Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 20:40

Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, my grandfather was a mime in World War II. He doesn't like to talk about it. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at Axis & Allies: D-Day from Renegade Game Studios.

In Axis & Allies: D-Day from Renegade Game Studios, two to three players take on the roles of either the German Wehrmacht or the Allies, mainly the US or the British armies, as they attempt to invade Normandy in June of 1944. Now, this game was first published in 2001. I actually bought it back then. I played it back then. Uh but, I've never reviewed it before. I'm going to go ahead I'm going to review this new reprint from Renegade Game Studios, then I'm going to tell you what I think. Essentially, the game board is divided into a of zones. You have landing beaches for the allies. You have the five landing beaches historically, Utah and Omaha Beach for the Americans, Gold, Sword, and Juno for the British and Canadians. The Canadians are just part of the British Army in this setup.

[clears throat]

But you also have areas on the board that represent where Allied paratroopers landed during the Normandy invasion. Now, the Germans are set up along the board, throughout the board. They also have, in addition to their units on the board, they also have blockhouses, which are static defenses that simply fire out against those beachheads. But they will also have some chance to wreak some havoc on the allies throughout the game. Now, critically here, your basic units for each side are infantry, artillery, and tanks. And then the allies will also have fighters and bombers that behave in a very unique way, a distinct way from the way they act in other Axis and Allies games. Now, this game utilizes a combat card step system. So, there are 16 distinct steps, each one represented by a card. So, every round of the game, you are turning over a card, essentially doing what it says, and then moving on to the next card, all the way through the 16 cards. Now, the first thing you're going to do on the initial round, but not on subsequent rounds, is resolve those airborne units. They've just parachuted in, so you can go ahead and activate the allies can activate their parachute units right at that time.

Next up, the allies will have a naval bombardment phase. Essentially, they can target those blockhouses and try to take out those blockhouses with their naval battleship guns. Next, you have the fighters patrol phase. Now, what you do here is the Allied player has two bombers, one for the Americans, one for the British, and then four each for the Americans and the British. And for your combat patrol phase, you can essentially place your fighters anywhere on the board. Now, here's the thing, they don't just attack. They can't just attack. That will come later. What they can do is whenever the Axis move into or out of one of these areas, then the fighters get to take a shot at them. But, at this point, number three, the Allies just simply place their fighters where they think it would be best for them to be positioned during the round. Next, the Axis anti-aircraft fire. So, if any of those fighters occupy the same space as artillery, the German 88s, the 88s can actually take shots at the fighters.

They can roll a die. If they hit they roll one die for every artillery unit they have, and for every one they hit they can bring down one of the fighters. Next, you have the bomber strike. Essentially, Allied bombers can can can go to locations on the board, and they can roll the die and attempt to take out units that are in those locations. However, you also get a chance to roll the anti-aircraft guns once again to take out the bombers the Germans can, and same thing they're they're rolling one for every anti-aircraft unit they have, and if they hit, then that bomber is taken out of the game. After the bomber anti-aircraft fire, the bombers will then return to base. After the bombers return, then the Allies can move. Now, Allied land units, these are units that are already on the land, not in the beach zones, they can go ahead and move. Now, every unit moves one space, except for tanks, they can move two spaces. So, you can go ahead and move your units, and usually you're going to want to move them into units containing the Germans to do battle.

Next, the blockhouses, the German blockhouses can fire into those those those beach landing zones that the Allies hold. So, they get go a chance they get a chance to go ahead and fire and try to take out some of their enemies and these I believe are targeted attacks. Next, the Allies can actually begin to land units into these zones on the board that that are their landing beaches. Now, a lot of these places may already have German units in it, so that's going to of course lead to conflict later in the round. So, after the Allies land on shore, you immediately go to Allied attacks. So, essentially, any space on the board that contains both Axis and Allied units, they will get a chance to do battle. So, this is typical Axis and Allies. Essentially, you put the units on a battle board and the attacker is going to roll they're going to check and see what they roll at. Of course, you know, infantry attacks at one, artillery at two, tanks at three. And then the defender, the Germans will defend. Of course, their stats will be different as defenders, but essentially you're rolling through one round of combat and taking off any units that were hit. Now, after the Allies attack, now it is turn for the Axis to move. So, the German units on the board, they can move.

