Good Games - Fairy Tale Inn, Navegador, Shipyard, & The Field of the Cloth of Gold
Transcript
welcome to john gets games this is a new good games vlog that i am recording live and today i'll be discussing my initial impressions for fairy tale inn navigator shipyard and the field of the cloth of gold i would like to ask that if you enjoyed this video that you please click the like button for it down below as well as the subscribe button and i also want to mention that i will be putting out a podcast version of this vlog later on and you can find that by searching for the john gets games podcast wherever you normally listen to podcasts the last thing i'd like to say is that if you enjoy watching vlogs like this that you consider uh directly supporting the channel by going to patreon.com john gets games there are a bunch of ways that you can really help things out over there and some of them give perks like watching some videos early and advertisement free as well as voting on some of those videos so with that in mind let's now go ahead and start things off uh the first game is going to be fairytale in and this one is a very recent publication i only learned about this one on twitter a few weeks ago i saw some photos of it popping up and you'll see those very soon the big thing about this game though is that uh well i guess i should just show the photo now because that is the big thing about this game this looks like connect four which is a game that i played a ton when i was a kid and i think a lot of people probably have as well but in particular this looks like a more complicated connect four because you have this plastic device in between you and your one opponent and then you are sliding tokens down in various columns but instead of these being uh like you know red and black tokens and you're
trying to connect four and line instead you are going to be trying to connect various uh tokens in different colors to get victory points so it's kind of like connect for the euro at least that is how i i thought it was at the start uh after looking into it a little bit i immediately bought a copy of it off the board gamegeek marketplace i received a copy and i played it twice in a row just a couple of days ago now let's talk a little bit more about the mechanics before i talk about my impressions of it um in this game there are uh eight different fairy tale um characters that you can choose from and you always grab five of them randomly out of those eight then there are these little square tokens for each and there is a colored side on one and a kind of uh black and white version or i guess a penciled in version on the other side you shuffle all these up inside a bag and then you reveal four of them onto a market out on the board now on your turn you have to take one of these tiles and then slide it down one of the columns in the middle of this device in the middle of the table that again looks just like a connect four game and the tile that you take will either be free or you might actually have to spend one or two coins depending on where that tile is on this sliding market now coins are victory points that's how you win the game you want to have the most of these so if you're spending one or two coins you're spending one or two victory points to place those tiles now once you place a tile down the rest of the tiles slide on this market so they get cheaper as time goes on which is a tried and true incentivization mechanic where the new stuff costs more stuff in this case it costs victory points
now each one of these different characters has a card associated with them and those explain the specific details of what those characters do uh some of them have an ongoing effect for example the evil queen um has a kind of negative effect for your opponent if you put an evil queen down and they put a token on top they have to pay you a point or a coin which is obviously bad now this actually brings me to an interesting point because in connect four which i keep coming back to the tokens are the same on either side but in this one you have a full color version and a penciled version and when you drop these tokens down you make the full colored version towards yourself this way you can easily tell as the game goes on which of these tokens you put down in which your opponent put down and that's very important because like i said that evil queen will force your opponent to pay you a victory point if they put a token immediately on top of that and you have to know who's evil queen that is now there are other types like for example the princess that has a immediate effect when you drop it down and the princess in this case gives you one coin and then you get additional coins for every other princess on the diagonal so uh placing a princess in a spot could give you multiple other coins um in this first game that i took a photo of i got a lot of points for princesses i got a bunch of them on the diagonal and those coins were really great i mean coins are victory points and also coins are good for having better control over which tiles you want to take from the marketplace now the last type of tile are endgame ones um in the picture example here we have the big bad wolf and i believe uh pinocchio
yeah uh and uh for the big bad wolf you just get three extra coins if you have the most of the big bad wolves facing you on each row so you have a little bit of a competition there and then the pinocchios get you extra coins at the end of the game for each of your opponents tokens that are there um so for example there is a pinocchio that my opponent played and i have three of my tokens next to it which means that pinocchio gave my opponent three coins at the end of the game so you want you have to be wary about putting your own tokens next to pinocchio's of your opponent now as i said every time you play the game you take five random of these uh different characters so that means you're going to have different mixes of these different types and we played this game once and then immediately took the three that we didn't have in the first game uh put those aside and then shuffled up the other ones and pulled two more out so over the course of those two games we got to see everything and um myself and my friend mike really enjoyed this game and were surprised at how thinking it was because from a theming perspective you know it's fairy tales it's the princess there's a the three little pigs in pinocchio it seems very light and easy going but the decisions here are not or at least not all the time uh there were many uh uh turns where i just looked at the tokens in the market and i just really had a hard time figuring out where i would go that wouldn't help my opponent out more than me because you're thinking about like the big bad wolf majority if that one's in the game you're thinking about well i really want to put this here but it's next to my opponent's pinocchio and that's going to give them a coin and this is a two-player only game so you have to constantly think about that competition like it's not like it's a three-player game where you have one
person but another this one you really have to pay attention to those things and also on top of that the actual plastic board that you're playing in has various bonuses um you might get extra coins for dropping a token in a certain spot you might be able to spend a coin to take as a bonus turn which can be really impactful taking two turns in a row although you do have to spend a victory point and there are these two spots right in the middle that actually negate the powers of those locations they're very um centralized locations so that makes sense and so this is just more stuff that you have to think about while you are considering all of the stuff that's going on so um overall i have been really impressed with this game i don't generally play two-player games all that much but the the connect four-ness of this one caused me to go out and get a copy of it and realistically the only weakness that i see in this game is the fact that there are eight characters and you choose five of them each game uh in our case we didn't go random for the second game we intentionally pulled out the other um three so that we could see all of them over the course of those two games but now that i've played it twice with all of those i've seen all of the characters but i haven't seen how they all mixed together for example there is the pied piper and jack and the beanstalk both of which let you put two tokens down instead of one and in our second game we had both of those out which meant the board got a lot uh more full a lot quicker because we were putting out double tokens frequently because of how that worked and i could see um a game with a whole bunch of the end game scoring ones being quite interesting where in the middle of the game you're not really getting much but at the end you have a huge payout and yeah i was just really impressed uh i was at first thinking maybe this is a game i could play
