Tang Garden: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for tang garden which is a game of lavish production and that's basically how it how it ropes you in so lavish lavish production well that's just because whatever kickstarter copy that i bought from someone they then get metal coins because they suck um no this game uh was it's weird because whenever we played it the first time kind of like village attacks uh we had i mean we had a good time it wasn't like anything that was like whoa right but whenever we played it again i was like oh this is kind of this is kind of it and like you start to see a lot of the it's basically the first time you play it it's like all the 3d stuff the trees the beautiful artwork um you know the 3d stuff you're kind of like blown away you're like wow this is amazing and you play it again and you you're like okay well i'm used to that and then you start to see what issues the game actually has in terms of mechanics it's like you still you like it's like seeing either there's i swear there's an analogy for it but it's like seeing a piece of art from far away and you're like that's amazing you get up close and you're like oh what the [ __ ] is that you know you slowly start to see little scratches yeah yeah little [ __ ] stains that are in it um there's just for me like the game is fine like on your turn you you pick a tile place it
you know go up on on the three different tracks to basically recruit more people um and and that's fine and i like building stuff especially together this is our garden that kind of looks like [ __ ] um just in terms of like the layout doesn't really make any sense i mean do the tile ones ever look pretty yeah there was actually one we just played called suburbia where you build like your own city and it all connects and looks good um you see you're smiling for some reason like is it is it though is it um yeah or uh castle's a mad king ludwig was a tile one where he built your weird castle right i mean or between two cities right but they always turn to some kind of weirdness as you're trying to like min mags it's just i mean all those those i guess my main reference i just have isle of skye yeah yeah i know that one turns into like a [ __ ] yeah you're trying when you're trying to place for points sure yeah and and here you kind of are you're placing really to go up on this track which allows you to recruit people um just so you can quickly try and get them out and score their end game points um honestly like it's like it's it's almost like a 9 out of 10 in terms of production this artwork is fantastic you know if you had metal coins they'd be nice like this this is beautiful this is beautiful artwork but mechanically these also fail because you put them on the side and a lot of your people require you them to look at those icons
so you're sitting there and you're like what the [ __ ] what the [ __ ] is over here it's it's like almost an eyesore because these are very tiny for my monk they are very i i had a hard time telling oh is this a village icon or is that a buddhist temple without me having to actually go through it like and be like okay what does a buddhist temple look like they're so tiny that you can't easily as i spit everywhere you can't easily look at it you have to almost be like okay let me just kind of it's just they didn't make the icons big enough on those because they wanted you to see the artwork and the way that you place them face up it's like okay we need basically you two to sit over here and you'll tell me what's on this side and then we'll tell you guys what's on this side um it's just they have a lot of mechanical flaws that kind of ruin it for me but what do you guys think i think just real quick i i just think this is a general good rule of thumb that um it's always bad when one person thinks okay i should just end the game it's really bad when two people think it's okay that you were thinking that because i was also thinking yeah almost it i felt like it overstayed it's welcome yeah i think that yeah kind of sets the tone because i i do enjoy it like i like tile lane and building things like this um but i mean and it is cohesive in terms of whenever you overall look at it you know all the paths connect all the terrain does touch i feel like we usually have a lot of friction with games where could players intricately control when
the game will land now when we are very much in control like we could have drug this [ __ ] out if we all avoided those titles right and or someone could just absolutely rushed it right and i mean usually like there's there's certain games that we play we rushed it well i mean yeah there's certain games that that the players do kind of control the speed great western trail is kind of one of them how quickly you you know go up to kansas yeah and but i feel like that those games are balanced this one it's just like i mean just how the nature of the tiles come out and like whenever there were literally for the most part like i thought the flow of the game was off as well especially maybe it's just a three player faux pas but kat and i were really the ones placing tiles and then when it came back to you you're like oh okay lucky me i'll decorate i'll decorate thanks for doing all my work i'll decorate yeah and it's like okay well that's not fun yeah i think that might just be an error with three players just kind of it just happened that way right i i mean i don't think this is like much of a criticism i feel like they try and balance it out a little bit i mean they try i don't know if they fully succeed but i know when you're like placing the tiles you can get coinage yeah um let's see here it also bumps you up on your elemental track um which also leads to your increased viability of your characters so i mean placing tiles benefits you as do placing the the decorations i don't feel like it's
