Does this long-awaited game live up to my expectations!? Planta Nubo Review
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today so in this video I'm going to go over a highly anticipated game of mine that is plantan nubo this is a 2023 design by Mike OD and Uber Rosenberg and if you are a stranger to my Channel or if you're not a stranger I suppose you would know that I love Uber Rosenberg games they are my favorite and so this is another reason why I was so uh excited to play this game this game is not shown here but it is produced in the United States by D or at least published and released and so I did receive a physical copy but decided to use tabletop simulator which the mod you know came on about a week or two ago so thank you to gc2 for all the hard work that was put into making this uh possible and it makes it easier for me to record and show you the components and give you my thoughts on this game so I'll I'll go over all of those a quick overview of how it works the game comparisons that I will make that remind me mechanically perhaps thematically to what plant anbo is all about and go over my final thoughts and review using criteria that I find important in a game so zooming out and and just to prove that I did indeed purchase this uh this is a tile that or you know a custom insert that I've used for tabletop
simulator that you know I took a picture of the solo bot which is the back of your player board you can see the components in the picture that I took and so these are rough and dirty you won't see these in the main uh build or mod for tabletop simulator but um you know this is how the AI works I suppose we'll get to this a little bit later so this is plantan nuo uh probably not a surprise to many of you who follow the latest hotness this game as mentioned before has been out for a year but in case you haven't seen this game or want a refresher of what this game is all about you are essentially tending a kind of a solar Punk type of garden uh it's floating in the sky and you know it's all about uh creating a sustainable and green energy source using these floating platforms to grow flowers and forests to to provide oxygen which gives you points and whoever has the most oxygen points at the end of the game wins you play this game over four rounds as depicted and marked by this telescope and you will do various actions throughout the game such as Gathering flowers or at least doing actions that will let you gather these flowers to make to to make deliveries to your own personal Freight containers as well as Freight containers that are publicly delivered to you do various things on
your Tableau such as placing these polyomino tiles on to get gain flowers you also have these one square soil markers that you can also Place flowers onto and hopefully you create a bottom foundational tier in order to place another Forest tile on top of that to gain income as well as the ability to flip these over for points as well in addition to all of that you are moving edise around this rondelle and building this rondelle out with cards that are collected from a uh a market here you have two types of cards you've got the endgame scoring cards which give you points in various ways and the module cards which give you extra actions that you are able to utilize throughout the game the interesting thing about these uh cards is that they run on on these tokens the some of them are more ongoing type of effects with these batteries whereas if you for example gain a uh module card at any time in the game you gain a certain amount of points based off of how many of these module or these batteries are on it versus onetime actions that you activate such as this one if you spent a action tile or a standby tiles what they're called then you get to activate this uh effect which means means you get to move your dice twice around or two spots around this Rond Del some of them
also offer abilities to store flowers away from the main Tableau in order to gain points and to just clear up space for uh forests to be planted as well and you can see some of these cards offer spots to collect them without the ability to score endgame points if you happen to have those flowers at the end of the game there are other things that you have on your personal board as well you have this bot charge Rondell that you can spend these bot points to do various things such as use uh any bot charge as a wild tile or cube that you can use for a delivery you can spend two of them to activate your actions twice which I'll get to in a second as well as progressing up this income TR or this uh uh I suppose I guess it's an income track for points you meet certain criteria that are listed here which are variable from game to game allowing you to gain uh points from income as well as bonuses onetime bonuses as you progress up that track I'm not going to go into every single uh feature about the Tableau or about the game but to wrap it up the Crux of this game is utilized via these tiles that you place onto this blueprint map that is randomized at the beginning of each game and you play them in between any one of these squares at least and that is touching a blueprint so um hence these uh rocks here that
aren't legal placement uh for the these action uh tokens and so these different blueprint actions allow you to do certain things such as gaining personal Freight containers to deliver to delivering to those public ones removing obstacles on your Tableau to be able to place out forcs and uh flower tiles Etc and soil onto it at a future time uh more delivery options here you get to activate one of your cards for free and gain soil tokens to your supply and then subsequently onto your board and various things such as flipping over uh you know Forest tiles gaining bot charges Etc uh so one quick note on the solo mode you essentially flip over a tile and it tells you uh what action it prefers on the ai's turn what tile it wants to utilize and where to place it on the particular blueprint the AI utilizes these different actions in a certain and unique way compared to how you would do as a player and there's always the optional uh opportunity for an extra action to be taken if the bot uses a bot charge uh there are different ways for the bot to gain extra points and uh progress up their own track as well for extra points and there are increasing difficulties the back of each player uh uh board board or Tableau as mentioned before has a certain difficulty from 1 to four and there are also different modes or variant that you