with uh friends and some of their children but after getting about halfway through one game of this we realized that um there was i don't know too much going on uh to play this uh certainly with my friend's uh seven-year-old daughter uh at least um that we felt that way in that situation i'm sure some seven-year-olds might be able to uh figure it out i mean mechanically it's fine you just take the thing slide it down but the um the way all of these things intermingle all of the strategy and whatnot um was was much deeper than i expected so this is one i really don't see getting rid of i guess i do want to say the other issue with this game is the size of the box uh for a two-player game that only takes 15 to 20 minutes to play it's a rather large size box i think it's a ticket to ride size box so that takes up a lot of space on the shelf but it also can't be that much smaller because of this plastic device that actually holds all of the tokens so maybe it could be a little bit thinner but honestly not a whole lot thinner than the box actually is so i do have to keep that into consideration as well but the nostalgia of the connect 4 part of my brain that loved that game when i was a kid combined with all of the wonderful decisions that are combined here means i do think this is a game i'm gonna be keeping um for probably the long run i'll try to find space for it in my collection uh this is one that i hope to play more in the future certainly as a two-player filler type experience um you know from waiting for somebody else to finish a game and there's a couple of us i could easily teach this game in you know five minutes to uh most of the people i play games with and then play the game in 15 to 20. so that that means it's very flexible to be fit into those circumstances and
you know the size of the box means i am probably more likely to actually see it on the shelf compared to some of the other smaller two-player games that i have so yeah that's essentially everything i have to say about fairy tale inn i'm looking forward to playing it more i'm looking forward to finding opportunities to play it more i just think it's aesthetically really cool it's got a bunch of great decisions in there as well and i guess that isn't too surprising considering uh the designer of this game or one of the designers is paolo mori and he's made a lot of games that i really enjoy so uh big thumbs up for me for fairy tale and i'm really glad i purchased a copy of this one all right the next game we have is navigator and um this is a very different experience this is a two to five player game um that takes 60 to 90 minutes to play or so and the main reason that i'm playing this game is because i am in the process of getting ready to do a top 10 uh rondelle games list i'm hoping to do that in a week or two and so i've been doing a bit of research to try and fill out um all of the rondelle games that i've been meaning to play for years but never quite got to uh navigator was at the top of the list honestly this is a matt gertz designed game and he has designed many games that have the rondelle mechanic in it which is essentially a circular usually clockwise action selection system um so navigator is one that lots of people said oh i gotta try and i've never actually got around to playing it so i made that happen i played a game of this one with my friends i think it was a three-player game and i played this one about a week or so ago now um before i even tell you how the game works i want to start by saying
i really like this game uh i i was very impressed with it and i've already started to uh put my finger into the wind to see if i can uh get a copy of it for a reasonable price it doesn't seem like it's crazy expensive but either way let's talk about how navigator works before i talk about what i thought a little bit more now as you can see there is a board in the middle of the table and you have a bunch of ocean spaces kind of going around africa and all the way over to india and the key part of this game is the rondelle which is again a circular action selection uh mechanic and this one is right in the middle of the board now in this game each player has a single pawn and on your turn you have to move that pawn forward at least one space and you have to go clockwise around the rondelle which is a pretty standard thing in these type of games and you can move forward up to three spaces for free without spending anything or you can move even farther than that by spending stuff and i won't talk about what you spend but in general the stuff that you spend is worth points at the end of the game at least one point i believe so you want to pay attention to that so usually you're trying to move just one to three spaces around this and then you perform the action of the spot where you landed and you can land where other people are that's just fine um there's no benefit or a penalty for that now as far as what you're doing with these actions out on the board everybody has ships at least at the start of the game over here in portugal and there is a sailing action which lets you move these ships along these sea routes there is also a worker action that you can go to and this one actually lets you purchase workers which you slide down this track to show how many workers you have there is also a market action which i'll
talk about in a minute after that there is the colonize action and this uh interacts with the ships in a pretty interesting way when you move these ships around there are these stacks of tokens next to each of the regions and when you do a colony action you are going to be able to take colony tokens from the specific region where you have the ships you have to have enough ships and you have to have enough workers i won't talk about the details of that but you need to have both of those and if you have lots of ships and lots of workers then you might be able to get even more of these things now these colony tokens will give you the ability to make various things like sugar and gold and those are important for the market phase which again i'll talk about soon now there's also this um privilege spot and this lets you take these privileged tiles from a market on the board and this is a really cool part of the game because specifically you take these tiles and you place them down on your own player board everyone has their own board and these are going to customize your end game scoring conditions now this vaguely reminded me of concordia which is also designed by mackerz uh navigator came out first but much like in concordia as you were playing this game one of the actions that you take is going to change your endgame multiplier for the stuff you do for example if you take the colony uh privilege tokens and you put those down you will increase the number of victory points you get at the end of the game for your colonies in this example i currently have four colonies and i have a modifier of two for the uh privilege so that means at the end of the game i would get eight points and a spoiler alert in this game i got all four of the colony privileges and i ended with 15 colonies so i had 15 times four or
uh 45 victory points just from the colonies alone that was obviously my big strategy that i pushed now there are other things that you can do like the shipping action which lets you make more ships over in portugal which you can then set sail around and there is also the building spot where you can construct various factories as well as shipyards which help you build more ships and church churches yeah which let you build uh or make more people at least for a cheaper rate now i did mention i come back to the markets and um you know there's i should actually talk about shipping a little bit more just a little bit more on these shipping spots there are these um blue spots which are exploration tokens and the first time you move into one of these locations you have to come in with two ships and um one of those ships just disappears and you also take that exploration token which could be worth victory points to at the end of the game based off of the privilege that you have so this is one of the reason you have to make more ships because if you are the first one right out at the front exploring you'll get victory points for those ships but the ships will go away and you have to kind of make more behind now let's talk about the market and again i'm going into too much detail about this game already but i'll try to briefly talk about the most interesting part of this game and that is that when you go to the market each of your colonies can make the associated goods or for that type of good you can use the factories in order to essentially i guess make some of that good i think you i guess you make it in the colonies and then you process it in the factories thematically something like that um either way when you make the good from your colonies that will give you money based off of where that token is and then the token