completely one-sided well i mean in terms of like i had more people out and then you had all all decorations and so i mean i feel like we all well i mean i feel like we all had a very similar i mean it's also depending i mean i know one of our complaints is the randomness of the drawing it's absolutely luck it's luck based i mean you literally had a spot like where you were looking for a certain card and yeah i mean most the time you were drawing three or four and then i'm like oh i have my monk i'll get two coins i'll draw two oh lucky me boom there's six points right and it's like that's not fair you know like but i mean at the same time to play both you have to use that one-time use right right i mean so it's not like you can just always do that sweet combo right i'm just i'm just trying to i understand we're kind of down on it but i just kind of want to lend some credit i mean i can't give any credit to pure randomness gotcha i i absolutely refuse like there's no better than me just rolling a die and seeing oh how many coins do i get yeah i feel like what game did we just play that we were like no like you know the dwellings dwellings was pure random whenever i just cycled through that deck right i mean you mentioned that they actually put out some i don't know what's the term for it addendum or uh errata is that the errata yeah for like they're supposed to be like two face up that they want to start doing that might help a little bit i don't know i know i know that fixed uh a lot uh that complains for a lot of people because you essentially will have two face up and you'll get to see them and be like okay do i want to spend essentially a point to take that one in particular
and that would that would absolutely fix it but and i mean i guess give credit where credit's due where hey at least they came out with a way to fix you know the pure randomness but at the same time you still got to give them flack for [ __ ] up on a kickstarter game anyway like okay you obviously didn't play test it or whoever you had playtested was probably your best friend it was like no no it's it's fun not getting to go the real part is like it's not so much that oh i get to draw and oh i didn't get anything it's the fact that that's your turn like oh i didn't get to place a tile to get coins or or increase my track i drew from this this deck and [ __ ] [ __ ] me i guess like i don't get to i don't get to do anything right and in the game where you are mid-maxing tile placement and there might be that perfect one out there and then someone else just gets to go because you didn't get to do anything like literally the end of the game like if we played it the way and the end game is [ __ ] too but if we had played it the way that we were supposed to my last turn would have been garbage yours was good but then cats was garbage and then i'm like no i'm house ruling it we're going to do what every other good game does and we're going to end the round and everyone gets one more round gotcha so so what they have in mind so like whoever has the token and so if anyone else ends it it goes to the person to the right so if if like if i have the token and i do my turn and i and i'm drawing and i'm like great token
definitely does not it does not rotate okay it just sticks with the whoever plays it's to give everyone an equal amount of turns but there's nothing wrong with also okay we'll finish out the round and everyone gets one more because that'll still be even amount of returns right so it's like oh i can't place those all right i guess that's my turn and then you come in and end it yeah and then that's your turn then cat gets a go so basically i am getting [ __ ] or whoever has the token gets [ __ ] because oh okay i didn't realize you were gonna end it i mean i guess it's a strategy you can sit there and be like oh haha your last turn [ __ ] you i'm gonna end the game so you don't get any points at the end i don't know it it definitely leaves a bitter taste in my mouth when you can only do one thing on your turn well i mean you can influence people and you can eat ass and whatever but when you're when you get one action really play a tile or or place a decoration and you can't do that it's like village attacks hey well you know roll dice and i can't attack i can't do one of the core mechanics of this game to help to help us survive right so what what am i doing yeah it did feel a lot like the decoration slots were quite limited and definitely in a more populated game that would become very frustrating right and maybe this is one of those games where two people is it's best yeah because i don't i mean kat and i we we had enough to uh control over like decorations or and i think i remember one to four liking it yeah blaze one or four pretty well right and i was like oh yeah this is f like this is fun like because you get like because the board shrinks essentially all these all
