The Manhattan Project: Energy Empire Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everyone today I'm taking a look at the Manhattan Project energy Empire which is a one to five player worker placement and engine building sty board game designed by Luke lorri and Tom Jolly this one takes around an hour and a half to two hours to play on average before I get into my thoughts on Manhattan Project energy Empire I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. co.uk who might go to online retailer here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so the Manhattan Project energy Empire is going to look like this when it's set up where essentially you have the main board here with all these different worker placement spots on them so all the places that you can go to are going to have this little kind of silhouette of a builder here and the board is essentially divided up into three different colorcoded areas which is important to the engine Style part of the game to the bottom left here where you have this newspaper you have the um these pollution tokens which essentially acts as a countdown timer for the game and it also kind of fluctuates the oil prices as the game goes on you have this United Nation track at the bottom here where you can get these points and at the end of the game whoever's pushed the furthest along will get a bonus three points and you have this little area down here where you can acquire these achievements for endgame scoring now additional resources are going to include of course the decks of cards here which correspond to these spots here which are always in flux and people buying cars and adding them to their little scoring Tableau um and also going
to have these six event cards these Global impact cards three of which are going to be from the early side of the game which is the first three rounds and the bottom three for the final three rounds generally speaking the first three rounds are going to be generally positive events and the third three are going to be negative St events you've got all the additional resources such as the metal here you've got the plastic you've got these oil drums you have the um these science tokens and these other kind of um big oil refineries you got the money you've got these dice which is going to be a way to acquire energy throughout the game and everybody's got their own personal player board that look like this and most most of this board is just for a storage area for all your different resources um however you do have some useful little tracks here which shows all the different faces of those dice that you can acquire um you can potentially keep up to five dice throughout the game which all going to give you a point for each one you unlock you're going to start with three workers at least as a basic rule and you're going to start with one private achievement so you can see my here says I get one Victory point for every $2 I have spare at the end of the game and more importantly you have this environment part of your player board here which is a way that you when you gain pollution you're going to cover up these spots potentially costing you endgame scoring and it can also cost you in-game scoring um the more contaminated this board is now additionally at the start of the game everyone is going to get given a couple of these um Nations and you can choose one but I just dish them out at random and they all dictate your starting resources so you can see
here as France I start with one of these yellow um die here I've got a science token and I have two money and also there's you know there's a bunch of different ones here like you can start with more or fewer resources depending on the nation you are and the bottom half of that um card is going to be a personal little spot you can go to in order to move along that United Nations track so you can see here if I spend a science and two coins then I can push along that track and everybody's got a different criteria on how they do that so naturally you are trying to get as many points as you can in this game and the player with the most points by the time the game ends will be the winner and a lot of those points will come at the final scoring and as I mentioned you'll get a few of them well quite a lot of them from the United Nations track and only one person can occupy that final step there you'll get them for all the die you unlock and add them to your personal player board and up to five of those you can have up to five of these personal achievements all of which you can score up to I think it's up to five points for each um you can also score points based on your environment as I mentioned every revealed spot or exposed spot at the end will give you a point and also these three columns here will give you three two or one points you know if they are empty at the end and I suppose more importantly you'll get a lot of points from the buildings you acquire because you can see here that in the top left hand corner you have a points tally like so which will all be added to those end game scoring so let's have a look at the anatomy of these cards which you'll be collecting and because you will have quite a lot of these and they do come in three different types again all three different colors um and when you go to
