Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 201: Matteo Menapace on Cooperative Game Design

Transcript 1:13:35

It's ad break time. I am proud to announce that the Beyond Solitire podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through Games and Simulations. Right now, they have a crowdfunding campaign on Backerkit for not one but two different games. Making History by Nick Proctor and Witch Hunt 1649 by Martha McIll. Making History uses scattered information about a breakup to teach historical lessons as players try to piece together what really happened, while Witch Hunt gives insight into the social and economic forces behind witch hunts in Scotland. Both are fascinating and you should check them out before the campaign ends on August 7th. But for now, let's get on with the show. Hey gamers, this is Liz David from Beyond Solitire and this week on the pot, I have a very special guest. This is Matteo Menace. He is a game designer. You might know him as one of the designers of Daybreak. How you doing today, Matteo?

I'm doing very well. Thank you for having me on the podcast.

Yeah, I'm super happy to have you on. Um I like to talk to people who love solo and cooperative games and uh you strike me as the type. So, um, so actually I want to kind of before we get up to Daybreak and what you're doing now, um, one of the most interesting things to me, uh, about your background is that you were, uh, a like a resident artist making games. Um, is that something that you always intended to do or I think I remember reading somewhere that your background was in graphic arts.

Yeah. Yeah. My I studied communication design which is another word for graphic design at university and then went into interactive media. Worked in um game design uh educational game design studio for for a few years. Then I transitioned into education. So I started teaching at university level and I was teaching a mixture of user interface, user experience, um web design, creative coding and then also a bit of game design. And in 2018 I had the opportunity to go for uh this residency at the big museum in London called the Victorian Albert or VNA. And at the time they had a big exhibition on video games. So how games are made whether it's a one person doing the stereotypical indie from the bedroom all the way up to big studios thousands of people big budgets. So looking at the behind the scenes of how games are made, what kind of games exist, bit of the history of games as well as um the the culture, how they relate to other forms of culture design and generally the museum when they have a big exhibition, they also have a residency attached to it which is run by the learning department. So I put forward a proposal to be a resident where I would take people from being

players or consumers of games into their first game making experience. And and I propose to do that through making board games because as you can probably guess uh from your own experience making board games is much easier and also more collaborative than making video games. And also in my teaching experience I had In my teaching experience, I had seen uh lots of talented students getting stuck with computer bugs and trying to make a video game and uh not being able to do it, not because they couldn't, but because they had technical issues. So, it's kind of get the computers out of the way and to get people expressing themselves through the medium of board game design.

So that that was a chance to both do this uh artist's residency at the big museum in London as well as an opportunity to then leave the world of academia. This was just before the COVID pandemic. So I I never went back to to academia after that. Uh so I think your point that board games are easier to make. Yeah. I mean in terms of physical materials, absolutely. So did you decide to do board games specifically just for that reason or were you already like somebody who loved board games and you wanted to explore that part of your own work as well?

Yeah, both. I I've been playing board games for for a long time since since I can remember and but it was specifically when I was teaching creative computing. So we're talking about 2015 2016 that I came across this method called unplugged computing. So the idea is that in order to teach people the thinking that then helps you structure write code for computers, you shouldn't start with computer language, but you could start with a language that people are more familiar with such as English if you're an English native speaker or whatever other language. And one way to practice those skills is to use board games. So I came across a paper that was using pandemic. So researchers did a test where they got two groups of people. One group of people that played auto pandemic, another group of people that didn't play pandemic and then they test them uh against a standard um computing test.

And the people that played Pandemic were consistently scoring better than the people that didn't play pandemic. So then the question was like why why is that why did it happen? And the hypothesis was that when you play a board game you have to interpret rules that are structured in a similar way to how code is structured. So variables, your setups, um functions which are your turn loop and so on and so on. So reading code that written for humans which is a rule book and then interpreting executing that code in your head and also making sure that no one else is uh playing uh that that is uh misinterpreting those those those instructions. So that gives you a way to practice the same skills that you would then need to to write code. But on top of that, the fact that pandemic is cooperative and it has open information, which means that you can talk freely about your strategy, about what you're intending to do, and then negotiate with the other players what you want to do.

Gives an extra layer to that computational skills training because you're not just doing that in your head. You're also verbalizing your your thoughts and you're discussing the the sort of code that you're executing with the other players. So that was the hypothesis that the researchers were testing out with this um with this paper and I thought that was really fascinating. Um I love pandemic. So I thought why not play that with with my students and see what happens. And I had similar results that I saw that students enjoyed playing pandemic and also they they got better at writing code at least structuring code. I should say code in in English first. Then when it come to translating it to a computer language, there was an different different challenge, but they certainly understood better what they were trying to do and they had a better grasp of how to how to structure their their programs after playing pandemic. So that was the the spark I should say. And and then I thought, well, I could also design these things. Um, because I design interfaces. I design I've been designing and developing video games before. So maybe I could try and and design my own games. And so that's that's where it started. And I started designing games by taking existing games and hacking them. So slightly

or radically changing the rules of those games and then see see what happens. So the the project that I gave myself to to practice game design skills was to take a bunch of quite abstract traditional board games from around the world and then first deconstructing them. So try to understand what the mechanics of those games were trying to say either consciously or unconsciously and then inject some topics or some issues that I was interested in just to practice at first. I wasn't necessarily trying to make any any big statements with that. But it was a really good way to to learn rather than starting from scratch rather than having that big pressure of I need to come up with an idea. I need to come up with mechanics that express that idea. Uh it's easier for me and I think also for quite a few uh quite a quite a few quite a lot of learners I think to to start with something that already exists and it sort of works and then to break it down to hack it and I've used hacking in a very purposeful sense. So to destroy it and then to rebuild it with new rules, new stories, new ideas so that it can express something else than what the original game was meant to.

