Katmai: The Bears of Brooks River Review - The Salmon Wars
Transcript
hi everyone I'm tally this is farell and we're Bor of it and today we're reviewing catm the Bears of Brooks River this is a two-player Jewel s game where you're both playing cards to your own side of the river to fight for dominance of your Bears you're going to place Bears out so they can catch salmon this is quite a nice theme based upon uh the real life Brooks River and the bears that flock to it uh during feeding season as they try to fatten up for winter so let's get into how to play and what we think but please note we provided this uh review copy from the publisher to play catm each player will have a deck of 12 12 bear cards and each round they'll take two of these out and put them to to the side so they have a deck of 10 bear cards and this is just to give a bit of variety round to around so you don't always know what's coming out then you'll take two bear cards you always have two in your hand and how the kind of round structure works is that the first player will take a bear card and put it against one of the river tiles on the kind of board here face down
and then the opponent will do the same and then you simultaneously reveal what the bear does and what its dominance is so the Bears mostly have kind of hard numbers for dominance one two three or four and some of the Bears have different effects which might affect that dominance it could be depending on what other bears are also placed there or maybe what other cards the opponent has on the other side of the river and the dominance is important because that is going to determine who kind of wins that River tile and therefore who at the end of the round can place a be on that River tile in a quadrant of their choosing the bear cards can only have three in each River tile so that's also something that needs to be considered when deciding which ones to play and the whole point of the game is to score objective cards and this is where the kind of placement of the beeps comes in so there could be simple objectives like have two beeps on Rock quadrants because every uh kind of tile or Big River tile has four quadrants with different symbols on them think there's five determining which kind of terrain it is so it could be that you need two bears on Rock tiles or it could be more complex objectives like have a connection of be uh across a certain amount of of tiles uh without touching
any waterfall quadrants or something like this if at the end of the round you manage to complete the objectives that are out you will catch a variable number of summon depending on how complex the uh objective is and the player with the most summon at the end of the game will win the game however the game can end um at any kind of point at the end of the round if one of the players has Z one or two be left in their supply or if there's a difference of four or more be between the players otherwise it will just kind of keep going round and around until that condition is hit two other additional kind of mechanisms are the initiative which is represented by the poor token so that will be the person who has that token to place their card on the river first but what's interesting is that you can elect to give the initiative to your opponent kind of force them to go first and they have to take that until the next round where they can then pass it back to you there's also another little mechanism where some of the bear cards uh have kind of a baby bear CB and in the event of a tie uh each player has this baby bearcub tile so when you kind of go through scoring to see who has the most dominance in each tile the person who has the initiative can choose to place this token to get the upper hand and score the dominance let's start with what we like
and I think for me uh definitely my favorite part of this game is the theming MH uh we're big Alaska fans so it's really I think we really appreciate the theming and the fact that the Bears are based on real life and it's kind of mirroring or it's a nice way of translating the fact that these Bears in real life have different behaviors and how they go about catching salmon and this kind of in incorporated into the actions they can do on the cards yeah yeah that's really nice that would be my number one thing I think I enjoy about the game the production quality is also super nice I mean you have little be which my least favorite part they call them be be bears are very nicely done the cards are nice quality I think the second thing I really appreciate the card play I I like the back and forth of playing the cards I like that most of the cards have these special little actions uh that you can use and I think they're interesting about what to play when um and I just yeah I think as you kind of touched upon the fact that both decks are basically the same you kind of then know what your opponent can play and once you have a few games you do kind of get the kind of meta strategy of being like well they haven't played this card yet yeah so maybe I should watch out for that and like holding them back yeah and you can use your cards kind of
