Transmissions: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and brett and i are doing a no run-through review for transmissions uh which is one of my newest kickstarter games and uh is it a game would you classify it as a game i i would here's the thing about this um as most people know my no run through reviews are four games we either don't like um or or yeah or they're very difficult to like it's not gonna be a fun to run through um and also expansions because i used to redo like the run through with the expansion and it's like nah so transmission is is one of those games that its biggest selling point is its art yes um and so the art by matt dixon uh stellar quality yeah and i mean it's good production quality the insert for the box is really good uh everything fits it's it's nice kind of like everything goes where it needs to uh it's also not a kickstarter game that's you know it doesn't have any bloat like uh like it's it was interesting whenever i opened the box i had like an epiphany of like it's so weird opening up a kickstarter box and just taking out one thing instead of like you know hordes and hordes of expansions and trying to stall it or store it right uh unfortunately yeah playing it um
it's so boring like i've i've debated with myself so many times on would i rather play an inherently bad game or like what's worse an inherently bad game where you can tell that they just like really [ __ ] the bed or a mind-numbingly boring one and i think for me it's the boring ones are the worst because you're so because at least a bad one you're you're distracted and you're you get criticizing yeah by criticizing it or you're you're laughing or you're thinking of improvements yeah so you're you're engaged with how bad it is right but and it's kind of like watching uh you know sharknado or something where it's like oh this is so bad but i'm having a good time yeah versus watching some dumb [ __ ] like red riding hood and you're like this is just this is a nothing movie and this is kind of a nothing game at least for for me um there are elements of this game that i could see being put into other games that would improve upon them right but here it's like with how cute it is like i i i love the you know the molds for the four different robots like they have some personality it's adorable this is the cutest box i've ever seen uh it's got a nice lovely meadow in the middle yeah but you do nothing with it this really could be any theme yeah like it's it's incredibly pasted on and oh it's fully abstract i mean
the theme of each area has nothing to do with what happens there right well technically the you will get forest cards uh the only one that does make sense is the power generator because you get lightning yeah you get power cubes this could be such a cool idea like is it you have your own individual player board that allows you to modify the robots and the initially it sounds like it's going to be a really cool concept it's like hey it's a new take on worker placement yeah and i like and it is i like the concept yeah i do like the idea of shared workers right and um the the not deck builder but the the randomness of which ones you can utilize yeah problem is all that inhibits any level of strategy exactly uh we played the game um i totally forgot what it was but it was me you and zach and it was it was that cyberpunk game where we tried to strategize but like we had to like you move to person so it's like okay well now i can't strategize uh what was that i don't remember what that game was called in 2d yes uh okay where any level of strategy was out the window because you're able to move you know workers way out of my range or something so it's like okay i can't do anything this one isn't as exaggerated as that because it's just a simple track yeah there's uh one two three four five how many spaces two four six seven so there's seven spaces so 14 total steps yes uh
that i mean it's not even that much because you skip over robots to get there so i mean yeah the yellow one it's like it's its slowest but it has the highest track so you get the most points if you fill it out and but you share the workers and over the course of the game you can get ideas and the game comes with a decent amount of different stacks of ideas that it's meant to be variety but it's like it's like a whatever you know like if you can tolerate it it is replayable that's the thing it's like if the stacks had a theme like so you can kind of change hey if you want to play a really aggressive game or whatever then choose h k and l or whatever but not really it's just kind of like oh okay well this is just what it is and shuffle them together and put them out but it's like what i did is i got yellow you know out and i was able to it it was the slowest moving one so i gave it two extra movement and i also gave it the ability to go forward or backward right so you can have some customization and that's the only interesting thing about this game is that okay yes we all move yellow but i might want to move him more because i get something out of it uh or he does something different but ultimately i don't care yeah like yellow was my coolest one but it wasn't even cool it was like oh he can move faster to go to you do the same thing yeah over and over and over
and the game is like there's a little bit of resource management but not enough to make it strategic no i mean because really at any given time i mean with the top decking of forest cards like you're really always able to kind of get what you want and then it's just like oh okay well no yeah there's enough like in the pipes there's enough variety you probably got whatever resources you need to get something yeah even if it's not what you really want yeah because at the end of the day it's like the pipes are my biggest complaint because it's like what it should be is because you know how you get extra points for your longest thing you should also only be able to score them that way right because otherwise just go here and get pipes there are a lot of there are a lot of points all by themselves yeah and then we string them along you get bonus yeah it's like seven eight or nine points they're relatively simple to go get and then it's like i mean you you 51 points off that alone and i mean really your only sense of points came from pipes yep and then you happen to fill out one robot and if we look at cat knives we're in everything yeah like i had three robots filled out uh points from forest cards points from ideas uh and it still wasn't enough yeah so it's like okay well here's the meta go get pipes yeah and it's not even a matter of oh well people need to compete against you it doesn't matter just go and grab them they're seven eight or nine points
