Skip to main content
Loading video...

Gloomhaven (2nd Edition): Discussion

Transcript 28:58

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and Brad and I are doing a discussion on Gloom Haven second edition. Uh, this is a extremely unique discussion because it's like we've we've talked for when did Gloom Haven come out? 2018

somewhere in there.

Um like for seven years on Gloom Haven. So I mean there's nothing really that could be said about it uh that hasn't already been said over time. So really it's just kind of like talking about the adjustments that they made to second edition. And I guess it comes down to one of those questions on if you don't own if you own first edition, should you go out and get second edition? Um, and real quick, if you don't own either, obviously you get the new version.

Oh, yeah.

Um, but yeah, so whenever this was announced, uh, I mean, first and foremost, I still think Loom Haven is a 10 out of 10 game. Uh, there's really, uh, nothing that it's ever done that would have warped that. Uh, and and yeah, so second edition. Brad, do you think this is a significant improvement on first edition? I [snorts] mean, some of the changes they made are fine, but I mean, I I don't know like like if you have first and you're in the middle of a campaign.

Oh, yeah.

And stuff. I don't know if it's worth stopping that and starting it over with this necessarily.

That's true.

Depends on how big of a fanboy you are of this, too. It's like like I played pretty much through all the first edition.

Mhm.

And I had no interest in doing this because it's like I already knew the story.

Yeah.

You know, so it's like I didn't want to go through and do it again. And I was like, I'll just focus on Frost Haven.

Um,

which you didn't even touch Frost Haven.

Not yet. Yeah. But um but uh I I like some of the changes they made.

Yeah.

But is it worth spending another whatever it is, 200 bucks to get everything or whatever?

As far as I'm aware, I know Gloom Haven Gloom Haven was such an anomaly because of the fact that it was that a massive campaign game for like a hundred bucks.

It was so cheap to jump into. I don't remember how how much Gloom Haven second edition ended up being.

Well, because you had all that you got with the wooden organizers.

Yeah, I got I got add-ons. I got the play service for Frost. So, it was all lump sum. Uh and then if you got the minis, which they really felt like the minis were just to be for their RPG.

Yeah.

Uh which I did not get. I had no interest in any of that.

No, not at all.

Um I but I agree with you. If you were like starting first edition or you were already kind of halfway through, I think it would kind of be a weird shift to be like, "All right, I got second edition and now because they mainly have structural changes." Yeah. If you were playing the brute in first edition now, you kind of have a weird improvement on it. Still similar character.

I actually like this better than the original Brute just because of the the massive movement and all that. Like it it makes it more versatile.

I I agree. I think he's cuz I mean I played my entire solo campaign with the brute and the spellw weaver and I think

I can't remember who I retired cuz it's been so long. I think I retired the spellw weaver and kept the brute around and just from the way the bruiser is being played. He's just way cleaner like way less clunky. Unfortunately, I haven't played Gloom Haven so much that I mean, I never unlocked characters in my own playthrough. I unlocked a few more in the Steam version,

right?

But I haven't even I don't even know what all the characters are and there's like 18 of them.

Yeah, I unlocked I think I told you earlier, I think I unlocked eight characters in my playthrough.

Um cuz I made it a goal I wanted to unlock as many as possible. just see what kind of cool

which is which is massive because you have two different play styles of like you unlocked a bunch of characters so you got to see a little bit of each of them but then it's like for me I only unlocked one I think or maybe two and that was at the end of the campaign so then it's like to even explore those characters you have to play it again

right

um which is kind of weird when you think about it because it's not a narrative driven campaign so it's not you're not really incentivized to play it again,

right?

Except to play different characters. So, the retirement system is, I think, a little bit cleaner from what I've read in this one. Uh, not quite to the extent that Frost, cuz in Frost Haven, when they retire, they shop in the settlement phase. They actually do something.

Here, I think you still get some events, but there's more I think they added more story to it. Uh but yeah, the actual the functionality of the game play is still the exact same. It's still a game that a lot of companies are, you know, uh emulating. You now you see the two the top and bottom effect on cards uh for different effects

and uh that is just such a clean design that was one thing you hated that Jaws of the Lion made you really like.

Yeah. um

the learning curve on how to use your hand.