Yeah. This actually I've noticed there's some press about your hack of the game memory.

Uhhuh.

So when you talk about breaking down something like memory, it's so simple like how do you deconstruct it uh in order to make something new? Yeah, the you're right. It's it's a very very simple game because it's uh meant to be an educational game for for children to learn spatial memor to practice spatial memory and to learn how to recognize shapes or colors or whatever and to and to pair them. And all of all of that is fine. I think it it does work in that sense. But the fact that it's set up as a competitive game was for me a little bit, should I say, problematic in in that it it does foster certain behaviors like uh hoarding, for instance, the fact that you win by hoarding cards and also you generally win by exploiting other people's mistakes. So someone might try to unlock a pair, they didn't get it. So you know that it's not that tile is the next one perhaps and and you're not encouraged to to share or to to work together to to solve that problem. So I I had in mind that I would want to do something that would want to do a cooperative hack of memories memories sorry in particular because as I was looking through the the museum the VNA museum so this is when I

was doing that residence mentioned earlier I I was looking at the collection of games that they have in the museum and most of the games that they have are children's games. And I think that also speaks to the general the general sense that games are something childish, something that is frivolous and that serious adults shouldn't do. So, so the VNA has this big uh collection of objects uh that span across different art forms from dance to music to painting, furniture, but when it comes to games, they mostly have children's games and and so they're on a separate branch of the VNA called the Museum of Childhood.

So, so that was also in the back of my mind to try to push this idea that games are something just for kids and and then at that time uh my grandma died and she she was um struggling with dementia in the last few years. So that was also the the grief uh of of losing her and and also the the experience of seeing her her memory, her ability to to share stories or to connect back to things that happened in the past deteriorate over the last few years. So I I try to put together these various ideas, this cooperative hack of memory with the the process of trying to revive some or keeping some memories alive or sharing memories and and so I landed on this um idea that was I call fading memories in this it's uh you have like in memory a deck of cards that have uh pairs. Then you shuffle them, you distribute them on the on the table, and then on your turn, you flip two. And those two cards will have two words written on them. And you use those two words as a prompt to share a memory that connects those two words. So words that could be a verb like play and a noun

like um grandpa. And so you would then use the word grandpa and play to share a memory that has something to do with playing whether that's playing an instrument, playing a game or playing as a theater activity and grandpa which could be your grandpa, someone's grandpa and so on. And then after you share the story with the other players, you use another deck of cards uh that are semi-transparent to fade those memories. So you don't flip them back like in the original memory, but you keep them up and you put those semi-transparent cards on top, which start to create this sense of the the memory cards fading uh quite literally in that you you see them uh less vibrant and you can't quite read the text on them. And then uh in order to so the goal of the game is still to pair all the all the cards but you do it cooperatively. So you win when you have unlocked as a group all the cards and you unlock all the pairs by retelling the stories that are that have been shared. And you're encouraged to retell someone else's story rather than your own. So, it's a game that essentially encourages people to to listen actively to what other people are sharing. And if you're the one sharing, it's also an opportunity to bring up a

memory that uh you might otherwise not not share with uh with a group of friends or with sometimes strangers.

That's really cool. Um I would definitely play that actually now that we've now thought about this. Um, so I want to pick out a couple things that you've like said so far that I think are interesting. One is, you know, um, it is true that a lot of people sort of perceive games as for children and is inherently frivolous. Uh, you deliberately brand yourself as somebody who makes and engages with serious games. So when you say serious games, I feel like this is a term that's floating around. Um, what do you mean by them and like what kind of counts as a serious game to you?

Yeah. And a serious games is a conventional term that is used to talk about games that are not played for entertainment but are played for training or for simulation in context like education or government or policym and so on. And I'm not a fan of that term because I don't think that series as such adds much to the to the word games. Um, and it's it's interesting because there is no such thing as serious theater or serious photography or serious whatever. Other art forms don't seem to need this extra justification that using games in a context that is not the intended one or the traditional one is uh something that we need to justify or apologize for. But it's it's the way that uh most people relate to this or most people use this this word for for when games are used outside of purely entertainment purposes. And so uh over the last few years I had a chance to work with primarily policy makers here in the UK using games to simulate what the near future could be and games are very good at that.