will drop for the number of colonies you used or if you do the factories instead then you will get a number of money that gets bigger as the token goes down and then the token will go back up again so in this example i got two gold colonies and i had two gold factories which i guess is maybe not the right thing to do in retrospect it seems like maybe you want to specialize in one or the other although i did win the game no no i lost on the tiebreaker i lost on the tiebreaker but either way i could either push this token down twice because of my colonies or push this token up twice because i have these two factories okay that gets you money and then you you need money to do all these other things and that is a rough idea of what you're doing in navigator and at this point i should talk about what i actually think about it now i was super impressed by this game because this is a very elegant euro gaming experience where everything kind of folds back in on itself and i just love it seeing those different things as you're going around this wheel you are going to be setting sail and obviously sailing is going to let you explore which will give you points for the tokens and position you well for going to the colony action to pick up those colonies so sailing leads into other actions then you also have the workers which you need to have in order to go to these colonies and you also need workers to construct buildings so that dovetails into other actions that you need and then obviously the colony action gets you colonies which you then use in these market spots to get money which dovetails into having money so you can spend it on all of these other things so you are just going to be going around and around here and i just love how each thing enables the next thing to a certain extent and
the decision space of how fast and slow do you want to go around here is really interesting uh for the first half of this game i went incredibly slow i stopped it almost every single action along the way while my opponents were just zipping zipping zipping around and i was worried i remember thinking am i playing wrong in this instance this was my first time playing it and the two people i played against had played it several times but then when i got to the later parts of the game i realized that zipping around the rondelle was going to be better for me so not that i was doing it badly in the beginning but you want to go at different speeds based off of what you want to be doing in the game not necessarily slow in the beginning and fast at the end just slow when slow is right and fast when fast is right and trying to figure out when to do these things is really you know the crux of the game i suppose i should mention one other mechanical thing and that is this navigator ship token that's over here on the rondelle you can't see it in this image but there's a navigator token and one person has this token and if they go all the way around this wheel without using that token they will lose it and this token gives you a free sailing action so you can stop at the sailing spot to sail and you can use this free sailing action from the navigator token and this is just a gentle way for the game to push people to sail more you don't have to go to the sailing spot and when you use it this goes counterclockwise around the table which again kind of reminds me of concordia again i have a good door came out earlier but you can definitely see some uh through lines of the design so that was just another really interesting thing that i had to keep in mind and i definitely had trouble with that in this game i kept forgetting that my opponents could do a free sale action
and then something else there were two or three times in the game where the person immediately before me um or i guess well a person before my next turn did a free sale action and then colonized and took the colonies that i was setting up to get remember i ended the game with 15 colonies so that was the thing i really pushed and i still ended up beating that player so that felt good but in the moment i kept saying ah i need to remember that there's a navigator token people can have free ship actions you have to keep that in mind so overall i just felt like it was a really uh smart experience it felt like a bit of a classic i mean it's um let's see here it came out in 2010 so it's 11 years old um so that is definitely a factor uh concordia i think came out more in 2014 15 something like that um so i love the classic feel obviously it looks like a classic game the art style is not amazing from it but i have an affinity to this kind of stuff as well and i just loved trying to piece together these turns there were many moments where i got i was just super excited to try and pull the thing off and hoping that my opponents didn't get in my way and it was also really cool to see how different strategies could go well as i said i lost on the tiebreaker with a whole bunch of points i don't remember exactly but it was not a small amount it was kind of surprising we had a tie and the person who won the game on the tiebreaker had like two colonies but they had a ton of factories and a ton of these exploration tokens so in that game they built this huge fleet of um ships they built some shipyards to make that happen and they pushed forward grabbing exploration token after exploration token and i came behind them with a few ships
and i just kept picking up colonies so i went this whole game i think i built one ship the entire game maybe two um i did explore it twice so that was a factor but i just kind of went in their wake they kept exploring things and i kept just hoovering up as many colonies as i could and it was really cool to see that when the dust settled we had a tie score so we both did very different things and um hypothetically did them well and came to a good spot so navigator is a game that i do want to play again i i thought that um the the way everything worked i mean realistically nothing bugged me about this game i i want to explore this one more for sure i can see why a lot of people mention it as one of their top euro games and right now i've only played it once so i don't want to be um you know i have to understand that i have a kind of a honeymoon effect with the game but i am very enamored with it and i don't want to say like this is my favorite euro game at this point but i think this one could easily push into a top 10 uh overall games list for me with a few more plays just to make sure that i do actually like it as much as i did in the first blush uh and i do think you know a big part of that is because i desire to see elegant euros and there aren't that many of them coming out these days or at least that doesn't seem to be the push so playing an elegant euro that came out 11 years ago just kind of reminded me of the euros that i really like and um made me want to see even more of these and want to play even more games like this so yeah i am hoping to get a copy of navigator at some point i have a big collection of games already so i have to keep in mind that if i get this i'll probably have to get rid of something else but either way
i'll see how that goes and um overall i'm very happy that i'm doing this top 10 rondelle list because it forced me to finally play this game all right let's see i just want to check real quick to see if there's any comments related to this or the last game uh oh uh somebody asked if i looked into endeavor i've actually played endeavor before and i'm pretty sure i covered my initial impressions of that one specifically of the second edition i played the first edition as well so you could search for that in my impressions vlogs if you want to find me talk about that one let's see here
matt asked how this one compares to concordia um now both navador and concordia obviously are designed by the same designer and they they're both very elegant euro games so there is that to keep in mind where you know everything kind of dovetails together but they felt like very different games to me uh concordia has you um you know putting out houses on the map you are getting uh production for those specific houses there's extra costs based off of where people are like in this game there's no penalty for being where somebody is i mean you kind of want to move your ships along and grab colonies before your opponents do but there isn't that territory acquisition feel to it and the things that you get victory points at the end of the game uh for are the colonies that you take the factories that you have the exploration tokens that you grab the shipyards that you made and the churches that you have made so obviously these are all things that you want to do anyway and you probably want to maybe go hard on one or two of these things to do well and in concordia you usually want to find a thing or two that you do well at as well like maybe you go hard on saturn or really uh really push towards jupiter or something like that but i feel like there's a lot more well there's a lot more endgame score customization in concordia every single card that you take in concordia has a end game scoring condition on it whereas in this game there's just one action spot that you swing by every time you go around the rondelle to pick up one of these things and when you do that when you plunk that token down you do get a cash payout for how you are doing so that's nice but for the most part this is a