can add on top of that for an even more challenging experience in this particular go around the bot scored actually scored about 46 points or so and I I got up to 67 points and so uh this was at a level two Baseline and so it wasn't terribly terribly difficult but it was a learning game so I may have made mistakes along the way but that is essentially the game in a nutshell I I didn't talk about these crafting tiles uh the very last action in a in a round you'll take one of these actions which are variable in the game with the leftover action token that you have uh and so on and so forth and you rinse and repeat over four rounds and that is the game so let's get into some game comparisons so here are three games that I would like to compare plant anbo 2 mean mechanically there are I mean there are games out there of course that are more solar Punk thematically but these are the first three mechanically that came to mind and obviously they going to be a couple of Rosenberg games as well as an OD game so first with holler toow I find that there are similarities between the way that this game works PLO as well as how uh it mechanically moves from turn to turn I I feel like there are a lot of similarities between holler toow and this game one because because just like in holler tole where you are moving Boulders off of your personal Tableau to progress your uh Tableau further to get more points so as in this
game you are getting the opportunity to use actions to move these Boulders out of the way to gain space to be able to place more flower beds and Forest tiles on it for additional points as well as opportunities to place those forests down and so both games are all about this tableau progression and creating more space from the get-go in in addition to that with holler toow you are moving your uh Tableau board your community center from left to right as you move these Boulders as well as certain uh buildings from left to right you are essentially delivering resources to those buildings as you do in this game with these Freight containers there are I believe six different colors of flowers that you are trying to deliver to these Freights whether they are acquired personally or uh publicly here as you make these deliveries which I feel like is the main way that this game progresses for you uh because not only do you clear up space from the flowers that you have planted but you also get to move that dice around and allow for further actions and cards to be placed onto your Tableau and in holler toow it's similar where you are using not only cards that are you know individual and have different types of requirements that you need to meet in order to use them they also help you progress gain certain resources points at the end of
the game and it it's kind of like a deliver you know resource generation and delivery type of experience now it's it's different in holler tole because you do have randomized um cards throughout the game in this one you might be a little bit more deterministic in what you can deliver to however the way I mean it is kind of randomized to what colors are going to yield more rotations throughout your personal Tableau and so I I suppose there is random randomization to that but the the way that this game kind of progresses in kind of like okay I need to acquire more flowers of different colors and then deliver those to freights is it felt similar to how the cycle of the game of H to felt as well uh quickly over to Feast A Feast for Odin this game does not utilize a sprawling worker placement map of course and you know honestly this whole worker placement you know action selection drafting type of experience is unique to me and so I don't have any direct comparisons to how this works I'm sure there are other games out there perhaps even by oday and Mike that represent this portion of the game but A Feast for Odin felt in in two ways similar to plantan nubo one in the variations of cards that are found in this game just like holler toow whereas holler toow is more the cards were more of the ways to fulfill orders uh in that
game in this game just like in A Feast for Odin you have a variation of cards that give you endgame points to pursue or you know conditions to pursue for endgame victory points as well as efficiencies that you can utilize for actions whether they are just additional action that you can take or you know different ways to uh you know cleverly get to the uh you know what you want to accomplish on your turn and in general whether you can do it through the blueprint actions or not and so that's it felt similar to the variation and the abilities that the cards offer in the feast Rodin and then of course there is the Tableau building with polyomino tiles I could use any Rosenberg game that is polyomino in nature starting with Feast for Odin and Patchwork moving all the way up to his most you know recent games that utilize those mechanisms and tokens and pieces but in this game there is the you know a very literal puzzle that you're trying to uh figure out where to place these tiles especially these flower beds beds onto your Tableau in order to uh cover bonus spaces and also create that Foundation once again to be able to place your uh your Forest tokens on so it felt very similar to how you try to utilize different uh polyomino tiles in A Feast for Odin to progress your tlau and then finally Cooper Island this is not a game