And then also to use games to create a structure playful structure around conversations. Uh so when it comes to policym for instance, how do we update or regulate a new policy space and traditionally that would be done by bringing people together, having a workshop, getting them to talk to each other and inevitably you have situations where people who are more confident or louder tend to monopolize the the space. So, a game also allows you to create rules that are shared between all the participants to to give everyone a fair share of time to to express their opinions. And then you can also have rules around how do we how do we know what is the best or or the most popular options for for this policy. So ways to to vote that uh can be can be used also outside of of uh you know entertainment.

So this is these are two ways in which I I I think of serious games. There's simulation and then there's structural structured conversations or structured workshops. Um, and so using uh light rules so that people can can get into the the simulation space or the get into the nitty-gritty of a policy quickly without having to read a a long a long manual and and they work really well, especially when there is an element of a bit of role play. uh when people understand that this is a a space where they can try out things, it's a safe space because you can experiment without worrying too much about the consequences and you can push that experiment quite far. And then very important at the end of that game session is to have a debrief. And the debrief should be almost as long as the game play I think because you need to understand and to discuss what happened in the game and how can we then apply lessons that we learned or things that we've seen in that simulated space to the day-to-day of of the people who participated.

I also want to talk about your interest specifically in co-op games. It seems um you've made a couple of comments uh actually so far in this interview I think are super interesting because you're very interested in the behaviors that games elicit from people. So competitive memory encourages players to behave in ways that are maybe a little bit antisocial or um you know using games in situations where otherwise somebody might just hog the conversation and you want to create a different kind of interaction. you're using games to kind of um encourage the behaviors that you want to see. So, is do you just prefer co-op gaming or is there something deeper at play here where um you're you're wanting to elicit a different set of reactions and behaviors of the people who engage with your work.

I I do like all sort of games. Also, I really like playing competitive games. So I have a a board game club on Tuesdays and we do play lots of competitive games and I can be quite competitive as well. So but when it comes to designing games I I think that cooperative games are an unexplored space. Uh although there's been lots of cooperative games in the last decade or so that have really pushed the this genre in in new ways and and made it more more popular. And as you say, the my interest in cooperative games is from from the perspective of designing more encouraging behaviors through designed rules. So when you create a cooperative game, the fact that you are as a team, as a group, or as a single player, you are tackling a problem that is encoded in the game itself.

I think there's a couple of things. The first is that you're modeling the problem as a systemic problem as opposed to saying, "Oh, that one player is the the enemy and we need to uh defeat them." And so it encourages people to see issues which could be any sort of issues but in particular if you're modeling things that happen also in the real world to see that as a as a systemic issue and and then it also puts people in a position where they have to work together and I think the best cooperative games are those where you're not necessarily working in unison or you're not like doing everyone doing the same thing because that would be slightly boring. But if everyone can find their their place their their role within that team and and then contribute and having some kind of specialty then I think that uh a a cooperative game can can really shine. So it's it's that bringing people together so that they they have to work together on on a shared problem and then seeing that problem as something as something systemic rather than something that is individualized to to a single player and then it's from a kind of ideological perspective you're also going against this idea of the of a zero sum game

where in order to win someone else has to lose. uh in in a cooperative game, you're you're putting a focus on the fact that sometimes we all win and we don't have to or we all lose, you know, and that also fosters a sense of solidarity with with other players. Sometimes a cooperative game is more memorable if you'll lose rather than if you'll win because you you're part of that shared struggle.

Interesting. Okay. So we kind of talked about your academic background and you know kind of like some of the philosophy behind what you're doing. So now I'm ready to talk about day break I think. So like um you know you mentioned that it kind of started as a co project for you that you know things got shut down. Um, did you initially see your game designs during that time as academic work and that you were going to go back in academia or did you deliberately want to make something more commercial and kind of break out?

Yeah, I didn't really have a a preferred route, but I I certainly saw myself as continuing. I mean, if the if the pandemic didn't happen, it would probably have gone back to a more standard academic career after the after the VNA residency. So, that finished uh a few months before COVID started. So, in those few months, I was doing a bit of freelancing, looking around, thinking about what to do. Um, and also 2019 was an interesting year because there was a lot of activity and activism around climate. So it was the year when the Fridays for future movement was very strong. Uh extinction rebellion here in the UK was going really strong. So there was a sense that climate was moving from being a fringe issue into into the mainstream. And then uh we had general elections here in the UK.

uh the the party that was a member of the Labour party had a strong climate uh manifesto. So there was really a sense that things could change uh and and and that politicians on the progressive side were taking the climate crisis seriously and then the pandemic happened and quite rightly so uh the focus of people changed and meeting in person was not possible. Uh so a lot of that activism faded but at the same time um I was I was lucky enough to not have to um look for for an alternative immediately and um my immediate family were all fine.

So, so that opened up a bit a bit of space to to consider what to do and a a lot of time actually. And the the chance was that I wrote an article for my I wrote a blog post about pandemic the game and what can we learn from pandemic applied to COVID uh lessons around cooperation, coordination, global solidarity and so on. And then a friend after I published it, a friend pointed out that Matt Leook had also written something along those lines for the New York Times. So I decided to reach out to Matt. I didn't know him then and to share the the blog post and that started a conversation.