Again, it's the same thing. They can move all their units one space, but their tanks they can move two spaces. So, they go ahead, they position themselves for their counterattacks, they move all over the board, and then the next step is the Axis attack. So, the Axis units, they're going to go ahead and begin their attack and the Allies now will be on defense. They're going to be rolling defense for that combat round. After the Axis attack, the Allies are going to reinforce. Now, what they're going to do is they're going to roll two die for the Americans, two dice for the Americans, and two dice for the British. And they're going to go ahead, roll that dice, and add up the sum of those two dice rolls. Now, they're going to look at their reinforcement schedule, and you've got your reinforcement schedule that's got, of course, units on it. And kind of in reading order, you know, from the top left over, you're going to take that many units off and place them then in those landing beach zones. You're going to go ahead, place them there in preparation for them coming on the board next turn.

After the Allies reinforce, now it is turn for the Axis to reinforce. So, now the Axis, they're going to roll two sets of two dice as well. Essentially, they've got two places on the left side of the board they can enter from, and two places on the right side of the board they can enter from. So, you roll dice for each of those sections, you add those together, and the Germans can pull reinforcements off of their reinforcement schedule for either side of the board. Finally, number 16 is the Allied fighters will return. All of the fighters that were on the board will return to the to their landing bases. Again, every time there was any any enemy movement in one of their spaces, including reinforcements, uh they will be able to take shots at those units. So, players are going back and forth. They are playing through the various steps. They're revealing the cards and doing what the cards tell them. They're moving around. They're picking battles, and they are trying desperately to reach their victory objectives. Now, if the Allies are able to then to capture the three objective cities of Caen, Saint-Lô, and Cherbourg before the end of round 10, they win the game. However, if the Germans are able to prevent them from doing that, or if they destroy all of the Allied land units on the board, then the Germans win.

Axis and Allies: D-Day. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now, back to the review. All right, ladies and gentlemen, so that's the basics of Axis and Allies: D-Day. You also have some advanced rules here. Uh you have tactics cards and fortune cards. Each of these, there are 16 cards in the deck, just like the command deck. And what you do is, if you want to play with these, you put these 16 fortune cards numerically ahead of each one of those uh order cards. And the tactic cards, you would put behind, underneath each one of those tactic cards. So, every time you're playing, for each step, you would reveal a fortune card, you'd reveal the order card, and then you'd reveal a tactic card.

Now, the fortune cards essentially have one of the players, either the Axis or the Allied player, roll a die, and the die is going to somehow kind of enhance or make worse the action that follows it. So, you may, you know, if you roll, I think, a one, you're improved. For instance, you know, if if it's the Allied move, all the Allies can move two spaces instead of just one. But if it's the uh six, if you roll a six, then you can only move out of two spaces, right? So, so stuff like that can either really help or really hinder you. Uh just a little bit of chance there. And then, the tactic card is a special ability that either the Axis player or the Allied player can use that turn, and then the card is burned, it's out of the game, it's not going to come back when you bring the deck back. So, there's some choices there. Now, uh so that's basically the advanced version of the game, and I'll comment more on that a little bit later. But first of all, let me talk about this game. It's been around, as I say, for about 20 years.

And I was so excited when I saw this game was coming out, because I had played, you got to remember, this was just on the heels of Axis and Allies Europe and Axis and Allies Pacific, the first editions, which I loved. I thought those games were so much fun. I thought they were great. And so, I was really excited when I heard that this Axis and Allies D-Day was a thing. And I got the game, and I remember the first time I played it, I was less than impressed. And part of that was it didn't feel like Axis and Allies to me. There was no IPCs, you couldn't buy your units, you couldn't determine, you know, what exactly you wanted each round, and that really bothered me. I didn't like the way air power was used in the game. Uh I I thought, you know, I didn't like the fact that just the Allies got the air power, but air power is it's not really as important as it is in some of the other Axis and Allies games.