that I've played but this is a game that has been compared to multiple times uh to plant anbo and I believe it's for the way that your personal Rondell Works in this game I think it's very similar to how it does in how it works in Cooper Island where you move around a tableau activating certain cards along the way you get to add cards to this Tableau making that Rondell progress a little bit slower but it offers the chance to uh utilize different cards in different uh you know sequences and ways you know to spice up the game for yourself make things more efficient and also to make the game feel different every time and so uh you know it's it's kind of a puzzle as well where you want to place these cards it all depends I feel on where the dice is currently when you acquire those those cards whether you want to quickly activate it again and place it ahead of the dice or if you don't and you'd rather wait for that card like these endgame cards to uh you know be behind the dice to not uh hinder the progression that the dice will make to allow for additional tokens to be placed on these cards for further activations and so I think that's very similar to how Cooper island is played so those are the game comparisons that I want to make and let's go into the uh uh the uh player reviews uh from Board Game Geek and what peers had to say both positively and negatively about this game so what I did was I ran a bunch of
comments that were made on this game into chat GPT from Board Game Geek in the comment section I I took some of the more lengthy and insightful comments both positive and negative and kind of came up with this uh this chat GPT generated uh summary of what plant anbo is about as well as what people say are the strengths and weaknesses of this game so a lot of people comment on the unique mechanisms of this game how puzzling it feels the solo play is fairly easy to run and the production of the game seems to be pretty good as well however for weaknesses a lot of people had issues with the rule book a lot back and forth with the organization of the book as well as how lengthy it is uh if you notice here in uh you know there are 32 pages to the rule book in general and so and overall and that includes the solo play so it is a lengthy rule book and uh more on that with my comments later a lot of people felt like there was a lot of complexity to this game a lot of fiddly bits to the way that the tabl works the way that the rules play the edge cases Etc some people didn't really feel connected to the theme and because of the fiddlin and the amount of complexity that this game requires to play uh rules-wise as well as strategically there was a lot of downtime and lack of accessibility to
you know bring players up to speed this is a definitely a heavier game more on the rule side as well as the uh strategic the Strategic depth of this game as well and understanding the administrative overhead of of this game basically understanding needing to understand what all the icons mean and how certain edge cases for rules plays out as well uh creates a lot of overhead to learn the game Upfront and so I mean with you can read this on your own time if you wanted to but like for General consensus people were given this rating about a 6 to 7.5 on average out of 10 on Board Game Geek and I believe the all rating right now that is weighted is like a 7.2 on on Board Game Geek so take that as you will but let's get into my own ratings for this game so getting into my review of plantan nubo here are the 10 criteria that I am using to rate this game for myself and these are things that I find important in games and I will get an overall score at the end of it so let's start with the rules teach and streamlined play um just going off of the I guess the the get-go off the top of my head I think the score that feels just about right as a four this game is heavy uh to learn it is an extensive rule book and with the disorganization of this rule book is it's just exceptionally tough to really wrap your
head around as I was playing this game it's if you are familiar with a lot of these mechanisms then you do have some sort of a scaffolding to fall back on but uh you know unfortunately this game uh has a lot of back and forth when it comes to the rule book uh if I were to to give you a comparison I recently learned how to play cvoluion which is a an equally heavy game with a big rule book as well however I felt like I could read that rule book from front to back and I did not need to refer to it as as often as I would with plantan nuo as I played that game and I feel like this kind of tag tags with a streamlined play yes there are icons in this game that allow you to understand what is going on at a visual level but the icons don't give you all of the information that you need to know in order to just play this game after reading the rule book once which is an optimal thing to do and of course every game you're going to ref refer to the rule book every now and and then but in this game for example uh I was in my learning game and I did not realize that when you placed a soil tile or even the flower beds you could place especially with the soil tiles a random or not a random but a a wild color of your choice a type of flower onto that soil bed and I think it's buried in the rule book somewhere but it's not as easily intuited just from the the game