offensively or defensively so after a few games I found myself clicking a little bit more with what you can do with everything available so for example um there's a card where if you play it and the opponent on the other side has the same amount of cards as you play then the dominance goes up so I was finding myself playing that almost like defensively like put it there and then I would hope that you then can't like play another card there because you're then increasing my dominance so it's like yeah I'm just GNA play that there even though the dominance is one in the hope that you then you know won't play another card there to increase my dominance or you can play kind of offensively by forcing uh your opponent to move cards around so yeah the strategies do become more open to you the more kind of games you play realize what you can do it's actually very maybe in the first game it doesn't for me at least it didn't quite click all of the kind of available options and you're like aha actually I can play this in this scenario to try and stop this or do this and it just becomes more light open and it kind of leads into maybe something that I did have an issue with which is the card Randomness and because you have a small hand of two cards at any point uh definitely have experienced that you draw your first hand at the start of the game or maybe first two hands you could say first two cards and some of the Bear's abilities are based on it kind of being the mid game
or the late game they let you move cards around or you're playing them kind of offensively yeah uh and I've had more than once I think where I've drawn the first hand and being like well these are really useless to play right now because I'm basically I have to play one of them and the ability isn't going to trigger or be of any use uh and that's something that kind of yeah annoyed me a little bit um I don't know if you feel the same um it didn't affect me too much but I guess I just got lucky and I could totally understand why you do feel like that if you pull those first two cards and like you say they're not super useful at the time both of them which could happen then that is frustrating I guess for me it didn't like happen in our games I think for me in like two out of the five or six games we played I started and I was like well like I'm wasting one of these cards now because I'm not using them tactically which was a shame cuz like I said I find them quite interesting maybe just one more thing that I did really like was the mechanism about how you can pass the initiative um to your opponent I think that is super interesting um because obviously in some instances maybe it's better to go first because you want to kind of get in there to maybe prevent the opponent playing a card where you want to go but equally sometimes it's better to go last so that you can try and either mitigate or you know especially at the end of the round where maybe those last one or two cards is kind of important where you're going to put them ex you want to see what the
opponent does and I think that's it's quite a fun always like gets a little smile out of us when we're pass it to the other person you're like haha I'm going to force you to go first um versus in some games I found myself wanting to try and keep hold of it because of the mechanism ex it's a really nice balance yeah so it's always that kind of decision do I to get the kind of upper hand of going second or should I keep the initiative so that I can be the one to play the um beup if you need to that's quite fun as leading on from that I think the game has that is most interesting in the very late stages of a round when nearly all the cards are played and that's when you have this ability to pass it on and CU there might be multiple battlefields which you know depending where they play a card you can lose that Battlefield so being able to force your opponent to have to go somewhere first you can see what they're playing and if you care or don't care or I think that yeah it's a definitely really like nice interesting little twist um verse you're giving away the tiebreaker if you do that yeah if you know is going to come out in a tie I think my if we kind of move to bigger problems I think my biggest issue is that I'm not sure what the longevity is like or the replayability because both decks are
essentially the same with some very slight variations you're playing the same cards every round and yeah there are a lot of objectives but it's one of those things where what really is a difference between have two peoples on rocks or have two bees on waterfalls if you know what I mean um and kind of the so there's different ways you can play more kind of competitive scoring or more friendly scoring but they all kind of follow the same pattern um and I just don't see me wanting to have a lot of games of this more than we've already played if that makes sense yeah there's not like so much more to get out of it let's say and but maybe that's fine not all games have to be that deep I guess it's just you know something that you could small books take around and play out and about um I think for me the thing that I had a challenge with is like you already touched upon a bit it it kind of for me any got more interesting towards the end of each round in the beginning of each round because there are like an amount of cars and you know there's kind of plenty of spaces say in the beginning you could almost just play randomly and just put one slap one down anyway where and that's actually what I ended up doing just sort of playing one somewhere where you hadn't gone and then only towards the end of the round start making a little