these uh landscape tokens go in uh one more one so so it's smaller but you know you almost have a balance of both people are kind of playing tiles the same amount they're decorating the same amount you're not fighting so much for one lotus card or pavilions or trees it just felt more balanced at two but here with me i guess three is just garbage with this game because it's like that one per one extra person throwing a wrench into things that's one more person taking a tree card so like on a four player are they all on the very edge of the wall no it stays the same stays the same um i just i also feel like um i would despise this at four yeah i agree i also think you guys really um really started closing things off early which is not not a bad thing to do um because you needed the points but at the end it really hurt all of us um because it's like oh i would love to place this rock but oh but i can't place it i found another opening with another [ __ ] rock like i mean because it came down to when we were playing that it's like okay i need to go up on on water but there's no water for me to place but i don't want to just open like i don't want to do this and open up like a new water area because i don't gain water doing that so i was like oh okay i'll decorate to try and find a card that if i can place it give me that water right but then i drew and it's like oh
nothing so i i was damned if i do damned if i don't i was screwed no matter what i did definitely having the decorations up would be helpful because it does feel frustrating when you um like say you know you are obligated to place a tile you didn't really want to play style you prefer to decorate but you don't have slots you can make slots you place a slot now they have a slot exactly yes yeah cause it's like okay well i want to get a tree because i'm trying to go for trees so i'll place this here and it's like oh i'll decorate oh look a tree i mean it's like i what the [ __ ] i did that for you yeah i mean i can understand that you could argue strategy but it doesn't decrease the player's frustration right yeah this is definitely one of those games where it's like okay well i can try to strategize but also like with so much heavy randomness you're like yeah even with two people it's like that's two different two completely different things can happen and now i'm like oh [ __ ] like right you can take the two tiles i need you could take the one and then he could say it's just yeah and then you're just like okay well i guess i'll oh you placed i guess i'll try to decorate oh look three cats yeah yeah okay like i guess i guess it's just like this game ended up being at least with three all icing but no cake for me like it's super sweet it's gorgeous but when it's it's kind of annoying as well when a lot of your end game points require you to kind of be able to see the [ __ ] board and even the decorations it's kind of like okay like like even the facing these miniatures really aren't that great
um the only one you can really tell is the whoever this is i okay well people wearing hats and clearly having things on their backs yeah like her with the umbrella this is obviously her back yeah um and i think that's interesting i actually like the you place them on the board like because i always like the uh the the card games where it's like you have this ability but you have to like move you have to do something like elysium for example where it's like you have to you have an ability but you have to move them down and you're scoring them for points but you don't get their abilities anymore i like that mechanic quite a bit and that's also here and i think the facing of the miniatures is that's an interesting concept they want to look at stuff they want to look at the garden um but once again yeah that's great in in theory in practice it's like what the [ __ ] is he looking at okay i think he's facing okay so that's kind of all right uh well what's over there oh wait he wants to look at what kind of landscape oh what's uh oh wait but he's over here and okay so that's oh [ __ ] i thought that was a buddhist temple this whole time you know and it's like oh it's not because they're like oh look look at our pretty art and oh i know these are really important but we're gonna make them as tiny as [ __ ] [ __ ] tiny don't obstruct the pretty visuals yeah what if this game came with a magnifying glass you almost like those uh those binoculars for like opera oh so you can sleep in fully and also since we're nitpicking i mean with the the 3d terrain on the board it does you know definitely helps um