But I didn't like that, that rubbed me the wrong way. And all told, [clears throat] I just I I and I remember too, when I when I got the game, I was missing one of the the the blockhouses, and that really bothered me quite a bit. So, I was not a huge fan of this game, and I only played it, I think, two or three times, and then I was done with it. And I I think I gave it away, if I remember correctly. And so, I was not a fan of it.

[snorts]

Well, years have gone by, and I've thought about that more and more, and I thought, well, you know, I wonder, now that I'm not just so wedded to the Axis and Allies, my conception of the Axis and Allies way of doing things, I wonder if I would have liked that game more now. And I've thought about that for quite a while, but the this game has been out of print. In fact, I kept waiting for Renegade to make a big announcement that they were bringing this one back, but I didn't ever saw an announcement. I I I didn't see that. I was actually at Barnes & Noble one day and I just saw a copy there. I'm like, "Oh, they've reprinted it." I saw it had the Renegade Game Studios logo on there

[clears throat]

and I thought, "Whoa, well, I got to get that." I reached out to the good people at Renegade and they were very happy to send me that. They did not send me a copy of Axis & Allies D-Day. They sent me two copies of Axis & Allies D-Day. I actually mentioned to them, I donate some games to my school and I said if if you'd like to send me two, I'd be more than happy to give one to my school and they did. God bless them. And so, I I I've donated a copy of this to my school. So, hopefully that will ignite some other people's interest in Axis & Allies. So, anyway, uh the other night Ray and I sit down to play this game and I was really excited cuz I'm like, "Well, let's see what I missed. Let's see what I didn't get out of it the first time here." And we set it up and the game itself is a lot like I remembered it. I remember one thing I didn't care much for too when I first played it was the cards.

You know, the the card system of steps and I guess they changed there's 16 steps. You want to remember everything, right? Um I didn't I I I didn't love that when I when I played it the first time. And now my you know, my I played so many games and my my kind of my tastes have evolved and my just I I throw preconceptions out the window now with most games and I just play the game. And I kind of went into that with this one, but I'd already you know, I played the the that kind of card system recently when it when we I reviewed Stalingrad. So, that was very similar. So, you know, I'm I didn't have a problem with that. The card thing this time I I I really did not have an issue with it. So, Ray and I are playing this game and I'm I was the Germans and he was the Allies. We're playing the game, we're going through it, we're going through it and it was like it almost just snuck up on me and hit me over the head about a round or two into it. I'm thinking I am just having a ball. I am having so much fun with this game. This is just great. I really was. I don't know. The the the the Allied air power don't didn't bother me probably cuz I recognized it wasn't as powerful as as as it is in the other Axis and Allies. I I remembered you know you don't have IPCs and you just get the reinforcements and I was okay with that although I will comment more on that in a minute. And so just overall I I really enjoyed it. And part of the reason why I was enjoying this so much is when I had this game originally, I don't remember those advanced rules. And if they were there, I just didn't play with them. And I got to tell you, we played with them. I I I said, "Yeah, let's try the advanced rules as we play with it."

And I love that. I thought that was so much fun. I always love this little spice and sugar to mix things up and it was so much fun, you know, from round to round where you're rolling a die and something really cool can happen or something really bad will happen. Most of the time nothing happens. But I always like that chance and it's a die roll, it's chance. There's really no mitigation, but it's it's you're either rolling a one or a six or something like that to happen. So it's it doesn't happen often, but when it does, man, it was hilarious, man. Ray was just rolling bad and I feel so bad for him. Um I rolled bad a few times, too. We actually had one die roll. I think it was he moved and I moved and our rolls were identical. Not just for the movement, but for the subsequent combat. It was kind of eerie. But really enjoyed it. Now the tactics cards are fun, too, because that just gives you these kind of one-off options that let you mix things up. But there's a great choice there of when you're going to use them because it's it's a one and done. You use it and it's out of the game. And so that was a very very cool aspect because it gave you that that tough choice there.

