Earth Express First Impressions | Should I back this if I already have Earth?
Transcript
Hello everyone. My name is Phil and I'm a doctor who loves to play and talk about the board games I've been playing recently. I'm a fan of the game Earth, which came out a few years ago. And now on Kickstarter, Earth Express is available to back, which is marketed as a consolidated Earth experience in about 15 to 30 minutes for 1A players. Much of Earth is carried over into Express, where you build a tableau of cards and activate their abilities in a certain order, trying to fulfill shared and personal objectives to hopefully have the most points at the end of the game. The major difference is instead of one player choosing an action and everyone following simultaneously with that same action, Express has you drafting cards from a hand that you pass over to your neighbor to draft from a different hand the next round. similar to games like Seven Wonders and Sushi Go.
In addition, there is a solo mode where you draft cards from a completely filled tableau of an automated opponent. And after you draft, you refill the tableau and score all the cards of the action color that you choose and race towards the shared objectives based on the cards in that opponent's tableau. My first impression is great for this game. It is an excellent distillation of Earth into a faster experience. I'm giving it a solid seven out of 10. And here's why. My question when I learned about this game and played it is who is the intended target audience for this game. It definitely makes sense to market this game to those who enjoy Earth like me. Now, the next question I have is how often would I play this game and with whom? In my particular situation right now, I bounce back and forth between two gaming groups. One at work where we often play quicker, lighter games and the group that I meet with about once a week to play more complex titles.
Naturally, I would think that this would be a good fit for either group. either to play at work during lunch, it plays really quickly, or to play as a filler with the other group, the uh in case we have some extra time at the end of the night. I don't think the folks in my heavy group would particularly want to play this or even the base game of Earth. Unfortunately, I think this game is a little on the complex side of things in terms of rules and play for people I consider to be newer in gaming or those who prefer more rules light experiences. For example, another game that I've been playing a lot with my co-workers recently is Castle Combo. It's a lightning fast game just like Express, but I feel the rules burden is a little less compared to Express. keeping track of all the cards in your hand in Express, their effects, your objectives, the shared objectives, as well as potentially keeping track of and drafting from other players hands can take a load mentally to keep together.
Honestly, learning Express felt like it covered most of the way to learning the base game of Earth, and I don't know if my co-workers would want that kind of experience right now in terms of the complexity that it takes to play Earth. uh despite it being both games being excellent visually and mechanically. And so while game length is definitely feasible and definitely attractive for say an experience to play like at lunch during work, I don't know if this game is right for newer gamers or lighter gamers because of its relative complexity. That may or may not be true to those uh who watch this video to you or to those who you might play with that. But that is just my opinion that I think it's a step or two above that comfort level of an introductory type of experience.
Another thing that occurred to me is how random this game can be with so many different cards in the game. And normally I really enjoy games with lots of individualized cards. But in this game, you only have five rounds to build out a tableau that's synergistic and hopefully scores you well. You have more time in the base game of Earth to do so. And while the mechanisms exist in both games to search for potential cards and mitigate as necessary, it's still often a randomized experience on what you get from a large deck of cards. At higher player counts, it's harder to draft for and remember cards that might come back to you. If they do come back at all, you might have a different uh slate of cards given to you at every round of the game at higher player counts. Granted, you can just shuffle again and play the whole game again in about 15 minutes or so, but each game may be made or broken depending on what you get. In addition, the solo mode is very randomized to how well your opponent's cards are synergized. For example, if they if you want to take the red action and your opponent has seven out of the nine cards that are red, they're going to score a lot of points.
And so again, this can be mitigated with seeds and other actions that you take, but in the end, in my personal experience, I didn't feel like I could strategize very well, but just kind of react to what's given to me and pick the best options at the time. And that may be intentional based off of what this game is providing in such a small time frame, and that's perfectly fine. I will say though that this this decision space didn't seem to be too complicated. So I think I prefer the complexity of Earth when it comes to those decisions even though there is randomness in that game. there is more time to kind of strategize and you know try to pick uh the best options and draw into the best options rather than have just a very truncated experience with with express and not being able to do so and having to play a different uh set, you know, a different game uh to hopefully get that satisfying synergy of cards. Uh, in other words, I didn't feel like I was challenged with the puzzle in building uh my tableau with Express. It was fun, but it it didn't click at the same level as it does with the base game of Earth. So, in the end, I think I will wait to see how I feel about this game when it comes to retail next year and probably won't back it now. Maybe my tastes and my group's tastes will change and this will be a perfect fit for gaming with them and for myself.
I hope it will be because I love the game Earth and anything related to that excellent title and I really like this game too. And hopefully what I said makes sense and helps you understand if Earth Express is right for you to back right now in Kickstarter and it's right for the people that you play with. So, thank you for listening or watching and hope to catch you on the next one. Take care.