these spots which are these spots here you're going to have to place a worker there like so and you'll get to take one of these corresponding cards now you can see the fee of taking these cards is going to be at the top here so either two three or four coins or you can play science tokens in these two you can play metal or plastic and when you pay that fee you are going to add it to your um you know to your little Tableau and that is going to mean that in the future whenever you take a action Cor responding to that color so if I took anything from here then I can as a follow-up turn choose to place energy or workers on these spots here and cover them up and get the following bonus so in this example I could voluntarily do this and take two science tokens and Peak at one of these event cards and these do a whole bunch of different things such as being able to pay SS to clean up these pollution tokens on your player board you trading metal in for Science and points just getting metal using metal to get cleaning up oil drums to turn into plastic you know any kind of variation of the resources and exchanging them into each other Etc something thing that's important when it comes to the worker placement part of this game is that if somebody else tries to go to the same spot as you or if you go to the same spot again then you have to create a bigger stack of workers than the existing one so you can see here that the first player gets it just to place one worker but the second player has to place a worker and an energy to create a taller stack than the existing one so you see here now this one has two wood chits basically or cardboard chits
if anybody else wants to go there they'll have to put three there and so on now if you play a two-player only game there will be some neutral pieces on there just to make it a little bit tighter but let's take a look at what all the different workers placement spots actually do so you've already talked about acquiring cards and what they do now something I should mention as well is that some of these cards when you purchase them will come with a pollution on them now the pollution is going to come in two different types basically it's going to have the basic pollution that looks like this or it's going to have this nuclear um pollution that looks like this and whenever you acquire one of these cards not only you going to add the card to your Tableau you're also going to take the leftmost revealed one of these tokens and put it somewhere on your player board and again if it's the nuclear side you'll have to put it this side up and the difference is with these ones that it's a little bit tougher to clean up and you can put it anywhere you like but let's just say I chose to put it here now let's have a look at all the different spots then so you have this one here they scientific research which means I can take a science token and peek at one of the cards I can spend three money in order to acquire a new worker and get a pollution token for doing so the cleanup here lets me spend a science to do two cleanup actions and again a clean clean up action would normally be to you know remove one of these basic tokens or as as an action you can flip o one of these nuclear ones over to the reverse side so again they take a little bit longer to get rid of these middle actions here are the mine which simply you to take metal you got the oil drilling um mechanism where you can take one of these tokens which are reverse you know reverse sides
and you can place them on one of these corresponding spots on your player board so you have these little ones with the oil drips on here now if I chose to put this one here like so that spot is going to be permanently blacked out for the rest of the game meaning that those points there are not going to be available to me however I will instantly take three oil barrels from the suppli so it's a nice little quick grab there you got the ones here the chemistry one that let you swap oil drums into to plastic and science but you will get a pollution token and you have these spots here which will give you money now you have three options when you take money you can take two just for yourself you can take three or four but if you take those choices then you'll be giving money to the other players as well and you can buy and sell oil based on the current value of the uh of the oil based on the market here so you could swap say three oil drums for a quid or a quid for for you know three oil drums or you got this little trade one here where you can interchangeably you know change um to money one of the metal or plastic resources or a science token now in the middle area you also have this power plant which is important when it comes to generating energy now when you come here you can pay resources in order to acquire one of these different dice now you have these green ones here you got the blue ones the black ones and the yellow ones and they all correspond to this little chart here which basically shows the different energy that they generate so you can see here that this green Dy um on one of the faces that has one energy well in fact on five other the faces it has just one energy but if you rolled the six per se you'd get two
uh energy now these two D here are are pretty nice because they don't come with any pollution but these ones while they might generate more energy they will actually mean that you generate um you know pollution and end up putting it on your player board so if you can't or you don't want to play any more workers or use any more cards from your Tableau then you can choose to basically pass which means that you'll take all your workers back um add them to your personal Supply but ready to be used again and then you discard any spare or used energy that you've generated so these will go back off ready for these cards to be used again in the future um but this also means that you'll have a chance to generate more energy um like so when you do you're going to take all the dice that you've acquired as well as having the option to spend any of these oil barrows on a one one: one ratio to exchange them for these petroleum dice that look like this so let's just say I ended up spending one oil barrel because I wanted to generate more energy by Rolling this dice then I'm going to roll them and then this is going to show how much energy you get now the higher number is going to be important because if that higher number shows one of the pollution symbols then you're going to add that pollution to your board like so always taking from the um little round tracker here so let's just say I added it on like that and then the rest of the symbols are going to show the energy you get so I'm actually going to get six energy for this round which isn't so so bad and any of these petroleum dies that you've gained from um you know trading in these oil drums will be discarded
