Skip to main content
Loading video...

Container: AllPlay has brought back a legend - TCbH Review

Transcript 9:12

Psst. Hey, you. Yeah, you right there. You want to learn how to play Container, don't you? Well, nothing simpler. You want to get containers. What's in the containers? Don't worry about it. You got to produce containers from your factory, but these need to go to some docks, but you can't put them into your docks. No, you never buy your own containers from your factories. You're a fool. No, you need to set the price here, which is then going to be purchased to someone else's docks, where you can take your boat, drive it over and load the containers. Never from your own docks. You're not allowed to do that. But, once you do that, then it's on your boat and you set sail, boom, to Container Island, where everyone has the opportunity to buy out all the containers that are on your boat. But, if they bid too low, then you can buy them all out and then the containers unload into your section here, where they can be translated to delicious end-game points.

Yeah, you get the picture. Container is a weird game. It's not particularly difficult to take your turn. It's not particularly difficult to learn the rules, but it's weird in the way that economics are weird. It's sometimes hard to know why you do what you do and, you know, what makes a good turn. From a big picture point of view, you have two actions on a turn, which are largely moving your ship from the port to the sea, aka any space that's not a port, or from the sea to a port, or perform some action involving the production or purchasing of containers. Also, to that end, you can build new factories to produce and house several more containers in different colors at once, build more warehouses to be able to hold more containers on your dock.

Heck, you can start or bid higher on an auction using money for containers or containers for money in the kind of separate taxation offshore bank pool that sits off to the side, which if you're the highest bidder at the start of your turn, you win and the money you paid for containers or container you paid for money then becomes part of the pool to which you can be bid on in the future. And whether it's getting a good deal from another player, or it's delivering containers, or it's winning one of these auctions, it feels really good. I can't undersell how great it is to win one of those bids, or convince others to buy your stuff, or to buy another player's stuff and stick it on your boat. And when you finally bring it to Container Island and everyone has a chance for the last purchase, you feel like you have all the power because the winning bid from that final purchase is matched by the bank, one of the only instances in which new money enters the game. So, if someone bids 10 bucks, then that's going to be 20 bucks going in your pocket. And you can make a loads of cash. But on the other hand, the containers themselves may be more valuable as in-game points, and you have tough choices to buy it out yourself for going that bid and matched investment. Then the loop continues, and you begin to see everyone else at the table

are as much collaborators and assets as they are rivals and opponents. At its best, Container is a dynamic, nuanced, and exceptionally clever game where all players are exerting mutual pressure on the market and the pool of money within. And at its worst, it feels like the driest economics class Mr. Torrance ever taught, that's some bizarre, abstract fever dream of the valuation of widgets, aka containers, aka whatever, to produce money. The fact that you set your prices to invite or dissuade buyers, but are then locked in until further actions to rearrange, means that you're committed to prices for turns at a time, dealing with the consequences of your actions. And did you want to sell green cheap?

You want green for your final end-game scoring, so maybe it's better to sell cheap so other people will buy them and let set them onto their docks where you can buy them and put them onto your containers, but if you sold them too cheap, then you don't necessarily have the money to buy them from the docks, let alone when it finally pulls into Container Island, are you going to be able to match the price? But does that matter because if other people are paying really high, maybe that's even better than the price that you would have gotten from end game scoring of the containers themselves or at least some of them. So maybe instead you take a loan, get 10 bucks, but until you pay back the 10 in a single swoop, you're going to have to be paying interest of one buck a turn. And that's just one loan of which you could have two active at once. Point is, this is a game of speculation and not a little bit of social salesman skulduggery where you're going to have to actively persuade everyone else at the table that the deal that you got going is the deal that they want. And as a result of that, I find that people tend to have a kind of dissatisfying first experience with the game, but once you get through that play, once you start seeing the game for what it actually is, the people who like it really lock in. Now of course, we're talking about a game originally from 2007, released and re-released over the years with long periods of unavailability, developing a semi-mythic status, now falling into the capable hands of All Play who decided to deck it out with more premium upgrades than you can shake a neoprene stick at. So of

course, the version I'm covering right now has said upgrades, ridiculous metal boats and metal boxes and a plush ocean sail upon, even an expansion which includes upgraded little golden metal containers, but I should point out that the retail edition at $39 is still

no joke and your chiropractor will probably thank you for not throwing out your back because the metal upgrades make for probably the densest board game box that I've ever held. Also of note, this is not the OG version of the game. In addition to the sort of Play School illustrations, which I'll note I really dig, but I could see being kind of polarizing, this includes the offshore bank, the whole bidding system introduced in the 10th anniversary edition. This is a zone where certain payments like loan interest build up, and players can bid money for containers or vice versa, allowing alternative methods of obtaining containers or scoring cash when you just can't leverage that out of your opponents. It's more complicated in an already complex game, but it gives them mostly non-confrontational way to interact.

Sure, bidding is interactive, but you don't have to rely on everyone else's market to take part. The rules include ways to play without it, but honestly, I see why it needs to be here. It's worth the inclusion. I taught my 11-year-old this game with the offshore bank off the bat, and while he struggled at first, like every other person I've taught this game, by the end, he was a container pro. And might I add, very pro container. This is one of those games that hits a bit different. It feels ambitious and unconventional in ways that can be off-putting, but also exceptionally rewarding, though also situational. Do you have three to five players to play with? And of those people, do all of them enjoy games that demand interactivity? And do they enjoy games where the interactivity is not about beating each other's armies into the ground, but about something infinitely darker, capitalistic industry. Fortunately, my family unit of three enjoys the game, though we tend to prefer the short game, which slightly reduces the number of containers of each color in supply, and thereby also ends the game quicker. Though I'm sure there's purists out there who are like, "What the hell? No, the only way to play this game is with the long game variant, so that way you can really let the economic juices flow.

But, I imagine that All Play is banking on Container being more flexible in player count and audience than in how it's been perceived in the past. All together, I'm extremely glad for this reprint as someone who thinks a lot about hobby preservation, whether it comes to board games, RPGs, video games, music, or any other type of media, the fact that this legendary and iconic game is now widely available and in the hands of such a stable juggernaut as All Play warms the cockles. Though, for the fickle whims of the gaming audience, it's not the easiest recommend. Container is a game that I think everyone should experience at least twice. Though, from a certain point of view, it may be simple, it's a game that demands engagement, encourages risk, and absolutely rewards replay. And that's our review. But, let me know, what is your favorite abstract economic game? Put it in the comments below, and as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for doing the things that help us grow, the likes, comments, subscribes, checking out our Patreon, and of course, sharing these videos goes the distance, all the way to Container Island to help this channel thrive. But, above all else, thanks for being such a great community. You know that I've been Jack for The Cardboard Herald.

Progress saved