Skip to main content
Loading video...

6 Negative Reviews - Fairy Tale Inn, Rattus Cartus, Saboteur, Design Town, Monstargh!

Transcript 10:37

hey everybody today i'm talking about six games that i really didn't like at all unfortunately now this doesn't tend to happen very often because i do vet my games quite carefully but sometimes things slip through the cracks and i don't really like doing this but you know i think it has to be done and it is necessary so i'm going to be as brief as i can with these because i don't want to kind of um kick a dog when it's down but let's get started and i'll start from my um my most favorite one out of these um and it's slowly declined into my least favorite so the first game i want to talk about is fairy tale inn which is actually i think only came out last year actually by paulo mori who is a great designer he's made some fantastic games and i was really excited for this one because this one really did try to put a new twist on the connect 4 mechanism where you have this vertical board or vertical plastic structure basically and you're trying to put these tiles in trying to get points and money in different ways i thought that was a really interesting idea i think there's a lot of potential for a game to use that classic connect four system but to bring it into this day in in gaming but this game i felt really did miss the mark so this one you have a bunch of different these um fairy tale fairy tale characters you're putting them on as you would with a connected four piece but you're trying to kind of line them up in different orientations to get money and points sometimes you want to get majorities in terms of the rows sometimes you want to stack ones on top of others or diagonal to others all to get rewards in different ways or even punishments in different ways the problem with this one was that i thought all the ways the tiles interacted and their powers and benefits

were all so bland and boring the decisions always felt extremely obvious about what to do and just there was no spark there you just kind of played on autopilot and before you knew the game was over with little to no fun to be had from that experience now i am somewhat lenient on this game because i think maybe it is well of course it is tailored towards a younger audience it has that mass market feel to it and i think it could be successful if you know to the right audience but for me it was just not good um and you know you could say a big unfair on a light game but there are millions of or thousands of really light games out there that are fantastic this one was just bland so um therefore i think fairy tail in really did miss the mark and um yeah it was a missed opportunity really the second game i'm talking about is monstar by mega corp and games who had colossal hits with scandalous and awkward guests this one is a much smaller little abstract card game as you're basically trying to have the majority of your color of monster on display after all the actions have been taken and all that action consists of is moving one of these cards which have again a monster type and a number on it you're trying to overlap a an animal or a monster with a lower card value than yours or exactly one lower card value and there's an alternative action where you can suck cards adjacent to you under yours so you're basically trying to have the most frequent type of your monster on display at the end of all these actions or potential moves could be made um the thing about this game was that not only are the actions extremely boring it was

dry to a fault i mean there was like literally no flavor in this game whatsoever no spark no nothing fresh nothing interesting but also that one of the parts of this game that was supposed to be the hook was that you had a a secret role no one knew what monster you were so therefore you had to kind of think and deduce what you were trying to do um and to decipher what monster you were so they can maybe try and engulf you but for me after one turn or two it was so obvious about which role people were that it kind of rendered that whole part of the game completely defunct so i just thought this was not interesting whatsoever it was boring it was um just just just awful really so that is monster uh it was the second game the next game is rattus cartus this is the card game version of the um of rattus which is an actual a game that i want to try this one is a pushy luck and hand management style game as at the start of the game there's going to be a number of these cards placed face down and on those cards there's going to be a number of these rat symbols and that is going to determine to determine the limit of rats you can have in your area at the end of the game and if you ever go over that limit when it comes to the end of the game you are automatically going to be disqualified from winning but what a turn consists of in this game is by flipping one of these objective cards over then each player almost attributing a number of cards to the objective of the matching type so you could say have this you know the church symbol when you're playing a number of church cards and depending on who or how many cards you play of that matching type determines how far you're