because they are only a one use thing so as you can probably tell as players keep taking the pass action or the generate action which is what it's technically called these pollution tokens are going to start shedding from here or when anybody gains pollution they're going to shed from there which eventually is going to expose the bottom spot here and then you're going to reveal one of these Global impact cards then this is going to be a little thing here that's going to affect all the players now the first thing you're going to look at is the top spot here which shows the different kind of um environment or part of your environment board which you're going to score points for based on how many spots are exposed so you can see here that this says for every clean piece of water that I have I'm going to get a victory point and this relates to all the players so you can see here that me as the yellow player would get four victory points because I have four clean pieces of water the top right part here basically means that the cards relating to that second are going to get wiped off so that new ones come on the board and refresh the U the Tableau there and the bottom part is going to be a little event that's going to affect all the players so you can see here that in this particular card it says until another Global impact card is triggered players May Frey discard science tokens um one Victory point is gained by the player for each science token discarded so it gives you the option to trade in science for points and these do all kind of different things yeah based on the different environment or this one says like immediately in turn each player May drill for oil as if using the oil drilling board action you get little bonus kicks there to do things a little bit faster and as the games gets to the second half of the game these rather
nasty ones or more difficult or more problematic ones come out and which again you'll score points in the same way but you'll get ones like this chemical spill which will say each player takes two pollution tokens from the supply chooses one row and um and places both tokens in that row so it's going to be like kind of you know pollution that you can't really do anything about and something I forgot to mention is that if you pass or take the generate action and you still have at least two or any combination of two workers or energy remaining on your board you have the option to take a new achievement into your personal playboard to give you an endgame goal to aim towards okay so let's share some thoughts on the Manhattan Project energy Empire and I'm going to start with the flow of this game because I think that's one of its strengths it's a very smooth um operation where all you're going to do of course is either place a worker down take the action potentially trigger a bunch of your cards from your Tableau that you've Acquired and then basically move on to the next play or of course you can generate but I like the fact that this game is not broken down into any individual phases or rounds it's a nice free flowing and smooth operation and that creates some cool interesting decisions because basically it means that um yeah I might be sat on this a spot here and somebody else really wants the metal um but they don't quite want to play that extra energy to jump in after me which I think is another cool touch because I generally like it when games or worker placement games aren't as I like it when they're they're tight but I don't like it when if somebody goes there you're completely blocked out I like the idea of you having to spend more to go there so this game does that well too but yeah what I like is the
fact that when I have something on the board it's going to be there until I take that generat action and then I remove it from the board so it has this kind of you know chicken mechanism where you know what I'm going to sit back here I'm going to sit on my worker until and hope that somebody else generates and then they remove their worker and then I can sneak in there for a better value so yeah I love the way that works you have to kind of look at what the other players are doing kind of guess when they're going to generate to know when is the best time to take the best action I also feel like the engine building part of the game is very strong um of course if you keep on going to the same um same worker placement spots and collecting the same type of card you know either the um the government the industry or these Commerce style buildings then again if you go there again then you're going to trigger all those matching cards or have the option to at least and these do synergize with each other really well like for example here if I had this environment environment facility and the this um Space Program here I can convert a metal into a science and a point and then I could change that science into a point a resource and to peek at another card you can see and imagine how all these events can string together and you can end up taking more powerful turns as you generate more and more energy now that being said I do think it would have been a good idea for there to be a better incentive for you to diversify in terms of collecting the different types because of course if you go to the same region again and again you're going to keep collecting the cards and get to use them again and again um meaning that you're probably going to you know very specifically tailor your strategy based on one of these different types and ignore the other two or maybe ignore one of them so it would have been cool that