Yeah,

that's the thing. That was what drew me crazy that

Exactly. Because it definitely punishes you whenever you play something and you're like, "Well, that didn't work." Uh and then the other thing, like I said, structural changes that they that they did is this book system. And this is from Haven, and I think it's significantly better is you have one book that is literally your scenario book. And so like for the one we just did, it's one page. This tells you here's the starting maps, here's the map layout, and then here's all the stuff you need and then the story. But then it just tells you, oh, any special rules, but hey, if this happens, go to this section. Then you go to this book that is all the extra stuff on, you know, the fog of the fog of the map where it's like, hey, now you open that door. Now you get to see what's in it. This is a drastic improvement, right?

um than being able to see everything. And even though Yeah. you're kind of fiddling with a couple books way better.

Oh, yeah.

Uh because they're able to add in more story, they don't have to try and fit it all on a page or two pages. Now they can just kind of have three or four sections with actual text. Well, and also, you know, we were talking about it earlier, the the campaign structure is different now where you have the the little advent calendar thing almost where you peel and and you make the decisions and go with that flowchart.

Yes.

Um because I planned Gloom Haven first.

It was just such a just a mess of knowing what you've done, what you're not because I remember I think it had like a little white boxes by the thing on the map and you had to like mark it when you did it or something.

They still have that, right? But it's just like this tells you if you you know

it just seems better.

This is better. But it would also kind of tell you the only way you could keep track of what you did was actually in the in the rule book or in the scenario book. It would tell you where it was unlocked. I can't like I can't tell you how many times I had to go through the scenario book and kind of backtrack and be like where what's unlocked? Like what can I do? because there were some scenarios that would have prerequisites

that the scenario would be unlocked but you couldn't do it. So it was on the map and you're like why can't like this is so weird. Now

again this is pulled from frost haven where now it's like okay this was scenario one two three and now you just follow the arrow

and then I believe if I'm not mistaken that the color coordination of these apply to a specific guild. Gotcha. Or it does it does matter. So you get to make decisions. Oh, if we want to do Crypt of the Damned, that's going to unlock seven and six. Or if we do Forgotten Crypt, that'll unlock 7, 9, 28, and 10,

right?

Uh, and you get to see it all visually and just keep track the entire time. And it's just overall second edition just improved on they they took what they learned from Haven, applied it to Gloom Haven and cleaned it up while still not completely, you know, replacing what Gloom Haven first edition was. Um, which to some people that might actually be a disappointment. They might be like, "Oh, did they completely overhaul Gloom Haven to be like Frost Haven? Is there a huge city phase now?" Nope. Um, and I It's kind of weird because I love Frost Haven for everything that they added. I love the settlement phase. That's so much fun. But I actually like that they didn't completely overhaul Gloom Haven and make it Oh, hey, now it's now it's Frost Haven, but it's set in the theme of Gloom Haven, right? You know,

it it it's still just kind of it's it's so weird because we're The game came out so long ago. Took me [ __ ] forever to finish it. Um, you know what? No, Gloom Haven came out in 2015. 2017. Okay. I thought it was 2015. Um,

that's probably when the project was fulfilled. Uh, so it it's just wild because well, Frost Haven broke the record on Kickstarter funding. Um, I think it beat KDM on that, but there are so many campaign games out

and I'm aware of almost all of them. Like I that's all my where all my money goes. And going back, Gloom Haven was still like almost top of the top and every top 10 or top 100 we do is always Gloom Haven/ Frost Haven lumped together plus Jaws of the Lion.

So then after all those campaign games come out, it's like, man, are they surpassing Gloom Haven?

Like I don't think so. And then second edition comes out and it just kind of reinvigorates like or re-establishes the fact that it's still such a top-notch campaign game

uh without having all the bells and whistles having all the I mean other games do have miniatures that are of character size appropriate like apparently second edition but they it it just kind of shows that this game does not need a million [ __ ] expansions and all that [ __ ] to to to

to be such a great game.

Um, over the years, Brad, are there any negatives you got on Gloom Haven or anything second edition added?

Um, well, second edition, we've kind of just started the campaign, you know,

but, uh, first edition seemed, if I recall, because it's been a few years since I went through it. Mhm.

Most of the missions are were just kill everything.

Yes.

And that's how you win.

Yeah.

You know, this one's had, you know, you had to kill the construct. We didn't have to kill everything else. Just like we left the bear and the dust and different stuff like that the last one,

but um

I mean it's it's just more the same. I mean it's it stands on its own as far as what it is and

like you're you're you said it's still a 10 out of 10. Yeah. You know, and everything. It's It hasn't changed for me from what it was back when I was playing it before either. It's

even though I haven't played it for a while, I I know what it is. Yeah. You know,

it's kind of like going back and replaying a video game that you know the story, but you're like still invested. I mean, how many times have you beaten Last of Us and you you're just like, you know, the story, but you still like the game.

