gaps between them because you would still be restricted by the gold tokens blocking you anyway but it would have added another dimension to that player uh interaction so objectively this is a good game if you like the original Splendor you are certainly going to like this one I definitely do not think you need to own both of them um so yeah that's it really
um it's just more Splendor so yeah are you willing to um just play the two players of those slight improvements or are you going to stick with the original and um you know maintain that Play account flexibility