Thebes Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
at number four I have thieves so this is a game that I've had on my want to playlist for quite some time now because it is from that byon Dusty dry Euro era and I love the theme of this one you the idea of being these excavators going around the ancient world pulling up these ancient artifacts to score points love that concept and actually on paper I actually do like some of the mechanisms as it is one of the forefathers of the time track system where different actions will take you a different amount of time and of course as long as you are furthest behind on the time track you'll get to take more actions back to back now this game actually the way it played out was quite frustrating and and probably not for a lot of the reasons why you might assume um for example this game is does rely on a lot of card drafting as you are collecting these cards it will get you books that will make you more proficient at diving or you know Excavating certain regions on the board now unfortunately the drafting pools are very small and what normally happens is that on your turn there's nothing you really want um and then you might pick a card it's not really a card that you want and it'll refill with a card that you're next really good for the next player or then you might spend all your time traveling from one side of the ball to the other um wasting all that time and then on the next player's turn the card you wanted appears in the place you've just left so again very swingy in that regard and some people it's just going to fall on the lap of and some people are going to get the hard shoulder in terms of how
those cards come out now I think a lot of the um criticisms I see on this game is the pure luck Factor when it comes to drawing tokens from these bags because basically the more knowledge you gain through these cards will mean that you get to dive into these bags more often pull more chips out and not spend too much time doing it whereas you know at the start of the game if you want to start diving into these bags you might only get to say pick up one token and that will cost you like eight time which is not a good ratio at all and again the more knowledge you get the more efficient that gets but despite that you are still hit with quite a huge luck Factor because these bags are filled with black sand tokens which are obviously just a waste of effort but hidden in there are all the points tokens now I do like the kind of passive Balancing Act of do I want to start Excavating earlier although my knowledge might not be great at least all the artifacts are still there um but again I'm going to waste a lot of time doing it and it's a huge risk or do I want to get really proficient get to draw a lot more tokens a lot better ratio but by that time other people might have ransacked that area and there's simply nothing left for you to get and as the game goes on of course more and more tokens are gone making it a lot more difficult to get the tokens that you need um so very swingy in terms of what you'll draw um and not only in terms of the cards but also in terms of the artifacts I thought the balancing of how long the time scales take is a little bit off and you can waste a lot of time
or spend a lot of time not taking a turn because you had a a poor action that spent a lot of time and everyone has to catch up with you meaning you're not doing anything at all so lots of downtime here as well so sadly I think um you know a lot like a lot like the theme would suggest this one hasn't aged well I think um you know the the all the new designs have really outpaced this one and it the luck factor is simply too much um but would love to see a reimplemented version of this or a second edition because I do think the framework is there just make the the car drafting a little bit more open so you have a bit more control and tighten up a few of the extra mechanisms to not let the luck Factor play too big of a part so a bit of a shame um again quite frustrating experience that is theves at number four