That conversation quickly turned from pandemic to another common interest which was the climate crisis. So Matt at that time also had been thinking about the climate crisis as a potential I mean as a general uh big source of anxiety that that something that exists in the world but also as a potential subject for for a cooperative game. And so we decided to have a conversation and see whether there would be the opportunity to work on this climate game together. And that conversation turned into a weekly meeting and soon enough we had uh ideas that we started prototyping and testing in our own physical bubbles.

Uh and then also online and you know three years down the line we we published Daybreak. So yeah, as you say, it started a bit as a as a lockdown project and it it turned into something commercial. Uh but at the same time also a game that is trying to get people thinking and that tries to make that connection between what the game models and the the real world and what and what is possible. Especially So, just to ask for I'm always curious about this because I do lots of code designing and I really love it as a process. Um, how did you and Matt kind of determine what that relationship was going to look like? And, um, you know, basically how did you do it? How'd you work together? I feel like all my code is relationships are different.

Yeah, we um, so we've worked completely remotely because Matt is based in the Bay Area in California. I'm based in London, so we have 9 9 hours time difference, which means that we would meet once a week on a Tuesday. Uh 5 5:00 p.m. for me, 9:00 a.m. for him. So, he would be having his coffee, I'll be having my tea, and uh then we would spend an hour or two chatting and uh updating each other on the the kind of ideas and experiments that we've been doing. and we had a shared document where we would document everything that was related to to this project. We initially called it climate crisis because that was the the problem that you're tackling. Then Dave Ray came later. Uh so yeah, we had this the share document where everything that was related to the project would go in and so we would uh uh write notes independently and then on the on the weekly meeting we would update each other on what's been happening and then we had a shared folder where we would uh put the the source files of prototypes and photos or videos from play test. So it was a shared space to to how all of the all of the files and the thinking behind the game and then uh independently we would diverge

throughout the week and then come back each week to to make decisions around how to proceed. And the it works really well. I have to say I I've been trying to use the same method for both client projects and my own projects instead. So to have this design journal that where everything that is related to that project goes is something that Matt introduced me to and I'm really grateful that uh I mean it just makes sense but it wasn't something that I was doing before. Uh so to have this very very long document I think we got to 500 pages by the end of the day uh design process and we had to split it up over several documents because it was just too slow to load otherwise. But you know when I say literally everything goes in there that's that's quite true. And and then the the other thing that I feel was a very important part and uh key to the to the way that the collaboration evolved was to have some shared design principles. So before we started prototyping or putting down ideas, we kind of shared some of general thinking around the climate crisis and how we might want to frame it because it's such a huge problem uh that that could be thousands of different perspectives which you could look at it and and frame a game around.

So to have ideas around so to have some design principles that we can then refer back to when we were doing our own independent experiments was was very very useful. And those design principles we also documented them in the in the blog for so blog.datebreakgame.org. But just to summarize them quickly the the first thing that we agreed on was that we wanted a game that has a global systemic frame. So not something where you play as an individual but rather something where you play as a as a country or as a government as a big decision maker because as the name suggests global warming is a global problem and therefore it requires solutions at that scale. Uh also because the idea of a personal carbon footprint is been pedled by the oil industry. So it actually the the term carbon footprint was popularized by a company called BP British Petroleum so that people would worry about their own tiny fraction of uh emissions and get distracted from the 70% of emissions that the oil industry is facilitating.

And and then we wanted a game that is realistic in that is based on real data. So real emission data, current emission data, as well as realistic solutions. So solutions that are not science fiction, but things that could be done tomorrow if we had the political will to do it. And and at the same time, a game that has a bit of a utopian uh direction. Uh and that's where the cooperative element comes in because we know that countries, governments are not cooperating even though they're they should or that they're meant to. So they they meet every year to discuss what to do with the climate, but real cooperation is not really happening. So to create a game that has this realism in the cards that you can play, in the policies that you can roll out, and also in the in the way that that the world that the climate is modeled, but at the same time shows you what is possible because it creates this cooperative frame. And so it puts people in a position to to work together whilst also having their own individual agency. So if you play Daybreak, you'll spend most of the time working on your own political economy if you like. So if you're representing either the US, China, Europe or the majority world and

the the large part of each round is spent doing what we call local local actions. So you you play cards that affect your your economy and your society. And then there is that moment of reckoning where you you look at the emissions that your economy is still producing. All of those emissions go into a shared space which is the atmosphere. And then they create all sort of bad effects around planet. They push up temperatures on the big global warming thermometer and that triggers a sort of a set of crisis which are become more intense and more frequent as as temperatures grow. So your your goal collectively is to stop them from growing to reach the point where as a as a global community you're not putting any more emissions into the atmosphere or rather you're you're putting you're emitting less than what the planet can naturally absorb uh also known as net zero. And at the same time you have to build resilience into your society, into ecosystems and into your infrastructure because crisis keep on happening and you have to make sure that you protect your your communities from from those crisis. And so the way that is structured means that the the the win and the lose conditions are cooperative. So you you cannot win individually, but you could potentially

spend most of the time just looking after your own political economy, your own people, and not cooperate with the other players. Like if everyone just did their own thing, it is possible to win that way. But you also discover while playing that it it is easier to win if you work together, if you if you communicate with each other, if you kind of get a sense of what other other players are doing or what they're struggling with, as well as working on your own specialties. So each player has the ability from the get-go to to do certain things that the other players cannot do. And if you work on those abilities, if you get help from the other players to develop those abilities, then as a collective, you have more of a chance to to solve the problem.