maybe if you got a set of each type of card you would got a little bonus maybe a bunch of maybe like five points or you know something like that rather than just being kind of tunnel visioned or almost forced to keep doing the same thing so you can actually utilize your engine and keep running it generally speaking I'm not a huge fan of event cards in games you know games that are going to change something for that round but I'm must say that I think the energy cards here or the sorry the um the global impact cards that come with energy Empire are fantastic you know these are some of the best examples of event cards I think I've ever seen um because they're not too powerful but they're interesting enough um and I like the way that the scoring works on them you know when you reveal one of these cars you're going to have a look at the type of terrain here and you're going to relate it to your personal player board to see how clean that bit of land is and get points accordingly so it means that you're not incentivized to just kind of start cleaning up your player board towards you know the final third of the game and just neglect it until that point you always want to be making sure that it's clean as possible because when these cards are revealed you're going to get the corresponding amount of points and if you are neglecting it and your opponent isn't you're going to start falling behind there I also think that the actual text here and the events that they do are interesting and they just kind of give the game a little bit of kick at times like it some might say just you know take a a worker from the supply for free so you got a whole new worker to play with so they all kind of keep the game moving forward and I even think the negative ones aren't that swingy and they're going to kind of hit everybody at the same pace and the fact that you do have ways to mitigate this if these would you know just by chance end up hurting you more than your
opponent there are ways around that because you do have the option to start peing at these cars in order to plan for that you know uh inevitability so yeah I do like that way that works and this has actually helped me quite a few times like for example in the game I played yesterday um I had a bunch of these pollution tokens and one of the cards was flip them all over onto the radioactive side or the nuclear side um so I knew that I had to try and get rid of them as quick as I can to not you know undergo that punishment and that being said I'm just happy with the way the whole environment part of the game works in you know in general you know the idea of managing the pollution it maybe taking the better buildings but the better buildings are going to come with that punishment or even know that nuclear pollution which is going to be a massive pain to get rid of meaning that you're probably going to have to start generating you know science tokens to clean it up or even start generating um you know a person player spots in order to get rid of that so yeah I like that pressure of wanting to keep it as clean as possible and that bonus incentive to keep these columns clean to get these bonus points just a nice little kind of corruption mechanism that we've seen but this just does it in a I think a slightly more interesting way if I'm honest and especially like the choice of these um these oil mining um idea here or oil drilling where you can take these tokens and permanently put them on your board but get that quick grab of you know three oil so it's like you're damaging your your environment permanently blocking off a space which means that of course you're going to forsake those points and also forsake the points based on the events but you have got that nice little quick grab of those oil which you can use to your benefit now despite there being a wide
variety of these engine building cards that you can acquire I do feel like the game would have benefited from having more of these cards that could convert resources into points because there aren't actually that many of them and it felt like yeah most of the points you're getting are going to be at that end game scoring rather than ing game so it would have been a better balance for me if you could mix the two and it feels a bit more satisfying if you're you know gaining a big bunch of resources from all the energy you're spending and you can con can quickly convert that into victory points so I like that idea of when is the time to start you know flicking that switch and generating points rather than building or expanding my engine and I feel like this game missed an opportunity when it came to that part of the experience I also feel like the game is a little bit loose when it comes to getting everything done so for example in my experiences with this and bearing in mind this could be a personal thing based on the pollute the pollution that we take because this is going to dictate the pace of the game and maybe we are risk adverse players but from my games of this I managed to completely max out my um you know my personal environment here by having no pollution on it I've managed to acquire five objectives which is your maximum and had them all maxed out I managed to acquire all five of the dice um I managed to have spare resources and um and Etc so it feels like and even like going to the top of the UN track so it feels like there's not much forsaking one thing for another which which ironically happened with another game designed by Luke laor that I've played called Whistle Mountain that was my one complaint about it was that you could get too much done and it was a bit too forgiving but yeah bear in mind that if
