Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is Sanctuary better than the original Ark Nova? - TCbH Review

Transcript 9:15

All right. Yeah, we're we're reviewing Sanctuary today. But first, I I gotta get this out of my system. What the f is this graphic design decision? I mean, the the there there's plenty of room on the box. Why'd you have to split the word? I mean, even Sanctuary, where you split it is awkward. Sanctuary. I maybe it's just me, but this is insanity. Absolutely unhinged. Namaste. Okay, this is actually a pretty good game. It's zoo time and brother, you're building. Each turn, a player takes one tile in the display, depending on the current strength of their project's action tile, then takes one of their four actions, either collecting more tiles in hand or placing tiles of varying types in their zoo, spreading out from their entrance to the furthest reaches, carefully sculpting to reap their benefits and maximize points.

Got a lot of rock habitats? Have animals that have rock habitat multipliers? Have primates? Maybe a special primate breeding project or specialist tile fits your fancy. Unlike its forebearer, everything in Sanctuary is relatively immediate. The tile is both habitat and animal, featuring familiar tags, action strength prerequisites, occasional immediate play effects, and unique ways of scoring. As you collect oodles of animals, and continent tags, you can back conservation projects set up randomly at the beginning of the game, netting big points and helping fulfill conditions to permanently improve the strength of your rotating action system. In a somewhat generous, though maybe too clean of a departure from Ark Nova, these conservation projects have no real contention between you and other players. Everyone come back at the same levels for all of the projects, or at least four of the projects. The only thing that's stopping you is actually getting the damn tags themselves. making sure you acquire enough Africa or reptiles or herbivores or what have you and deciding if you want to commit one of your four tiles at any given point in the game. See, if you feel really confident that you're leaning into the primate game, then you're not really sure when you get to two primate tags that you want to commit your level two

tag because you have a level two, three, four, and five that you're going to try to put out throughout the game. And if you think you're going to get a lot more primates, then maybe you want to hold off on backing it at the level two, saving that for something that's a little bit more of a side project later on and go for the five if primates are your thing. Once any player has put out all four of their conservation backing tokens or completely filled up all the land space in their zoo, then that triggers the end of the game. They get an immediate reward and all other players get one final turn to wrap up whatever they need to. After which you move on to an altogether fairly frustrating though familiar and frustrating that it's just all too common in modern Euro board games. Point calculation sesh. As a diehard Ark Nova fan, every aspect of this game feels like a consolidation and adaptation of concepts from the original, preserving challenge while greatly reducing complexity, contention, and time at the table. And while there are some additive concepts like buildings which can be freely built at the end of your turn if you meet the requirements, habitat types, pairing the male and female animals that if you get lucky enough to place together, you get bonuses, a general emphasis on proximity, which is really what makes this feel akin to

suburbia. And my personal favorite, these little conservation reward tokens that can be used in place of the tags that you're trying to acrue to back the conservation awards. You earn these through a variety of means. Most often the pairing of said male and female animals together, which gets you these conservation rewards that you can use to make up those tags to get out your conservation backing tokens all that much easier. It's clear that the intent of Sanctuary is to take the experience of Arkn Nova and make it just more manageable and in that it totally succeeds. It's only in direct comparison where it tends to suffer. Ark Nova is a big sprawling and somewhat spiny game that's success often in spite of itself.

The idea of sanding those edges is really intriguing to me. But Sanctuary's biggest flaws are where it smoothed just a little too far. The definitive balancing act of sequencing turns, managing money, keeping an eye on competition, and struggling to join separate but unifying tracks of capitalistic success and altruistic conservation is altogether gone. All of Sanctuary propels you in the same direction instead of making you feel like you wish you could be doing five different things at once. If just like 15 to 20% of the original's DNA were translated over here from competitive goals to maybe that separate conservation versus points track to a separate avenue to interact with the game outside of the tile laying itself like the partner zoos and universities which by the way all four of your actions either feed into drawing more tiles or playing tiles directly into your zoo just of different flavors. This would be in my mind the definitive game.

Both more polished and presentable than the original, but instead now I'm in the position where I like both. When I play either, I'll be wishing it had elements of the other. But they're so closely related that in the face of my own gaming and collection habits, it's hard to justify both in the long run. So for me, I'm going to need more time. I'm not prepared to let either game go. If you wanted a clear this is better than that sort of review, well, that ain't what you're getting. It's possible that like Aries Expedition did for Terraforming Mars, a very similar situation for me, an expansion will come down the road for Sanctuary that'll add just enough of the OG's DNA that I feel like it makes it tilt over the edge and I'm fully prepared to let the original go. I will say I really like it. Like I played games multiple times for each review that I do, but as soon as I got my hands on this one and played it, I just played it again and then wanted to play it again and kept showing my friends because it felt so good to play. It was so easy to teach.

It had a lot of compelling systems and that distillation of the game that I love hitting only an hour, an hour and a half or more than two and even less than that if you're playing solo, which is altogether a really good implementation of this game as a solo. It just is effectively playing the exact same game with some Ottoa to swipe some tiles from the market and working on a timer that gives you more points if you manage to succeed with one of the endgame conditions before the timer runs out. Okay, so brass tax trying to accommodate what most people are probably wanting to know out of this is if you own the original, you probably don't need sanctuary. I mean, if you love tile laying and popping off effects and things that are working symbiotically and having a lot of proximity bonuses, you know, that suburbia vibe, then I do think you're going to get a lot out of this game. But if you're wanting a more sprawling simulation, an attempt at actual zoom management with a lot of systems involved, then the original is going to be much more your jam. And that's our review. But let me know if you've played both of these, which is your favorite of the two. Have you decided to get rid of one versus the other after owning both? Put it in the

comments below. And as always, thanks for watching, supporting, liking, subscribing, checking out the Patreon, doing all the things that really help us. We are entirely audience supported. We don't charge anything to publishers for any of our reviews, so it means a lot when you do all the things that help support this channel, help it grow. But above all, thanks for just being a great community. You know that I've been Jack for the Cardboard Harold.

Progress saved