And that's actually kind of where I'm at with second edition. It's like I know the story for the most part. And I mean this the Gloom Haven story first edition wasn't anything to write home about. It was serviceable perfectly fine. Now another thing is with second edition they have since added

audio narration with Foreller.

Yeah.

I mean if I can give it an extra like anything with audio narration immediately gets an extra point. So Gloom Haven second edition already is like an 11 because it gets that point because first edition didn't have that. Uh, and if I have to read it out loud to someone or I read it to myself and then I come back months later, I'm like, I don't [ __ ] remember.

But this just makes it so much more atmospheric.

But besides that, coming back, it's like I'm I'm invested again, right?

Like I thought I was kind of like, all right, well, we have a C. I don't want to do an open world campaign because it's [ __ ] weird sometimes to record and do the series. So, let's just do something where I can have an episode that's a scenario, make it clean cut.

Yep.

But really, it was kind of an excuse to for us to, you know, play this and then just beat it, then go to Frost Haven because I haven't done anything on that except a discussion,

right?

So, I'm like, cool, we can do that and this will be whatever. But, I'm like, I'm into it. They did just enough to be exciting every time. a cleaned up city phase, a little bit more with the reputation track, more story stuff based off reputation.

Um, I picked a character that I have only ever played in like this community event series that was [ __ ] Uh, but so yeah, I'm having an absolute blast. Well, and there are extra scenarios in second edition that, you know, other board game designers y

got to create. Like this one we just played was was one of them, I believe.

Yep. With Rob Davio,

right? So,

you know, it's like so you do have some a few more extra little

differences

with again without it being completely bloated. And it and even if it's like a few scenarios, it does it feels so much cleaner for us to know how to like I just feel so much efficient. That's one thing as as of as at the time of this recording I'm doing Kingdoms 4 at the same time and the flow of that game would be perfectly fine if I wasn't recording but because I'm trying to episode it out it it it feels so disjointed. I feel like all over the place and here it's like set it up. Boom. Got everything out. Oh, what do we need? Oh, we need some imps. Okay. And it's just like h it's been so long since I played a clean game. And for some reason, Gloom Haven's rule book is a 70page rule book. And I have barely ever went through it.

Just look at keywords,

keywords or like one one oh what do they do if the if they if they heal what you know just very like specific rules. But other than that, the efficiency of this game's design, because I mean, a on Trespass Odyssey, my favorite game, 70 page rule book. Every single time I play, I have to figure out I have to reread it or I have to watch a how to play to figure it out cuz it's just so many just all over the place stuff

that I'm glad is in the game,

but it's like, man, can I why can't I lock this down? and Gloom Haven. We were playing second edition, watched Paul Grogan's 10-minute video on what the differences were. Right back into it like clockwork.

Well, on the app that we've been using because the Gloom Haven does get very tedious if you're using the stupid monster with the with the stupid little pin wheel.

Yeah, that is true.

So, using an app makes it even like so much more less convoluted.

Yeah. No, that's that's actually a very good point. Uh, I would highly recommend using the XHaven app. I think it's free if not a couple bucks. And it has every as Frost Haven, Draws a Lion, all of them in there. And it actually, it's improved since last I used it. Now it kind of

Hey, just seen like it pulls up a thing. Oh, the Arkan Construct has, you know, double attack, double movement.

Just very quality of life. Um, you know, companion apps. And I know some people are like, "But you're not using most of the components."

Good.

I mean, when you walk through this game, you're probably gonna be tossing it anyways. I know. You know, so

or when you have or buy a reill pack.

When you have six enemies and you have their stupid charts and you have to fiddle with the health tokens.

Oh, number six has this and you're trying they're falling over [ __ ] Yeah.

Yeah. It it's that is actually a very good point. If you're not using an app, the game can be very fiddly with all that extra stuff. Uh, but there's a fix around it. You're just not using some components. I would agree with you though. The biggest negative is all of the main scenarios seem to be kill all enemies. I wish they had fixed that. Uh, Frost Haven, I had I had done I was doing the campaign but then I moved. I think I had done like 10 scenarios and from what if from what I remember like all of those had a completely different goal,

right? Some of them gimmicky, some of them it's like I appreciate the idea and execution this sucked ass or it could have been our characters were really bad for the scenario, but they were at least all different here. Yes, it is kill all enemies and from what I had heard that stayed the same except for the side missions. The side missions which we did seem to be completely unique,

right?