uh like say like some bored edges so we need pagodas right here in a tree and like i didn't know i don't know my poets over there like oh yeah i'm sitting right here like yeah symbols and whatnot so you almost have to take the sky approach yeah and find all your stuff and i know like for uh for a few games like when we played recently uh five minute mystery like you had like that crane like that neck crane where you had to kind of go and look and you kind of have to do that here so it's like yeah i mean from from a stand back this game looks awesome all these people looking at stuff the the the surrounding bull we even made it thematic we had the village over here the buddha temple the village and i think the water stuff over here all of it is gorgeous but i don't know i just i have a bitter taste in my mouth for the for the mechanics and the practicality of those mechanics um and it's like i mean you see all the trees out there and then you're like oh surely i can place a [ __ ] flower but i guess for some reason that whole forest area can only hold one flower
this little gas station where you pick up your anti-issue yeah i want to know the the juicy story of why the empress doesn't want to see the emperor i don't know i mean all the characters are unique they do have different uh you know in-game abilities and game abilities those are nice um it's kind of easy they give you their their own unique ability so it's like oh man i really don't want to drop them because i remember early on uh when uh let's see here i dropped the child but i i just dunked the princess and like she was giving me you know two points for placing the two pointers and i placed like two or three after the fact and i was like oh two coins yeah exactly um and i mean it sucks because what you have 68 yeah i had 62 if i was able to place that last [ __ ] thing but nope i couldn't [ __ ] you can't see the small because the thing is the icons also kind of blend in to the color so you can't clearly see like these like what the [ __ ] is that that's that icon which is pertinent to your decorations is the same color as the forest they just went for you know aesthetics over focusing on the mechanic yeah yeah yep these cookies are very pretty i mean yeah it's very pretty and like uh definitely like you in a pitch meeting i'm like oh that sounds wonderful yeah good idea yeah the actual board like the baseboard like i love the hint of gold yeah it's very very beautiful they did that correctly like it's almost a nine out of ten on on on presentation and and art so so what do you think they
could do to improve so the few tweaks that they could do i mean definitely you could you could you could put the symbols a little brighter simple that will just make that random maybe make the symbols a little more frequent on the board a little more decoration slots maybe yeah like at least have some tiles that have like two like why can't two flowers be on a [ __ ] tile like giving you the freedom if if you want to make these random at least let you place more on the board or maybe like one of these could be like i felt like i never needed this uh to reorganize someone i never felt like i needed that it could be if like let's say my my gardener that wanted landscapes like he got four which ended up working out because of the flower here but let's say there was like six and then i could be like oh that's way better than i can move him or yeah the emperor did come out and he stood in front of me and she could move yeah there are other ones in here um see if i can find or if maybe like if they may introduce the mechanic to where you could like hold on to your decoration maybe and play it later oh right and be a little more tactical with it rather than it's like a knee jerk out of place it now right i'm just trying to think because i feel like they're almost there basically i mean it's the same that's funny i mean these games are not similar really in any way in terms of theme but village attacks in this one village attacks was almost there just more dice mitigation here give you more mitigation on a huge component one of the two actions tile placement which the tiles i think is that's fine like you have four options you get what you get right i don't even mind the fact that the more tiles you place the more
options of decorations you get that's fine too it's just the mitigation of this and i get the i get that they tried by two face up ones but even then it's just like oh okay well those two face up ones suck so i guess i'll still draw from the deck and i still can't place those i wonder if it would be better if we got to like like if everything was just face down we got to pick two choose one kind of thing like with tiles um i mean it'd still be random but at least you kind of feel like you have it's like okay well at least i get to look at these two yeah i mean i like the tile placement because it's the four different types you have your greenery you have your uh you have your water you have your rock and then i don't really know what this one's supposed to be like the the yin yang one i guess i guess it's like a mix of all of them um yeah i i don't have any really any problem with the way the tiles come out uh it's the the the fact that the tiles you can't really tell what's on them you their own for some reason even thematically it doesn't i get the the pavilions i get the bridges i get the trees it's the tiny ones that like why can't there be two or because even then it's like that's not going to be any more broken yeah i felt they really uh choked us with a lot of i mean there's so many options to place people yeah like so many places like there's like just their own tiles that like oh you can place a person here and then these just open up turn a mountain into a place where you can put someone yeah you can you make a bridge you can place a person
