Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is Origin Story Stonemaier’s strongest release since Wingspan? - TCbH Review

Transcript 7:43

Okay, so I got to cop to something. Obviously, I try to keep up with announcements, new title releases, just basically news in the hobby space. And while I have several venues to talk about this publicly, I also privately have a group chat to discuss this type of stuff with some of my closest friends in this space. While I'm not normally one for just outright dunking on games, especially before I played them, as soon as Origin Story was announced, I sent this meme, which yeah, that pretty much sums up my feelings. Now, I'm bringing this up for two reasons. One, it succinctly says what this game is convenient for an introduction to a video review. It's a tableau building tricktaker with a superhero theme and gorgeous illustrations. And two, even though I had this initial gut reaction that this was going to be pretty boring, it turns out it's actually pretty damn rad.

Trick taking. You know the drill. The lead player plays a card. Everyone else must play a card of the same suit from their hand if possible. Whoever played the highest on suit number wins the trick, unless anyone plays the trump suit, which conveniently is always hearts representing friendship, in which case the highest heart wins, which is more or less the concept of every trick- taking game since hearts was invented 2 days after the creation of the universe. What makes Origin Story different is you are playing out five hands where each round except for the last starts with you drawing and selecting a story card, a power which will have a wide range of game altering effects and ways of accumulating points. Then in the final round, you select one of two set aside superhero identities which hopefully you've carefully planned your growth, your origin story, preparing you to become. Setting aside the strategic implications of the mechanics for a bit, this is some of the best thematic resonance that Stonemer has ever achieved in a game. See, your player board is your origin story, and each has its own individual on it with their nent powers. This is the beginnings of their tale. And during each round, you're upgrading your player board with their new encounters, their powers, their story development. These might be arch enemies. They might be tools. They might be particular events or evolutions of

the powers that they initially started with, culminating in their superhero identity, which takes up the final slot unveiled on your fifth round. Yeah, it is ultimately just abstract text modifying different ways for you to interface with this game and lead to points, but placing the powers into this tableau as you escalate into that final conclusion just gives it this natural arc that makes so much sense and everything ties together beautifully. But that would be meaningless if the game weren't also good. Which admittedly it is pretty standard tricktaking here down to the fact that it's a 52 card deck with four suits. So essentially it's just using a reskinned poker deck.

But aside from this accumulating power where each round you can assign stamina to activate each of your cards already on your tableau, each round you get one more stamina to spend and it always comes back to you rather than your supply. But the other nice inversion is that each round use your score tracker to reveal whether you're going to be in your superhero or villain side for the round, which means you're either scoring one point for every trick that you win or four points at the end of the round if you win exactly zero tricks, which sounds like a pretty easy thing to do, but definitely is not. It comes with its own mental gymnastics that you have to do about how many points you want to slough off to heroes if you're playing the villain trying to not score any tricks and also are you choosing your cards based off of whether or not you're planning on being a villain or hero more often. It's a small system, but there's [clears throat] a lot of life breathed into this game. One thing I have to make clear is that while this is a tableau building game, it definitely ain't an engine building game. Sure, you grow in capacity and good play seek synergies, but there's rarely a sense of exponential growth, rather just more options. Though the game does plenty to let you build selectively, knowing your final two hero options out the gate and getting three story cards per round, some just combo with each other way better, like a power that gives you a

permanent boost to stamina growth combined with the hero card Styia, who doubles your stamina and scores points based off of it. Fortunately, most of this is conditional, and the dynamic nature of trick-taking makes it more often an interesting avenue to explore than hurdle to overcome. Also, with few notable exceptions, I'm looking at you, Sale. Trick- takingaking has never been strongest at low player counts. Though, there is a valiant effort here. In two-player games, both have a dummy player to their side as a sidekick who always have a choice of two cards to throw into the trick. It's fine. Good even with its own set of gymnastics to work against. Especially when those face up cards at use to you and your opponent can be accounted for as you start a trick. Though it's certainly not as fluid or clean as with three or more players. and solo by Ottoma Facto's own Morton Monrad Peterson.

Solo collaborator with Stonem dating all the way back to their debut of Viticulture along with David Studley and Leness Hutter is at very least an academically interesting attempt to capture the logistical decision space of trickticking, but trade some of the genre's vibrance for a more contemplative puzzle. Successful, even if it requires more management than this depth of game probably deserves. I've had fun with it and I actually think I'm going to be playing a little bit more solo. But I couldn't help but feel that it never was really good, just good enough. All that said, this is a game that I really like. From the captivating illustrations standing in such contrast to typical superhero affair to a sense of personal narrative to the neat little combos you can make that it saw through my blasoise attitude to the fact that we're getting such a deluge of tricktakers lately and like many other recent bangers from arcs to sail to the office dog lo tricktakers it asks can we use this system this core mechanic panic to facilitate something greater. And I honestly think that origin story is among Stone Meer's best output in a long time. And that's our review. But let me know what is your favorite recent trick-Tak game. And what's your favorite game that uses tricktaking as a way to facilitate

something greater? Put it in the comments. And as always, thanks for watching, supporting, subscribing, commenting, doing all that stuff. It really helps. But above all, thanks for being such an amazing community.

Progress saved