It is what it is. I think it doesn't really bother me now because we just know that going into it. But yeah, that would probably be my biggest negative and and wish they had changed.

Yeah.

Um yeah, like I don't know. I unfortunately I don't know enough about the characters to know, oh, the Kragar is playing completely different or the mine thief plays completely different or this secret character or this unlock character. I just don't know. I would say this guy because the character I put the most time in was [clears throat] the brute,

you know, and I would say because a lot of the cards are are the same.

Yeah.

As the brute, but then there's so much like

it's it's a it's a

a modified brute and that, you know, makes him a little even more aggressive move and and stuff. So

yeah,

he was he's cool just because he is different. I don't know cuz I never played Craig Hard. I

cuz I think I did the rat the little uh

mine thief.

I did the mine thief cuz I ran two at the start of mine. It was mine thief and and uh

brute ran.

Yeah, I should have played spellw weaver just to see how rat cuz I know a lot about the spellw weaver. From what I have heard it's a it's a lot of class tweaks. I don't know enough about the items yet, but I've also heard that the items have been tweaked. And so far, it seems like they give you more money. More money and XP. Yeah.

Because I don't I I've always felt like I was starved unless you went out of your way to loot a bunch. So, it again, if you if you own first edition, and I would say second edition is worth it if you really like Gloom Haven. Um, if you don't own either, second edition is definitely the one to go out and get.

Yep.

But yeah, I don't think there was a single thing change that they actually made that is that is worse

where it's like, oh god, now this sucks. Um, yeah. Oh, a few other things they changed or that they actually pulled from Haven. One is the uh your characters now have keywords.

Yes.

About them.

That was handy. That is very nice. One, it actually just Oh, hey, it tells you uh icons on here. So, one of the I was looking

Oh, yeah.

I was looking at one of my cards. I'm like, is that teleport? It is. Um, but what's very cool, one, you still have your backstory. You still have the things that have a have a like a stat thing on it. But then it also kind of gives you, hey, here's how your class plays. That's really cool. But then like I have arcane, outcast, and strong. So, personality quirks that actually are applied in events. And it'd be really cool if they were applied in scenarios. Yeah.

But if not, that's fine. I think them being applied in events is adds a little bit more depth, but again, not something that's like wow,

right?

And then the other thing which I loved in Frost Haven because it's so cool uh when you can do it are the masteries with each class having a mastery. And so you kind of have passive perks

that you can get. One you can just unlock through natural perks, but then two of them are insanely difficult to do. Um, that I don't know if we'll ever get to. Um,

so I think I could do my top one.

Which one was What was your top one again?

In three different scenarios, kill an enemy that you pushed or pulled that round.

You mean push or pull? Do you push people? Have you pushed people?

I haven't really yet, but that'll hold.

So, you just need to push them and then kill them.

Kill, but I need to be next to them. That's the unless I have that one range card, I can I can maneuver maneuver it, but I

Oh, you have to push them or pull them and then kill them.

And then kill them.

Got it. I thought it was just like you push them and then at some point in the scenario Well, it says it it has to be in that round. So, it says kill an enemy that you pushed or pulled that round.

Okay.

So, it's like I all I have to do is do that in three different scenarios and I've got that mastery.

Yeah.

You know, so

um and you can look at what what they say. That's what the these cards the ones with the different backs. That's what That's what these are.

Gotcha.

Um I don't know which one of mine I think my top one is made. I It feels like the top one's the the easier of the two. In a single scenario, create, destroy, or move at least one obstacle tile each round,

right?

Like these almost feel like you're waiting for a scenario. Like, okay, oh, this one has a time limit of five rounds. I just need to do this for five rounds. You know, things like that, right? But the other ones are are wild. Um, and they should tell you. Maybe they don't. Which one do you pick?

I think you just pick, I bet.

I thought they were tied to a specific one, but maybe maybe not. I don't know. I'll have to look those up. But I do remember that being in in Frost Haven. So they definitely took a lot of cool things from frost haven and put it into this.

Y

So I think that I think that was it. That's all I could really think of on on major changes. Um [snorts] and yeah, I mean I guess we'll see some of the bigger ones with the reputation stuff, the imbument. No idea what that is. Uh, and I guess on, you know, just later tweaks on items and and character stuff and more story elements just we might see a little bit more. But overall, I'm very happy.