there maybe if they like maybe reduce those a little more and placed a few more you know elemental symbols yeah in place with a few more decorations so you don't feel like you're you know having a choke churn exactly something like that yeah i mean i mean because you know me i'm all about turn efficiency and when like multiple times it can happen throughout the game where you don't get to do anything that's that's pretty punishing in a game that was as close as it was at the end uh so that that would be that would be ways that i could fix it um but but yeah it does it does there is a certain amount of frustration when it's like you replace a tile and it's like well now i gotta suffer through three turns someone's gonna use my tile yeah placing a decoration or someone else's i mean you have to hold out that someone else is going to place one right because it's also random i mean the tiles are random you have control over kind of where you go but yeah it's like okay well i'm going to place this and so i go up on green and i get i get a coin ooh i get one coin but really i'm trying to go for trees for 25 coins but yeah then that just gives two opportunities for you to be like oh great that took a tile great so now that's two gone so i get to draw four oh yay a tree and you could really be an [ __ ] and be like oh i know you're trying to get trees so i'm actually going to take this to stop you so you kind of essentially wasted your turn there by placing it by doing a tile because you there's really you kind of have to hope that other people do what you want to do yeah and when they don't it's like all right well maybe they'll go for something else and i thought maybe maybe i'll get lucky
and play set there and and i'll and if they won't use it which is why in a two-player game that's less likely to happen it sounds like yeah you guys had a lot better time yeah it was it was better at two um totally different game what a shame i know so uh you guys got anything else anything that you i mean i guess well i guess you guys can we'll explain what you're based on your scores um i'll i'll go yeah uh i will give tan garden
it looks so good though but that kind of bums me out that it just kind of i'll give it a five i think i'll give it it's it's it's an average game like especially the tile placement games we have played and that i've played recently those were a lot cleaner in terms of mechanics uh yeah they don't look as good they're not 3d especially we just played suburbia which mechanically was fantastic but it's that top-down view almost like take sim city and just do that top down so it's not highly detailed you still get to see how your city plays out and all the roads connect which is nice but yeah it's not like elaborate or anything but mechanics were good um and so yeah i mean all i sing but no cake and even though yeah now we could easily just be like oh these two are face up and to get that one you just play a coin and then and then you can take it and place it that would probably fix you know a lot of the frustration but i don't really like doing house rules i didn't even really like doing how we house ruled the end of this game i mean yeah and i know earlier like earlier when you said that and i was i said you know your house your rules but i mean really it's it's your game like if you spend all that money i don't remember how much well that's even then like you did you spent money the point is like if it's that frustrating because you really totally did just burn three turns like yeah i mean it's kind of like i'm the consumer i expect your product to work as intended i don't want to have to like it's like buying a [ __ ] contraption and you have to
fill with it to make it work it's like no i bought this i should it should work super expensive it's like buying a super expensive game and having to assemble the minis yeah yeah it very much is it's a sickness stefan you're almost there too you almost sold it this is an intervention no um but i mean it's it's fine it's it's fine at least at three at two i'd probably give it a seven i enjoyed it way better at two but i i really only keep games that either work only at two or hey this works great at two and three and four i don't really like to keep games that are like oh you play you can't play with more people but it's really best with two i don't i don't know so i guess at two players with our experiences because at that point don't market it as a right i mean it can be maybe it's just one of those games the three sucks ass but i feeling like four would be even more frustrating i don't think i'd like it at four because there's yeah maybe the game would be shorter i mean yeah yeah so i'm gonna give it a five seven ah yeah i felt just a little off i mean yeah like village attacks just oh god they really i mean it's very pretty it is very pretty i mean that's i almost gave it a six for that but i had to take it a more negative way in that it looks so pretty but yet it flopped yeah yeah i'm
