YOU told me I would LOVE this... Skulls of Sedlec board game review
Transcript
you said I'd love it so I gave it a shot I recently filmed my all killer all filler top 100 a list of my favorite games with simple rule sets short durations and portable packaging and I particularly loved reading all of your comments and opinions the pics you agreed with disagreed with and the games you felt had overlooked one title came up several times in the comments a tiny card game that I'd never heard of but you seemed dead sure that I'd like it so I decided to check the game out I'm Adam Porter I design games and review them on this channel with a focus on product design if you like what I do please subscribe share the video and join in the conversation in the comments novice monks dig up Graves and stack skulls in the sedlec ostuary your job is to collect the most pleasing combination of skulls and position them according to the final wishes of the deceased skulls of Sedlak is a simple dose of card Drafting and set collection for two to three players a lot a game in a tiny package the entire deck contains just 18 cards after reading your comments I reached out to the publisher button shy games and they kindly provided me with review copies of skulls of sedleck and its six card executioners expansion for the purposes of this video skulls of sedlec is a 2020 release by Californian designer Dustin Dobson the 18 cards are divided into six face down piles the top card of one pile is turned face up and
the game commends is on your turn you may either take the face up card into your hand or turn two cards face up and take one of those into your hand or place a card from your hand into your display you have a hand limit of two cards so pretty quickly you'll be stacking skulls on the table in front of you the cards essentially function as dominoes with two skulls on each you place these cards in a pyramid-shaped Arrangement and the individual skulls score points based on position for example Royal skulls score one point for each Royal or peasant on any lower level the first priest on each level scores two points a pair of adjacent Romantics scores 6 points and criminals score two points only if they're adjacent to priests the game ends when all players have completed their stacks and scores are totaled and the highest scorer wins the game has many expansions available but the one you recommended was The Executioner's expansion and hence that's the only one I've tried this six card expansion allows you to play the the game with four players and it adds a new card type the executioners are mixed into the deck and they score for adjacent connected chains of criminals now I'm going to try and follow my usual format exploring the product design choices apparent in skulls of sedlec but it's going to be hard because I don't really believe that this game is the product it seems to me that the publisher button shy themselves are the product and skulls of sedleck is simply one installment in their wider project
now I haven't previously paid any attention to button shy but I must admit I'm intrigued there's a vast catalog of micro Games available from the company titles like tassimasi from wingspan designer Elizabeth Hargrave and City Builder sprawlopolis are perhaps their most prominent games but it's apparent that the real draw for these games is the collectibility button shy released one new hand assembled wallet game every month that's 12 very affordable games per year and if the quality of sedlec is anything to go by that's an appealing Prospect like subscribing to a magazine looking back at past kickstarters I can see button shy branded carry cases overflowing with wallet games something I never knew I needed but now I can't get it out of my head button shy appears to work hard to create a community the designers of their games seem to return from multiple titles skulls of said like designer Dustin Dobson also designed button size solo puzzle game Rove their tactical Skirmish game battle Crest and the Intriguing 18 card Legacy game wild Tales now that one I have to try many of button-sized games are developed as entries into their regular design challenges where designers are asked to design to a brief a theme a mechanism or some other constraint with a component limit of just 18 cards skulls of sedleck was a finalist in a challenge where designers were asked to design an 18 card game based on a real-life location
so we know a little bit at the onboarding strategy button shy has a following new entries are likely to be picked up by fans of the series and Word of Mouth spreads the message wider bringing new fans into the mix just has happened here with all of you directing me towards skulls of sedleck and me subsequently getting sucked into the wealth of other tantalizingly affordable wallet games on offer the rules of skulls of sedleck are as simple as the packaging I explained them all to you earlier it can't have taken me more than a minute and yet the gameplay is super entertaining card drafting is always enjoyable especially when combined with set collection but the simple variation on the formula splitting cards to create dominoes provides just enough to make the decisions feel substantial the game Clips along at a pace and if you're anything like me when it's over you'll be asking for a rematch and most likely playing several games on the Trot I rate games using my ladder engagement system so games are awarded zero to three points in five different categories and each point scored climbs the game one rung up the ladder a score of 10 or above tops the ladder and indicates a real favorite with me for thematic immersion skulls of said Lex scores one there's no Narrative of course but the skulls are nicely drawn the pyramids look great when they're done and the skull scoring criteria relate nicely to their titles and illustrations for player interaction it's also a one there's some minor potential for blocking play here drafting cards specifically to deprive your opponents
but the focus is largely on your own display stress and challenge scores a little higher the game is tense you can only hold two cards in hand but you might be holding on to some valuable scoring opportunities just waiting to place them in higher scoring positions in Upper rows of your pyramid there will be many times in the game where you're waiting for just the card you need to emerge in the central display willing it to appear before you're forced to place a card from your hand in a sub-optimal position feedback describes the ways in which a Game responds to the player's input rewards penalties special abilities and there's not much here you're collecting cards placing them and you score them at the end of the game any gratification is delayed as you have to wait for gay men to see the rewards from the combos that you set up the choices in the game are compelling deciding when to play a card and when to hold it back which card should I select from the display should I take a face up card or should I flip two cards at the risk that I don't want either of them the overall score of 7 is very respectable though it stops short of the top of the ladder frankly achieving a game disengaging with just 18 cards is a huge achievement now I'm hesitant to apply my usual product design checklist is the game Innovative no not hugely does it fulfill a need or fill a gap in the market again no but I'm reluctant to put too much weight on these criteria because we know that skulls of Sedlak wasn't created using a design thinking
approach it was an entry into a competition focused on theme first design and the product is really something much bigger a catalog of tiny games in cute wallets curated experiences sold at an affordable price I do think there's a market for this stuff primarily among those of us with a drive to collect positioning skulls of Sedlak on my idea execution Matrix isn't fair because it's not really a standalone product the real product is button shy itself and that's a great concept well executed but that's not to do skulls have said let down the game holds its own against the most popular titles in the genre Sushi go is a comparable weight and skulls of sedlec provides a similar experience with a much smaller footprint if you'd like to hear more about some simple portable games then click on the link and until next time all the best