uh end game victory point action whereas in concordia when you get those end conditional end game points they're attached to cards that are also actions that you can do so in this game it often felt like i should stop and do a privilege action i could use some more money but man i'd really like to do a market or a build action instead because it feels like you have to kind of pause and grab those victory points and then push forward now that's not always the case because you can get money for putting these down but i think that's a pretty significant difference um also in concordia you're obviously customizing your hand of actions that you were doing whereas in this game the rondelle is always exactly the same so they you know again concordia is more of a territory acquisition feel like it isn't a majority style game but it has more of that going on whereas this one felt more like a comboy situation i mean you have to combo things in concordia as well if you go really high up you can certainly find some uh similarities but i could easily see owning this one and concordia at the same time and playing them for different reasons i will say that i think concordia will probably play faster than this one our three player game probably took close to two hours maybe an hour a little over an hour and a half somewhere in between there i think i had some pretty big analysis paralysis moments as i was trying to grapple with things to do and i could certainly see this one going faster but i do think concordia is a faster experience overall oh yeah steven mentioned that um the market is very different in this uh game as well and that's that's a really good point uh the market is a huge part of this game in particular because when you do a market action first of all there's two market action spots on the rondelle
and we do this action you're modifying the marker for other players that means you can easily set somebody up for a huge payout or you could do something that will really hurt the amount of money they're going to get and i guess the oh my gosh i can't remember the name is flying out of my head the the thing that you do to produce regions in concordia my gosh i play concordia like 20 times where you could produce and everyone else can as well um when you do that action it will affect other people and sometimes somebody will be upset that you did that before they were going to do something else but this market mechanic it doesn't feel all that similar to concordia so that definitely makes this one feel different um steven says i wonder if there's a team variant that would work for navigator like it works well in concordia um i'm not so sure i mean i mean maybe in the team version of concordia which is concordia venus you play a card and then do actions and then your partner across the table has to do that exact same action i guess in navigator you could move on the rondelle and then your partner would have to do the exact same one but a big part of venus is also not really knowing what's in your partner's hand exactly and trying to figure all that stuff out whereas this is an open information game there is nothing hidden i'm not saying a team version of navi or navigator wouldn't work but um my first gut instinct is that um it'd probably work a lot better in concordia all right um oh one more thing uh steven says there is an expansion for navigator that adds in one-time use cards that you
can grab with your privilege it's pretty good oh that's cool so the privilege again is the action that lets you uh get the conditional scoring uh i just said you get money but if there's an expansion where when you do privilege you also get a one-time bonus that would incentivize that more although i do have to admit that it didn't seem like the privilege needed that much incentivizing um within each of the games three acts i didn't talk about that but there's kind of like there's act one act two and act three uh you refill this privilege board and there's not that many of these tokens so um when we actually got near the end of the second act of the game there was no privilege and it was actually interesting because the privilege rondelle action spot felt like a speed bump because we couldn't do anything there was no privileges to even grab so you had to kind of get over it to do the things that you wanted to do which was kind of cool parts of the game you just wanted to stop at privilege in other parts it was just kind of a hindrance and it was in the way i would certainly not shy away from trying uh that expansion though that sounds cool all right let's now move on to the next game which is shipyard now this one much like navigator uh is uh was played by me because of research for the top 10 rondelle games list that i'm still putting together uh this one was also right there at the top of the list of games that i was told i really should play before i make that list and this one is uh was designed by vladimir suhi now this one came out in 2009 so a similar time period to navigator when that wing came out um and uh vladimir tsuki uh is probably most famous for doing uh last will or maybe underwater cities these days that was a really good game that was a pretty big hit for them uh so i am a fan of essentially every uh
one of their games that i've played so that made me also quite excited to try out shipyard it's a two to four player game that takes about 120 minutes to play and we played a i think it was a four-player game uh yeah it was a four-player game uh so shipyard is an interesting game and i was told specifically i had to play this one because it's not just a rondelle game it's a game that has like what one two three four four to five rondelles based off of how you want to uh define what a rondelle is so i figured i had to play it like most games have one rondelle if they have any and this one just has rondelles everywhere uh now mechanically i'll try to go maybe a little bit more high level with this one i went into the weeds too much with navigator mechanically in this game there is this action market essentially a track around the middle of the table with these action tokens on them and each player has a pawn now play goes clockwise around the table and when it's your turn you are going to move the spot where your pawn is and the action on it all the way to the front of the line and then you will move your pawn to an action that's currently open and then do that action so right off the bat um this one um this is arguably uh a rondelle although it really depends on how into the weeds you want to get because you're kind of going clockwise but either way it's a circular action selection type of system i don't know if i would consider it a rondelle but it does mean that when you go to an action that means somebody else can't do that action until you leave that action to do something else so it almost has more of a worker placement vibe where the incentivization for the spots changes because when you place a token
down you get one uh money for every pawn that is ahead of you so the farther back you go the more money you get but if a token is far back that means people have probably been avoiding that token so it might be less good in the particular moment or maybe it's a great situation where it's good for you and not good for your opponents now that's one of the rondelles and out here on the table there is another one there's actually a rondelle within a rondelle and each of these is associated with the various actions here on the board up here the one of these actions lets you move a token around this green rondelle which is going to give you access to propellers as well as potentially people who are going to be going onto your ships and it occurs to me i've already in the weeds on mechanics i should talk about the broad vibe for this game in this game it's called shipyard you're going to be building ships in your shipyard and then you are going to be setting sail with them and trying to get a bunch of points for them so you are constructing these ships piece by piece on your player area and um there's a whole bunch of uh things that you can do um your ships are first of all kind of a puzzle you have to put them down and once you place them you can't move them and the size of your ships is going to affect the amount of stuff you can do with them um you can put you need to have captains on them you can put sails which will help you move um you can also add cranes which will help you potentially get victory points and various other icons and all of these things are tokens um the pieces of the ship are tokens the various uh laborers that you can put on the ship are tokens the sales are tokens this game has a lot of different tokens