That's interesting. Also, I mean, I'm sure you've been asked this question many times, but um you know, the the way that the powers are divided in the game is the United States, Europe, China, and then majority world. Why did you decide to divide it up that way? And how has that played out in hindsight?

Yeah, the well there was a practical reason that is that we wanted to have a game that can be played by up to four people. So that gave us a simple number to work with. And then the next step was okay, if it's four players, how do we divide up the the world in a way that feels still somewhat realistic? And so the first two choices US and China were fairly easy. So the US is the global hedgeimon uh the I mean economically politically the the strongest um country in the world also the biggest emitter historically. So the the US has the largest share of historical emissions and recently is become the biggest exporter of oil and gas.

So it has lots to to play for in the in the real world. Then there is China which is currently the biggest yearon-year emitter of emissions. Um and also a growing political and economical power. Then we have Europe and by Europe we mean essentially the the European Union plus the UK uh that historically have lots of responsibilities for the for the climate crisis. not just in terms of emissions but the the economic system that led to to the climate crisis and they're also quite uh quite a big market. They have lots of uh options when it comes to tech technological and and social innovation. And then the fourth player we we worked on that quite quite a lot. Uh that was the hardest one to to frame. Um and we decided to go for the majority wall. We called it majority world after someone suggested this term.

Initially we called it the global south. So the global south meaning the countries that historically have been colonized. So South America, Africa, Asia um and those countries tend to be at the um on the front lines of the climate crisis. So they are the ones that are mostly suffering the consequences of the climate crisis both because of geographical reasons but also because they've been underdeveloped by colonialism and secondly because they tend to work together when it comes to the uh climate negotiations. So there is a a group of countries called the G77. there were 77 countries that tend to work together uh at the COP meetings at the climate negotiations meetings. So it was a way to to bring those countries together and to show that they have a shared past in terms of their historical uh trajectories and also when it comes to climate they tend to work together and uh yeah so when you play daybreak you see that as the majority world you're the you're representing essentially well as this as the term suggests the majority of people so we're talking about up to five billion people and your emissions are the largest uh in a in an in absolute terms. But

then you look at the the US for instance which is 300 million people uh and has a a bit less emissions in in absolute terms but then you can see that those emissions are produced by a fraction of the people that that represent the majority world. And you have different kinds of um challenges. So that the majority world starts with a disadvantage. The we call them communities in crisis. So groups of people that are already suffering as a result of the climate crisis. And if uh any one player gets 12 communities in crisis at any time during the game, then the game is over and everyone loses. So the majority world starts with three of them. So we a quarter of the loose condition whereas the US and Europe start with none and so they they have a slightly easier ride if you like if you play the majority world that's the most challenging player to play but also it has the potential to to scale up quickly and to become very powerful by the end of the game.

So, do you think I mean I'm of course talking in a currently a timeline where the United States is maybe actively against uh helping the environment right now. Um um but do you feel like Daybreak made some of the impact that you were hoping it would in terms of getting people to think about climate change? And I mean, you know, what role do you think that games about this topic? I know you're making another one right now, uh, play in in impacting our our social ideas about that.

Yeah. So, Daybreak has been played, we estimate, by about a million people so far, both online and and offline. So, there are million people that had a chance to bring this topic to the table. And one of the things that we wanted to do was to create this opportunity for people to engage actively with solving the climate crisis in a way that would be quite hard to do otherwise. So imagine even if you're a climate activist or if you're in if you're professionally working in that space to sit down with people who may or may not be in that space and to and for two up to two hours to engage with quite indepth problem solving around how do we how do we solve this problem? How do we protect people? How do we decarbonize economy? how do we help each other out is something that is quite um quite difficult to do outside of certain professional circles. So, so that's one thing and the other is that it can help people get a a better understanding of how um not necessarily the climate. So the when you play you get you get an understanding of what happens with with emissions and the various uh side effects that they have around the planet. But the main thing that you do is you get familiar with lots of different solutions and some of those solutions might be more obviously related to to climate or

to energy. So building green infrastructure uh solar panels uh or solar parks and wind farms and so on whilst decarbonizing the rest of the economy. But then there are also the whole aspect of resilience which people tend to not think is um is a climate policy or is is part of the the same problem space. So for instance, free health care or affordable health care is something which you see can have a a role to play in an increasingly destabilized uh climate. So when you have a heat wave or when you have one of the so-called natural disasters, if you have invested in in a healthare system that is more resilience that can respond to those kind of crisis, then people suffer less.