and i just don't like that it's a bonus of 15 or 20. yeah if you're if you if you really want to you know string them along and have like one massive path that wasn't hard to do actually i had two decently long paths yeah i if i built them together i would have gotten a lot more yeah exactly it's like yeah i mean because the clothes the scores were still close like in this latest game 67 62 and 62 right uh and funny enough i had like the two green cubes in the white to be able to get that one that blocked off which i think it was worth nine uh that was actually the difference maker between first and last and it's like oh dang you got there before me well nothing i can do about that um and this game could be weirdly cutthroat about about in in the in the slightest feels that way because you did something that screwed me you didn't mean to you didn't know it yeah oh by moving but yeah but i've got i've got one plan yeah [ __ ] i can't do it now right oh well we have a backup plan yeah well it's also like oh okay i saw how you moved your um how you moved the robots to get those very specific uh resources luckily it's my turn i also have those resources i'm gonna move there and just take that from you yeah and it's like okay or the toaster thing yeah the toaster thing where you could just be like oh i'm just gonna run up to that area the idea area area and just grab that idea just to wipe the toaster if anyone was going to try and get a collection going and we actually talked about it we couldn't do it right right i mean even when the the ball came out that was going to get you uh 16
points and i didn't even notice because it came out and i was like because i was waiting for it because i'm like well i can't let him get 16 points uh i was gonna but then it comes out it was at the bottom of the deck and so if you're if you're betting on that to show up and it shows up at the very end and you're like okay great they're all over there i can't even go get it why did i play this game like why am i trying to maximize off these points because whenever cat ended it was like oh we get one more turn each [ __ ] it you know there's really nothing we can do yeah i mean i literally was like and i hate hate stuff like this i was like okay i'm gonna go to the forest and see if i can pull points off the only way you can possibly get points yeah and i didn't and i was like oh lucky me and i didn't yeah and you get two of the exact same cards and there was a game that came out i think it was last year uh called dwellings of elder veil that was a lot of that of just top decking points and i uh what's the panda one about the irrigation does the same thing you top deck uh objective cards it's like oh man lucky me fulfilled that fulfilled that i just i don't like points that way i don't mind point salad games where everything you do gives you points but you have to work at least for those oh hey i mean not all of them sometimes it's like oh i drew a card that's a point but just flat out no strategy and just hey three points it it just leaves a sour taste in in my mouth yeah um
so the fact that this game is well one this would be fine if this was a for sure 30 minute game and it is an hour yeah yeah because i mean then you'd have at least some you know like i don't think it's intended to be that long what does it say 45 minutes yeah i think is yeah cat said the problem is you know i'm trying to accomplish something you guys move them and i didn't draw the cards i need to do what i want to do so on my turn i've got to figure out the next best thing and everybody has to wait yeah and so that's what happens every turn is everybody's waiting for somebody to figure out what their second choice is yeah i don't like so everyone has the same seven cards it's dependent on if you know just how they're initially shuffled uh because what i do like about the seven cards is you don't have a discard pile right so you can start memorizing okay my red should be should be coming up but you have uh you have one card in each deck for each of the robots and then you have uh three cards corresponding to the places on the um on the board yeah i hate these i i hate these so much because it's like yeah oh well there's no room like i want to get over to the pipe area okay well i can't okay the none of these robots i have in my hand can make it and the card that i have is for areas that there are no robots in or they're too far away so i guess i'll
just waste my turn and move the green there yeah and get a useless too white i don't need white i don't need blue okay i can't tell you how many turns or how many times it was just like i was i knew exactly what i just wanted to do because it didn't matter cat goes and i'm like move it okay here's my energy put this to the bottom draw a card and and i understand that this game's it's not for me like this is definitely very gateway-esque it's it's mind-numbingly simple so maybe it's intended for kids yeah maybe that's the only thing i can think of it's like it's definitely a higher complexity than candyland sure yeah and that's the thing it's like i can never tell like what games are good for kids being because i don't have any uh so i don't buy games that are intended for kids yeah so then these games come out and it's like okay it's not a party game it's not it's on the it's too complex to be a simple throwaway yeah fun but it's not strategic enough to actually be an hour long compelling and to hold attention or to want to strategize between turns yeah because i thought for sure i was like okay like you like the more straightforward games and then cat likes you know games with like art like this so i was like oh okay this is maybe it's just me and when i'm bored out of my mind and not like and
