Black Forest Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
at number two I have black forest so black forest the newest uve Rosenberg game and if you've watched my channel over the year or ever watched any of my uh videos about My Games Collection you might know that I have pretty much no uh U rosenbergs games in my collection with the odd exception and those exceptions are not the Farming Simulator style games that he's most known for so I have played a lot of them but none of them have really worked for me one of them that did kind of sit on that board line of me keeping it or not keeping it was glass road now I really like glass Road um especially that resource system where whenever you gain certain basic resources you will automatically automatically generate the more kind of luxury uh resources and when I heard that mechanism was coming back in a new game Black Forest that really did Peak my interest especially when the rest of the game was kind of built for from the ground up and was built on more traditional Euro Concepts rather than the car driven concepts of um of glass roid which I thought was cool but I thought it was a little bit gimmicky and didn't really stand up to repeated plays I found it a little bit too experimental this one again more of a traditional Euro Style game as you are moving around this map with your worker visiting different people on this map getting resources converting resources building buildings all the Euro goodness that I tend to enjoy
now the game itself I think is really well done I think it's a polished game as you'd expect with a designer like oia Rosenberg I thought the actual main worker movement board was really cool as you know you are spending Provisions in order to move from town to town so you're trying to plan your routes efficiently as not to waste anything you can even manipulate the board state by moving different kind of traders to different locations to try and suit you there's a race to get certain kind of um contracts done so again lots of traditional Euro things that I tend to like and I thought that was executed really well um much like the original glass Road I really enjoyed that resource wheel where you want to very meticulously get the right resources because again you do automatically generate um the luxury resources which can actually ruin your plans if you're not careful loved all of that um there was one thing that I found a little bit clunky though or maybe not clunky more overwhelming and that was the sheer variety uh of options here now I know that some people will look at that or hear that and think excellent there's so much you can do here and that is true but I found it a little bit daunting and a little bit too much to take in because I think every single game here you have like I don't know 50 buildings or something and you got some big ones as well as a ton of the smaller ones they are kind of organized in a way that you can break it down into the different resources but there is a lot of cross-contamination and what I found myself doing a lot of the time was just just collecting random stuff and then
looking at the um at the Resource Board and then building whatever I could build rather than working towards something so I felt that this game lacked a little bit of direction I think it would have been better if there was maybe round by round objectives or something you can try and go for to get some bonus points just to put you on the rails a little bit I found it a little bit too sandboxy and just too many kind of conversion tiles where you could turn this into this into this into this again I like the idea of that but in practice it was like oh I don't know just pick one of them and hopefully uh it will work out um there are some good different strategies you can go here as you can focus on you know really densely populating your player boards or keeping them bare um again lots of different ways you can get points but again I found the points a little bit a little bit minor it felt like you're doing a lot of work for very few points in return um and all in all um Can despite me object liking a lot of the things that went on here I found the game a little bit too Meandering and a bit too plotting um and just Li lacking that little bit of drive and that little sense of urgency that I would have liked to have seen and what I tend to enjoy in a lot of other Euros at this one was is a little bit too foot off the gas and just hopefully things will work out and so on so maybe I'm just really bad at this maybe well it seems to be a running theme with u Rosenberg games I just find them I don't know they just don't gel with my with my play style too much and
this is sadly another example of that despite me thinking it would be the polar opposite just again too many things going on in terms of these buildings and it feels like you're pulling teeth in order just to get a very small amount of points in return for that now that being said I'm sure if you like UV games then you're going to get a lot from this one because it is a solid design objectively it's just one that didn't quite work for me and um even the people I paid it with actually agreed with me so maybe maybe it's not just just me saying that and if you're if you are tried and tested in terms of playing uve and enjoying uve games then you'll like this one if you don't then I don't think this is the one to change your mind so again objectively a good game but just one that's not right for me that is black forest