compared to the navigator which you know just had money i guess and i guess those those uh buildings that were on the table but this one has just piles and piles of tokens now these tokens are again associated with rondelles uh you have a green rondelle which will give you some people or uh propeller and then a brown one around the outside which could give you things like cranes guns and steam stacks and that kind of thing now when you do these actions you're going to move around these rondelles and you can move one space for free or you could spend i believe money it's been a couple weeks since i played this one to go farther clockwise around to get the thing that you want um there is another rondelle where you can move this token around in order to pick up employees which will give you um essentially powers that you have for the rest of the game uh conditional things where when you do this you get that bonus or every time you do this one thing another thing happens so it really intensifies doing things for example in um this game um i had a hidden goal i won't really talk about the hidden goals too much but when the game is over these are things you can reveal to get bonus points i had a hidden goal to have a bunch of captains on my ship so i guess after one captain they're called officers so i picked up an employee that said every time i moved on the green rondelle every time i did an action there i would get a captain so what that means is in this game i tried to do that action as often as i could and sometimes i picked up a captain and then a bonus one for my employee other times i picked up things like a propeller and i got a captain because of that employee tile that i had now another thing in this game is these train cars which you can acquire through actions and then you can also spend these tokens to get a variety of
money as well as other tokens uh from this rondelle we're going to be moving a pawn around so as you can see there's just so many of these rondelles and for each of them this is different from navigator because they are neutral rondelle ponds i move this pawn and then it stays there for my next person's turn so that means in this game there are lots of times where you want to do an action you're kind of planning around it and then somebody moves that pond and you're like wait ah now it's gonna be crazy expensive to go all the way back around and you have to maybe alter your plan or just spend a bunch of money speaking of bunny this game has an interesting thing where you have this kind of incentivized work replacement e tracky kind of thing in the middle but every turn you can spend six of your money in order to immediately take a second action and it can be any of these actions so that means there is blocking where somebody can take the action you want but if you have money then you can get around that and say you know what somebody you know maybe did the take pieces of the ship action and i really need to do that right now well i'll just spend six money and then do that as well taking these pieces of the ship is another action and i think the last mechanic i want to briefly mention are these canal tokens another one of these actions lets you pick up these canal tokens and the cost for doing these things is printed with numbers and these canals are going to be placed in your own area and you can kind of stack them next to each other and you have this single boat now whenever you do a boat building action and you finish a boat which means you have a front you have a back and all the pieces in the middle the boat is immediately going to set sail um when that happens you are going to get victory points for a whole bunch of stuff the various tokens that you have littered all over
your boat um and your boat is going to move depending on these tokens and you will actually move this token on your canal tiles and you will gain bonuses for the icons that you move on to or move past you can get multiple of these canal tiles next to each other to try and set up a long track if you're going to be moving a bunch or you might make a gigantic ship that barely moves and that's fine but this is just one more thing that you have to pay attention to you have to build your ship you want to have the right tokens to score things that you want and you have to make sure there's a good canal for you to move on as well as as one that has icons that will give you extra benefits so hopefully this should give you an idea that there's just a lot going on in this game there's a lot of tokens there's a lot of mechanics and from a high level perspective i do feel like the mechanics are pretty elegant with the way they uh they tail into each other uh specifically you know you need these canals in order to sail on them you need these ship tokens to actually build out that ship but in a game that has so many different tokens um i do have a hard time calling it elegant i'm not sure if it really deserves that moniker uh we'll stop to see maybe if i play this one some more i've only played this one on tabletop simulator and i can only imagine the piles of steam tokens of crane tokens of captains and um you know uh workers and propellers and all this stuff just kind of scattered all around the table it just seems like a lot that's going to be out there now speaking of the word a lot when you are thinking about what you're going to do on this game there is a lot to think about and i did enjoy this game i'll say right now that i enjoyed this one less than navigator but i did enjoy this game because the uh
specifically because the puzzle of piecing together these ships was just a lot of fun uh it was a cool thing to see the different spots that you need you may not notice but these tokens have different little graphical things on them like maybe life preservers or lanterns and um these are things that can give you conditional points if you have lantern spots or like preserver spots over here on your canal tiles so you are not only trying to extend your ship out so you can put more people and cranes and that kind of thing on it but you also want to match these icons to the canals that you have and again in order to get all these things you are going to be performing actions to buy them from various markets or you could also go here and spend the rail cars that you purchased to get the various different things it's one of those games where you can get where you need to go from a wide variety of ways and figuring out the best way to get there is the crux of the game now i did mention that each player has these end game scoring tiles at the beginning of the game you get three of them and at a certain point you have to discard two of each type so you will end the game with just one and this really is where the strategy of the game comes into play you need to play towards these i definitely did with the one that was all about having lots of captains and my opponents did as well um hey i think i lost this game by a couple of points um which was kind of interesting because in this game i went for really big ships i had a goal card which i'm not showing here that said i wanted to have i believe two or maybe three ships that were size seven or larger i think that's what it was so i was making these really big ships whereas another one of my opponents um which isn't really on screen here but they tried to make tiny ships they had
like six or seven ships at the very end of the game another opponent was just making nine size ships which is i think as large as they can go not necessarily because of a goal but just they just were having fun building gigantic ships and of course they spent you know half the game putting together one size nine ship but then when they scored it they got so many points because it was just covered in different things i do want to mention that when you are putting these ships together you don't have to commit these different tokens they can kind of live over here in a nebulous space in your shipyard area and it's only when you complete that ship and set sail you have to decide but you can obviously think about it as the game is going on so overall i enjoyed this game not as much as navigator i think mostly because there was just so many things to consider that it kind of made my brain get a little bit murky um you have to consider how far the ship is going to be going based off of the different tokens you have if you have a propeller and a smoke stack you'll actually go even farther and it increases the return rate you get for movement on various steam stacks there's just all these icons on your player board which are great they do help teach the game well and explain the victory points that you get for all of these things but man it's it's a little overwhelming the amount of things that you can consider with all of these options and i do also have to admit that there were a few times when playing this game especially later on where it was my turn and i had a hard time finding an action that i wanted to do it seemed like specifically these employees later on in the game didn't feel like a great option for your turn because you might not get that much benefit out of them although some of these do give victory points again i only play this game once so maybe i'm being dominant it's always