then both of you are the same way it's like oh no the art's not keeping cat in the game and the actions are too dull so brett's not enjoying it you know what i got it and i've got friends who i think would enjoy this game because this is a game that you don't play this is a game that you talk yeah and you chat and then every once in a while you look at your cars and go okay i'm gonna do this sure i've never done an hour and a half where 30 minutes is actual gameplay yeah and i know people who play games that way and they might enjoy this because it doesn't take thought it it really doesn't but that's the other thing is like maybe this is a generation thing it's like i could just sit down and just talk with my friends i don't need this to be at the center of it yeah it's just like no i mean i've sat at this table and talked to people for hours and there wasn't a game being played we just happened oh games are over yeah i thought you were leaving but it's like oh man we could have had we could have played another game yeah but we sat around and talked yeah um it's uh it's here's the thing is like these these games are so hard to review because it's like it's not inherently bad right there's just nothing to it there's no substance yeah empty calories yeah it's not like there's a it's not like there's a flaw right it's that the entire premise just doesn't come together right and we were talking about another game that we played recently that did have inherent flaws but we had more fun playing it than we did this one
and that's it's like okay well that one is i mean spoilers i mean i'm going to give this one a higher rating than that one but that's just because of just how i rate games yeah like that one actually had problems yet i was less miserable playing it than i was right here right really the game not your personal experience right got it so i don't know it's it's whatever like i think the concept has promise about shared workers and about limited uh ability to utilize them at any given time this is not an execution that works yeah because that's the thing is like you you get items that fill up your slots so you use items those are your other ways of getting points you can do really good set collection and that fills up your your robots quicker yeah but you're not getting ideas well who really cares when ideas don't get you points like the end of the game is all about points so it's like why wouldn't i just bum rush for items one that's gonna end the game quicker two if i can get three pairs of socks that would be uh 24 points yeah and on top of the fact that if i get two pairs of socks and i put one in my green slot and then get you know another one that fills up the secondary you know part of the green slot so that's uh 16 points on top of six so
it's 22 points already and my green is uh yeah he doesn't do anything i can still move him but he doesn't have anything special and so then i sit there and go oh no i didn't get any ideas but the ideas kind of suck that's the thing they're not exciting they're not game it's and the rules are like they break the game no they yeah i technically i move them and i get i get a lightning yeah oh i can swap spaces okay oh they're not that powerful they're just simple yeah it's not like they're talking about like voyages of marco polo where everyone has a special ability that does break the game right or it's not cosmic encounter but with robots where it's like damn that's your ability like never once while playing this game will be like whoa yeah that's a cool i didn't even see that combo i mean even the card that lets you take an extra turn yeah anytime you want yeah like this could be really great and i wasted it by using it too early sure but the other thing is going for ideas it occurs to me filling up filling up robots with ideas which are extra things to consider yeah you're going to slow the turn down even more right if i can move that one then i can do this and i can do this but if i move that one yeah you get the most i can't move them you get the most basic uh engines for them it's like oh if i activate this one that gives me two lightning which i can then use to get a green
yes whoa that's the best thing i've ever [ __ ] seen magic combos dog [ __ ] compared to what my yellow robot can do yeah it's and like you said the concept of my yellow robot does something different than you than everyone else's that's that's cool if they could take that idea and expand it into a heavy strategy engine building game like where there's a lot more going on like that concept like a mineclash game would be it would be amazing it'd be amazing for me it would be um because i mean if you can get some really cool engine buildings but people still share the workers so if you have ways to really accentuate the fact that oh this is what my worker does that is like let's say we all had like our yellow worker completely filled out but it's like mine does something so drastically different from yours it's it's a very cool idea but boiled down to like a nothing game and that's what actually upsets me because it's like that's that's a cool concept i haven't seen before we've seen the concept of shared workers yeah but they're in better games well maybe not in too deep kind of suck too uh yeah and then you have pipes that are the meta like i don't know i don't know and it's it's
also annoying that the uh the higher level points the ones that are like like there's no variety these are just randomly shuffled and placed so the nine pointers it's like okay it's still three cubes yeah why isn't nine points four or five why can't seven points be three cubes and then eight points is four nine nine points is is five you can hold seven so that really makes you have to start strategizing on getting your workers to certain spots because it's like there's a nine pointer out there it's two blue a yellow green and white that's that's a lot of you getting around and that might actually make you take certain ideas and move a worker that you can then boom move him and spend a bunch of lightning to then get those exact cubes and then be like boom here i go not that you can't do that in this but it's just so easy to just be like oh nine points yay me you know what's interesting we're way more engaged talking about the game than playing right because it's like we like the concept of what they had here but yeah it has to be for kids or something like yeah i mean it's got the feel of a gateway game but again if i think it's with these cards being in play and trying to figure out how you move them um it's definitely not for strategy gamers no and i just i just don't know who it's for because you're gonna you're gonna want i mean this box alone that art is it's it's so it's so adorable