itself you know and so setting up this game too was kind of a nightmare just because I I didn't know to play it Solo or to play it two-player that the board would look different from how it is represented in the example page which is for a four player game so you know it did take a lot longer for me to understand this game despite my background in Rosenberg games as well as uh you know Euro games in general and so it it wasn't a very enjoyable uh you know situation to to or experience to learn this game skill expression you know how how VAR variable and deep can the strategy be in this game uh I think it could I think it could be okay I'll give it a seven I I think the way that you play this actually a six let's go for a six um there are different ways to score points in this game and I feel like the cards that are offered in the uh Market of cards that you're going to uh draw from as well as your own personal goals that you're trying to ascend can give you some guidelines and I think that is important to do is there a way to really score points that is aside from those guidelines that are given to you based off of the cards as well as uh what's in front of you on your Tableau uh kind of you know you you can draft starting modules as well to add a little bit of complexity at the beginning of the game is as you understand this game more to give you a
you know something to jump off of and pursue from the get-go but I I feel like there's a lot of tactical decisions to be made as the market is pretty Dynamic uh there is a variant where you can look through the cards or cycle through the cards twice as fast as you would in a normal game and so there are a lot of tactical decisions and to me it felt like you know as opposed to the tacticle uh nature tactical nature of a lot of other Rosenberg games I feel like in those games you do have a base understanding of what you want to try to accomplish and the Tactical nature can really spice up the game and offer tantalizing you know side Avenues to gain further points whereas in this game I felt like you know in in the future it it kind of rinses and repeats right it you are pursuing the same things over and over again just delivering flowers to Freight containers moving your Rondell Etc right and so it's it's pretty straightforward what you're trying to accomplish and you're just looking for really minute efficiencies along the way with the cards and the goal tiles that you're trying to pursue with and so you know it it it didn't feel like there was a lot of skill expression uh in this game but there is some to react to what is being offered from round to round the mechanism uniqueness and execution uh yeah you know I I think it it was pretty well executed I'll give it a seven the once again the the way that you draft actions in this game felt pretty unique and so I think that very that carries
the Crux of what I feel is unique about this game you know there is a rule where you have to place a certain action tile of a certain type or color uh that it or I should say you can't place it onto a blueprint or next to a blueprint that already has that type of tool present and so there is interaction and I I guess we can talk about interaction now uh with at higher player counts where you can place those uh action tiles you know so I would say there's a fair amount of interaction based off of that at a three or four player count uh I guess the board let's let's move it down to a six because the board does really accommodate a higher player count and based off of my experience which has been one in two players it's it feels like the board is fairly open enough to allow you to take the actions that you want to do uh it really only comes down to what tile are action tile are you going to save for the crafting phase and you know what kind of action would you like to take with that right and so uh you know there is enough interaction to beat your own opponent to certain cards from the market as well as certain actions but you typically have an a good alternative way to accomplish what you want to in this game so it it doesn't feel as tight as it might look essentially thematic integration you know I'll give it a uh I I don't want to be as biased as most people are where they say this game it does not feel very thematic as at all
you know so I'll I'll probably go for four I I do enjoy the fact of like placing down in the rule book it explains that you place down the soil and flower beds on on the bottom to create a fertile environment for forests to build be built up right uh you're not really like like you look at this cover you know you're not really building a city or you know a sprawling environment for people to live in you're essentially just tending a garden and you know great you creating forests and and nothing more than that and so uh this game I do feel focuses more on the mechanisms rather than the theme and unlike other Rosenberg games where I feel like there's a lot of thematic and mechanical integration one with another this game felt more leaned more towards the mechanical side than anything uh there's plenty of variability I think there are a lot of different cards that you will see throughout the game you see I would say about half of each deck if you're playing with the twice as fast variant uh with when it comes to cycling those cards and with the starting cards as modules as well to create an asymmetric start for your own Tableau the different types of Tableau each have different bonuses in different spots that allow for variability of play the solo game has a lot of different challenging uh tiers to try it at and so um and so yeah for variability and replayability well there's a lot of variability in this game for replayability probably give it
you know a five and average score because once again going back to that streamlined play and skill expression it just didn't feel like I was doing much more uh you know different things from game to game right it felt like it was pretty much the same thing uh that is only spiced up by little things it it didn't feel as drastically different as a type of game like like civan like I played recently and newford that I also brought back to the table and re experienced I feel like each game is variable but also can really push yourself into different Avenues of and you know nooks and corners of the game uh to where your Tableau looks a lot different the amount of you know different things that you AC you know acrew from from that game to game just felt more grandiose in those than it did in plantan nubo fun Factor I'll give it a six I think it's fun to figure out the puzzle each time and you know there are a lot of cool little combos that you can stack on top of each other when you place a tile onto a bonus you gain a certain type and then you know you can gain all the flowers that you need to make deliveries on you know your turn or the next turn Etc and so it flowed pretty well but uh you know it's honestly wasn't the most fun experience one because of the rules uh complexity uh and as well as the uh lack of replayability for me the solo mode was pretty good I'll I'll still give it a six out of 10 because um maybe a seven