Now when you're rolling the die for those that that one through six and uh you know, I think I think there may have been some other dice rolls, too. Uh you had to use the D6. The The comes with I think eight D6 black and white die. Uh we used it there, but for basic combat we used the Axis and Allies hit die, which is just fun to play with cuz you can roll all your dice together and and see the explosions and see the hits. Uh really always have fun with the Axis and Allies hit die, and that was a great way to use it there. So, I really really like that quite a bit. Uh I I all told, the advanced game here was a lot of fun. I just I ate it up. I really like these cards in the game. In fact, I will never play this game without those advanced cards. It would just be too vanilla for me. I really like the highs and the lows that come with these cards. They're great fun.

The reinforcement step, as I mentioned, probably my biggest criticism of the game is the reinforcement step. And my problem is when you are rolling the dice to determine what you're bringing in, that is That's all luck, right? And I wish there was some way to mitigate that. Because you're rolling the dice, and like I I remember one time I rolled 12 on my left, and I was able to bring in a buttload of units on my left. And I rolled a three on my right. And it was like actually two or three turns in a row I rolled a three on my right. And I was just, "Man, that sucks." I just kind of I mean, you know, Ray was able to take Khan pretty quickly. And [clears throat] I I think I took it back briefly, but he was able to take it and hold it for the rest of the game cuz I just could not penetrate in there.

Um so so reinforcements, that's my probably my biggest issue with the game. I wish there was a more I wish that wasn't just a die roll. I understand the chance there, but I wish maybe some if it is a die roll some mitigation there. I think would have been pretty cool. Uh so so so that was as I said, probably my biggest um issue. Now, Ray We're playing the game. Ray took Khan. He was this close to taking Cherbourg. I still had a unit there. If we'd gone another round, he would have taken Cherbourg. But he just there was just no way he was going to fight by the end there where I think around seven or eight, there was just no way he could have taken Saint-Lô. I I was there in force and he had no more reinforcements coming. There's just no way he was going to take it. So he conceded.

And I think probably that is another issue with this game. And that is I think the game from what I remember when I played it before and when I played it here recently, the game is kind of imbalanced. I think the Germans probably have the advantage in this game. And I'm fine with that. I don't mind games that are, you know, maybe a 60/40 imbalance like I think this one probably is. I don't mind a game like that if you kind of know that going into it, right? To me that's just a challenge. One of my favorite games in recent years is uh Dune War for Arrakis from Come On. And I think I think that's kind of a 60/40 leaning toward the Harkonnen. I think the Harkonnens have an advantage in that game. And I'm cool with that. I still think it's a fun game. I don't mind playing against odds, you know, as long as I've got a a reasonable chance of winning. I don't mind doing that. Again, I got to know it going into it, but I don't mind it. And and so Axis and Allies to me feels a little imbalanced in favor of the Germans, but it's still a lot of fun. I just I love Axis and Allies. You know, Ray is upset because every time we play Axis and Allies, I win.

And I'm like, "Dude, I've been playing Axis and Allies since I was 12 years old, right? I'm a I'm a I'm a military historian, a World War II historian and I probably owe that to playing Axis and Allies when I was 12, right?" But he he gets upset because he's the dice hate me, the dice hate me. But man, I had a lot of fun. I really enjoyed this game far more than I remembered enjoying it. Uh on the Cody scale, I'm going to go ahead I'm going to give it a seven out of 10. I think it's really a good game. With more plays it may go up, uh but I I I really really had a lot of fun with this game. Thank you once again for joining us today on the Discriminating Gamer. As always, we'd ask you to please leave a comment for us here on YouTube, on BoardGameGeek, on our Facebook page, on X. We'd love to hear back from you. Uh please go ahead and like uh this video and subscribe to our YouTube channel if you haven't done so already. Now, if you really like what we do here on the Discriminating Gamer, I would humbly ask you to check out my other channel, that is Cody Carlson PhD, where we talk about history, military history, books on history.

And it would mean the world to me if you'd subscribe to that channel as well. And again, if you really like what you see here, I would humbly ask you to click on the Super Thanks button and leave a tip. You know, my grandfather killed six Germans at Normandy Beach. Last week.

[screaming]

Best roll. And I got that on tape. It's the best roll OF THE GAME.

SECOND BEST ROLL OF THE GAME.

Progress saved