Or if you have invested in agricultural techniques or agricultural methods that are more climate resilient, that means that you're going to suffer less droughts or from other effects of the climate crisis that could lead to famine or that could lead to price inflation. I mean all of this stuff that we're seeing happening in the real world. uh or you know if you have invested in green energy then you're less dependent on fossil fuels produced and sold by countries like Russia or Saudi Arabia and so on. So that's one of the things that people can learn in in an active way when when playing daybreak.

And then there is uh another layer which I'm very interested in is to see whether data can be used in in education or in training context where it can be used as a as a simulation or as a strategy kind of tool and there are a few a couple of projects that I've been uh involved with um where people are are using Dre as a way to get policy makers or politicians to understand the nonlinear uh dynamics of of the climate crisis. The fact that you can't plan and predict what will happen in 2030 based on what happened in 2020 or 2010. It's it's not it's not happening that way. And so to to get a sense of those nonlinear uh effects and also to to then get people strategizing about what what to do uh to to solve the problem and and also to understand that there isn't one single solutions that will just sort it.

But there are various many different combinations of solutions that happen that could happen and and and some of them are also kind of outside of our control which is what happens in daybreak as well. Interesting. So speaking of things that are partially in and partially out of our control, um so you care about a lot of issues, not just climate change. And as your shirt uh reminds us, uh you're about a year out from last year's Shil is yours. So I mean there have been a lot of little news blurbs and stuff about a lot of tweets, but in your own words, what happened at Shil last year and then a year later, how are you feeling about it?

Yeah. Yeah, it's exactly one year today. So 21st of July 2024. So Daybreak was nominated for the Keshield the CRS at um in Berlin and so uh we went to Berlin. It was me, Matt and the CMK team, the publisher that the American publisher as well as the German publisher. And um I decided to uh bring on stage a message of solidarity to the Palestinian people. And uh that message, that symbol was a watermelon. Watermelon is something that Palestinians have been using since at least 1967 when Israel occupied the whole of historic Palestine. and um banned the use of the Palestinian flag.

Uh so in a similar way, I thought if I were to go on stage with a Palestinian flag or with any kind of text that said free Palestine or anything that related to that, I would have probably been stopped before even going to Sage because we're talking about Germany, which is one of the countries that has the the biggest kind of censorship when it comes to this topic. Um, so I chose a a watermelon and I went on stage twice. Um, I didn't say anything about Palestine while I was on stage, but as you can see from the pictures and from the live stream, the watermelon was very much visible in uh on my chest. And uh then after the after the ceremony as a result I suspect of uh people um complaining online.

I was approached by the chairman of the uh of the spiel and I was asked to remove this uh symbol because in his own words we don't allow political statements. So that political statement was not allowed according to their rules and and then the day after there was a there was um press conference at that time I had already left I was already back in the the UK. So this at a at a press conference uh the chairman read out a statement saying that the going a symbol that was on on my on my t-shirt was uh anti-semitic and he actually said that symbol must be seen as anti-semitic by Jewish people and it's unclear whether any Jewish people were consulted or whether the SDJ the decided to speak on behalf of Jewish people. But nevertheless, so I was accused of being of having an anti-semitic symbol. And then um the day after, so Tuesday, they issued a statement on their website repeating all of this stuff plus uh saying that I wouldn't be welcome to any more of the events by the by the organization and I didn't have any direct communication with them. So they didn't reach out to me or to um to the

publisher. So, it's it's all been done through statements on the website and at the press conference

and I think a year later that remains the case like nobody's ever said anything directly to you.

Uh yes. Yeah. Nobody said anything directly but I was sent a magazine spiel box which uh some of the members of the award jury contribute to and in the editorial they mentioned the what happened and then there was also a brief interview to the the chairman of the SDJ who said that the ban was not a lifetime ban but it was only until October last last year. But again, I've I've not been contacted by anyone, so I'm not sure whether the ban is still in in place or not. But, you know, to be honest, it doesn't matter. The the point is that I wanted to to bring a message of solidarity to the Palestinians on a specific stage. So Germany is the second largest exporter of weapons to Israel and you can guess who's the first and also uh is one of the main sponsors of of Israel. So uh doing that in Germany was quite uh was quite significant for me and yeah I I I felt that in in the current climate in the context of a genocide that's I had the privilege to do and I decided to to take the opportunity. For the record, I agree that what's happening in

Palestine is genocide and that we should globally have a problem with it. Um, a year later, your position has just continued. I wish that we I it's just more clear a year later and I wish that it wasn't because that means that so many people have died. Um, however, so I mean I guess that's I guess to like kind of get back to like what happened. So you knew that you were taking a risk and you accepted the potential consequences of the risk.

Yeah. Yeah. And I think I mean to be honest the the consequences were not uh anything that I would say is um serious in the sense that apart from receiving a few emails from random people um and some comments on my blog after I responded to the the statement by thearis organization. I don't feel like I've had any any personal consequences. Uh it might have been different if I were to be based in in Germany. Um so I would understand uh people who are um who are based in that in that country or who are primarily working with that kind of market being a bit more cautious about the the the censorship that exists.