out of 10 it it no let's go back down to a six I did feel like the the solo mode in particular was difficult I always had to have the rule book in front of me because even though there are icons to explain what each action does for that is different and unique for the AI opponent there are always edge cases as far as like delivery how deliveries work different conversions that you would make flowers and this kind of spoke to my overall experience that I I felt like I was always forgetting something and you know always remembered something a couple of turns in the future as far as like what uh certain you know things did I I missed a certain sub action or a certain way that the AI would gain points here and there so I you know I showed my score earlier I'm not very confident in in that score because I feel like I felt like I made you know plenty of mistakes despite having already learned this game and played it before so you know it it's somewhat easy to to utilize but at the same time it's hard to I think utilize correctly and then finally strategic competitiveness uh probably give this a five as well I I think you can learn how to play this game pretty efficiently but it's very tactical in nature and and there's a lot of Randomness to what cards come out and what crafting tiles come out in what order and it's all about uh grabbing the most efficient cards and tiles and action you
know sequences as you can rather than uh coming up with a baseline strategic uh you know Pursuit from game to game that is you know spiced up with tantalizing different you know uh tactical offerings from here and there it's it you know it it doesn't feel like an arc noova or an agrica in the sense where as you play this game more and more you get better at this game I feel like the the ceiling is lower in plantan nubo than it is in those games and you can probably maximize your efficiency uh pretty quickly because it all really comes down to the uh tactical uh turn-by-turn you know strategy offerings that are in this game it actually felt more in line with holler toow where I I felt like even after like 10 15 plays of holler toow even before then the the scores that I would be getting kind of plateaued I could probably squeeze out a few extra points here and there if I played the game more but you know there was a point where I felt like I understood what was going on with this game and it was relaxing to come back to and revisit that puzzle but I feel like plantan nubo offers that same ceiling that you can probably get to pretty quickly when it comes to your score but unlike tow which felt really relaxing and really cool to pull off different combinations with the cards that you
have in your hand once again to harp on the complexity of this game I felt like there was you know so much going on with the rules and with you know different phases it kind of felt clunky you know as as I played it it didn't feel very streamlined and it kind of hurts the effort that I would want to come back to this game and play it to really feel cozy with you know the puzzle itself is cozy enough I suppose but but the upkeep of you know the rules burden that you have in this game I think is a little too overwhelming for me and and the way that my brain works unfortunately so telling up my score it's a 5.7 out of 10 I tend to be you know I average lower on my ratings as I've begun to do this and this is quite low for me I think this was a lot lower than I had anticipated it being at the get-go I I think plantan nubo is still a fun game I like the DNA of what Rosenberg might have brought to this game when it came to like the polyomino puzzling as well as the variations in cards but Mike and OD have also done that as well and I feel like you take games that I've enjoyed by that duo such as L granha where it is a very phase oriented type of Euro game but the the Tableau building and and the variations of the game just in L granha for example felt uh better and more streamlined than
it did in plantan nubo and unfortunately I do feel like this game is quite complex too complex for what it ends up being and it it doesn't have the this the Strategic you know uh variations and uh ceiling the skill ceiling that I'm hoping to find in a game such as this uh it doesn't as much of a thematic integration as well as I was hoping it would have but you know overall you know it's it's worth trying out to see if you enjoy that I and a lot of comments mentioned this game is really probably best played at one or two players I would agree I think this game would be very long at those Higher Play counts and would I would rather return to this game by myself or with someone else who would be interested in playing this but with the people that I play with with normally they wouldn't I don't think would enjoy how long it would take to learn this game and play it properly so for that it is a 5.7 out of 10 for me so uh let me know what you think about plantan nubo I know this game is over a year from its debut but here in the states it is brand new and perhaps if you have the chance to find this game now you know what what I I feel about it and if that's worth something then that is you know that is great for me so and for you as well so thank you for Consulting with me and hope that you schedule an appointment with your board gaming doctor real soon
I'll catch you on the next one take care