you do have players that are going to go completely you know Bonkers in relation to the pollution and just keep on taking it and bleeding that those Stacks there then maybe that is going to change it but again depending on your player group that could be the case so bear that in mind I also feel like there's a point in this game where there's no real incentive to do anything apart from just keep spamming and buying buildings um just to get those additional points for me again that felt a little bit unsatisfying I like having a breath of options to go for with all of them being inviting in this one when I built up a relatively solid infrastructure it was just a matter of you know keep going back and buying buildings again and again and again which you know takes away from the magic of games like this despite the flow and the uptime of the game being very solid and positive I do feel like the game overall goes on a little bit too long um May maybe one round shorter would have done it for me but again maybe that is a personal thing based on people taking pollution tokens but yeah I definitely felt like you know the first two or three rounds seem to fly by and it goes along at a really great pace and then the final three rounds because everyone's acquired so many cards and are taking longer turns unlocked more workers Etc um it feels like it starts to drag its heels a bit and I'm ready for it to end I do feel the game scales pretty well particularly at that two or three player count um I'm not a solo gamer so I can't really testify to that um but yeah it moves at a relatively decent pace I think if you are going to start playing at four or five players it might outstate as welcome a bit too much for me cuz you are probably looking towards that 2hour Mark which I think is a bit Overkill because this is a you know a midweight Euro at best really and if I'm going to
play a 2-hour game I'm probably going to lean towards something a little bit metier I don't feel this video will do it justice but the production of this game is absolutely stellar and every single thing is wonderfully designed I think the board looks really like kind of um atmospheric and the actual resources themselves are just unbelievably good like these oil barrels are weighty they feel great they look great even the plastic cubes and the metal everything looks fantastic high quality dice um all the general resources are fine nice clear iconography on the cards interesting and well laid out player boards so yeah this for me is spot on the money when it comes to the production okay so let's get in some final thoughts on the Manhattan Project energy Empire which You know despite me making quite a few complaints or CR critiques there I do feel this game is is really well designed you know it has a lot going on for it and even a lot of things i' would normally shy away from I think this game pulls off to a good standard I mentioned the event decks these are all fantastic I love the way it scores I love the environmental part of your board that's brilliant and pro probably my favorite aspect of the game in its entirety and even little random things that normally I wouldn't enjoy such as the energy generation I think that's a really good touch of the game and I have no issues and in fact I actually enjoyed that quite a lot the engine builder can be satisfying yes I do feel like there could be more incentive to diversify and I think there could be more cards to generate victory points rather than um you know just the few points here or there um but again that's personal opinion but my biggest critiques were the fact that you can get
too much done um again maybe that's a personal experience thing but it it is what happened um you know you can completely Max almost everything out and for me that almost cuts the legs out from under a game because it really does kind of nullify my desire to come back and play it any further so yeah I would have l it to be tweaked to be a little bit tighter a little bit more harsh and a little bit more restrictive um but said mechanically there's nothing really I I dislike about it you know I like the idea of the worker placement being in flux people going in and out of the board of the time um I like the idea of having to place stronger energy on the board to go to the same spot as somebody else putting the pressure on the players again I like the pressure of the event scoring um and the way that it affects the game so yeah almost there's there's so much I like here and it was very close for me to you know making considered to keep this one but I think because of those concerns I'm not going to end up keeping it because I do have a lot of work placement games and while this one is definitely a better than average workpl game in fact it's way better than average um I don't think it's as good as the great ones but if you want kind of a maybe a mid level or kind of a Gateway plus maybe maybe a bit stronger than that weight game then this is not a bad one to look at if you can get your hands on the copy because I do think it is out of production um but yeah for me it's just slightly missed a near Miss that's for sure but that being said I am a bit um I'm a little bit apprehensive when it comes to work placement games anyway because I tend to like them to be a little bit heavier than this one um is but yeah very near Miss um so that is the Manhattan Project
energy Empire