Um, but also at the end of the day, I mean, the the personal consequences that you can can go through are not uh are really nothing in comparison to what Palestinians are going through. And um it it was just a small thing in my in my opinion. I think as you say if more people were to to take uh small steps and to to show that kind of solidarity not just in a in a visible way but also there are other other ways in which people can can make a difference. I think um that that that can have an impact. So it sounds like you feel that the consequences were one negligible and two worth it.

Uh but I mean have there been any repercussions for your design career outside of just spiel being mad at you? Like I mean is your publisher been fine? Has your relationship with Matt been fine? I mean

yeah. Yeah, it's been it's been really fine. So, like I said, I I don't feel like I suffered any any real consequences for this apart from being invited to events that

I can I can live with.

Um, you also just a principled person in other ways. So, I noticed in when we were started exchanging emails that like you don't use Microsoft products. Yeah.

So, I guess my question is just like how far does your do you think your principles extend right now and how does that play into your life and your work as a game designer?

Yeah, I think it's a constant uh yeah, it's it it's something that I renegotiate pretty much day by day. Uh so the the principle is what what is what what are actions that we can take that have an impact and where can where can we make an impact or where do we have influence. So for instance going back to the the spielaris I was given a pretty much global stage when it comes to at least the the board game community. Now, of course, uh board games are pretty much niche in in in in relation to to video games or to other forms of culture, but still the the is potentially one of the biggest um events in the in the board game world calendar.

Um yeah, and so that that was quite a unique opportunity. So I I thought about how could I use that opportunity to um yeah to to send a message and uh in my in my dayto-day I'm also thinking along those terms. So the the key question is like what is useful to Palestinians and feeling guilty or feeling uh defeated is not useful. uh although I do I do feel very um all sorts of feelings like when when seeing what's what's happening but uh when it comes to deciding what what to do uh the question is really about where where do you have leverage and one of the things that I noticed uh and again it's not something that you don't necessarily need to have uh to to to to lead on but to rather to listen to what Palestinians are asking us to do. There is the BDS movement. So bdsmovement.net which is Palestinianled and is boycott divestment and sanctions. So boycott is an effective way to show companies that are complicit in um in the Israeli state uh that we're we're not fine with it. So uh I happen to be uh invited quite often

to Microsoft Teams meetings by various clients that I that I work with and and so one small thing that I decided to do recently was to essentially say I'm not I'm not going to use uh marks or products and uh I put in I put that in my signature so that when someone sends me an invite or when someone just reads my my emails they they get a sense that okay that's it's not going to happen and and I suggest alternatives but also I make it I make clear that there is a specific reason why I'm not using Microsoft products not because I don't like them from an interface or from you know from a functionality point of view but because Microsoft is directly complicit in uh selling software to the Israeli military and that sparks very interesting conversations because when you have a meeting with a client and you're I'm not going to use your platform. So, we have to find a workaround. Uh that brings up that conversation and that forces them to acknowledge that also they are paying for for a product that is complicit in in war crimes. Um so so yeah that's that's just a small example of uh things that we can do to bring bring up that uh on a daily basis and so far it's been really good actually I haven't heard anyone who

actually enjoys Microsoft products so

I mean no in terms of negligible consequences not using teams like oh no Right.

All right. So, I want to ask you one more serious question and a couple fun ones because I've been taking up a lot of your time. Uh, but um, you know, your your next game is also going to be a climate change game. So, can you tell us about that game and then also why climate change as your preferred game topic given how much there is in the world to care about?

Yeah. So, the ne the the game I'm working on at the moment is it's called Dawn, and it's a it's a cooperative card game that uh shares uh some DNA with with Daybreak. So you you play uh up to four up to four players uh also in the role of world powers like in Daybreak, but you're you're playing cards in a way that is is different from Daybreak. So your goal is still to decarbonize the global economy and to protect people from from crisis. Um but it's just one deck of cards. So, the cards have double face. Um, on one side you've got the good stuff, so like the resilience or the uh green economy policies. And then on the back of each card, you have either emissions or crisis. And the idea is that I wanted to try and condense the the key dynamics of Daybreak into something that can be played in half the time and can also be set up really quickly and also that has a much smaller kind of uh material uh presence. So something that you could play on a small table and uh you could play in 45 minutes, half an hour, 45 minutes rather than 1 hour, an hour and a half

like in Daybreak. And of course that means that some of the some of the elements of Daybreak have been have been removed and the the game mechanics have been simplified. But the the idea is that it could become a sort of starter to to library in that you you play Dawn you learn some of the things that then you see are quite familiar when you're

when you move on to daybreak and to the other question was why climate why am I so obsessed

with climate

um well it it felt quite natural truth after after having worked on Daybreak um to and and seeing how many people want to play Daybreak but for var reasons don't mostly don't have the time to to sit down for for an hour and a half and and play what is a game that is in complexity terms three out of five or almost three out of five. So in particular that there's a really interesting uh episode where I was I had the opportunity to play Daybreak with a group of uh weather presenters. So people that go on TV and explain what's happening with the weather in different countries. And so we play we started playing daybreak and then one of them came to me and said showed me a card and said look I have a PhD in this card but I don't know how to play it. I don't know what to do with it. So, there's something about the way that Daybreak uh can unlock a lot of really interesting strategic play through the way that cards combine and uh the the the engine building, but at the same time is something which the average person is not familiar with. The fact that, you know, you've got a cooperative engine builder without turns is something that puts off a few people. So I wanted to make something that is smaller, simpler, and uh shorter.

