Star Wars: Battle of Hoth - Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. And Brad and I are doing a discussion over Battle of Hoth, the I don't even know. I I don't have a segue. Battle of Hoth, the the newest game by uh Richard Borg. um re-implementing the Memoir 44 mechanisms even though they're still supporting Memoir 44. I'm talking
I think this is just a streamlined version of that.
Yeah, smaller streamlined uh version using that that sweet sweet Star Wars IP that hasn't been relevant since the 80s. Uh um it this was a game that I remember I think it was announced at Gen Con, wasn't it?
Somewhere around there. Yeah, like around that time that was kind of like the new or like the hotness that was being like, "Ooh, a new Star Wars game." Completely out of my radar. I was like I'm like, "Oh, it's a Star Wars game." Eh. Oh, wait. It's uh reimplementing memor 44. Big eh. Now, years and years later, it uh it's made its way back. Brad, what do you think of Battle of Hoth?
This is your game. I didn't
I I like Memoir 44, but it was one of those that would take a while and it had its it had its com, you know, things that
Mhm.
you know, which got rectified in this, I think, because um we're not sharing a deck when we draw, so we each have our own deal.
They have the leaders that you don't have to play with the leaders, but I went on went ahead and threw them in just to give it a little bit more
stuff. I mean,
the games take 30 minutes.
Yeah.
Or so. I mean, cuz the board's so small, you know, but for it being Cuz it wasn't a This was a $60 game
really,
but it's, you know, the plastic and the
No, it's a $30 game with a 30 with a $30 increase because of that Star Wars tag on it.
But like I said, you know, it's like cuz normal Memoir 44's, you know, around that if not a little bit more.
Is it really?
Yeah.
Wow.
So, it's like, wow. But the stuff that they did with this, uh, the upgrades, because remember Memoir 44 used like wood dice.
Yeah.
And stuff, you know, this has got good dice. The miniatures are decent for what, you know, for
what they are. What I'm happy about is I think because it has that little Galactic Battles tag on it. I'm wondering if they're going to do more Star Wars stuff or if they're going to do more space stuff like go into other IPs.
Um.
Oh, interesting.
Because it's Galactic Battles, it doesn't say Star Wars. It can be true. They could do
Battlestar Galactica. They could do
they could they could do Star Trek. They could do
Starship Troopers. Somebody's somebody's controlling the the
the bugs
bugs and you know I mean there's there's different ways they can
Firefly. They could do Firefly.
And mind you, I haven't heard anything about that. But I saw that tag when I when I got this game and I'm like
it wouldn't be there if like it wouldn't be there if it didn't matter. Um
I think so. I I've never been a fan of Memoir 44 for a couple reasons. One, I hated that shared deck where it's like, man, I wish I can control my middle units. Oh, you're drawing them all.
I always thought that was [ __ ] stupid. The second thing was the I I just have never liked one v one dice based combat. Um, and it was extremely showcased here on how these games go in that it it becomes very one-sided when through no tactics or strategy of your own. It's just like, huh, I'll just see if I mean, that's how Undaunted always felt, right?
I'm not going to move. Let's just see if I can roll a a 10. There it is. Right.
There's another 10. And you're like, okay, I'm going to move all the way up here. I have all these dice. One. Okay. And that's how uh this game is. However, coming back so many years later, I I'm I'm just get this out of the way. I'm still not a fan. This isn't going to make me run out and buy this. It It never was. This I knew going in. There was nothing this game could bring that I'd be like, "This is amazing." But like you said, we each have our own deck that that just even if it's random on who I can activate, at least it's my own deck. I know it's in there somewhere,
right? Um, I feel like they had a lot more uh kind of like blanket cards where it wasn't just this lane, this lane, or this lane. It was kind of like order two units of your choice. Now, you would know more than me if Memoir had a lot of those.
They had some, but that deck got was so large. It was large. It's been a long time since I played it, but
yeah, but it at least this felt like, okay, two units in this lane, all units in this lane, or hey, choose any two units, and they get a buff. Okay, yeah, that sounds fun. So, I felt like I was never sitting here going, "Okay, I I don't know. I It doesn't It doesn't [ __ ] matter who I activate." I maybe felt that. But there was also still that little element of whenever I was really advancing on this side that I was kind of like may maybe he can't activate over there now. You it it never happened. You were always able to. But there's always that slight chance that maybe I'm making a huge push in one way and you can't react.
Um so that's that is a huge improvement on on the system. Uh I still hate these dice, dude. Like like these are like they're so shitty.
Well, they do better than the memoir dice.
They do
because um I mean they still have the soldier side.
I remember the soldier the grenade.
The Yeah, the grenade and the vehicle. They have the pretty much the hit everything.
Yeah.