good to take these employees i'm not really sure but it did seem like there were many turns where the tough decision was not um oh my gosh i have so many things i want to do it was more what's actually going to be good for me this turn and i feel like you know i keep comparing this to navigator because i just played that as well in that game it was more often i want to do all of these things how badly do i want do you want to do every single one of them as i slowly go around to the rondelle or is it worth skipping over this thing that i want to do so that i'm faster to get around to the other things whereas in this game there were frequent moments where i said eh that's not very good that's not very good that's not very good okay which of these do i like the most of these options that aren't that great and maybe that's just me putting myself in a position that's not great but um those moments didn't really sour the mood it's just kind of a different mental perspective and again i only play this game once so maybe that's a rare thing that just kind of happened because of groupthink that we had at our table yeah so that is essentially my feeling on shipyard i don't think i'm gonna try to go out and buy a copy of this one but i would not turn down playing uh playing it again our four-player game i think took around two hours which is not bad for a euro game of this overall kind of weight and uh i'm really happy that i got to play it and i do think it is going to make the top 10 list um because uh specifically the rondelles were fun i mean just rondelles after rondelle's somebody moves a neutral rondelle in a position you don't like well maybe you move a different one because there's so many of them to choose from and it's really cool to see how all that works especially in an older game i mean i guess 2009 isn't that old but as far as looking into researching all these rondelles it doesn't seem like
that mechanic was made all that recently or all that long ago i think um it depends on your definition but i think ntk is maybe considered to be the first rondelle game and i think that one came out in like 2005 so just a few years prior to this so this game was like i see a rondelle and i'm going to multiply it by four or five and see where we go and where you go is a pretty cool game all right uh steven says there is a circular action track like shipyard and craft wagon that also is a hybrid rondelle takaido type time track uh yeah i actually um i've played craft wagon i think i gave it to a friend i think it's in my local friend group i played that one a couple times i really liked it but i have a hard time uh thinking that that's a rondelle and that's something i've been thinking about a lot for this top 10 list that's going to be coming out soon i think i need to define what i think a rondelle is at the very beginning of that video and i'm still trying to figure that out um i think the time trackiness of that pushes it in a direction that i don't feel really lines up with the rondelle as much but you know that's going to be a personal preference type thing i've really been going back and forth as to whether i want to put craft wagon onto that top 10 list at this moment i'm shifting towards not putting it on the list but we'll just have to see um al johnson says this sounds like navigator is an easier teach than shipyard would you agree um yeah probably um i didn't teach you either of these games that's worth noting both of them were taught to me by friends who had already played these uh we have a discord channel and i
i put in there like does anybody know shipyard does anybody know navigator can anybody teach me these games that i can play them for the top 10 list and fortunately both of those were games that my friends had played and wanted to uh play again um i do think that from a teach perspective uh yeah shipyard has a whole bunch of nooks and crannies for rules like how does this rondelle work how does that rondelle work how does the ship scoring work how does putting the ships together work um you know how does uh you know the canal scoring work and how does the canals go together there's just a lot of little nooks and crannies and a lot of tokens that you have to talk about whereas in navigator there's just less tokens to discuss and for the most part it seems like it's a more streamlined experience again i haven't taught either of them but i think if you were to ask me which one i would prefer to teach i would probably say navigator uh yeah so that is shipyard maybe i'll get to play this one again in the future again i certainly wouldn't say no to it but i'm not uh burning my way towards uh getting a copy of it it's a fine game it's a fine game but uh not as fun as navigator i think all right let's now move on to the fourth game that i'll be talking about today and that one is the field of the cloth of gold now this is a relatively new game it came out last year uh and it's a two player only game and this is a really fascinating game from a thematic perspective um the uh short version of a longer story is that 500 years ago as of last june that was the 500 year anniversary there was this massive like two-week party
where the king of england and i believe the king of france essentially tried to one-up each other spending just incredible amounts of money on stuff trying to see who could spend the most money so that would mean they were you know a bigger person or something like that and supposedly they you know spent significant portions of the royal treasury on like a two-week party which is just crazy and that's just a fun theme perspective to start off with and i actually almost bought this game last year i remember reading the uh the blog article that was uh written that came along with it and being fascinated by it and um this one is being published by holland spiel and at that point i was not really familiar with holland spiel as a publisher i knew they were a print-on-demand publisher but that's pretty much all i knew and i remembered thinking that i didn't really want to spend the amount of money that it was plus the shipping cost just for this game so i kind of put it on the back burner uh but um subsequently over the last year i've become a big fan of train games which is something that holland build does a decent amount and um there was a moment uh just about a month ago where an expansion to dual gauge came out and i knew i wanted to buy that and i was like okay this is the moment where i'm going to buy the field of the cloth of gold because it'll um integrate the uh the shipping cost make that lower overall and i remember hearing a bunch of people say that they really enjoyed this game last year like it looked interesting but hearing that people actually enjoyed playing it was you know certainly enough to push me even more now this is a quick game it's only listed as two players sorry 20 minutes and it is uh it was designed by emma bell holland um and i i believe
she said in that article that um she designed it over the course of like one month like she realized that the anniversary was like a month or two away and was like oh crap i've been meaning to make this game for years and uh just made this game really quickly and that is something to keep in mind that you know some games get made very quickly and some games don't and if a game is made very quickly it's probably going to be on the shorter side when it comes to rules and that is certainly the case with this game now what you have in the middle of the table is a player board kind of a cloth mat that you put out here and then there is this action track along the top now this is a two player only game as i said and each player has two of these action tokens and then you have a victory point token down over here now um on your turn what you're going to do is select one of your pawns and you're going to move it to one of the two or sometimes three empty spots that are out here on the board so in this example if i was the red player i could move this token to this white action spot over here or i can move it onto this secret spot over there those are my only two action options and i must move so i have to go onto one of those two spots with one of my red action tokens now after i go onto that spot you'll notice there is a token directly underneath those specific locations and what i have to do is take that token and give it to my opponent as i said thematically this game is all about two kings trying to out give each other and so in this game mechanically you are literally giving each other tokens back and forth every single turn every turn of the game you were going to give a token to your opponent so you have to keep in mind
what you want to give them obviously this is a competitive experience so you probably want to give them something that's not going to help them out but you know you only have these two options and you have to keep that in mind now another big part of this game is the fact that when you go to an action spot you are forced to take that action and you don't necessarily always want to do that and with that in mind i'm now going to briefly talk about these actions because there's really not that many of them let's skip the dragon for the moment and start with this secrecy token now when you go onto this action spot you look down to the victory point track and you'll find your token and then the row that it's on will dictate the number of random tiles that you will take out of the bag and then you'll keep those face down in front of you you can look at them but your opponent doesn't get to see them so what that means is as you score more victory points in this game you actually get more tiles out of the bag for this action at the very beginning of the game that actually gets you one tile but if you have 24 points that actually is going to get you three tiles out of the bag so that's a big deal obviously if you have 32 or more points well you don't get any tiles out of the bag because once a player hits 30 points the game ends so that's why there's no icon there so this action is generally one you don't want to not do having tiles is good for the most part this next action lets you score if you have the most gold in front of you and when you go to this action you must reveal all gold tiles from your hidden area and put them face up but your opponent does not have the ability to reveal any and then if you have more gold than they do you get two victory points so that means if you have the tight amount or you have less then you don't get any points and it's possible you go onto the spot and nothing actually