but then you go to play the game and you're like oh it's that's not really depicted here yeah rules-wise it is where it's like hey you actually multiply birds and butterflies why that's just because he's he's wanting he has a butterfly on his finger that's a balancing act so you're supposed to get both items and right pipes right because it is a multiplier which would have changed things a bit if i had first of all realized it second of all had the resources to be able to actually do anything about it yeah by 30 minutes in i was like this game should be over like and it's not and that's another thing whenever you expect a game to be over and it out stays it's welcome uh so yeah um cute game i mean 9 out of 10 on cover art i think it's super adorable but it's it's not in this game nothing like i didn't expect this to be like a campaign storytelling game no but i expected kind of you know more robot [ __ ] going on right uh not just four different things that really don't matter yeah like the only thing that's different about them inherently is their movement and two of them are even the same yep so i don't know another covid game i guess maybe i think yeah if cove it's been going on for two years yeah it was definitely within that
uh there's kickstarter exclusives but if you're watching this you don't have the kickstarter game that doesn't really matter they're short mini things like a couple extra cards or something there's there's pipe forest cards that if you have your pipes in a certain order you get victory points like um like this if you had your pipes in that or do you get an extra five points wow um the acorn thing i thought was [ __ ] stupid yeah um like oh if you have the least you get five points okay we're gonna use the force the least and got the least benefit out of it yeah yeah if you just went like if anyone went there and was like oh i'm using this one that gives me an extra turn well that's three acorns so if someone knows you did that then all they have to do is just be like okay i'm just gonna take this one that's one a chord and it's like okay now i'm guaranteed five points yeah but that's also that's not a game breaking score no no it's not i mean it was just an extra five points but it's like it's just it's like why why is that there well you know and the more i think about it the more we talk about it the more i think they did a lot of good work to balance things out and to make you want to do all of this stuff instead of just automatically going for one area which happened to work out for me but it just doesn't come together as a playable game no and and that's what i agree with that's disappointing well actually slightly disagree with what you said because there's a lot of stuff that's in
here you said that to make you want to do it i didn't want to do any of it well because it wasn't it wasn't exhilarating to be balanced and you're supposed to i mean i wouldn't say this game is unbalanced like it was a five-point swing like that's uh i mean that was one pipe tile for me being able to give cat ended the game in any area where i had you know a yellow cube if i happen to have a yellow cube at that time it's like oh look i mean but that's the other thing that's kind of annoying because it comes down to oh lucky b not did i out strategize you no it's just okay well cat ended the game i'm able to move there i have a yellow i can buy this i now won yeah there's not enough resource management for that to be strategic this doesn't boil down to in the game where it's like does my strategy is it better than yours it comes down to luck of the pipes right place right time and then luck honestly luck of the items and just drawing the right cards to be able to capitalize on it all right right um so yeah so that is uh transmissions on scale one to ten what would you give it i see the possibilities enough that i'll go as high as four oh as high as four yeah um
this is one of those games there was a game that came out you you be you you don't have to be influenced by me because i it's like well so what i was going to say was there was a game that came out a while back called die settlers and it was such a nothing game that i remember watching dice tower talk about it and z garcia was like i don't even want to score this because it's so nothing you know this game doesn't need to exist like the fact that he was like he seemed more mad that they were sitting down to review it because it's like all i feel is that i wasted time like i gained or lost nothing in this experience right and that's kind of the same feeling i get here where it's like it's like for all intents and purposes just by ranking it i should just give it a flat five this is right in the middle this is a game that has been produced yeah but i have i'm more annoyed the more we talked about it just kind of some little instances but it is counteracted by at least a cool concept and i'll give it an extra point for an art so i'm gonna keep it at a flat five i agree with your four but i'll give it an extra point because the cover art they got me matt dixon i'm gonna find him at gen con if he's there beat him up no that's not true uh be like your art is so cute uh so just just do art don't do games yeah do make a comic like do a graphic novel yeah this begs for story yeah like and that's this picture alone has
story all over it and i want to know what it is right incorporate it into a game that this could have easily been like like like maybe like an aftermath kind of game this is still in shrink but like a plaid hat where this is a story driven experience you could have easily had that centered around these robots if he gave them personality or anything like that yeah but the fact that they're robots it doesn't even enter into it right it knows that it's all uh it's there's no reason for robots to be wandering around like this collecting stuff i know yeah so it's just it's such a disappointment um but that's uh that's transmissions let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that's for you