Yeah.

With second edition,

it's good so far.

On a scale of 1 to 10, would you give Bloom second edition?

I've always given it nine.

Oh, okay.

So, I think I'm going to stick with that now since we're early. I want to see how things

Yeah.

You know, ramp up, but

it's still outstanding. Yeah. You know, I want to give it a little bit of room, you know, because if Frost Haven's that much better than it, then

to me it is. I think a lot of people with Frost Haven were overwhelmed by they they felt like they probably wanted the the succinctness of Gloom Haven and then it's like here's this whole other settlement phase that is an ordeal to which I get

like but yeah, I I love Frost Haven. So, they're lumped together for me because they're virtually the same game. Um, but yeah, 10 out of 10 for me. I still think Loom Haven is amazing and I'm actually very happy that I'm having as much of a fun time. Oh yeah, for the record, we didn't really bring this up. Uh, the the minis are [ __ ] weird. Like they completely overhauled the Bruiser or the Brute. And you know, it's kind of I'm looking at it. It's like your mini looks so much bigger than mine, but you are on a rock,

right? So, you take the rock out, then your mini is tiny. Uh, like like our characters are tiny, but you have these massive standes. But then it's like I pulled out the crackart and I literally thought I pulled out the gloom haven buttons and bugs craart and it's like why is he so small?

We'll have that remedyed for the next

Yeah, but it's like it's just stupid. And in and even if they wanted to make like the characters tinier, why is your character on like a cool piece of you know?

Yeah, cuz she's almost about the size of the Vermling and and

Yeah. You know, oh, and I have those I have the the minis like on on hand for the other ones. So, here's the Scoundrel.

Unfortunately, I don't have first the my first edition copy. I have all the first

anymore.

Um, so okay towers

like dude it's now it's cuz I thought the crack was like this big [ __ ] rock character.

I think he is in the first

well in the first

in the new second edition uh they're they're little people.

They nerfed them.

Uh yeah. Now lorewise is lore accurate. Craart rock people are this big.

They're like Gimly.

They're like

uh

the mine thief.

Oh, he's about the same size as he normally was. He's not much different.

He's not. That's so [snorts] weird.

Yeah.

It's It's just It's crazy. And but that's the thing is like I don't know like the fact that the bruisers character I guess he got a different name so they gave him a different mini but he is he has the coolest mini. He's actually on something. Everyone else just kind of has a little bit of terrain around him but has this whole Oh, and then the tinkerer which is also it's like a quarinth or quintath or something like that. Um. Whoops. Wish they're really small anyway.

Yeah,

those guys.

They're about the same height.

Um, but to be fair, the other thing is is I'd have to look at the first edition minis to do a size comparison, but just actually from looking at this tinkerer, it looks like it's very it's like less detailed. Like I could barely tell what it was. It's like

I have every mini from first edition. I kept all the minis.

Yeah.

And their character sheets and everything cuz I knew that you it was said that you could play them at

Frost Haven.

Like so I like that's why I kept those is cuz I was like, you know.

Yeah. No, that makes sense. It's

the minis are clearly the worst aspect. Um, you know, I almost I dislike the minis so much. Maybe not so much, but I dislike the minis. Every character comes with a stande. I almost would rather have the stande than blob looking tiny ass

miniatures that kind of look like [ __ ]

I'll bring my first edition that way that way it'll look a little more comparable.

Look a little bit more Hans and Fron.

Yeah. Yeah. Uh it's just it's weird and I don't know why they halfassed it. Which if these are the minis for second edition, it does not bode well for what their miniatures look like for, you know, 300 bucks or whatever it was. Yeah.

Yesesh. But that's pretty much my only major complaint of second edition. So if you have first edition, keep your minis because these are not an improvement uh at all.

Except for the bruiser.

Except for the bruiser, but uh I mean I really didn't hate the way he looked in first either. But this one's kind of cool cuz he's in the action pose cuz the brute in the other one he's just kind of like

he's just standing there with a sword and shield like he's like waiting in line. Anyway, yeah, he's the only one that that looks pretty pretty cool, but he's also tiny. Um, that's it. That's all I can think of. So, let us know what you think of Gloom Haven second edition in the comments below. And, uh, stick around for the rest of the series. Like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever day is for you.

Progress saved