going to climb up on these tracks and that is basically what the game consists of to this i think there's six different suits of cards with a corresponding track to each of those but the problem was that none of these tracks had anything unique about them they're all exactly the same completely zero sum tracks where you could see exactly what other people were going to do and there was no like checkpoints or anything to make it interesting to reach certain points on those tracks which i think is completely necessary with a game like this and additionally a lot of these times in this in this game you were just completely top deck cards from the from the stack of cards which is fine but the problem was that you could end up acquiring a bunch of cards that the objective never came out that matched with it so you could have a whole bunch of cars here that are just useless and you could say yeah there is there is this option of putting cards down which will give you rats but you still got up the track when it doesn't match which is fine but the problem is that you are almost completely blind to how many rats there are there are ways you can have a look at them but sometimes that rat limit is so so low that you don't even have that wiggle room to put those cars down into it actually enjoy that push you like mechanism so there was just a combination of moving pieces here that just didn't come together in a good game it took way too long i'm talking 45 minutes here with next to no decision space and i'm excited it just was not interesting the game could completely swing against you through no fault of your own and i just did not enjoy it one bit so that is rattus cartis next up is a design town also known as

flip city i believe and i'm not sure the differences between the two but this one is like a almost like a deck building pushing luck style game as you are revealing cards and trying to acquire money to buy new cars all with the aim of reaching a certain amount of points and to be the first to trigger that so i think it's really easy to make a good poster luck game you know it's a very visceral mechanism um something you can get invested in quite easy because you know who doesn't like the idea of am i going to go bust or not for some reason this game managed to make that unfun it was convoluted there was too much here that didn't need to be there um it was long ago this game took 45 minutes to play and it was just excruciatingly long boring and tedious and again i i find it baffling to to um to understand how a game manages to get pushy luck wrong um it's not a hard thing to pull off and uh this game managed to do that and none of the buildings were particularly interesting when you'd upgrade them and flip them over which was supposed to be one of the hooks of the game um it just felt like an absolute slog and a massive game i'd highly avoid um you know this was supposed to be a filler push-a-lot game and it just managed to completely go astray of that and um was a big big miss for me so that is um that is design town avoid at all costs the next game i'm going to talk about is saboteur so this is a traitor style gamers basically all but one playoff maybe two are going to work together try and build this network of tunnels to reach these different cards and basically to try and find this gold

gem i think but the problem is that one of these players involved i mean you don't know who that is is the saboteur and they are trying to basically divert you off track um and to avoid you getting to those gems before all the cards run out or just to prevent you from doing so um i quite like the idea of this and i thought it could be good but in practice it's an absolute mess of a game there's some really horrible take that moments as you can play these cars just to completely nullify the abilities or the the capability of any player taking an action on their turn which was really boring you know when it's your turn and somebody please just take that card on you you just have to waste your time to get rid of that um that negative defect and it just it's just really frustrating and annoying additionally you'd always find that people would work together to a certain point and then all of a sudden the saboteur become overly obvious about who it was then start diverting you off because there just wasn't that potential to do anything else so i could see what it was trying to do it just didn't pull it off again i hated that idea of playing cards in front of people in order to stop them doing anything on their turn it just was just not fun at all i suppose one thing about this game is that it does cater to a higher player count um and it's i suppose uh a different direction to a past game when you do tend to have this pla play accounts but for me the game still did fall very flat and i just do not enjoy the game simple as that and the final game i'm going to talk about today is a game called get out of colditz um i think this one was purely a kickstarter game i'm not sure if it's

still widely available but despite that the game is absolutely terrible so this one is one of those games where you're trying to lay out i believe it's three cards of the same title or two cards and then one of your escapees and the idea is you're trying to escape from colbits um but you're basically playing these two of these rope cars or two of these tunnel cards um and you're basically trying to be the first player to get to a certain amount of these prisoners being escaped but this one was one of those really dated games where you are just playing cards to cut your opponent off or to wipe their cards back and it has like constant back and forth um just start stop start stop start stop it comes becomes so frustrating and so tedious um and you just want it to come to an end before it does it drags on too long there's zero decision to be had in this game and it's just an absolute catastrophe i would just could not recommend um this game to anybody really there's just no there's no really redeeming features about it it's just awful so that is get out of coldness also had one of the worst art styles i've ever seen basically these these filtered photographs of these action men it just looked awful as well as the gameplay being awful enough

and for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved