Dune vs Dune: Uprising or Imperium? Board Stupid Recommends.
Transcript
hello and welcome to board stupid my name's Wayne and I'm Matt and you'll notice in front of us we have what's widely considered one of the best games released in the past decade or so which is June Imperium yes and we're going to do a dune versus Dune today June versus June yeah we're going to just discuss a little bit about the the game and discuss what the difference are between the two and uh which one you will have to pick if you're looking to buy one or exactly if you already have the original one should you buy the new one all of these questions and more we will discover after the jump but if you want to avoid being eaten by the sandworm and you want to dance through the desert what's something they should do M I think if you hit the Subscribe button right now all those things are not going to happen so you're going leave your live in um yeah it's famously in the June law that if you subscribe to board stupid the sand worm do not eat it's one of the prophecies one of the Prophecies of J exactly and if that's not enough for you we've got a very special little discount code in the description below if you would like a wonderful new set of t-shirts or casual wear from our friends at into the am please check out the link for 10% off on top M of any other discount you can find already on the website so not yeah it it's at 10% on top of whatever and the guys usually do a lot of like buy3 pay two and all that
kind of stuff but double check they got a new new design coming every month basically so and the super graphic the fit is great the print is amazing so certainly check those out there wonderful t-shirts with some great clothing so go do that hit the Subscribe button uh run away from the sandworm and let's find out which of these is the one that you should buy so Matt for the people at home what on Earth is J Imperium if they've never heard of June Imperium tell us a little bit why is it a big deal all right so June Imperium is first of all one of our favorite games one of our favorite games yeah so um and uh it's basically a deck building work placement game that that's what it is however it's one of the best of its gener and uh this is completely deach from the theme I mean it's a very good game even if it was whatever other theme however is even better because the team and the mechanics they just got hand inand in a perfect way so if you're already fan of the of the IP uh the is a is a must have you are fan of um deck building work placement this is your game if you f a both that's it if you want strategic Euro game yeah this is great it's got lots of things for lots of different people it's a great mid to heavyweight deck builder SL that work work placement game it's a tremendous strategy game and we did play with
people that don't care about the theme and literally don't care at all and they really like it so um absolutely absolutely fantastic uh the UN Imperium came out now what uh three four years ago I want to say yeah at least four years ago now while durum Uprising is B basically a version 2.0 version 1 fiveish and that is um um the difference is this is the original game this is a standalone expansion that plays as a core game basically this is where it gets confusing because when you look at these two things you're like this looks kind of similar but it feels like if I if I want this I should buy this right but that's not the case this completely Standalone product so let's talk a little bit about the game um in general Mt I think one of the things that makes it so good is this is a game that gives you really hard crunchy decisions every time it's your turn right you'll have your hand of cards and what this game does really well is where you place your worker will depend on what cards you have yes because each card will tell you some spaces where the workers can go so you'll be torn between okay which card do I use to put my worker out or um what cards do I want to keep in my hand because later in my turn I'll have a reveal phase and anything left over will get me some sort of bonus Yeah so basically during your turn you will play your cards placing your workers getting bu bonuses getting what the resources
all the action related to that specific position but the cards that you don't want to play at the end of your turn will give you either money or fighting Power for the for the battles yeah uh or all the bonuses but normally generally going to be uh buying power or fighting Power absolutely and the buying power will let you get the cards from the open market so you can buy more cards like any deck builder yeah exactly so you can start building your Combos and stuff and the while the fights that going to happen at the end of each round are going to be basically how you getting more points or other type of bonuses yeah and the fights in junior Imperium are bloody are brutal everybody eventually dies at some point uh but it is a big abstraction of of warfare but it's done in a really amazing way uh where you're been throwing troops into the desert and uh playing cars to try and up your power before eventually uh you'll resolve everything and hopefully be the winner and one of the amazing things about this game Matt is it's a race to just 10 points yes and every points really counts you feel it there is ways where you can steal points from other from other um players um during the game one of the mechanics in the games is this like um allegion to one influence with the different factions like the bener or the fman the emperor the emperor yeah and um uh but um up up to a certain point you can get points
with those faction but if someone's got more influence than you it's not like they're going to get a point they're going to take your point exactly um so that that was um what's Mak the the game really really um TS yeah uh cuz it's just 10 points and each single points really really count you feel it if you lose it you feel it if you gain a point you feel it if you manage to do a round where you get two points in a round you are flying and it is uh very very again very impactful very interesting very crunchy decisions every single round the production of Jude Imperium I think is great it is a I've had some heard some criticism saying that you artwork is a bit flat but it's very much based on off the new movies movies yeah think it's fine in more in um in in that kind of like cartoony um real realism cartoonmy hyper car um but yeah all the all the graphics are based for the cards the character and everything on the new uh movies that coming out especially dude Imperium is based on the first of the on part one while do Imperium Uprising is based on part two and saying that I will go and touch a little bit more about what is actually really different from the two let's dig into the
differences okay so I think one of the most obvious changes that you would find uh if you had to play J Imperium and then suddenly open Imperium Uprising is that the board is quite different there are various different space and little elements of the board that make it very separate from the original board right it is um probably First Look is going to be like yeah same but actually actually not um uh you will start finding um spaces for what they're call the spies um you're going to find spaces for the contract yeah um and um you're going to find the sandworm symbols sandworm symbols all over the yeah all over the board um so let's start breaking down so uh what Uprising at from the from the from the normal things the three main mechanics are the spies they are basically uh token workers that you can place in between places where they can basically your spice can be on the lookout on a couple of different location and you can basically um put one of your workers on one location that already been used by by someone else that makes it quite a big difference with the original one where it's a like a normal worker placement where only one worker can go on the single location it gives you the ability to then you know use something that someone else could have otherwise have blocked the spies can also be used in another way by giving you more card draw so you can
take your spy off the board to then draw an extra card and talking about extra cards um I I find that the deck building in Uprising works better just because you got more spaces on the actual board to take action to draw more cards or to um to trash all the cars that you the cha that you don't want um anymore and I find that makes the de building going faster and I really like it because I found the deck building in this game is really good so yes this is a more Dynamic deck building approach this one is a slightly more static deck building approach where it is less forgiving than this one so once you start buying cards they're probably going to stay in there for a while yeah exactly this yeah it's it's more Dynamic you can go faster in your so you can build more combos I find it more interesting and because deck building is one of my favorite thing and the more I can do the better is um the the uh the basic cards are less less trashy than the than here so it's more it making a choice on which one you want to trash is more difficult and that is always um good it's more C decisions right more interesting crunchy decisions yeah and uh the other uh new mechanics that we say are the contract so it's basically uh will um give the player who are going to do this or that certain action so you as an action you
can take a contract they will tell you okay whenever you're going to achieve this thing you're going to get some um some points or money or spices and most of the time it's going to be like oh you need to place your worker this or that that makes it again more dynamic because um maybe I got no interested at all on going to a certain location however the contract will push me to do it and create different Dynamics within the other players absolutely sometimes those contracts can make a location that you are previously completely uninterested in really appealing cuz actually by doing this contract will get this extra resource which in addition with this will let me get this and then let me pull off my combo right it can really change the game absolutely and uh the last big things that's is not present in uh the original game are the sand worms um I and I love it like you can't have tun without sand worms so so um uh so sandworms basically will help your Army in battle and if you win the the battle with a sandworm you're going to double up your um U your income from that specific battle and that means a lot cuz again as we said earlier it's just 10 points so if on a battle you made one point or two points or two points or four point that is a big difference a huge deal if you're getting one or two
spikes that becomes yeah four Spice you can then use for everything else there was a game that we played Matt where I think I won a couple of games early with the sandw and they gave me so many resources exactly it just it really set me up for the game so it's very important I think the the sand this game um I heard that some people find it like a little bit too overpowered swingy um I think it's it's thematic uh so you still need to go through a process before you can't just go randomly P worms you have to go and get a thing for yeah you need to have a a certain what yeah before that you need to be friends with a fr C then you need to need to get your yourp and then you can start getting right a whole process it's not like everybody's getting in but my suggest like if you play the game trying to get a s worm as soon as you can because that's those are are really important and um yeah on top of that one thing production wise so in the games there are all uh mles it's all like it's woodles for the most part yeah wooden cardboard um and there are four Ms for the sen that absolutely make no sense at all they gave you wooden meeple sandworms yeah and then they gave you plastic mini sandworms and said use all of these frankly I would have rather all be wood yeah I I would have preferred just all wooden and then and then maybe buying an
expansion a pack for all the meis uh Min absolutely pointless in this game uh but hey um that's a weird that's a weird Choice weird production choice I yeah I have no idea why the guys did it um D wolf if you thereare please let me know I mean don't get me wrong The Minis are absolutely gorgeous I don't understand why yeah um anyway there's another thing I want talk about just very briefly you talked about the sound being another thing this game also includes uh the wall around yes so around aren I think it is yeah so so um there is um there are three or four location that are inside the the city and at the start of the game you will have a wall in front of that city um that means that if um the battles the difference between these two again your battle cards are basically named after a territory it's just making it more thematic like oh you fighting in here or you fighting in there well in here it's just but normal they are they do have names with a less impact for it's less less important um going back to the wall so you're going to have this three three location I think inside the city then if the wall is up you cannot use your sand W yeah so you need to go through another process that will let you destroy that wall to make so to to make uh your worms available to fight in the in those location which I think is
tremendously thematic obviously goes along with the story of June obviously I I played po of tradies in the last game so my first thing was how do I blow up that wall how do I get that was that was great I loved it yeah um so yeah again another little addition to the um to the game and um I think that's very very nice yeah and other big differences between them Matt um what I will say is um well it can be swingy toward the end more than than Juni Jun Imperium dun imperian is very much one point one point I got two point I got one point um um Uprising with the fact that you can double up your points with your with your worms at the toward the end in the end game you can literally probably do like four or five points all together in one single turn but again that's the magic it's just like you're trying to save all your resources to have like a a very big swing at at the end it also gives the ability to have big comebacks from behind I think set upate yeah and I I really enjoyed it yeah all right should we dig into I suppose some more General preferences M about what one what yeah let me let me add a couple of more things so first of all if you got the original one and you got the um um the two older expansion oh what's the name rise of X and immortality the expansions
can be played in Uprising yes like you take the expansion you play here actually for the uh rise of the X you got some special contract and some special tokens already inside the box so you can you can do it you can take the expansion and play it straight with the with the uprising you can take all the leaders from here and put it in in the in this box as well so you can play with your original leaders and and this one you can in theory mix up all the cards from the original game to here not really sure if I will do it you could if you wanted to but the Char the character probably yes if you are really attached to to some characters you can you can definitely do it what I will say I feel the characters from the from Uprising are slightly better more interesting more interesting and um some cards got like um like um um a tree that you need to follow yeah various other things you can do with them I find a little bit more characters less less vanilla yeah um but yeah so that that it means that if you got the expansion you can play it with this now now if you don't have any of these two okay now we're getting into it which one would you get okay so I own this this is mine this is my copy of jun Imperium and this is
mine and that's your copy of jun imperian uprising here I've put in rise ofix okay I think June Imperium with rise ofix is amazing yeah I June Imperium vanilla by itself is a wonderful game it's a great game if I didn't own either of these without a shadow of a doubt this one couple of reasons why this has in the base game already the additional content and crunch that I wanted from Rise of VI what I mean so I Lov T Imperium when I got rise of Vick I was like that improves an already great game this comes with that kind of kind of built in that yeah like there's that for sure also what June Imperium Uprising does is it adds a couple of those extra thematic Elements which if you're a fan of June makes it even better yes so like you said about the sand worms and the wall and how that works and the process that is also fantastic so definitely that I also think I'm going to roll off a couple of thoughts while they on on my top go on go on this is the more forgiving game than this yeah yes so the fact that you can have bigger swings this one if you the if you start a small margin for error here your deck build if you don't get your deck building right at the start well you go to the wrong places you're cut in junior Imperium because you have the ability to sorry in Uprising because you have the ability to go to places where other people areh that's already forgiv with your spies exactly that's super forgiving doesn't exist in in the original the ability to
trash way more cars and draw way more cards that helps you get through your deck and get rid of all of that chaff that you've built up so again that makes it a much more forgiving game I think if you want a punishing June experience and you're not concerned about the extra fluff and if you can get it cheap maybe get the original Juni period but that's the only circumstance that I'd recommend this over this yeah um I'm absolutely of the same thing um I will get Uprising uh if you need to buy a new one get uprising like 100% um if you then want more you can probably buy rise of vix and immortality and you can still play and then if you are a mega Dune fan you can buy this one and if you're a maniac yeah and you can get the Cards into it um I would have loved for U pricing to get um a reprint of the character cards in here so you so you can play that that is the only thing that I I would say I would like to have in this box the original characters yeah cuz yeah I would like to have the original character as well um if I don't own both of them uh but apart from that I would say 100% go go with this and then and then if you really love it get the the expansion and if you got if you finally secondhand or you got money to to trash by do an Imperium for yeah just for the extra cards so Matt if you already own
Juni Imperium would is June Imperium Uprising good enough and different enough to buy um if you are uh if you love The theme I would say sell it a second hands and buy and buy Uprising um if you don't really care about the the theme and you already got it you don't really want to spend any money you're fine with dun Imperium it still stays one of the greatest games in the last years dun Imperium is an amazing um so we're talking like we going from a 8.5 to a 9.5 I mean we're not talking a 6 and a 10 it it just like it's marginally better but those margin makes a difference at least for us I guess yeah absolutely I I think I'm of the same opinion I think if you have this uh you're fine with it I don't think you need to buy Uprising if you really want something extra and you feel like actually you want it sell you an Imperium yeah and get Uprising uh if you need the money um I don't think there's too much of a case to own both unless as you said Matt you're a maniac and you really want all of the content if you're a collector something like that yeah I will um that's the only reason why otherwise if you need to start um Uprising and uh and that's it yeah so match we take it to the outro yeah so that was our video on June Imperium versus Jun Imperium Uprising
but what do you think have you played both of these fabulous fabulous games please let us know in the comments below and let us know do you agree with us do you think this is you know clearly better because I think for from our perspective this is objectively the better game it's like if you're going to buy one of them buy that one um I don't think there's a case you can make to us where you say you'd rather buy this over this no not at least not for us at least not for US unless you deliberately want the more punishing experience then maybe that but again I think that's just a better game so but let us do you do you agree do you not agree uh what is the best June game do you like the original game from the uh is it the 70s now 70s 80s the original board game wow yes we need to take that one out that one off get that on the table let us know in the comments below and again just to make sure you don't get eaten by the sandworms or go crazy from Spice overdose hit the Subscribe button Buton prot you right now yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah it's in the prophecy you click in the prophecy and you will be the chosen one click on subscribe make sure you check out the rest of our videos Matt and um yeah don't forget to check the inm link into the description and apart from that I think that's it catch you again real soon ciao