bit more strategic decisions about which ones I wanted to go after because in the beginning it's like you can put three cards on each one you might as well just go and then just see what you end up with almost there's kind of no point I found in trying to strategize about which places to get in the beginning because you can come back you know six cards can be played on each side yeah so it was almost yeah like less interesting for like half the round and then it only gets interesting when it kind of ends up mattering a bit more because you're kind of filling up the spaces I also personally and you will argue against this but I don't like how the game is like triggered to end um because basically if one person goes ahead in it could be around one or round two and puts uh more bees out and there's a difference of four but between them uh between the opponents then the game will end and for me that was a bit anticlimactic and I I get what you were saying we had a bit of a debate about this what you were saying is you know it's kind of you might as well just end it because one person's gone so far ahead that the other person basically can't catch up and there's like lack like kind of lack of space if everyone if one person has a lot of their Bears out but it just felt like it almost ended abruptly sometimes and for me I'd rather just continue to play the three rounds and see if I could claw some back in a way yeah um because
sometimes it would end in end in the first round even once I think one of the games I get your point because I think because I think there is a difference between having to meet certain criteria for scoring and that getting away from you if you keep kind of losing by having less peoples out but at the same time because really what happens is very is only dependent on the cards played in that one round as you say we had one round where I think I've won basically every game we've played except for that one and this was in the middle of the plays as well but then you basically took every terrain type in the first round of a game and then it ended because you put out six bears and I had like one left to play so it just ended um and that you know that wasn't as an effect of anything else that come before or after that was just that one round so you can have these swings depending on play yeah so I get your point there that's also a bit weird to cut it out before it gets going yeah why not just go another round and see if the other opponent because if I managed to claw it so far away in the first round who's to say you couldn't do that in the second round yeah and balance it out like if it's a it's a kind of tug of war a little bit why not just continue just to see like what happens almost so I didn't really like the way that it ended um yeah so I think turning to wrapping up I think this is something we said to each other when we're discussing it that I
think our biggest issue in recommending C my comes down to the kind of two-player head-to-head game Space is very crowded and there are so many Stellar games in that space and you know always a question now especially because it's not really doing anything particularly new is is it good enough you know to beat some of these top tier games um and I don't really think for us it it does enough I don't think we're getting it out over you know most other two-player duel games and I think part of that actually goes back to something you touched upon where you know when you're saying about the start of the game and you play and you might as well play random randomly what I found is because there's only like five symbols and they spread across all these tiles there's actually almost it feels like too much space yeah it's not when you're going like eventually you might need specific spaces if you're going for the higher Point objectives but because there is like so much space it doesn't to me have that really like tight tense feel of two-player jewel games it's very like loose yeah and it's nothing you really do it's annoying if you take something away from me but it's it's nothing like playing Ironwood or radlands or you know even um uh kind of Lord of the Rings Jewel right cap of Europe where you're like ah here
it's just like okay well I'll take this rock over here then in this other train I I won agree so I I feel like it almost would have been yeah like sharper if there was less terrain and it was more Savage because then because there's so much it's also hard to especially like you said at the start of the game focus on where to go cuz you could just go anywhere really you could pick two corners and only later on really tightening up no I think that's a good point maybe it is down to what I was saying it is down to space and it not being like super tight when in the beginning I was just like I'll just put this anywhere and I didn't really like care where I put it and I think we prefer games where kind of every decision is a bit of a dilemma basically and this doesn't really tick that so maybe you don't like things that are kind of tense and tight and you prefer to play more loose this could be something for you but we prefer that kind of tension and um for the decisions to like matter a little bit more I guess yeah no so I think there's there's a fair amount going for it kind of uh production price uh theme there is some nice card play it's just I think for us and the situation we're in having a lot of games playing a lot of two-player games more than the average person it's just yeah yeah harder to recommend for us and it's probably not something we'll be rushing to go back to because we feel that we've seen it not that we didn't enjoy it necessarily yeah is there any last words you'd like to say no I really love the
peop I hate the word people but uh I don't like the word people but I love the peoples yes they are great so that was our review of catm the Bears of Brooks River please ask us any questions you have about the game we really appreciate you watching and please consider subscribing if you haven't already and you found this helpful see you next time bye