important torn porn i'm born porn is on the mind um torn between like let's say a five and six i'd say i mean yeah i felt like it's got good ideas i felt like a few little tweaks here and there would fix it up i don't know i don't want to encourage them to make expansions and then there was they already have two amazing yeah they have the ghost stories expansion and then the uh the golden age which basically the golden age they like they both add scenarios so you just kind of roll a die and then it tells you oh okay here's the kind of lanterns that you use here's the tiles that you use here's some addition you remove certain decorations um which is fine like pretty much the expansion's just added new characters and new landscapes and new decoration cards um but well i mean i mean i'm not like super jazzed to like play it again but um i'm gonna give it a six yeah it's i mean i feel like it's definitely a little above average but there's like a few niggles here and there that might be frustrating but i felt like it it can't be balanced but it's it's frustrating it can be it's frustrating right uh yeah i'm giving it a six all right cat uh yeah it's goal uh i think i'll give it a five as being i mean again very pretty very very aesthetically pleasing um until you until you really lean in you're like oh my i cannot see a goddamn thing that i need to especially because board games are so
fiddly or like they're they're physical and fiddly and you want them to be able to appease into the eye and ease on the player and when you're struggling like to to kind of just because there's a play it's like there's a flower down there but it's like you have to like really get in the right spot and hope you get looking to see it um but yeah so i mean like very pretty but also again with the biggest things are bringing down for me is the uh the fact that we were wanting to end it like please for the love of god someone end it kind of thing and then uh the fact that i mean it was so random to the point that it just completely ruined your last three turns and i mean like you can take the approach of being like well didn't ruin my last turn but right but like sure but that's not the point it's like that just means luck was on your side if it happened to me how many times did you flip me off throughout the game i flipped you off yeah i was getting into it because i mean the randomness of the of the pears and like when you just draw a pair and you're like oh that would have been smart to use it for if you're trying to draw up here which i did not right at all i mean goddammit if i didn't get pavilions yeah i'm not like i could have had four yeah and that's another thing is i i only i once i found this brazilian i was like oh okay another one shows up i'll get two just in case um never again did i see a pavilion yeah also yeah another nickel the elemental track was a little frustrating for me
in my experience yeah because i felt like it was a struggle because if you're not getting earth out you're not getting earth you're not getting grass out and it's like and when they're pivotal to getting the people out which are huge in game points yeah yeah that was very frustrating i'm like yeah give me some [ __ ] earth i mean we've got three turns it hinges so much actually this game on on turn order like it's i mean because if i play a tile that could give you the the room to decorate okay well if but then it's your turn but then i place a tower that closes off earth and so that means i bump up on earth well now you have no options for earth well i think i can kind of i guess i think i can see their mindset they were thinking that okay say the two players ahead of you placed a tile now they created that implementation to where you get to draw more um decorations so i think that's kind of what they had in mind right but at the same time when you do that they don't flip back so then everyone can get on a decoration kick while two are face down right so i don't know if there's like a way to you know change the kind of the flip back or something like that or or just change the the draw mechanic but i kind of see where they were coming from yeah yeah okay because i was just uh okay yeah i was just double checking that it wasn't like okay once someone decorates um that you know the tiles flip up but i am not seeing that so um
yep look at that in the event there are no free spaces to place decorations from the drawn decorations card the player discards all the duron decorations cards and their turn ends yeah it's just but yeah you're right the idea is that you want to take into consideration oh if i place this tile that's going to let them draw more decorations but it's inevitable like it's not like oh what's my other alternative i just draw two and oh didn't give [ __ ] anything so i wasted my turn oh now you get to place the tile you know i i just don't feel like it's balanced and yeah this this is kind of this track is just kind of there it doesn't really make any thematic sense either it's like oh i need to go up on these tracks to hire more people right it's just all icing but no cake that's why it's an average game so yeah that's it everyone that's our thoughts on tang garden let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful word every time a day is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you