But I don't remember them having the retreat which which adds
a little bit of stuff cuz you can kind of knock them back and that takes them out of range, you know, and
Yeah. But it almost seem to always hurt you every time you're like, I'm activating all these units and your first roll is a bunch of retreats. It's like, okay, we run back and now you're two units you're activating can't hit anything.
So, it's almost like, huh, yeah, I mean, I guess that they're kind of helpful, but every single time I rolled that, I was like, okay, well, now what do I do? Right. Uh but other other than not like in this in the scenario we played with the AT-ATs taking them out is I mean you have so little opportunities. Yeah. You have the the what are they called? The a are they a wings? They are a wings. If you get I mean they're pretty much going to get right up on them. You're going to roll four dice. Let's see how it would have gone if I was controlling the rebel.
Okay. I at least got two,
right?
Nothing.
They're actually snow speededers. They're not a
Oh, okay. I was like, I didn't think they were A-wings, but you have the chance of rolling potentially a bunch, but then you still have a Hey, I would have gotten one,
right?
But every time you you hyperfixated on that one,
I just know how powerful they are.
Oh, yeah.
Cuz I mean, they're crazy.
Like they still get to move and range one, two, or three, they're rolling three dice and can't retreat. So, they're always a I think they captured the theme really well,
but you just kind of have to um you just have to get super lucky. And I guess the slight silver lining is you're right, this game does take 30 minutes.
Well, right. That's what I was going to say. Like like you know, you kind of steamrolled me this this game, but that doesn't affect my enjoyment of it because it's such a fast game.
Yeah.
You know, like you know, you you have your victory conditions. Like my I had to kill five of your units. I didn't kill one.
No.
Um cuz I kept focusing on the hats and I wasn't killing them. But
Right.
But uh and you just had to kill the two.
Yeah. I think what my first opening roll was a one die and I took out your turret and was like, "All right." So that's how this game's going to go. Feels like But last time we did Undaunted um the space one, I was like, "Oh, see if I roll a 10. Oh, look at that."
Right. And that doesn't make me feel really anything. Like I wasn't sitting here going, "God, this game's so unfun." It was like, "All right, that was that was a 25 30 minute game,
right?" Well, and the thing is this game comes with cuz I I didn't know when I first saw this, I was like, "How many how are you going to is it just going to be the Hoth battle?" But then, you know, I asked it got closer to time. There's 17 scenarios. 18th if you have a second copy of the game or somebody that has a second
pay $60 just to have another board.
Well, but if somebody else has the game, you know, then you could do it for it's a big kind of grand mission. It's the sold on the Echo base.
I think like in the movie, but
yeah, I think they kind of do shoot themselves in the foot like the Galactic Battles if they do potentially. I think they would they'd be smart as Days of Wonder, but they've been kind of shitty with expansions if you're looking at heat for any example. But if they did Star Wars, you know, the Endor battle, you know, and then I mean Star Wars has such an expansive universe
that you can take this to space and do dog fight,
right?
Now, this one is like battle of Hoth. That's the only named battle I can think of.
Right.
Uh but they could just do a small box like this and another 17 scenarios and it's two more units. Now, what where I think they shoot themselves in the foot is this feels very restrictive. You only have Battle of Hoth. You can't combine box sets like Memoir 44 at least. You have all those expansions.
Yeah, I know what their release plan is with this and nothing's been said or anything, but I know this is very been a very high seller for them. So,
I'm not surprised. I know I'm an outlier when it comes to
Mamorph. Well, no, I know, but I'm just meaning like it's it's ripe for whether they do expansions or whether they go to other IPs,
space IPs, you know, I don't know what their plan is, but
and then the question kind of becomes, okay, if they do other IPs or other stuff, is it literally this just oh, now it's a green board because it's a it's the it's a forest.
Yeah.
I mean, Star Wars anything Star Wars just always feels like cash grab cash Star Wars. Hey, and it's like is it good? Star Wars and you know, shut the [ __ ] up. We're Disney. This is Star Wars. We will end your life if you even remotely criticize our stuff. And we'll see. I mean, we'll see. But I I personally think that yeah, if you like Memoir 484, I can't see any reason why you wouldn't like this unless you really love the single deck in your deck. And I think because it's it's for eight and up age wise, so I think they made it a little easier to
a little dumber, you know, just for
family type type stuff, you know. Sorry, but
I do really like the small inclusion of the leaders. I think that's that's a nice wrinkle. Uh cuz what was interesting cuz I was asking, oh do are are decks the same but like the leader throw and you play as soon as I asked that you played a loop card that I was like I have that in my hand right now. Yeah. And but it wasn't a Vader card. It was a standard uh Imperial card, but I would imagine that they're identical with a different a different title on it.
I haven't like I said I haven't really looked through them to see
sat down look through it. Do you have a card in there that's a that's kind of like a recon card when drawing a new command card. Draw two, keep one.