happens but what that means is having a bunch of gold is good the name of the game is the field of the cloth of gold so that does make sense the next one is a blue banner and this one will score for your banquets which are which are these blue tiles now for this one you will immediately score one three or six victory points if you have one two three of these tiles or more if you have five tiles you'll still score the six points and then you lose all of your blue tiles so um for this action you actually don't get to keep these tiles the gold one you do keep the blue one you do not and that's important to note um now after that there is the white one and this one is similar you get one point for every white piety uh token you have in front of you and then you lose all of your white tiles so again you want to probably score this when you have some of these but then you do lose access to them so you can't keep scoring them after that i'm actually going to skip over the red action and go to this one at the very end because this one i forget the theming of it but this one lets you score for sets you get two victory points for every set of the four different types of tiles that you have and then you keep those tiles so this is why these lose tile actions are sometimes something you don't want to do if you are building yourself up to have a few sets that you can try to do this action over and over again being forced to go here and lose all of your white tiles is terrible because that means you don't have any sets anymore if you lose all of your white tiles but you have everything else you have zero sets and that's a big thing to consider when you look at this red action here because this one is a little more interactive the red tiles are tournament tiles and when you do this one you are going to reveal the tiles from your hand i didn't mention it but for the blue and the white as well as this one over here you are
going to be revealing specific tiles from your hand and the red one you reveal red and then each player is going to participate in a tournament which technically means you just get one point for every red tile you have in front of you which means your opponent might score points on your turn now what happens after that is you both lose all of your red tiles so what that means is if somebody is building up a bunch of these sets and you are worried about that well maybe you'll go over here and perform a tournament which forces them to discard their red tiles so they lose access to those sets so they cannot score a bunch of points from this spot anymore now the last part of this action is the fact that each player then does a secrecy action so that means it's potentially my turn and i do a tournament to break up your sets well now we both are going to draw tiles from the bag and it's possible that um your opponent when you do this action is going to draw more tiles out of the bag than you will because maybe they have more victory points in that moment than you do so that's something you have to consider now the very last action is the dragon and when you go here you're going to put this neutral dragon token down and then you will gift the token that's underneath it and you will not perform the action above it and this is important because again sometimes you don't want to perform the action so you can use that dragon to gift the token that you want that maybe doesn't help your opponent out very well while also dodging having to do an action that's potentially devastating towards the strategy that you're trying to put together now that's essentially the game you're going to keep playing until all of the tiles come out of the bag or until any one player has 30 or more victory points and then for end game scoring you just have these points shown here plus you will get three two or one victory point for every one of these
gold tokens that you have in front of you now this is really interesting and honestly super weird because if you look at the victory point track the lower you go on these rows the less victory points those gold tokens are worth and this is a point where my brain when i was playing it really started to spin out about what do i actually want to do you might be in a situation where you have a bunch of these gold tokens and you are maybe on the 14 victory point spot and you could go on to maybe this gold token spot to get two victory points because you have more than your opponents that will give you two points bumping you up to 16. so that means you just gained two points but every one of your gold tokens went from being worth three points at the end of the game to two and if maybe you had like seven gold tokens that means you gained two points but lost seven points when it comes to end game victory points so that means you didn't just gain two points you actually lost five victory points and that is uh especially interesting when you consider the tournament because what this means at least from my limited play experience is you kind of want to end the game at the far right of one of these columns like the ideal spot to end the game would be 15 or maybe 23.
um i guess seven yeah you probably don't want to do seven because the first two rows make those golds worth three victory points each so yeah you want to end this game at 15 or 23 because that is the moment right before you tick down to the next lower level which makes your gold tokens worth less points and this tournament gives you gives points to your opponent so there are situations where you might actually run a tournament not necessarily break sets but to push your opponent onto that next row which could have a devastating impact they might you know have just one red token but they're at the 23 and you force them to get one point but then they slide down here and lose one point for all of the gold tokens they had and that's obviously a great swing for you that was a good tournament that you just did but it also means that sometimes things that seem obvious are not good things to do like this blue action right here getting six victory points for three tokens is an amazing rate of return but if those six victory points push you down to another level maybe that's terrible and these rows are only uh eight wide so that means more often than not this is actually going to push you down to another row so that could potentially be really detrimental um so that's all strange it's a considering all of this stuff and then when you actually sit down to play this game and start taking these actions you just i at least found myself instantly surrounded by a bunch of very interesting very odd decisions and i really enjoyed exploring that space uh we actually played this game two times in a row uh immediately back to back we finished the first game and we were like what just happened let's play this one again um and it is worth noting that
technically we played the game slightly wrong uh this image is correct but uh when we played it uh we filled in all of the token spots which you're not supposed to do which means our games technically ended a couple turns too early but um i am going to play it correctly in the future and i don't think that really spoils my overall impressions of the game um so a big aspect to this game that became clear after playing it um about halfway through the first game is that blocking is a big thing there are what one two three four five six seven actions in the game and you have two tokens and on your turn you move one token now nothing in the game forces you to move either of these tokens you can decide which one you want to do on each turn so what that means is in this very quick 20 minute game you can have experiences where somebody might put a token down onto an action and then never move it the whole game they move the other token around which means that action might be gone for the entire game and in fact we had this happen in both of our games i think largely to groupthink between the two of us on this blue spot right over here it got used maybe once or twice and then somebody had a whole bunch of blues and the other person just left their token there so that it would never get freed up so that the opponent could ever go there and score the six points although we realized about three quarters away through the second game like wait a second i could totally leave this spot because you don't want to go there because you're going to get six points but it'll knock you down a row which means you'll actually lose a couple points and we realize that while at first glance the blue action looks like the strongest one and one you want to block constantly it's actually a really double-edged sword and so from a strategic perspective i think in future games the blue action is not going to be blocked all the time it just