And so that's that's what I'm working on. And also lots of the research that we've done uh in Daybreak is being repurposed into this condensed version of it. But I certainly am not just interested in climate. I'm also interested in other uh other issues. And I I am working on on another project at the moment. I'm um which started a few months ago, but it's it's been accelerating recently uh with a couple of friends. And the game is somewhat inspired by root in that we wanted it to be asymmetrical. They have these different factions, but the the factions are going to be um there's going to be a capitalist player, a socialist player, a fascist player, and an environmentalist player. And they're all vying for power over a a state.

uh also somewhat inspired by a Germany, but you don't have the state that there are different groups of interests that are vying for power. And we're still early stages, but at the moment we're we're looking at doing some kind of roll and right type of game where the the design principle there is that we want something that is super simple uh that people could get started within a couple of minutes. So you have your your player sheet. It shows you what you can do, the various strategies, the various tactics that you can put forward. Um so in in the form of different tracks and then you roll two dice, you do your thing and then also the two dice that you rolled will have an impact on the central board that determines how the economy is going or how many um how many crisis you're going to unleash on the on the game state. And it's uh yeah, it's it's it's an interesting one.

First of all, it's not copy game. So, it's a co competitive game.

Oh, no.

And oh no,

breaking the streak. And um but it's it's trying to model something quite complex with with dice, which is not my favorite uh thought material, but it's a it's a really interesting challenge. Um because we thought about using cards, about using different kind of mechanics, but we decided to try and start with something super simple cuz there's so much that we could bring into it. Um that maybe giving ourselves this this this design restriction of like you roll two dice and then that determines the choices that you have.

Um, yeah, we'll see how it goes. But we've been playing broad and right games that are really interesting from a from a political perspective. There's one called Paul and Wright that I had a chance to play a few months ago and it does something very similar in that you you roll two dice and then each player represents a political party in the UK election last year. uh and and you have you you can make choices around how to how to get voters of different types in different parts of the country. And it at first I was quite skeptical about it because the idea of you know having only two dice and having to make strategic political choices just around those two dice felt very limited. But the the fact that it's so simple that you you immediately start strategizing and uh and also something very interesting is that I observed other players you talk about what you're doing in metaphorical terms very very quickly. Whereas normally when you play a game the first time you tend to talk about it in terms of mechanical terms. So you say, "Oh, I need that card or I need two of those tags in order to do this thing." And uh which is which is fine. You know, you need to internalize how the game works mechanically. But I think when when a game starts to have a

transformative effect on on players is when they start to translate and they start to think of and express what they're doing in metaphorical terms. So what is the game actually representing rather than the physical things that you're doing? and and with that system of rolling two dice and then assigning those dice to different parts of your strategy sheet, I noticed that people people do that very very quickly. Um, so it is something that I wanted to explore and that I'm currently exploring.

Well, I'm looking forward to all of that actually. Uh, but for now, you know, you're you're making games, but you're also a gamer. Uh, what have you been playing recently that you have enjoyed?

I really enjoyed the uh Lord of the Rings trick decking game. So, I've been playing that with with various people, both people that have familiarity with the Lord of the Rings, so they enjoy how this story has been modeled within this traditional card game mechanism, as well as people that have no clue about The Lord of the Rings, like my parents. Somehow they didn't they didn't read the books, they didn't see the films. So, for them, it was just like, "Okay, fine. and we're just playing Briscolola, which is a traditional card game from Northern Italy where where I'm from. Um, we play Briscolola, but we play cooperatively, so we have to do these missions together. And yeah, it was really fun because they they could immediately relate to the the mechanisms and and and apply them to this idea that we need to band together in order to solve some some problems. Uh, so that's that's been on heavy rotation recently. And also on the same streak, I've been playing the the Lord of the Rings game by by Matt Mikok, uh, who's been which has been recently published, and I had the opportunity to play various pl various prototypes before and, uh, and then to see it and to play it in its published form has been a real pleasure.

That's awesome. Uh, and then if people want to follow you and your work, uh, where can you be found online?

So, I have a blog on Medium. So, medium.com b- a do and then at the moment I'm quite active on LinkedIn. So, you can search for my name and um a little bit on Instagram, but that I'm not going to dip in and out of that. And I I still have a Twitter account, but I'm not really using it anymore.

Yeah, I'm in the same boat on that. All right. Um so, however, uh for those of you out there, I am chronically online and can be found pretty much everywhere at Beyond Solitire. Uh Matteo, thank you so much for coming on the show. has been a delightful conversation. It's been uh a real joy to meet you and get to chat.

Thank you. It's been indeed a joy to speak to you.

All right, everybody out there, please like, subscribe, comment, ask questions, and most of all, happy gaming.

Progress saved