Yeah. And it lets you choose there's like a move one and a lane.
Yep. So, I have that. Um but like and then direct from HQ order three units of your choice.
Yes.
Yeah. Those are those are probably going to be the exact same, but the the uh
leaders
leaders are going to be different. Invaders were very very good. Ordered all of your units. They each roll one die less. I mean,
do you have one? You're not going to have one called Rebel Spearhead, but it's order two units of your choice. These units ignore movement and attack restrictions. You have anything that
Oh, I was like, what?
I'm just curious like cuz I have speeder assault. You're not going to have speeder assault, but you may have some.
So, I think there's some
I don't like a defensive position. So, I think there's some basic cards that are the same.
The closest I have is order two units of your choice. These units ignore all terrain protections for their close combat attacks. I think I did a lot of stuff with close combat getting right up in your in your face and getting benefits from it. Hell, in this scenario, I started with I mean that never came to fruition, but the one that if I destroy the unit, I got to move and attack again. That actually happened. That was fun. Uh so little wrinkles, I think. And it's going to be hyperdependent because I know another thing in Memoir 44 was they tried to go the historical route and they're like, "Hey, you can replay this battle." Uh, didn't the Germans severely lose that battle? Oh, yeah. They they're gonna lose this scenario. Um, but you get to replay it and it's like I'll just read a Wikipedia page. Yeah. If I I don't want to be on the losing side. That was kind of like when you asked me who I wanted to play. I'm like, who has the advantage, right?
You know,
and I don't I think this was pretty equal. It was just I wasn't hitting you because
Yeah.
You know, because a lot of them are whoever gets five medals first
or four medals first or whatever. And then there's but this one had a other winning condition. It also has uh two campaigns
really.
Um there's like little books and it's like there's a you know campaign one each of us would have a little booklet and stuff and then there's a campaign two also.
Yeah.
That runs through I don't know much about them. They're they're just like one page open.
Okay.
Like stuff. So but uh that's something to put into too. So, you know, I mean, it's it's not the perfect game obviously, but I think for it being as short as it is, and if you have two players you want to throw throw down real quick, I mean, it's not it doesn't take super long to set up either really.
No,
I mean No, I mean, they do they do a good enough job. Both units are just in in a vacuum sealed tray. It my my issue kind of comes down to it's not long, but it is $60, right? Uh yeah, you get 17 scenarios. That's a lot. But I mean, you can blow through those pretty quick. So, I don't know if it quite the gameplay quite matches the price point. And normally I don't bring up price unless it's like really egregious. But here I'm like, yeah, like it is only 30 minutes for 60 bucks. Damn, that's rough. Well, I will say it's almost like buying a $60 video game and it's like gez couple hours. Cuz like Memoir is close to I think Memoir is a $70 game, I believe. But but here's the thing though. I don't know if you remember this or not, but the miniature quality and Memoir 44 was nothing like this. Like they were barely they were really tiny and they weren't very detailed.
They were the new Gloom Haven minis. They're really
right. But but these are actually I mean they're not like but they're detailed. Yeah. Enough. So I think the miniature quality of these is much better than Memoir 44.
Yeah.
So I mean that's probably why because of the miniatures.
Yeah. And I will say I would if if it was like if you brought out Memo 44 and this I would much rather play this because I I because it is shorter. So the the dice aren't going to piss me off. And Memoir games always felt like they were longer depending on the scenario. But man, if you're if let's say Memoir was cheaper or it was it was the same price but the missions were an hour, I'd be fuming halfway through because it's like if I was in your position for this game and but I knew I had another 30 minutes. I think I'd rather cut my wrists and bleed out and wait for that to
Well, the memoir board is twice this size.
It is. Yes.
So, I mean, so you have a lot more space to move. Yeah.
You know, and stuff. This almost feels like kind of like Battle of Five Armies to War of the Ring where it's like War of the Ring had all this buildup and setup and then Battle of Five Armies was like get into the action real quick.
Uh here it took like two card plays before it was already trying to shoot. Hell, it took even maybe one card play and it's like a might I can roll a dieice.
Well, because you play that one that let you move like two extra spaces,
but they couldn't attack,
right? But you just
they couldn't attack. Just threw you right into the
threw me right into it. Yeah. And then but then it's like ah I think I can actually potentially I'll shoot your turret. Let's just see what happens. And it was a blast. Hey,
yay. Uh so yeah, I think I think the longevity of this game is going to be determined based on how they support it, right?
Not specifically Battle of Hoth, of course, but
Right.
And that would be cool. I think that would be a really cool, hey, here's the Star Wars memoir 44. You know, you just have a bunch of different scenarios. So, you get to kind of pick your favorite and they have different leaders. Hey, if you're on Endor, you have the stupid bears. And then, or you can be on
stupid bears.