was in our first couple of games but it was an interesting um situation and honestly it sparked some pretty cool discussions between myself and my friend specifically about is a game bad if you never get access to an action because you can block it for the entire game um i think my answer to that is specifically in the case of the field of the cloth of gold no that that isn't bad for the game if this was like a two-hour game and somebody could do that well that might feel a little bit weird but in this really tight really quick um two player only experience i think it makes a ton of sense that you have this position especially considering you only have two tokens so that means you are given this opportunity to potentially infinitely block one action but you cannot infinitely block two actions so if you're staying on that spot then you have to move this other one around and if suddenly that one lands on a spot that's also great for your opponents well now you have to move one of these tokens and maybe you'll get to the point where you decide the first one is actually the one that you want to move out of the way and i found personally found that fascinating now from my personal perspective on playing board games i am drawn like a moth to a flame when it comes to interesting mechanical quirks and how things interact with each other so i am predisposed to um find situations like this uh quirky uh odd uh situations like this uh to be endearing and i think for some people they would actually find that quite frustrating i also think a lot of people would be frustrated by the fact that when you gain points when you seemingly gain points you actually lose points um again i think that's super cool when i kind of realized that i was like whoa wait a second we we're totally overvaluing that blue spot
i kind of talked it through and we both realized like oh and honestly that makes me now want to play the third game a third time to see what happens uh going forward um i will say that in both of these games i won but the scores were a lot closer in the second one and interestingly enough in the first game i had a bunch had way more endgame points than my opponent did going into endgame scoring and then we scored the gold tiles where i got a lot less because of this multiplier than my opponent did but i still was able to win and in the second game i won and my token was lower on the track uh so i actually surpassed my opponent by having a higher value gold token so it didn't seem like oh definitely going up the track is good or oh definitely going up the track is bad it just seemed like in specific moments you had to check to make sure that you were doing the right thing for that right moment um and a lot of this uh you know this quirkiness this oddness about this game circles back to the fact that this game plays in about 20 minutes uh our games might have been more like 30 but we were talking a lot and honestly just having a great time uh with the experience of the game and i think that um playing a game with these weird quirky edges like this uh in a small time frame like that with somebody you might want to play a game multiple times with um leads to a very pleasurable experience for me like i said i had a blast playing this game and i don't think that's necessarily because the game is amazing my favorite game ever or anything like that but it created a game state it created a situation around the table with me and one of my good friends where we were just taking actions and laughing and uh you know being exasperated with the options that we had and
and thinking things through like okay i could go here but that'll give you a gold token and then i won't have the majority in any more then i won't get those points but wait do i even want points yes of course you want points but do you want points like it just puts you into such a strange spot that i personally find very enjoyable um circling back to a criticism i had with fairy tale uh in at the beginning a very mild criticism that the box was very large for a quick two-player experience this is again a two-player experience that plays in about 20 minutes but this box is a great size it's it's like about this big um you know like you know a foot and a half by you know 10 inches or maybe not a foot in half i'm bad with these things but it's a standard kind of like um uh what am i trying to say for the podcast people out there it's it's a large dimension from one angle but it's very thin it took me a long time to get there this box is like an inch thick or so so it slides into a collection very easily and i do not see myself getting rid of this one because it's so quirky i think this is also one i would take off the shelf to play when waiting for other people to finish something up or when waiting for other people to arrive honestly i just want to teach this one to all of my friends so that they can experience the quirks of it and i think i'm going to try to not spoil some of them i don't want to like take advantage of them to just you know run away with the game i'll probably say a little bit of things but i want all of my friends to experience the oddities of this game and also um to experience just how quick and rules light an interesting gaming experience can be uh now i do want to mention that uh not everyone agrees with me i went on to boardgamegeek and looked
through all of the comments and uh let's see it's rated right now at 7.4 which is pretty good but um the comments are pretty uh um polarized there are a lot of people who say this game is really fun tons of really thinky hard decisions and there's a bunch of comments of people saying um you know this game is totally random i was i was hoping for more but you know i was just totally disappointed and that doesn't surprise me i think this is a game that is going to be polarizing it's certainly not going to be for everybody but for somebody with me and uh my love of quirky mechanics and also my love of elegant systems because i do think this is a super elegant game um with the very tight rule set but the way these tokens just and these actions just all circle back in on each other how you um might lose tiles for yourself which could break your sets or you could break your opponent's sets you're trying to build sets but you're also trying to get gold because gold is the only one of these that scores for extra victory points at the end of the game i just think all of that stuff cycles around in a really fascinating way and i'm honestly really happy i have the game uh as far as you know the cost to the component quality i mean what you see in this image is what comes in the game it's it's not a whole lot they're tiny tokens um and i think the game was 35 so for me that was worth it for some people it might not be but i'm looking forward to introducing this one to a whole bunch of people and i think at this point i am a bit of a broken record um yeah so that is the field of the cloth of gold and that is also gonna bring me to the end of all the games i'm planning on talking about today um i don't think there was any comments
of people uh chatting about that one uh i will say that the field of the cloth of gold is not a game that's ever gonna be like at the top of the hotness it's not surprising to me that honestly most people haven't even heard of it uh but i do also enjoy talking about it here because i like uh shining a light on uh funky games like this one that aren't gonna be at the top of the hotness list and aren't gonna be uh spouted about by a whole bunch of people because i think that um around the uh edges of um design spaces especially when you have games made by an interesting publisher like holland peel with their print on demand model i just think that those things are going to be really fun for certain people and i want more people to know about them uh so yeah i think that is going to bring this to a close thank you so much to everybody who joined in for uh the live part of this and thank you to everybody who decided to join in later um i have actually played imperium classics at this point and i thought about talking about that today as well but i kind of want to keep these to no more than four and i'm hoping to maybe play a couple more rondelle games before i do that top 10 list so hopefully i'll do another one of these good games vlogs relatively soon where i'll talk about imperium classics i'm also hoping to get another game of imperium classics in or maybe legends i really enjoyed that first game but i would like to explore it more maybe even before i talk about it so i should stop talking about it okay that is going to bring this one to a close thanks again to everyone for coming by