Um,
Ewoks.
The Ewoks.
I knew what they were called, but they don't deserve me to call them by what they're called. Uh, or you can do the battle on Yashik. Was it Yashik? Kashik. Kashik. And have uh Chewbacca as a
as a thing. Or you do a space version where now you have Han.
That'd be interesting because it would you could just go with no infantry and just have three different ships,
three different ship types. I think that would be
a star like a death star, not death star but star destroyer and tie fighters.
Maybe one scenario does have an advanced TIE like your like the X- wings and the TIE fighters would be like your infantry since those are deals and then it kind of branches goes up from there.
Yeah. And then maybe a scenario does have a Death Star in it.
And that's like that. I mean, I think that would be that'd be really cool because, you know, they're just gonna kind of do it's always gonna be it's empires and stuff, but uh and I like that it's still troop based that you don't have like a hero running around.
Um cuz I think if they did a space version, I'd rather play that than Star Wars uh Rebellion. Is that what it was called? Or X-Wing? Not Star Wars Rebellion. That's a totally different game.
X-Wing.
X-Wing. I'd much rather play a quick version of that than X-Wing where it's still like where it's way tactical. Like, okay, I got this perfect positioning. Dog fight. He didn't expect this and I missed. Okay, I guess I'll just [ __ ] myself. Uh, so yeah, I think there is a lot of opportunity here. Not enough for me to be like, "Oh man, they they've released five versions of this game. I'm going to buy them all."
Right.
No, but you will.
Yeah, I will. and you'll never get a played except with me. And uh that's just that's that's how it goes. Um you got anything else? I don't think so. I think pretty well set.
How many of these? Okay, so I can see them over there. So they only have one other special token. The blue one.
This one. Oh, no. That's the other. Yeah, that's the other side of this. Oh, wait.
What's that? No, that blue one. Literally
Well, these are the other side is is uh weird side. So those tokens are looks like a droid thing. Um those would do like um it's scout. So these special forces can give a significant battle advantage to friendly units by providing information on enemy troops. When you scout them uh when the scout unit occupies a ridge hex and has line of sight on an enemy unit, any other friendly units attacking this unit rolls one extra die. Absolutely.
Those ones with the three stars are elite troops.
Got it.
So, they let you do be more powerful.
One thing that
Yeah. So, I I think I mean more of those would be cool. Uh but cuz I think at least it was just the way I was the way I was playing. I never used the the ones where they had to set up because I felt like it was way too much work to have them do. It's like I'll just have the I'll just have them rush and hope that they don't die. One thing about this game that I do think is really stupid is the line of sight.
Yeah.
Um I imagine it's edge case scenario like but like here to here but there's a there's terrain. It's like I can see you bread. Ah damn that tree and that tree. Can't I can't anymore. I guess I guess I can't hit you. Oh no. I'm I'm I'm right here. No. the trees. They're they're right there. It's dumb.
Yeah,
I think they for some reason just I don't know. That's just a weird
That was Yeah, these are kind of cool though, too. Kind of
the little sheets. Yeah, that was kind of neat. Double-sided. So, you can kind of
Yeah, I never had to look at your stuff cuz they were the exact same,
right,
as mine a little bit. But yeah.
All right. Well, were you giving this on a scale of 1 to 10? I think right now with what's on the table and what's out, I'll probably do a seven.
Seven.
Yeah. I mean, cuz it has room to improve depending on how they how they uh,
you know, work with it in the future,
cuz I imagine part of the fun with like Memo 44, especially with the ridiculous amount of expansions that they eventually dropped on it, is playing through each scenario. And then I know they did campaigns for that. And here would be the exact same way. Start on scenario one, go through them all, and then it's kind of like, all right. And then I mean at that point you got if each scenario is 30 minutes you know you got what is that
or 17
17 um so 16 8 hours 8 and 1/2 hours of of of gameplay. I'd say that's probably worth your money. But I'm at a six. I I can't go quite up to good. I do think this is a slightly above average game, but it's not one that I mean it would be a little bit different cuz like with Summoner Wars, I felt that the first edition was kind of like, oh, I guess he rolled better than me, but in second edition still has that. You could just whiff every single time, but chances are you're going to you're going to hit and here I felt like there was a lot of missing.
Yeah, especially on this side.
You would have thought I was the Stormtroopers that couldn't hit [ __ ] I have no idea how that's true. It was uh and that that that that's what affected the game. It wasn't any, you know, spectacular card play or Darth Vader's more powerful than Luke, whatever it it is. It's literally just dice didn't go your way. And that doesn't qualify as a fantastic game to me, but it might to other people. You got anything else?
Nope. Don't think so.
All right. Well, that's our thoughts on Battle of Hoth. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.